Is Islam Against Entertainment? | Reasons behind the Gap Between Youth and Scholars |

[@I6eeikahdu38]

Iliyas sir your thoughts are also inspiration and solution for Indian Muslims 🇮🇳

[@raziagauhar1456]

مدتوں بعد کسی مذہبی عالم سے اتنی متوازن گفتگو سننے کوملی ۔ دل خوش ہو گیا ۔ اگر یہی رویہ اپنایا جائے تو مذہب سے بھی بیزاری نہیں ہوگی اور زمانے کے ساتھ آگے بھی بڑھیں گے

[@Alex_oldmomories]

Is he a mazhabi scholar?

[@qamarshahnaz6701]

Yes he is ​@@Alex_oldmomories

[@syedharismahmood]

Great discussion. As long as there is intelligent discourse still happening, there is hope!

[@ehsanjavaid1858]

Mashaallah itni intellectual batein 2002 say humaray main stream media pay hu rahe hote tu shayad is mulk mai kuch behtari hote... Great Work Raftar.. ❤❤

[@ksgaming3401]

Good line of questioning by the host.

[@pakgamingyt1066]

Raftar channel goal is change the youth of Pakistan mindset well 👍✅

[@RajKumar-bq9hb]

Impossible ,Plastic surgery se kuttey ki poonch sidhi ho sakti hain magar Pakistan ki nahi

[@sajjawalkhan6200]

A hadith says, "Seek knowledge even if you have to go to China" The Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) emphasized the importance of education, saying, "Seeking knowledge is an obligation upon every Muslim". He also said, "Whoever takes a path in search of knowledge, Allah will make easy for him a path to Paradise"

[@muteebahmed4675]

Brother The Hadith which you Quote regarding Knowledge if you have to go to China, It is not authentic it is a quote from another person. Please be careful while quote Hadees and also share reference from where you share Ahadees

[@sucralfate333]

Yes, we definitely should take knowledge, learn, and try to observe and think about things... But there is no such hadith present which u just quoted.

[@ranaumer5860]

Exact and accurate discussion about Pakistani islam…

[@jayoenix8763]

On point

[@Rumi649]

Best topic ever

[@muhammadsarfraz1752]

This vedio is not playing...Check the problem???why its just buffering???

[@Uzma084]

Yeah same problem

[@malkahans]

Excellent guest Hassan Ilyas

[@FusionFactsDaily]

Excellent!! Bhot maza aya ap logon ko sun ke.

[@SultanAhmed-my9cm]

Great discussion. But the thing is that our leader either political or religious are running their own business by binding people under political parties or religious sectarism. If people start asking question then at the end they would need to close their businesses. But the goal is always to live the life based on the current principles of life and need to go side by side with the modern world but making sure it abide by the shariah as well.

[@letslearntogether.4336]

How can I join team of Sir gamdi's team? Can anyone guide about it?

[@tabishhassan8951]

You just have to be an apologetic Muslim and change your deen by the passage of time to align with modern culture. There you go you are part of it.

[@ahmedkhalid8937]

@@tabishhassan8951 not changing deen

[@sucralfate333]

In Islam, we must follow the Quran and Sunnah as the Prophet taught us, and as understood and practiced by the Salaf, Not based on the understandings and interpretations of hasan ilyas or ghamidi sahab or sahil adeem or any random tom, harry or dick😊🙂

[@Hashaam0]

salaf didn't eat watermelon therefore we will not eat it too, Ahmad bin hanbal

[@sucralfate333]

@@Hashaam0 Senseless reply. Btw do not be a twit Imam Ahmad bin hanbal never said this🤡

[@SajidKhan-jg8bk]

​@@Hashaam0Imam Hanbal never said, what's your source?

[@Hashaam0]

@@SajidKhan-jg8bk I said it sarcstically bcz he used to do such things, wo aik hardcore salafi aur jabriya tha tu har cheez hadees me hi dhoond'ta tha

[@villianair3450]

@@sucralfate333 why understandings of salaf and why not sufis?

[@usero_50]

Invite Qaiser Ahmed Raja on your podcast.

[@wwaqashussain]

totally mentally bankrupt person,

[@MuhammadSaleh-n3j]

Thumbs 👍 up raftaar thanks for making a video ,much knowledgeable

[@isaamuddin9596]

Great talk.

[@waqarali6214]

very well executed ! brilliant!

[@TuahaSohailSiddiqui]

such kind thinker we have need

[@petersands169]

Ap k channel ki videos data pr nhi chalti

[@i_shahzad302]

Request to raftar please invite Qaiser Ahmed raja with Hassan ilyas and cast a podcast like TCM do .... PlZ

[@M.Rasheed-v]

@@i_shahzad302 I also agree

[@MuhammadAnas-n5d]

Yes 👍

[@BilluDon420]

andhon mai kaana raja, qaiser raja, qaiser raja

[@aliakbar5232]

Agree

[@asimmalik2246]

Hassan Ilyas ka peshab nikal jae ga agar Qaiser bhai kay samnay baithna par gaya to

[@ajk.671]

Perfect example 14:14

[@list10s]

Meri Raftar team se request hai k please Khalid mehmood abbasi ko bhi invite karain

[@mahmoodazwar6971]

🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

[@ranahammad4561]

Compounding process me Raftar aghy barh raha hai Appreciate 👍 ❤

[@2269917]

Zaberdast

[@kamranilahi2796]

Sir vadio play ni horahay 😢

[@shifagujjar794]

good job..well needed podcast

[@sherazahmed3722]

2050 ke baray me jo b prediction ki hai woh aik khush fehmi hai.

[@farrukhsiraj6453]

ہمارے مذہبی مدارس مسلک بنا رہے ہیں مسلمان نہیں کالج یونیورسٹی سے ڈاکٹر انجینئر بنتے ہیں تو کیا مدارس کے بچے نہیں بن سکتے پولیو کے قطرے پلانے پر اطراض ہے لیکن کوئی مدرسے والا ایسی لیبارٹری کیوں نہیں بناتے جو یہ طے کرے ہم کو یہ دوا لینی چاہیے یا نہیں

[@MEssa-ot2uj]

Next podcast jaldi ❤❤

[@MuhammadNaveed-jd6xr]

Sir ap itni documentary banate ho..Baldia town me Pani ka shadeed masla hai is pe documentary baneye ye humara Awaami masla hai please sir😢

[@alimasood7116]

Awami masla? Haha bhai bura naa maanna leki ap ki bhool hai ke ye awami masla hai, apki ye soch bhi Galat hai ke ap inki nazar me insaan ho. Ye nizam baldiya ke abadi walo ko gutter ka Keera samjhty hain

[@iftikharali1121]

Request to bring Gamdi sab to raftar please

[@pakflix01]

broadcast with engeniar muhammad ali ❤

[@Hassan_Rajput_PAS]

Hassan Ilyas ❤

[@rajeshwarvishnoi]

Religion cannot save the man It can only show the path

[@Alex_oldmomories]

"Religion can't save the man", said the person who never read the Qur'an with translation.

[@ahmed19924]

There are alot of renowed ulma-e-deen which can be more beneficial than him. Please always invite well renowed ulma-e-deen.

[@abdulrehman9ar]

Great wark ak achy topic par ap ny nazar dali ha

[@faysalqayyum]

Very good video... ❤

[@FarazKhan-du5ef]

Bohat aala!

[@CheckMater007]

If photos are considered haram in Islam, why aren’t videos also haram? After all, a video is essentially a sequence of photos played rapidly to create the illusion of motion.

[@ranadanial7165]

So, you don't know anything about Islam. Photos are not Haram in Islam. Only God's and Prophet's Photos are haram. Not all photos.

[@CheckMater007]

@ranadanial7165 Refer to Sahih al-Bukhari 5949 and Sahih Muslim 2106, as well as Sahih al-Bukhari 5953 and Sahih Muslim 2107 for references on the topic of images in Islam. This isn’t merely my opinion. With the rise of the internet and platforms like KZbin, many Islamic scholars have shifted their stance on photos, perhaps recognizing the impracticality of banning them entirely. However, prior to this, it was more commonly taught that photographs were haram, and there are still scholars who uphold this view. A quick search will reveal this ongoing debate.

[@abbasmazhar567]

Disagree on this opinion which you are talking about that we dont have to rely of salaf and our elders If we disconnect this chain how can we say that this islam which we are following is Accurate. These are our elders which protect our deen with a proper manner and complete chain till our prophet. we have to follow salaf and sahaba but with intellectual thinking and research. Superiority is Quran and hadith and then sahaba, salaf saliheen.

[@waqasahmed1396]

Guest k nazdeek taleem ka matlab sirf Deen say Dori hy, wohi taleem yafta ho skta hay jo Deen say dour hoga

[@mhommadahmad1060]

Tumhare pass 35mint nahi h Pura vidio dekhkar samjhne k

[@waqasahmed1396]

@mhommadahmad1060 tumhen koi takleef hay kya?

[@mhommadahmad1060]

@@waqasahmed1396 koi smjhane k liye itna kosis karta h aur tum Jase jahil Pura dune bagir fatwe lagane lagte ho

[@ahmedkhalid8937]

@@waqasahmed1396 khoty ka khota he rahi, puri video dekhi bhi hai k nahi?

[@waqasahmed1396]

@ahmedkhalid8937 tameez hay nai tumhen bat kerny ki, in jaysy Nam nihad schoolers and engineers may aap jaysy jahil hi payda kiye hen, pori video dekhi hay or uska merkaz yehi hay k taleem yafta wohi hoga jo Deen say dour hoga, aap apni ankhon say perda hataiye

[@AllahSayDarr]

Invite Engineer Muhammed Ali Mirza, 😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮

[@imranriaz009]

ایڈمن کیا وجہ یہ ویڈیو پلے نہیں ہوتی؟

[@muhammadsarfraz1752]

After the independence Colonial Forces took over Pakistan since 1952 & they destroyed everything with 75 years of illegal Rule 😅😅😅😅

[@abbasmazhar567]

اس رائے سے اختلاف کریں جس کے بارے میں آپ کہہ رہے ہیں کہ ہمیں سلف اور اپنے بزرگوں پر بھروسہ کرنے کی ضرورت نہیں ہے۔ اگر ہم اس سلسلہ کو منقطع کر دیں تو ہم کیسے کہہ سکتے ہیں کہ یہ اسلام جس کی ہم پیروی کر رہے ہیں درست ہے۔ یہ ہمارے وہ بزرگ ہیں جو ہمارے نبی تک ہمارے دین کی صحیح طریقے اور مکمل زنجیر کے ساتھ حفاظت کرتے ہیں۔ ہمیں سلف و صحابہ کی پیروی کرنی ہے لیکن سوچ اور تحقیق کے ساتھ۔ فضیلت قرآن و حدیث ہے اور پھر صحابہ، سلف صالحین.

[@ahmedkhalid8937]

kya salaf k zamany mai camera aur internet tha?

[@Aaasim725]

wah RAFTAR..kahan say lay aatay ho aap log itnay zabardast intellects..kabhi kabhi to aisa lagta hay kay dunya main intellects ka fuqdaan hay especially in Pakistan aur phir aapki videos aa jaati hain to koi encourement hoti hay kay himmat nahi haarni aur bas musalsal mahnat karte chalay jaana hay.. I bet agar in sahib jaisay hamare mulk kay madarish teaching system ya educational system sanbhaal lain to na sirf hamari deenwi zindagi balkay dunyawi zindagi bhi sanear sakti hay..well-done RAFTAR

[@codified1]

Problem playing Raftar's videos

[@sbmr]

افسوس کی بات ہے اسلامی معاشرے اور اسلامی امت کی بات ہورہی ہے اور موصوف کو سعودیہ و ایران یاد ہی نہیں آیا صرف ترکی ملائشیا ہی نظر آئے جو سیکولر ہیں

[@DwindlingLamp]

جبر و استبداد کے اڈے اچھی مثال نہیں ہوتے۔

[@waqasahmed1396]

Israel or America say kisny pocha aaj tak?

[@SairaJalilParacha]

The guest is a pseudo intellectual.if his thoughts are implemented by the youth surely they will be more confused about themselves and Deen e Islam. This is the age of Islamic Renaissance. And the true believers of Allah as mentioned in the holy Quran will be the champions of the world sooner or later. If any person who has read the Quran with depth can easily identify the hidden pathetic loser in the words of guest. May Allah guide him towards the truth.

[@rinkumanohar-un7ed]

and galib kamal

[@GhulamMustafa-o5i]

aj confirm hogya ha ya channel Pakistani youth ko complete secular bana rha ha

[@rkkhilji8271]

Acha kar rahye hey

[@Dawood_Rehman]

mashallah bht acha karr rahe hain phir tou.

[@purposefullife87]

Kindly invite qaiser sahab with this this person...

[@revolutionaryplans3369]

Raftar is also a wrong no. If you are not biased then invite sahil adeem and qaiser Ahmed raja also

[@waqasahmed1396]

Yeh kis naujawan ki bat ker rhy hen aap? Kaysy aap yeh bat channel per Beth ker tamam noujawanon k bary bol skty hen?

[@SajidKhan-jg8bk]

True!

[@ghulamfarooque8986]

Jureslum pe q nahi jaskti umat aur hum muslim q bs dard dil mei rkhna h Palestine ke liye sir

[@MuhammadAnas-n5d]

RCMs Imam

[@usamaali2146]

Please someone ask him this: if he really encourages debate and discourse then why don't he accepts invites of such offers? In logo ko bus band kamro mein beth ke baatein kerna aati hain or jub koi inke thoughts ko challenge keray tou yeh bhi babao ki tarah pareshan ho jatay hain.

[@DwindlingLamp]

He and Ghamidi sb sat on TV , and had discussions with big ulama. They are present on KZbin. Stop lying to us. Ilyas was on tv along side one of - ilahi zaheer brothers (ahle hadees) talking about 295 c when someone was deleted by people.

[@youdhveersingh3827]

Pakistan Kalme ke naam par bana tha. Jabtak yahan proper shariya 100% laagu nahi hoga, tarakki nahi ho sakti.

[@sarimansari5374]

Its hilarious how people are crying about Qaiser, but Qaiser only gives them one thing, and it is a "meethi Goli" and they only what that

[@JawwadZahid-e2e]

Jb zawal shuru hua you app ki trah k moseeqi aur khwahish k deen pr chalnai ki waja sai hi haui

[@TalibPirani]

Only possible with Imam Mehdi (A.S)

[@MahaButt-rp3im]

Invite the living legend Enginee Muhammad Ali Mirza

[@muazmohd2670]

Ek baar engineer ka interview chalao😂😂mazaa ajaigaa

[@JawwadZahid-e2e]

Entertainment pr kadgan na lagao netflix soundcloud ko islam ka hissa bana do . Matlab kro jo marzi zindagi jo marzi bs naam Islam rkh di wah New Mullah Wah

[@mohdnaved2863]

Bhaijaan mai India se hoon, jab mai Pakistan mein mazhab bezaari aur yeh baatil roshan khayali dekhta hoon toh yaqeen jaaniye itna khoon khaulta hai aur yahi aawaz aati haii kee agar aiyyashi hee karnee thee toh batwaara kyun karwa diya musalmano kaa, agar India Pakistan aur Bangladesh ke Muslims ek saath rehte toh bhale Hindu se kam rahte lekin phir bhee unke saamne bari taaqat rehte, yeh jo bantwaara hua uska sabse zyada azaab toh India ka Muslim bhugat raha hai, Hindu Pakistan ke Muslims ka toh kuch kar nahin paata, woh bantwaare kaa ghussa Indian Muslims par nikalta hai, ab toh zulm aur zillat kee intaha ho gaee hai Waqai bahut badnaseeb hai Pakistan, Allah ne ek mulk diya aur usmein Islam nahin naafiz kiya gaya

[@swapnilm1856]

Discussion about problem elephant in the room without blaming the elephant, rather celebrating it.

[@tabishhassan8951]

Please don't invite these goons unless for a debate with someone like qaiser ahmed raja. Otherwise its seriously misleading.

[@BilluDon420]

qaiser raja is himself a misinformer

[@SajidKhan-jg8bk]

​@@BilluDon420Don't know about Qaiser Raja but this guy was surely more than a goon!

[@manitrim]

Qaiser Raja is the biggest religious charlatan after Orya Maqbool. Wo Ghalib Kamal aur Awais Iqbal wali debates se jitna zaleel hua hai utna shyd hi koi is daur mei hua ho.

[@ehtisham49]

@@tabishhassan8951 raja 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 lanet tary Deen pa

[@usamaali2146]

@@BilluDon420 you clearly have some personal issues with QAR. you're constantly targeting comments mentioning QAR. i don't understand, bro. it seems like you're a mad fan, lol.

[@jawaidakhter08]

جاوید احمد غامدی کے موقف پر غور کرنے سے معلوم ہوتا ہے کہ وہ کچھ حدیثوں کے مفہوم اور اعتبار سے بھی متفق نہیں ہیں: 1. حدیث کے اعتبار سے: - غامدی صاحب نے کچھ احادیث کو مضعوف یا غیر معتبر قرار دینے کی کوشش کی ہے، جیسے حضرت عیسٰی علیہ السلام کی واپسی اور امام مہدی کے ظہور سے متعلق احادیث۔ - اسلامی علماء کے اکثر جمہور نے ان احادیث کو معتبر اور مقبول قرار دیا ہے۔ 2. حدیث کے مفہوم سے: - غامدی صاحب کچھ احادیث کو ان کے ظاہری مفہوم سے مختلف طریقے سے تعبیر کرتے ہیں۔ - مثلاً آنحضرت ﷺ کی سود سے متعلق احادیث کو معاشی نظام سے منسوب کرکے اس کو مخصوص زمانے تک محدود کرنے کی کوشش کی ہے۔ لہذا کہا جا سکتا ہے کہ جاوید احمد غامدی کچھ حدیثوں کے اعتبار اور مفہوم سے بھی اختلاف کرتے ہیں اور اس طرح وہ کچھ حد تک منکر حدیث بھی ہیں۔ اسلامی علماء کے اکثر جمہور کے موقف سے ان کا موقف مختلف ہے۔

[@SajidKhan-jg8bk]

Bilkul sahih!

[@usero_50]

Now every secular channel & personalities are taking their way and are getting badly exposed one by one Alhamdulillah. So you don't find any other compatible personality to discuss the topic.

[@athar753]

💯✨

[@syedaamir4019]

Dunya kay mamlat itnay kharab hay kay ab sirf imam mahdi he isko thek krskstay hay kio kay anay wala waqt unka hay

[@muhammadsarfraz1752]

All Pakistani Institutions including Judiciary don't like criticism 😅😅😅Root Cause is Absence of Law across Pakistan since 1947 😅😅😅Stick policy implemented from 77 years o. Pakistani society 😅😅Mashajids Become Pvt Ltd(It's a Business in Pakistan)😅😅😅😅 companies

[@umairsiddiqui9696]

Bring back shabber bhai

[@Abdullah-uv9nk]

@9:55 Qaiser Ahmed Raja ke kyuN comments aarahe hai? 😂😂

[@MuhammadHamza-gz4vs]

میں بڑا حیران ہوں انکے امریکہ اور یورپ سے متاثرین ہونے پر ۔۔۔یہ سب جھوٹ ہے وہاں کتنے مسائل ہیں یہ مسلمان ہی بہتر جانتےہیں۔۔۔ان کے سوال ہی بے مطلب ہیں۔

[@Muslim_ilmikitabi]

Bahut Aala!! Very well reasoned ideas and practical steps for positive change. Thanks to Raftar for organizing this

[@waqasahmed1396]

Raftar k level say kahen nechy k guest, afsoos

[@SajidKhan-jg8bk]

Sd afsos!😡😡😡

[@usamaali2146]

@Raftartv Please invite Qaiser Ahmed Raja ! Sir, Yeh RCM ka perspective le liya apne ab hamari bhi baari banti hai.

[@PeopleRepublica]

Firqoo ki dukaanain bandh. Damage has been done.

[@zargarspeaks]

well needed podcast. I request you to continue more and have a session with Ghamidi sb

[@ErHajiHussain]

ہمیں مسلمان کی نہیں اسلام کی حکومت چاہئے مشکل یہی ہے کہ ہم مسلمان کی حکومت کو اسلامی حکومت سمجھتے ہیں ڈاکٹر اسرار احمد فرما گئے ہیں کہ سنی دنیا سن ہے اور أج تک یہی حالت ہے مسلمانوں کو اہلبیت کی طرف أنا پڑے گا ورنہ ترکیی جیسے ممالک کو نمونہ عمل سمجھتا رہے گا

[@SajidKhan-jg8bk]

Kamal Atatuk ki Islam dushmani puri duniya ko maloom ha, k us ne Masajid main ghore( horses) bandwa diye the!😡😡😡 So much for Turkish Islam!

[@JawwadZahid-e2e]

Agar app loog yai sab views k lia nahi kr rehai tou app bulaiyai Mufti Abdul Wahid Qureshi sab ko

[@JawwadZahid-e2e]

ایاک والکتب بدون الاستاذ

[@MumtaazaliMumtaazali-rc1bh]

Apni zaban bolo.ghamidi ki zaban mat bolo.wo bhi uska hawala diye baghe

[@saqibshahzadfarooqi]

Hasan ilyas is a big misinterpretor....you should have invite Qaiser Raja with him...

[@shabtaabz]

How is he a misinterpretor ??

[@Dawood_Rehman]

qaisar raja nigga you sure?😂

[@hidayahtv8010]

Yes bro❤❤

[@amsislamiceducation6839]

Who are these people, where do they come from? Till today no one yet no one knew them , if rafter and some other channels would not invite them, it is request to rafter that please do not take people from every street and village and focus on proper people with proper Islamic and world qualification, what is that when we chose any Engeenier we chose him with proper degree but when it come to Islamic scholars we only chose that unknown and non Qualified peoples . 😅

[@mohammadshameer4302]

Controll Karo Bhai..apni channel Ko conflicted nhi banao.. Yeh aur Iska Baap Kia karte phir rahe qayamat k din Jawab dena parh Jayega..

[@irfansaeedkhan7242]

vote pei haq nhi chori ho jata hai ,adalat mein insaaaf nhi milta ? degree chatoge aap ?? yeh taleem ka nhi jang ka time hai , methi goliyaan de rha hai yeh molvi khak nhi pata chal kya rha hai unsub this channel inke paas koi proper aalim tk nhi hai jo sai jawab dei skay

[@MuhammadHamza-ph5po]

According to the guest: kuch bhi na karo, esy hi ghulami me jeo kiun k hume control kArne walon ko bhi sawal karne wali quaten hen,, Wah kya logic hy

[@adnansiddiqui7177]

Karo magar strategy to batao pehle...

[@alimasood7116]

Teri aqal dekh kr pata lag gaya hai ke tu Pakistan ke Islam aur Nisaab ke haatho barbaad ho chuka hai. Allah tujhe hidayat nhi balke aqal de. Ameen

[@uzairkhan-se4zo]

Should provide equal level playing filed to ulamas as well. yeh jo itni haqeet se dour beth kar batein kar rahein hain. Kisi alim ko bulaty take ap ko asliyat aur haqeeqat batata. What a double standard? Ap ek party par tanqeed kar rahy ho aur unko safai ka moqa bhi nhi de rahe ho. sawal bhi unke khilaf poch rahey ho. jawab bhi un ke khilaf de rahay ho.

[@ghulamfarooque8986]

Bolna ata hai aapko bari izat hai h muslim hun, phir q nahi aap awaz uthe hain without any action just bitching about Israel and Indian article 370, pata ha kya hua Burhan Wani ke baad?

[@alieffendi4224]

Mufti akmal qadri plz invite

[@SajidKhan-jg8bk]

Yes. Please invite Mufti Akmal. Thanks in anticipation!

[@MuhammadKashif-in1jf]

Dear team of raftar, This is the worst podcast . Only one way . Please dont spread negativity in youngsters.

[@Kitchen_1b]

Team Raftar please invite Qaisar Ahmed Raja with Hassan ilyas ❤

[@Stateless.Pakistani]

3:00 talwar k sar pe galba hasil kiya

[@syedaamir4019]

Ghalat admi ko sahi jaga bulaya hay apnay raftar Ya fitnay hay plz avoid kray inko itni ahmiyat na dain ya youth ko kharab krrhay hay