China’s Black Jails: The Shadow Prison System

[@IntotheShadows]

Take your personal data back with Incogni! Use code SHADOWS at the link below and get 60% off an annual plan: incogni.com/shadows

[@cloodhound9417]

Woah actually journalism? You guys good?

[@MrDavebeemer]

why do I pay for youtube premium to avoid adverts?

[@BlargBlarg-z7k]

West Taiwan is currently committing a Genocide of a Muslim Population that make the Germans of 1932 to 1945 seem insignificant... and the UN is ignoring it.

[@redchief94]

@MrDaveBeemer Because you mistakenly believe paying Google will somehow mean you don't have to see adverts I assume. It doesn't but you know that already.

[@MrTieeeem]

I hope Simon isnt planning a little trip to China anytime soon

[@thehangmansdaughter1120]

I have the greatest respect for those who speak up in the face of personal danger. They are courageous.

[@Max-sd7lm]

like snowden or asandge for example

[@byrona.689]

I'll take "countries I'll never go to" for 1000, Alex

[@cheekyb71]

I've been 5 times, it's beautiful, scary, and incredible. 7/10 recommend 😂

[@BewareTheLilyOfTheValley]

I used to think I'd maybe like to visit Hong Kong since they have a higher level of English speakers and opposed the mainland, but it seems the autonomy of Hong Kong has now sadly fallen.

[@Nystariii]

Avoid buying food that originates from there too. They have little to no oversight and there are multiple food safety scandals per year (that we know about).

[@bluegold1026]

Not while you-know-who is in power.

[@zakb7418]

Add list Dont go the usa

[@turdferguson9356]

The Earth King has invited you to Lake Laogai

[@biazacha]

I remember when I learned what Laogai was refering to and damn if the writers weren’t balsy

[@TheDjpwn3]

I am honored to accept his Majesty's invitation

[@Wargasmo]

There is no war in Ba Sing Se.

[@rbgtk]

@@biazacha I didn't realize it was a reference, just looked it up and damn, balsy indeed EDIT: was mentioned in the video like not even a minute later 🤦‍♂

[@Alcatrazrezz]

Honestly, I rewatched those ATLA episodes after learning about Loagai, and it puts the episodes in a whole new light

[@Kaltagstar96]

God, just imagine being thrown into an unofficial prison with absolutely zero due process, just for petitioning against the government? I can thing of few things more terrifying. That said, Chen Guangcheng escaping his house arrest and getting to the United States is at least a tiny bit of positivity in such a grim topic.

[@ShadowKatt]

Yes, imagine being targetted by the government for speaking out against it or refusing to fall in line with the party mandate. So glad that doesn't happen in the US.

[@Novastar.SaberCombat]

In the U.S., you'll just be digitally silenced, socially shunned, and ignored as you shrink into (and ACCEPT) your inevitable invisibility. 💪😎✌️ That's just how it be. #copium

[@hughjass1976]

​@@ShadowKattname 1 person who has been jailed in the US for criticising the government

[@samaeltheundying]

​​​@@hughjass1976Me. I was. I even won a settlement that I used to buy my bidet so the city can polish my asshole every morning. Then you have the people who just straight up died at Kent State.

[@rubiconnn]

@@ShadowKatt Are you ashamed of yourself for being a ccp shill? Taking money to abuse your fellow countrymen so that a few people on top stay in power?

[@ClannCholmain]

As of 2023, the global rank of China declined to 179 out of 180, with only North Korea having less press freedom.

[@keyboardmanyoutube3189]

Press freedom rank is a joke…. Never buy it… where is the freedom to pro Palestine on press in USA ?

[@captsirl]

like the US has freedom of press?

[@zethloveless7238]

@@captsirlyes

[@Daniel-zm1wt]

@captsirl it's pretty common knowledge.

[@brandonvasser5902]

Hi wumao have you done your daily Xi Jinping thought app exercises? You and your family depend on it.

[@holyheretic3185]

Do one on the secret Chinese police stations in NYC

[@jlshel42]

They’ve set up in DC and Maryland too

[@blarfroer8066]

They have those around the world.

[@Jadzo87]

They arent a secret, govt lends money, they use it to go abroad..."police" look after repayment

[@sashimijones]

They did in the recent Warographics video

[@Nystariii]

@@sashimijones It deserves it's own "Into the Shadows" episode though, considering it is more clandestine than overtly war related.

[@Kevan808]

Appreciate your exposure of the CCP's human rights violations. Keep up the great work!

[@bluegold1026]

Funny. If I had written the same comment, it would have been automatically deleted by KZbin.

[@JoeRogansForehead]

He loves the ccp

[@baikeiast5255]

Let talk about the white first 😅😅😅😅😅

[@yourfriendlycynic]

as someone from hong kong i really appreciate this vid, these things need to be brought to light

[@Hakzer]

Simons social credit has to be negative at this point

[@waichungsham1578]

Paid by America lookup H.R.1157 a $1.6 billion fund specifically made to pay influencers and mainstream media to post negative propaganda against against china it's a fact

[@nulnoh219]

He's getting that US congress money for anti China propaganda tho.

[@SquirrellyMom]

I'm impressed there Simon, most people are not willing to tick of China.

[@4362mont]

China just acts all hard but is made of cry.

[@FutureBoyWonder]

All sorts of critical videos what can the Chinese do to simon? Weird comment

[@ZhouMama69420]

Truly a Bing Chilling moment

[@evankimori]

1:09 to skip that obnoxious Incogni ad.

[@alext3811]

Thanks!

[@darkmoon4135]

Life savor!

[@Darby_1516]

Just started the video and thought come on you can't just start the video with a sponsor. Well problem solved ig 😂

[@Gamer1990100]

Not all heroes wear capes!

[@felonious_c]

A man after my own heart ❤️

[@nighthawkcof]

Any country that has a 99% conviction rate can not be taking serious as a country of law and order

[@Genesh12]

CONVICTION RATE IN JAPAN IS NEARLLY THAT.

[@Michael-hg5hr]

Simon Whistler aka whistle boy if you had been a teacher at my school you'd have single handedly transformed it from a place of disdain and boredom into a place i personally would've looked forward to attending and probably would've excelled in the subjects the whistle boy was teaching ❤

[@louisoost121]

A really good channel abou life in china is by serpentza. He love in china for 14 years. Also has a channel with a friend called the china show. Glad simon is also talking about this.

[@benjaminsmekens2344]

He's like the worst source of information about China, and has a pretty clear agenda... Both of them are unwatchable.

[@annenelson5656]

It is a good channel. Thanks for mentioning it.

[@stevenphillips3506]

These black jails must crammed with people considering how many problems there are with the system, people losing over 9 trillion dollars with the corrupted housing sector, banks refusing to pay people, the struggling jobs sector etc.

[@blarfroer8066]

The central government usually doesn't mind protests against local structures. The local party might send out brutes to rough up protesters, but you'll likely not end up in one of those prisons unless you dared to protest against the central government.

[@CCPVirus-19]

they are organ donors now

[@rebeccaaldrich3396]

By beginning a video with a commercial, you risk losing views. This information is vital for people to hear so please consider adding the commercial to the middle or end of the video. Thank you for reporting on this!

[@tinomartinez7820]

I thank God every day that I was born in the USA. We’ve got a sick history of our own but I’d take my present life here over anything the average Chinese or Russian citizen goes through.

[@will.green.]

also to be born in the USA in the current era. we have a sick PRESENT as well, but i agree its better than what most people around the world have to deal with

[@buscarryad]

You are ignorant then. Typically the average american is worse off than the citizens of the countries you mentioned. The good bad and ugly included. Not to say that those countries don't have miserable people and human rights abuses, the USA just covers those up better.

[@wolfrickthedesigner4748]

Simon just got -1,000,000 bing chilling social credits

[@Myself-im9xi]

Australia also has them. I was locked up in South Australia, denied legal counsel, and doctor prescribed medication, for placing a formal complaint against an officer who refused to take my report of domestic violence, because I am a man.

[@freedfree7933]

I don’t think you understand what a black jail is. You were in regular jail that apparently has misused it’s appointed powers.

[@DingoNovember]

I’m from Thailand, though most people don’t know this but we do have this kind of jail, a jail outside of jurisdiction system. Most of people who got sent there are high ranking military and police officers.

[@will.green.]

sounds like a coup

[@dsnodgrass4843]

The Chicago PD tried to have one of those, a few years ago. Not sure what happened with it.

[@will.green.]

in america we have 2 kinds of black jails

[@johnynoway9127]

Another prison system! another prison system! For you and me to live in!

[@soonmeekim930]

So I’m not listening to this as a podcast, I’m listening to it via KZbin over my cars speakers. Simon’s wonderful enthusiasm just made me jump and throw my phone across the car. My volume might have been a bit too loud. 😂😂😂

[@elricofmelnibone425]

Hey! No one cares.

[@soonmeekim930]

@@elricofmelnibone425 hey! Most things I say no one cares about, even me. Also, even if you don’t care what I say, I do hope you have a great day. I’m having an ok day. I’ve got major surgery on Friday and you just commenting means a lot to me.

[@itsdan722]

Why are you using your phone while driving?

[@soonmeekim930]

@@itsdan722 oh! I was sitting in the pick up line waiting to get my daughter. It’s safely in a parking lot. I get there an hour early cuz the line goes through the parking lot and onto the street.

[@metalbrony2012]

Honestly, even 50 secret jails in China sounds a little bit low😅

[@will.green.]

ya its gotta be in the hundreds

[@sabelonxosi7336]

Can you please find out about Joshua Wong,he was sentenced to less than a year,to those black prisons,but it's been 3yrs now,no sign of him

[@richardroebuck1915]

Black jails, imprisonment without trial or reason....I can hear Keir Starmer frantically scribbling notes as I type... ;-)

[@leonschumann2361]

the DDR (east germany) had those too up until 1990 and still a lot of people don't know or are silent about that. it was pretty much the exact same thing

[@Sir.Leonardo.Scherer]

This channel should focus on stuff like this, that's happening right now, it need to be known

[@StigmaX]

Tom Cruise knows where Shelly Miscavige is

[@TeemoQuinton]

Evidence?

[@JParker.]

She's fine. Alive and working with the organization she still believes in wholeheartedly.

[@davidbennettracing538]

1984

[@Nick-v7b3l]

Except ask the rooms are Room 101.

[@smalltime0]

In 1984 the government still actually charged the dissidents though.

[@goodbyerealworld8982]

​@@smalltime0 the ccp is worse than the state.

[@iceteal3mon108]

​@@smalltime0 think he means the book/movie

[@smalltime0]

@@iceteal3mon108 I know he means the book. The government in the book still charged the dissidents with crimes, you just were guilty of them.

[@blueboltshrimp]

(as a chinese american person:) thanks for covering things like this!

[@marksmith6811]

Anyone else feel like they're being stalked by incogni via KZbinr sponsors.....

[@paulanderson7796]

I certainly cannot hack Whistler in the slightest. One of the most irritating fabricators on YT. Don't hunour him.

[@xeeda2259]

@@paulanderson7796??

[@alexaugustynski3620]

Watching this makes me grateful for my own life. It could be much, much worse. When your day to day life is ass and suffering and you've faced many severe indignities, perspective can be difficult in the moment.

[@katherinecollins4685]

Fantastic video

[@OG_BettyBoob]

Someone in Simon's team pls tell him to wear that shirt he is wearing in the ad more often it looks fab.

[@danieldavis9348]

When you have the threat of something like that over your head. Isn't that life itself a prison?

[@will.green.]

youre not wrong, but then you can start asking if our lives are prisons as well for various reasons including our own govt, poverty, and tech

[@CC-gg4oj]

What a lovely country... I'll be going there...

[@gordwrath6811]

I had no idea they even existed.

[@macroscopes]

"Do not say we have nothing" one of the best books I've read, the author if Im not mistaken is now a refugee in Canada (or she was born in Canada and her family came as refugees)

[@BagEnd0]

There is no war in Ba Sing Se

[@donger007]

How many channels is this host on? I swear, every time I see a thumbnail of the host, it's for a different channels.

[@chiedzawith2ds]

Yes

[@chiedzawith2ds]

The Simon Whistler Cinematic Universe knows no bounds

[@sophiebennett568]

10

[@KlaximumSkroeft]

Welcome to the Whistlerverse

[@rtyrsson]

@@sophiebennett568 I must be missing a few. I dropped Biographics and Geographics when he left.

[@trishmcl9055]

I'm widowed, retired and disabled. So I know all about solitary confinement.

[@BarneySm0kesCrak]

Thanks for the great videos

[@paulanderson7796]

These videos are absolute nonsense in my opinion. There are many like Whistler scattered across Western media.

[@jetcat00]

Less than 100k views 4 days out.. a little sus KZbin🤨

[@josephgraham1540]

Do an episode on guantanamo bay

[@jasong546]

Sounds like the dc jail

[@JackTavern629]

Sounds fun. I wonder how the food tastes.

[@4362mont]

Spit sauce & gutter oil with a gkass of milk & melamine.

[@J.Severin]

Perfekt sponsor. 😂

[@DMSrunit]

I think once you reach one billion plus population in a single nation societal structures become rigid and sharp but also bendable in a bad way. There’s a way to do it but we don’t got it down yet

[@GoetzimRegen]

It's DDR 2.0, only with better technology.

[@rtyrsson]

Du hast vollkommen recht.

[@Adm906]

Oh my god… Lake Loagai… from ATLA… this is where that name comes from?!?? 3:25

[@bizzfo]

Think about it, give someone all your data so they can make sure no one has all your data. Makes sense.

[@will.green.]

guaranteed they sell data

[@lisapop5219]

4:12 I thought that it was before because of Falun gong

[@will.green.]

in america we have 2 kinds of black jails

[@KarlMarch-z6k]

Got it

[@dearthditch]

Free Winnie! 🐻

[@MimiYuYu]

Simon- please don’t plan any holidays to China

[@victoriaelizabeth9726]

So they're like miniature Guantanamo Bay's

[@rogerpenske2411]

Name someone in Gitmo that doesn’t belong there, and doesn’t know why (charges)

[@gravel7614]

​@@rogerpenske2411considering they didn't have to put them through a court system. I'm going to say none of them deserve to be there getting tortured without anything being proven.

[@JParker.]

​@@rogerpenske2411 Abu Zubaydah is probably the most notable, but you can be sure that there are many more.

[@will.green.]

there are people sitting in jails across the country waiting years for a trial

[@rogerpenske2411]

@@gravel7614 hanging out in the Caribbean. Some torture. They are POWs, not citizens charged under civil or criminal statutes. Go ahead, Perry Mason, you can pro bono for a terrorist.

[@jeffvansloten1897]

How many channels this dude on????

[@joellelinden7079]

Chinese gov: he tortured himself. What i don't understand, why don't those people come to make resistens together and bring it to public, UN etc or try to seperate themselfs from tje system. There must be millions of oppressed people. A small group can't do much, but millions can make a rebellion

[@will.green.]

thats never worked anywhere. what actually happens is power is overtaken by another power and the people always suffer

[@JGDRConsulting]

How can they know when to release the detainee if there are no records to start with.

[@jellyfishfields5657]

Im not sure thats their intention

[@PortalFPV]

I have a dark view on this. But I hope this keeps going on and gets more severe......because if it's too silent, everyone will keep going on with their lives woefully oblivious to such despicable government overreach. There's only so long a government can suppress its people before the people snap

[@iveBENwatchin]

Do russias black jails next please

[@theelitistjerkmetalhead8047]

Typo in text overlay at 15:37.

[@user-HellcatHemi]

RIP to all those who lost their lives to 😈 such as this & may God wrap those left hurting from said 😈 in his loving arm's & may they find each other in the Kingdom of Heaven someday for Christ is King. ♥️❤️

[@will.green.]

i cant take you seriously when you use emojis

[@smithbilly467]

Zao shang hao zhong guo, xian zai wo you BING CHILLING, WO HEN XI HUAN BING CHILLING!!!! dan shi, su du yu ji qing jiu bi BING CHILLING su du yu qi qing... *stutters, su du yu ji qing jiu, wo ZUIIIIII xi huan. suo yi, xian zai shi YIN YUEEEEEE shi jian. yi... er... san

[@yz250ftony]

Simon shouldn't go anywhere near China

[@GrievousReborn]

Videos like this where you talk about the Terrible Things trying to have done is why I think it's stupid when people on another video of yours think you're pro-china because you didn't say something about them like they wanted you to show those people are idiots

[@rosshemp2783]

Crazy story time: a few years ago, I traveled to China and got caught in a misunderstanding that landed me in a detention center. The conditions were brutal-starved for days, beaten to enforce ideological control, and forced to sleep in a cramped room with barely any space. It was surreal and terrifying, feeling trapped and powerless. Luckily, after what felt like an eternity, my embassy intervened, and I was finally released. It was a nightmare I’ll never forget.

[@unknownsoul1206]

Holy hell man, I'm glad you made it out; as a foreigner that's an achievement. But why would you willingly go to China? Business?

[@rosshemp2783]

@@unknownsoul1206 man I put a prompt into chat gpt to make a comment about escaping a Chinese black prison and it made that, insane right

[@ArpanDe]

IT'S FAKE?

[@Viviko]

West Taiwan is a horrible place.

[@peytonlaporte7800]

Any viewer of this vid loses all social credit

[@thepax2621]

Damm... So they caught chinese Matt Murdock 😅?

[@trayvondcrawford8186]

Does anyone know the background music 🎶??

[@adventure_onthedaily9851]

Can someone do a wellness check on Simon’s beard pls

[@yookalaylee2289]

“There is no war in Ba Sing Se”

[@lukasritzer738]

Truth: this man can never go to China lol

[@zch7491]

JJINA!

[@jlshel42]

This’ll hurt my social credit score

[@rtyrsson]

You jest, but I suspect something similar coming to western nations in the near future. There was a good deal of a push for this to ensure compliance with Wuhan virus restrictions and mandates.

[@ramseydoon8277]

10:12 🗣"maonutrition"

[@multiyapples]

China needs to become free for everyone there.

[@will.green.]

good idea. they should be free like us. we get to vote for people that hate us and actively try to ruin our country. but at least they let us vote!

[@thepax2621]

Does a stay at a "Black Prison" affect your "social points"? 😅🤔

[@damienhunt4264]

Coming soon to a Western country near you.

[@FootagebyDJI]

This guy has 600 channels

[@notusneo]

Shadow prison money gang We like detaining people

[@Vile_Entity_3545]

And because China has money the Western politicians never say anything.

[@will.green.]

bought and paid for. it would be hypocritical anyways

[@dunk7073]

Careful what you say on the "intranet"

[@waichungsham1578]

they blocked me talking about HR 1157

[@SavingMsBlack]

lol Guantanamo bay? Chicago black sites. That lady on the cruise who was kept in jail even though she was not on the warrant? Common… What are we doing here?

[@will.green.]

pretty much every jail in america esp drug "crimes," people that are poor and have no access to a lawyer, people that are sick, half the police interactions with civilians

[@niceonechief6302]

-90 Social credit

[@Moog012]

1 billion people...

[@NationalTidende]

😮

[@JoeRogansForehead]

Simon loves chian

[@jac6548]

black jails aren't any worse than other jails, they're just doing the best with the circumstances they were given!

[@oler777]

Taiwan number one

[@bengaisford3304]

Kid Starver Foogie Freezer Peado Protecter can do all this.

[@katywyld5534]

Hi, i promise im not being a pedant or a troll, i have really noticed how your pronunciation of chinese words has improved. I wouldnt say anything but the pronunciation of a couple names sound like completely different words in chinese. As a rough guide Cao is pronounced like sow not cow, and Zhi is like the Ge or Germs not Jee, which sounds like youre calling him a chicken 😂

[@will.green.]

the AI gets better every day. you almost cant tell the dif anymore

[@Guyonthecouch420]

Thank goodness I'm brown. Black jails look terrible

[@richardhall3896]

Whats he difference between people being silenced for a cohesive comunity (china), and being silenced so someone can make money selling faulty medicine or poisoning water supplies (US)?

[@bluegold1026]

What will it take to end this unjust system once and for all?? I'd say what, but my comment would be automatically deleted by KZbin.

[@will.green.]

this is the way it has always been and will always be