We Tested 5 Long-Wearing Liquid Lipsticks - Which Is Best?

To determine which liquid lipstick is best, INSIDER's Herrine Ro tried five different long-wearing, fool-proof formulas. We determined the best liquid lipstick based upon four criteria: long-lasting, transfer proof, dryness, and comfort.
Check out Herrine's videos:
BEAUTY INSIDER believes everyone should shine from hair to makeup and everything in between. Life is an adventure.
Subscribe to our channel: insder.co/Beauty and visit us at: thisisinsider.com
BEAUTY INSIDER on Facebook: / thisisinsiderdesign
BEAUTY INSIDER on Instagram: / insiderbeauty
INSIDER on Twitter: / thisisinsider
See more from our talent:
Herrine Ro: / roherrine
Produced by: Natalie Fennell, Nico Reyes, Herrine Ro

[@LoVeasaurMusic]

I think all the lipsticks tested should have been tested with the same foods (dry foods, watery foods, and greasy foods) for it to be more valid..

[@mariadln777]

My thoughts exactly.

[@jamiehershon]

Good point.

[@tamuforpatienceameih1816]

Exactly my point

[@jht3fougifh393]

I just wasted time commenting the dame thing. Glad others realized this, too!

[@Miss_Cali]

You should have ate the same food with all the lipsticks. Chocolate does not affect the same way oily noodles will.

[@persianice8697]

MissCali I completely agree,you can’t make a comparison if you use different foodstuffs.

[@megannwalsh]

No lipstick will last through oily pasta. Oil is what removes most liquid lipsticks. I would suggest Beauty Bakerie. That lipstick stays on forever. I personally love the NARS Power Matte. The colors are beautiful. I don’t mind reapplying my lipstick tho.

[@e.sgarrison3777]

Yes there's lipstick that losses all day and you can eat anything you want go buy dis esgarrison.com

[@purpleworm4725]

cheaper option - maybelline super stay matte inks :) after dinner might wear off a bit on the middle part, so its visible when you open your mouth, but otherwise lasts pretty well through oily pasta or pizza. It layers pretty well, if you have to do a touch up. If you don't eat anything oily, it can actually live up to the promises that they give in the product description - 16 hour wear time.

[@Sara-xx4bf]

E.S Garrison how would you remove it? (I’m complete newbie to makeup btw)

[@farzeenab7490]

Maybelline superstay is really good

[@gpljk]

You haven't tried maybelline matte ink then!

[@jht3fougifh393]

Horrible standard of testing. Oily foods will obviously take off an oil-based product like a liquid lipstick. You can't go nuts slurping up cheesey alfredo looking noodles, then in another one take a gentle, clean bite of a cake pop, and expect them both to be the same level of wear. Just expected something that actually made sense. My bad, I guess. This just seems gimmicky.

[@YiPeaches]

This isn't an accurate test because you ate different foods for them all. Some of those foods would have much less effect on lipstick than others.

[@ItsMzPhoenix]

The differences between foods seems like too big a variable to ignore...

[@maefitzpatrick8844]

This was so fun to watch. I can confirm that the Stila lipstick is the most transfer-proof lipstick I've ever tried.

[@bidyulatasahoo1253]

OMG....love that glittery wall😍😍😍

[@niveditaah5512]

Love insider and their content.❤

[@NataliaDanceFitness]

Thank you for this video! I think it's the most honest video I've seen, it's super helpful :)

[@Rzz941]

Natalia C noooo

[@ivybklyn]

I had tons of grilled pork belly today around 7pm with Maybelline super stay that I put on at noon and it didn’t come off or transfer Better than Stila which was my favorite.

[@helenadamnjanovic8976]

Does it Maybelline dry your lips

[@kimmysmall8705]

Make up & food😲I didn’t know my dream job existed 😍🥰🥰🥰

[@lindapedroza4207]

Thank you this helped a lot🙂

[@sreypov255]

I cannot cut the brand name. Could you pls tell me here ?

[@graceninayoshida5708]

I have tested several lippies but I can vouch for Revlon Ultimate Colorstay Liquid lipstick :)

[@mishiifayaz5392]

How do you mainten your weight instead of heavy calories intake

[@inboarduck8589]

“I have High hopes for this one” *patd starts playing

[@themeadowmae]

Isabella Merhi omg yes, exactly what went through my mind

[@cathysilva5011]

Does anyone know how to spell the winner? I couldn’t understand what she said.

[@joannahtorres6651]

Mmmm, give Kat Von another try. If you eat pasta with any “long lasting” lip, it’ll come off. But try Kat Von D eating other stuff.

[@cathlainetea]

Gorgeous 😍. Nice makeup

[@jessiemakeupqueen2896]

Mayblline liquid lipstick works!

[@marisel0127]

You need L'oreal Infallible Pro-Matte Les Macarons Scented Liquid Lipstick

[@juliakrol9453]

Your video content is always a breath of fresh air! 🌸 Ever since I started using the LeloBeauty lipstick, my lips have never looked better. Truly the best!

[@HS_Shiba83]

Can you plz test these matte lipstcks..fenty beauty stunna lip paint..dose of colors matte liquid lipstick, jiuer matte lip cream, jeffree star & Gerard cosmetics please and let us know

[@StunningEmu]

3:55 did you get that from Cake Boss? O:

[@foreveraloneg123]

how do i get your job

[@justsmart7987]

I love NARS i use it for all my bridal clients

[@madisoncarnahan6561]

Yessss

[@2006ayla]

Nice video 💖❤️💖

[@staytube4572]

How is she even eat that much and still stay in shape😍..?tell us the secret..

[@snehavyas5827]

She looks like asian jenna marbles...lol

[@shymarak5794]

Stila doesn't last that much when you eat oily, creamy food.

[@purpleworm4725]

The best long wearing lipstick that I have found so far is from drugstore - maybelline super stay matte ink :) I also have a few shades of the sephora ones, but they don't last on me as long as the maybelline ones. I have also tried kat von D ones, huda beauty ones, wet n wild liquid catsuits, and too faced melted latexes - nothing compares to the maybelline super stay matte inks. The only drawback that they have - they are a bit sticky, but I'm ok with that.

[@ninahagen8193]

The ones from Loreal infinitive pro matte are also great!

[@wanderwoman9528]

All that makeup and all the food. Yummmm

[@Rzz941]

Not a fair comparison. I stan by kvd liquid lipstick

[@Niicky09]

I want her eyebrows

[@jonginkim8206]

try la splash lip coutures

[@crystal1417]

'VERÕNNI' Waterproof Matt Lipstick is absolutely the best ever.... You have to use soap to wash it off otherwise it will not budge at all.... I received a set as an early birthday present and I love them

[@niveditaah5512]

I reallly wanna work with insider😭

[@conroecurio5145]

Bought KVD long wear liquid lipstick, was aweful retyrned it same day!

[@marthacastro7948]

After vomit it was still on. Lol. I wonder if Kat Von D will add that to her packaging.

[@wonderchild1465]

Surprisingly: bare minerals works really well.

[@bethanybutelectronic9846]

Everyone complaining about the consistency of the food for KVD test, when it was obviously coming off before she even ate. I had the same experience, there are much longer lasting lipsticks om the market.

[@LoveNaisa]

Sephora brand lip stains last all day even until the next day . The color will literally leave a stain on your lips. I can only get it off with heavy oil

[@jakealexander6046]

Hi Herrine! How are you able to eat a lot? Do you do some sort of preparation? You are second only to Mike Chen from strictly dumpling in this regard.

[@dianeadams5510]

Nothing stays on my lips

[@uday1259]

Best

[@alexiatorrez7680]

I want those cannolis, I want those cannolis now

[@user-zo1uc6yt9t]

It only made me hungry

[@TashaChristineC]

You ever tried lipsense?

[@dianereiser6417]

How is she not fat.

[@jht3fougifh393]

Maybe that's all she eats that day. Maybe she pukes it up. Maybe she fasts. Maybe she takes uppers. Maybe she works out excessively (this one imho is the least likely, as she does not appear toned at all, just thin). Maybe she has a naturally high metabolism. Those are really your options, right there. So yeah, most likely something unhealthy, but she might just be lucky enough to have that very rare kind of metabolism. More likely culprit is something not so pretty. Imho, best to just move on from it, and accept that it's not a normal standard by any means.

[@omgwtfrofltomato]

the one guy watching this video, reporting in the comments!!

[@fearlessQueen176]

hello new friend here try maybelline superstay

[@helenadamnjanovic8976]

Does it dry your lip?

[@fearlessQueen176]

@@helenadamnjanovic8976 for me nope

[@maymendoza5116]

😍😍😍

[@teaaddict8372]

How does she not get a stomach ache after all that dairy

[@thaotrannguyenngoc151]

That’s not fair

[@mon1708]

the sephora ones resist even when I eat tacos (real mexican cabeza and pastor tacos)

[@kara.buddrius]

Why would you not test the lipsticks on the same foods?

[@theprolorenzo]

I can't speak for anyone else but I open my mouth when I vomit. ☺

[@brookelockhart2658]

Can I just have your job please lol

[@qi4421]

♡

[@mishaleeslime6101]

When you bite the food you don't stick your lips on it you just stuff the food in your mouth

[@kendallmarillier3967]

I'm 2nd! 1st like!

[@madisonsang2197]

This test isn’t that accurate

[@blewprent]

Poor Herrine and her baby mouth. 😔

[@bakxdsquishixzz3402]

Im the first like and third view!

[@usergirl4122]

Crypto Program a

[@phacesbydimples4194]

Sooo what's the secret to eating anything you want and not gaining weight 😮‍💨😮‍💨😮‍💨

[@humai2939]

urm

[@tamuforpatienceameih1816]

Very wrong lipstick test

[@janaewc3384]

Such wittle wips

[@yorukoglumariaela]

Dude 😂😂😂

[@hannanfatima9995]

hahah😂😂😂people testing lipsticks now🤣🤣🤣

[@pinkelephantsandlemonades4011]

How is this even a comparison? 👎🏼

[@annetteherrera2813]

Kat Von D is a waste of money. Absolutely does not stay on. Very disappointed. If you want long lasting stay away from this.

[@marichristian1072]

My lipstick flaked off in a short time. No more Kat Von D.

[@TwentyThree-23]

You picked the person with the smallest lips to do a lipstick review. I can't even see her lips with a telescope let alone the color...

[@Surferchick90265]

Moon Chromosome why you gotta be so mean? - Taylor Swift

[@moirad6632]

but she barely has lips lol

[@racheldsouza8895]

perosn dhdjd wth is wrong with you butthurt people. If someone has tiny lips comments are negative. If someone gets filler there's hate. Why can't you just shut up if you have a problem with it. You have no idea how insecure people become because of it.please!!! Be nice.

[@moirad6632]

Rachel Dsouza honestly idc what ppl do to their bodies or how they look. what I'm saying is she was not the best person for this bc you can't really see her lips thus making the video kinda useless

[@racheldsouza8895]

She was testing them out. So what if she didn't have the right size. It doesn't matter ffs.

[@mariadln777]

I think all the lipsticks tested should have been tested with the same foods (dry foods, watery foods, and greasy foods) for it to be more valid.

[@helgaserge7152]

yes, oily pasta and chocolate are not very honest)