Idah concern, possible McGregor good news & will Celtic move for Lennon Miller?

[@VerdeSocks]

Watching these videos has definitely become part of my daily routine now and much preferable over trying to scroll through social media to get the same info. Cheers Hamish!

[@sooperhooper]

Yes,Miller is only 18 and he is physically developed & excellent on the ball,its a bit unfair to gauge him against our midfield as its by far the best in Scotland but in my opinion Miller is the best player outside Celtic in Scotland & we should buy him while we can before he ends up in Europe or England & above our price range.

[@keynoteFlyer]

Buy him and lend him back while we can. He’s going to be a top player.

[@jimmyjohnstone5878]

​@@keynoteFlyerthat's fine at a reasonable price but I think he's got his sights set on getting a really big money deal straight to England or other place outside Scotland.

[@JimBoyd-wb8tb]

This wee guys clueless he's been trying Tae push scales oot all season

[@shaunmclarnon5107]

Didn't realise Millar was as young as 18 until the the weekend and that was the first time I've really seen him play. Agree with signing him in January and loaning him back to Motherwell for the rest of the season but I could see him really progressing under Rodgers with a full pre season next season.

[@greenlichtie]

It’s a no brainer, get miller in he’d be a major player in the long term future of the club

[@henrymcvey6538]

@@greenlichtie Really? When he’s 25?

[@stephen3540]

Evening Hamish, good morning everyone else. HH Mon the hoops and the 🐑😂😂

[@Craigiebhoy7]

Totally agree with you McCowan looks a great character to have around and what a player. After just watching his interview post Motherwell I think this guy is a fantastic signing. Lennon Miller I agree would also be a great signing for Celtic so hoping we are able to get this done soon. HH 🍀🍀🍀🍀

[@eugeneritchie5403]

Thought Trustys passing out on Sunday was very good,straight to full backs in a forward position

[@maebtadhg8307]

One word “YES”.

[@camdenNW1]

Would imagine it will take £5m+ to get him. "If" he isn't getting a game every week it would be daft to buy him, he will stagnate. . BUT if we buy him on 5 year deal then give him back to Motherwell for 18months ..Yes, he has lots of promise

[@keynoteFlyer]

Lost all respect for Kettlewell after his ridiculous remarks about the red card 🤡

[@dvp36]

Think the ship may have sailed with miller . He was with us we let him go . He is a talent that the eyes of Europe will be monitoring closely . My bet would be the premiership or Italy . If we have a chance would probably have to be January. I would presume Motherwell would want at least 6 or 7 mil and not sure we would spend that on a guy who’s just turned 18.

[@bradc1003]

We have a squad of 18 players who are all starters imo. Pick your starting 11 and then figure out how many of the 7 on the bench would start for Them. I’d say it’s 3 or 4.

[@cmurph321]

Can't drop Scales in my opinion.

[@francisgreen8925]

Like the lad Miller. But is he wot we need? I'd prefer someone with physicality in midfield. But he is definitely a real prospect for the future.

[@gigpod5785]

Yes, a future star, but reckons he moves abroad or down south tbh

[@helenk1078]

Its an aye for me 👏

[@stevengordon3183]

Hi Hamish I also live in Australia and use to watch your platform All the time . Are you going to Be staying in Australia Long term Love your podcasts And videos

[@undersoundproductions1915]

3:15 a photo of luke that reminds me of diego surrounded

[@ian_corbett]

If Idah is going to be out for tomorrow will Meada be on the bench as back up for kyogo?

[@lf67hh28]

Maeda starts on the wing. 😂

[@ian_corbett]

@ would hope so was just if we have no other back up striker could that be a option

[@jamesmcnally5838]

His Dad advised him to leave Celtic youths, and was proven correct by how he’s developed. He’s not coming to warm a bench

[@mickydem5920]

I couldn’t understand why we didn’t go and get Lennon Miller in the summer and loan him back to Motherwell yo keep developing. The better the boy gets the harder it’s gonna be for us to get him cos English clubs will come sniffing. Is the boy a Celtic fan??

[@williamhyslop2067]

I like Miller but he’s a seasoned professional 1st team player at Motherwell, would he be 1st choice at us? Doubt it. Would he be willing to be a bit part player as there’s plenty in front of him, boy has a big decision to make..

[@MalceeCapone]

He awready knows how to make Big decisions leaving Celtic to progress n get game development n now we should pay coz he can easily walk in play not saying take someone spot but he is best young Scottish player in long time

[@eugeneritchie5403]

Miller will want to play every week,not going to happen at Celtic unfortunately,great prospect at Celtic,Main Man at Motherwell

[@johnoneill8211]

Back 4 and mid-field largely unchanged except for injury. Cal mac went seasons without missing a game. Under Ange Hatate and Maeda hardly missed a game. Kyogo was a fixture for a couple of seasons. I'd deffo buy the boy and develop him into a player with massive sell on value.

[@johncopeland3826]

Well , there won't be much Scottish competition to sign him ,as theRangers just posted a £17. 2 million pounds loss and have to sell pencils on match days to make ends meet !

[@woooooooo9061]

Get miller in. Hatate won’t stay long term, so a good replacement.

[@o-way-zilla3394]

Watch Miller end up at Rangers. He'll want to play regular football not sit on the bench and wait for his moment in our midfield behind the likes of Hatate, Engles, Bernardo and McGowan. Hes a good player but when and where do you fit him in the squad? Cant have him just waiting till pre season for a sniff. Would love to sign him but you need to be logical.

[@garymccolm1112]

Buy him loan him back to motherwell problem solved

[@jimmyjohnstone5878]

Miller will be expensive to buy. If he's as good as suggested, then England and others in Europe will be after him.

[@williammclaughlin497]

Too soon for him and us, needs game which he gets now but won't with Celtic if we did sign him.

[@GraemeTyrrell.]

Depends how much, 2m yes- 5m no chance

[@camdenNW1]

£2m ..= No chance

[@GraemeTyrrell.]

@ 👍

[@fidelservare5852]

We move Holm out creates a space for lennon miller

[@Mantis_Toboggan_MD.]

A space in the reserves? We should be moving Holm out regardless of signing Miller or not

[@wordupcornflake]

isnt miller a sevco fan?

[@McLaughlinP-y1c]

There's been a host of Celtic greats who grew up supporting rangers .. it doesn't matter a jot

[@Mantis_Toboggan_MD.]

That didn't stop Dalglish, Davie Provan, Tom McCadam, Murdo McCleod, Barry Robson and many others over the years. Don't get me wrong, I wish it had stopped Kenny Miller, Steven Pressley and a fair few other dumplings over the years but the point is, that if the player is good enough then his off field life really shouldn't be a factor unless he tortures animals in his spare time or something.

[@dvp36]

He was with us as a youth .

[@matthew_jw1318]

Scales should have been to moved LB at the beginning season, and another CB signed.

[@aidaaan_5083]

He’s been our best CB this season, don’t see why we should start this LB project with him. He shouldn’t be a left-back for us imo

[@greenlichtie]

No chance, he’s proved his worth at CB this season

[@Michael-n5y]

Never a left back in this Celtic team, he’s not technical enough. He’s been our best CB by far this season

[@Mantis_Toboggan_MD.]

Scales wasn't even good at LB at Aberdeen. He's proven over the last two seasons, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that his best position is CB. Maybe he could also do a job as a LCB in a 3-5-2 type formation but that's by the by as Rodgers doesn't play with a back 3. Point is, Scales best position is CB by a mile.

[@henrymcvey6538]

Do Celtic need to buy every player. FFS give other teams a chance to enjoy the talent they bring through. That’s why the Scottish game is garbage with no depth.

[@paulmelvin8427]

Who cares about anyone else ?

[@o-way-zilla3394]

Exactly. Why tf would you want to give other clubs a chance to sign the best homegrown players over your own team? Plus, at the end of the day, look at history. If Celtic dont sign the top talent in Scotland, they get whipped away down south, so other Scottish teams won't get to enjoy that talent anyway, and if you ask me, its better us than them. You took an L with that comment, mate.

[@henrymcvey6538]

@ Won’t matter what you or I think. The boys father is obviously switched on and won’t let him warm anybody’s bench. The kids used to playing and won’t go where he’l be frozen out of the game. Or sent on loan to where he doesn’t want to be! Leave him at Motherwell to develop.

[@henrymcvey6538]

@@o-way-zilla3394 Don’t know what an L is. Hope it’s a compliment!

[@woooooooo9061]

@@henrymcvey6538he’ll move very quickly to wherever the money is. And he’ll soon warm a bench in the English championship no doubt.

[@robinlau40]

Hamish.stop in now!!! You said a big result coming before the Dortmund game,got me excited mate so chill out a bit on your predictions please pal🍀😆👍🍀HH🍀

[@briand.1537]

calm doon with the McGown is a "cheeky guy" sound too like McCoist crap. Just say Luke is gallus. End of. HAIL HAIL.

[@danduggan3335]

Miller will be off to Germany. Not sure what his contract situation is, but his dad took him away from Celtic already. Celtic isn't really a place for a young talent. The amount of players whose careers have been damaged by coming to Celtic is all the proof needed.

[@lf67hh28]

That would signal that they are not of the required quality. Stop blaming a club for the failings of a player.

[@danduggan3335]

@@lf67hh28 i don't think that is true. When you look at players that were genuinely talented that disappeared in the celtic youth system. Its frightening. Infact, Scales was almost another casualty only for he went out on loan, same as christie and ayer. All of them were saved because they went on loan. While other highly regarded young talents have disappeared without trace when they stayed in Celtics system, holm is the latest casualty. Its well recognised we are not very good re youth development and nurturing. I'd be amazed if Miller took that kind of risk with his career. We need a proper loan arrangement with 2 SPFL clubs.

[@lf67hh28]

@@danduggan3335 Scales isn't good enough, even now. Makes too many mistakes - and is starting to be phased back into a back up role at the club. None of the players you list were good enough at the time, Ajer was poor defensively and by all accounts - still is (as he's been dropped by his club regularly). If you're good enough you play, Tierney and Calmac being examples of this.

[@danduggan3335]

@@lf67hh28 I'm not looking to argue mate, but thats my point. Had Ajar and Christie stayed in the Celtic system, they would never had made it cos, as you said "none of the players were good enough at the time". Thats exactly my point, we bring in young players and the only ones who stand a chance are those that leave on loan. The vast majority of the, i think, 40-50 17s - 22 year olds brought to the club in the last 6 years have had their chances of a career completely derailed by being at Celtic.

[@lf67hh28]

@@danduggan3335 No they had their career derailed by not being good enough. Tierney was good enough, he went into the starting 11 at 17 years old. Celtic have the best youth setup in Scotland. However what no club in Scotland has is grassroots access - Scotland as a country doesn't invest in grassroots football as we can't afford it.

[@sandersson2813]

Stop denuding the league. Buy from elsewhere.

[@lf67hh28]

Why? Stop blaming Celtic for other clubs' business acumen (or lack thereof). 🙂

[@Mantis_Toboggan_MD.]

But wouldn't it help the league if the money at least stayed in Scotland. What did we pay for Odin Holm for example, was it £2 million? Wouldn't it have been better for the league if that £2 million had at least gone to another SPFL club ?

[@sandersson2813]

@@Mantis_Toboggan_MD. Not really, Dundee are a lot better off with McCowan for instance than the £1m they got for him aren't they? Celtic fans continuously moan that the level of competition is so bad in Scotland when they go up against better teams in Europe, yet they never acknowledge they play a part in keeping it down. Bain, Cifti, Christie, Turnbull, Mackay Steven, Hayes, Robson, Flood etc didn't really add much to Celtic, but it really harmed the teams they left.

[@lf67hh28]

@@sandersson2813 Why did these clubs accept the offers? You don't seem to be able to speak to that. You also blame Celtic for players not applying themselves properly, and failing. However Barry Robson and Ryan Christie were mainstays, so you've categorised them erroneously. Perhaps inform me of the various players Celtic loan out to other Scottish teams...

[@sandersson2813]

@@lf67hh28 Why did they accept them? They can't afford not to. Scottish football is set up to reward the biggest teams and keep them on top and keep other teams as minnows. It's funny that you don't seem to see the irony when your players get plucked away in similar fashion to play for better teams and you moan. Barry Robson a mainstay? He only played 42 times for Celtic in three years, so didn't even play a third of the games Celtic played. He played 145 times by comparison for United in 5 seasons, far more of what you can call a mainstay.