Is it possible to Build a 3d printed Press?

[@RowanNL]

Instead of printing 100% infill you could increase the numbers of perimeters, this will make the gear a lot stronger while not wasting material and print time on the parts where you don't need all that material.

[@blank-re8qv]

99% infill, on gyroid or something similar that uses x and y motion, is actually stronger than 100% infill. 100% defaults as filling the spaces with walls, which all share a common weak axis. however, using gyroid or other infill pattern, they face perpendicular to the axis of which the wall is printed, therefore increasing strength/rigidity perpendicular to the wall, as compared to printing at 100%.

[@julianwitte]

Indeed, 30% infill and 3mm walls should be really sturdy.

[@paulgupta2454]

CNC kitchen actually ran tests that prove more perimeters and thicker perimeters are sturdier than infill

[@spacecowboy07723]

Also higher layer squish or layer depth to previous layer increases strength

[@surajkarmakar2744]

Rd

[@pseudo_goose]

Those gears definitely were going to deform at the axle. It would probably be wise, while you are CNCing, to also make some steel "hubs" that bolt into the final stage gears at a higher radius and transfer the torque there where the forces are much lower, and then the hubs can take the forces on the axle instead of the plastic gears.

[@ThePhotokill]

that's genius!

[@3gearrc]

Or at the very least a crosspin through the shaft and into the gear..

[@wage4598]

You should use bearings. You only see low friction under no load. That's what bearings are for, low friction under load

[@conorstewart2214]

They still aren’t really needed in this project, the gears that don’t have bearings won’t have all that high load on them and if they do, then they are at low speed, the final gears that mesh with the rack have bearings on the ends of the shafts and they are the highest load gears. There also weren’t any problems related to not having bearing on the other shafts, so why add them if they aren’t needed?

[@piercemcmurry7914]

@@conorstewart2214 In the pursuit of over engineering, no cost is too high

[@julikb]

yeah!

[@julikb]

@@piercemcmurry7914 pursuit to invented things.But trying make them wrong

[@theneoangeles]

i think having something to synchronise the two motors (belt or anything else) can also help a lot because those motors are not realy precise and so they can rotate at slightly diferent speed and the press don't push horizontaly (like at 11:25), i think it's reason why your green guide broke (plus the fact that the objects are not flat).

[@juanit0tackit0tackito2]

the Kingdom of GOD is coming…“Silver is for the kettle, and gold for the furnace, but The LORD is the tester of hearts- Bible” your heart is like discovered silver, dirty and not pure, when silver is purified it is melted over and over, to the point that when it’s melted and glows red hot, it is pure enough to see your own reflection in the puddle, so also does the LORD purify your heart, till HE can see HIS own reflection in it, seek the LORD and be reborn, ask The LORD to renew and restore you, repent and ask The LORD for HIS Salvation for those who seek will find and those who knock the door will be open unto them, no man is good, all are in need of salvation, Jesus died so that our sins will be wiped away and so that we could be made new, seek The Kingdom of GOD for if you would be wise you would be wise for yourself, pick up your cross and deny your flesh and follow the path of GOD, for The Kingdom of GOD is at hand, in JESUS MIGHTY NAME Amen and Amen

[@208Concepts]

So, a tip on wiring DC motors: Wiring them in series splits your voltage, and amperage. You can actually wire them in parallel, just flip the polarity. DC motors usually aren't polarized. Parallel allows you to keep the power up and resistance low, resulting in more current capacity.

[@nipdev6666]

Series splits amperage, parallel splits voltage.

[@reidprichard]

@@nipdev6666 You got that backward.

[@nipdev6666]

@@reidprichard yeah I did, but the point still stands.

[@MaxImagination]

Fantastically-made mechanical press! Great work as usual... I really like the fact that you started implementing a bit of voice-overs ;) Your videos have become more profesional!

[@retsetman9698]

Glad to hear that Max, Thanks a lot:)

[@MaxImagination]

@@retsetman9698 Always, bud! 😎

[@IvoTichelaar]

My grandfather was a traditional book binder. He had a beautiful cast iron book press, which was very easy to operate (with your little pinky toe, so to speak) and would press down very hard. It was simple, but precise engineering. The press is moving sideways a lot in your design. You lose contact at the gears, which makes them slip, and the press slides along the object it is pressing. Adjusting that aspect would help, imo. Also, weight, weight and more weight.

[@dale7561]

Man, it won't be long before your channel blows up! I am certain. This is really quality content! You use the simulation on Fusion 360, and it would be great to see some more beginner lessons on how to use the F360 simulation for 3D printing. Also, it would be great to have some more detailed videos on the calculations you use and how we can implement them in our own projects! Thanks for the great vids - you got a new sub!

[@retsetman9698]

Thanks a lot! You actually gave a good idea and may be i can mention about the calculations roughly through the end of the videos anymore.

[@dale7561]

@@retsetman9698 Sounds great. It is something that makes me really interested in your videos - Pro-Maker videos - like makers who want to go to the next level!

[@NUENG_v.5.356]

@@retsetman9698 12:59 motorover

[@pawepeszko9726]

@@retsetman9698 You can use engine from car window cleaner, its much more powerfull (14Nm) but have slower rotation 😀

[@MsTubby420]

Only thing I would recommend is 2 guide rails and 4 bushings from McMaster carr. Could extend the base and top plates to accept the bushings. Would eliminate any misalignment and flexing on the frame.

[@thememegeneer5716]

this just popped up on my recommended. Instant sub!

[@retsetman9698]

Glad to hear that, thanks a lot 👍

[@josipbalaban783]

You need to add walls to the side of the press that it can ride against so the press face doesn't skew

[@mrono1910]

Add a belt between the two engines on the output of them so they go in sync on eatch side so the press doesnt tilt from side to side when you squish something

[@andraskovacs5247]

the amount of work that goes into your videos.... amazing

[@aaroneugene1654]

Awesome video. 9:12 , you basically made a gravity powered DC generator, well, for a very short duration haha. I wonder if you hooked up an AC motor and basically pulled/pushed the press up and down if it would output an AC signal.

[@steelcannibal]

Just found your channel last night, totally digging your projects, keep up the great work!

[@bobsmith3291]

Dig it ! Dig it!

[@mariusj8542]

I calculated this back in the University many years ago. It’s two main forces that are under pressure. 1 is the axels, the other is the teeth surface on the gears. You can easily solve both with widen the gears, so that the surface area increases. In short make the gears wider. Then off course you can calculate pressure based on the ratios. You can in principle achieve hydraulic pressure with gears, but the “power density” of hydraulics is hard to compete with.

[@weareallbeingwatched4602]

Geared rollers - or just rubber rollers / cams

[@NiSE_Rafter]

This is the way. Everyone trying to say oh use X filament or Y filament and this or that but those are only marginal improvements at best versus designing this to work with 3d printing constraints.

[@mimimi9170]

Hocam eline sağlık, güzel işler çıkarıyorsun. 👍👍

[@Genjure]

Using straight cut gears may give more torque due to the thicker teeth and surface area of contact between the gears but it will become noticeably louder. One of the other comments 6 months ago suggested PLA+ like in firearms. PLA+ is good for handling the shock from said device and not a gradual load. I have no suggestions on material though so go for it. Also I think the Algorithm sent me?

[@hasanrcn]

Profesyonelce hazırlanmış ve çok fazla emek içeren bir çalışma olmuş. Animasyonlar ve analizler muhteşem.👏👏👏👍

[@retsetman9698]

Çok teşekkürler 👍

[@arsimert]

Türk olma ihtimalin var mı diye yorum atarken cevabımı aldım. Eline sağlık

[@mimimi9170]

@@arsimert Ben de :)

[@JustinDaze]

Cool design!

[@retsetman9698]

Thanks man!

[@ESS284]

Great job using the graphics dude, really enjoyed it.

[@pawepeszko9726]

You can use engine from car window cleaner, its much more powerfull (14Nm) but have slower rotation 😀

[@brett567]

Next up on the hydraulic press channel we crush a punny plastic imposter 😂 Serious note.. Fun build looks like a great toy and bet you learned a ton along the way

[@dustinsmith8341]

I have never heard of PCBway doing CNC stuff before. Crazy because I've heard many people advertise their pcb stuff.

[@embers_falling]

They also do metal 3d printing which is cool. They actually have *hella* services it’s impressive

[@embers_falling]

They also do metal 3d printing which is cool. They actually have *hella* services it’s impressive

[@osmanpasha_diy]

Crushing nuts and cans is not what hydraulic presses are usually used for) Do you have actual forces of the resulting press?

[@3Diest]

Hello, Do you have any tutorial to design Herringbone Rack and pinior gears?

[@retsetman9698]

You can draw a helical gear and simply mirror it. I briefly showed in the last parts of my which gear performs best video

[@claws61821]

I've been thinking about doing this for a while myself but didn't know where to start. Mine probably wouldn't be with v-slot or 2020 rails, though XD Those are still a bit outside my budget ATM thanks to unforeseen events. I think you would get a lot more performance out of this if you redesigned the frame gantry to eliminate that rather significant canting to either side as it's coming down. It was more than 30° out of alignment at some points in the demonstration. That adds a LOT of resistance into the system, regardless of herringbone gears.

[@SianaGearz]

Problem is with these DC motors there is nothing to synchronise them. Depending on differences in friction and load it will always drift. I'm thinking of using a belt to drive and synchronise a while bunch of m4 threaded rods, like maybe a dozen of them. They would provide both the bulk of reduction and the force would be distributed. Cheap construction? Just square box alu section, you can braze them together or use angles and plates to connect them.

[@eideticex]

@@SianaGearz I wonder if adding a clutch mechanism to the out put of each would help. Kind of like the slip type of clutch where it has play to slip forward but not backward (no idea what that's call, just seen it in a lot of random gadgets).

[@SianaGearz]

@@eideticex I can't see that it necessarily would? Depending on friction and the like the forward speed of DC motors is different, even unloaded two "identical" motors off the same batch could differ by several percent due to low precision construction. Back slippage isn't really the issue here. If you were to implement a clutch like mechanism it better detect which of the motors is too far forward and apply extra friction to that. I do think this is possible but i don't have anything in mind.

[@TheRealStructurer]

Nice video and project explained in the right pace and no nonsense 👍🏻

[@slimsqde7397]

wow i love how you did all the math on everything, dont see many channels do that, very impressive, i design things but never do the math that stuff is way over my head and just new, im only educated up to trig level so nothing to crazy high

[@jimmlynden2261]

Beautiful work. 👏👏👏👏

[@embers_falling]

Bro is just drawing on his wall with a pencil 😂 love that

[@gaetanclamart5963]

There are mathematical calculations at 5:14 Is there a website to learn how to do these calculations please?

[@core36]

Did my comment just not post? Anyway, Can you share how you made those gears and linear parts so they fit together? This is exactly what I need for a project of mine

[@JL-pc2eh]

5:00 I wondered why you didnt use a higher module for these gears already

[@davem45]

On the surface that crushes your items. Would it help putting those arms in tracks so they bare down evenly and not apply uneven stress to the gears? I hope that question makes sense

[@NeoIsrafil]

You should set a second limit switch on the downward travel, on a sliding bracket that will allow you to quickly adjust how far it smashes into things, and so if it accidentally fires off it won't strip its gears at the bottom of travel. Best practices dude, always follow em if you can and it won't do you wrong.

[@Helpyourselfs]

I think it would be stronger to use a cable for the pulldown force instead of the linear gear

[@cesararmandogarciamtz.7402]

4:22 A moment of silence for all those suzanne who give their lives for the simulation of science and technology

[@excitedbox5705]

A $30 car jack will produce 5 tons of force. I think you would have been much more successful adding gears, a frame and a motor to a car jack and with 2 jacks could easily have 10 tons of crushing force.

[@wtechboy18]

I think you should design the next one with some lever action, so the 3d printed parts aren't taking the brunt of the torque. For example if you had a scissor jack and made one of the arm halves on each side much longer past the fulcrum, you can get a very long lever that still preserves some kind of parallel motion.

[@julikb]

lever+ screw

[@HariharSubramanian1996]

I can imagine that teddy bear saying "why you bully me" 🤣🤣🤣

[@katiebarber407]

the fact that you use blender makes me respect you infinitely more

[@pstrap1311]

With this design the force produced by the press is limited to the sheer strength of a single tooth on the pinion gear/rack multiplied by the number of pinions/racks on the final stage. So one way to increase the force produced before failure would be to increase the size of the gear tooth, or to increase the number of racks on the piston.

[@rodanvsandrew]

Love this. What is the name of the aluminum extrusion you used?

[@2009dudeman]

80/20 you can get them in imperial or metric, just about anything you'd want, they have.

[@ronburroughs8200]

Is it possible to make a mini 3d printed can & plastics shredder, using those gear ratios?

[@gedr7664]

did you make the square bar perfectly round with just a file?? w0w

[@maxjointoyeurpro5994]

Bravo pour votre partage 👍

[@markmywords5342]

Where did you learn how to figure this out? The way you modeled it, had it in excel doing the math for you, and even had a program showing stress points, is amazing to me. Any way you can point me in a direction for resources?

[@gfr2023]

Amazing job!!! In your design you unload the stress of the pressing action on gears. If you look at a screw press version you notice that with that design the gears turn only and the stress is adsorbed by frame

[@mistaecco]

Really cool project! I'm currently drafting plans for a project to test out sensors that'll be stepped on, torturing them in various ways to see what will make them fail sooner. Not sure how much I can get away with 3D printing, but I'll definitely be trying to do as much as I can. Might just end up basing my design off of some of what you've shown here :)

[@MrChachacha64]

💪🏿😅

[@hmt0939]

You may consider adding current limiter to motors, and pressure sensor to main table

[@literate-aside]

Loved this. Would like to see a second gen, with: Solution to keep the press straight Reinforcement of the gears More power

[@zbigniewloboda3393]

1:42 You limited the force of press to force which can withstand the tooth of gear. Which tooth and which gear would be an interesting math activities. It would be a better to use the simple leaver.

[@BspPlays9287]

Think if you did block and pully system instead, would you get more power? You would have to spring load the press to return to neutral. Just a thought.

[@Chris-wf2lr]

Is it true that mechanical press is better than hydraulic if you don't mind about speed very much? for example cold welding two thin aluminium sheets together would require the mechanical press to move only slightly and so speed not so important because only a small distance to move. I would make one for cold welding stainless steel sheets and build up structure by adding layers that have been cut with lasers. Like a 3d printer but with cold welding and I could use supportive structure cut into the steets for difficult shapes which would later be removed. I think mechanical is better for that than hydraulic but what do you think?

[@JamieBainbridge]

It is time for MGN H linear guides and get PCBWay to CNC the gears from metal.

[@RixtronixLAB]

Creative video, thanks for sharing it :)

[@hamishfox]

I love the danger tape

[@nandino]

Whats the software you use to makes the mechanical animations?

[@jeffh4581]

Hey, nice job on the animations. Those really help.

[@laurentoutan9922]

PCB WAY c'est génial combien coûte par exemple votre plaque sur mesure ? Merci

[@anto427]

i think that connetting gears to axels by splines instead of squared angles can improve gears life

[@hiroshrosh3535]

it would be really cool to see a part two to this with all of the 3d printed parts printed in metal instead, if i remember correctly pcb way offers that now too

[@Fulou]

would a piece of threaded rod not be better to apply the force?

[@theremoteanater]

What if I make molds of the gears and cast them out of a metal alloy

[@conorstewart2214]

Why did you use 3D printed T nuts instead of just normal metal ones? Also the press seems a little flimsy, it might be better if you strengthened the frame and added some linear rails or something. With all the flexing of the press bit I’d be surprised if the plastic rail at the back is still intact. I would also be surprised if you were actually getting 2000 N out of it, it seemed to struggle quite a bit with crushing things, like the can.

[@josephjacklett]

Why not use a torque limiter to keep your gears from breaking?

[@Spook_Boi]

13:00 i was hoping the bottle cap would go shooting lol

[@BishopVapes]

Can you use stepper motors instead of DC motors please and thank you.

[@Gambiarte]

I believe you should put something to sync both motors.

[@salihaydn2260]

Now I see why there is no video for three months.

[@retsetman9698]

Thanks a lot my friend👍

[@TheMetalButcher]

I have a lathe with herringbone gears. You didn't see them much until 3d printers due to cost.

[@kcscustom9759]

A very interesting idea🤔

[@NearEDGE]

I will say, that steel plate did not need to be CNC machined. With just a center punch, careful measurements, a saw, and a regular power drill you could have very easily made that yourself from 1'x1' sheet steel.

[@divertechnology]

GREAT MAN!!! this is really useful experiment! you are a pather. why didn´t you use just straight teeth and not that like V?

[@stefanguiton]

Great video!

[@retsetman9698]

Thank’s a lot.

[@desiman289]

can you use this to make cold press juice?

[@dtec30]

Might pay to have side guides for the lowering plate to stop side play

[@smorrow]

Can you get Torx shafts?

[@dishahotwani8124]

Pls use metal gears. Will u use ?

[@pizzainc.1465]

In games: hey why is my hydraulic press floating up at an accelerating rate?

[@karmicknight]

I definitely like the idea of the video but long drawn out technical explanations is tough to sit through for anyone that's not seriously interested in learning. There's a channel on youtube that does these kinds of experiments but with lego and they do the videos without talking at all and it holds my interest through the whole thing.

[@TheDistur]

Idk if it is practical for anything but it is a neat project.

[@vanhieule6263]

Can you share the software you use to simulate the distortion?

[@acdettwiller]

how many nuts to break a traditional press?

[@aminghanchi8721]

Sir what is the diameter of each gears

[@themanfromcabowabo1559]

Is it possible to build a 3D printer instead of the printing press?

[@madjimms]

Do some FEA and acetone the parts so they are smooth on the outside.

[@theluc1f3r93]

I thin star like metal rod (not square) at least for cogs joints, and larger/wider cogwheel with teeths with 100% infill all from ASA it would hold up to 200KG or maybe more.

[@graphenepixel8231]

Can you make a chromium cast out of those gears, I bet it could withstand a crap ton of mechanical stress.

[@abo_9al7]

Try increasing the gear ratio it might make it stronger but you will probably need stronger gears

[@Brickedaboss07]

What are the slotted rods everyone is using for building 3d stuff I wanna find where to get some Edit:( I mean those metal extrusions with the slots

[@Joe-xr2xl]

What about a worm gear inline with a rack. That should be the strongest for something like this.

[@ronbaer67]

now can it bend steel flats

[@jafinch78]

I totally was thinking a lost PLA casting metal version, no?

[@am_astro_backup]

you could buy metal gears like aluminium ones they dont break easily but slightly costlier

[@laurentoutan9922]

Bin Voila un parfait compacteur de canette ! Réellement

[@정미자-z5v]

수위치켜는걸 어떻게 만들면 스위치가 켜지고 어떻게 만들면 스위치가 꺼지는법 만들때 스위치 안쪽에 무슨선이 어텋게 연결해야 되는지 알려 주셔야만 한국인기가 많으실거 같습니다

[@arekrudy3662]

Make the intermediate gears from PETG Stronger layer adhesion

[@Orphanlast]

So... this was a cool video. So, if I were to scale this up, I could do some cool shit. Like, before you broke it. You might have been able to make an adobe brick with that little compressing machine. Scaled up, made of steel... you could press Hempwood with it. Or Bamboo stands into Baboo plank or pillar or whatever. Like, seriously... this was a good... simulation. Suppose you were in Madagascar, and the best technology is a car. I suppose, there might be a way to set two car engines on either side. What if you wanted a hand cranked press. Like... low tech. Wouldn't you want some worm drive setup at the bottom output? That way the design works as it currently does, but it retains tension. I suppose the worm drive would be the hand crank. I suppose if you wanted a hand cranked one... you'd need a third gear set... so... the gear sets would be covering 3/4ths of the faces to the press machine... and the whole machine could be made of hempcrete. So it could begin getting constructed within 150 days (the time it takes for a harvest of hemp). Lol. With a third gearset... wouldn't you have more torque. (Is that the term?) More power with less stress on the gears? Anyhow... if it was a manually cranked press... it would be less stress on the guy cranking it too. That guy cranking it would need one BIG wheel to crank it... I think. Lol. Leverage is your friend, especially when it comes to compressing materials, to make a DIFFERENT material. Like compressing hemp fibers and glue. PAPOW! Hardest wood on earth. Right there. With the machinery that an ingenuitive cave man could invent and make, with ease. He'd need to know a bit about Botany. But Hemp's not a picky plant. He'd get a shit load of cool shit from that plant. But Hempcrete is just hemp fibers, water, and lime. You compact it into any form. Wait to dry. It's harder than concrete with no steel reinforcement. He could make pottery forms of everything. Cast the hempcrete. Assemble it (because Hemp isn't heavy). Lol... I'm no one to ask... but... could you... make that video? I just subscribed. :)