If Osho met Nietzsche (a debate)

Рет қаралды 44,590

Desi Philosopher

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 303

@PRATIK-u5y Ай бұрын

"Life is a festival, enjoy it" -OSHO

@aak597 Ай бұрын

😂 overrated 😂😂😂

@TrioTube-AKA Ай бұрын

@@Acharya_RahulMen Are Cursed They have To Work as muchbas possible -Nietzsche

@TrioTube-AKA Ай бұрын

@@Acharya_Rahul Dalal hai kya?

@Nimit_oc Ай бұрын

@@Acharya_Rahulthat was good

@udayrajjoshi1901 Ай бұрын

Yes it is a festival

@PhilosophersCanvas Ай бұрын

When Nietzsche said God is dead to Osho, he responded. How ? How can anyone be dead who was never alive ? Osho further added, "Your statement sounds like Santa is dead. Dear Nietzsche, I am highlighting the absurdity of declaring the death of something fictional. "

@pratyushsandilya5053 Ай бұрын

Pehle too khud padh le aur isko bhi achhe se padhkar video banane ko bol

@willofd6981 Ай бұрын

I knew osho is incomplete godman, upanishad padha hota to nasadiya sukta ke bare me Pata hota , jaha bola jata hai existence of universe ke bare me shayad ishwar ko bhi Pata nahi , yahan hame samajh ata hai Hinduism nahi bolta Hume sab Pata hai

@aloneboy_0696 Ай бұрын

😂 nice one 🔥

@JAIBHOLAY13 Ай бұрын

So what... Whats ur own... Everything is Cut copy paste.... You are not giving a solution just pointing errors, grow up 😒😒@@Acharya_Rahul

@JAIBHOLAY13 Ай бұрын

@@pratyushsandilya5053ek kaam kr bhai... TU HEE roshini dikha de 😭😭 main bhatka hu...😢😢

@positiveness143 Ай бұрын

Bhai Osho is not comparable with any one, He is on top..

@QadeerSindhi-b7u Ай бұрын

You don't know about Nietzsche

@shivamji1234 Ай бұрын

@QadeerSindhi-b7uyou don't know anything about osho ...go listen to him , specially his Hindi audiobooks ...which is brilliant.

@positiveness143 Ай бұрын

@QadeerSindhi-b7u see the practical life of both being. U can see the difference

@Overman2000 18 күн бұрын

How many books of Nietzsche have you read? And what's his philosophy?

@savvy_me Ай бұрын

Osho was just a presenter who collected pre-existing philosophies and spiritualities and presented them in eye-catching fashion

@kashafbinshamim Ай бұрын

What's wrong with it?

@gauravmalik1883 Ай бұрын

Ideas build upon ideas. Everyone gains knowledge from others - what's wrong with that - apart from that osho examined all that knowledge , relate to his life , applied it all and gained new insights from his consciousness too as i said ideas build upon ideas you can also try learning something snd if you do examine, relate , apply - then you will also have aha moments So He had his own insights too and he presented them in very simple and logical manner 💯 And he was so so amazing .. so grateful for him .. he was a buddha ❤

@singhskeptic5742 Ай бұрын

He had orginal thoughts as well

@gauravmalik1883 Ай бұрын

@@savvy_me name one person who didn't learn from another Be it jesus , krishna , buddha , kabir Everyone learns from their fellow beings too We all are one only ❤️ And he had his original thoughts for sure 💯💯💯💯💯💯💯

@anerkant Ай бұрын

Who tells everything by himself except prophets? No one ever did that. Everyone has to learn from others directly or from books. Osho read but he did not pretend or pose as fake. He said what he deeply grasped. Prophets neither read nor study under a teacher. They say great things lines high level language only because god helps them. When god stops even they can't say something that high on their own.

@napoleanhill_123 Ай бұрын

"Nietzsche saw man as a bridge, but he could not see what man was a bridge to. The superman is not outside, it is inside." - Osho

@tekamaniket3619 Ай бұрын

Bhaisaab...... I am not so religious person but you helped me to get the words for my feelings and thoughts Kudos to you man. Keep up the good work it just blow my mind

@rudraraval7581 Ай бұрын

came across your channel a few weeks ago.. one of the best philosophy channel on internet keep it up man great work

@bijayrao Ай бұрын

Boss what a topic and what an innovative approach to cover it. Have been going through your lectures as a silent backbencher student but could not stop today .. you were amazing in this one my friend. These are like two voices within you and as long as you decide to follow at least one, you are home else keep looking for your god!! 😄

@DesiPhilosopher748 Ай бұрын

❤️

@user-je1hi6jy1i Ай бұрын

Nietzsche is like a kid in front of Osho, Nietzsche is a great thinker and philosopher but he is only a thinker whereas Osho is a Self-realised individual which comes under the category of Buddha, Krishna Murthy, Alan watts, bodhidharma, Krishna, Jesus, Ramana Maharshi, Ramakrishna paramhansa, etc he experienced the highest level of experience any human can achieve. I believe he is Buddha of this century but people are not even realising this now, Maybe after 100-200 years later when collective human consciousness and paradigm will shift, then people will understand these highly experiancially intelligent people like osho.

@amandeepsinghpathania5500 Ай бұрын

Nietzsche is way above osho Bhai. Every thought of osho is borrowed from philosopher before him . Even in his lectures in Germany, he used Nietzsche to convey his message.

@Sarguntyagi1.0 Ай бұрын

The knowledge osho had is unveliable

@user-je1hi6jy1i Ай бұрын

@@amandeepsinghpathania5500 but the question is "is Nietzsche an enlightened being" no infact his life is very miserable that means whatever his philosophies are they didn't work even for him too, but Osho's philosophical ideas are just not ideas they are experienced intelligence he experienced god and helped many of his students to experience the same thing. Your lack of understanding of osho clearly shows you are just an intellectual parrot who just repeats the ideas of other who but didn't understand anything by heart. You do not have any spiritual understanding.

@Rohanisheree Ай бұрын

@@user-je1hi6jy1iBhai don't judge someone by one comment. He's just giving a statement. That's ego

@RahulRathor-z5v Ай бұрын

how do you know what self realization is ? how do you know what was the level of buddha or krishna ? osho has made a video for people like you which is called 'ye to madhushala hai' i think you should watch it.

@prashsin7662 Ай бұрын

**Nietzsche:** You talk about celebrating life, Osho, but most people live in a state of weakness, following society's rules and not truly being themselves. To truly be free, we need to rise above these limits and create our own values. Life is about struggle and overcoming the "herd mentality" to become something great, the Übermensch (superman). **Osho:** But Nietzsche, you're focused too much on struggle and control. Life doesn't have to be a battle. The true freedom comes from letting go, from accepting life as it is, not from fighting against it. You don’t need to constantly strive to be better. Just relax, be present, and you will find peace. **Nietzsche:** If you relax and accept everything, you're just giving up. Life is a fight! The strong rise above the weak. You need to create yourself through struggle and willpower, not by accepting everything. **Osho:** But if you're always fighting, you create tension and suffering. True freedom comes from letting go of that need to always control and fight. Embrace life, accept it, and you’ll find that you are already free. You don’t have to be in constant conflict with others to be great. **Nietzsche:** But accepting everything means accepting mediocrity. The weak do that. Only the strong who push themselves to the limit are truly free. You must be different, not just blend in with the crowd. **Osho:** But you don’t need to be different by fighting. The power comes from being yourself, from being connected to life. If you stop fighting against life, you might realize that you are already powerful and unique, just as you are. **Nietzsche:** That might sound comforting, but it's not true. Life is about striving, creating, and becoming more. Without that struggle, life would have no meaning. **Osho:** I see it differently. Struggle is only in the mind. Life itself is about being present and enjoying the moment. When you let go of the need to fight, you naturally become the best version of yourself. You don’t have to strive for it. **Nietzsche:** I’ll never agree with that. For me, it’s all about pushing forward, creating greatness. For you, it’s about accepting things as they are. **Osho:** Maybe so, but in the end, both of us are looking for freedom. Whether you push hard to create your own values or just let life be, it’s about breaking free from society's rules and being yourself. **Nietzsche:** I’ll keep climbing. I need to rise above. **Osho:** And I’ll keep letting go. I need to flow with life. ---

@sadhak-hc2th Ай бұрын

To Nietzsche : If life will be taken as battle rather than a play, one day you will get exhausted with 100% guarantee. Have you not seen a little child playing, enjoying making a miniature house with such a joy, without any lack of energy whole day. And, same child with a task, a battle given by his mother to complete school homework, or the same miniature house making project seems to exhaust instantly.

@piyushsahu591 Ай бұрын

Please continue this series 🙏

@Saadhu_Baba Ай бұрын

If Osho and Nietzsche sits in one room then believe me Osho has no need to speak..Nietzsche will surrender himself like an innocent kid and will learn to meditate 🧘 like Osho.

@raghuvarkimadi Ай бұрын

Nietzsche "God is dead" Acharya prashant : "God was never born" intellectual mind at peak ❣❣😂😂

@Nevio918 Ай бұрын

Acharya Prashant is baccha in front of JK and Osho

@raghuvarkimadi Ай бұрын

@Nevio918 if you use that word for acharya prashant, means you haven't yet known JK and osho.

@Nevio918 23 күн бұрын

@raghuvarkimadi oh really? I have listened to what they have said and out of that I am saying this. AP is a great intellectual and scholar. But those two great masters have experienced the truth themselves not just uttering words.

@jeesafar6430 Ай бұрын

Osho has a series of discourses in which he has responded to Nietzsche's statement 'God is dead'. The name of the Hindi discourse series is (क्या ईश्वर मर गया हैं ?)....You can both read and listen to it. There is another book by Osho on 'Thus Spoke Zarathustra' its name is 'Zarathustra A God that can dance'.

@growwithaman Ай бұрын

Which discourse

@RupeshKumar-ni1vd Ай бұрын

Keep up the grind dawg, we will be supporting you no matter what

@xancon_rixx Ай бұрын

Unique content idea. And please bring an ultimate video on Nicolo Machiavelli soon. Pls 🙏

@DesiPhilosopher748 Ай бұрын

Next up

@willofd6981 Ай бұрын

@@DesiPhilosopher748I knew osho is incomplete godman, upanishad padha hota to nasadiya sukta ke bare me Pata hota , jaha bola jata hai existence of universe ke bare me shayad ishwar ko bhi Pata nahi , yahan hame samajh ata hai Hinduism nahi bolta Hume sab Pata hai

@Sarguntyagi1.0 Ай бұрын

Osho used to read 2-3 books a day imagine the knowledge he had

@DurpatipangiDurpati Ай бұрын

Bro that thumbnail says how much dedicated you are to deliver content best of luck I have never written such word to anyone,you were worthy

@DesiPhilosopher748 Ай бұрын

Thanks to the person making the thumbnail for the channel

@IamTruthist Ай бұрын

@@DesiPhilosopher748 Banda down to earth hai down to earth

@DurpatipangiDurpati Ай бұрын

@DesiPhilosopher748 kudos to him and lots of blessings

@biswajitsen001 Ай бұрын

@IamTruthist he is brother of balraj

@IamTruthist Ай бұрын

@@biswajitsen001 ?? Who is balraj

@Ayushi4646 Ай бұрын

Nietzsche is good but osho is something different... Accept this

@69FPSGAMING 27 күн бұрын

@@Acharya_Rahul yes,it's your thinking 😊

@Indian.badger Ай бұрын

I just came here to let you know that this thumbnail is so attractive and clickable. Your skill in creating this thumbnail is top-notch - truly remarkable!

@pinku_49 Ай бұрын

Osho has accepted Nietzsche's philosophy there's no need of Any debate.

@FarruKhan-g9s Ай бұрын

1:45 thumbnail nailed ❤

@aloneboy_0696 Ай бұрын

These topics/videos/books are good for current youth... Biography/Autobiography Memoir Self-help History Science Philosophy Religion/Spirituality Politics Journals Research papers Literature Psychology Rationality Ethics and morality Logic argument reasoning fact check

@forogboy Ай бұрын

Bro thumbnail aur content dono hi top notch wala he!

@neilcreation Ай бұрын

You've been on a spree of uploads and im all in for it

@supporton6327 Ай бұрын

carl jung psychology full video plz

@Acharya_Rahul Ай бұрын

Carl Jung v Sigmund Freud

@rainmaker1989 Ай бұрын

Overall Winner? It depends on the audience: For the individual seeking empowerment: Nietzsche. For the seeker of inner peace and transcendence: Osho. For intellectual rigor and philosophical depth: Nietzsche. For an inspiring vision of humanity's future: Osho. Realistically, the "winner" would be subjective, as both thinkers operate in realms that fulfill different human needs. However, Nietzsche might win in a Western, rationalist setting, while Osho would resonate more in a spiritual or holistic context.

@rahulgoswami7813 Ай бұрын

Bhai Osho aur Nietzsche ki kasam badi sahi acting ki hai. Veey good and intellectual video. Ty!

@everytimelatest7453 Ай бұрын

Life is a battle and fight with enjoy dear thnks for this beautiful wisdom Let's go beyond everything Once again thanks my brthr ❤

@guribourhai Ай бұрын

Please brother continue this series 🙏🏻

@chionophiled Ай бұрын

Bro your thumbnail and content is going 📈 .

@rohitmalhotra918 Ай бұрын

Bhai baised nhi hote ho aap most amazing work❤

@batgoat1857 7 күн бұрын

Nietzsche may be the most criticized philosopher in history but he certainly destroys Osho

@sahil-yx2wv Ай бұрын

this is very good concept for a video i would love to watch more

@sumitmangar8563 Ай бұрын

Please make more Osho vs Neitza fight

@UniversalDisciple Ай бұрын

Next Video on Jeremy Bentham pls

@pravesh-sudha Ай бұрын

Bhaiya I really liked this lecture. Would love to hear more on this series soon! I was reading Notes from the Underground by Fyodor Dostoevsky and I was not able to understand it properly. I watched JB Perterson, explain the crux but I would really appreciate your understanding on the novel. PS: Loved your Work, keep it up :)

@Abdullah04u-q3c Ай бұрын

Amazing content 😊

@JayTVIndia Ай бұрын

Thnks for making this happen

@Jayantamondal-d6m Ай бұрын

Osho talks about every bad aspect of almost all the religious book in a neutral way And also he explianed the good thing about those books "Scriptures are dead" You have to be your own light

@akshitatamrakar Ай бұрын

I don't know about other religion but in my religion God had never said that you have to just sit back and tolerate things and one day he'll come and do things...In my religion God said that Do your Karma and do your best and always remember that I'm always here with you but for your goals you have to do hard work Shree Krishna said that when one do his/her karma with his/ her full potential then all the devik saktiya and even God himself help him/her to achieve their goals..but one should initiate himself and have to deal with their problem and fight from everything by themselves..with the faith that God is always with him and he can do anything because when he do his karma God will help him achieve anything.

@FangYuan-m6r Ай бұрын

Osho : east or west only the only greatest philosopher who ever live , one whose thought somethings reaches the depth of buddha and zobra ,( Neitsche)

@Devxchauhan0 Ай бұрын

Bro is dropping bangers continuously

@Ecatasy Ай бұрын

Why we are comparing them , Just absorb which is Good ❤ Comparison is the Theif of Joy ~ Confucius

@Narasimha_TheSher Ай бұрын

Your last video on Osho was a masterpiece. But seriously, I am cringing the whole time you speak on behalf of Osho in this video.

@DesiPhilosopher748 Ай бұрын

Nah, you totally missed it, I never took sides here

@Narasimha_TheSher Ай бұрын

@@DesiPhilosopher748 Absolutely, you represented both of them fairly. It was just a small feeling of cringe from my side during Osho's words.

@willofd6981 Ай бұрын

@pratikdulal1248 Ай бұрын

Bhai jitna garib hota hai utana religions hote hai insan 😂

@happyrao3830 Ай бұрын

Haahaa 1000 percent stayaaa

@FarruKhan-g9s Ай бұрын

Point

@hetalsoni4576 Ай бұрын

Fellecy

@FarruKhan-g9s Ай бұрын

@Acharya_Rahul kyunke woh bhootiya banane ke liye 😂📈

@Home-o2v4h Ай бұрын

@@Acharya_Rahul Because they are attached to their material wealth and thats why they need a higher power to prevent anyone from taking their attachments away from them.

@tokyostreams7982 Ай бұрын

Bro you have good content. Only suggestion I have is that you should improve you delivery .

@travllrtalk Ай бұрын

I think amazing content Matlab mazzzza a gya 😂❤

@Hatake07618 Ай бұрын

Bro what a topic😭

@johnsonjon8034 Ай бұрын

Damnn thanks for such a awesome lecture

@SumanRoy-b3n Ай бұрын

sir duniya ka gyan dejiye❤❤🎉🎉

@TECHCRAZE-TC Ай бұрын

OSHO FAN ASSEMBLE HERE ❤

@arpitkoliwal558 Ай бұрын

pls aap apna face chhupa kr or awaaz ki pitch same level pe rkh kr kre to jyada smjh aayega

@jayatewari1272 Ай бұрын

देखिए हम किसी को डरायेंगे नहीं। लेकिन एक प्रश्न पूछेंगे समय उत्तर देने के लिए ताउम्र कभी भी दे सकता। इत्यादि

@Acharya_Rahul Ай бұрын

Ask

@utkarshjogdand8197 Ай бұрын

great vedio unique concept

@Akashsharma.2004 Ай бұрын

Osho will win always 🎉🎉🎉

@aliakbarhussaini7343 Ай бұрын

Please make a video in detail If Rumi met Nietzsche

@rohitchaker3153 Ай бұрын

Great Debate 👌

@ShuklaAtul-p5l Ай бұрын

Nice video

@keshavsood2676 Ай бұрын

I read osho books, he mentioned that Nietzsche did great work .

@ArpitMaan-yt Ай бұрын

Nice thumbnail

@omkargouraje6243 Ай бұрын

The complete statement is like ... 'God is dead. We have killed the God.' That means we believe in god, pray to god but we ignore him for our selfish gains. The every human is like that and hence concept of god (good-bad) is dead.

@rdc515 Ай бұрын

Just for kicks, I tried this topic with GPT: create a conversation between osho and nietzsche ChatGPT said: Certainly! Here’s a fictional conversation between Osho, the modern spiritual teacher, and Friedrich Nietzsche, the 19th-century philosopher, centered around their views on life, spirituality, and human nature: Osho: (smiling) Friedrich, you speak of the "Übermensch," the "Overman," as the one who transcends conventional morality. But tell me, what is it that you think he transcends? Isn’t transcendence itself just another form of escape from the very life we live? Nietzsche: (laughs) Ah, Osho, you have a knack for cutting to the heart of things. The Übermensch is not an escape from life-it is an affirmation of life in all its chaos and suffering. He is the one who says "yes" to existence, who embraces its struggles, its pain, its beauty. We must transcend conventional morals, those shackles that make us feel guilty for living fully, for asserting our will. Osho: (nodding thoughtfully) Yes, I agree, but you speak of “will” as if it were something absolute, something that could be harnessed. To me, life is not something that needs to be controlled by willpower. It’s not about overcoming, but about surrendering, letting go. The moment you grasp at life, you limit it. True freedom comes not from asserting one’s will, but from dissolving the boundaries of the self and flowing with existence. You see, Nietzsche, life is not a battle to be won, but a dance to be enjoyed. Nietzsche: (smirking) Ah, surrendering, you say? I believe that’s the easy way. The masses of humanity surrender to fate, to destiny, to the comfortable order that suppresses their true potential. But my vision of humanity is one of strength, of self-overcoming. What you describe is a form of weakness, a submission to the forces of life. The Übermensch is not someone who submits; he creates, he conquers, he dares. Osho: (gently) But Nietzsche, isn't there strength in letting go? Isn't there power in the ability to surrender to the present moment, to the flow of life, without the need for domination? Your Übermensch, while seemingly powerful, seems burdened by the weight of constant striving, as though he is never at ease with what is. True power lies in being utterly at peace, in being the observer of your thoughts and actions without attachment. It’s not about conquering the world-it’s about becoming one with it. Nietzsche: (pauses, intrigued) You speak of peace, Osho, but what is peace without passion? Without the fire of the soul to drive us forward? To be content, to rest in the flow of existence, seems to me a kind of resignation. I believe that life is not meant to be passive, but active, dynamic. It is through struggle that one becomes more than oneself. Osho: (smiling) Struggle, yes, but what if the struggle itself is the illusion? What if the very idea of becoming "more" is part of the trap? In your pursuit of power, you may forget that all the striving in the world cannot bring you peace. It can only bring you exhaustion. You can achieve all the greatness you desire, and still, the inner emptiness remains. This emptiness is not something to fight against-it is the space from which all creativity and true joy arises. You are already everything you need to be. You don't need to struggle to become; you need only to awaken to your own nature. Nietzsche: (looking thoughtful) So you would say that becoming is not necessary, that we are already whole? But if that is so, why then do we live in such a fragmented world? Why is there so much suffering, if we are already complete? Osho: (gently) The world is fragmented because people are disconnected from their true nature. They live in their minds, in their conditioning, in their past. They are not present to what is. The suffering comes not because life is inherently painful, but because people resist what is happening. They cling to their desires, their expectations. They identify with their egos and become fearful of their own dissolution. True peace, true awakening, comes from the realization that you are not the mind, the body, the ego. You are the eternal witness, the observer of it all. When you realize this, suffering disappears-not by changing the world, but by changing your perception of it. Nietzsche: (laughs softly) And yet, I find this idea of dissolution troubling. You would have us dissolve the self, and in doing so, make us less than human. My vision was one of self-affirmation, a celebration of the will to power, not renunciation. Osho: (smiling deeply) But Nietzsche, in your search for the "will to power," you miss the deeper truth-that the strongest power is not the power to control, but the power to surrender. When you surrender, you are not diminished; you are liberated. The self is not a fortress to be built, but a veil to be dropped. When the veil falls, you see the whole universe reflected in your own being. You are both the dreamer and the dream, the creator and the creation. Nietzsche: (quietly) Perhaps, Osho, you are right in your own way. But I would never wish to lose the fire that drives me forward, that gives life its meaning. Osho: (gently) The fire is not lost; it is transformed. It becomes the flame of awareness, not the fire of egoic ambition. When you live from that place of deep awareness, you are not burning out-you are simply shining, effortlessly. Nietzsche: (pauses, reflecting) Perhaps that is a fire I have yet to understand. Osho: (smiling) Ah, the journey never ends, Friedrich. Each of us has our own path, and each path leads to the same destination-the realization that there is no destination, only the moment. In this conversation, Osho and Nietzsche explore their differing views on life, spirituality, and human potential. While Nietzsche focuses on strength, self-assertion, and the will to power, Osho advocates for surrender, awareness, and inner peace. Both recognize the complexity of human existence, but they offer different paths toward understanding it.

@rishabhthakur8773 Ай бұрын

How many have read both osho and nietzsche ? How many books have you read ?

@ahmedlabib999 Ай бұрын

Good video

@anantkumarsingh5355 Ай бұрын

Aisa Chhota Chhota video mat Dala kijiye please baki logon Ki tarah Vahi Lamba Lamba dekhne Mein bahut maja aata Hai

@DesiPhilosopher748 Ай бұрын

Bnane me toh lagg jaati h na bhai

@ipushprajyadav Ай бұрын

@xancon_rixx Ай бұрын

@@DesiPhilosopher748 💀

@abhi8030 Ай бұрын

😂😂@@DesiPhilosopher748

@willofd6981 Ай бұрын

Ай бұрын

I think Dostoevsky was the first and you mentioned it well. I'm waiting your lecture for his novel, The Idiot. Just consider it. Thanks.

@usmanshakiir Ай бұрын

Respect and wishes from Lahore Pakistan.

@Viikram21 Ай бұрын

Bro thumbnail day by day 📈