Is Karachi facing an Economic Genocide? Ali Zaidi Vs Shabbar Zaidi, MM Podcast, Part-03

"Is Karachi facing an Economic Genocide? Part 01" Watch a candid discussion between former Federal Minister Ali Haider Zaidi and Former FBR Chairman Shabbar Zaidi.
-----------
MM News TV - The Unbiased Perspective
MM News is a subsidiary of the MM Group of Companies. It was established in 2019 with the aim of providing people of Pakistan access to unbiased information.
-----------
Follow us on:
Website: mmnews.tv/
Twitter: / mmnewsdottv
Facebook: / mmnewsdottv
Instagram: / mmnewsdottv
-----------
Watch Previous Episodes:
Ep 01: • Establishment or Govt:...
Ep 02: • Pakistan Hasn't Change...
Ep 03: • Corruption: The Ultima...
Ep:04: • FBR Should be Shut Dow...
-----------
Economic Genocide of Karachi:
Part -01: • Is Karachi facing an E...
Part-02: • Is Karachi facing an E...
-----------
#shabbarzaidi #alizaidi #z2 #povertyline #tax #psdp #establishment #businessmen #bureaucracy #naidqasid #pakistanipolitician #pakistanipolitics #govtemployees #pansion #sindhwastemanagement #karachi #genocide #economycrisis #dataanalytics #economicgeography #economyofpakistan #muradsaeed #corruptioninpakistan #altafhussain #mqm #mqmlondon #kachiabaadi #uno #sindhi #muhajir #sindhpolice #propertymafia #propertytaxes #quaideazam #indiaproperty #waterissues #karachimafia #kpt

[@GuzzarAwan]

😂😂😂😂 why ZARDARI and Fojis will leave the golden egg laid by Hen called karachi. Suplus labor of Mohazirs r extracted by rangers jarnails and PPP wadheras without giving them basic needs of life

[@bhadshakhanaa]

Zalim governance

[@msr7373]

Dear Indian guy, thanks for your concerns but some pointers for you to better camouflage yourself. Its MUHAJIR not MOHAZIR, it's WADERA not WADHERA and it's GUJJAR not GUZZAR

[@faz5171]

@@msr7373 not his fault, too much cow urine killing his brain cells

[@javedfazal59]

Wise words from Shabar Zaidi sb ! Points to ponder for those in power!

[@nizamuddinahmadaali3244]

EXAMPLE: PECHS block 2 had a park where children and women used to walk in the evening. Mullas built a masjid later m,address was built. Justice Gulzar order3d the recovery of the park by demolition. Court order said “ park is public property and is only for play ground and waking, therefore all the structures should be removed.” Mullas created a narrative “ government wants to demolish masjid and madrasa to biol a park and recreation place” Completely distorted and false rumor . Which public started to believe simply be aud a holy man who is wearing “ an Islamic attire “. What a lie and disinformation. by demolishing by demolition.

[@vjam139]

And, and, and a much larger amenity plot for a mosque and a park situated in the centre of Kashmir Road, Hali Road, Sir Syed Road & Allama Iqbal Road (P.E.C.H.S Block 2) has been encroached upon. There is a private nursery on it, and many houses have been built illegally. How can someone expect that there will still be a vacant plot in PECHS Block 2, but 2 units are in the process of construction on a 1,000 square yards on the same amenity plot. Only masjids have not been built illegally on the amenity plots.

[@deserter25]

Prior to partition Karachi was part of Bombay Presidency.

[@msr7373]

Because british made it that way. Even northern Karnataka was under Bombay presidency as well as entire gujarat was in Bombay presidency.

[@Changeisconstant-dg2yd]

@deserter25 Whole Sindh was part of Bombay presidency

[@user-dx8fd7yg9b]

Always good to hear Shabbar sahab

[@ashalivarma4623]

You have no idea how much I suffer because Delhi is divided between state and Centre. When it was a Union Territory it was magnificent

[@GuzzarAwan]

@@ashalivarma4623 most Modern infra in delhi was built by Shila dixit. CM of delhi . BJP was at centre

[@Rohit_verma_ui]

​@@GuzzarAwan arey quom you are using free water because of aap

[@masroorkhalil9655]

how can pakistan improve pls share your ideas?

[@jamesbundi1468]

Karachi should be a separate province

[@Changeisconstant-dg2yd]

Pass a 2/3rd majority resolution in Sindh and federal assembly

[@manojbhavsar9217]

In India we have tax on open land in Maharashtra 2.2 Rs per metre per month

[@World_Explorer_GIS]

I am in love with Mr Shabbar

[@ZoonChenar-lw5hx]

Why not sell the Quaid mazar too like jam sadiq? Dont leave any open green space. The Queen asked Walpole the price to buy Hyde Park... he said THREE CROWNS.... the king's the queen's and the crown prince's crowns.

[@ZoonChenar-lw5hx]

The population is too great so local govt with LOCAL BUDGET directly from fed govt and local police control ... all over Pakistan

[@S4NM]

Ali Zaidi Saheb & Shabbar Zaidie Saheb = why dont you put a condition to Sindh government that make entire provience as FREE from street crimes (No Mobile Snatch, No Bike / No Car or No Jewelley or No ATM Cash Snatch), put this proposal with Tajir Association. If government can make the Sindh (Karachi & Huderabad) FREE from Street crimes, all shops in both cities will start paying PKR 2,000/= monthly in terms of TAX with 10% increase per-year! Raise the same option in Sindh Assembly

[@affanzubair213]

Bhai karachi ko bachana hai to zardari or fouj/Fouji establishment ko nikalo Karachi ko bachao

[@HistorywithShahrukh]

Ali zaidi k pass bus kahanian hain sunany ko k me yaha gya waha gya shabbar sahab k pass knowledge hai wisdom hai

[@tahirahmedzia7157]

Poory pakistan ki aik hi problem hy. Hr jaga warddk gussi hui hy. 25 crore awaam aik ho kr jaan nhi chrwaa sakti.

[@CraftiMize]

That religious party has legacy of deliverance they aren't corrupt they had transformation plan and the same replica of that party is rulling Turkey throughout the nation. That religious party had best mayor's. They are more democratic then your's PTI.

[@AliKhan-fk8ev]

so non serious, ali zaidi. this man has no concentration

[@ZoonChenar-lw5hx]

There is a 3 story mosque on chundrigar next to std chartered bank and opposite Habib bk and Cotton exchange

[@lifewithfarrukh7691]

Mandate na hone ke byjud from 2007 Zardari sahab is tying to take over the city called "Sonay ka Anda deny wli murgi also known as Karachi", ab kr lea take over, Mayor Karachi bhe Zardari sahab ka, CM bhe zardari sahab ka Finance department, Home department sub under Zardari sahab us ke byjud Karachi ka satiya nas horha hay Soteli ma wla salook hy Karachi ke sath ye log Kbhi bhe Karachi or Hyderabad sy sincere nh ho sakte.

[@GuzzarAwan]

@@lifewithfarrukh7691Mohazir talented hote h. In sab ko bughz isi baat ka h

[@rj6404]

Bandar kya janey ad'rakh ka swaad .. sub kuch de diya in bandaron ko , sub tabaah kar diya , satya'naash , insaan ke bache bano, kisi aur ke liye nahin , apne khatir .

[@alexrudulf781]

Awaaz hee nhee hotee podcast main

[@K.Riaz59]

It's the Port authority of New York and New Jersey that controls all the 3 airports, as well as the World Trade Center building.

[@bluebird7575]

Sir land acquisition law 1894 kay upper b bat karain ... government qabza kar layti hai aur pasay vnahi dyti na wapis krti

[@Health-Blitz]

Karachi Should Be a Separate Country Like Singapore

[@Broken_Bulb]

Please wait apko bati bana k detay hain iski separate...

[@asadali2311]

@@Broken_Bulbwoh batti aap apnay chootar main daal lo.

[@Health-Blitz]

@@asadali2311 😂🤭

[@madotlive]

😂​@@asadali2311

[@madotlive]

Karachi should federal capital territory or union territory with its own budget😊

[@jamalzaidi4200]

This is True, British did not confirmed karachi.

[@Zul994]

Armey garnels ney barbad kya karachi ko or nawaz Sharif ney number 2 zardari ney

[@zaf7794]

The policy of plot should be on second or third plot. People cannot buy a land and do construction in just 3 years, it will put a strain on the coffers.

[@muhammadarsalan1805]

Bhai ye Banda Karachi me itna Kuch new banane ka bol Raha hai is ko koi batay k Sindh government ko corruption karni hai in Sab Kamo me ye Sindh government Pakistan ko or maqrooz kar day gi

[@vikasb1400]

Example should be given from Sudan Nigeria Chad Syria Liberia Iraq Yemen Lybia Uganda as they are comon and biradar Mulk

[@ChefbyMistake]

Come see Syria and Iraq.

[@msr7373]

Ab tum kuch bhi boltay raho. Tumhair bharat mata khandit hi chuki hai and you are not getting Bangladesh and Pakistan back. 😂😂😂

[@user-xz8mp1em8r]

Next part

[@tahirhabib4056]

Good topic for Karachi city.

[@MuhammadNawaz-tc8zr]

شاہ صاحبان ❤ بڑی مدت کے بعد ایک پر مغز گفتگو سنی ورنہ قحط الرجال کے اس دور میں بات کرنے کو ترستی ہے زباں میری

[@ZoonChenar-lw5hx]

Isksmabad is militarily defensible. Karachi is not defensible from naval attack despite Manora fort.

[@faisalahmed1268]

Balakot mein aa ge thay na Ander. Islamabad ballot say Kitna dour hai.

[@shoaib526]

Jb ya seat per hota hain en logon chars pee hwi hota hai. Ab salah ko policies yaad aa rhi hai. Ya bewakuf bana rhy hain awam ko

[@bluebird7575]

Sir land acquisition law per bat karain

[@danishsiraj8242]

Plotting k peche kon cantonments kis k har major issue k peche wahi ek

[@sarwarabbas2723]

Like GCC to build a Masjid need to get Permission from Ministry of Auqaf

[@shivajibhilare2881]

To build huse masjid it is rediculous statement given who known intellectual person

[@IrshadAhmed-su6sk]

Ali zaidi is tout of establishment.

[@hassanjalal822]

❤❤❤

[@vlogsunchained]

Shabbar bhai, thora sa halka ajayein. Ali bhai is trying his best to be as safe as possible

[@muqeetmasood4383]

there is not a single state masjid in saddar and ii chundruigar rd

[@zaf7794]

Karachi should not be paying anymore tax whether its property or any other tax. People are already paying high taxes. Ask from othere provinces and cities to pay their due tax first.

[@BAQARABBAS-yf5sx]

Shabar zaidi rocks n Mr. Ali zaidi kindly listen to wise men Infront of you.

[@mohammadyousuf1806]

If Ali Zaidi is in this programme, then it is bad news

[@zoyee1]

I am only watching this because of Shabbar Zaidi Sahab, though I would never listen to Ali Zaidi at all. He had all the power to do something for Karachi, and he failed us badly. He was never accessible, never available, and never existed after he was given Karachi by PTI.

[@tempuser109]

Karachi under corporate governance? MUNGERILAL KE HASEEN SAPNE

[@Khalidkhaan528]

My favourite is shabar zaidi❤

[@javaidabbasjeeda]

Karachi should be capital again

[@syedaamir4019]

Ap jasay power or pasay walay log bhi itnay baybas hay dekh kay sharam ati hay aplog sirf batain krsktay hay lakin is nizam ko na khatam krsktay hay na is system say larh sktay hay ap logo nay apni life pori trya enjoy krli hay or ab bhi krrhay hay kbhi ap logo nay 18000 kamanay walay guard ki life ka socha uska lia kuch kia nahi kia na kch krygay

[@farhanrazzak5813]

Bahria Town Expensive...YES...is it worth it..Absolutely (if you can afford it) You have to clean the common areas, and that is what HOA (Home Owners Association fees) in first-world countries is for, this concept is in the USA, Europe, Dubai, Moscow, and Some Arab countries...Pakistanis are not used to it. so they are Angry as to why they have to pay for Clean Sewers, Parks, and Streets in Bahria Town...Why do they have to pay for Parks, Why do they have to pay for someone else's kids, Playing in beautiful Lawns and Gardens...Pakistanis are used to living with loadshedding, Broken sewer lines, Broken roads, Walled homes, and smelly toilet water in front of their expensive homes.....That's why Bahria town is Different. Bahria Town is the ONLY first World City(after Islamabad) in Pakistan. Tension Free-living (for the rich), Pakistanis are sending watan, $50 BILLION dollars a yr ($35 billion dollars via Banks, huge amount) Pak is not poor, it has huge population, 5th largest in the World, so some people in Pakistan will remain poor. Bahryia will fill up...Pakistan zindabad....We need more cites like BahrIa Town.....From the USA

[@moosakhan2687]

شبر زیدی صاحب اپ نے تمام باتیں کی ھیں ان سے اتفاق کرتا ہوں مگر سب اھم کراچی سے جو ٹیکس وصول کیا جا رہا ھے اس کا کتنے پرسنٹ کراچی پر خرچ ہو رہاھے یہ نہی بتا یا

[@asadali2311]

Separate karachi from pakistan. We can sustain on our own. Bhikarion ko khilanay ka hum ne thaika nahin lia hua

[@kmvlogs5288]

Tu aik indian suwar ha ais lye bhokta rah 😂😂😂😂

[@kamaqlmolvi7812]

At least Sind say separate karain nahee to ya wadairay is ko tabah kardaingay.

[@asadali2311]

@@kamaqlmolvi7812 sindh to sab se bara bhikari hai tatti dhoni nahin aati badmashi aati hai. Nikalo haramion ko and make karachi a separate country. We don’t need any more bhikari

[@urduone6007]

​@@kamaqlmolvi7812 صوبہ بنانے سے قبل گلگت بلتستان ، اور فاٹا ماڈل بھی ٹراٸی کیا جاسکتا ہے ۔ مگر سندھ دھرتی ڈاٸن سے ہر صورت کراچی کو الگ کرنا ہی پڑے گا ۔ آخر کب تک مہاجروں کی ازلی دشمن سندھی نسل پرست جماعت ہر الیکشن ہارنے کے باوجود مفت میں کراچی پر حکومت کرتی رہے گی ۔ دنیا میں کہیں بھی الیکشن ہارے پر کسی کو کونسلر تک کے اختیارات نہیں ملتے مگر پیپلزپارٹی کو کراچی حیدرآباد میں ہر الیکشن ہارنے کے باوجود نا صرف صوباٸی حکومت مل جاتی ہے بلکہ کراچی کے تمام سرکاری اداروں میں سرکاری ملازمین کو بھرتی ترقی تعیناتی ، تبادلے اور احکامات دینے کے اختیارات مل جاتے ہیں ۔ پولیس رینجرز کو احکامات دینے ، آپریشن کرنے ، زمینوں کی خریدو و فروخت ، بجٹ بنانے ، اور ٹاون اور ضلاع کی حدود طے کرنے کے اختیارات الیکشن ہارنے کے باوجود مفت میں مل جاتے ہیں ۔ آخر یہ تماشہ کب تک چلے گا ؟ آخر کب تک مہاجر بیگانی شادی میں عبداللہ دیوانہ بن کر ناچیں گے اور احساس بیگانگی کی زندگی جیٸیں گے ؟ حل صرف مہاجر صوبہ ❤ شیٸر

[@muhammadsaqib2961]

Hahaha haha plot zaya ho raga ha ....dha, bahria ....he defines karachi situation on lighter note......dha n bahria

[@AjayKumar-uk4sp]

Basically he does not want to be in pakistan and asking for separate Sindh 😮

[@asadali2311]

Separate karachi from Pakistan

[@GuzzarAwan]

@@AjayKumar-uk4sp lol u won't understand the politics . Better stay away 😂

[@muhammadhassaansiddiqi8586]

Ali zaidi fazool btayen krta ha, is kahen cuhp raha kre bs shabber ku bolne den.

[@ImtiazAli-sn1nh]

please let shbbar speak

[@afzalidrees720]

Shbbr shb ya kaam sheya comnity na bhi kia ha hr elaky ka kony pa Imam bargah bnya hva ha

[@danishsiraj8242]

Only 4 th option

[@muqeetmasood4383]

Karachi was the capital designated by Quaid e Azam. who transfer it .... A dictator ... this decision can be revoked.

[@shahidhassan8799]

Wild dreams

[@HistorywithShahrukh]

Who is only for Shabbar sahab???

[@kamaqlmolvi7812]

Karachi ko sind say alahada karain aur is ka control karachi kay parhay likhay awam ko dain. Sindhi apna sindh ko taraqee nahee day saka to karachi ka bhee baira garakh karaingay. Sindhi aur Baloch qom parastee kee bimaree may laga howa hain aur aisee qaumain taraqee nahee kar saktee. is kay ilawa, PIA, property mafia wagaira ko punjabi tasalut say bhee azad karain.

[@ashalivarma4623]

I have lived in New York and you are wrong. New York has a countries in it. Karachi has only Pakistani people. Even Mumbai is more cosmopolitan with every state and several countries residing in it.

[@virtualinsanity4446]

You've misunderstood him, he means to say that hundreds of different ethnic people reside in Karachi.

[@furqansalam7013]

Shubbar Bhai Khuda ko Mano puri dunya main log land khareed kar hold karate Hain phir sell karate Hain is main Kya burai hai Bhai agar aap construction charges bohat kum karden to log Ghar banalengay agar aap utilities provide Karen to bhi log Ghar banalengay us ki to baat karo

[@9Rehankhan19]

Every time he compares Pakistan with india. Do Indians compare themselves with China? Get out of this mindset. You need to compare Pakistan with Pakistan. How was Pakistan 5 years back.? Is it same or improved or downgraded ??

[@Apala-ou8jt]

True , we indian lot of promblem

[@pakistanfuntime3423]

karachi is capital city of sindh .jes ko rehne hain rehe jes ko jana jae baqi karachi sindh ka hisa hai hemsha rehega

[@Furnitureworld-r3c]

The pain of Karachi is only for the people of Karachi who speak Urdu

[@Changeisconstant-dg2yd]

Mohajirs are responsible for Altaf's onslaught on Karachi 's population

[@Spooky_Screenings]

Pakistan inshallah default hona walla hai

[@malikpunjani3413]

Sir jee musjed kay naam par kabza hota hia.

[@nadeemtabish-do6vx]

alag soba bna daina best solution

[@SachinKumar-rz6cw]

Dono jahil baithe hai. Nobody allowing other person to complete. Nobody can wait.

[@awaiskhanofficial2586]

Ali zaidi ka intellectual level. Dekhen 6.30

[@naheedfatimahasnain7033]

کیا کراچی میں مزید کچھ بچا ہے تباہ ہونے کے لئے؟

[@user-yr3so4fo8g]

The last survey of property tax in Karachi was conducted in 2001-2002. Shabbvar sahab, rectify your record.

[@IrshadAhmed-su6sk]

Shabbar zaidi sharam kar.quiad azam kay mazzar ki bat na kar.

[@tauqeeralam8762]

This is the trap. They want to join again pti and it's not possible for any cost

[@Yankee7000]

You are making assumptions. This is the conspiracy mindset that is the blight of Pakistan. Let me assure you: there are no conspiracies behind every corner.

[@awaiskhanofficial2586]

Sindh say chutkara hasil kiye bina karachi ka kch n hu skta

[@bilalghizal]

ڈی ایچ اے تو ایک اور آرہا ہے کراچی میں ۔۔۔

[@zohaibkhan4076]

mqm ne tabha kia hay karachi ko.

[@vjam139]

قائداعظم کے مزار کا پلاٹ شبر زیدی اور ان کے ساتھیوں کے لئے رکھا گیا ہے۔

[@Changeisconstant-dg2yd]

As per 1941 census, 67 percent of Karachi's population was Sindhi. Karachi has always been part of Sindh since times immemorial. Unity of Sindh is in the hearts and literature of ethnic Sindhis. Being a Karachiite, I stand for empowered local govt for Karachi, with excise road tax and SRB's revenues given to Karachi. Do not sow hatred and divisions Sindh is one and remain so InshaAllah.

[@kamaqlmolvi7812]

Sind kay wadaira karachi par hokomat karaingay to is ka haal kabhee theek nahee hoga. Kya shah rukh jatoi ka qisa bhool gaya.

[@Changeisconstant-dg2yd]

@@kamaqlmolvi7812 Kon kambakhat PPP ko support kar Raha hai. Mainey Sirf Sindh soobey key original ethnicity yaani Sindhion ki BAAT rakhi hai. Dobara parho Jo mainey likha hy, taasub ka chashma hata key!

[@masroorkhalil9655]

​@@Changeisconstant-dg2yd Brooo karachi meeee sindhis keee sorry to say bhot minor contribution hain karachi koo abad balochio neee kiyeaa thaa or developed issko british neeee or gujrati hindhu buisnessman neee kiyeaaa thaaa pheer after partition urdu speaking community kee bhee bhot khidmat hain isskelyee sab jaaantee hain under musharaaf local govt kee great leadership of mustafa kamal and niamatullah khan neee kitne brilliant projects shoru karwaeee isssleye yeee city sab kaaa hain leekin saaab isss seee pyar keee bajae issskoo loote mee lagge howe hain .....pure duniyea meee sab jagah provinces bantee hain administration kelyee ageer yee south sindh bangyeaa toooo koi qayamat nae ayyegee koi india meee shamil nae hojayeegaaa ager south sindh bangyeaaa too

[@Changeisconstant-dg2yd]

@@masroorkhalil9655 The indigenous people i.e Sindhis consider Sindh as motherland and mother cannot be divided. Why don't you people get it? Do you want blood to be split? What I am arguing is for independent, financially empowered, and authoritative local govt for Karachi. Is it not better than a province that suits all interests? If u are still persistent, go pass a 2/3rd majority resolution in Sindh and national assembly for carving another province.

[@masroorkhalil9655]

@@Changeisconstant-dg2yd Yeeee meera itnaaa samjhanee kaaa pata nae kyaa faydaa huwaaa 😳😲😤😤😒😒 khaair bro naaa yeee sindh koi mother hain naa koi body ageer yee sindh texas yeaa california hota too tab appp yee baat karteee

[@danishsiraj8242]

Karega kon 😂😂😂

[@lubnanadeem4628]

السلام علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ سر آپ دونوں جب اقتدار میں تھے تو آپ بے بس تھے اب آپ اقتدار سے باہر ہیں تو آپ اپنی اس وقت کی بےبسی کی کہانیاں سنا رہے ہیں اور اس وقت جو مسائل ہیں ان کا حل عوام کو سنا رہے ہیں اس سے کیا ہو گا؟

[@muhammadarsalan1805]

Karachi ko Mustafa Kamal chahiye bas

[@Zul994]

Karachi ko jan buj kar barbad kya yahan poray Pakistan sy yahsn akar 2 numberi kar tay hain or phir karachi ko hi gali dy ty hain 30 sal phalay itna rash ni tha ye pata nahi kahan kahan sy log aey hoay hain kuch ni pata

[@syedaamir4019]

Ap jasay power or pasay walay log bhi itnay baybas hay dekh kay sharam ati hay aplog sirf batain krsktay hay lakin is nizam ko na khatam krsktay hay na is system say larh sktay hay ap logo nay apni life pori trya enjoy krli hay or ab bhi krrhay hay kbhi ap logo nay 18000 kamanay walay guard ki life ka socha uska lia kuch kia nahi kia na kch krygay

[@syedaamir4019]

Ap jasay power or pasay walay log bhi itnay baybas hay dekh kay sharam ati hay aplog sirf batain krsktay hay lakin is nizam ko na khatam krsktay hay na is system say larh sktay hay ap logo nay apni life pori trya enjoy krli hay or ab bhi krrhay hay kbhi ap logo nay 18000 kamanay walay guard ki life ka socha uska lia kuch kia nahi kia na kch krygay