IPL Auction Debate: Retentions and RTM | R Ashwin | PDogg

In this episode of "IPL Auctions Debate: Retentions and RTM," we dive into the complexities of player retentions and the Right to Match (RTM) card. R Ashwin and PDogg offer their insights on how teams should approach retentions, the strategic use of RTM, and the potential game-changers in the upcoming auction. Tune in for a dynamic discussion as we analyze the impact of these decisions on team compositions and the overall IPL landscape!
#ravichandranashwin #pdogg #iplauction #msdhoni #iplauction2024 #iplretention #csk #aroundtheworld #rashwin #ashwinchannel #india #indiacricket #indiacricketteam
Subscribe to my Channel - bit.ly/Subscri...
HIT THE BELL ICON TO STAY UPDATED
Watch Out Our Previous Episodes of Payanangal Mudivadhillai👇
🏏Local Salem Boys Meet | Kaun Banega Cricketpathi | Ravi Maestri - • Local Salem Boys Meet ...
🏏Thattu Settu ft. Nattu: Exploring Salem's cuisine with Natarajan - • Thattu Settu ft. Nattu...
🏏Kovai na Gethu | Payanangal Mudivadhillai ft. Coimbatore - • Kovai na Gethu | Payan...
🏏House of the Dragons ft. Indrajith & Varun CV - • House of the Dragons f...
🏏Tirunelveli Alwa Da! | Namma Payaluga Makkaa - • Tirunelveli Alwa Da! |...
🏏Struggles of a District Cricketer - • Struggles of a Distric...
🏏'Joe Biden is the leading run scorer in test cricket 😂' - • 'Joe Biden is the lead...
Watch Out Our Previous Episodes of T20 World Cup Preview:
🏆Afghanistan & Bangladesh Preview | EP 1 - • Afghanistan & Banglade...
🏆T20 WC Curtain Raiser: Associates & Ireland Watch | EP 2 - • T20 WC Curtain Raiser:...
🏆Pakistan & Sri Lanka Preview | EP 3 - • Pakistan & Sri Lanka P...
🏆South Africa & West Indies Preview | EP 4 - • South Africa & West In...
🏆Australia & New Zealand Preview | EP 5 - • Australia & New Zealan...
🏆 Defending Champions England Preview | EP 6 - • Defending Champions En...
Watch Out Our Previous Episodes of Kutti Stories with Ash: Season 2
Episode 1 ▶️ • Inception | E1 | Kutti...
Episode 2 ▶️ • Kapil's Devils | E2 | ...
Episode 3 ▶️ • The 90s | E3 | Kutti S...
Episode 4 ▶️ • Dada to Dravid to Dhon...
Episode 5 ▶️ • The Pinnacle | E5 | Th...
Episode 6 ▶️ • India is now second ho...
Episode 7 ▶️ • There's a rule book, O...
Episode 8 ▶️ • No Holds Barred ft. Ga...
Watch Our IPL 2024 Team Previews Here
🏆5th Episode SRH & RCB Team Preview Here 👉 • WWE Night of Champions...
🏆4th Episode SRH & RCB Team Preview Here 👉 • The Southern Flavour |...
🏆 3rd Episode KKR & RR Team Preview Here 👉 • The Purple & The Pink ...
🏆 2nd Episode GT & LSG Team Preview Here 👉 • New Kids on the Block ...
🏆 1st Episode DC & PBKS Team Preview Here 👉 • Kings in the North | I...
Check out my Previous "Around the World of Cricket" Videos Here
🏏World Cup 2023: A Reflection - • World Cup 2023: A Refl...
🏏Half-Time Analysis | World Cup Roundup - • Half-Time Analysis | W...
🏏Thala Dhoni upset about the decline of ODI's - • Thala Dhoni upset abou...
🏏 Naa Ready Dha Varava - • Naa Ready Dha Varava -...
🏏 A chat with TNCA Treasurer Mr Srinivasaraj - • Why is getting tickets...
🏏 'Naan Solvadhellam Unmai' - India's WC Campaign - • 'Naan Solvadhellam Unm...
🏏 India at the Asia Cup | Squad Analysis by R Ashwin - • India at the Asia Cup ...
🏏 The Ashes Review - Ashwin's Request to Indian Fans - • The Ashes Review - Ash...
🏏 The Inspiring Journey of T Dilip - India's Fielding Coach - • The Inspiring Journey ...
🏏 Spirit of Cricket: 'Yaarra Neengellam'? - • Spirit of Cricket: 'Ya...
🏏 Mission 2023: The ODI WC is Go | Schedule | Venues | Build up
🏏 The Bazball Ashes Discussion | TNPL Touchdown | R Ashwin - • The Bazball Ashes Disc...
🏏 Aadukalam: WTC Final 2023 | India vs Australia - • Aadukalam: WTC Final 2...
Check out my Official Website - www.raviashwin....
Follow me on:
Facebook - / ashwinraviofficial
Twitter - as...
Instagram - www.instagram....

[@richardparker3841]

4 rent, 2rtm is perfect ,5 years once mega auction , retired uncaped player rule so we retain ms

[@AshwinRavi99]

😂😂👌

[@user-wg3lh3uh5r]

Nakal na unaku...​@@AshwinRavi99

[@viveganandhanravichandran8794]

😂​@@AshwinRavi99

[@yk8959]

😂😂Ipl is not only for csk bro😂😂

[@richardparker3841]

@@AshwinRavi99 thanks 😊😊😊 ash na

[@AshwinRavi99]

Hope you guys are enoying the episodes of 'IPL Auction Debate'. Let us know what other IPL topics you would like us to debate about.

[@nandhakumars7800]

Pdogg's analogy will not be implemented in ipl auction

[@balavk7481]

Ashwin na commented 7 mins ago - THALA for a reason 😂

[@worshiperofcricket1083]

Anna do a full mock auction with franchise owners as the viewers shortlisted .and give prizes to the best team. It would be fun. In our school times we used to play auction with our friends..

[@gopicr7]

Now 18 minutes ago Kohli for a reason ​@@balavk7481

[@dearmrkiran]

Why don't you guys give a blueprint of an ideal T20 xi, with respect to team combination? Also advise if the concept of 'batting till 8' is going to help sustain the little remaining balance between bat and ball.

[@TamilCricketNews]

Completely disagree with the Pdogg suggestion here. Obviously we need to address the salary inequality between Indian and Foreign cricketers and also between Retained/RTM cricketers and Auctioned cricketers. But we can't make the auction process more complacent. The reason why the IPL auction is as big a spectacle as the tournament is because it is too simple for a viewer to understand. If we make the rules and processes too complicated, then the existing viewers themselves will lose interest let alone new viewers. I am not belittling the knowledge of the viewers but i believe we need to think from a layman's perspective. But i completely agree with Ash's solution on RTM. I would like to point out that none of the T20 league drafts/auctions generate even 5% of the IPL auction excitement because of how simple the process is. I can't think we can trade off that simplicity.

[@rohitvicky4909]

Tcn bro😁

[@ajeeth8224]

Magaprabu neenga ingaium vandhuteengalaa😂😂😂

[@selvag5762]

if faf goes to punjab for 2crores & bangalore RTM use panna. Only punjab can bid for only 1 time to faf whatever the amount they bid for example 8cr if bangalore agrees for RTM the bangalore will get faf otherwise Punjab anyway faf get 8 crores

[@mkgamerytpro9718]

Pdogg Ah Thappu Sonna nee vadikatna muttal

[@Sathish-pk7bs]

Y so long

[@TamilCricketNews]

Pdogg wants the auction done in half a day which is understandable. But on the other hand the media rights of this tournament is 50,000 cr. Let that sink in. They wont splash the cash if the auction is a 3 hr event.

[@ranjithv6260]

Ivangga solldramathri neenga clarification video podunga please 😊

[@TamilCricketNews]

I would like the retentions to be the same as usual. 4 + 2 RTM. But I would want to change one thing. These 6 players( including 2 RTM ) can negotiate a salary with their team which can be max 2X of their retained salary(had to be disclosed). But this additional salary wont be deducted from the auction purse. The teams get their favour of retaining the player and the playerz get their increased salary.

[@iamrafik85]

Unode channel la pesu vro funzip uuuhu

[@karthikkeyan7768]

That would be a nice idea. You are at least not suggesting a change in RTM and make it no RTM :P

[@AnandhuArun-cc2uq]

There is some problem. Please add me to a live debate

[@kkn619]

good

[@qbrofanarmy4774]

Bro apo budget en iruku if undervalue of a player is problem then what about overpriced? Will a player take price cut for underperforming

[@vikkramsasidharan5120]

I feel there is no point of RTM if you can outbid. How is it difference from normal bidding!

[@om_avi]

Exactly!

[@dhannushkumar]

Exactly, glad that someone asked this. I was thinking the same thing.

[@wbrucebale]

unbelievable he blabbered for 10mins on this

[@thiru_asc1]

Exactly RTM is a gamble,can go either way

[@vigneshk7630]

Exactly!

[@koushikraghava2167]

3:58 pdogg says "Zero retentions 10 RTMs" Impossible 👎

[@user-jq9ib9rk7x]

4 retain(3+1) 2 RTM(1+1) 💛

[@DJSarvesh007]

Whenever the topic is about IPL Auctions RCB Fans be like Halla bol konjam pathu bol 🤣🤣. Pdogg full focus on RCB 🙌.

[@madavakousik1527]

Anna please do mock auction before the ipl

[@arulm2026]

Yes

[@madhan_ak6134]

Yes waiting

[@madhankrishna7232]

Yes

[@Sarabheswaran7010]

00:10😂😂, 2:03 pdogg mentions RRs retention approach, 2:28 SRH retention approach. 3:19 CSK retention options 3:55 pdogg's sir asks 0 retention and 10 RTM 😮, 6:23-09:37 pdogg sir explains his 10 RTMs methodology, 7:35 ash anna comes to break it down for us plebians, 13:30 15:58 pdogg wants an amendment to RTM rule, 14:40, 16:55 19:05 ash talks about demerit of RTMs, 22:33, 23:35, 21:51😂, 20:08 😂😂😂, 21:04, 25:46 fin

[@subramoniapillai7903]

Csk : Jaddu Rutu Dhoni Conway Pathirana Dube and Rachin RTM

[@bhaskarteja1997]

My honest review is 5 retentions(3 for Indian + 2 for overseas players) + 3 Rtm[1 overseas + 2 uncapped Indian players) + No impact player for upcoming mega auction 2025

[@edwardallan5633]

My honest review . 20 retentions 😂

[@Mercy_banishier]

Impact player rule is the next evolution of cricket,embrace it.

[@pavanthomas007]

We don’t want such complicated auction. Just keep 3 retentions and 2 rtm (only 2 foreign )

[@prakashchandramohan7759]

The problem is none of franchise is thinking out of the box.... They need to make the core from uncapped and retired player and just have 1-2 superstars

[@SUPERMAN-pi5bx]

That's not core

[@240vedhavarshini2]

Pdogg's idea of 10 RTMs is brilliant 🔥

[@matheen3832]

😂

[@bhuvidar97]

Worst

[@sarankirthic4532]

Worst uhh because kholi kandipa RCB ku than aaduvan so matha teams oru 30crs vara amount ahh increase panita?

[@cjdevil6124]

kadaisila enna sonnarunu pathiya RTM=normal bidding😂

[@Raj_Developer]

I think starting of the dream11 giving point that concept

[@DJSarvesh007]

Just like how it's difficult to predict when it will rain we never know when Pdogg will turn into Anniyan 🤣🤣. Vera level sambavam irruku 🙌.

[@RajkumarRajkumar-zq4kd]

RTM களின் எண்ணிக்கை < retention இதை என்றுமே IPL management மட்டுமே மாற்றாது

[@balamukunthasaravanan4295]

Ash anna talking in player point of view, pdogg talking in team owner point of view

[@KartikVeerakumar]

Hello Ashwin, Firstly Thank you for your analysis, hard work and efforts to discuss so many topics in cricket, I have been following your channel since 2020, your channel has always enlightened me. Kudos to you and your team. Congratulations on your 500 wickets. You are truly an inspiration for our country. Suggestions for IPL Auction: Retention players should get the highest price in my opinion and auction players should always receive less than retained players. For ex: RCB retains Virat, He should have the highest price in the team, rest of the players should be below him, similar with Bumrah/SKY in Mumbai, Like BCCI has a grading system of A+ category, A category, B category - Retention players should also have the same. So All A+ category players should have the highest value if franchisees want those players to be retained. Another suggestion is that IPL is for Indian players and upliftment of Indian players, In the auction there should be a cap for bidding, Maximum Bid for Indian player should be below the A+ category of retained player, so for ex RCB retains VK at 25 Cr, then in the auction the cap for Indian auction player- say Siraj can maximum get 25 CR, As for the Foreign player the cap should be at 20 CR. so If RCB wants to buy Will Jacks or FAF - he can max get 20 CR in the bid war, but for Siraj they can go upto 25 CR. This way the number of retentions can be reduced, RTM can be cancelled. Maximum 3 Indian and 1 foreign retention. Foreign players should always receive lesser than Indian players as they have more opportunities to play in different leagues, whereas Indian players do not have that opportunity until they are retired. Bidding war should be seen for Indian players and not so much for Foreign players, whether it is in mega auction or in the mini auction.

[@rahulreddy8854]

Hi Ashwin! My thoughts are explained below in a example: Suppose Pat cummins is at 16crs with Delhi and Hyderabad decided to use RTM then the price of pat cummins is 16crs but we should allow delhi to bid again and outmatch their rtm so delhi says 16.25crs then srh can use their rtm again which will not increase the price of the player and now srh has the player at 16.25crs so what this rule does is it will not nullify the advantage of rtm, it is an advantage to the player because if delhi wants to buy pat cummins even for 30crs they have to outbid themselves and no team will be worried about rtm usage.

[@AshwinRavi99]

I suggest u watch the whole show before commenting cos we are saying the hike needs to 20 percent higher and if the team still wants the RTM give it to them. Also the right of the RTM should stay with the player. So…

[@Murallij]

An RTM charge should be applied for the player. Like a certain % increase based on the player slab (predetermined by bcci). If the team applying RTM is okay to pay the premium along with the final auction price, they can apply the RTM, if not that price will be taken as the true value of the player and the last bidding team will take the player. What do you think?

[@charansastry7113]

RTM is a fair concept according to me. For example, there is a young breakout player who is most likely not to be retained. The team that scouted him and trained him have the right to get him back as they spotted his talent. Now only the price becomes a deciding factor which is completely fair. And somebody like a Bumrah is not losing 8 crores he's earning 18. There is enough money. The RTM price cap seems like the fair concept.

[@aargee11]

How about giving an option to the player within 10 mins after the player gets picked to decide if the player wants to opt in or opt out of that particular session. For example if Hasaranga goes for 2C again in the coming auction. He should be given an option whether he would be willing to accept that offer or not in the next 10 mins. If he opts out, then he can come to auction the next year but current year he can't play. By this, the teams will look for some other player and the money is not locked. I think it's fair for the player and also the teams.

[@BCMPraveenKS-uf5jl]

Ash na said right, value of players is important

[@Smmjifri]

If other franchises are allowed to bid after RTM card rasied then what is the use of RTM? How it will be different from usual bidding?

[@krishnanandpremanand3581]

You could get the first shot at the player at any price

[@prakashn363]

​@@krishnanandpremanand3581 don't understand plz explain?

[@adachai793]

18.00 ethume panna mattanga

[@krishnanandpremanand3581]

@@prakashn363 in this scenario it's only when you refuse to take the player he'd go to the other team As in if someone bids 5cr for a player and you could use RTM but they could raise the bid to 10cr and you could take the player at 10cr Or let the other team take him

[@gautamanilkunneth9586]

​@@krishnanandpremanand3581 what about if he outbids again? What is the use then?

[@hasansyed8728]

23:46 Ash Anna Perfectly articulated, Absolutely agree

[@rishaavinashpradee9078]

Fantastic idea and suggestion Pdogg. RTM based on player value slabs. This makes so much sense because one of the purposes of mega auction is to keep teams in balance, reset and nullify teams advantage of specific player/ player set.

[@denimarshal8572]

Ash na... Oru Team Oru Player ah RTM use panni thookanum nu asapatta...antha player ku potential irukum la..athanala..Other teams price ah hike panna ...RTM use pannalum...antha player ku nalla amount thane povaru...

[@Shamavane]

5 retention without restriction, foreign big players registered for big auction can be part of small auction,good trade transperency.

[@Suryamsd77]

4 retain (3 indian + 1 foreign) +2 RTM perfect💯 CSK ( 1st jaddu 2nd ruttu 3rd msd 4th pathirana) 1st RTM convey 2nd RTM dube MSD uncapped list

[@worshiperofcricket1083]

Anna do a full mock auction with franchise owners as the viewers shortlisted .and give prizes to the best team. It would be fun. In our school times we used to play auction with our friends..

[@worshiperofcricket1083]

With the idea given by prassana sir. 10 rtms based on slabs.

[@AravindRants]

One of the Interesting Episodes❤ Good suggestions PDogg but it's too Complex..

[@avinashvivekanandan5159]

Pdogg why can't we implement the retention rule in RTM like if 3 RTM is given the first RTM card will have the amount of 15 crore and the second RTM will have the 12 crore and the third RTM will be 8 crores . For example if SKY got 14 crore in auction then Mumbai need to pay RTM amount of 15 crore not the RTM 12 crore. And at the same time if SKY gets 17 crore in auction then Mumbai need to pay 17 crore not 15 crore. This is just an idea this might work out

[@aparajithsrinivasan9496]

There is no point of RTM if there is an option to outbid, instead like ash anna said the player should be able to set a base RTM price (eg 8 Cr) like the base auction price (eg 2 Cr). This will put players in the forefront and will give them the price that they think is crt. However, what happens if the last bid in the auction is less than the RTM base price set by the player. I love to hear your thoughts.

[@stormmy7554]

Then the team can retain him only at the base RTM price orelse if they want to pay less then try bidding n get him below that amt

[@baskar.s7399]

@ashwin If a team wants to use RTM than bidding should be allowed between the team that had the last bid and the team that wants to use RTM, whoever bids the highest should get the player (Other eight teams will not have the right to bid as they opted out once the last bid is completed)

[@muhammedashik9162]

Ithikkellaam oru solution thaan irukku Example:- 1)ashwin annaave csk 10 kodikku edukkuraange 2)appo vanth "RR" RTM use pannuraange Inimethaa twist 3) csk kku mattum innoru bid chance kodukkanam 4) one and only one chance csk can bid with the maximum cash if we say 18 crore 5) ingeyum RR rtm thookkiraanganaa RR kke poyidu

[@joesachin5791]

We got Indian 2 review by Ashwin before Gta 6

[@vijaykrish4684]

Every bidder will have a maximum bid limit for each player. Once rtm is used, last bidder should expose their max bid and that should again be taken back to the team who uses RTM and reconfirm if they are willing to use RTM at this price. This is the best way to run a fair competition.

[@niwashlarc4599]

How about when a team uses RTM card, the final bid will increase by 1cr. If any other team wants to break the RTM and want the player, they need to bid with extra 2cr.

[@ManiKandan-SLM]

First disadvantage - players ya tharam pirikara mari irukum , players kulla oru kasapana feel varum. Second disadvantage - Oru nalla players thappana slot ku poduvanga or nalla perform pannatha players ya first slot poduvaga Third disadvantage - etha vachi slot la piripanga, kandipa performance vachi pirika matanga😅 Do you agree with this?

[@murugu85]

One humble opinion.. everyone knows pgods 10 rtm is not option.. pls don't dwell on it for long.. pls discuss d options which mostly will happen based on ur inside knowledge

[@deepak6412]

Great "hike up" concept. Except there should be one extra rule - the team using the RTM will have one and only one chance to hike up. Let's say sunrisers use RTM for Nitesh Reddy. The bid between MI and RCB ends with 6.2 crores. SRH can use RTM but they also need to submit the "hike up" to a certain amount. They should be careful in hiking up the price. If they say hike up to 10 crores. That's it. They cannot bid further. Other teams will get option to bid higher and continue or stay away and let sunrisers take the player. This can also be used to trick other teams into biding higher - let's say a player ends bid with 4 crore but SRH doesn't need any more players but they are aware that other team definitely needs this player then they just raise the bar by 4 crores after it ends. The other team will lose a lot of money since they really need the player.

[@svishalpondy]

I agree with all the points But I suggest an RTM trick If a previous franchise use RTM Card at the last bid price, The team which bids the last should get an opportunity to bid again only once IN WHICH the franchise can hike the price which they want to pay without any threshold After which The team which used RTM should tell its ok to retain him at revised price or not For eg If ash na comes to auction the last bid was with CSK in 8 cr and RR uses RTM and CSK will get an opportunity to change the price, In that opportunity if suppose they wanted ash na at 13 cr The RR can reject or accept the proposal If rejected ASH TO CSK AT 13 CR If accepted ASH TO RR AT 13 CR ( In this way the player can get the fair value and there is equality between franchise)

[@naveenrajkarthikeyan15]

If 7 players are retained ( 5 retained + 2 RTM) then each team compulsary should retain one indian uncapped which will benifit younger players to grow

[@user-tv3mm8mq4t]

According to csk fans that one uncapped Indian youngster is dhoni

[@Mastertheblaster19]

Yeah its going to be completely difficult task for team owners in terms of Pdoggs 10 RTM suggestion, as its a MEGA auction. What ASH na said could be possibly implemented in terms of player agreement to RTM value from the existing Team. Because teams also want to warn foreigners if they are not available for complete season, players should have a point of liberty to agree or not. 4+2+2 most likely the solution to owners! 5 year period is possibly welcomed.

[@adishv518]

Pdoggs idea of 10 RTMs is great but I think there should be another condition that if the RTM is called by a franchise over the highest bidder then the auction should go on only between the highest bidder and the franchise who called RTM so the player wouldn't lose his value .........hows is that Ash Na

[@shankarats9347]

One More option we would like to see is if any team uses RTM then they must have participated in the last 3 bid(Highest) for that player. Eg : Travis Head base price in 2 Cr then if he gets last bid from DC for 7cr and if hydreabad want to Use RTM then if they are in the bid for Head in the last 3 highest bid. Else he will be sold to DC who raised for 7cr or SRH can show RTM and get Head for next highest bid which can be 7.2 Cr.

[@keerthivasan34]

Ur points are valid sir,Each and every player deserve equal rights,But pdogg says like a Andhra premier league concept is difficult one fr Ipl,If a player got 5cr bid suddenly a rtm of 14cr is impossible and every team will start to ruin other teams pursue,For that they can increase a final bid like if a player got 5cr bid and if team uses rtm they can buy him at a final price of 5.5 cr or 6 cr to get a equal for biding franchise. Retention be 3 Indians 3 r 2 foreigners 1 uncap, 2 rtm

[@harishankarvenkatesh9927]

Ashwin anna sonna rules ellam apdiye solli inthe rule ok va nu kekuringa pdogg 😂

[@chandramouli8610]

After the last bid .if u want to use RTM last + base price, that will be good for the team as well as players

[@Iem_crazerrr]

Okay..if a placer X..is at 5cr in auction.. So a Team using their RTM.. If a team wants to outbid them..then they have to give them extra 2.5cr from the last bid (so 7.5 crores).. If no team wants him at 7.5 crores then he will retained by the RTMs team.!!! If not,the auction goes on like this..?? Ash na your thoughts 🎉🎉

[@rajp9320]

They have to give the option to retain 8 players and 4 RTM cards

[@Arjun-bo9uq]

This 10 RTM rule will affect teams with more marquee players as they would be in a situation to pick atleast 2 players in 15 cr slab...this rule should be equipped with an icon player for each team..but the 4 retention 2 rtm rule would be perfect since it has worked for years

[@agathiyankolhi]

Bro RCB best playing 11 01.( Devdutt Padikkal 02. Kl Rahul (C). Opener) 03. (KOLHI 04. Nishan kishan (wk). Middle order 05. Patidar. ]✓ 06. Maxwell. ]✓spin destroyer 07. Rinku sigh. ] ✓ 08. Rashid khan ]✓ finishers 09.Acher 10. Stark 11. Siraj COACH : Rahul Dravid Heat coach Mentor : Dinesh Karthik Bating coach : chirs Gayle Bowling Coach :Dale Steyn Fielding coach : Mr 360

[@rajavel4728]

Ash Anna plese read this I hope you might like this For example starc is been retained by KKR by rtm for 10cr after being bidden by 2 teams like mi and pbks with mi being highest bidder for 10cr and after kkr announced to use rtm, the auctioneer should ask how much max money u want to buy Starc and for example if they (mi) said 18 cr is max then KKR should use rtm for 18cr only or else they should give him to mi, So by that the player gets fair value the franchise gets satisfied and time is also saved Ash anna please see this

[@balamukunthasaravanan4295]

That's why RTM is called a steal

[@rakshith.a.p.8977]

Maxwell in RCB or not tell me pdogg sir and ash anna

[@happysad4828]

Therinji enna panna pora moodevi 😂

[@kriyadarshana9623]

@@happysad4828😂😂 mass daaa bro

[@kriyadarshana9623]

@@happysad4828moodevi ultimate

[@bhaskarteja1997]

No bro rcb will release Maxwell before next year ipl 2025

[@SN-xk4cn]

In home ground like gt , pbks matches the crowd will be less in the stadium , but when dhoni arives the whole stadium gets housefull , so the tickets has been sold in higher prices and revenues are aquired by bcci

[@Sriramh7297]

I loved the ending but not the idea, of RTM , For me 5 retention with or without RTM with three indians and two foreinger . They can use all the retention if they need or They can retain any number less than 5, and for example if they retain 4 with three indians and one foreigner they can use only one RTM, that too with one foreigner. The main rule in the RTM should be every player who played in the IPL, should say the highest amount he feels is right should say to IPL governing council, And the RTM should be used if the auction bid is at least 80% of the highest bid. For example if bumrah say My highest bid amount is 30cr then the RTM should be used if the auction bid is reaches 24cr and above. Even if the auction bid closed at 23.5 then also no RTM is applicable. I think this would be a better idea.

[@madhankumar212]

Congratulations ash anna❤❤❤ Tnpl Champion

[@harithehulk_]

Ash anna seems to ignore the fact that there will be multiple teams pushing the fair price for a player. Add to this Pdoggs point on Teams ensuring the original team not being able to exploit RTM by hiking price, RTM doesn't really bring a players price down by much.

[@s.praveenkumar1498]

Travis head explosive opener 🔥🔥🔥🔥 in all three formats

[@dineshgokuldasm7887]

The concept of 10 RTM's is a genius one. I have a suggestion to it the team can go for RTM only if they were the last second bidder to the player or maybe they could be in one of the few most recent bids for the player, the number of bids is debatable. I feel it might make franchises to compete more on the auction table.

[@karthikeyan-wp6mb]

I reckoned SRH approached Pdogg for Analyst position. 🤔 💭. The way he has been talking for last two programs.

[@subashbrock]

Ash Anna on yellow jersey is what we want for the upcoming ipl auction csk(ipl)💛dd(tnpl) Kasi thatha please bid for ash na pride for tn 🙏

[@Mukeshraja0007]

When a team take rtm on a player the final money what he had bidded by the another team has to be increased by some percentage like 20%, 30%

[@siddhaarthl9884]

Having 10 RTMs is just crazy, one problem is that you can't predict which players will go for which team except for a three or four. Also we have to understand that people require time to process through a change. If such drastic rules are brought in, we can get to see a disparity in the understanding of auction dynamics among team owners where some teams will end up picking better players and might kill the competition considering it is a mega auction and the core will be reatined for the next three to five years. Hence any change should be incremental and should be brought in a phased manner rather than something groundbreaking.

[@about_srii]

HELLO ASHWIN ANNA BY AVOID RTM CONCEPT 6 RETENTION 4 INDIANS 2 FOREIGNERS IT'LL MAKE MORE SPICY IN AUCTION MORE THAN 6 RETENTION DOESN'T MAKE MEGA AUCTION CONCEPT IS THIS OKAY OR ANYTHING ELSE

[@ramanathanmeyyappan1212]

What Ashwin saying is correct..in Rtm ..even after rtm bidding needs to continue..then only player get correct value

[@saiharir3385]

Ash anna talk about how india want to improve in olympics. I know you definetely tough to talk about this but its useful for poor people

[@srimukesh8242]

5 Retention, 1RTM, maybe 3 indian players and 2 overseas players (or) 3 overseas players and 2 indian players according to ipl teams, but not more than 3 indian players (or) 3 overseas players

[@user-sn7ri6us1u]

Which players will retained by the teams, using 5 retentions and 2 rtms. Make a video about that ash anna

[@kbswork2882]

Feel for you ASH anna.. I can see the emotion when pdogg broh mentioned about Head .

[@patrioticpersonal6639]

I really agreed with pdogg suggestions. His Idea is definitely good for players and help those team has a need for opportunity to strengthen their team. It gives more exiting for viewers also everybody makes more sensitive.

[@vijaym3667]

Why does Pdogg's look remind me of Shashi Tharoor?

[@NITNIK]

CSK 5 Retention 1. Rutu 2. Sir Jadeja 3. MSD 4. Pathirana 5. Conway RTM - Dube , Theekshana

[@iplfan9143]

The whole point of RTM is to tell the player that the team who owns them is paying the highest possible price that 'other teams' are willing to pay for him. It is as simple as that. This is mainly to 'protect the player' from the franchise retaining him for a below par value as it happened with Ruthuraj for CSK, Narine/Rusell for KKR etc. I am very surprised that Ashwin doesn't seem to get this.

[@shankarats9347]

One More option we would like to see is if any team uses RTM then they must have participated in the last 3 bid(Highest) for that player. Eg : Travis Head base price in 2 Cr then if he gets last bid from DC for 7cr and if hydreabad want to Use RTM then if they are in the bid for Head in the last 3 highest bid. Else he will be sold to DC who raised for 7cr or SRH can show RTM and get Head for next highest bid which can be 7.2 Cr.😊

[@karthikjega6594]

Or it can be like this After RTM is exercised The bidding war should be only between the team with final bid and the team which used RTM

[@atulbalaji1321]

I feel for RTM concept, there should not be another bidding war. If Team A buys player X, and team B does RTM on it, then team A should be allowed to put down a final price. If team B wishes to exercise RTM, then they should pay that final price, otherwise team A buys that player for the final price.

[@kalamsachin24]

7:40 10RTM laa nadakathunu therium kolapama nadakiratha discuss pannunga please 😊

[@badboy0749]

My Retain 6 players 💛CSK🦁👑IPL 2025 will be like 1.Ruttu 2.Jaddu 3.dube 4.Thala 5.✈️ pathirana 6.✈️Rachin

[@siddharthvenkat7920]

Semma exciting idea proposed by PDogg from 03:44... Adha apdiyae lock panni 10 RTMs badhilaa 5 RTMs only-nu panna mass-aa irukkum! 🙏🏾

[@balajip5347]

I completely go with Pdogg sir

[@sivavisagan4232]

IPL is now only for brand value and franchise pride .. but the actual winning formula of IPL is making a strong youngsters core ( uncapped ) .. and building the team for next 5 years .. like what mi did in 2018 .. where anukul roy , rahul chahar , sky , ishan were set the core for next 6 years ...none of the team is concentrating on this idea

[@harishramesh2110]

I would say pdogg idea is good 0 retention 10 rtm and rtm slabs and a player should be given a choice to set his minimum rtm salary cap for example dube knows that he can get upto 7-8 cr so he will set his minimum rtm cap at 7.5cr so if the player crosses this amount then only you can use rtm

[@kvmoorthy83]

The IPL auction need to start fresh, players from the mini auction has changed the dynamics of composure and team dynamics. I would suggest to go back to the first Auction where the teams had a Icon Player. IPL governing body should form a list of 10 Iconic players, the teams can have the existing player as Iconic or have a mock auction for bidding the remaining players in the list. Kohli, Rohit, Bumrah, Dhoni, Pant are some of the Icons

[@hemanth5610]

Intha ipl auction ehh vendam summa football maari tranfer and singnings maariye players ehh edukalam like bbl

[@ar.elamparithielangovan]

Old Bitting is Better... I agree with Ashwin When RTM is intiated... Last bidding franchise will finalize the last bid value... For Example if ASHWIN goes in last bid of 6 crores for mumbai... When RTM taken by RR.. MUMBAI having option for 1 final max Bid as 8 crores.. If RR still intrested they have retained for 8 crores otherwise MUMBAI have to give 8 crores to take ASHWIN in thier team... I think this is the best option This will create a option for b

[@satishs5097]

With due respect, RTMs are like auction manipulative strategies which are generally unfair to the player/franchise/auction process. Maximum 5-6 retentions should be allowed and a mega auction once in every 5 years would be a fair process and would even out the teams while giving them a chance to retain their core group (5-6) players.

[@harikishan3315]

if franchises are allowed to outbid after the RTM is called, them the purpose of RTM is lost. Ithuku keep an minimum RTM amount. Let's say rtm base for faf is set at 3cr, if the auction bid is only 2cr, still rtm should be for 3cr. But in case the auction bid is 4.5cr, them rtm will be for 4.5c

[@giridharsekar51]

My proposed RTM rule is, that the franchise should declare at the start of the bidding for a given player an "intent to match". Other franchises can then bid appropriately and set the fair price for the player. The franchise can then decide based on the final price if they want to execute the "intent to match" or withdraw if the price is too high and forfeit their RTM. In which case it goes to the highest bidder. In this case competing franchises can operate with a clear idea that this player will be matched and force the franchise to pay fair market value. The spirit of RTM should be that a franchise can retain a key player while paying fair market value for them. It is not for franchises to get "steals".

[@dheenadayalan871]

Yethuku RTM aa ivlo confuse pannitu irukenga . auction la outbid pannanum na aprm ethuku RTM option kudukanum? Just keep it simple , players auction list ku register pannumbothu last aa oru option add pannikonga , do you agree your current franchise to use RTM on you no matter what the auction bid is ? Which means , base price aa irunthalum sari or 25crs aa irunthalum sari ennoda current franchise team ku naa play Panna aasai padren without considering my auction bid. If the players disagree to use RTM then the current franchise does not have the rights to go for RTM on him , he must be selected in bid.

[@anandakumar4948]

@Ashwin I really like pdogg suggestion.. if they go with this idea , auction would be more entertaining than actual game (mind game) 😊

[@TyrerellRG7]

Pdogg 👌🔥. Ash anna solradhu correct than. Players ku fair values kedaikanum👏

[@sriramiyer4612]

Would like to disagree with the suggestion of auction to be continued despite an RTM.Then what's the point of the RTM ? Maybe ,they could have a financial penalty where a certain amount of additional purse money is deducted if a team wants to use the RTM. Or maybe have a generic formula where if a team is to use RTM they need to pay an additional 2 cr for eg. Example RTM is done at 6 then the team should pay 8 if they are utilizing the RTM

[@Syed-iu2ps]

"PDogg, what you're saying is correct, but IPL owners are quite clever. They often come to a mutual understanding about which players they plan to buy using the Right to Match (RTM) option during the auction. Since they are investing a lot of money, the owners minimize their risk, but this strategy could potentially disadvantage the players, as it might limit their opportunities to be bought at higher prices by other teams. Please understand that the loss could be more significant for the players than for the owners."

[@kaushikka]

The teams should submit a secret market bid of potential RTM players. Eg: CSK should submit their market value of Shivam Dube in a secret bid to BCCI before mega auctions. This figure is 12cr for example which is equivalent to second slab if the player is retained. Suppose MI wins the bid for Shivam at 10cr. And if CSK chooses to use RTM then Shivam will be sold to CSK at 12cr as that is the market value CSK is convenient to buy him. IPL can invite secret bids of 5 players from each franchise if 2 RTMS are given.

[@pkj3787]

MY RTM RULE : If Ash na picked for 2.5CR in AUCTION with CSK RR wants Ash in the team , then 1 RTM will be closed for RR and Bids starts from 2.5CR with CSK AND RR alone (End price decides between the two franchise alone )