If John Wears A LEGENDARY ANIMAL HAT When Meeting Charlotte She Will NOTICE | Red Dead Redemption 2

It’s kinda cool how most of these interactions with significant characters will almost always comment if you’re wearing interesting particles of clothing. Always fun to test out these little experiments and have something actually happen like John wearing a weird hat to the widows house and her actually noticing it lol can’t wait for all the “out of videos, huh?” Not even close, baby. This is exactly why I do this #rdr2 #reddeadredemption #arthurmorgan

[@dontbethatguy2881]

“That’s an interesting choice of hat, if you don’t mind me saying.” *Pulls out gun* “I do mind.”

[@Rory695]

i was about to say i wouldve shot her for that

[@darthmaul6902]

Proceeds to run around valentine wearing the viking helm speaking nordic gibberish with whiskey in one hand and an axe in the other LENNNNNNNNY!!!!!

[@shafakap]

@@darthmaul6902 god of whiskey

[@thephoenix4093]

@@shafakap the only one to defeat Thor Whiskey

[@loominizer31]

@@darthmaul6902 excuse me sir we're going to have to ask you to leave the saloon you literally Resurrected an arsonist

[@j-307]

I love this game so much. Its awesome how she actually notices the hat. I just wish that she will also say something if you wear Arthur's hat. Its not just her too. Maybe if John wears Arthur's hat former gang members and even Rains fall will say something about it.

[@loading2968]

Exactly

[@Rosegoldshawwty]

Yeah because an old man who’s memory is fading about people would remember a hat

[@Z4ven]

@@Rosegoldshawwty yeah

[@motherfuckingbego]

It's not just her, everyone notice

[@Hypn0tic_01]

Only thing was that they would have to make it so that they would only mention it if arthur wore the hat when helping them i didnt wear it

[@Xiter2025]

Just when i think i've seen every detail of RDR2....

[@BimmerWon]

John’s lookin like he’s about to storm the Capitol.

[@RDBTheRedDeath]

Lmao

[@ex8800]

What

[@TheBasedTyrant]

That was Dutch's final plan

[@Jmcelwain17]

@@ex8800 after the election of joe biden, a great deal of trump supporters raided the capital building. The most notable of which was a man in a buffalo hat. Seen in several photos and videos leading the hate mob into the building.

[@charliewilson9884]

Maybe he’ll have better luck

[@boogiesrevenge2087]

Of course she noticed the hat! Look at hers! :)

[@eds1942]

They will comment on any hat that doesn’t fit in as normal. I often wear the tricorn pirate hat for that reason.

[@sine_nomine_ct]

I wear tricorn all the time 🤣 And got the same comment from Charlotte

[@princessjoanna8245]

My favourite hat :D You actually get comments even from random npcs. But that's the case with almost every legendary or unique hat.

[@narsbigmonkeynuts]

does it do that with the fisherman hat from the legendary fish missions?

[@danield6672]

Yeah, I can't wear my Viking helmet for more than a couple minutes without a couple npc's making fun of me. When you wear you Nevada hat your gang members will go "you some kind of lawman now Arthur?"

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

@@danield6672 yeah, I wasn't expected such a reaction to the nevada hat by the gang, but this game is always surprising. in this playtrough I didn't get the hat on the waterfall, i picked it up from the dead sheriff (main one, but he always respawn) in Valentine. Guess it's a hat commonly used by lawman?...

[@DRGEngineer]

Charlotte: "That's an interesting choice of hat, if you don't mind me saying" John: *you've yee'd your last haw partner*

[@Gingersnap_Adventures]

That meant to be a Revtrosity reference.

[@level7susceptible528]

I've noticed almost all people will comment on the peculiarity of your legendary clothes if you walk through the streets of a town. Mostly along the lines of "i wouldn't be caught dead wearing that" and "well that's an interesting choice of attire." I think it's got something to do more with fashion then it being legendary

[@NomadSnow]

The trapper's clothes are notoriously bugged. Even things that the gang members are and have worn themselves, if you're wearing the model from the trapper (as opposed to a non-trapper recolor of the same item), they will insult you.

[@seva7500]

@@NomadSnowclearly camp members have no sense of fashion. The trapper clothing is the best attire in the entire game.

[@peoplez129]

When I first got the bear hat, I rode up into Rhodes and the newspaper boy said "what a ridiculous getup" and laughed at me lol. It stung a bit.

[@Tahitilover1899]

Same with the legend of the east outfit

[@MariusBoss11458]

I heard the holster at the end 😳

[@matthews7805]

I'm on my second playthrough and I just can't do evil Arthur. I played GTA 5 and loved mowing down pedestrians though. Edit: I even return the escaped convicts who want their shackles shot off.

[@comfyphoenix]

It's because Rockstar made the GTA NPCs so lifeless on purpose

[@TheBoomhahaha]

I tried doing evil Arthur a couple times. I just couldn't

[@Randomperson-if4hy]

@Ayo True, I usually turn on cheats and go crazy there so I don’t suffer the consequences.

[@Hyaenis]

I’d say the same but once I gun one witness down I gun the whole town down

[@borbo1266]

@@comfyphoenix it's because it is gta 5 😂💀

[@ricardomenendez2709]

In case anyone is wondering she comments on the hat at 1:18. 7 seconds before the video ends lol

[@bean7039]

If you can't sit through a 1 minute video you may have ADHD .

[@Anonymous18923]

@@bean7039 Or people have seen this cutscene hundreds of times and just want to see what the title promised.

[@qwerty.44]

I tried meeting her again as John but all I found was her corpse

[@FrEffectsIntroforOffer24]

"thats an interesting choice of hat" - *grabs his gun*

[@princessjoanna8245]

She says the same thing, if you wear the bear hat with Arthur while visiting her the last time. Not in a cutscene, but just if you stay near her after they say goodbye

[@jamieburn4577]

I feel like this is just unique dialogue from an NPC if they see you wearing any special hat ngl

[@crimsonviper0069]

@@jamieburn4577 it is

[@Muneeb_Akhtar]

0:50 John be looking a Assasain lol

[@ridermanyt8029]

Assassin in Wild West

[@NubizZ_]

They got assassins in modern days, in ancient egypt, ancient Greece and much more, why not wild west?

[@novaunited5732]

Once at the post office in new hanover, a lady said to me "Normal people find that very odd", i wasn't wearing anything special. She just judged my basic clothes

[@lucadeeley8377]

1:20

[@Mig21Fishbed195]

I screwed up as Arthur as I only met her with only a few missions left so I couldn’t do all of them. Went back as John today and found her body. I picked her up and placed her beside her husband as a way of burying her.

[@elliottmanning9376]

Bro The fact that I also did the exact same thing yesterday even lying the body in the same place 💀

[@DocEtan]

I simply love the RDR community🥲

[@Dyslexify]

Buddy you’re insane😂😂😂

[@Farfigschiter.]

That hat might be the closest thing to assassin's creed and red dead redemption coming together

[@CornholioPuppetMaster]

I only met her as John on the first playthrough because I didn’t know when Arthur would die

[@silkroad1201]

Jesus. She aged 20 years in 7

[@aminedioua748]

John pulls out his gun 💀

[@RDBTheRedDeath]

Arthur didn’t teach her about the element of surprise

[@zakenmaru8612]

0:02 General Kenobi!

[@Thatonepatriot77]

You are a bold one

[@retrospect5056]

Our pfps are the same

[@Thatonepatriot77]

@@retrospect5056 enclave

[@faraday1548]

"Those are an interesting choice of last words Charlotte."

[@lautaroescarlon7501]

Wow great find i cant believe they put this in. What the heck rockstar lol

[@funasylumstudio]

I got COVID and feelin like Arthur right now NGL

[@DaManAbove]

Elderberry's and find something OTC with Famotidine in it. Be Better in no time

[@fdn1697]

Lol at the end there, it was like John was saying, "what do you mean by 'interesting'??!"

[@sidjr98]

I wore the entire ghost bison outfit during all three missions with her and she finally said something about Arthur’s hat when she kissed him goodbye. I haven’t gotten into the epilogue to see if she notices the hat again, but I’m going to update this comment when I find out!

[@Reyfan601]

So you found out?

[@jaykdos9521]

John's about to show the purity of the Legion's justice

[@t-dog82]

After that she’s never home again .. would have been nice to have a friend way out there !

[@jenniferespiritu9482]

Bro the end.......

[@jacobr8063]

All NPCs say that sort of thing whenever you wear anything made by the trapper.

[@javohngritten2361]

Video ends “RED DEAD REGRESSION”

[@matthewcarruthers3141]

The tricorn pirate hat gets the same response from randoms

[@kingartison]

I wore a legendary bear hat with Arthur when I met her I didn’t know it wasn’t a common response

[@cherrypoptart2001]

He looking like weather report from jojo lol

[@jotarodogo6535]

When I came back to her as John she was dead in her house still wearing that blue dress when she was with Arthur

[@Kolcx]

Then you didnt Teached her to shoot with Athur. Its the second Mission from Charlotte which appears a couple days after the first one And because Arthur didnt teached her, she starved to death

[@BananaFanatic]

@@Kolcx nope. She got killed by a stalker

[@fourthhorsemendeath218]

I physically cannot be evil as Arthur. I would just end up replaying the game with all good choices

[@dj-ez4yf]

pulls gun

[@fienddao7975]

PUT THE GUN DOWN!!!

[@Werenerjohns]

"Any friend of arthur is a friend of mine." Dutch and micah💀

[@SpaceMeister790]

Meanwhile I still don’t even know where to find these stranger missions

[@steelreal254]

She was dead in the cabin when I went back as John

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

you didn't do the side missions with Arthur. As she says in the video Arthur thaught her how to survive

[@calebthomas3820]

are we just going to go over the cut at the end?

[@Equilibrium21]

Bro became an assassin

[@re11o]

Attention to detail 🧏🏾‍♂️

[@gercey3314]

i wish i could get half immersed as everyone else in the comments of these videos.

[@Ic3h0rnEt14]

0:57 John kinda looks like Ezio from Assassin's Creed here

[@MARKY_D3]

Other than the box with the 100 bucks I never touched anything from her home

[@NicholasUmstead]

The only time I played as a “evil” or low honor Arthur I’d have to be a little tipsy first, only way to make it enjoyable

[@CCJJ160Channels]

As much as I enjoyed God Of War RDR2 absolutely should have won game of the year.

[@amir.music2005]

I actually helped her hunt as John.

[@sami_irl]

because the outfit is custom. its like that with every outfit.

[@NomadSnow]

Nope, just trapper items.

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

@@NomadSnow nope. tricorn hat, viking helmet and to a point the nevada hat too

[@bmprimer7809]

i hear the words *Weather* *Report* are references to something, like those words are related to a green dolphin? i don't know, but it's something to think about

[@realQuestion]

good voice actress

[@SuquinDeMaracuja]

also happens to gang members, they ask where you got that quirky hat

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

it happens with almost all clothing you get from the trapper, as some other extras like the viking helmet, the nevada hat, the prirate tricorn...

[@Metaalbox]

gun

[@Avlarrr1988]

All that video for just the last 3 secs..

[@komengav]

On my evil play through, as Arthur, after facing off against wolves, shooting rats and learning how to hunt, I had but one final challenge for Charolette; survive ME. 🙈

[@strummi1]

She says the same everytime

[@sponjbob911]

I'm am a whole ass (that one french guy)

[@Novelist1029]

Assassins Creed Munneh

[@redpandascorner6539]

Why'd you draw that gun john...

[@jesse7157]

Not exclusive to her either. Npcs all over will comment if you're wearing animal hats

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

basicaly everything made by the trapper in terms of clothing. And others like the tricorn hat, viking helmet and the nevada hat (they'll tell you you seem a lawman and when do you'll be stopping playing lawman, as it bothers them)

[@McBoiMally]

Me who never talked to her as aurther

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

congrats, you found a skeleton, lol

[@TAGZLABZ]

Directed by Robert E Weide

[@S4SATYAM1]

I just did this quest after the cut scene ended I pulled a gun at her to see how will she react She started shooting at me ☠️ I killed her(as John) (out of instinct ) now idk I feel bad so much bad

[@ody-ev7be]

After that where i can find her again ?

[@luannguyen9522]

So can i aske i should done all mission of her as Athur then can i come back to meet her as John ?

[@kingkeyon-lo2oi]

yes john would just find her corpse in her home if Arthur didn't help her.

[@Dreamer23245]

way to cram it all in the last 10 seconds of the video though..

[@RDBTheRedDeath]

People complain about not including the full cutscenes then people complain about 2 minutes wasting their precious time. At least this way the impatient people can just skip around or find it somewhere else.

[@returnmann6496]

Can’t lie you did numbers and asmr might be a thing continue😅

[@brandonparson8821]

Does she say anything if you're wearing the pirate hat?

[@light2230]

That's pretty cool

[@i-ate-bread]

thank fuck you didn't decide to just randomly aim the weapon at her like some other videos edit: oh no

[@elizabitty213]

Where exactly is her home again?

[@iambuhlockay8007]

North of Annesburg

[@aldrichhf35]

Pretty much at the edge of rdr2 map. Just south west of it, or just north of annesburg

[@elizabitty213]

Thank you guys! 😅

[@harsh111yt]

Use Google map for navigation

[@testypresidentgaming]

lol the last 2 seconds come on

[@RDBTheRedDeath]

Ok so For everyone complaining about it being in the “last two seconds”, when I used to just upload things excluding the cutscene people would complain that the video wasn’t longer or that I didn’t include the full cutscene. So that’s why I do it now. I mean is it really that hard to just watch 2 minutes of something or just skip? I mean come on.

[@maaz322]

she aged like sour milk

[@Badookum]

No? She was already in her mid 40s when you meet her in 1899 as Arthur

[@TheMindofagenius1]

This cutscene won't happen if you already did it with Arthur right? It's the final mission of her quest line?

[@IIKraftI]

no, this cutscene happens only if you helped her as Arthur, otherwise there will only be her dead body for John to discover.

[@TheMindofagenius1]

@@IIKraftI bruh what?!! For real?? I was just wondering if the cutscene with Arthur is the last one so even if I do go as John, will she still be there or something.... but now I'm just shook o_o

[@Maddog-xc2zv]

@@TheMindofagenius1 Arthur taught her how to survive, as she well recognizes it. without the help missions with Arthur she wouldn't last long in the wild, like her husband was proof of it.

[@luannguyen9522]

I have the shame question. What happen if i just help her in two mission and left the last mission for John will i see this cutscene of find her body

[@TheMindofagenius1]

@@luannguyen9522 I have yet to find out xD

[@tiag78]

hat

[@SoapyIsThe1]

Why are you acting like it only happens with legendary animal hats?

[@Aaaaamon]

Wow. Now im blocking your channel

[@repghost9481]

i wear this as arthur and the gang keep making fun of me🥲

[@DrXance]

1:12