Revisiting the Doctor that Diagnosed Arthur with TB (Hidden Dialogue) Red Dead Redemption 2

[@vxmaper7257]

Hey i know the guy who told you to do it

[@IndoJordy]

Yeah, it was you and thank you for that ❤️ 👍

[@Chr0m3dD347H]

@@IndoJordy cheesecake

[@vxmaper7257]

anything for my favorite rdr2 youtuber

[@MariaMartinez-ee4sq]

@@IndoJordy i love the fact that you support rdr2 rdo

[@UnclBerry]

:')

[@shane4429]

Honestly though indo, rdr2 is the most detailed game ever, sometimes when arthur starts randomly coughing people will walk away and when arthur has his attacks they’ll run

[@IndoJordy]

Yeah, it’s really realistic

[@MR.ICE.]

I’d say the game with the most detail ever is the first dead rising. Although that’s with minor details easily missed. Rdr2 has huge details that can be missed too, but it is one of the most realistic games I’ve ever played.

[@fredster594]

@@MR.ICE. Man I miss Dead Rising 1. It's sad that the series just got worse and worse with every sequel.

[@MR.ICE.]

Fredster It’s my favourite game of all time. I still play to this day on the PS4. And I know exactly what you mean. Dead rising 2 was alright, but didn’t have that same feel to it. 3 was a huge leap, it was fun but not like dead rising 1. Dead rising 4 should never have existed lol

[@sulkii9437]

Very detailed untill epilogue

[@ZSmith-yy4lv]

Arthur: “I need money for that” Also Arthur: has the equivalent to 62,000$ in his pocket.

[@IndoJordy]

🔥

[@counter.123]

wild guess but i think he’s really referring to dutch and his “plan”. he could probably head west himself but he doesn’t want to abandon the gang, or at least, he wants to wait until dutch and friends has their ticket to tahiti

[@suntzu6468]

B Girls also wants to make sure John, Abigail, and Jack get out safe.

[@bluntlyhonest6803]

@@counter.123 I think he wanted John and His Family to get out safe first. But i get you're point.

[@JohnMarstonPlayz1911]

Wolflord 7756 lmao

[@flip7490]

He's the only clerk I don't rob, it feels like he's one of Arthur's last friends before he dies.

[@IndoJordy]

Me neither

[@legopachycephalosaurus6825]

Doctors and people in the medical profession are honestly saints (Some of them at least).

[@gamester512]

@@legopachycephalosaurus6825 Plus, since doctors take the Hippocratic oath to even become doctors in the first place, they have an obligation to help people who need them even if they can't pay for it.

[@Obamavrat671names]

I never robbed no one but clerks, who have secrets

[@gutforhire2265]

@ well i feel the same but for the docs only and if you wait by the people who are gold mining they will get a nugget and then i pew pew em then take there gold nuggy

[@aether3023]

Arthur's expression when he found out he had tuberculosis is heart breaking..

[@IndoJordy]

Indeed

[@eddydiaz2609]

It was the equivalent of being diagnosed with lung cancer, except even worse because there was really *no* treatment for either disease in 1899. I guess, at least, unlike lung cancer, you had a *slim* chance of surviving TB even in 1899, but even then that chance only came if the ideal conditions were met. Perhaps if Arthur had decided to stay and rest in Scarlett Meadows.

[@aether3023]

@@eddydiaz2609 true, if arthur could've went back to black water or near armadillo he could've lived a bit longer

[@yourlocaljoyandhappiness8461]

I legit almost cried when i saw his expression

[@colescheig5495]

@@eddydiaz2609 Scarlett meadows was very wet he woulda been more likely to live if he had gone to armadillo other tumbleweed

[@gamerlordthebest]

Fun fact: if you bring the guy who has to get his arm amputated during chapter 6, the doctor will also have some unique dialogue

[@IndoJordy]

Thanks for the tip bro

[@vxmaper7257]

Lourenço Dias it’s a random event in any chapter near the swamps

[@projectmilk3267]

Lourenço Dias yes dumbo. Lol jk :D

[@terriblebadedits3814]

He also gets hanged for some reason

[@terriblebadedits3814]

@@mrghost579 i just said I don't know

[@kronical5099]

Being a doctor must be a really hard job. You want to help people, but sometimes you just can’t. Must be heartbreaking sometimes.

[@IndoJordy]

Indeed, sounds heartbreaking

[@SavageBunnyGetMoney]

Especially with Covid19 going around I don't know how they do it

[@lokilockness2970]

My dads a doctor it’s hard when he can’t help people it’s hard to see

[@batowner1]

In 1899 they gave patients cocaine lmao

[@herr_dohler]

My girlfriend is a doctor. She always says: "I can't save everyone, unfortunately. Sometimes, the disease wins. But I can save someone among all people who come to my hospital. And saving someone is worth every single bad day I had".

[@Milty2001]

Interesting that if you don't have enough money the guy that helps arthur to the doctor will give you some money to the doctor

[@IndoJordy]

Never saw that, I will check it out one day, thanks

[@Milty2001]

@@IndoJordy no problem

[@camdenolson9031]

I see you everywhere

[@dorkle9085]

Yeah I saw that! This game is so detailed!

[@fernandom.varela1109]

The guy is similar to nigel

[@PelozoF]

2:35 This dialogue changes according to honor. With high honor Arthur says something like “I got people who need me here”

[@IndoJordy]

Thanks for the heads up

[@JustinCage56]

Might be a long shot but that could be one reason why Low Honor Arthur kept taking with John and Sadie about wanting to steal Dutch's money.

[@kimmeeb]

@@JustinCage56 You're right; High Honor Arthur talks more about how he wants to keep John safe and out of the life. He asks Sadie to help get John and his family out during Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow, and repeatedly emphasizes how he's just about done with everything but that

[@lightwhited47]

Actually nothing changes in the dialogue, the only thing that changes is when you are walking away.

[@lenny9672]

I remember I tried to smoke too much cigars near John and he said “stop doing those stuff probably why you sick”

[@meowmeow3778]

I like how Arthur just said that he has people chasing him when the doctor said if he has anyone that can take care of him, and the doctor didn't bother and just asked how he may help to ease the suffering.

[@IndoJordy]

True, sounds like a good guy

[@nev12345678910]

In the medical profession you quickly learn not to judge

[@meowmeow3778]

HOLY SHIT. That's a lot of likes! still got some higher ones though.

[@somecityorc]

Arthur: Got a lot of people coming after me Doc: Oh no! Anyway...

[@vaibhavagrawal3083]

@@IndoJordy not true, most doctors are greedy liars

[@f.7407]

Arthur: *Has tb* Also arthur: *smokes a cigarette in front of the doctor*

[@IndoJordy]

I liked to do that

[@Elmir1998]

When you know it‘s over anyways, why not lol

[@FormulaVase-kp3dc]

They didn't consider it Lung Cancer in those days. Actually they thought it was healthy for your lungs. That was 120 years ago though, and things have changed.

[@deadchanneldontwatch7347]

he coughs whenever he smokes

[@evolyn403]

You can tell by the way the doctor literally starts smoking a tobacco pipe right in his office in front of a patient lol

[@Alexei1771n]

It's heartwarming watching how the doctor was worried about Arthur :(

[@IndoJordy]

Yeah I loved that 2

[@therealheem6035]

Dude asked for his money before he even treated him

[@eddydiaz2609]

@@therealheem6035 IKR! How dare a businessman who runs his own store make money?

[@judochopmaster8233]

@@therealheem6035 he literally said that he had a family to feed. The St. Denis doctor is one of the most honourable men in the game in my opinion

[@mattcornford1]

Yeah totally. Compliments to the voice actor, you could just sense he cared and was sad for Arthur

[@cloudyiii9422]

Watching Arthur get sick and eventually die is probably the most heartbreaking thing I’ve ever experienced in a video game

[@pjyeates1250]

In life........

[@nathanielmadsen6494]

Literally waiting for him to die really put me down I didn't want to play it and watch him die

[@moss93]

For me it was Sarah in the last of us

[@bunnyfufu7470]

dude this is why I'm hesitant to have a second playthrough, i might get depressed again :((

[@TMeek94]

I thought it ruined the game The first rdr was way more heartbreaking

[@spookybeagle6943]

Imagine how to story would play out if Arthur never beat up Tomas/got Tb He would have killed mica easily in a fist fight and then go after Dutch perhaps

[@IndoJordy]

Indeed bro, it would be way different

[@georgereeves8137]

I’ve seen someone mod Chapter 2 Arthur into the cliff top fight instead of Chapter 6 Arthur, Micah got the living fuck knocked out of him

[@sophcass2974]

Probably would've married Mary Linton too

[@lovefreijsandberg6373]

Tbh even tho its tragic i like this end more.

[@tommytaylor2084]

Personally I'm happy with the way it ended. Arthur gets laid to rest. Charles and Sadie go do their own thing. John gets to settle down with his family and Micah gets turned into Swiss Cheese

[@petrikor]

Doctor: How are you feeling? Arthur: 🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬

[@Quxrk]

Same

[@Pibola64]

Doc: How are you feeling? Arthur: *turns into a chimney*

[@thotspecialforces1341]

🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬🚬

[@MIHIRSK-lm6qf]

He doesn’t say anything cause it was only until the 50s/60s when people started associating smoking with lung diseases. Before that folk had no clue that cigarettes would this harmful to you.

[@CJan65]

@@MIHIRSK-lm6qf you don't get TB from smoking.

[@mortipvp]

"I need money for that" Has almost 2000 dollars

[@IndoJordy]

😂

[@smeshnoy8538]

In my walkthrough he had 5000 dollars, and you can get more, like more than 10000 or maybe 15000 dollars

[@CR7GOATofFootball]

LLightNiNGMoNSTeR GaMiNG I got 20k

[@RTALICE9]

Love Quarantine lmao i had 350k dollar prior to this mission dawg

[@CR7GOATofFootball]

dari I find that hard to believe. This isn’t even a mission

[@TheTroystreet]

When finding out Arthur has TB it’s heartbreaking it’s like learning your uncle or brother has a terminal illness and the only way to prolong his life is not finishing the game. That’s why in my second play through I’m 30 hours in and I’m still in Valentine, Micah is still in Jail, and Arthur doesn’t have TB.

[@thouxanbandaizen]

my arthur got tb cuz there wasnt any missons left :(

[@miraduhvetvem2712]

Same rn I’m exploring the whole map and gonna reveal some stranger missions n stuff I missed first time playing

[@FrantzVissarionovitch]

@@miraduhvetvem2712 Do that and do in different % of the game. Theres things i see till this day for the first time

[@jacobtaylor8723]

I have two loads saved one as John and one as Arthur in valentine fully stacked up on everything

[@silent.reaper.4429]

Right wish there was a chance u can ride out towards armadillo or the ranch out in the corner of the desert....sad he had to die

[@friccle_]

Theres dialogue for all merchants and such Mostly goes like “You good friend?” *cough cough* “Yeeaap”

[@IndoJordy]

Thanks for the heads up

[@mileschow5961]

Coughs up a piece of his lung: Yeah I’m alright feller

[@budge3035]

“I’m alright boahhhh”

[@PrinceGummy]

Yeah, and sometimes Arthur said "You mind your business and I mind mine" Shopkeeper: "okay, friend"

[@sherolanglin363]

i really like the dialogue that all the stable owners have. it’s funny how they say they can’t do much to help him but if his horse has any issues they’d be able to help 😂

[@azazel166]

Nearly every shopkeeper and post office clerk comment on Arthur's condition.

[@IndoJordy]

Indeed

[@elrisitas3052]

Even the stable

[@thecowboy9698]

Even the dance hall girls.

[@Obamavrat671names]

@25-Pixel-Man some seller said „You look like death“

[@Dacia52]

@@Obamavrat671names bruh

[@jaysanj152]

Man If only there was a "Get a Shot" option where the doctor helps you by temporarily boost your stats cus it really hurts to hear whenever the doctor offers the option but the game doesn't/refuses to let you take it.

[@sausage6136]

Yeah thought the same.l

[@generalgta3528]

@@sausage6136 Hey, nice profile picture! Please reply to me, buddy!

[@Pibola64]

I bet it would cost to do it, but not much, like maybe 2-5$

[@giovannicervantes2053]

Yeah because tb causes you to stop metabolizing food and you can only restore cores by sleep and bath so this would act like a seasoned big game meat or high quality camp stew and keep him going but it would have worse effects like instead of 3 days it would only work for like a day

[@WarriorDan2008]

Well maybe if he took too many shots then he would probably get cured and ruin the game's writing

[@_giovannisanchez6032]

Lumbago hits worse

[@IndoJordy]

😮

[@JIMMYSCHOPSHOP123]

But I've got lumbago get up old man poor uncle

[@HappySmilingDog-d7u]

Fr

[@jayden8487]

It’s slow and painful death my brother

[@holyKoreanJesus]

Its a slow and painful 'slight lower back pain' death

[@johngarry3723]

This scene where the doc says "I'm sorry son, it's a hell of a thing..." It got to me so deep first time I played it, because my doctor told me pretty much the same for my own condition barely a few months before

[@JustLookinkAround]

Damn... I'm still hoping the best for you. Take care, friend

[@johngarry3723]

@@JustLookinkAround Thanks Borrelia is a hell of a thing, stay clear of those damn ticks

[@icanhasyellow]

:(

[@trevorphilips9065]

@@johngarry3723 Hope you're doing better now

[@johngarry3723]

@@trevorphilips9065 I'm holding on and fight, thank you for caring and your words...

[@justsomeguyontheinternet5917]

He REALLY wanted to give Arthur that shot. That amuses me

[@IndoJordy]

Yeah 😂

[@justsomeguyontheinternet5917]

Indo-J 😂

[@brytoncox]

It’s probably all heroine too lmao

[@justsomeguyontheinternet5917]

@@brytoncox lmao, yeah

[@surprisedguy7375]

🤔...

[@eighthdoctor]

4:38 - "You're always here alone...do you have anyone to look after you?" 😭

[@IndoJordy]

😞

[@kubenblisk6311]

SHOW SOME FAITH ARTHUR

[@yourlocaljoyandhappiness8461]

When i heard that the first time i was playing i just wanted to give Arthur a hug and say it'll be ok ;-;

[@Tom-it9nu]

@@yourlocaljoyandhappiness8461 that's gay

[@yourlocaljoyandhappiness8461]

@@Tom-it9nu lmao

[@adriansaavedra7923]

“You’ve got tuberculosis” *immediately starts to smoke pipe*

[@IndoJordy]

😂

[@deadchanneldontwatch7347]

they didnt know back then

[@exelero9282]

He smoked because people back then thought that smoking kills bacteria.

[@IamtheDesperado]

Like rubbing salt in the wound. "You have tuberculosis? Haha nerd" *smokes pipe*

[@quadnod4605]

Welcome to 1899.

[@TheSchmandarinOrange]

Arthur: *has tuberculosis* Also Arthur: *smokes cigarettes in front of the doctor that diagnosed him*

[@IndoJordy]

😂

[@gangrenousgandalf2102]

@@bobsemple7660 Yeah, the advertising for cigarettes back in the day had fake doctors describing the various, "benefits" of smoking. Everyone thought that smoking was fine anywhere.

[@Baba-li6hc]

@@gangrenousgandalf2102 Yea it was advertised to remove "irritation" to throats. So it made sense that everyone was smokin.

[@Obamavrat671names]

He just took his revenge for doctor smoking the pipe after diagnosing Arthur's tuberculosis

[@yourlocaljoyandhappiness8461]

@@Obamavrat671names true lmao

[@yinniferdurmyd]

Words cannot explain how bad I felt for Arthur (and still do) when he gets diagnosed with TB. He just looks so hopeless.

[@IndoJordy]

I had the same

[@fabiomoscadelli7564]

@@IndoJordy i wonder how he found out what tb was ?

[@Kissalege]

@@fabiomoscadelli7564 what do you mean?

[@FetaCheezyAlfredo]

@@fabiomoscadelli7564 Everyone kinda knew at the time

[@phillipschouw2462]

I took Care of Arthur. Gave him warm baths and a Nice bed to sleep in. Wether it was in a town or in a warm House. I made sure he was well fed due to him becoming underweight from TB. I always Got him out of the rain where ever we went. The doctor told me he looked a bit better. It isn’t neceserally the TB that kills Arthur but the outcome of the story.

[@Tom-H1]

It would be cool if you could survive the TB by really taking it easy, and not doing missions for long stints and so Arthur gets to live, but I get why it's necessary he dies of something. The TB helps him realize time is precious, and he tries to redeem himself just a little bit before he dies, thus the name 'Red Dead Redemption'

[@bluecricket6157]

@@Tom-H1 it really break the realism tho. Tb was a death sentence

[@rafaeltemplario]

​@@bluecricket6157 It is STILL very serious. Like you need 6-8 months of antibiotics and staying on a hospital bed in quarantine for the entire time.

[@GamingWithJazz]

Wow. Damn near a year of treatment. ​@@rafaeltemplario

[@stewpid4410]

​@@GamingWithJazzNot to mention contagious too. Quite a threat

[@yinniferdurmyd]

Crazy how there's still some things you don't know about the game even after 2 years of its release. Thank you for the video!

[@IndoJordy]

Your welcome buddy, there is indeed a lot to discover

[@Attmozzy]

Mhm!

[@achmadtitofauzan3809]

This and the witcher 3 have lots of hidden things

[@nightspicer]

Two years?!?

[@yinniferdurmyd]

nightspicer Yes, unbelievable, right 😭

[@professionalgamer6522]

Arthur had TB and he refused to go and take it easy because of his loyalyty to the gang. Micah on the other hand says he does not care... Nice one Dutch

[@IndoJordy]

He was very loyal , that’s what I love about Arthur

[@Delxy-2k]

Stop disrespecting me

[@NoOne-ju8fi]

Micah Bell billy midnights final kill was putting a full clip in your head

[@hoseamatthews5767]

@@Delxy-2k you're a dirty rat micah, you know that very well

[@Delxy-2k]

Hosea Matthews well well well old man it appears to me that you are dead so I wouldn’t be talking even black lung survived longer then you so shut your trap or I’ll shut it permanently

[@kennysylvesterbaldettibarr8784]

Crazy how the streetkid that gives a tour to arthur when he first enters town, says, "and in this street theres a doctor, hope ya never require his services" or something like that.. giving us a clue of what would happen

[@friesfourreur6518]

in french the streetkid says he's a good doctor but nobody goes to his office

[@randomlyentertaining8287]

I do like how the doctor seems legitimately concerned for Arthur's health. EDIT: Also love how the doctor is concerned enough to wash his hands but not throw away the depressor he used on Arthur's tongue XD

[@The_Real_Soldier_Boy]

1. Hes a doctor. 2. Mans got fucking tb

[@randomlyentertaining8287]

@40,000 bees Just being a doctor doesn't mean you actually care for your patients or people in general. Some people become doctors just for the money. Then others use their knowledge for evil. Josef Mengele actually did attend school and had a doctorate in medicine, making him a Doctor. We know how he turned out.

[@rijkaard1579]

@@randomlyentertaining8287 Here we go with jewish lies

[@receecup9082]

Better then any mr boss video that’s for sure

[@IndoJordy]

Thanks buddy

[@receecup9082]

Indo-J np

[@SudeennnSam]

If this were MrFagFTW’s video, it will be a 10-minute video of him kissing his own ass for 8 minutes THEN RDR2 content for 2 minutes lol

[@thag7749]

FR tho mr boss trash

[@opium_00piumchaos]

@@SudeennnSam lol

[@JoshIdstein]

The thing that makes Red Dead Redemption stand out from the rest of the Rockstar games, is that it's world isn't really a satire, but instead takes history and the people within it seriously. That makes the world so much more genuine and interesting and moments like this really show how much respect Rockstar had for their characters in this game. I'll take RDR2 over GTAV any day.

[@szrsplaythroughs]

Probably the reason i find it far superior to gta. Gta was just a bit much you know. I was amazed the first time i played this cause i didnt realize rockstar was capable of serious story telling. But they dont throw away the satire completely. They keep just enough robots and time travelers and UFOs to make the world funny and mysterious XD

[@spring063_4]

@@szrsplaythroughs there was also satire in rdr, just more subtle

[@iceysuhn5503]

1:12 even with bad news, Arthur still had his sense of humor

[@WarmRepeat]

Doctor: Want another shots? Arthur: Yes please **BANG BANG BANG!**

[@IndoJordy]

😂

[@blueviper64]

Dutch: “Arthur, we gotta stay low and hidden as the Pinkertons are on our ass. Keep a low profile.” Arthur: “Ok Dutch” Also Arthur: 3:42

[@MariusBoss11458]

He trusts him. Tells him if it's a good place or not.

[@Артём-х8ф]

It’s been said numerous times before, but this game is insanely deep.

[@IndoJordy]

Indeed it is very deep

[@keknov5555]

Yeah it’s not like some stupid ass woke garbage like tlou2 it digs deep into its story and its characters and makes you understand and feel them.

[@McCbobbish]

After the diagnosis, I started making sure to have Arthur rest every chance he got. Always took a nice bath when I got into town, set up camp and waited out rainstorms, tried to make sure he got a good night's sleep, ect. Poor poor man

[@tommyboy1039]

Arthur: “yeah well I need money for that” *Also Arthur with almost $20,000 in his wallet*

[@IndoJordy]

😂

[@thelastassassin1190]

2,000*

[@badatvideogames5832]

@@agentmoron747 No need to be an asshole

[@aviatorfox4789]

The U.S. dollar experienced an average inflation rate of 2.89% per year during this period, causing the real value of a dollar to decrease. In other words, $2,000 in 1899 is equivalent in purchasing power to about $62,630.84 in 2020, a difference of $60,630.84 over 121 years. The 1899 inflation rate was 0.00%.

[@PopperMatronicNation]

@@agentmoron747 Fuck up

[@Kappaman0430]

WHY WHY DOES THIS GAME MAKE ME SO ATTACHED TO HIM AND THEN TAKE HIM AWAY

[@elementz301]

“Is there any blood?” His mouth is covered in blood lol

[@titaiao]

I think the doctor was referring to when Arthur coughs

[@cheesepuff5577]

Notice how after the Doctor says "You have tuberculosis, its a progressive disease.." he then says "You'll be.." but doesn't finish his sentance, I reckon he's saying "You'll be dead within a couple of months." But doesn't want to finish the sentance and quickly changes the subject afterwards.

[@IndoJordy]

Good eyes buddy

[@cheesepuff5577]

@ you could just be thinking hes rambling

[@aestusarido9109]

Wow nobody would've thought that

[@Obamavrat671names]

Yep, i noticed that while playing

[@yourlocaljoyandhappiness8461]

Omg that's the same thing i thought, this doctor is such a good guy ;-;

[@thedondaithi1304]

That music when Arthur has these realisations is enough to rip your own soul apart

[@dice5361]

Suuuuuu

[@alexanderstauber]

*Dying person goes to doctor* Doctor: You got money? *American anthem starts playing*

[@alexanderstauber]

@@BurritooMafia well that's also what robbers say but come on it's just a joke...

[@ajdrig]

@@alexanderstauberYou're a joke. >:)

[@alexanderstauber]

@@ajdrig can't be true, i am not american ;)

[@ajdrig]

@@alexanderstauber Well played... :(

[@RCXDerp]

@@alexanderstauber Blah blah blah *something about murica inventing the vast majority of recent drugs* XD

[@strat458796]

It’s odd to see the doctor wash his hand at 0:50. Hand washing by doctors was practiced in the 1870s but it was only by a handful of them; the majority didn’t believe that germs could be spread by the hands. It’s a small detail that this game is known for. Also he has running water which is another luxury.

[@yuhaye3986]

The fact Arthur could’ve gotta some medical attention by going to sanitarium but in stead waited for death shows you how bad his depression really was

[@Snaps08]

Mean the pinkertons were either gonna catch then faster up cause Arthur was legit just some steps away from his dead so he made it easier to sacrifice himself for John

[@simonnachreiner8380]

The Sanatarium would only prolong the inevitable. Active tuberculosis requires broad spectrum antibiotics to cure that simply did not exist at the time. The most a Sanitarium could to is intentionally cause a pneumothorax to force the bacteria clusters out for a time while dosing him with narcotics to ease his pain.

[@Snaps08]

@@simonnachreiner8380 so what you saying now in a short answer

[@gregmattes2119]

@@simonnachreiner8380 i just looked up what a pneumothorax is. Holy shit, does that sound ungodly painful.

[@morallygray6527]

@@Snaps08 Basically the medicine required to save Arthur's life did not exist at the time. The only thing they could have done was prolong his life slightly.

[@naif4129]

- You’re always here alone, do u have anyone to look after u this is a sad one😣💔

[@legendgamer676]

That line broke my heart. It just goes to show how (imo) Arthur was extremely undervalued by the rest of the gang. Especially towards the end. Granted everyone had their own problems but it seemed to me that the only people who truly acknowledged Arthur’s illness and tried to comfort him were Charles and Mary Beth. Maybe Swanson and Uncle aswell. Everyone else just seemed to ignore it even Sadie

[@naif4129]

@@legendgamer676 We should learn from arthur how to live strongly with Loneliness 😭

[@DunceTree93]

@@legendgamer676 I realize this is 4 months old, but i dont think sadie was necessarily avoiding it. I just think she acknowledged that arthur wasnt the type to look for or accept pitty for himself from others. That scene when abigail gets kidnapped and sadie and arthur ride to vanhorn, she alludes to him that she should be the one to do the upfront stuff cause she knows that arthur doesnt want to accept that hes limited now, but spares him his pride by saying, "youre a better shot". He knows shes known, but she still belives and values him. Their friendship, i think is beautifully complex and it kills me even more cause hes the only one in the gang she is truly close too, other than abigail. She even calls him hun.

[@a_j1menez]

You know, I met a man, his name was Arthur I think. He was a bit sarcastic but he kept coming back to the hospital and seeing him grew on me a bit, I didn’t think the tb would kill him since he kept coming back to the hospital. Although eventually he stopped coming back.... I hope he’s in a nice place now

[@IndoJordy]

😮

[@MagiconIce]

Does the doctor say that, when you visit him with John in the Epilogue?

[@narrator8534]

@@morenightops4565 just shut the fuck up

[@loyaltyornothing6839]

@@narrator8534 really no need to be an asshole you should instead shut the fuck up

[@bendover8652]

@@loyaltyornothing6839 No need to be an asshole to that asshole xd

[@james24668]

Am I the only person who started to wear Arthur’s winter jackets thinking I can help him get better in my first playthrough

[@ramiabiakar2391]

When you get TB you actually feel much colder, despite the occasional sweaty night.

[@BadMoody420]

The amount of people that actually believed that they can try to make Arthur feel better is actually heartbreaking, considering just how much he grew on us as a character. On my first play through I tried buying and crafting any kind of medicine I could find.

[@Xmunchiexx]

In my first playthrough, that scene hit me hard. It felt like a smaller scale of what being in that chair would actually feel like, but I felt it. Although my honor wasn't high at that stage I actually ended up helping a lot of people in the game, and maxed it. Although, I knew that Arthur wasn't going to survive because in those days it was almost impossible to survive tuberculosism

[@JohnDoe-um8td]

My Arthur never got to wear a simple shirt+vest after that, I had to keep him warm and well-fed. And then he started coughing when eating and that's just... my heart broke

[@Obamavrat671names]

@@BadMoody420 I've stopped smoking as Arthur when he got that last stage of disease

[@mikeycisar2665]

There is a random encounter north from Saint Denis. A wounded man wants you to take him to this doctor and if you take him there, doctor recognize you and is impressed that you had strenght to carry him there. I remember when I first did this event, I rushed to the doctor and helped him, because that random person in Saint Denis also helped Arthur to the doctor 😄

[@tomzplayz4867]

Mad respect man I tried doing this several times and I couldn’t get him to say a word about the diagnosis I knew there must be some hidden dialogue 👌

[@IndoJordy]

Indeed bro, thanks for the feedback

[@YungFrenchToasty]

I'm still wondering when the doctor said "I thought you'd be dead by now"

[@AtomicKevin42]

Man it's kind of hard to watch that scene. still gets me a little emotional. The moment the doctor said tuberculosis my heart dropped the same way Arthur's dropped I'd imagine.

[@MasterKcoop]

“I was hoping you’d be in a sanatorium out west by now” “You’ll need gold for that. Do you have some?”

[@ehmehsmeh824]

Doctor:You need rest. Arthur: *goes out and kills someone every 2 minutes, robs a shit ton of things, goes into many gunfights, does alot of missions *

[@crytpoex_ploiter4295]

1:18 Doctor is dope smoking beside a tb patient.

[@xmonkey3330]

Arthur: "I'd need money for that." The $1,900 in his pocket: "Am I a joke to you?"

[@randomstuff8149]

Doctor: You gotta stay somewhere warm and dry. Is that possible? Arthur: Sure I can just take my winters in my country club in California "cough" no it's not possible! New Austin: Am I a joke to you?

[@linchubbard3711]

he wanted in new austin

[@randomstuff8149]

There is no civilization in new Austin

[@YouTubeisgettingworse.]

Well you insta die when entering New Austin as Arthur

[@emmanuelov8998]

It’s actually: no *cough*, it’s not possible

[@TheoTungsten]

2:40 "I need money for that." The 1948 dollars (which is now WAY more due to inflation) he has: am I a joke to you?

[@Mihoyminoy124]

I like that the doctor actually seems to care about him

[@creatureconnor]

1:32 Anyone else notice the random human skull just casually sitting on the table?

[@danielvillegas8200]

I can imagine the doctor thinking "how is this guy not dying if he looked really sick" everytime he sees him walking inside

[@TheGreatFryMaster]

2:40 “ehhhh I need money for that” The near $2000 in his pocket: 😐

[@Poet482]

He doesn't know it yet, but getting the TB is the best thing to ever happen to Arthur. Gave him perspective in life.

[@ephemeralomen6116]

This part in the story really pulled my heart strings I really liked Arthur he was an amazing character and I could not believe he went out like that.

[@smoldragon339]

4:15 Perfect, spread that TB just aaaaaaall over that doctor's office. Be the original anti-masker!

[@Rikabe-bt3jc]

0:52 “You got... L U M B A G O”

[@SammEater]

Then he would have lived to his late 70's and end up getting shot by the feds. hahaha

[@MechWarrior894]

Very serious!

[@joshvogt6687]

I always find it funny that the doc lights up a pipe 2 feet from his patient after diagnosing him with a degenerative lung disease

[@bfpierce]

When Arthur opens his mouth to say ahhh, I imagine his breath would be horrific. Rotten teeth, infected gums.

[@Ben-x8x8v]

No doctor would ever say “huh I thought you’d be dead by now” to someone with cancer

[@V4vendettA_A]

This is heartbreaking to watch. it really is. TB is serious. but to see everything Arthur did even being sick was monumental for a game character. I guess he will live on in everyone who was touched by this game. vaya con Dios Black lung.

[@X-SPONGED]

3:28 The Doctor : "so how are you doing ?" Arthur : *smoke weed everyday*

[@PadamiPlays]

Tobacco was believed to cure Tuberculosis then. Only... Instead of tuberculosis, you'd have lung cancer.

[@CCJJ160Channels]

“I thought you’d be dead by now.” ‘This Indian gave me some herbs . . . ‘

[@doggdemuro]

Doctor: "Do you need anything? Some cocaine perhaps?"

[@n4mel3ssw0lf8]

Nah I have 99 of that

[@Spellcaster01]

Arthurs death was so avoidable you even see the guy that gave him tuberculoses the freedom the game gives you should be able to save him

[@SunBunz]

I love how all the merchants in the stores comment on Arthur, mostly out of concern, and Arthur’s like, “WHAT MAKES YOU SAY THAT?” 😠

[@Irreverent_Radiation]

Arthur: *coughs one of his lungs out in the camp* Everybody: Mmm yes, Dutch's plans seems to be made out of Mangoes... Arthur: *goes to the doctor's shop a few times a month* Doctor: Are you good, son? Do you need another shot of Horses Balls crushed and mixed with licor and cocaine?

[@alladeen2k8]

Doctor: Hello sir, Same problem as before? Like no my TB just went away.... OF COURSE THE PROBLEM!

[@GamingWithJazz]

I found another one. A random event NPC spawns in the swamp area off of St. Denis. He's injured and Arthur can take him to the doctor. If you spawn him after Arthur's diagnosis, the doc will have a different dialogue something like "you shouldn't be doing this in your condition" he will remember you when you bring the injured npc to him.

[@SephirothXRA]

TB may have been common in the late 19th century. Still, the doctor diagnosed it simply by Arthur looking sick and a cough with some occasional bloody sputum, which to me as a physician, is funny when I think of how we diagnose TB today with our multiple lab tests. A bloody cough could be lots of things, including cancer, bronchitis, infection (bad pneumoniae can cause bloody cough). Listening to the lungs and looking at the tongue will not really help that much in diagnosing TB. Granted, I know doctors back then had far more limited understanding of these diseases, how to diagnose, and treat (treatment for TB didn't come until the 1950s, and they only developed rudimentary microscopic staining abilities to diagnose in the late 1800s, around the time of this game).

[@Ezdine_G8261]

I mean it is a game

[@highboi870]

Pretty sad when he dies it makes me sad.

[@IndoJordy]

Yeah it is

[@willjones6369]

Stand there chain smoking cigarettes in front of the man the told you you have tuberculosis, then coughing blood all over him

[@zezeiko]

"You have tuberculosis" , Proceeds to smoke a pipe 2 inches away

[@demoncore4467]

You know I’ve never even seen the doctors catalogue before I usually always just loot or craft the tonics

[@williamlamb7026]

What’s amazing this game has been out for a while and you are still finding secrets

[@IndoJordy]

Yeah lot to discover her

[@RandalfElVikingo]

@@IndoJordy Do you have the Guarma "camp" conversations by any chance?

[@83uwb]

4:38 Aaaaand the emotional trauma continues

[@DocHolliday1851]

3:09 "The same problem as before?" I mean, this tuberculosis isn't going anywhere.

[@seanconnor925]

The doctor giving Arthur some cocaine after the checkup is the most 1899 thing ever

[@lewisjones4737]

A what if you never see with red dead is what if Arthur took the doctors advice, headed out west with John, Sadie, and some others that were by that point already loyal to him. Not likely but a nice thought non the less. Interesting to think if he would have survived.

[@kyleliberty9978]

Do you know what worse than turbocolosis LUMBAGO A slow painful death

[@IndoJordy]

It is if we believe Uncle

[@anemone105]

Fun fact, you will have more dialogue if you bring the arm man to the doctor before the diagnosis he will recognize you.

[@IndoJordy]

Thanks buddy

[@dexterjettster3683]

Yeah

[@Dutch_van_der_Linde_1899]

Doctor : what can I get for you ? Arthur : ( coughs ) Also Arthur : sure

[@silentdream-]

There’s actually a random event where you’re able to talk to the Doctor again after you brought someone who needed to get his arm amputated in his office. He’s really shocked that time..

[@BathSaltShaman]

Born too late to survive TB, born early enough to still get meth from a doctor

[@charlesboots6508]

Arthur: "I need money for that." Also Arthur: has $2000 in his wallet.

[@HeavyTanker-vx4oq]

If only there was a ending where you told Dutch what was going on, and he helped, gave you the money to get the proper care.

[@clickbait3753]

I like how he literaly is witnessing a man dying of a respiratory illness and yet still keeps on smoking lol.

[@123beyaahqb]

It's 2020 and I still discover new events, secrets, dialogues... the amount of content and detail this games has is mind blowing

[@RJ_Productions316]

Makes me almost kinda wish there was a secret dialouge for going back during/after the epilpuge where John informs that doctor that Arthur had since passed away