Is Mecca Mentioned in the Bible? Where is the Valley of Baca? - Dr. Joshua Bowen Answers

This scholar calmly destroys one of the major revisionist arguments that Muslim apologists nowadays make to prove that their Islamic religion is true. I hope that the apologists will see the major flaw in their claims and let it go.
Watch the whole interview here: • Mecca is NOT Mentioned...
Subscribe to Dr. Joshua Bowen's channel ‪@DigitalHammurabi‬
Links to Dr. Joshua Bowen:
The Atheist Handbook to the Old Testament Joshua Bowen (2021) (tinyurl.com/4jj2tcny)
Learn to Read Ancient Sumerian for the Absolute Beginner Joshua Bowen & Megan Lewis (2020) (tinyurl.com/yatg8ty3)
Sumerian Classes on @🔺 T A N G 🔺 : • 📜📜 Learning to Read An...
Did the Old Testament Endorse Slavery? Joshua Bowen (2020) (tinyurl.com/y6uytbkv)
Learning to Pray in a Dead Language: Education and Invocation in Ancient Sumerian Joshua Bowen (2020) (tinyurl.com/2f5rd7tc)
Website: www.digitalhammurabi.com
Support AP: apostateprophet.com/donate/
Patreon: / apostateprophet
Paypal: www.paypal.me/apostateprophet
AP Merchandise: merch.apostateprophet.com/
Equipment Wishlist: www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls...
Twitter: / apostateprophet
Facebook: / theapostateprophet
BC: tinyurl.com/y8qvjh9z (auto-upload)
Intro Visual + Music made by Egyptian Atheist ( / @egyptianatheist )

[@ApostateProphet]

This is a brief summary of the definitive destruction of the Baca - Mecca argument. I am thankful to Dr. Joshua Bowen. Please subscribe to his channel: kzbin.info

[@Hannestv4607]

! top position! ***////Why Muslims say Jesus is a Prophet of Allah !! ⚠️Even though Jesus is named after another god! ⚠️ /////*** So Yehoshua (Jesus) is supposed to be a prophet of Allah according to Islam ??? How does it work if Allah is not YHWH! In addition, it is the UNFORGIVABLE SIN in Islam to testify to YHWH as the 1 True God! But Yehoshua means "YHWH SAVES”” So Jesus is definitely not the prophet of Allah! Because he only confirm YHWH!

[@Hannestv4607]

***////////⚠️⚠️ Allah's prophets are named after another GOD⚠️⚠️ Has Allah forgotten his name or is he just an IDOL!⚠️⚠️//////////**** Why is it the unforgivable sin in Islam to confess " there is only one God and this is YHWH"" The Name Jesus means------------- ***"YHWH SAVES "** Elijah means------------- --------------***" MY GOD IS YHWH"*** John means ----------------------------***" YHWH has been gracious""*** Zakariya means -----------------------***""YHWH has remembered""*** are all prophets according to the Quran

[@RoarT19]

@@Hannestv4607 Exactly

[@RoarT19]

@@Hannestv4607 Allah is not Yahweh Allah is not Father Yahweh is Father Almighty So how come Quran 29:46 be possible ??? Only True God is the *Father* So they busted yourself Because Allah is not the Father Yahweh is Father , Deut. 32:6 Psalms 2:7 Isaiah 9:6 Isaiah 63:16 Matthew 6:9 John 3:16 John 17;3-5 John 20:17 Romans 8:15 But Allah hates being a Father and not a Father And Also wants Muhammad to do the same Claiming he is also not the Father Yet he had Daughters and sons They called hey Moody naughty-mad Sura 5:18 Sura 112:3-4 Sura 33:40 So Logically how come Quran 29:46 be possible...???? 4) Yahweh Can Beget a Son John 3:16 Psalms 2:7 But lollah cant *Sura 112:3-4* 5) Yahweh Does not Need Wife or Sex or Even gives an lame excuse like that .. But lollah needs Wife to have sex Allah Needs Sex to have a son which is Logically a Hunger Quran 21:17 Quran 6:101 Quran 39:4 So you proved Allah is a false God And he is not the God of the Jews and Christians

[@Hannestv4607]

@@RoarT19 AMEN!! God bless you

[@anderstopansson]

The valley of Baca is in Cuba and it´s the place they make the Bacardi rum.

[@sunnyvarghese6419]

😀😀😀🙏👍

[@ggvgj2079]

Bible is corrupt by pagan Romans

[@Hannestv4607]

⚠️ CHESS MATT !! ⚠️ (Paul DESTROYS Islam "The Islam Paul Paradox") PAUL is said to have CORRUPTED the Bible, according to Muslims! Paul lived at the time of Jesus = beginning to the middle of the 1st century! Why then does the Koran writer in the 7th century know nothing about Paul's teaching? Why do Muslims always think of Paul corrupting the Bible? Allah doesn't even know what Paul taught according to the Koran !! (So no matter if Paul CORRUPTED the Bible, the Koran is proven FALSE!) Allah knows nothing of a TRINITY !! And that in the 7th century! Trinity = the 1 YHWH! According to the Koran, Allah believes: Christians believe in 3 gods! Allah + MARIA + Jewish Hercules !! (PAULUS never said) According to the Koran, Allah believes: Jesus is a Jewish Hercules (newly created GOD) in Christianity! (PAULUS never said) Allah has no idea that the ETERNAL GOD himself became a man! Because he believes there is a 2 newly created God in Christianity!

[@sunnyvarghese6419]

@@ggvgj2079 and it's fulfilled each and every words in the Bible Jesus is coming back to judge each and every false prophets, including muhammad who misguided millions of people, Jesus Christ is the Lord He is on the throne yesterday Today and for ever

[@pyrrhonist7970]

And that's where Aloh snack Bar franchise all started. Heard they also serve Moh-ito, Bloody MoMad, Sex on the desert, Screw Slave, Camel pee Bacardi and Murky SunSet Tequila.

[@Xbalanque84]

Short answer: no. Long answer: Hell no!

[@paritoshchauhan3266]

@My Dear Brother Ben nah!

[@Kramer_.]

Then you disagree with joshua kzbin.info/www/bejne/q2rUfah5pM6LY80 Its same. Joshua refuted APUS 😂😂

[@Imagine_No_Religion]

Best answer: *F*CK NO!*

[@Xbalanque84]

@@Kramer_. *Muhammad is in Hell, eternally drowning in an ocean of boiling pig shit.*

[@RabeeQiblawi]

In the Quran Meccah was refered as bakah Quran 3:96. plus it's a place for pilgrim, but what's wrong for it being in the bible?

[@jgil848]

A Muslim told me about this text in the Psalms, but he didn't even know that Zion is in Jerusalem, 1500 kilometers from Mecca

[@ApostateProphet]

When the Israelites go to the pilgrimage, they make a quick stop at Mecca for some reason and then they go to Jerusalem.

[@jgil848]

@@ApostateProphet It sounds like it was very easy at the time to travel 1500 kilometers to Mecca and then return to Jerusalem

[@davidjanbaz7728]

@@jgil848 YES, they had the flying carpets.

[@sarenareth689]

@@jgil848 Magic carpets, flying donkeys, the people were so far ahead of us

[@jesuslovesu3948]

@@ApostateProphet Adding 3000km to their trip from mount Sion to Jerusalem?

[@BLACK.ANGEL.]

*Baca is an old word for BÄCKER / Baker !!!* The Jxws went through that *valley of their local Bäcker* , to get delicious bread. Sometimes though the bread was sold out and they started weeping under the trees on their way back home! Welcome!

[@BLACK.ANGEL.]

Sarcasm 👆

[@TandemSix]

Oh yes,also Baker Street 221B,we all know that if you translate London into Transylvanian it means Jerusalem. Subhanallah,alhamdulillah,mashallah🙏🏻

[@reinercelsus8299]

No, it's actually a disguised prophecy, about Boris Becker and Wimbledon.

[@TandemSix]

@@reinercelsus8299 exceptional deduction,mashallah,Ali baba...I mean Allah gave you hikhma

[@avdima5000]

If you don't think that this is true you have to bring clear evidence

[@johanwhiz2632]

Two intelligent people having an intelligent conversation. That’s what we like. ❤️❤️

[@arolemaprarath6615]

@@Alisalah_24 Prophet Apuss sallallahu alaihi wasallam is better than Profit $ MoMoHAMbutt (Police be upon him)

[@j7bsecond540]

@@Alisalah_24 you believe in primitive magic - pot/kettle

[@joeysal007]

@@Alisalah_24 I mean he does demonstrate his points wuth proofs from different source unlike the potheads blindly following a cult. The reason itself makes him an intelligent person

[@Poodlepaws44]

We're proud of that!

[@Kramer_.]

Sorry,dr.joshua refuted apus. He said bacca and mecca is the same

[@kaloarepo288]

When ancient writers mention Arabia they usually are pointing only to the northern part -Arabia Petraia -which was part of the Greek,Roman and Byzantine empires for hundreds of years-its capital,during the Roman period, was Bosrah now in Syria that has amazing Roman ruins like a very well preserved Roman theatre.Arabia was divided into three parts -the main,vast,sandy,hot and inhospitable part where Mecca is was called Arabia deserta and neither Greeks,Romans or Byzantines managed to invade any of it or even wanted to.The third part was Arabia Felix or happy Arabia because it benefited from the monsoonal rains and was fertile and is now called Yemen.Greeks or Romans nor Byzantines never conquered it but the Persians and Abyssinians did and there was a marked Jewish presence there that lasted until Israel was created and most Jews migrated there

[@tropicalstrings]

Tat is why Yemenites where sailors. Arabs not.

[@heborweihcraxilef5996]

The valley of Baca is in Barcelona because of Barca FC. Please forget the r in Barca.

[@baran1170]

it was a great conversation

[@LuisVazquez-hx3bk]

The Valley of Baca is not a place. Is the weeping (the sorrow) of a person when a love one died.

[@lastprophet8338]

Islamic standard narrative has giant holes in it. Valley of Baca is different from Mecca 🕋

[@dyawr]

Of course, lol

[@Kramer_.]

I wonder why mr.joshua said this kzbin.info/www/bejne/q2rUfah5pM6LY80 Its same😂😂

[@qasimfareed5821]

firstly bro do your own research don’t let this guys opinions become facts for you. Very immature and ignorant for you to do so. But Isaiah 42:11 says the ppl of Kedar will rejoice. Kedar is Arabia. Book of Ezekiel 27:21 talks about the business and trading done Arabia saying they were favored dealers. This is thousands of years before Muhammad. Next line in Isaiah 42:11 gets even more specific to the city of Medina saying let the ppl of sela sing in joy. You can look up yourself of what those places are called today. I can keep going too 😂😂😂😂.

[@lastprophet8338]

@@qasimfareed5821 I know all these Islamic lies before I left Islam ☪️. What you just said don’t match at all.

[@lastprophet8338]

@@qasimfareed5821 Check your map 🗺 to understand the distance between Israel and Mecca 🕋, even that Abraham went to Mecca 🕋 is a fabrication if you look at the distance.

[@alphabeta1337]

Make a video of your cat walking on a Quran

[@Luiz-jr3lp]

Beautiful

[@feduntu]

@Subutai Khan yes please!

[@johnlop7763]

@Subutai Khan can you show me the video about him shatting on the Qur'an I want to see lol

[@ggvgj2079]

Bible currupted by pagan Romans kzbin.info/www/bejne/sJ6ohJZ_isipsJI

[@Hannestv4607]

⚠️ CHESS MATT !! ⚠️ (Paul DESTROYS Islam "The Islam Paul Paradox") PAUL is said to have CORRUPTED the Bible, according to Muslims! Paul lived at the time of Jesus = beginning to the middle of the 1st century! Why then does the Koran writer in the 7th century know nothing about Paul's teaching? Why do Muslims always think of Paul corrupting the Bible? Allah doesn't even know what Paul taught according to the Koran !! (So no matter if Paul CORRUPTED the Bible, the Koran is proven FALSE!) Allah knows nothing of a TRINITY !! And that in the 7th century! Trinity = the 1 YHWH! According to the Koran, Allah believes: Christians believe in 3 gods! Allah + MARIA + Jewish Hercules !! (PAULUS never said) According to the Koran, Allah believes: Jesus is a Jewish Hercules (newly created GOD) in Christianity! (PAULUS never said) Allah has no idea that the ETERNAL GOD himself became a man! Because he believes there is a 2 newly created God in Christianity!

[@BoneMarrowVirgin]

Baca is a valley in Jerusalem represents the balsam trees that line the valley of Jerusalem and why would the jhewss take a huge detour and go to Arabia? LOL

[@RoarT19]

No It's Mukka Jukka in Mad-eena 😆😆

[@BoneMarrowVirgin]

@@RoarT19😂🤣

[@RoarT19]

@Subutai Khan Well There are lots of wonderful peoples there

[@johnlop7763]

@Subutai Khan not really at that time, yes there was a lot of barbarians and other tribes.

[@Ahmed-ef6ss]

@Subutai Khan Why make your hatred for Islam turn into hatred for a geographical location? Arabia is a beautiful place with a very rich and wonderful pre-islamic culture.

[@treson8640]

AP you've been kicking ass lately. Thanks for your hard work!

[@seanrathmakedisciples1508]

Thanks for a great video on the truth. Going up to Jerusalem to praise God

[@jamesscalt0172]

well muslims? How could "the valley of baca" mean mecca when the psalm is clearly talking about somewhere on the way to a pilgrimmage to jerusalem? Is mecca anywhere remotely on the way to jerusalem? No. more importantly, why would the bible mention mecca in this one psalm and not mention abraham building the kaaba or going to mecca/arabia at all during the chapters of the bible that give Abraham's lifestory? Why would jewish scriptures not mention there being a place of continuous pilgrimmage in arabia built by abraham at all in any of their books? You're telling me that jews since the time of abraham have been going on pilgrimmage to this place built by abraham in arabia and they didn't record it at all in the talmud or any other jewish text? Come on, the obvious, most likely explanation that fits the evidence best is that the creator(s) of islam simply made up the claim that abraham built the kaaba in order to claim that the kaaba was a place of monotheism connected to the jewish line of prophets .

[@kwameofori8947]

Fully agree

[@foundthetruth2003]

Very well said !

[@sarenareth689]

Flat out denying everything in the face of overwhelming evidence, seems to be a universally acquired skill nowadays

[@Kramer_.]

Why joshua said:bacca and mecca is same kzbin.info/www/bejne/q2rUfah5pM6LY80

[@hmm7934]

@@Kramer_. keep cryin indon kiddos. And keep paste the link here. But hey, do me a favor. Could you tag me and paste me the link again here??

[@gerardocantu9702]

Baca or Vaca means cow in Spanish. They were walking in a valley full of cows. I think it was actually in Texas.

[@istvansipos9940]

but, had it been in Texas, then all the abrahamic religions would mention a "lawrd", not a lord :- ) (I do love Texan English)

[@traceywu9123]

GODS does LOVE BBQ

[@shanbeauty4193]

@@istvansipos9940😂😂😂😂

[@luiszapata6864]

That ending music, just... genius!!! Keep the good work AP!!!

[@ponygirl6258]

It's "Ave Maria." An ironic choice for an atheist, but a good one.

[@luiszapata6864]

@@ponygirl6258 Thanks for the remainder of the name (I had it in the "tip of my tongue" hehe) Yeah, but I don't know... it gives a really nice "in your face" touch

[@tonydarcy1606]

Schubert.

[@pyrrhonist7970]

Yes.. yes I believe Baca is Mecca... just like there were azan heard from the moon and Neil Armstrong converted to cisslum LOL.

[@Ko-gp2qi]

Cisslum😛😛😛

[@Kramer_.]

Really?? Joshua said its same kzbin.info/www/bejne/q2rUfah5pM6LY80 LoL

[@hdl135605]

Neil Armstrong ate pork after his conversion to Islam. LOL.

[@steen275]

@@hdl135605 Can you blame him pork is delicious

[@DEUS_VULT_CROATIA]

It simply must mean Mecca! Cmon guys both mecca and baca have an A in it.

[@timothysheahan9730]

Haha, excellent logic! just what you would expect from their tunnel vision obsessive followers

[@DEUS_VULT_CROATIA]

Muslim logic is weird

[@chiggen_wings5703]

Step 1: Fabricate a Muslim statement. Step 2: Mock Muslims for "using" the logic you fabricated about them. Step 3: Be happy about what a great person you are.

[@unknownuser4816]

@@chiggen_wings5703 it's not fabricated though

[@chiggen_wings5703]

@@unknownuser4816 Who said it?

[@charlieseisun5667]

Interesting! Maltese is described as a Semitic language and it looks like Maltese BIKI (weeping) and BEKA (wept) are directly derived from the semitic original.

[@Kramer_.]

Then what is this kzbin.info/www/bejne/q2rUfah5pM6LY80

[@joshuagenes]

I believe Petra was referred to as Beca or Mecca by one Christian writer back in the 7th century. Petra a stone city which had been hit by earth quakes often had great weeping hence Baca or Becca refereed to that also it was a Holy city of the Nabatseans and probably had great weeping during the haj as well.

[@RERGamingorTecdreaminshort]

So you are saying bible was written by humans??

[@penitoanikeve7288]

One question for muslims, actually four: 1. What year did Muhammad go to the farthest mosque as written in Qur'an 17:1? 2. Why did your original manuscripts says farthest mosque, why no name nor location given? 3. When was "al'aqsa mosque" added to Qur'an 17:1 almost 1,000 years later? 4. If the Qur'an says Muhammad was the only prophet of Islam, your standard Islamic narrative says Muhammad upon arriving in this farthest mosque led prayers for 124,000 other prophets of Islam? Please explain this.

[@James-en1ob]

The "Eve Maria" at the end was beautiful!

[@lahleholivia7398]

Trying to argue Zion is mecca was the muslim mistake.

[@qasimfareed5821]

Lol I’m bout to have fun with all you clowns.. firstly bro do your own research don’t let this guys opinions become facts for you. Very immature and ignorant for you to do so. But Isaiah 42:11 says the ppl of Kedar will rejoice. Kedar is Arabia. Book of Ezekiel 27:21 talks about the business and trading done Arabia saying they were favored dealers. This is thousands of years before Muhammad. Next line in Isaiah 42:11 gets even more specific to the city of Medina saying let the ppl of sela sing in joy. You can look up yourself of what those places are called today. I can keep going too 😂😂😂😂.

[@d3adang7l]

@@qasimfareed5821 also what does Ezekiel have to even do with this? The Bible also mentions the Ishmaelites as enemies.

[@qasimfareed5821]

@@d3adang7l has everything to do with the subject. He’s implying there’s no historical evidence in Arabia or sub middle eastern areas and there is. He’s just unlearned. And I said nothing of ishmealites but I can give references that say they were beloved friends of Moses

[@user-wg9ul9wj5o]

@@qasimfareed5821 lol kedar is way above high away from Medina and mecca so claim your source about this abdool

[@user-wg9ul9wj5o]

“’Arabia and all the princes of Kedar were your customers; they did business with you in lambs, rams and goats" this verse you mean but it has no connection in medina and it's specifically points out of how they traded with the ancient Arabs in that time

[@Lpettro]

Great job digging into this! It is a very interesting question and, as usual, the Muslim interpretation is insane. A real stretch.

[@qasimfareed5821]

😂 firstly bro do your own research don’t let this guys opinions become facts for you. Very immature and ignorant for you to do so. But Isaiah 42:11 says the ppl of Kedar will rejoice. Kedar is Arabia. Book of Ezekiel 27:21 talks about the business and trading done Arabia saying they were favored dealers. This is thousands of years before Muhammad. Next line in Isaiah 42:11 gets even more specific to the city of Medina saying let the ppl of sela sing in joy. You can look up yourself of what those places are called today. I can keep going too 😂😂😂😂.

[@goodboi4939]

@@qasimfareed5821 bro be honest, did you copy and paste this comment?

[@qasimfareed5821]

@@goodboi4939 I wrote it myself and copy and pasted according to who needed to see it. Not retyping same thing to same argument

[@qasimfareed5821]

@@goodboi4939 I make great point tho Because I have everyone against Islam dumb founded, quiet, or in denial. Just look it up lol

[@revertrevertz5438]

@@qasimfareed5821 Like an idiot, you don’t see no one is disputing that. Even in the video it is claim that there might have been commerce going around. What they are disputing is the Islamic claim that Mecca is mentioned in the Bible. Which of course makes no sense lol.

[@christianfrommuslim]

"Blessed" by Hillsong is a stirring contemporary song which the words of this psalm in English. Some of might enjoy it!

[@christianfrommuslim]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/ap28cn9qgdipbJo

[@anupadeshmukh3318]

Now thats how the conversations are supposed to be...

[@wlparker008]

Quran 6:154. Then We gave Moses the Scripture, perfect for the righteous, and explaining everything clearly, and a beacon, and mercy, that they may believe in the encounter with their Lord Therefore Allah also inspired the New Testament writings correct? But who is we?

[@SamuelHill94]

Allah and his daughters probably.

[@tedytedy5598]

Pagan gods

[@dr.ashkad4964]

It’s Petra, when the great holy city started becoming deserted, water dried and had earthquakes and suffered a lot

[@SuperPoisondartfrog]

Kinda ironic that the ad at the end of this video was asking me to donate to an Islamic school.

[@klila16]

Apparently Petra was known as Beca the valley of weeping and there is apparently evidence that Petra was the original Mecca. No one ever mentioned Mecca.

[@moshameem99]

Dan Gibson’s new book claims to turn upside down all of what we know about one aspect of early Islamic practice, namely, the sacred direction (qibla) toward the Kaaba in Makka. He believes that Islam began in Petra, not Makka, and that the focus of Muslim prayer for the first two centuries was toward Petra, not Makka. As evidence for this he attempts to show that dozens of early mosques face Petra with remarkable accuracy. Since his revolutionary ideas ignore what modern scholarship has established about the early qibla, I present an overview of how things actually were. I then show how Gibson has misunderstood most of the data at his disposal, comparing medieval mosque orientations with modern directions of Petra and Makka, and why his interpretation is completely flawed. In brief, he has wrought havoc with information that he cannot master, and has - wittingly or unwittingly - produced an amateurish, non-scholarly document that is both offensive to Muslims and also an insult to Muslim and Western scholarship. None of the mosques investigated by Gibson has anything to do with Petra. Nor, indeed, has early Islam. *** Note: In early September 2017 Dan Gibson responded to this review at www.academia.edu. The author and Muslim Heritage are grateful to Mr. Gibson for pointing out an error relating to his family background, which is corrected in this new version. In his reply, Gibson mistakenly claimed that King thought the Arabs in the early 7th century were innocent of any astronomical knowledge of practical consequence. On the contrary, such Arab astronomical lore is documented in the Kitâb al-Anwâ’ of Ibn Qutayba. King just does not think that the first Muslims in China were in any way capable of orienting their first mosque accurately toward Petra. muslimheritage.com/pibla-back-to-qibla/

[@kenji1212]

Mecca is mentioned in Playboy magazine!!!😜

[@traceywu9123]

Yup … Those crazy BEATLES were Really something .. the gals sure loved macca!!🤣

[@afollowerofchrist5789]

Baca? We're talking in Japanese here, right? Because that would directly translate to the Valley of "Idiot"😂

[@sarenareth689]

Indeed, the Bible here is specifically mentioning tsundere anime girl conversation, a downright miracle if nothing else xDD

[@ball_sack_mcgee]

@@sarenareth689 Bible?

[@polyhistorphilomath]

馬鹿の谷。

[@traceywu9123]

SUGOI SUGOI 😂

[@MAX-tw3qz]

You've got o be desperate to prove your faith, particularly when it's a couple of vague geographic words in a book you don't believe in. Islam lingers due to chaos.

[@abanoubmorcos318]

I am an Arabic christian and in the Arabic bible it is وادي البكاء The valley of crying

[@ndogarakumbare9471]

Oh my goodness how ignorant can you be 😂🥴your Bible has been changed so much

[@adude849]

​@@ndogarakumbare9471there wasn't even a bible in the first 300 years😂😂 But it doesn't debunked Christianity but rather supported Tradition and Magisterium

[@albusai]

Remember Jesus was a Palestinian Muslim 😂

[@rusuriasuria9989]

Remember Jesus is Judea jew

[@johnlop7763]

Keep it up apostate prophet!

[@dannyooi4951]

Is there a valley in mecca with springs and pools?

[@Rijasebna]

Beca means weeping or crying , I am geez semetic language speaker which is sister language to hebrew Aramaic and arab and we all sharing that Verb .

[@sonix6271]

Yay, I got early

[@1turkish1indian43]

Your channel has been super informative! Not that I will stop being a Muslim but it gives everything a new perspective 😊😆

[@chiggen_wings5703]

@Niro Pattar source: weak hadith/David Wood's interpretation

[@davidjanbaz7728]

@Lindsey Marie they have weak Quran verses also!

[@chiggen_wings5703]

@Lindsey Marie Oh wow. Anyone who knows a little about the ahadith knows that there are three main gradings of authenticity: Sahih - authentic Hasan - good Da'if - weak Scholars look at the chain of narration (isnad) and check the authenticity of the narration. They look at the biography of every person in the isnad and find out if the hadith is acceptable. For example, if one narrator had issues with memorization, the hadith is rejected. This is known as hadith science/terminology and goes a thousand times deeper than what I briefly explained. I feel like discussing quantum physics with a kid. How can you not know this simple thing which anyone interested in Islam knows - and be so confident in what you are saying?

[@chiggen_wings5703]

@Lindsey Marie 1. The reason I used quantum physics as an example is that a kid wouldn't know what it is. 2. The authenticity of ahadith is not subjective. Do you know anything about hadith science? 3. What do you mean by "as it's purely irrespective of the material as its written"? Let me teach you something. "Hadith" means "narration," so, as you can think of it by yourself, the ahadith weren't written down things. All of Muhammad's companions told others about what they heard from him, and only a few actually wrote them down. These companions also taught what they heard from the Prophet to their students, who also told others about it and sometimes wrote them down. Up until great scholars like Al-Bukhari and Muslim came a few generations later, not many ahadith were really written down/compiled into one book. These scholars also tried to only write down authentic narrations in their books, but other scholars realized some were inauthentic (through the process I described earlier). 4. Who are the self-styled Islamic experts you'retalking about? Scholars? You're saying scholars are not knowledgeable enough to make precise judgements on the narrations' authenticity, therefore twist the texts? Give me a reference, it would be interesting to see what you mean. Oh wait, you made that up because you're too ignorant to accept that we grade the ahadith sincerely, not because we dislike them. In fact, many beautiful narrations are weak. It is not cherry picking.

[@chiggen_wings5703]

@Lindsey Marie I never said that Apuss and David present weak ahadith. I just said that weak ones are often used to "disprove" Islam.

[@jinesh027]

Hey bro can you do a quran series like Hemant do in his channel 'Friendly Atheist' with bible. It's really fun and rare to hear real and full religious verses and texts.

[@alaxchiiahoushakduxxiilee5898]

"YOU ARE FINISHED BOI!!!" 🤣🤣🤣

[@thinkingperson2122]

Islam logic: - The Bible is corrupted. - The Kaaba is in the Bible, so Islam is true. Ha, ha, ha... I can't believe...

[@tiotiwilliams8311]

We say most of the bible is corrupted not all of it.

[@starla4534]

@@tiotiwilliams8311 🤣🤣🤣

[@BizBytesTVs]

@@starla4534 keep cry infidels your books says about it and you can't do anything about it

[@Toolgdskli]

AP you read the wrong bible. Read the bible authored by Muhammad 😅

[@metamaggot]

easy..beqaa (Bekaa, Biqâ, or Becaa)is currently a fertile agricultural valley in lebanon..where baalbek and its roman temples are still to be found...

[@Sa_xll]

(baca) is one of the names of Mecca go to the quran surah (Al imraan ) Verse (96) : (The first house established for the people was the one in baca, blessed and a guidance for the worlds) Go and look at the verse in the Qur’an, even the Qur’an says that the name of Mecca is also baca

[@Kumarapwmss1989]

Who believe that bullshit in the quran 😂

[@Sa_xll]

@@Kumarapwmss1989 baca is Mecca Your Bible mentioned it too

[@michaelpoapst9465]

Praying for you "Brother "AP " to come to Jesus for Eternal Life !!!

[@user-yn5sk5ru5g]

So you havent actually read the bible then?

[@davidjanbaz7728]

@@user-yn5sk5ru5g sounds like a rhetorical question!

[@nicktronson2977]

@@user-yn5sk5ru5g You are right about Yod Hay Waw Shin Waw Ayin(YaHuWSHuWa). A somali offered me a koran and I told him I have the truth in my heart and rejected his offer. So he said " I told you what I believe, so you tell me what you believe." And I told him about The Father YaHuWaH and Son, YaHuSHuWa and when he repeated YaHuSHuWa, we heard a loud ovation and he even said it was angels and we saw a horizontal rainbow and a cardinal was flying across it and we both said it was a miracle. But he is still muslim. Even though the LOUD CLAPPING OVATION happened when the muslim somali said YaHuWSHuWa. No one was around us when the loud ovation happened and he was looking behind me and I was looking behind him to see where the ovation came from because the sound of the ovation surrounded us and my heart was pounding in fear like what just happened? No matter how much I've stalled THE INEVITABLE FUTURE TIMELINE, THE INEVITABLE FUTURE TIMELINE will come into fruition. 1. The sick children will be healed with utterrance of THE NAME ABOVE ALL NAMES, YAHUWSHUWA. 2. The heavens will open on Earth for all to witness as the angels will commune with the healed children as the children heal the sick and feed the poor in THE NAME ABOVE ALL NAMES, YAHUWSHUWA. 3. The multitudes all over the world will learn of YAHUWSHUWA. As that is the true Good News that will be preached and demonstrated for them to witness. 4. AT THAT POINT THOSE MULTITUDES OF PEOPLE ALL OVER THE WORLD WHO CALLED UNTO YAHUWSHUWA TO FEED THE POOR AND HEAL THE SICK WILL KNOW THEY WILL NEVER DIE OR BE HURT DURING TRIBULATION. 5. THOSE HUMAN MULTITUDES WILL LOVE EVERYONE, EVEN THOSE WHO HATE THEM BECAUSE YAHUWSHUWA TAUGHT THEM THAT HIGHEST LEVEL OF LOVE WILL SHOW THAT YOU HAVE ARE SINCERE WHEN YOU CALL OUT TO YAHUWSHUWA. YOU WILL HAVE THE HOLY SPIRIT AND REALISE YOUR EXISTENCE WILL BE LOVE AND PARADISE. 6. THE ANGELS WILL SEPARATE THOSE WITH HATE IN THEIR HEARTS AND INTENTIONS OF VIOLENCE. AS THOSE WHO CALL UNTO YAHUWSHUWA WILL NEVER DO VIOLENCE EVER. SO THOSE WHO CHOSE TO FIGHT WILL BE DOING SIN. 7.THANKFULLY EARTH WILL BE CHANGED TO HEAVEN EVEN BEFORE THAT PROCESS, WE WILL BE WAITING AS OUR BODY PERMEATES WITH THE BEST FEELING OF THE HOLY SPIRIT DWELLING WITHIN US. I FORGOT TO MENTION PEOPLE WILL BE RAISED FROM THE DEAD IN YAHUWSHUWA'S NAME AS THE SICK IS HEALED AND POOR BEING FED HAPPENS. Re: He made the ILLUminati an ofFer thEy Could not refusE!! Quoting: AlphabetA "They can certainly refuse, but refusal will result in falling forever down the deepest depths of this hell we're all stuck in.. So, why not just help everyone out of here, with everyones help?" "Love those who hate you and persecute you." -YAHUWSHUWA "Forgive them. They know not what they do." -YAHUWSHUWA "None is good but The Father(YAHUWAH)" -YAHUWSHUWA "“Put your sword in its place, for all who take the sword will perish by the sword." -YAHUWSHUWA "Those who understand WILL NOT TASTE HARM OR DEATH." -YAHUWSHUWA "The man aged in days will not hesitate to ask a little child of seven days about the place of life, and he shall live; for there are many first who shall be last, and they will become a single one." -YAHUWSHUWA The final tribulation will be conquered not by violence, but by FEEDING THE POOR AND HEALING THOSE WHO ARE SICK AND RESSURECTING THE DEAD IN YAHUWSHUWA'S NAME I say unto you, that likewise joy shall be in heaven over one sinner that repent, more than over ninety and nine just persons, which need no repentance. -YAHUWSHUWA. Amen.

[@Luiz-jr3lp]

Jesus is better than Muhammad. Have a nice day.

[@BoneMarrowVirgin]

better? Christ and Anti literally

[@BoneMarrowVirgin]

@@Suppiluliuma_1 that is ur Isa, false Jesus

[@feduntu]

@@Suppiluliuma_1 even still... jesus or isa, either one are better than mhmd, your mhmd wouldn't be worth picking up the sandals of ISA (fraudulent jesus) let alone the actual jesus himself!

[@BoneMarrowVirgin]

@Morning Star lol i am guessing u dont live in the timeframe divuded by Jesus

[@BoneMarrowVirgin]

@Morning Star btw bible can be verified historically, archeologically and proohetically, u are living a 100 yrrs backwards lol

[@coffeetwosugarswithhikingb4180]

FYI l had to sit through a quran study course advert before your video started.

[@derjungemensch5902]

I have a message that I’m sharing where I can, some may not want to hear this, but I ask that we stay polite and seek truth together. 😊 Love is an action. Feed the hungry, house the homeless, father the orphan, and protect the defenseless and vulnerable. Read the Word for yourself, not only relying on others for guidance. Pray for guidance.Yahushua/Yeshua - His Hebrew name who is usually called (Jesus) taught to keep the whole Word. Including the Law/Torah. Matthew 5:17 “Do not presume that I came to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I did not come to abolish, but to fulfill. 18 For truly I say to you, until heaven and earth pass away, not [g]the smallest letter or stroke of a letter shall pass from the Law, until all is accomplished! 19 Therefore, whoever nullifies one of the least of these commandments, and teaches [h]others to do the same, shall be called least in the kingdom of heaven; but whoever [i]keeps and teaches them, he shall be called great in the kingdom of heaven." Read 1 John. John tells us that sin is lawlessness, and that we must keep the commandments. Trust in the atonement of Yahushua/Yeshua who is usually called Jesus, and keep God (YHWH)'s whole Word/commandments. Revelation 12:17 So the dragon was enraged with the woman, and went off to make war with the rest of her children, who keep the commandments of God and hold to the testimony of Jesus. Revelation 14:12 Here is the perseverance of the saints who keep the commandments of God and their faith in Jesus. Go to parableofthevineyard youtube channel for information about the bible and good bible studies. I'm in no way paid or sent by him for advertising. I just have learned a lot from his content. He's just a man who is trying to learn as well. :) Yeshua died so we may be resurrected to eternal life.....

[@youngjayzgh.]

I've missed David Wood ❤

[@sebastianmelmoth685]

All non-ancient religions have to invent a geography for their cults. No exceptions.

[@JohnSer33]

Apart from Christianity because all the geographical claims in the NT have been proven correct by archeologists

[@sebastianmelmoth685]

@@JohnSer33 Well - "all" is a bit of an ambitious statement that smacks of American evangelical triumphalism... but a great many, certainly.

[@guerillaguru8650]

Some say Petra is(was) the real Mecca.

[@kerengracefabian7371]

Living Bible Nehemiah 6:1 When Sanballat, Tobiah, Geshem the Arab, and the rest of our enemies found out that we had almost completed the rebuilding of the wall-though we had not yet hung all the doors of the gates-

[@sosorsaba2243]

Baca means Mecca, no doubt of it!

[@newERA1432]

Makkah or Mecca has another name in which is "Bakkah" Which is also mentioned in Quran "الذي ببكة" مكه = بكه As usual, the Jews hide the truth.

[@ksa_1325.]

Baka is a valley in the middle of Mecca. Also it is the old name of Mecca

[@orasinias]

You are wrong

[@ksa_1325.]

@Ali No you don't know

[@orasinias]

@@ksa_1325. First Islam never started from Saudi Second : there is old maps in Catalonia public archive they show baca in a completely different country If you see the area where baca is written on the map it will make sense and you will see all the history missing puzzles Saudi is not the holy land

[@ksa_1325.]

@@orasinias I respect your stupid opinion

[@jorgandrfilio8040]

​@@ksa_1325.It's not stupid it's facts that you're already in denial about it

[@noamto]

Baka also has one k and Mecca has a double k (with shadda), which is significant. And Baka is masculine while Mecca is feminine.

[@YamnayaSintash]

There literally exists the valley of beqaa in Lebanon..

[@ashishpatel350]

The bible is as real as Santa Claus

[@arolemaprarath6615]

No

[@davidjanbaz7728]

UR ignorance is overwhelming.

[@jasamkojajesam6108]

Your iq as low as winter temperature in siberia.

[@hdl135605]

The Quran is corrupted by Satan evident from the Satanic Verses.

[@awesomefacepalm]

Well I have a real bible at home 🤷‍♂️

[@RedLFCBlood]

Detective O’will appears to have been deliberately lying again in his refutation video. He says the verse 22.27 doesn’t refer to Abraham calling people to the Hajj… Classical Islamic scholar Ibn Kathir completely disagrees with Detective O’wills fallacious reasoning. Tafsir Ibn Kathir 22.27 "O Lord, how can I convey this to people when my voice will not reach them'' It was said: "Call them and We will convey it.'' So Ibrahim stood up and said, "O mankind! Your Lord has established a House so come on pilgrimage to it.''

[@ApostateProphet]

There are some scholarly opinions that 28 and 29 do not address Abraham, because if they did address Abraham then the Quran would be communicating something strange. Lol Now some smart people want to go further and add the ridiculous assertion that 27 is not directed at Abraham although the context is very clear.

[@RedLFCBlood]

@@ApostateProphet Just keep doing you AP, when you see how they have to blatantly lie and throw their classical scholars under the bus you know you’re having an impact, no matter how much they try to deny that.

[@RedLFCBlood]

@@RaRa-xv2bu The Tafsir of classical Islamic scholar Ibn Kathir disagrees, you obviously don’t know your Islamic literature… And proclaim to mankind the Hajj) meaning, `announce the pilgrimage to mankind and call them to perform pilgrimage to this House which We have commanded you to build.' It was said that Ibrahim said: "O Lord, how can I convey this to people when my voice will not reach them'' It was said: "Call them and We will convey it.'' So Ibrahim stood up and said, "O mankind! Your Lord has established a House so come on pilgrimage to it.'' quranx.com/tafsirs/22.27 Or are you deliberately misleading people as you’re the con man with no knowledge? Ironically when you use the you don’t know Arabic argument you’re dismissing every single Muslim who doesn’t understand Arabic and that’s the overwhelming majority … engage your brain…

[@smidlee7747]

@@RedLFCBlood It interesting when someone reads from Muslim's own sources Muslims will call that person a liar. They do that often with David Wood who just read from "Muslim's most trusted sources"

[@RedLFCBlood]

@@smidlee7747 Yep, you link them to the Tafsir and he still attacks A.P calling him a liar etc when the highly regarded classical Islamic scholar with the most comprehensive exegeses completely and unequivocally agrees with Ap’s position… It’s almost like they’re not interested in the truth from their own literature…

[@Revelations7]

The Valley of Baca is literally in The region Of Palestine,in the north of Jerusalem I think

[@joelb3613]

A genuine question. Not asking to be insulting. I’m just curious. Many Muslims call Apostate Prophet “apus” meaning it as an insult. What does apus mean?

[@dbo514]

Just a dumb insult referring to "pussy"

[@coolbuddydude1]

For a people known for their memorization, they are not good at preserving history.

[@Margatatials]

I am getting Muslim charity adds on this video, tells us something about the demographics that watch AP

[@swexsepticeye2805]

I swear every year i come here to check your content, it just keeps going worse and worse bruh

[@Kemenyan73]

If God wanted us to bow to a cube of rock then that God must have liked LEGOS

[@istvansipos9940]

which would be a smart choice from any god. a slight compensation for all the bad choices

[@m.stellar309]

Beqaa valley is in lebanon

[@matteorobb5370]

Bakha is Petra, they would have passed through on the journey

[@MM-oj8vb]

It’s so very very simple. The Hebrew word baca means “balsam” but is also the Hebrew verb for “weep.” (As in The balsam tree “weeps” its resin.) This is not hard. Clearly this is the absolute majority consensus and understanding among scholars of the Bible. This is silly for Muslim apologists, it comes off as desperate.

[@kernlove1986]

Then some genius may say that he isn't speaking in absolute, as if that's how we speak in scholarship.

[@petermarklund6449]

In Petra! Listen tog Dan Gibson.

[@Filip_Wessman]

There is a valley of Baca in Lebanon. My ex gf was born there.

[@Hopamptube]

"Bakkah" as a verb!? So why it is B in capital

[@echo6cat526]

Islam claimed lots of things that don’t belong to them. They claim one of the biggest buddhist temple in Indonesia ( Borobudur) with their own so-called “research “ . Anyone please tell me how many historical structures they have built?

[@Alathea123]

I really hope that someday in the future new religion is born and it will worship tolkiens work because it is much better literary work than bible and would love to see all those theist interpretetions of it, and dont get me started on the Lovecraft pieces of art

[@stephenmorris3382]

Jesus Christ when up to JERUSALEM and cleansed it from the people that were trading in the temple. Jesus Christ said this House shall be called the HOUSE OF PRAYER FOR ALL NATIONS. Why didn't Jesus say the house of prayer is in Mecha. Because it's not known or acknowledged as that. If it was important as Abraham built an altar there the Jesus would have definitely mentioned it. But he didn't, instead he said the house of God in Jerusalem will be the house of prayer for all nations.

[@Bengalinationalist]

The injil is distorted by the christiams of judea, that's why it is so unclear

[@Anonymous-sq6eo]

Just like the Quran is so unclear on many instances? Was it also distorted by Christians of Arabia? 😂

[@sawmaniac12]

Ef dawah refuted your entire argument on this argument. Alhamdulillah for Islam

[@hyperionstardust6571]

So? Win one battle doesn't mean winning entire war you know overproud religious nutter

[@bacabrother4331]

Are you could have done was ask me about the word and I could have told you about it and it's meaning in several different languages. I'm not bragging just fact.

[@sam-elite484]

Most biblical scholars also this guy you brought on the channel confirms they don’t know where the valley of baca is specifically. So this still leaves the door open for it to be interpretated as Makkah which you are trying so hard to disprove

[@sam-elite484]

@Prophet of PataliPutra we have the same story in detail which is in bible of how Hagar the wife of Abraham got was in lost and miraculous water came out for her son to drink. Quran confirms it is Makkah where she was and the same spring of water is still coming out today called zamzam and we believe it. I don’t see why they would be mad to pilgrimage there if God led them there. If you look on map it is not that far it is distance that could be reached. Not like travelling from Jerusalem to Europe.

[@sam-elite484]

@Prophet of PataliPutra there may be a distance yes but it’s not impossible to assume they couldn’t have travelled there which is my point.

[@quransamjhofoundation6898]

Pslams 84 mentions pilgrimage and then Valley of Bacca, even a school boy can understand it is talking about the Annual Pilgrimage of Mecca(Also mentioned as Becca in the Quran). In the Muslim Literature Prophet Moses also made a pilgrimage to Becca and so did, Prophet David as he is singing about it.

[@igotcookies]

Dr. Bowen on Tik Tok as “Not Kent Hovind” 😂

[@archangel8489]

I think Muslims missed de c with the b .. The Valley of caca is indeed in meccaca

[@ventriu]

mecca... you mean that huge japanese robot? LOL

[@m.d4310]

The only god that reaches down to people is Jesus, and all the other gods we have to reach up to them. Jesus is the only god that you won’t find his bones in a grave, because he has risen! Amen Jesus answers prayer, the other gods don’t, the other gods are all demonic.

[@user-kv7yn2js2h]

I totally disagree. The mother goddess herself appeared to me.

[@NotChinmayi]

Baca is in Lebanon

[@stephenmorgan3909]

Where does it mention Mecca in the Bible?

[@awesomefacepalm]

It doesn't

[@stephenmorgan3909]

@@awesomefacepalm sone how I didn't think so, so another lie by Islam

[@awesomefacepalm]

@@stephenmorgan3909 indeed

[@stephenmorgan3909]

@Salahuddin Ayubi OK where does it mention Mecca it, what Gospel, what Pslam, what passage, what page?, because I have read the Gospals and the old an new testaments and can't find any referral to Mecca within its pages and now you are going to say, well you didn't read it properly and if I did miss it where us the entry in the Bible the refers, to Mecca directly or this just been simply made up for another thing for Islam to latch onto to put it in an equal par to Judism or Christianity? Or an attempt to make to a superior absolute truth? Which in reality means that all of the trio of desert religions are flawed and have inconsistencies and abnormalities whkch makes them all questionable

[@istvansipos9940]

and Star Wars mentions sand. Sand is proven to exist, thus the Force is real.

[@chuganoga1908]

So it’s actually pronounced Baha like Baha blast Mountain Dew.

[@kironmanuel664]

It seems the Baca here is the Bakkah Valley in Syria.

[@joexviii8662]

It’s the valley Moses went through before he spotted the fire on the Mountain where he got the commandments. Islamic scholars have the opportunity to read the Quran and see this but they don’t. 17:1 is about Moses.

[@MasterMote]

o wow. tehillim(psalm) 84, line 7, says עברי בעמק הבכא. read hebrew right to left, first word means either ‘passer’ or ‘transgressors’, and in this case it means the latter, from context.(those who transgress, or ‘passing/trampling’ past boundries) then middle word just means valley, the last word which they think means ‘kabba’ actually means ‘tears’(like crying). the entire verse 7 of tehillim 84 says "transgressors arrive in the valley of tears(this means gehinnom/hell), there they create a fountain (from all their crying), still they will shower their judge(God) with thanks" meaning even in gehinnom the sinners are thanking God for His righteous judgements. (its like purgatory for them and cleansing them to prepare them to enter gan eden).\ such a fitting verse for muslims to apply to themselves😂 its amazing. btw on a deepee, spiritual note, the verse shows the power within even sinners to transform, that there regret is so great, the cry so much, that ultimately they extinguish the flames of hell with their sincere tears and instead of fire there’s flowing rivers of water from tears. obviously its all metaphorical and symbolic, not literal, but its a powerful visual image i think to convey the power of repentance. and theyre not crying cuz theyre sad from being in pain. theyre sad because the regret what theyve done to land themselves so far from God.

[@victorunbea8451]

Senpai you Bacca!!!

[@meowzers4380]

Aww imagine Mecca was named Becca... That would make their argument a little more believable. (Not enough tho)

[@bos811]

ممكن بس الشخص يلي بدو يعطي دليل ما يكون جاهل كليا خلي يفهم قبل شو عم يحكي اولا: وادي بكا هو اسم وادي في فلسطين (في حياة يسوع) أن هذا الوادي كان المرحلة الأخيرة في الرحلة من شمالي فلسطين إلى أورشليم، "، وهو واد ضيق كئيب تنضح فيه المياه المالحة من الصخور، ومن هنا أخذ اسمه "وادي البكا" أو "وادي الدموع". ف لو سمحت قبل ما تحكي شي قبل تكون تعرف شويت جغرافيا تانيا بكا الموجوده في الإنجيل الإنكليزي the valley of Baca; ((((Baca)))) was actually a valley near Jerusalem, but its name means the place of weeping. Baca اي وادي بكا و ليس bakah ما يقصد به بكة اي مكة و اتمنى هاد الكلام يكون كافي و واضح عن كيفيه محاولة لتشويه كلام الكتاب المقدس كتاب الحق و بالنهاية الله يهدي الجميع و يفتح عيونهم لمعرفه الله الواحد الآب و الأبن و الروح القدس الإله الواحد أمين ✝️💜

[@jonathankhine4073]

Why they kissing to a rock?! It's just a rock or toilet.

[@user-nx5be4sw6w]

What happend to bagga 😂 😂

[@KingKing-er9rq]

Let sing to the lord the new song(Gentile).. he will not speak by his inspired Bakha بَكَ בכה cry .. Hagar and ishamel cried without the water and God made here became spring for them and their descendants . Then God said I will make him(Ismael) a Great nation .. now let see who deserves to be identified here? Where has pilgrimage and blessings God in huge number now Jerusalem or Mecca

[@lileveyc]

Khalil the Eisegete king