IS COLOURPOP DUPING THEMSELVES?! 🤭

[@yukinablossom5459]

It might be difficult, idk. but if this was turned into a short series, I think that would be pretty cool. This was so nice to see bc there's constantly so much makeup being released :) Thanks Angel. Love you💕💕 Edit: lol I didn't know other ppl were thinking the same thing while reading the comments. Great minds think alike 😝!

[@j.uuuuudy]

yes for sure maybe from time to time!!

[@DancingKoalaaa]

I honestly have lost interest in Colourpop's products. All the launches keep coming almost weekly and, in my opinion, it takes away a fun side of makeup. I like being surprised by new launches but the quantity is juste overwhelming (and not in a good way). Your video just showcases that their own products can be duped. I'm sure that the quality is good, but nothing jumps out as being different from what they've already done. I don't understand their marketing/business strategy right now of wanting to launch so many products consecutively. I believe it doesn't give them enough time to see if they work and people actually enjoy them. Hopefully they'll slow down and I'll be once again interested in their products 😕

[@pinkgyaru._.]

Agreed!

[@stratosphere94]

Yes absolutely! They all look the same. It's so boring.

[@alishamyers68]

I feel the same way, I love tinkerbell and was intetested in the launch but when I saw the eyeshadow palette I was like Meh nothing exciting, i did pick up the 2 lip stains but thats it. I also had my eye on the Lust Dist palette but when I really looled at the colours there was othing new that I dont alreay own

[@j.uuuuudy]

i agree with you! for someone who reviews their products consistently it's very rare for me to get excited!

[@nicoolfielder]

ICYMI = In Case You Missed It! xoxo, would love a series, especially because I love watching people use the collections they already have rather than buying new all the time! You're so good about that

[@j.uuuuudy]

ahhh thank you!! and yes i think this will turn into a series for sure!!

[@thehotcrippled1]

Please make this a series. I would love to see Oh La La and It's My Pleasure. Thank you so much for the lovely video. Have a beautiful day. 😊

[@j.uuuuudy]

thank you for watching 💕

[@lenn5194]

Judy Colourpop self-dupes is a brilliant idea! It’d be amazing if you can turn this into a series with you being pretty much a Colourpop connoisseur now. I understand this would take a lot of time and effort, so dont be pressure abt the videos’ frequency if you do want to make it into a series!

[@j.uuuuudy]

thank you for thinking of me! maybe we can do this seasonal?

[@marcela3167]

i love this video/the idea to continue doing more of a series! i think the only products i could really notice as being different were the lip ones, and that's because i already knew you were wearing different lipsticks.

[@j.uuuuudy]

thank you for watching 💕💕you got a good eye!!

[@casieg.7040]

They're definitely duping themselves lol if their launches were more spread out throughout the year it probably wouldn't be so obvious. Sweet talk is my go to palette since it's just so cute. It was my first ColourPop palette so it has a special place for me.

[@j.uuuuudy]

i agree! i wish they would slow down a bit!

[@stephaniezhang1901]

I think this would be a really interesting series! Especially if it continued to compare their newer collections to the older products so we could really just how similar the products are. There is always a lot of focus on the shades of their eyeshadow palettes being repetitive, but I think its so interesting to see the comparisons between other products like lip, highlighter, and blush shades too. Thanks for all your work, Judy!

[@j.uuuuudy]

ill be sure to do this type of video more often!

[@Pin_official95]

Definitely would love this to be a series Your comparisons when you have reviewed colourpop collections have been so helpful to me and stopped me from buying things essentially double or three times

[@j.uuuuudy]

ahh im so glad i could be helpful!!

[@lorrainewhitlock5377]

Yes! Do series I would really love to see one with OhLaLa and lilac you a lot. I just love purples

[@j.uuuuudy]

will add that to the list!!

[@livijean1]

I would be interested in seeing you do this as they launch newer palettes. Like if they have a new collection, letting us know if there are palettes from their past that are nearly the same.

[@j.uuuuudy]

noted!

[@kw3rkygurl406]

I love this concept. I would love to see comparisons for discontinued colourpop palettes like dream street, raw beauty Kristi, or some of your favorites that they no longer make. It would be interesting to see what we could use to have a similar look.

[@sunshineyrainbows13]

Wow. If you watch her put it on the difference seems obvious at first, but by the end, once you see the whole look you literally can't tell. Great job! Liked. I really like these videos, it helps me figure out which CP palettes I actually NEED to buy and which ones I can afford to skip because the color story ends up pulling the same. Can you please do their green palettes next? Also, seeing you do this with other brands who have a surplus of palettes (like BH, Wet n Wild, W7, Makeup Revolution, Profusion, Morphe, Kara Beauty, Elf, etc) would also be so helpful!

[@makeupandbeautea]

I'm desperately waiting for colourpop to release a rosy nude all matte palette, perhaps a "Rose" palette but all I get are colour stories they've released a million times 🙄

[@ari5200]

I’ve had really flaky and dry eyelids too and I switched to the colourpop/fourth ray beauty eye cream in the pink tub and the flakiness had gone away in a few days, I really recommend trying it if you haven’t already :)

[@ari5200]

Also i would love to see a blush crush or nude mood comparisons /dupe vid

[@j.uuuuudy]

thats actually the eye cream im currently using!! and yes will add blush crush/nude mood to the list!

[@annazhao211]

Personally, even though sweet talk has more shades, coast to coral seems more my vibe without the glitters 😅

[@j.uuuuudy]

i was the same but after this video im vibing with sweet talk more now :')

[@hoodedeyemorena]

This is why we love Judy, right, people? Love this series in the making 🤎

[@j.uuuuudy]

❤️❤️❤️

[@SS_S.]

I think this was a great idea! Swatch comparisons are helpful, but nothing beats showing a look side by side on the eyes. I'd love to see a basic neutrals look like the bare necessities vs going coconuts! (And Georgette is a name, pronounced jaw-jet)

[@j.uuuuudy]

noted! thank you ❤️

[@romaineszabo7362]

Yes please do more comparisons. Pls do their green and blue palettes.

[@bevbrockway894]

I love this! So many times i see comparisons and think its close but different so yes i need it but in reality once on the eye you can't really see a difference. Please do more of these!

[@YukiSaeki]

The thing with Colourpop is I know for sure I already have the same shades in my collection, but they somehow manage to make me want to buy more!! I think they play their game really really well. I appreciate this video though because like you said, sometimes the arm swatches and and actually appearance on eyes could differ a bit.

[@rebekkatingz]

I love colourpop and I appreciate that even when they do release something similar it’s usually still different, palette size, formula, tones, shifts, etc. Idk I think they’re a fun brand and with crazy good quality

[@dawnr9158]

Love this video. Would love this as a series!

[@dana395]

One thing that stood out to me was how much more depth and smoothness the older palette had, the texture looked more high end and the new palette looked a little chalky. It would be interesting to see if that is the case in other comparisons.

[@danaleighsheehan5120]

Love this video and would love to see more of this content as a consumer, I love colourpop, but don’t want to buy close duplicate pallets. It’s so hard not to buy them all! 😊

[@j.uuuuudy]

ill be sure to do this type of video more often!

[@helenngo7762]

would love this as a new series!

[@Kayla-lz6ry]

I haven’t even watched the video yet and I know the answer is yes 😂 Amanda from makeup just for fun shows comparisons of colourpop products for every launch just in case anyone is interested

[@SuperStarr817]

This is exactly why I only order Colourpop once or twice a year, just because things end up looking similar over time. It's why I'm also rarely heartbroken when they discontinue stuff, something similar will release in its place in a matter of time. P.S. In case you missed it

[@bessonovafan6454]

I’d love to see you do a similar thing with the You’re Golden palette alone! Found so many shades that are super similar within that palette!

[@ProffesorElm]

like many others have said, i would love to see a series of this! i'd be curious to see a comparison between "all that" and "wine & only"

[@j.uuuuudy]

noted!!

[@baileyb0615]

Totally here for a series! 💛💛

[@alishamyers68]

Please make this a series loved it

[@ac2055]

I love that you did these comparisons!! I've always wondered how close or not Coast to Coral and Sweet Talk are on the eyes. It seems like it would be obvious, but sometimes you don't really know. Jen Phelps used arm swatches to show that Sweet Talk was a close dupe for many of Sigma's Cor de Rosa shades - but on the eyes they are very different - either too pink, or too red, or too orange. I was actually disappointed bc the Cor de Rosa was everything around coral, but not coral! (Still love it as a companion palette tho). I'm also curious about Baby Got Peach... but that might be overkill for comparison vids. This particular comparison was also great because corals are so popular bc they're versatile for everyday wear to everyday glam to full glam. I would like to see comparison vids, but I wonder if it makes sense to compare palettes that aren't sold anymore? I guess it makes sense for the ppl who already have those palettes, but maybe not for those who don't. In that sense, it makes sense for CP to re-release smth similar. Or to release a new version that builds on feedback. Like Coast to Coral seemed to be aiming for those ppl who almost wanted Sweet Talk, but couldn't buy it bc of the pressed glitters (like me!). If they released the exact same shades without the glitters, ppl would complain "Oh, they're just re-releasing old shades" (like I think they've done with the Sonic Blooms), even though I think it's okay since eyeshadows technically have a shelf life of 2 yrs. If CP just released the exact same Sweet Talk shades in a 9-pan without the glitters or Baby Got Peach shades without the glittery Hungry Ghost and replaced it with a shimmer and replaced the darkest shade w a dark, cool brown, I would totally buy them (tho, they can release them in another yr or 2 after my current palettes expire, lol).

[@Madeline-Cano]

I like this style of video a lot! I really feel like lots of colourpop is dupes of their own palettes and I appreciate knowing which I can skip and which are more unique.

[@The3GMom]

I wore those exact Coast to coral shades today! Great series idea!

[@princesaa__]

Please make this into a series!!!! 🥰❤️

[@j.uuuuudy]

of course!!

[@TurtleBeautyxx]

Really liking the idea of making comparisons videos just to save time from buying palettes that you may already own 💕

[@lindsaym1261]

i would love to see this as a series with their older vs new products!

[@j.uuuuudy]

yesss!

[@rosieisbored]

Another comparison could be flutterby and making mauves, or any other of the cool toned purple palettes they have! (I’ve lost track)

[@jennyjoyce9465]

I would LOVE a series like this 😍.

[@Evastar23]

Would love to see more, maybe on some of their green palettes?!

[@j.uuuuudy]

noted!!

[@SANDY-lg9gh]

This is such a unique video idea, totally love it and would like to see more!! Also I love when you make monochromatic looks ( especially when you match your clothes too) 💕

[@j.uuuuudy]

hehe thank you ❤️

[@katerynaplesiuk9113]

I would love to see it with more of fun colors. Like their in a trance palette!

[@j.uuuuudy]

noted!!

[@stephaniethat40somethinggi45]

I do think this would be a fun series. Your skin tone carries both cool and warm tones very well, and the depth of your skin tone is light medium range, so I think on more fair skin and on darker skin there might be a bigger difference. Especially depending on undertone. From my pov, ColourPop provides the range people keep asking for from other brands. Then everyone complains about having too many options and variations. Unpopular observation, but, it's true.

[@ArtisticButterfly93]

I loved this and really want to see more of these. Maybe next time compare the cherry collection with others? Like Strawberry, Watermelon or Wine & Only?

[@j.uuuuudy]

noted!!

[@akong331]

I love these!!! Between em magic hour and cp sweet talk, I do not need coast to coral! Please do a series. ❤️ I’m eyeing extra toppings and creamsicle, and don’t know if I already dupped them with my own colourpop collection 😂.

[@moida_official]

This is so damn interesting! Their originals have been doing great and their new ones remain the quality but the better? How can u not buy it😭

[@Rognara13]

I want to see that kind of comparisons with discontinued products and products in stock

[@feliciasoh1154]

love this video idea!!!! series pls

[@AJL2012]

Could you do a comparison video with Colourpop’s Give it to me straight and 3CE’s Overtake? Thank you.

[@isamint]

Really loved the video, im kind of a long time lurker hehe , i really hope this becomes a series maybe with discontinued stuff even :)

[@carolecarson6467]

Love this video would love it to become a series! You are definitely the best colourpop reviewer!!!

[@j.uuuuudy]

aww thank you!!!

[@kattiephan4080]

i relate to the eye dryness soo much !! i have psoriasis on my face and it sucks so much :c

[@natashakneale7432]

This is such a good idea for a video, hope to see more colour pop dupe x

[@j.uuuuudy]

more to come!

[@izznutella1473]

Yes girl plz do a part 2 and series love this idea 😍😍😍

[@alygomez944]

Yes to series!!! Moreee ❤️

[@beautyceleste91]

This is awesome content! Cannot wait for the next video, you should do a series with this idea!

[@j.uuuuudy]

for sure ❤️ thank you for watching love!!

[@katl8825]

My face was the shocked pikachu face when you said your makeup look is actually half and half products 😂

[@Elvi0010]

I would like to see So Jaded and At Forest Sight comparisons

[@natashanatasha7875]

already waiting for part 2!

[@melissaspurgeon7419]

I would LOVE for you to do more of these videos! I am currently in the process of combining some of my Colourpop palettes so that I can make color stories that I enjoy more. This is giving me tons of inspiration! ❤️ ICYMI is “In case you missed it” by the way! 😊

[@alliauyeung3004]

Would love to see some “less obvious” dupes where you might have to mix the shades a bit. I’m thinking like maybe sandstone and garden variety-you could possibly get similar looks but it’s not obvious.

[@j.uuuuudy]

sounds interesting!! will consider that for me next video , thank you for the feedback ❤️

[@therealdonnawagner]

This is great! Thank you!

[@deerestdiary.makeup]

Great video! I'd love to see more in this format, it's pretty fun (and frustrating I guess, since it proves that CP really is repeating itself). Just as an aside, Georgette is the French feminine version of the name George, so it's basically pronounced as George-ette, with a soft g!

[@sheknitsthings49]

When I saw the title of the video, my answer was yes. Now to click and watch 😂 ngl I would've never known that you were wearing different products on one side of your face if you hadn't said anything and I hadn't watched the video. They're pretty good dupes for each other! I was interested in Sweet Talk, but that pressed glitter had me passing on it. I wasn't interested in Coast to Coral but now that I see that it's a good dupe... I'm adding it to my wish list.

[@Lesyeuxdechelsea]

❣️ yes!!! Waiting for this vid! Love u

[@jacquihida8618]

Love dupe videos!

[@christinecho779]

I really love the less red toned side, the older palette. It’s more of a true orangey peach shade.❤️

[@j.uuuuudy]

me too!!

[@Momo-oz4ek]

Maybe an aura n out dupe, I'm so sad that palette is being discontinued

[@kattan7431]

Love this series💗

[@pe4774]

You are so pretty!

[@beijoflor]

I love Colourpop but they're like the fast fashion of makeup in how many products come and go. Like they're so focused with how much they can pump out, but at least the quality is usually consistent

[@brunellaparis9200]

Thank you very much for the video! And thank you for put all the brushes you use in each moment :) :) :) :) :)

[@kavyareddyy]

I loved watching this video and would love to see more like this ❤️ they are very helpful, we can avoid buying duplicates 😅

[@EvlNabiki]

Please do make this a series, especially with price comparisons 🙏 I'm on a really tight budget, and especially considering the shipping costs would love to be able to get the best value for money 😅😅 at the moment I'm looking for a comprehensive pastel palette that works on tan skin 😊😊 Oh, and icmyi is in case you missed it, and Georgette is like saying George+ ett ^u^

[@j.uuuuudy]

ill be sure to add pricing next time! and thank you for the corrections!!

[@CM-pc3dl]

Is there a way to use those supershock blushes with a brush instead of the sponge? It drives me nuts and I never use it bc of that😂😂

[@thynguyeexn]

I saw some KZbinrs use a stippling brush 🤷‍♀️

[@CM-pc3dl]

@@thynguyeexn I tried stippling brushes and dense ones.. they still do not pick it up at all🥲

[@princesaa__]

I absolutely love Colourpop!!!! 🥰😍

[@jessicamelo2698]

Judy is always coming up with the best videos! Thank you so much, I really wanted to try Georgette but is sold out, now I have an option. Please, turn it into a series. Love u, Judy 💖🧚‍♂️

[@j.uuuuudy]

love you too, thank you for watching ❤️

[@annazhao211]

Your pronunciation of anemone caught me off guard omg lmao I didn't realize people in NZ said it so differently

[@airbearcares93]

It's not, she just mispronounced it (no shade, it's not a commonly spoken word, though I guess Finding Nemo did popularize it, hehe). 🥰 If you look up the UK pronunciation on KZbin it's the same basic pronunciation, so it's not a aluminum/aluminium situation.

[@j.uuuuudy]

^ i did mispronounce it sorry!!

[@thuyvantranngoc3027]

great idea. could you duping with discount product and availeble product???

[@tabithagoh3668]

The pERFECT description for ColourPop really

[@sheknitsthings49]

Oops I forgot to mention that I'd be down if you did a part two or turned this into a series before hitting comment!

[@bessonovafan6454]

ICYMI: In Case You Missed It

[@annmarieliermann9839]

ICYMI = in case you missed it. Great video!

[@kambroa71]

Ay judy soy de Argentina amo tus videos y comparaciones aqui colourpop no es una marca económica por el valor dolar cuesta bastante gracias a tus videos supe comprar mucho colourpop que amo pero me haces dudar tengo la wsiss talk y ahora quiero la coral porque a ti te gusta mas jaja dios no se que hacer soy una ama de casa yvya tengo 95 paletas colourpop te mando besoss

[@sydt7104]

There are only so many warm toned palettes you can make, ColourPop

[@rochellebalasta2672]

Part 2 pls😍ICYMI-in case you missed it!

[@meixdenise]

the effort in this video ! for you to find "duplicates".

[@babyg.4207]

Judy, Your animal crossing lip crayon has a orange logo. So Is it peach surprise or orange cutie? just to be sure 😝

[@j.uuuuudy]

it's peach surprise! i must of swapped the caps by accident!!

[@babyg.4207]

@@j.uuuuudy oh! got it. Thank you

[@MarisDirection]

Yes, the answer is yes.

[@jennyjoyce9465]

ICYMI: In case you missed it 😘

[@chocochipcookiez]

Ooooooh spicy 🤭

[@jiyulkim3205]

💜💜💜

[@rootbeef]

ICYMI = "In Case You Missed It" :)

[@hellom6533]

ICYMI= In Case You Missed It 🧡

[@janvierbalser2849]

ICYMI In case you missed it