Is alcohol forbidden in Judaism?

[@WeyardWiz]

Yes, your question to us at the end is answered by Quran:: "With vessels, pitchers and a cup [of wine] from a flowing spring, No headache will they have therefrom, nor will they be intoxicated"[56:18-19] The type of wine in heaven is described in multiple verses in the Quran to be a different wine than earthly wine. the wine in heaven for example is described in another verse as delicious unlike the bittern taste of the earthly wine, as well as pure unlike the intoxication that the earthly wine causes "There will be circulated among them a cup [of wine] from a flowing spring, White and delicious to the drinkers; No bad effect is there in it, nor from it will they be intoxicated." [37:45-47]

[@rjnm6697]

Weyard Wiz don’t know what wine you’re drinking cause the wine I have isn’t bitter.

[@ReformMsia]

Weyard Wiz If a person drinks wine with no feeling of intoxicating can he/she still consume it ?

[@aboubilal4614]

Interpretation of the Meanings of The Noble Quran 5. Surah Al-Ma'idah (The Table Spread with Food) 90. O you who believe! Intoxicants (all kinds of alcoholic drinks), gambling, Al-Ansab , and Al-Azlam (arrows for seeking luck or decision) are an abomination of Shaitan's (Satan) handiwork. So avoid (strictly all) that (abomination) in order that you may be successful . 91. Shaitan (Satan) wants only to excite enmity and hatred between you with intoxicants (alcoholic drinks) and gambling, and hinder you from the remembrance of Allah and from As-Salat (the prayer). So, will you not then abstain? www.noblequran.com/translation/

[@adeajja2252]

You know what,,, u got no idea to quote this verse. WE TALK ABOUT WINE IS FORBIDDEN OR NOT! that verse talk about any pleasure that u get in paradise and it is actually out of topic.

[@adeajja2252]

@@ReformMsia BIG NO,,, THE PROBLEM IS NOT A BIT OR MUCH. BUT U SHOULD STAY AWAY FROM WINE PERIOD

[@dkff321]

Alcohol was forbidden gradually as revealed in the Quran. The earlier verses revealed to Prophet Muhammad PBUH commanded the followers not to be intoxicated while praying and gradually it was forbidden as it has been cited to be harmful than being of benefit. I am not a scholar but this is what I understand when I read the Quran. Thanks for this amazing platform for mutual understanding of our Abrahamic faith.

[@DarkerObed]

Allah is the devil

[@dkff321]

Odogg based on your ignorant research.

[@ebrimajawneh6918]

@@DarkerObed You're company of satan

[@nazdabner2685]

Muslims not allowed to drink it’s forbidden it’s totally haram. Not allowed. If your addict you slowly come of it.

[@TheRIZeffect]

Very nice explanation. I love how you incorporate Islamic ideologies in a respectful manner.

[@saifulissam636]

Yes, prophet Muhammad had never drank wine at all in his lifetime. However last time, before the forbidden of the drinking of alcohol and other stuffs like smoking druggy leaves and fruits that can cause drunk, Prophet Muhammad's close friends had used to drink wine and such like when his friend Umar Al-Khattab said he used to drink before. Then when the instruction from God to forbid drinking alcohol and to become drunk, then his friends and people at the market poured and threw the wines onto the ground and never to drink again.

[@alexmathew6786]

We are not relation between Muhammad

[@DSMDomo]

Alhamdulillah! What timing you made the video lol! Me and my friend were just talking about like: "I wonder I see Jews drink wine but I don't know if its written in their Old testament for it to be allowed, or is it just through time with their culture/tradition they chose to drink it?" Then 20 minutes later you made this video. What great timing! And Great video and explanation like usual! :)

[@vasanthi1439]

Do jews sacrifice lambs for atonement for sins guilt offering grain offering and other offerings as mentioned in the torah

[@MisrakBereket]

In Genesis the first person who ever was recorded to get drunk was Noah and it explained how alchol leads to shame. I always found how advanced the people in the Torah were astonishing the fact that yoseph could write the colored coat biblical people are so advanced how much smarter and wiser they were.

[@ReformMsia]

What a great 👍 presentation ! Bravo 👏 Before Allah sent the commandments muslim use to drink Alcoholic. When they got drunk they neglected to perform the ibadah required. So this why Allah sent the prohibition of taking things which will intoxicate you Intoxicating : - alcohol - drugs - etc

[@abc_6]

Agreed 😌👏

[@CocoSpuzzillo]

I wondered because I serve alcohol for hasidic jewish ceremonies but didn’t want to seem disrespectful by asking! Thanks for the video of information ☺️

[@MuhammadZubair-js8og]

Nice explanation. We Muslims are forbidden to consume intoxicants. Also there is a verse saying we shouldn’t approach prayer while intoxicated. There is a Hadith stating a person who gets intoxicated his prayer is not accepted for 40 days from the point of intoxication.

[@magichobbiest3425]

I don't even remember my prayer 😩

[@themname9392]

What is imaan (belief)? Answer 1. To believe in oneness of Allah 2. To believe in all prophets of Allah 3 To believe in angels of Allah 4. To believe in books of Allah 5 To believe in day of judgement 6. To believe in desitiny Good or bad

[@mrmm7322]

It’s amazing. That. Most of your followers are Muslim s not Jews does that tell you something

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Mr M M yes that is really interesting. I think it's probably has to do with the fact that what I'm saying most Jews already know this about their religion so it's not interesting for them to hear it again.

[@themname9392]

Because jews are about 20 millions and Muslim are about 1.8 billion

Them Name so what the hell is that supposed to mean

[@yakovisaacs6441]

Most Jews will outright reject the views of the Rabbi in the video and consider them ill-informed and heresy.

[@ashiqueaash5002]

Blessed is HaShem, the G-d of Israel.Iam Muslim I would like to learn more about Jew religion so I need your help..

[@mesumali1859]

Hello i m muslim and i like ur video.. Its really nice and sightful

[@leahkatsumi6829]

Well.... as far as i know not only judaism allows people to drink but it kinda urges people to drink too. Like every holiday there are always wine and every shabat too. In purim, you must stay all day drinking and you’re spected to get drunk.

[@faizoorrahman196]

I agree that wine 🍷 was forbidden during the time of Prophet Muhammadh ( PBUH ). At first Muslims were allowed to drink alcohol. Then Allah said in Quran that consuming alcohol during the prayer is prohibited. Later in Quran, consumption of alcohol is completely prohibited and Muslims are not allowed to drink alcohol at any time.

[@coreybalsano7334]

Its true. The legal rulings regarding alcohol were revealed in 3 stages in the Quran. First it was permitted, then the ruling to not come to prayer drunk until sober, then to stay away from it all together. Although the Quran acknowledges the benefits of wine it says the harm outweighs the benefits therefore it would be better to refrain until paradise from the Quranic morals. Hence for all Muslims its absolutely forbidden ever since. Also a side note, the Prophet Muhammad (S) never drank wine even when it was permitted.

[@JahidHasan-ne3uu]

Brother, are you a Muslim?

[@aguscahyono9692]

Alcohol wasnt forbiden in the first decade of Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) preaching of Islam in Mecca. But Moslem at the time was not allowed to have prayed when intoxicated. Alcohol was begin to prohibited, in second decade in Medina. So basically in Islamic view, God didn't forbid people of the book (Jew or Christian) before the prophethood of Muhammad (peace be upon him) to drink alcohol.

[@willbergie55]

It gives me a headache just thinking about alcohol.

[@hayatullahrahmatzai9839]

you are such a great connector between Judaism and Islam. you have a balanced, moderate and nice approach towards important issues.

[@EkAks]

Muslims humbly request you to say ‘Peace be upon him’ when you speak of Prophet Mohammad (sallay alahu alaihi wassalm). The Muslims are very keen on saying ‘alahis sallam’ , same as ‘peace be upon him’ to all the Prophets. For example, just to name a few such as Abraham, Moses, Solomon, David ( peace be upon all of them) who came before Prophet Mohammad( sallay alahu alaihi wassalm). Wishing you the best. Shalom brother. 🌻

[@fairusfedder7206]

As a practising muslim, to the best of my knowledge, alcohol was forbidden at some point after prophet Muhammad pbuh Hijrah to Medinah from Mecca. So prior to that some sahabah of the prophet did consume alcohol. And fyi, alcohol and other stuff that can make us loose our ability to think is considered Haram. This includes drugs. Thank you.

[@markusgarcia4136]

Not drinking alcohol is a real feat nowadays but something that sets you apart in a good way.

[@malenedietl3369]

Shalom alechem assalamu aleikum dear Rabbi. I'm not a scholar, but I heard that the sahaba, followers of Muhammad, peace and blessing be upon him, were drinking alcohol in Mecca and also for a period after the migration to Medina, untill one day it was prohibited, because now the muslims were in a safe place, away from their enemies in Mecca and there was not the same pressure of fear, persecution and stress, so therefore no reason to drink to calm rhe nerves and forget a little the troubles. So everyone emptied their winecontainers into the streets of Medina. So much wine was there that the streets were flowing with wine. That is what I heard according to hadith. And Allah knows best.

[@christianprince4508]

Leviticus 10:9 “Drink no wine or strong drink, you or your sons with you, when you go into the tent of meeting, lest you die. It shall be a statute forever throughout your generations.

[@TK77718]

Ecclesiasticus 31:27 “Wine is as good as life to a man, if it be drunk moderately: what life is then to a man that is without wine? for it was made to make men glad.”

[@christianprince4508]

@@TK77718 A similitude of the Garden which those who keep their duty (to Allah) are promised: Therein are rivers of water unpolluted … and rivers of wine delicious to the drinkers. Surah 47:15

[@christianprince4508]

@@TK77718 Surely the pious will be in bliss … their thirst will be slaked with pure wine sealed. Surah 83:22,25

[@christianprince4508]

@@TK77718 There will be circulated among them a cup [of wine] from a flowing spring, White and delicious to the drinkers; No bad effect is there in it, nor from it will they be intoxicated. (Surah 37:45-47)

[@sunset2.00]

You sbowed the bad effect but the good effects worth it.Many marriages got ruined for consuming alcohol.

[@newworldorder6764]

not using but abusing, you can not get drunk from one cup of some alcohol beverege.

[@alec4547]

Jazāk Allāhu Khayran

[@p_9220]

You don’t really know how much alcohol makes you uncontrollable

[@AdilElhajEljack]

In Islam Wine is forbidden in steps; but now little wine is forbidden as more. Some clerks say that if you a convert to Islam or Muslim whose addicted or used to drinking wine you can quit step by step.

[@vinitaw8219]

Amazing explanation. Thank you so much🙏

[@dustindaniel4973]

I was in search for an explanation of whether kosher, like halal, meant "no alcohol." I believe you did answer my inquiry because cooking with food according to Jewish law wouldn't relelitively cause disobedience to the commandments and there for it could be used in food. As a layman, a philosophy and religious studies major, and former Judeo Christian, I would like to contribute to the discussion started by your question, if I may? First, with a position widely agreed by sunni islamic scholars: One of the wisdoms to why Muhammad (Peace and Blessings be upon Him and may his Allah be pleased with His family and companions, Ameen) chose milk, was because wine only quenches the mind, while milk quenches thirst and satiates the belly. So, there was practicality, in addition to the complete Devine intervention, with His (PBUH) decision. Wine and the Pleasures of of this world compared to the wine and pleasures of this life is a whole other convo and depends on how one hopes and engages in this limited, ever changing, ferocious, time sensitive, and disappointing worldly life. Now, while wine, like gambling, has benefit, the bad of alcohol has always, by large, out weighed the good, which every Prophet (Peace be upon Them All), even before Muhammad (PBUH), has held this position of alcohol being an absolute threat to dignity, leniage, family, the brain, and society. This would logically rule out any ambiguity, grey areas, or relativity. Subsequently, there would be no reason a Prophet would need to quench his mind (or risk walking on the boundaries) since Allah has made his Prophets infallible , determined and focused: fully submit with unwavering faith. They knew there purpose and there connection to Allah was infallible which would make them the best of creation. They were told to relay the message clear and precise, and never was there ambiguity, or relativity with Allah's prohibitions. We only speak and believe the best word spoken of Them, which is why any scriptures that slander the Prophets would be dismissed and considered changed due to translations or conspiracy. I hope this contributes constructively to this 2 year old discussion. Any mistakes I pray Allah corrects them and forgives me. I'd like to hear your feed back about my conclusions drawn about Jewish law, alcohol in food, and Islamic position to whether alcohol was prohibited prior to the prophethood of Muhammad (PBUH). Thank you so much, Your Brother through Humanity, Cousin by faith.

[@dustindaniel4973]

Disobedience to the commandments is what I meant: Not social disruption.

[@TK77718]

Ecclesiasticus 31:27 “Wine is as good as life to a man, if it be drunk moderately: what life is then to a man that is without wine? for it was made to make men glad.”

[@Ooooiops]

In Quran alcohol not forbidden clearly but it’s written it’s not good & not allowed to pray while drunk & to leave it because it’s making people fighting but there’s no forbidden word (Haram) for alcohol But the Muslims Shiekhs said it’s haram/forbidden

[@babanana6318]

No its said is haram in the quran and not shieks

[@salahali2710]

يا أيها الذين امنوا إنما الخمر و الميسر والأنصاب و الأزلام رجس من عمل الشيطان فجتنبوه لعلكم تفلحون

[@manasanapaka279]

I m new here . Love ur videos . I think it s interesting & i hope i can learn hebrew in the future

[@mrmm7322]

Alcohol is forbidden in all relageines. And you know that well even in cristians religion is forbidden because for the same reasons that said. It bring us to do bad things and things are forbidden so if the fax is forbidden why the title is not forbidden remanded you that. The fax is based on the title you understand me I know you do Good luck

[@mancerayder7687]

They bring wine to the Church

[@AshrafAnam]

It seems intoxicants/alcohol is not Haram in the Jewish Shari'a, but Makruh. It's like crabs and shrimps, they are Makruh for us but Haram for them.

[@irfaanhassan]

Shalom Aleicheim Rabin, Regarding your view on wine in the bible, i would like you to do some research on "Ergot Wine" a drink popular by Romans, Greeks and vikings, A part of me always feels that wine was more risky to drink during that time than now, these days , you can order a glass of sweet merlot for example, do you think that "ergot wine" could have or would have been known since before the time of Babylon, Thats how i always defend the mention of wine in Toirah and in Q'ura'an.."Good wine Vs Bad wine" Todah Raba, Ma'asalaama'

[@dontsweatthesmallstuff.618]

Yes Muslims know alcohol was not forbidden pre islam

[@johnirby8847]

Alcohol has importance to Christianity...wine and bread are taken as the body and blood of Christ. Even when alcohol was prohibited in the US...wine was still used for that purpose. I've never met anyone that stole church wine and got drunk but it has happened in history. It is not good but no one gets in trouble. The priest or minister might be angry but they would try to help the person.

[@greenhouse3801]

Being Muslim my self i like his video

[@MUSTAFAXII]

The alcoholic part

[@rick91443]

My question for the learned Muslim, perhaps Mr. Wiz deals with why alcohol was so prevalent in Europe; the water wasn't drinkable! Beer and cider's alcohol content permitted the liquid to be stored and somewhat purified it. "Drinking water" in large cities and concentrated rural areas just wasn't to be trusted; hence, you drank cider or beer...How did the early Muslims, who, had even LESS natural water, get around this, and what a hefty testament to their faith! Shalom/cheers...rr Normandy

[@wingoal6959]

There was an incident during the time of prophet (s.a.w) an imam lead prayer where he was toxicated and in his intoxication he read the words wrong in prayer then that situation was brought before prophet and then God almighty sent down his word thru Gabriel (jibraeel a.s) to prophet(s.a.w) not to drink since then it was prohibitated but wasnt till the early times of prophecy of (s.a.w).

[@woodstalon1881]

How bout a weed, i'm really curious of about that. can you explained it?

[@Llyllpuria]

thanks, that helps a lot to know more about Abrahamic religions.

[@rockbottom1014]

Can you prove Islam came from Abraham?

[@abc_6]

@@rockbottom1014 Yes Islam came when Adam pbuh came since by definition Islam means submission to god and he the prophet Adam did do just that. This suggests that Islam is the oldest religion and here’s proof for that; m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/bKHIoYqbjqiAlZI

[@rockbottom1014]

@@abc_6 It’s not mentioned as a religion in The Bible. Islam is not even a Hebrew word. Nothing about Islam is in The Holy Bible. The religion of Islam was made up by mohammad

[@abc_6]

@@rockbottom1014 ur religion is nowhere to be found in ur scripture whereas mine Islam is mentioned in the Quran, do ur research the respected rabbi admitted that mine is an ancient religion and much older than any other abrahamic religion What’s ur religion?

[@abc_6]

@@rockbottom1014 u asked a direct question in the beginning and i answered it truthfully, instead u wanna now get into a debate tactic since I exposed that Islam is the oldest huh?

[@MJAli89]

In Islam, no drinking alcohol in this life, however in the next life in Jannah (heaven), drink for eternity.

[@manojsingha9439]

Shalom Aleikum... Sir I have been following you for last month. Your video are on depth to erase the misconception we have between Abrahamic religion. I have one query with you sir. Why number of atheist increasing from the Jewish community, and it really sadden me when folks leave the rope of GOD ALMIGHTY.

[@repentance1748]

Your videos are very interesting. Good job

[@AzamatBagatov413]

I wanted to know if shooting journalists is prohibited in Judaism?

[@user-dw2yr5df4g]

Azamat Bagatov What sort of stupid question is that, have you never looked into the 10 Commandments?

[@clashofchampsoo2697]

@Ricky Reynaldi Awsome answer

[@rosapril3398]

Don't make stupid comments And don't put jewsish religon in box because of the actions of some jew We don't accepted of Islam so don't do it back to other religions

[@Starbreaker2012]

Thank you. Very helpful. Jesus said at the last supper he would not drink again of the fruit of the vine until he was in heaven. What we should consider is not just the impairment of our following the 613 mitzvot, but that we are to be a light to the world. Therefore, not only is it a question of being able to 'handle our drink', but to account for any provocation by the world and/or evil. Sometimes we have to abide by laws such as not to drink drive for example, because collectively so many people have otherwise underestimated the influence of alcohol and the potential danger from those that believe they are in control

[@Johnywang1]

i def can see what your saying about alcohol being allowed before the quran was revealed. as a muslim it is our faith to live our lives as close to the morality and actions of the prophets. no prophet (from my recollection) has ever drank wine or alchohol. so even if it was allowed, the prophets didnt partake in the substance.

[@JUSLOFI]

Haris Bokhari If many Prophets (pbut) were Israelites, they drank wine during the Passover Seder.

[@Salah-vg4tn]

Wine was not prohibited in early years. The prohibition came later and gradually.

[@Gambitheart]

Yes wine wasn't forbidden before Islam.

[@zulkiflirazak6206]

Good. Thank you for ur explaination.

[@abdirahmanmahamed5164]

Those who follow the Messenger the unlettered prophet whom they find written in what they have of the Torah and the Gospel who enjoins upon them what is right and forbids them what is wrong and makes lawful for them the good things and prohibits for them the evil and relieves them of their burden and the shackles which were upon them So they who have believed in him honored him supported him and followed the light which was sent down with him - it is those who will be the successful ( Quran 7:157 )

[@ibrahimabdullah7793]

IN SHORT WORDS ,IT'S NOT GOOD TO DRINK ALCOHOL FOR A RELIGIOUS PERSON WHO PRAY 3 TIMES A DAY OR 5 TIMES A DAY, I PERSON ALL I THINK ALCOHOL IS MOTHER OF ALL EVILS,

[@AshrafAnam]

It seems intoxicants/alcohol is not Haram in the Jewish Shari'a, but Makruh. It's like crabs and shrimps, they are Makruh for us but Haram for them.

[@Ooooiops]

Ashraf Anam crabs not makkruh in sunni but Shia only

[@AshrafAnam]

@@Ooooiops crabs are Makruh according to the Hanafi fiqh

[@darinedahu]

@@AshrafAnam @Elegant im a Muslim I dont like to identify with any sect. after doing my own research and I am not a scholar by any means only my opinion , my reasoning tells me that crab would be Haram forbiden in Islam and its not why you are thinking. but I would say it is Haram not because its a crab but because the way the crab is cooked, it is boiled ALIVE and that is torture to the crab and Allah ( subhanaho wa ta3ala) forbids us from torturing animals before eating them!!! Swift cut!! what do you guys think about this thought!! please let me know.

[@darinedahu]

@@Ooooiops read above

[@MurtajaBarbhuiya]

We Muslims Beleive In All The Prophets Who Came Before Prophet Muhammad SAW Like Adam Noah Ibrahim Mosses Jesus(peace be upon them all) and We also beleive in Torah Zabur Injil..Allah Mentioned These Books In Quran Thats Why We Beleive..Allah Also Says He Sent Books On Every Age But Mentioned Only 4...And Our Beloved Prophet Muhammad SAW Said That There Were 124K Messengers Were Sent On The Face Of The Earth By Name Only 25 Are Mentioned In Quran.Among 25 Majority Were Jews...And Prophet Also Said All The Prophets Who Came Before Him i.e Before Muhammad(pbuh) They Were Only Meant For A Particular Place And Their Message Was Supposed To Be Followed For A Particular Time Period..But The Final Messanger Prophet Muhammad Was Not Sent Only For Arabs or Muslims infact Allah Says In Quran He Has Sent Muhammad(pbuh) As a Mercy To The Whole Of Humanity..And Quran To Be Followed Till The Judgement Day..

[@judaism1505]

Agree brother good job

[@jaredini]

Hang around a haredi/orthodox community during Purim....... yup, alcohol is very heavily consumed

[@moorooster223]

alcohol is more harshly criticized in islamic hadith than in Quran. there is one verse that undoubtedly says alcohol and gambling is forbidden, but there are other verses that are more complex. like one says "with alcohol and gambling there is great benefit, but the wrong outweighs the benefit" or another verse in chapter 4 saying if you are drunk wait until you are sober to pray, which mirrors what you said about Jews not being allowed to pray drunk. this being said I believe alcohol is forbidden for Muslims and for Jews as well, for all intents and purposes. you see this in verses of the Tanakh like Ephesians 5:18 "And do not get drunk with wine, for that is dissipation, but be filled with the Spirit," or Proverbs 20:1 "Wine is a mocker, strong drink a brawler, And whoever is intoxicated by it is not wise." etc, etc. there are actually quite a few examples from proverbs. but yeah as you can see alcohol is a complex topic in Tanakh or Quran, but it is discouraged and has been since before the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him was born.

[@TK77718]

You are decieved

[@TheWilly5514]

Shalom Rabbi. I have many question to you. 1. I know in judaism have kosher wine. How much percentage of alcohol in kosher wine? Is Kosher wine in present day same with ancient kosher wine especially in alcohol percentage. 2. Is in jewish wedding day alcohol allowed? How much it can be consume? 3. How maximum percentade of alcohol and dosage wich allowed consumed by jews? That is my question. I hope you answer my question

[@user-dw2yr5df4g]

TheWilly5514 Sorry to answer on behalf of another, but kosher wine is a similar percentage in alcohol to normal wine, it's kosher for pesach. It would be interesting to know whether the ancestors had it pure or watered down.

[@TheWilly5514]

what percentage is it ? Is kosher wine usually mixed with water?

[@MrBears25]

If you can’t violate the law while drunk I’d say drinking alcohol is prohibited; I personally think it’s a sin because Alcohol is essentially poison the body can tolerate to a degree. I have to ask if smoking Western commercial cigarettes is a sin?

[@syedarsalahmed8936]

Yes sir, alcohol was permitted before Muhammad came, but became forbidden after that... Containers of alcohol were thrown out in Arabia... We believe that anything that harms in large quantities should not be consumed even in small quantities because it's very difficult to draw the line!

[@alnahian1796]

yes anyone could drink wine or alcohol before Muhammad (s) he became a prophet. I don't know the validity of this story but it goes on like this somebody was drunk and came to prayer and said something wrong and then this commandment was bestowed upon Muslim

[@nexusadministration8958]

Which do you believe is better: 1) to allow mankind the freedom to consume alcohol when it is the cause of so much spiritual, societal and physical harm and human suffering (eg. violence, rape, drinking and driving related deaths, alcoholism, addiction, oral cancer, fetal alcohol sydrome and the destruction of entire communities such as aboriginal communities of North america and australia etc., etc.) or 2) to ban it for all humankind (except as a disinfectant).

[@Suhaylan]

The Torah written from their pocket says alcohol not prohibited. The Quran says they write from their pocket and say it is from God Almighty for Jews HaShem. 😁

[@MariaSilva-sp8wr]

woww! I'm Christian but I learned a lot! Thank you sir. What about women that want to get closer to God? What would they have to do?

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Good question. I'm not sure if women can also become Nazir.

[@rantube369.]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 I'm Muslim ...but allow me to ad one thing ...Mary the mother of Jesus was so devoted to God..so don't you think woman and men are equal infront of the creator... I would like to ad one thing ,thank you for the Video... In the Quran...I was shocked when you say in prayer no alcohol..it's exactly the verse in the Quran... The Quran also mentions a verse that grapes give us something useful. And the word can mean wine in arabic ( sakar),also another verse says wine has benefits and sin at the same time,then another verse says gambling and wine is rejes from shaitan which means something not pure as a deseive from shaitan,and then then it says in arabic so avoid it,the word in arabic avoid so God didn't use the word forbid,but implies for that. All Hadith is narration ..which could not be so true or 100 percent true stories. I told you what the Quran says ,which is a holy book which God said in it that will be preserved to be true. In brief I could say ,we are so semilar .which is logic. But there is little differences .for example the stoning to adultery is not in the Quran... Only in the narrated Hadith which could be not true to great extent. The Quran is amazing ,it's like amystery,and if you really try to discover it,you will realise that we are brothers and sisters and God love us all.and God is merciful .

[@pisalivorno2325]

Come on guys Try to understand what he is saying. The Secret he is talking about might be he don't know and he is saying what other Rabbi's Saying. But what he is saying this is Unbelievable to understand these days. I cannot even imagine he will revel that. Don't take me wrong but if you do I really Apologize.

[@irfaanhassan]

Shalom Aleicheim Rabin, is there a way to interprate the Midrash, where whatever you may become from the four animals.. its part of satans way, maybe thats why you cant drink and pray?

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

I think the interpretation of the midrash just warns us of the dangers of becoming drunk.

[@jacobwilloughby9215]

For someone looking to convert what is the starting point?? I have been a Baptists Christian all my life. But I just agree more with the jewish religion. How should i look into it deeper?

[@HasanSarfarazKhan]

You can't convert to Judaism, Islam is your next best bet

[@jacobwilloughby9215]

Over my dead body. Not to be rude but Islamic religion is dark and pointless to me. And I have met converted Jews. So it can happen but. I would rather stick to being a Christian before resorting islam

[@HasanSarfarazKhan]

@@jacobwilloughby9215 suit yourself mate, good luck! Highly recommended this channel though, hopefully it helps you

[@owfuldev]

@@jacobwilloughby9215 you can visit channel Blogging Theology while you are learning about it here. Good luck!

[@ElMikeSpace]

From what I’ve heard and read yes it was revealed after the prophet Mohammed pbuh came or at least made more clear for the people

[@haiderilyas6253]

Brother , what Jews think about Pashtuns ?

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Haider khan from what I hear is that Pashtuns are our Israelite brothers. I think only now Jews in Israel are realizing that we have brothers living all the way in Afghanistan. They even have a Facebook group that connects Pashtuns and Jews.

[@haiderilyas6253]

Blessed is HaShem, the G-d of Israel. I think same , they have very potential as of Jews and also they are very proud of their race and many qualities, but unfortunately they haven't find a good leader who can unite them and can give them what they really deserve , btw brother can u tell me that facebook group name .

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Haider khan yes brother. "the people of israel's jirga - pashtuns and jews"

[@haiderilyas6253]

Blessed is HaShem, the G-d of Israel. Thank you my brother .

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Haider khan pleasure brother. May Hashem / Allah gather and unite all the scattered tribes of Israel.

[@themosinguy6508]

The Seventh Day Adventists don’t drink alchohol either, they’re also vegetarians

[@IftikharAli-it2yi]

Yes you are right . Alcohol was forbidden in the later years of Muhammad's( PBUH) life. There is evidence that Before that, his companions used to drink wine. Muhammad PBUH never forbade them until Allah ordered him to do so.

[@rosapril3398]

Yes to your answer brother But you know that drinking nothing goid cones from it and even though the never out right forbids it ,constantly tell you stay away from it And that you l serve God better by doing so

[@jayapaulreddymotatireddy]

In the presents of G-d by worshipping him we do get great joy in him and why do we need to search for in world in alcohol when we get more joy in our Lords presence I to read torah G-d allowed us to drink alcohol if we had any health issues if doctor advice to drink we can allow to drink it for some amount as a medicine but not for fun in hinduism drinking is not a sin but most of indians we wont drink alcohol our family is a hindu family but we never drunk we also not allow drank men into home my uncle having health issues so doctor adviced him to drink alcohol but he didn't drunk because its not a good thing he took the pain but he never drank this is something you jews should learn about drinking

[@naseraziz7967]

It wasn't for the Angel Gabriel to ask prophet Mohammed to choose and what Mohammed pick the other beverage will be forbidden

[@noahali3663]

Please read proverbs 20,1 and Leviticus 10, 9

[@anabid]

Intoxication is forbidden in islam for the same reason 😊 you told

[@mohamedalshirawi8678]

Just to add here, that the wine in the heaven is not the intoxicating type not like the worldly wine which causes intoxication.. this I refer from the Quran.. God dignified humans by giving them their brain, and that is what elevates them from level of animals as you mentioned .. and when people drink alcohol and get drunk , they lose their brain and lose their dignity and come down to the level of animals driven by their instinct only..also God will never allow anything which will lead to committing of sin.. Therefore Islam generally and shia Islam specifically believes that alcohol was forbidden from day one.. And that non of the prophets mentioning Moses , Haroon, Ibrahim, Lot.. etc peace be upon them never drunk or consumed any alcohol including wine.. Just wanted to explain how Islam sees alcohol as we Learned from our scholors.. Thank you for your interesting videos..

[@johnirby8847]

Christianity and Judaism do not prohibit alcohol but it is a sin to become drunk or go to religious services drunk. Islam outright bans alcohol. If someone is sick or dying..alcohol is used to relieve pain..so those people can be drunk. I don't know if Islam has the same exception for sick people.

[@abdillahibasheabdi4904]

In islam i never saw sick person drinking but i think as antiseptic or something related may be but dri king never. i am about 40 I have never seen person drinking

[@christianprince4508]

Judges 13:4 Therefore be careful and drink no wine or strong drink, and eat nothing unclean,

[@dmitrishostakovich5209]

The angel of the LORD appeared to her and said, "You are sterile and childless, but you are going to conceive and have a son. Now see to it that you drink no wine or other fermented drink and that you do not eat anything unclean, because you will conceive and give birth to a son." - the context is important, the verses are about the mother of Judge Samson, who were to become a monk/friar(נזיר), and that's why she wasn't allowed to drink alcohol.

[@ambreenyousuf2652]

Wine was haram before mohammad (saw) in the torah and injeel but people disobayed , after mohammad (pbuh) it again announced as prohibited in quran . Alcohole is haram in all 3 books torah injeel quran

[@TK77718]

Ecclesiasticus 31:27 “Wine is as good as life to a man, if it be drunk moderately: what life is then to a man that is without wine? for it was made to make men glad.”

[@sharkfaced]

The quran, in various verses, tells muslims to keep away from intoxicants as they mask the mind and affect the remembrance of God in addition to causing problems between people. As for the situation before islam, that would be christianity, and before that judaism - so the quran didnt mention the permissibility of alcohol before islam.

[@Positive-Energy-Vibes]

I agree with you, Jews were allowed to some point but Allah wants to see if a new law which wasn't mentioned in the Torah if Jews would accept it, this new law that was made clear drinking alcohol is forbidden. Secondly Jews who revert to Islam, are told to practice there own faith with Jewish family members. as long they don't deny prophet mohamed & the correct Islamic Jesus. & you could celebrate the Jewish religion with your Jewish family. Only christians & pagans are told to follow Islamic way 100%

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Really, that's interesting. I didn't know that converted Jews are told to also observe Torah.

[@Positive-Energy-Vibes]

There is no false in the Torah about God (Allah) & Jews were the first believers. Allah wants Jews to keep their identity & call themselves Jews who believe in mohamed pbuh But after Jesus came & Jews heard Muslims believe in Jesus they just laughed and walked away without hearing the Muslim VIEW point of Jesus All you need is to take your Shahada (oath of believe) in the masjid in front of sheikh and in front of witnesses audience at masjid of your believe

[@fbiagent4841]

My brother can you please answer my question. Can a Jews women marry to Muslim man?

[@benmarsh1168]

Khan Zazai yes read surah maida ayat 5 ahle kitab(jews and Christian) women are lawful to muslim man ....but muslim woman cant marry jewish man

[@NeoLegendX]

This is what I said to a jew Why come close to it It might cost you to sin

[@noorallahaljomaa142]

Alsalam alikum wa rahmat allah wa barakatuh! I belong to the islamic school which we trust only the Quran as 100% . Since Hadeeth was written after about 200 years after profet Mohamad death, so I can not trust it 100%, as some other muslims do.That is why my expanation will come only from my understanding of Quran. Unlike Turah which came to Mussa in 40 days in Sinna, Quran came to Muhamad as many parts in 23 years. God told Mohamad where to put each part in orders. Quran tolked about wine in three different time periods, in orders as the following : يَسْأَلُونَكَ عَنِ الْخَمْرِ وَالْمَيْسِرِ قُلْ فِيهِمَا إِثْمٌ كَبِيرٌ وَمَنَافِعُ لِلنَّاسِ وَإِثْمُهُمَا أَكْبَرُ مِنْ نَفْعِهِمَا وَيَسْأَلُونَكَ مَاذَا يُنْفِقُونَ قُلِ الْعَفْوَ كَذَلِكَ يُبَيِّنُ اللَّهُ لَكُمُ الْآيَاتِ لَعَلَّكُمْ تَتَفَكَّرُونَ (219) (البقرة) (2:219) They ask you (O Muhammad SAW) concerning alcoholic drink and gambling. Say: “In them is a great sin, and (some) benefit for men, but the sin of them is greater than their benefit.” And they ask you what they ought to spend. Say: “That which is beyond your needs.” Thus Allah makes clear to you His Laws in order that you may give thought.” يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا لَا تَقْرَبُوا الصَّلَاةَ وَأَنْتُمْ سُكَارَى حَتَّى تَعْلَمُوا مَا تَقُولُونَ وَلَا جُنُبًا إِلَّا عَابِرِي سَبِيلٍ حَتَّى تَغْتَسِلُوا وَإِنْ كُنْتُمْ مَرْضَى أَوْ عَلَى سَفَرٍ أَوْ جَاءَ أَحَدٌ مِنْكُمْ مِنَ الْغَائِطِ أَوْ لَامَسْتُمُ النِّسَاءَ فَلَمْ تَجِدُوا مَاءً فَتَيَمَّمُوا صَعِيدًا طَيِّبًا فَامْسَحُوا بِوُجُوهِكُمْ وَأَيْدِيكُمْ إِنَّ اللَّهَ كَانَ عَفُوًّا غَفُورًا (43) (النساء) O you who believe! Approach not As-Salat (the prayer) when you are in a drunken state until you know (the meaning) of what you utter, nor when you are in a state of Janaba, (i.e. in a state of sexual impurity and have not yet taken a bath) except when travelling on the road (without enough water, or just passing through a mosque), till you wash your whole body. And if you are ill, or on a journey, or one of you comes after answering the call of nature, or you have been in contact with women (by sexual relations) and you find no water, perform Tayammum with clean earth and rub therewith your faces and hands (Tayammum). Truly, Allah is Ever Oft-Pardoning, Oft-Forgiving.(43) يَا أَيُّهَا الَّذِينَ آمَنُوا إِنَّمَا الْخَمْرُ وَالْمَيْسِرُ وَالْأَنْصَابُ وَالْأَزْلَامُ رِجْسٌ مِنْ عَمَلِ الشَّيْطَانِ فَاجْتَنِبُوهُ لَعَلَّكُمْ تُفْلِحُونَ (90) إِنَّمَا يُرِيدُ الشَّيْطَانُ أَنْ يُوقِعَ بَيْنَكُمُ الْعَدَاوَةَ وَالْبَغْضَاءَ فِي الْخَمْرِ وَالْمَيْسِرِ وَيَصُدَّكُمْ عَنْ ذِكْرِ اللَّهِ وَعَنِ الصَّلَاةِ فَهَلْ أَنْتُمْ مُنْتَهُونَ (91) وَأَطِيعُوا اللَّهَ وَأَطِيعُوا الرَّسُولَ وَاحْذَرُوا فَإِنْ تَوَلَّيْتُمْ فَاعْلَمُوا أَنَّمَا عَلَى رَسُولِنَا الْبَلَاغُ الْمُبِينُ (92) (المائدة) Believers, wine and gambling, idols and divining arrows are abominations from the work of satan. Avoid them, in order that you prosper. (90) satan seeks to stir up enmity and hatred among you by means of wine and gambling, and to bar you from the remembrance of Allah and from praying. Will you not abstain from them? (91) Obey Allah, and obey the Messenger. Beware; if you give no heed, know that Our Messenger's duty is only to give the clear delivery. (92) When you read the instrutions of Quran in order, you will understand that the wine was allowed in the beginning of Islam, both in (219) (البقرة) and in(43) (النساء). Later on in (90) (المائدة) was it totally banned. So I can guess that wine was allowed in both Judasim and Christianity which came before Islam. (فَاجْتَنِبُوهُ) This verb in arabic languge which have the meaning which goes behind just drinking of wine, we are not allowed to touch it, not to buy or sell it , not even to serv it others. I hope it was clear and good enough explanation. Thank you for your fantastic videos! Keep on doing it! שלום עליכם

[@Kemo-sc7nt]

Give me number of rakaat of dhuhr prayer from the Quran please

[@adibagouher4182]

Alcohol is forbidden in quran i mean in islam . Islam is perfect , islam never permit bad think , nor indicate it direct tell what is permissible and what is not . Islam never permitted to drink alcohal , it never permits to drink alcohal a little bit .

[@vinramirez8859]

The consumption of pork is forbidden. But not smoking and drinking. I get it, its kosher smokes and booze.

[@rangerstrade2268]

The TaNaKh forbids alcohol. Leviticus 10:9; Judges 13:4, and many other scriptures. In order to be a nazarite in numbers 6, you must take the vow. You are to drink no wine nor eat grapes and raisins.

[@azertyqwerty5946]

No those verses were related to specific context. Leviticus is talking about before a meeting and entering a certain tent. Judges was talking about a pregnant lady. Numbers was talking about a Nazirite vow. So these are all special cases. But there is nothing to indicate that generally speaking it was forbidden.

[@TK77718]

Ecclesiasticus 31:27 “Wine is as good as life to a man, if it be drunk moderately: what life is then to a man that is without wine? for it was made to make men glad.”

[@LAD7907]

Do you live in uk

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

No. USA

[@alexmathew6786]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 Shalom habebaei

[@hafiz-x9p]

hai mr,if we al not drink alcohol god can like you,,,you face n you heart can have a light from god,we can see it at your face whos do a sin not have a light in your face,if you seriusly eat a kosher like muslim say kosher its halal food god can bless us but very important we all make sure we cannot do any sin,,,amen,,,

[@richellyosoria5346]

maybe if the wine is not fermented and you dont hurt you or other is good.

[@engmahrousfci]

In the beginning of revelation wine or alcohol was not forbidden, then after while, the first stage of forbidding alcohol was only before prayer, however prophet Muhammad (pbuh) don't drink it and it wasn't recommended, and then came the totally forbidding it even a little bit... And about Arab before prophet Muhammad specially in Macca, they supposidely have to follow the rules and commandments of prophets Ibrahim and Ismaeil [peace be upon them], but they after while they started to worship idols and changed so many rules and invent other rules, and you can see so many examples of that playing and changing those rules in Quran (could give you examples if you would), so the main streem fall on that sins and the followers to those rules of prophets became less and less by the time, even rare (so many example and peotry about that over time shows many examples and ppl), and that stayed like that untel God Almighty send prophet Muhammad [pbuh] with the revelation ... So the conclusion is that "probably" alcohol was not totally forbidden within those rules (i.e. Ibrahim and Ismaeil - pbut- rules)

[@user-nq4ly5sh9u]

So you mean, alcohol isn't forbidden in case it's under control and limited?

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Yes. In Judaism it's not forbidden as long as it doesn't lead to violating a Torah law (like being aggressive or not being able to pray, etc.)

[@mylestteague]

Wine is not haram, it's prohibited. In the same way that an observing jew is prohibited, unless one really knows ones limits(and Allah knows best:) ) it's pretty hard to make any justification for alcohol beyond it's medicinal and practical uses(even then). The only things that are haram are what goes against the 10 commandments, the flesh of swine, the blood, that which is gored by another animal, and that which is already dead. Allah prohibits wine but doesn't forbid because He knows that most observing Jews will not give up the Passover and observing Christians will not give up the Lord's Evening Meal. But Allah knows best in all matters and here is the verse of prohibition O you who have believed, surely wine and games of chance, and altars (for idols) and divining (i.e., divination by arrows or in any other way) are only an abomination of Ash-Shaytan’s (The all-vicious, the Devil) doing, so avoid it, that possibly you would prosper. Surely Ash- Shaytan’s (The all-vicious, the Devil) would only (like) to excite enmity and abhorrence among you by means of wine and games of chance, (Literally: in wine and games of chance) and to bar you from the remembrance of Allah, and from prayer. Will you then be refraining? (Dr. Ghali)

[@boxingmonthly]

is Muhammad' not mentioned in the holy Torah? Shalom alaikem

[@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397]

Alechem Shalom, no he is not.

[@abc_6]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 By name not in Torah, Tanakh however u’ll find his name there. Reference: Song of Solomon ch5 v16

[@abc_6]

@@blessedishashemtheg-dofisr7397 his prophecy and name is also mentioned in the Hindu text surprisingly, google it. Scripture Name : Bhavisha purana The Sanskrit text of Pratisarg Parv 3; Khand 3; Adhyaai 3; Shlokas 5 to 27 is given below:

[@abc_6]

TRANSLATION OF SHLOKAS 5-8 At that time a spiritual teacher (Acharya) known as Mahamad (Muhammad) appeared amongst the Mlecchas (non Indians/non Aryans), along with his companions/disciples. The King after giving this Mahaa Deva (of angelic disposition) dweller of the desert (Marusthal Nivasi), a bath in the Panchgavya and the Ganges water (meaning honouring and praising him) offered him presents and showing him all reverence said: “I pay obeisance to you (Namaste) O Pride of Humanity (Girija Nath) dweller of the desert (Marusthal Nivaasi/Arabian dweller). You are the destroyer of the Devil (Tripurasur Naashaaya) who propagates deceit. You have been protected from fellow Mlecchas, and you are the embodiment of Divine Qualities (Sacchidanand Roopine). I am a your servant, and have come seeking your refuge. Few points come out of these verses. Mahamad (Muhammad) has been called an Acharya (a spiritual teacher) of Mlecchas (the illiterate people). The King Bhoj (innocent Indian people) will yearn to follow Prophet Muhammad with all humility and accept him as their teacher. Muhammad is the destroyer of the Devil. Tripurasur in Puranic mythology stands for the Devil. Muhammad is a dweller of the desert. It cannot refer to Lord Shiva of the Puranas because his abode is said to be the Mount Kailash in the Himlayas and not the desert. The Prophet will be given protection against his enemies, the fellow Mlecchas. Raja Bhoj washed the Prophet with Ganges water and Panchgavya. Since this is a vision, it cannot be taken literally but must be taken as symbolic for honour. He is called as the embodiment of divine qualities.

[@مارتینلوتر-م8غ]

@@abc_6 brother whoever Gold you, he have used quoting out of context fallacy. Ut is not muhammad.

[@talibhussain1824]

My Jewish cousin, Your observations in all of your videos point to Islam being the natural successor to true monotheistic faith. Only when you accept Muhammad PBUH as the final messanger of Allah and Jesus as a true prophet of Allah ,only then will your faith be firm enough and acceptable in front of your creator.

[@frisnelleger6023]

Shalom in response to your reference on whether alcohol was permitted prior to prophet Muhammad peace be upon him yes however Allah has made it forbidden indefinitely and surely Allah knows best in addition it will be allowed in paradise in a different form without the effects of intoxication. Quran surah 47 ayah 15 titled Muhammad. The prophet peace be upon him delivered a plethora of sermons banning alcohol here's one hadith from a hadith Narrated Aisha: The Prophet said, "All drinks that produce intoxication are Haram (forbidden to drink). Sahih Bukhari 1:4:243 The Quranic passage is Al Baqarah surah 2 ayah 219. peace and blessings!

[@HA-vy9ow]

Frisnel Leger The Qur’an does not say is is haram. It does say that there is good in it however it can lead to evil things. If the Hadith says it is haram, then surely that would be a contradiction somewhat..

[@frisnelleger6023]

H A there's no such thing as contradictions in the Al Qur'an GOD mentioned the consumption of alcohol is a great sin for something to be a sin would be haram.You can verify for yourself Qur'an surah Al Baqarah 2 ayah 219.

[@HA-vy9ow]

Frisnel Leger I believe the verse states that there is great sin in it. Not that it is explicitly haram, whereas for example the consumption of pork is explicitly made haram. This is not in anyway encouraging drinking. If there is any contradiction, it would be on the side of the Ahadith, which are strictly sanctioned against in the Quran.

[@frisnelleger6023]

H A true however sin itself are to be avoided as much as possible. Mind you we muslims are followers of prophet Muhammad peace be upon him he taught us to stay away from wine all forms of intoxicants. Allah said categorically to obey the prophet those that do so obeys Allah.

[@HA-vy9ow]

Frisnel Leger To obey the prophet is to obey what was revealed to him, which was the Quran. The Prophet is no longer with us, how do you suggest we obey him. Say, "I possess no power to harm you, nor to guide you." 72:21

[@emam_speeches]

You should just say its Prohibited. Alhamdullilah Im a Muslim And Hate Alcohol

[@TK77718]

Its not prohibitted

[@mohamedalshirawi8678]

As it definitely leads to committing sin.

[@AdilElhajEljack]

Did you say a pig is disgusting!!!

[@flexgado249]

Their is not such law against Drinking Wine. Now to get more complex with it Over drinking can cause lost of critical thinking and your not in control of their body. So it can be bad also but it's not a sin to drink it Christian don't understand that they just think Drunkenness

[@travelswithaz]

muslim bro's and sisters here? raise your hand! :D

[@ashiqueaash5002]

✋

[@travelswithaz]

@T I Inshallah I will. thanks.