Indian Calendar vs. Gregorian: How the Christian Calendar is Holding Us Back | Dr. CK Raju on ACP 86

[@krishnajar]

Finally someone got hold of him. He should be all over the podcasts on KZbin

[@abhilashuppala9944]

This conversation should get a million views at least and should be taught in all schools...

[@rakadus]

Part of NCERT mathematics curriculum and chapters in maths text book.

[@ankitakachhap7933]

Could'nt agree more.

[@dailyui636]

Finally Abhijit sir found a competition in terms of knowledge! What an amazing episode! Thank you sir. Bharat is really incredible!

[@crypton_8l87]

🙄 He's not "competing." Scholars are not into competitions.. they keep their minds open to Learning.

[@MadhavBhandari-k4c]

This is why Nepal continues to use the official Bikram Sambat calendar instead of the Catholic calendar. Most people in Nepal are either unaware of or have no interest in the Catholic calendar.After the monarchy was overthrown, some leaders tried to impose the Catholic calendar, but the people of Nepal firmly rejected it. We don’t need to conform to a foreign system. I hope India will also move towards adopting the Bikram Sambat calendar, embracing its own heritage and breaking free from the lingering influence of foreign occupation.

[@shumbuk4383]

Whoa CK Raju! His talks are so interesting..watched him for years! Such a great teacher.

[@datarampurohit6964]

प्रणाम प्रोफेसर राजू।IAS Shimla, especially its pathways and porches, it's galleries and gathering- halls used to resound with your scholarly naad. Good that you are back to your guru Brihasati seat

[@achunaryan3418]

Amazing conversations. Please bring him again for an Indian astrology/astronomy episode.

[@vijayrk7329]

Pranams to the great man!!

[@Soorilee]

The academic calendars (Vacations) too are set as per British seasons. April, May & June were good for the British officers employed in India bec it was summer there, preferred in a cold country. For us better season is winter so we must have vacation from Navratri to Diwali & weekly off on Thursdays

[@SS-eh4um]

Hi. What's the significance behind Thursday having to be a holiday?

[@richaladdha1973]

​@@SS-eh4um due to the Novena mass that happens at noon on Thursday

[@Rohit_Gawande_Patil]

Thank you ​@@richaladdha1973

[@Parth_Si]

​@@richaladdha1973 still didn't understand the Thursday thing. I googled novena mass it is related to Christian thing and not any Hindu thing or any scientific thing.

[@kannanramasamy3460]

Thanks for sharing this podcast Abhijit Chavda ji. Dr CK Raju ji has explained the whole astronomical science behind the calender concept.

[@pranithmaddirala]

Love Prof CK Raju ❤

[@srr2937]

This should be the next course on Abhijit Sir's offerings on KZbin. Indian calenders and astronomy.

[@divyasinghphougat8520]

Its a joy listening to C K Raju ji.

[@codedusting]

What did you understand?

[@sridharradhakrishnan5134]

He learnt that CK Raju saying your are not collies of west ..fool

[@ffinfac]

Always eye opening.. to hear Acharya Shri Abhijeet Chawda Everything about Abrahmic systems is about control And everything about us Dharmiks is about liberation.

[@renlamomtsopoe]

And everything about you is propaganda

[@vinayakjoshi5029]

Great knowledge comes out from this discussion, made easy and clear for connecting dots. many thanks 🙏

[@umaneelakantan9327]

I think the Hindu Cakebdar shiuld be ysed for all areas of Planning, ... Administrative Planning, Space Technology and Astronomy, Weather Research, etc ..

[@Dimensions-5]

Amazing Episode

[@3ggymania]

Fascinating discussion. Thank you for uploading this!

[@AARYAN-r1A1]

Hindu is not a religion like abrahmics.....hindu is a geo cultural identity. So it is a HINDU calendar.

[@chiranjeev5]

Most most most awaited

[@umeshjagtap63]

Very very important podcast of knowledge in my life time Thanks to both of you

[@artificialization]

wow o wow!!! so many questions answered which had for over 20-30 years. Thanks for bringing him Abhijit. Nice interview. He didsnt digress at all

[@Rishi123456789]

Thank you for getting CK Rajuji onto your show, Abhijitji. CK Rajuji is one of my most favourite people ever along with Kapil Kapoorji and Shrikant Talageriji. Hopefully someday you can get Kapil Kapoorji and Shrikant Talageriji on your show too. Anyway, I completely agree with everything that CK Rajuji said in this video.

[@Vishal-]

Real important for people to know their civilisational systems in order to come out of shackles of ‘mental colonialism’

[@NrupaPatel-ze7sm]

Please call the Dr. C K Raju Sir for another podcast because there are so many things, which we can learn from him...

[@ithedimpleboi]

You can appreciate Nepal for this ❤

[@gajananvk]

Please make such episode in Hindi for all public 🎉

[@BharatXtreme]

we need to introduce bharats own calender system in the main stream.

[@bluewaters2231]

what are u sayg?? in india we hve dt-mth-yr. still, our stupid electricity board uses d american method. now hw many people understd it. banks put d commas accordg to millions n billions n not lacs n crores. need spine to stand up n not be servant class all d time.

[@user-jp9eu1vf7g]

Yep Chins already had

[@paparinomansa7272]

We need to decolonize from all kind of colonizations, be it by Greeks,mughals,or Britishers and get back to the Sanskrit language and research our ancestry before those manipulations from all the colonizers.

[@D.Baatar1998]

Absolutely true ​@@paparinomansa7272

[@ska4666]

Solution is very simple, you start using all things traditional and we’ll see the Change😊

[@malur1980]

Dhanyawad for this podcast 😊😊😊

[@harryp7107]

Very interesting indeed and based on this information on being unscientific.

[@dikshitreddy2707]

Ending was Banger 👊🤣🤣🤣 1:16:03

[@amitsaxena7048]

As an IIT Alumnus and an astrology student, I would like to humbly submit that Vedanga Jyotish consists of astrology also. If you take Atharva Vediya Jyotish by Om Narayan Dvivedi - it has chapters on both astronomy and astrology. In my opinion, astronomy and astrology have always historically gone hand in hand.

[@adityarajsinghrathor]

Don't know how much more time will it take to get True Independence...

[@agniswar3]

But nowadays all Indians use both the Hindu panchang and the Gregorian calendar in unison. In my home we have a calendar that has both Gregorian and Panchang dates printed on it.

[@sns_creativity]

Great talk... Unique topic which you will not get anywhere...

[@ManojSingh-bg9ue]

It's a shame that we have all these great personalities in every field who can counter all the falsehood that have been taught to us and yet we are still being taught all the bullsh*t in our books. We failed as a civilisation!!

[@nirabkarki2838]

NEPAL uses Bikram Samvat calendar. Hope India follows soon.

[@Jagannath38103]

Lol Vikram samvat kalantar is Indian king vikramaditya invention and we use it.

[@sanchitwadehra]

Abhijit ji Dr. Ck Raju ke saath ek podcast kariye specifically define karte hue ki maths mein kya galti hai aur ganit mein kya sahi hai meine unke kayi lecture sune jahan pe unhon ne ye point bola par exactly kehna kya chahte vo kabhi bhi asal mein detail mein samajh nahi paaya agar aap donon iss topic pe discuss karenge toh clarity aajayegi

[@avsingh4995]

Thankyou very much indeed ❤

[@SrikanthIyerTheMariner]

Fantastic talk

[@monkeymindat]

❤ 🙏🏼 Dr. Sir

[@aimlesssurfer8607]

Damn, I was just thinking about this topic by Dr. CK Raju a few mins ago....and here it is 😮

[@sanj1552]

Comon guys, give this podcast more views and likes. So informative

[@MrJamesthomas07]

We are very well to known on debates and arguments in social medias..on science ..when it comes to scientific theories and proposals we struggles to stand firm on scientific methodology and slowly falls to religious mythologies..that’s why we don’t get recognitions from scientific community even in our country ..

[@ruzzireyan5982]

Jai Shri Krishna Jai bharat vande maataram namaste 🙏

[@rajeshshukla15]

अभिजित जी इस प्रकार अदभुत संवाद को हिंदी भाषा में भी करने की कृपा करें

[@ऋषभx]

It's a shame that this Christian calendar is still imposed upon us after 75 years of so-called independence.

[@Divine_wave23]

Congress did it😊

[@jagatsimulation]

​@@Divine_wave23 love khangress 😊 ❤

[@chandrashekharkalyanaraman5224]

Well, it has become an international calendar, just like the unscientific English has become an international language. Not easy to do undo such blunders.

[@Cartoon_World_Dhamaka]

It can be changed but you know there will be a lot of fight etc

[@shubhpatel2350]

​@@chandrashekharkalyanaraman5224 unscientific and script less English 😂

[@ashcharya27]

I am surprised that World and mainly Bharat is using the unscientific calendar. When we have our own calendar, which is scientific, having 5 parameters to define a day uniquely (and that means anyone can know the exact date of events even thousands or lakhs of years later also, even if the knowledge of Gregorian dateis lost.)

[@raghuramakrishnabezawada6120]

Sir. . publish original indian calender who all know it's benifits will follow it . Mainly Agriculture is Monsoon dependent . Maintence of Dams, canals.......

[@jzzquant]

The idea of recursion is a completely Indian idea going all the way back to recursively enumerable arithmetic's. Irony is that today we can't Recursively pinpoint our new year on the calendar

[@neeladrisekharneogi5837]

Vikram Samvat should be our national calendar.

[@ArtVandelay-av-av]

it is already our national calendar

[@neeladrisekharneogi5837]

@@ArtVandelay-av-av Shaka calendar is our national calendar. Check your facts.

[@ArtVandelay-av-av]

@@neeladrisekharneogi5837 ok

[@crypton_8l87]

Traditionally our family followed the Chandramana calendar

[@SouthindianNarendra]

99 % i don't know anything, love his knowledge

[@baikunthadeka1327]

Yes we must Learn and upgrade but Adaption should not affect . INDIAN culture

[@mrluckygilli]

Thank you Abhijit ji for bringing C.k.Raju sir whom I adore. No! No! I revere him.

[@RohitJadhav-po5vj]

Mind blowing

[@shiftenter10]

Our Calendar is christian and mentality is Islamic

[@crypton_8l87]

Our woke mentality is exactly like Slave - to both Islam and Xtianity.

[@ajaysanampudi]

Missing the coherence sir, CK sir going from one topic to another without addressing the matter he stared .. interlocutor has to come here... CK sir needs atleast 4hr to complete this ...and 2 gallons of water .

[@svariar]

another point to note...........the church used latin or roman numerals up to the 17th-18th century in dating and note that when they converted to hindu numerals they did a sleight of hand deception which basically added 1000 years to their calendar........in their roman dating inscriptions or paintings etc...they would inscribe the year by having prefixed the millenium century then the particular year of the century for e.g. 1st millenium 5th century year 56..........when they rewrote it in modern numbers it became 1556 when in reality it was the year 456.....why is this the case..........because roman numbers HAVE NO ZERO and 1st millenium means year 1-1000 and 5th century is year 400-500.........when they changed it to modern numbers they added 1 millenium and 5 centuries to the current year and fooled everyone.....so in reality we are only in the year 924 AD not 2024.......but if course another thing is because the so called churches themselves had no clue when jesus was crucified they actually added centuries to their calendar in retrospect rather than actually starting the so called calendar 924 years ago which means this calendar only began some 600-700 years ago around the time of the dark ages in europe and not 2000 years ago as claimed

[@CyrusTheGreat-b3k]

Why Rahu and Kethu are called snakes? When eclipse happens a shadow will start from moon and falls on earth, this shadow is visualized as snake just like constellations are visualized as Leo and Orion…

[@चंद्रकांतकुमार-ण2थ]

Because one shadow is short is head of the snake and long pointy shadow is tail of the snake.

[@shumbuk4383]

42:48 "But that predates the Aryan invasion?" "Ahh there's no Aryan invasion!" That was too heart warming.

[@y_k3096]

Is Dr. Raju's "5-day course on calculus", an online course?

[@codedusting]

Mathematically, isn't all the ills of the Gregorian calendar already solved since we are using GPS system to track the timezone and times? And computers work on epoc times? When the topic is of mathematics and science, why are we talking about history? Also, the dates are no longer dated in AD or BC. It's BCE or CE. Anyways, how does any of that matter when it comes to the topic of maths and science?

[@therewere2032]

Dates are talked about in AD and BC. Even BC and BCE is a stunt by apologetics, which is an essential practice of the two Abrahamic cults. And just like you are discouraging discussion of history, since it connects to one of the Abrahamic cult, this is exactly the purpose of apologetics. Apologetics and polemics are the most essential part of these two cults.

[@therewere2032]

Harvard University even today uses the year of the lord in academic diploma papers to denote the year of graduation. So please do not try to be an Abrahamic apologetic, if are really not one.

[@codedusting]

@@therewere2032 Ok. Let's come back to the topic. How does that change anything in Mathematics or Issue with Indian Weather pattern which is now done by Super Computers accurately, like predicting storms a week before it will happen to rescue people and so on? What is the significance of historical nonsense at this point in the domain of Mathematics? In the domain of decolonisation, sure, go ahead; do whatever you think is right for the culture.

[@therewere2032]

@@codedusting i think you need to clearly read the topic set by the channel. instead of being the apologist of the abrahamic cults, which have clear roles of apologetic and polemics to deviate the discussion from their cultish dogmas and actions. abrahamic cults need such faculties to impose, sugarcoat and whitewash their beliefs on the infidels, and when caught red handed, deviate the discussion as effectively as possible. again to reiterate, the topic set for the discussion by the channel is about comparison of christian calender with bharatiya calender and how it holding us back. well i am sure a reasonable and rational person will agree that the historical context and differences between them will be discussed.

[@codedusting]

@@therewere2032 How is it holding us back in the age of Super computers which are responsible for weather predictions and are not running on Gregorian anything anymore in my knowledge. Let me know.

[@IndrajithNaidu]

Whydont you bring over nilesh oak

[@harshithkumar2644]

Kaliyuga everything goes bad golden age of bharat existed before Kaliyuga once only never again

[@CR_with_VG]

How do we get our calender

[@shaolinzen726]

Shame that so called hindurastra india do not follow bikramsambat , we nepaese have been following since ages. Modiji need to fix this

[@agniswar3]

In Bengal we follow the Bengali calendar which is based on the Hindu calendar. As of now it is the year 1431 of the Bengali era also known as Bangavd.

[@riasarangi6876]

❤❤❤❤

[@Deepakrai767622]

Jai ho 😢😢

[@umaneelakantan9327]

Vedic Mathematics and Mathematical Operations via Vedic System more accurate and efficient, error free.. . Learnt in Gurujuls for the very practical purpose of calculations for Agricultural and Administrative Planning...in the Indian Itihaasa. .from millenia...

[@Ldhd69]

What’s with a disclaimer?

[@geetg61]

@AvhijitChavada sir thanks ...ill call it a scientific calendar

[@baikunthadeka1327]

We need Indian Calendar not Georgian . India already have their Rich Culture and History . We don't need to Borrow anything

[@Qwerkywoop]

Yes, so try to stop using the Gregorian calendar

[@jonah4185]

Do it 😂

[@gajahendrikswamidat]

India use your own calendar

[@priscillacramer474]

Frieda Ports

[@KateStombaugh-y3t]

Vanessa Forges

[@HarrimanVictor-f7y]

Tremblay Mission

[@sunitait8671]

From Hindu pov sesh nag is the representation of kal(time), therefore earth rotating on top of seshnag's 1000 heads, is simply telling earth's rotations decide time or something related to spiritual like time is infinite etc P.s. Aryan invasion 😂😂😂

[@Buddi9288]

😢😮😂 1:51 1:51 1:51 1:54

[@Buddi9288]

😢😅😮😮😮😢😅😮😅😮😅😮😅😮😅😮😅😊😮😊😊😊❤😂🎉😂🎉🎉🎉😮😊😮😅😅😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😢😢😢😢🎉😢😢😮😮😢😮❤❤😢😢😢😢😢😅😢😮😊😮😊😅😊😂😮😊😊❤😂😂😢😂😢😢😮😮😮😅😢😢😅😢😢😮😊😊🎉🎉😮😅😅😅😮😢😅😊😊❤😮😢😊😅😂😅😂😂😮😊😊😊😂😊❤❤❤❤❤❤😊😊😊😊❤❤❤❤❤❤😊😊😅😊🎉😢😂😂😂❤😮❤❤😅😮❤🎉🎉🎉🎉😅😅😅😮😅😂🎉😢😢😂🎉😅😢😮😮😮😮😮😮😂🎉

[@Chakrawat-Pakshii]

दुसारा मुद्दा असा आहे, की पाश्चात्य कालगणने मध्ये कधी काळी दहाच महीने असंत! भारतीय विसंगतीमुळे दहाचे बारा झाले. जुल आणि अगस्ती नंतर जोडलेत, प्रत्येकी ३१ दिवसांचे! हे कधी झालं आणि कुणी केले? बरं, कालांतरांची नावे बघा. सप्तांबर, अष्टांबर, नवांबर आणि दशांबर? काय दर्षवितात ही नावें? हिंदू संदर्भ तंतूच ना? मग कां नाहीत एकादशांबर तथा द्वादशांबर? सोपं तरी वाटेल, आता जसा अर्थार्थी संबध नाही वाटत तसं!

[@UtkarshSrivastav-d4v]

Sir with due respect i think he might be wrong coz, I talked to an astrophysicist, and he said Gregorian calendar (christian) and Mayan calender or Indian calender were based on both solar or lunar cycles. Which gave an approximate number 365.2425. But, the leap year system was an addition to 365.2425 time after four years to account for this approximation which was left unaccounted in both mayan and indian calenders. Lunar cycles were part of Original calender but in modern Gregorian Calender this approximation was scrutinized already. So till date it's the most accurate one. Isn't of using original calender we Indians should focus on giving either new or better calnder than the Gregorian calendar!

[@madsnail-nf7bv]

Listen to his talk carefully, what he's talking about... Use your own faculty, try it yourself whether what he says makes sense or not...

[@UtkarshSrivastav-d4v]

@@madsnail-nf7bv no it doesn't. If it did actually i wouldn't have said that

[@madsnail-nf7bv]

@@UtkarshSrivastav-d4v you're talking about correction, that's why we use adhik mas for correction!

[@UtkarshSrivastav-d4v]

@@madsnail-nf7bv koi meaning ni h na bhai. Fir uske sath sath sab additional ajaega usme. Vo chahie ni And secondly most importantly, While Adhik Maas helps to adjust the Hindu calendar to the solar year, it cannot perfectly align it. The lunar month is a fixed duration of approximately 29.5 days, and adding an extra month every two or three years cannot completely compensate for the difference in length between a solar year and a lunar year.

[@UtkarshSrivastav-d4v]

@@madsnail-nf7bv i understand ki Gregorian sunke Christianity or British authoritarian vali feeling arhi hogi pr bhai ek common unit honi chahie sab field's m. Hum ye kr sakte hai ki iska nam change kr sakte hain or Gregorian ko as a history hum yad kr sakte hain. Like pehle AD or BC bola jata tha which means before christ and Anno Domino which meant before christ. But now it's BCE, which means before common era and CE means common era!

[@ArunRawatLimitedEdition]

🙏

[@kudaisiaduntola2523]

Western calendar perhaps. There's nothing Christian about the Gregorian calendar.

[@LeonardPound-o9x]

Hills Plains

[@ConradBernice-y9n]

Bella Plaza

[@AnandAnand-h9m]

What is the name of the Indian calendar ?

[@TSammy03-i6v]

Saka!

[@MOHIT836]

Vikram, saka

[@JeffersonStrachey-r7y]

Doug Square

[@AnonyMous-ds2wt]

Atoeast explain calculation...

[@vaishnavichaphekar8779]

Hindi

[@AnonyMous-ds2wt]

Too much beating around the bush... didn't understand anything...

[@AnonyMous-ds2wt]

U confused more... not good example to promote our calenders... lidya concured... tithi, angle... what?? Do detailed video...

[@AnonyMous-ds2wt]

U make it look like scientific but not usefull...

[@MollieCrisman-r7x]

Stroman Unions

[@ashwanidubey8076]

Stop saying "okay hmm hmm I see" every couple of minutes man..!!

[@divyanshsh]

Bruh

[@Deepakrai767622]

This channel is slowly died plz share

[@AnonyMous-ds2wt]

This is more of geography than anything to do with calender... pls redo. Kindly edit put water drinking... sorry but not value for my time today.

[@sudipkumarroy3790]

I dont know but I have heard that tribals in ocenea have nakshatra or titbi or something like that. It may be due to Indian influence. But colonialists say that its owing to the fact that pre aryan austrenesians migrated from India to there but the concepts are not Aryan that is vedic.

[@sudipkumarroy3790]

C K Raju sir's comments on Vedanga Jyotisha and saying jyotish not meaning astrology is laughable. Jyotish has meant both astronomy and astrology in India no two thoughts about it. As to astrological content not being present in the next well he need not agonise over it and just look to the allied text Atharva Veda Parishishtha which is the earliest dated document on Indian astrology. The astrology there is of course not natal but electional and electing auspicious astrological time for conducting rituals is essential part of Vedic Religion.

[@sudipkumarroy3790]

"Not a single word on astrology in jyotisha texts" Sir is really on weeds or what?? 🤣 Indian Tradition considers Jyotisha to have three skandhas Siddhanta Samhita and Hora. Astrology is dealt in last two skandhas while pure astronomy is in the first. Therefore it is natural that texts like Panchasiddhantika or Yuktibhasha wont have an iota of astrology bcoz its not their purpose.

[@चंद्रकांतकुमार-ण2थ]

You should listen carefully what he is saying. The jyotish books he recommended doesn't have Astrology.

[@raghu_nandan18]

❤❤

[@kudaisiaduntola2523]

Western calendar perhaps. There's nothing Christian about the Gregorian calendar.