PM Modi's Economic Advisor On India's Hidden History | Sanjeev Sanyal

[@yugmathakkar4023]

Man I love how outspoken Sanjeev really is. We need more people like him in the government.

[@utub1ng]

not just government, even in our day to day, the more we apply the principles discussed here the better our chances of being sensibly outspoken. This video is a gem for anyone and everyone who wants to understand how Sanjeev Sanyal sir approaches life. An hour well spent.

[@yugmathakkar4023]

@@utub1ng Agreed.

[@NitinWarty]

@@utub1ng😊😊😊😊😊

[@NitinWarty]

@@yugmathakkar4023ii

[@indranilseth1551]

Keep in mind … he is also a no nonsense man

[@pawanchabukswar6707]

As an Architect and Urban Planner, I agree with his broader view of the organic city, NBC, master planning and urban mis-management in India.

[@user-ix7zq1hz8w]

'THE STITCHED SHIP PROJECT' IS SO INTERESTING 💯👏

[@user-kk7kf7vr5h]

Can you name it?

[@nikipods]

Both Sanjaav and Mukesh are so articulate

[@chaitanyakada1341]

I loved your statement when you said : We are not trying to rebuild our economy, we are trying to rebuild a “civilisation”

[@manishashimla]

Thank you thank you for having him on the show! Fan of Sanjeevji! Everytime he shares something new historic facts.

[@SakshiBatavia]

15 minutes into It and already loving the conversation

[@priteshtrivedi510]

Damnnn so good. We need a part 2 asap with Sanjeev sir. 🔥

[@kvtechvarshney5179]

What a man, Sanjeev Sanyal sir! I'm his big fan. I've listened to all his podcasts, such an inspiring person and a scholar. Looking forward to read his books!

[@vaishakh3]

If you make a second video with Sanjeev Sanyal, like Neelkanth ask him about the quality of education in India and why Indians don't have the skillset or the work ethics like Chinese and how do we bring that in India.

[@Immortal_lion99]

Its surprising chinese and japanese follow karma theory, meaning be a karmayogi, and dont care about unnecessary results and stuff. Irony is this theory originated in India. Maybe in the garb of secularism and modernity we failed to embrace it.

[@namansinghnegi8931]

I feel that we attribute too much to the Chinese and Japanese work ethics. In my opinion factors like western patronage and cold war played a more important role in development of these countries. Also the loss that India suffered in 1962 war, reduced the importance of India in western circles.

[@YuvrajGarg]

Great Conversation , Looking forward to more such episodes !

[@saksheesarrawgi]

Have been waiting for this episode! Can't wait to watch the whole thing.

[@MikaSinghLookalike]

Mukesh looking fireeeeeee

[@JatinV1]

Hey Sparx team, love your Intro Man!

[@zanishgajra2726]

A really insightful conversation!! Loved it

[@subhashishdutta]

I stopped watching this channel after that charlatan Manu Pillai with his "nuance" came as a guest. Manu is particularly dangerous because he is not a liar but he conveniently ignores or omits events, people and other details that doesn't suit the "neo Marxist/Nehruvian" narrative that he is attempting to peddle. This episode has brought me back. Changing school textbooks is an uphill battle but parents should tell their children stories of our revolutionaries and the many other phases of violent resistance that colonizers (both Islamic/Turkic and the British) faced. Sanjeev's (and similar) books should be a must read for all children growing up.

[@VigneshGouthaman]

Amazing episode. Love hearing Sanjeev Sanyal. Please have Prof. Prasanna Tantri on your podcast to speak about various govt initiatives. He is an amazing mind with a unique ability to communicate succinctly.

[@nikipods]

Honestly so insightful

[@lipidsled]

Hah, i commented and tweeted about Mukesh calling a very myopic set of propaganda writers on history & mythology and should probably explore someone like Sanjeev Sanyal instead.. Whatever be the reason (probably neelkanth mishra is) good to see Sanjeev on the show instead of dolts like Devdutt etc.

[@jigsaw2281]

Omg devdutt is a complete frauudd ... vampathi

[@amritbansal2119]

Funny that you think sanyal is not propaganda 😂

[@varunkhugshal9049]

​​@@amritbansal2119he is not propagandaist, he is a free thinker, whose facts are not half assed. You are free to present alternating interpretetion of those facts. Devdutt knows neither sanskrit and makes so many mistakes to reach his sexual conclusion, clearly shows he is a cunning dolt.

[@FriendlyVimanam]

​@@amritbansal2119 if it's so funny why don't you go ahead and help us lowly creatures and enlighten us with the exclusive knowledge that is only present in the WhatsApp groups of the high-class people of the society called lefticles.

[@harshitgupta5223]

Totally agree. He also brought manu pillai guy. A leftist.

[@Ganapathyraman]

superb episode ! what a perspective !

[@daneilpatro2776]

thnx. for this episode/

[@aniljagruth7664]

Excellent,may b he can speak on our education policy to make future generation on polymath...

[@SattickDas2001]

Sanjeev Kaku , tumi WB er FM hoe jao du tin bochor er jonmo, State tar chehara palte jabe।❤

[@manh9105]

FM with crook Mamta as CM ?

[@dwaipayanmoitra4651]

Obviously not ​@@manh9105

[@arpan9937]

​@@manh9105obv. not. Bengal is going to be one of the strongholds of the BJP.

[@st376]

Sanjeev Sanyal ji truly is a visionary, and would love to learn from him. I need a new career as an urban planner, and learn to make and implement a new non-soviet non-boxy mindset.

[@Anmolkumar-ii8tc]

So informative!!

[@nikipods]

So good!

[@Rajl52039]

Excellent discussion and some inspiring insights and ideas for the youngsters.

[@mayankkadhikanshh4685]

Finally , thank u mukesh

[@mayankm5200]

Very good.

[@NearLWatson]

I am amazed at how much the colonial mindset has really impacted us. Looking at Mr. Sanjeev I would have not thought he is a Black belt in Taekwondo or involved in sparring. Usually we assume, either they have the Asian look, or they are muscular. With the specs and the professional look, he clearly looks like an economist, administrator. What a learning for the self, I definitely am taking something more than the talk, our own people can surprise us, and we should definitely not judge by physical appearances.

[@shekhspeare11]

excited!!

[@MikaSinghLookalike]

Is this THE SHEKHSPEARE??????

[@sakshxxm5588]

Soo good!!

[@djsunshine1]

Inspiring!

[@ushamenon6975]

thank u both..enjoyed Sparx

[@Darshankapadnis.93]

❤❤❤

[@oneworld633]

Make Naina City 🌆 3rd Mumbai AS--- 1) 1 CR+population livable, atleast 70 lakhs + Flats with own garden 🏡! 2)80 lakhs floting population accommodable With 4X width of current Indian Road standards, Enough padersrian patha, Bycycle,path, hokkers path & parking space on ROADs , Encroachment Free space NEEDED 3) enough unirals, Free space, Grounds,Ample Gardens Needed!!! 4) Skyline should be like Hongkong, Dubai, Manhattan Area,but Roads 4X wider than these international metro cities !!! Hope Maharashtra Government will not make it Failed cities like New Mumbai washi Area !!! Think Large Global in nature! Problem of 1000 yrs Gulami is that Even in Dreams , thought 🤔💭 we occupy little space & leaving large space for Self Doubt ,international labels approvals !!!

[@Breakoutindex]

Next big thing smart village ❤

[@jigsaw2281]

Can somebody will tell me from start to finish how many days it takes to start a business in India...???

[@eshnasharma1644]

what an episode

[@bharatkashyapindia]

Sanjeev for Minister of Urban Affairs

[@mayankkadhikanshh4685]

Now one with Nitin Gadkari and Tarun Mehta … please

[@Akshat_Ji]

I'm loving the conservation 🎉❤

[@nikipods]

❤❤❤❤

[@bakuleshdalal1280]

We should apply the system used in BUDGET to observe Secrecy and make leak proof.

[@funnymanallinsanw9606]

Legends say he's still saying "right"

[@Breakoutindex]

Only talking about city buzz, smart village next big thing❤

[@ndb14421432]

👍👍

[@gurusaran1892]

But being frank soviet also built sisters of moscow

[@dobidobi8257]

*I have read Mr Sanjeev Sanyal books* *If someone could please pass it to Mr Sanjeev Sanyal* *That please include maps in his book so that it becomes more clear and more people will buy* It will also increase the geopolitical and geo incidents awareness of the readers *The maps if like military maps depicting call out boxes with incidents would've fantastic* ANYWAY DON'T THINK MY HUMBLE SUGGESTION WILL REACH MT SANYAL AND IF IT REACHES DON'T THINK IT WILL BE Considered BY MR SANYAL HOWEVER POSTING IT JUST BECAUSE MAY BE JUST MAY BE IT MAY BE CONSIDERED AND I CAN BUY THE BOOKS AGAIN AND ENJOY READING WITH MAPS

[@AnAn___]

How can India quickly become a world leader in AI inside India (versus the diaspora dominating AI outside India)?

[@bharath2508]

Lens kart ceo😮

[@MrPurnima123]

So smart city was his idea.... What did happened

[@nrao8977]

Shatru Bodh is absolutely important. Leave showing the other cheek to the Pope. Ordinary people need to follow Dharma.

[@MikaSinghLookalike]

No way

[@lenkababu2339]

He is pointing towards nonsense comment/theory of Raghuram Rajan

[@niraj2020]

For congress and Left Jihadi mukth Bharat we need to decolonise democracy, history, deradicalise, deregulate, delicense, debureaucratise our system and govt functions. 21st century must run with start 'de'. We need minimum govt for maximum governance.

[@arjunkansal]

why does no one ask such venerated people in a seat to effect change about reservations? why is it a no go area when it directly impacts the human capital of the country right from school till after employment and how it affects our capabilities?

[@chiragr1336]

🙏🙏🙏🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@mjmanan91]

It pains to hear India wasted years on socialistic approach and now again BHINDI alliance is dragging India again to caste census.

[@lopa1108]

trained in history? is it needed to be so called trained if anyone want to explore the fact?? How did Deepesh Chakraborty graduate in physics and have so much knowledge in history??? Desire to know the subject/ fact is important!!!

[@MikaSinghLookalike]

First comment

[@zahidnazir6223]

Practically everything is zero Only good speeches and writing

[@kuldeepsuthar3259]

if formula 1 car race happen in indian city then car will fly to moon due to speed breaker and uneven road

[@madhusudanrao1280]

🪷🪷🪷❤️

[@kuldeepsuthar3259]

there are many socialist leader and freedom fighter like bhagat singh, sardar valabh bhai patel, subhash chandra bose ,savarkar ,gandhi ,and almost 90% pf them are socialist why just blame nehru

[@DARKKNIGHT-jk2eo]

Sawarkar , Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel & Bhagat wasn't socialist at all. For them country & culture first then others.

[@ab-bi7qq]

​@@DARKKNIGHT-jk2eoI am sorry but bhagat singh was a communist to the T.

[@ReturntoJustice]

I beg you Sanjeev to join BJP and become the Chief Ministerial candidate for West Bengal. Otherwise, may the God punishes you 😊

[@varunkhugshal9049]

Politics is no joke...

[@manh9105]

BJP leader who defeated Mamta will be CM. Sanjeev can be a FM and reform minister

[@FriendlyVimanam]

Bhai sab thik tha bas last line thoda galat hogya, hope you see it.

[@KejriwalBhakt]

Lol

[@Red.bulldozer3]

Is god your good friend

[@suhasshetty4563]

Sir you'll be called andhbakth or something now 😅

[@cnthjcb9108]

I don’t agree to many of his points.. even though he is a great achiever

[@ab-bi7qq]

empty talks from a person holding such an important position in our country, but it acts as further proof how baseless and substanceless this neo-RSS ideologues are. Fascism surely gives a dopamine rush but it kills poor first, the privileged later.

[@srinuisnow]

It is quite presumptuous of Mr. Sanyal to talk of building a civilization. Only myopic despots think of crafting a civilization and they invariably fail. Civilizations evolve. At best we can provide an impetus in one direction or the other. I don't have an idea of the economic ideas and philosophy of Mr. Sanyal. But as a historian he often provides a unidimensional view. He is not a honest historian. Historians should not be driven by an agenda. On this count, he is as guilty as the Nehruvian historians he often derides.

[@thearnav67]

First, he has a long track-record of speaking and writing about multiple views and dimensions of various historic events, people, and geographies. Admit that you're mad because he doesn't validate the distortions and misrepresentations that you may have learnt or continue to learn in the name of history. Second, building a civilization doesn't mean building it physically. It refers to cultivating a society with people who are confident in their identities and can aspire and take risks. Civilizations are built when every generation wants to leave behind a better/stronger society and is willing to take the risks and pains today for the benefit of tomorrow.

[@srinuisnow]

The authenticity of history depends on sources. It is not based on interpretations. Historians with integrity present sources as they are. What Mr. Sanyal does is cherrypick his sources or often cite dubious sources without cautioning the reader. Without even knowing me you are presuming things about me. That gives a peek into your mindset. 😊 There will be no further comments from me if you indulge in your tirades.

[@ab-bi7qq]

well said

[@ab-bi7qq]

vacant talks. Problems, prejudices and fancies discussed of privileged class. None of what the economic advisor of our gov talks concernsa those earning 20,000 and below, which is the majority in our country, and it is hard to believe that such poverty exists in our civilzation that mr sanyal is so proud of