Is Pakistan Not for Ahmadis? - Bilal Mahmood | Abbas Haidar | ViewPoint #66

[@Shrimpspiration]

Every Pakistani should have equal rights. It’s sad how the community has been treated in Pakistan. I am making sure that my kids do not fall into such hatred for fellow human being. Stay blessed.

[@khalidsheikh4852]

I am Muslim. And I believe La-ekrafaydeen, Ahmedi should have full right to practice their faith in Pakistan the way they practice in the rest of the world. I apologized from Ahmedi community for such an abusive treatment in Pakistan at govt. level as well as at community level. Good program conduct by Abbas and intelligently answered by Bilal.

[@TabasumAhmad-d3l]

Kia tum apne aap ko musalman kehta hai. Ye shaitani sor Begerat, khaatimun nabin sallallahu alaihi wasallam ke munkir hain.

[@SaleemKhan-z1d8w]

You are looking qadyni

[@SaleemKhan-z1d8w]

Abbas Haider who are you?plz expose your faith and what do you think about qadyanies.

[@anjumsaeed7167]

Khalid sheikh your believe..... Listen then Have you red. لا نبی بعدہ Allah سبحان تعالیٰ Han been closed the chapter of any Nabi or rusul after Mohammed PBUH, so there is no way ahmadis are not Muslim they are kuffars and have no right of minority status

[@faranahmad5699]

@@anjumsaeed7167 is trha to hazrat muhammad s.a.w last prophet na hoe hazrat esa hoe last prophet

[@ejazkiawaz]

Being an educated and enlightened person, I strongly endorse right of Ahmadis who are allowed to live and exercise their faith according to their wishes in Pakistan. I am nonbeliever of Ahmadia Jamaat. Ahmadis live as a minority in Pakistan. All minorities have right of independence and same in the case of Ahmadis. But unfortunately, in religious matters, Pakistan is controlled by the extremist religious groups. Extremist molvies are the trend setters of religious affairs. They set the standards. They will decide who can live in Pakistan and who can't. These extremists enjoy luxuries by milking Pakistani dirty politics as well. Unfortunately, there is no culture of freedom of speech in Pakistan, though it is granted to every citizen by law. It does not matter if even you speak the truth. But what you speak should be aligned with the policy of extremist groups or molvies of Pakistan. You have to support it whether you agree with it or not. I personally do not support religious violence. No one should be allowed to take law in hands. Every religious dispute should be decided by the court, not by the individuals.

[@ZaidKhan-ue2dt]

I am sunni muslim and I love our beloved ahmadis muslims ❤

[@mdamin2190]

Wtf u just said 🤣🤣 Qadiyani are kuffar

[@warnergaming4645]

Ahmadis are true Muslim 😊

[@moiz55]

Non muslim

[@ZaidKhan-ue2dt]

@@moiz55 yes you are non muslim

[@SaifullahKhoshhal]

Yes but as a kafir😊

[@junaidyousaf4485]

Leave Politics and Religion aside as an Ahmadi i think Pakistani mainstream Journalists, should learn how to conduct a discussion programe. the behaviour, the conduct, the manners, the politeness of Abbas Haidar Sahib is of very very high standards, Abbas Haidar Sahib not even once disrupt the coversation in between instead he let his guest finish his coversation and then he put another question, on the other hand Bilal Mahmood Sahib shows the same through out the conversation, i must say that i thoroughly enjoy this beautiful program.. Thankyou very much...

[@Voice4Paece1889]

ماشاءاللہ جزاکم اللہ خیرا

[@munibrehman9747]

This just goes to show the absolutely pathetic and abhorrent state of the professional ethics of journalism in pakistan. Those mainstream so-called "journalists" and "intellectuals" have actually set the bar so low that the simple act of allowing the guest to respond to the question without interrupting them mid-sentence, speaking over them, yelling and shouting on top of your lungs, and engaging with them in a civilized manner to conduct a healthy, intellectual discussion whilst adhering to the basic principles of courtesy, mutual respect and human decency is considered to be nothing short of a REVOLUTIONARY ACT. 😂😂

[@zebashaheer5173]

What you mentioned how a child feels when his grandfather was arrested for wearing a ring with quranic ayat When I left Pakistan in my teenage I used to see nightmares of mob coming to put fire on Ahmadi houses for ten years and then my fear was gone as I felt safe Now I am a grandmother but I want to tell you how ahmadies feel in Pakistan

[@faizanraza8116]

As a non ahmadi and as a human I feel sorry for you guys the way people behave with you

[@jamilmalik6296]

Two civilized gentlemen!

[@Voice4Paece1889]

جی بالکل

[@munawarahmed983]

No one says he is Muslim or not. Allah knows better

[@ViewsGoogler]

Problem is that Allah is the biggest fool creator

[@gulraizahmad1118]

Abbas bhie very good interview. Every ahmdi Muslim l need a equal rights . Bless u brother

[@ShahidShahid-dh4mt]

Mirzaeey Kadyani accepts that as Per constitution of Pakistan they are not Muslim then demand their rights being a minority citizens of Pakistan....

[@lambother]

​@@ShahidShahid-dh4mtagreed

[@fsu3328]

Your not Muslims listen you deny the finality of the prophet

[@ahmaddaniyal967]

ماشاللہ ❤ بہت اچھا پروگرام ہے آپ کا 🎉

[@zainshafiq7995]

I really love and respect the common Ahmadies. Whether they are from the followers of Khilafat Ahmadiyya or Whether they are from the Ahmadiyya Anjuman Lahore. The persecution and the Anti-Ahmadiiya Hatred that is mostly prevalent in the religious circles is totally condemnable. Even if we think, they are not on the right path, we must treat them with courtesy and humbleness. We as a society, really need to be tolerant and pluralistic. Only in this way, we can open doors of communication and exchange our ideas. I have read and studied the Ahmadiyya literature (Selected books of founder Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani Saab, 1st Khalifa Hakim Nooruddin Bhervi, and 2nd Khalifa Mirza Bashiruddin Mehmood Ahmad saab,1st leader of Lahore Ahmadiyya Movement Molana Muhammad Ali Lahori) Jazak Allah

[@tahirmirza8521]

Beautifully structured and probing questions by Abbas Haider, as usual, leaving behind no ambiguity or one-sided favouritism. And equally, superbly answered by Bilal Mahmood without stuttering, hesitating or shouting back in disgust or despair. What a change it is to hear such an intellectually rich discussion than a typical shouting match. Well done. At 1.21.00 Bilal has picked up a pertinent point about how Pakistani Muslims raise concerns against current hostilities of Hindus against Muslims in India. Why should it really matter to them when in the Justice Munir Report of the 1953 riots, the following is a recorded fact: Maulana Moududi was asked: “If we have this form of Islamic Government in Pakistan, will you permit Hindus to base their Constitution on the basis of their own religion?” He replied: “Certainly. I should have no objection even if the Muslims of India are treated in that form of Government as shudras and malishes and Manu's laws are applied to them, depriving them of all share in the Government and the rights of a citizen…" There you are. Why should we be concerned if we preach the same doctrine ourselves? Abolish the 2nd Amendment and Zia ul Haq’s archaic ordinance laws and other current laws being placed. Let the country flourish. Live and let live. Pakistan's economical and intellectual decline must be stopped.

[@aameraslam2984]

It is a sad situation. One of the many sad truths of Pakistan's decline. I'm not an Ahmadi, but I don't understand why this cruelty happens in Pakistan. Possibly the greatest scientist Pakistan had ever produced (the great Dr. Abdusalam) was not even allowed to speak at QuaideAzam University.

[@sadafsaleem5042]

Mashallah Ahmediyyat zinda Baad…proud to be a Ahmedi muslima

[@mohammadfaizanhashmi4213]

😂Gu kha le

[@foyzanahmed4091]

In Every non-Muslim country Muslim want religious right and want to practice their path properly. But they are not ready to give same rights others in other own country. How shameful and pathetic..................

[@RP027]

I$lam is the problem not M0slims

[@sachinsingh5329]

Bitter truth 😊

[@mohsinafzaal7159]

@@sachinsingh5329Heights of Hypocrisy 😂

[@sachinsingh5329]

@@mohsinafzaal7159All These muslims are unhappy under Sharia laws in Islamic countries, and want to settle in rich European countries. But once they get citizenship of European countries, they start demanding separate Sharia laws and wish to follow Islamic values. Barbarism of Islam is exposed to the world now. That is the reason, far right parties are on rise across the globe.

[@silver_springs22]

​@@mohsinafzaal7159that's what islam stands for. Hypocracy utter shame

[@m.ataulaleemsiddiqui9545]

Great job Abbas and Bilal. We need more of this type of conversation in order to develope tolerance and dialogue in the society. May Pakistan becomes a peaceful country one day and no religion/sect is under the threat of extremists and common people practice their religion freely.

[@zebashaheer5173]

The reason why 1984 constitution was made was because our hazrat Mirza tahir ahmad was becoming very popular with his question answer sessions and people were converting fast into ahmadiat and Zia ul haq did not like this He used to say I will clean Pakistan from ahmadi cancer So he made this constitution Although after that ahmadiat is spreading worldwide alhumdolillah

[@Pakistaniblog-89]

Muhamad saw is last messenger of Allah. No mirza shirza was popular.

[@khurramawan4559]

Muahammad is the last Prophet, That is the meaning of خاتم النبيين

[@livelife4461]

Such a humble interviewer❤.

[@shaguftachowhan7074]

I’m not an Ahmedie but both sides did a great job 👏 Thank you

[@khawarbhatti8436]

I am Ahamdie, I think we should have open dialogue. We as an Ahamdie are not from Mars. I have all my best friends are Non Ahmdies and belong to different sects and religion. They are far better human beings and I respect their religion because of their personalities and always say that I am so thankful that you guys are my friends. You definitely have great roots and great religion. A MAN IS KNOWN BY THE COMPANY HE KEEPS....

[@ShahidShahid-dh4mt]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/eIWbnYCYndB5m5Isi=vaD-if8nb3s-aiNE

[@Voice4Paece1889]

جزاک اللہ خیرا

[@MuhammadIshaq-ul3of]

​ 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@anjumsaeed7167]

What good job 😮 They are your enemies and the commit to distroy Pakistan who put them on their right place... They are worst than yahood and hindus, no way to praise them.....

[@MD_Gaming07964]

Mirza gulam Ahmed is a real imam Mehdi massiah Maud.

[@mdamin2190]

He was a kuffar so as his followers

[@mohammadfaizanhashmi4213]

Tatti krte krte mrr gya 😂

[@sarahkhan3711]

A wonderful effort which I as an Ahmadi Muslim appreciate it a lot.

[@induchopra3014]

Vajubule katal

[@esamahemad6394]

​@@induchopra3014pehele to bo vajubule katal nahin he 😂 bo wajebul qatal hotahe. tum jese jahil log jinhe na padhnaa ata he na likh na atahe. suar kahin ke.🐷🐷. tum jeso ke wajese Pakistan ajj ek katora leke duniya var vik mangta fir raha he. jo ayat rasulekarim (s.w.a) ke upar sabse pahele najil huatha -- iqra bisme rabekal laji khalak. iqra- padh (education) yahi chij tumme kami he. or tum keheteho wajebul qatal.. ye Pakistan he isliye tum jese jahil logon ka mun chalta he. yahi bat aake India men kaho. agar tumhara pichwada lal naa krde. to fir tum kehena.

[@Voice4Paece1889]

جزاکم اللہ خیرا

[@lambother]

​@@induchopra3014 chup Kar lanati niyog ki gobar olad... Average lindu brain

[@lambother]

​@@induchopra3014Tu apni maiyya ki niyog ki fikar kar

[@drhamidullahkhan]

Mashallah very useful discussion. I hope there are further programs on the beliefs of Jumaat to make general public informed of the facts from Ahmadiyya point of view.

[@Pakistaniblog-89]

No

[@FamilyTaz33m-us4ix]

@@Pakistaniblog-89does that worry you? If there is no worry, then let everyone share their belief.

[@awaqashashmi2619]

Take your Nabi out of islam and make other religion and give other name

[@FamilyTaz33m-us4ix]

@@awaqashashmi2619 ask Allah swt to do that. If God tells the Mahdi, you are an Ummati Nabi (part of the Ummah and a prophet according to the prophecies of Holy Prophet ﷺ ) then the Mahdi has no right to say otherwise. If you don’t accept him to be Imam Mahdi, that is your choice. But asking him to change his view, is ridiculous.

[@vardhamanpatil1539]

This is the dichotomy of Muslim Society... They want all the rights when they are in non-Islamic countries like UK, France , Netherlands, USA , Canada, India etc.. But in their own country, they will treat non-Muslims as second class citizens... Pakistan is the best example of this...

[@JJ-xo3bc]

This is very true. They cry in western counrties, europe and aus/ new zealand, we want rights we want rights. But what about their own countries.

[@tttv4218]

جزاک اللہ عباس بھائی آپ نے احمدی بھائی کو بولنے کا موقع دیا اللہ تعالی تمام پاکستانیوں کو حق کی بات کرنے کی توفیق دے آپ کا بہت شکریہ ❤❤

[@humsafar-xu8yz]

Masha Allah, this is a very good effort and a very brave and courageous work. May Allah Almighty bless you and your efforts. Ameen, a very good conversation was had by both sides.

[@amatulqayyum5836]

bohut accha conversation.jazakallah bilal sb.❤🇧🇩

[@QaziMuhammadYasir-]

Only @abbashaider , can pull off all these interviews!! We are very grateful to have you Abbas Bhai

[@nasirnadeem9628]

بہت خوب عباسی حیدر صاحب کم از کم کوئی ایک تو ہے پاکستان میں جو ہر ایک کا موقف سنتا ہے اور انصاف کے تقاضے پورا کرنے کی کوشش کرتا ہے

[@Voice4Paece1889]

ماشاءاللہ

[@NasirAli-hs8np]

This indeed a very thought provoking approach for upcoming generation. Being brought up in Pakistan till the age of 10-11ish, and now when i think back i feel a great regret/burden on my chest and feel that I should have been brought up among a multi-religious/multi believe system / multi-dimensions society without any persecution of any kind towards any sect/religion. This too has caused us to be a narrow/closed minded beings because all i saw were Muslims around me, but radically different and extreme in their approaches when it came to dialogues, and I have been informed that its all thanks to Uncle Zia-Ul-Haqq for radicalizing the over all nation's institutions and public mentality. Before Zia people were accepting, they were "relaxed" and tolerant. May Allah grant us patience and open mind to accept people for whatever they believe in, and above all, for simply being human. Ameen!

[@yousafanwar1]

Appreciated the open dialogue with the Ahmadi's Muslim. Let there's a space for the peaceful existence in Pakistan for the Ahmadi's Muslim.

[@Pakistaniblog-89]

No they.are not Muslim

[@KingKing-bd4yb]

From Last 75 years Iseral making land narrow for Palestine and Pakistan making land narrow for Ahmedi Muslims..and Other Minorities

[@Afaqi2012]

Due to the religious nature of both states

[@ArafatAli-j7e]

Hmm and mirzai girls are appointed in idf regiment of isreal for period of two years

[@skysight1553]

​@@ArafatAli-j7eye Kya Hai Jani

[@zillurrahman-h4t]

You are absolutly correct, ku k Nabi(sw) formaia mera ummot ko koss molla yeahudi ki tara hoga.

[@MegaNainaa]

I admire and love your show, you chose topics that are not mainstream. Power to you for your show. Blessings from Houston, TX

[@mudisstudio3048]

Abbas bahi ....u have such wonderful heart and ethics.....superb streaming

[@Humanity_matters708]

Alhamdulilah I proud to be AHMADI MUSLIM , thank god I am AHMADI MUSLIM LAILAHA ILALAH MOHAMADAR RASULULLAH….

[@Pakistaniblog-89]

Non muslim hain ap. Hazrat Muhammad saw last nabi hain

[@Humanity_matters708]

@@Pakistaniblog-89 god knows better who are in a right path ,,,, khuda na bano khuda janta hai Koon sacha hai Koon jhutha hai … we also belive prophet Mohammad peace be upon him…. Our kalma is lailaha illalah Mohammadar rasulullah Agar aap nay achay say darud sharif pada hota to yai baat nahi kartay

[@mubasharahmad8013]

Mash shaa Allah ❤ Alhumdullillaah ❤

[@mubasharahmad8013]

​@@Pakistaniblog-89non Muslim hyn ap ap Hazoor pak Sallaalaaa hoo Aly Hay wa Aaaleehee Wasullum ko akhree nbee ni manty, ap kehty isaa alysalam ny abee ana Hy

[@kiran4044]

اپنے کافر ہونے پر فخر کرو

[@minnilifestlye]

Alhamduliallah i am ahmadi❤

[@mwaqarwiki1289]

Nonmuslim

[@reelstrend7089]

@@mwaqarwiki1289so you’re disagreeing with Hazrat Muhammad SAW now, because they said those who read Kalima is Muslim

[@ChRamizTahirQureshi]

الحمدللہ 💖

[@tayyabrizwans2009]

Main b ahmadi hoon aap kon c city say hoo

[@albertmassey8529]

Abbas doing great work ❤

[@Voice4Paece1889]

Yes

[@MUSHTAQAHMAD-mi8yv]

اگر جماعت احمدیہ قائد اعظم کا جنازہ پڑہانے والے کے پیچھے نہیں پڑہنا چاہتے تھے تو علیحدہ پڑہا لیتے۔ ایسا کئی دفعہ ہو جاتا ہے۔

[@AsimKhan-om3yo]

It’s hard but you’ve again managed to out do yourself! Thank you for keeping up with your commitment to engage all sects and thank you for bringing forward such a well articulate and brave guest.

[@Voice4Paece1889]

👌

[@shreky.singh.sindhu]

Salutes to those who had tolerance to listen to this podcast after the first 5 minutes... Thought provoking.

[@ASh-ks2ty]

اچھی کاوش ھے اپ دونوں کافی ھر قسم۔کا علم رکھنے والے اللہ اپ کو ھر میدان میں کامیابی عطا فرمائے آمین

[@Voice4Paece1889]

آمین

[@Qallash]

I learnt a lot from both the guest and the host. I must applaud Abbas sahib for having good etiquettes to run a well conducted interview 👏👏

[@munawarahmed983]

Respected Brother Pakistan is for everyone, Ahmyyda are respected citizens of Pakistan Mashallha

[@manishsaini9360]

No Actually there are not

[@ilyas2025]

@@manishsaini9360 Jo Allah ky Rasool ki Nubawat par naqab lagay usko kaisay Ahmedi ya Muslim kehyn Muslims ka 100 percent muttafiqa aqeeda hy ky qadian is kafir

[@Voice4Paece1889]

ماشاءاللہ جزاکم اللہ خیرا

[@lambother]

​@@manishsaini9360Tu India ki fikar kar.... Shudar ko Mandir main ghusnay ki ijazat Nahi... Lynching Roz ho rahi hai.. yahan bakwas mat kar.. average lindu brain

[@irshadmohammad8048]

ماشاءاللہ بہت اچھا پروگرام هے ❤

[@a.a2572]

Bohat acha Programm Hai...shukar Hai kisi ko Himat hoi baat karnay ki

[@mshirazbaig6055]

Both of you are brave people. Good. We must allow everyone to be equal citizen.

[@Voice4Paece1889]

Yes

[@Voice4Paece1889]

عباس حیدر صاحب آپ کی جرات اور بہادری کو سلام ہے جو آپ نے ایک احمدی مسلمان کو اپنا موقف پیش کرنے کا موقع دیا۔ اللہ تعالیٰ ہمارے ملک اور عوام پر اپنا رحم فرمائے۔ پاکستانی عوام کی اکثریت دن بدن اخلاقی پستی کا شکار ہوتی جارہی ہے۔ مذہبی رواداری کا فقدان ہے۔ رحمۃ للعالمین صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم کا نام تو لیتے ہیں لیکن آپ کے مبارک اسوہ حسنہ سے کوسوں دور ہیں ۔ ہماری ہمیشہ یہ دعا ہے کہ اللہ تعالیٰ ان پر رحم کرے اور ہدایت دے۔آمین

[@Masood-w7h]

Just Ahmdi and not Ahmdi muslim

[@Aliarshad000]

Great effort!!! Everyone have a right breath freely

[@aamirsattar5493]

پیارے اللّٰہ جی، ہمارے پیارے ملک پر رحم فرما اور عوام کو رسول کریم(ص) رحمت العالمین کے بےحد پیارے اسوہ پر عمل کرنے کی توفیق عطا فرما (آمین)

[@kiran4044]

آمین

[@nooruddinnasir769]

اللہ تعالیٰ بلال بھائی کو صحت و سلامتی والی لمبی عمر عطا کرے نیز مخالفین کے شر سے محفوظ رکھے آمین

[@muneer3016]

ماشاءاللہ بہت ہی اچھی گفتگو کی گئی

[@Voice4Paece1889]

👌

[@captainvic123]

Mashallah ❤ Good job . Allah knows what in your heart and region is very personal for everyone.

[@Justice4All-]

You are awesome Abbas Bhai. 👏🏼👏🏼

[@wissen2337]

Main Ahmadi Muselman hu. Ahmadi and Sunni Muslim = Peace ❤

[@tanvirahmad2568]

Excellent

[@momo19991]

Everyone should be treated equally and our religion should be a personal matter. Take religious categorization out of all public and government matters. Thank you to Abbas Bhai for another terrific piece allowing us to each other’s humanity.

[@Voice4Paece1889]

ماشاءاللہ جزاکم اللہ خیرا

[@Zigsalecom]

Ap sai bol rahe hein but ahmadis apne har jalsa pe puri dunia k flages legate hein but pakistan ka flagella ni?

[@umair.saleem]

That is perhaps the most ridiculous thing I've heard, if it is such a personal matter then why did Abu bakr siddique r.a wage war against the Arabs who claimed prophethood ? Why did he punish those who refused to give zakat ? Do we follow the rules and regulations set out by the Qur'an and sunnah or the rules and regulations set out by men and women according to their own desires ? The answer is a simple one if you're a Muslim you cannot choose option 2 that's go completely against islam.

[@momo19991]

@@umair.saleem Not everyone shares your blind faith and they deserve equal protection in a modern state unlike the oppressive ways of early Islam.

[@umair.saleem]

@@momo19991 either Ur a Muslim calling Islam oppressive in which case Ur an gone against Ur own Deen or your a non Muslim which in which it doesn't what you think this country wasn't built for what u want it to be millions died for the creation of a nation in which Muslims are free to practice their religion and be ruled accordingly. You're saying secularism is a good path forward when in history the biggest deaths was caused as a direct result of secular governments.

[@muhammadasaad2681]

It's a new perspective towards them...thnx abbas Haider for being so Tolerate and brave to invite him

[@Sabaahmed2000]

Tolerate mean ?? Is just conversation and interaction Mr haider must be knew all everything before starting conversation so no worries

[@riffatkashif4624]

People who are believing another nabi/ rasool, they are not Muslim anymore. However they can have rights to live in Islam but they don’t have to call themselves Muslim

[@SkazimSkazim-qv3od]

دنیا کا اختیار اللہ پر ہے ۔ جماعت احمدیہ لا الہ الا اللہ محمد رسول پر ایمان رکھتا ہے ۔

[@akhtariakhtari8187]

اللہ آپ دونوں پر اپناہر لمحہفضائل و برکات نازل کرتا رہے۔آمین

[@Voice4Paece1889]

آمین

[@ranakhalil5911]

MashAllah,braveness is there

[@nadimzahid5718]

MashaAllah, very nice discussion, May Allah Taala Bless you both Ameen.

[@KyaHamAazaadHain]

حیدر بھائی آپ مبارک باد کے مستحق ہیں کہ آپ ھمیشہ بھترین اور ضروری موضوعات پر اور انصاف برابری سچائی کی تلاش میں سرگرداں رھتے ھیں اور عوام تک یہ تمام ضروری حقائق پھنچاتے ھیں اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کو صحت وسلامتی والی لمبی زندگی عطا فرمائے اور بےشمار خوشیاں اور کامیابیاں عطا فرمائے آمین ثم آمین یارب العالمین ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@Voice4Paece1889]

ماشاءاللہ

[@amtulbasir7017]

Nice Programm.👍👍👍 Jazakallah kher.❤️❤️❤️🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟

[@skynet2010]

Every Pakistani should have equal rights, irrespective of his religion.

[@Munjya_Jinn]

Except Jinnah no body believe in this

[@RP027]

Not according to i$lam

[@rowenaravenclaw3483]

You are going against Islamic shariah here

[@Moodus55]

Should Ahmadies also have equal rights within their own jamaat? Do they?

[@vvk594]

Don’t talk nonsense. You guys hate Hindus, Christians, Ahmadiyas, Sikhs, - a stupid country for minorities.

[@anarkali_217]

I dont agree with all ur views abbas . But must say this effort of yours to get views of all minorities and marginalized religious groups is really commendable and positive. People need to listen to views different from their owns and learn to be respectful to each other . I learned alot from this video i had no idea n alot of fake propaganda about ahmedis. Thanks

[@Syt-zj8mq]

religion is very personal matter people must understand this.

[@bint-e-khadim4112]

May Allah the Almighty reward host immensely for his courage.Ameen Wonderful program

[@IftikharKhan-il2nc]

Mr Abas , you are also a big human who showed such a great courage that may be dangerous for you if you are in Pakistan cos mullah is utterly nonsense, cheater as well as deceptive. You must be aware of hounds . I take my hats off to both of you braves .

[@na789]

Marvellous, Jazakallah

[@Voice4Paece1889]

ماشاءاللہ

[@jvsuryanarayana]

Ahmedias were in the very forefront of the fight for Pakistan but now they are neither Muslims nor even a recognised minority there in Pakistan. As Bilal said, it is very unfortunate.

[@ImranMalik-nc3nz]

It's a strange comment. Neither Muslims nor a recognized minority ? Ahmadis are Muslims . why would we let any Gov't decide who we are? why should any Gov't have the right or power to decide anywhere what any person's religion is or isn't ?

[@ambuj100]

Karma

[@sachinsingh5329]

Ahmedis of Pakistan are paying for what they did to India 🇮🇳. Bloody partition.

[@sanjithkmemon8525]

Poor fellows. Worked so hard for Pakistan and are now unwelcome on Pakistan.

[@ravindramorey5433]

​@@ImranMalik-nc3nzvery true. It is very strange that Ahmadi Muslims, who were in forefront for forming Pakistan on basis of two nation theory were constitutionally categorized as non Muslim's during Bhutto regimn. Is it not the fact, However strange it may sound to you. And remember, I have said constitutionally, it's a Pakistan state policy.

[@syedshussain1]

I salute the host and appreciate his courage, Bilal sb I enjoyed listening to your answers, very simple way of explaining Ahmadiyya side of point of view

[@miralfatima]

V nice discussion. Quite a lot of ambiguities about Ahmed I sect were clarified Wish all of us learn how to exhibit tolerance patience n how to co exist in a society. We r no one to judge or label other minorities as kafir. Let Allah decide it. Islam teaches us tolerance n sabr

[@Salman.Sma.]

Great initiative brother you opened up some space by providing ppl with your platform to atleast speak their minds and blvs so that ppl can understand each other better. ❤

[@tahirgaming3396]

I love the way you answering the Abbas question you are such a good person I am also Ahmadi i support you bilal bahi

[@Salman.Sma.]

Im surprised that your video survived this long 🥲

[@bushranaveed3368]

ماشاء اللہ بہت اچھے جواب دے رہے ہیں

[@Voice4Paece1889]

ماشاءاللہ

[@HT-rita]

سلام۔ماشاءاللہ سے میزبان اور مہمان دونوں نے نہایت صبرو تحمل سے اپنے اپنے نظریات کو پیش کیا۔اور تمام نظریات کو مدلل طور پہ پیش کیا۔سب سے اچھی بات یہ کہ دوستانہ ماحول میں ڈسکشن ہوئی۔بہت شکریہ بلال حیدر صاحب اور بلال محمود صاحب۔

[@ijazkhan5806]

Assalamo Alaikum Wa Rehmatullah MashaAllah,very cool ,amazing conversation. May Allah Grant you best reward.

[@MuhammadMehdi-cx5is]

This is the first time ever im hearing an ahmadi's point of view about islam. I used to think they dont use words like mashallah, alhamdulillah etc. Well after knowing the basics of qadiyani religion im not convinced to call them muslim but i believe every qadiyani should have all the rights as the rest of Pakistani nation.

[@jamilmalik6296]

Please note, no human has the right to decide if an individual is a Muslim or not. A Christian or not. A Hindu or not! Only the Almighty can. Regards.

[@talatchaudhry423]

Great job bringing different perspectives highlighting different benefits.

[@talatchaudhry423]

I meant talking about different beliefs which are misunderstood by different groups.

[@muhammadhaq8330]

Masha Allah,, nice to see Mr Bilal Mahmood after long time..

[@daapengineer9226]

I'm not Ahmadi but in Pakistan ahamdies are not secured.Humanity first and protect their basic rights

[@bilala4887]

Thankyou Abbas Haider for a very beautiful and spiritual conversation. Thanks for Bilal Mahmood sahib also for defence of his point of view.

[@ChRamizTahirQureshi]

میں احمدی مسلمان ہوں اور صرف قربانی کرنے کی وجہ سے ہمیں 7 دن جیل میں نظر بند رکھا گیا 😢۔

[@theinnocenttruth]

Toba Toba Astaghfaar.

[@Dhruvathee]

Muslim nahi ho mirza maloon kuta mirza tatti

[@ChRamizTahirQureshi]

@@theinnocenttruth 😓😓😓

[@Hina78672]

Maine puri video dekhi or mujhe lag raha hy k AHMADIYYAT IS THE GREAT ISLAM.

[@beahumanbeing5832]

Hum sanatani bhi bwhutst7fy karte han kodtly hwkare sanatani isdibnaat ke liye idkaam ko oarhte hsen ke ke 72 hooron ke chsksr mien b 72 firke nsn gae. 8n kirn gari kiya har dub ke hath mien m9hd talwar pakrha hiya hae sivae ahnadiyyon ke inka jihaad logicaly samajh aata hae 9r baki musalmanonka j8haad dirv khoon nichorh ke k9hd ko pilana hae 2o musalmaam k9hd ko qik rakshash ke tor pr pesh karte hwrn jahan har waqt katlo haraya chalti rahe jo talwar mohd ne inko oairhaee hae wo hum kafiron pr to bahut kam chalti har aps m8en hi j8haad kar bethe haen musakmaan ne m7salmaan hi kata. Dar asal buniyaad mien khoon hi thas jahan 8mwm Hussain wl8 8noq khalifa ummar or usmaam sub ko inke apno ne inka katal kiya. In se achhi to shmdafiyyon ki khilafat hae jo katal to nahi hue. Jahan tak samajh kehti har or 2 mohd aae hwrn sik ahmafiyyonbka doosra mohd in musalmanon ka ahmsfiyyon ka to unko insaan bana gita 8n musalmanonkw mohd in musalmanon ko jsnwar bana giyaà jo inke mohd ko na mane us ka katal jo maan ke chhith jae uska katal jo sahaba ko kuch kahe uska katal jo Mohd ko kuchh kahe uska katal à jo inki ammaon ko kuchh keh de uska katal à jo ye kahe muj se allah kalam karta hae us ka katal jo keh de m8en nbibya à mad8h hoon ud ks katwp matlwb hwr daur miej mohd ko khoon cjshiye hota thaa. Pehle hum sanataniyon ka khoon bahut pasand thas aaj kal in ahmsfiyyon ka khoon mohd ko bahut pasand hae ye hi wajah hae je har mahine 2 char qhmafiyyon ka khoon mohd ko pila diya jata har itni fehshat phaila rakhi ke shmafi apni shanakht chhupate phirte haen pajistaan mienà. Ye hi yreek Islaam ko phaikane ke liye hum sanataniyon ke saath poore arab mien kiya gita thas. Sik aa ke xwkham lagaya gae diisra was ke marhum patti karta hae poore pakistaa n mien har koi jannat ke chakkar men ahmsfiyyon pr zulm pr zulm karta ja raha hae or whmafi aage se jawab isi liye nahi dete àke unke mohd ne ianko talwar nahi pakrhaeeà what un hon ne bhi talwar pakarhi to mirzaà jhoot ho jata haeà. Ye hi wwjah ke unhon ne talwar nahi oakarhi wwtja badle ki hhawwnw mien wghanistaan mien sik doisre ke khandan hi khatum kiye haen pichhale sik so 20 saal se usne mere mwrw mene uska mara bas ye hi chal. Raha hae shmafies is de bache hue harm warna jun tak goli na lage sik aadmi ho fehshat phalane mien koi kami nahi chhorhat

[@newsandinfo804]

Ahmadi are non Muslim. Ye log khatme nabowat k munkr hain

[@arshaddurrani3885]

Jahilon k ma'ashray may kya behas karni. I wish every Ahmadi finds a peaceful,educated society to live and prosper.Ahmadis have contributed greatly in every department they served in Pakistan.Their decency and professionalism have never been questioned,setting high standards.

[@Voice4Paece1889]

ماشاءاللہ جزاکم اللہ خیرا

[@lambother]

Good joke

[@hafizshams8733]

بالکل جاہل مطلق انگریز کی پیداوار مرزا قادیانی کے ماننے والے بھی جاہل مطلق

[@wissen2337]

Iam Ahmadi and i love Pakistan 🇵🇰

[@muskanbabar3177]

ماشاءاللہ ماشاءاللہ بہت زبردست پروگرام ہے بہت بہترین سوال اور بہت بہترین جواب ❤

[@shaikhtalha4553]

Salam.Abbas bhai.i m First viewer

[@ShahidAli-by4iz]

Religion is nobody's franchise. No one has a right to call anyone a "Non-Muslim". This is idiotic, and I condemned this grave injustice toward our Ahmadi brothers and sister. Nice conversion, Mr. Bilal Mahmood. Excellent vlog!

[@syrajatt6141]

No one has right to call anyone non Muslim? That's idiotic statement itself

[@rehankhan-ud1dv]

Bakwas and Totley disagree Pakistan is a Islamic country and we have Wright to decide who don't believe on khatme nobowat

[@faranahmad5699]

you cant force your opinions on any one thats what islam teaches us @@rehankhan-ud1dv

[@ShahidShahid-dh4mt]

Kadyani not a Muslim it's seperate religion

[@ArafatAli-j7e]

Abu Lulu feroz pe lakh di lanath

[@aaqibmahmood9877]

Bht acha explain kia. Shukran

[@SahibG2763]

ماشاءاللہ بہت اچھی کاوش ہے اللّٰہ تعالیٰ آپ کو کامیاب کرے آمین

[@Masroor-jq2un]

ماشاءاللہ اللہ تعالیٰ اپکی دعا قبول فرمائے

[@MC-qr1js]

Abbas Haida shahid Good Topic you are great,May Allah Ta’alah bless you Ameen.Bills Mahmood shahib also did good job Mashallah.

[@official_ashhh]

Great debate. Very important.

[@Cosmic_Exploration]

Apna khayal rakhin Abbas Bohat sensitive topic *"religion"* choose kea hay apny or hamary logon ki mentality Ap khoob janty hain

[@anjummahmood1381]

May Allah bless you

[@21stcenturylucifer]

we stand for equal rights.. enough of this bulshit.. full respect to Abbas bhai for doing such amazing work

[@Voice4Paece1889]

جزاکم اللہ خیرا

[@lambother]

Lanat kanay Mirza par

[@ShaheenIqbal52]

اپ کی باتوں اور باتوں کے مفہوم میں بڑا فرق ہے۔سمجھنے والے بہت سمجھ رکھتے ھیں۔ I am very close to this firka.

[@inamurrahimkhan8986]

A very interesting, mind opening and intellectual podcast, only you can do such a podcast.❤

[@saleemakhtar7059]

جزاک اللہ تفصیل سے جماعت احمدیہ کے عقائد بتا نے کا بہت بہت شکریہ ۔