Is Shane OVERRATED The Walking Dead Hot Takes

Thank you for watching and for 5000 SUBS! I hope you enjoyed today’s video, I do not claim ownership of any of the clips in this video I am purely adding commentary and stating my own opinion.
If you enjoyed todays video please do like and subscribe remember this video is only my opinion so don’t cook me to much in the comments hahah.
Captain Golds Channel- ‪@TheRealCaptainGold‬
#theohunt #walkingdead #shanewalsh

[@shadowmomochiuchiha6839]

Shane fans about to tell u sum

[@theohuntt]

I’m prepared to be roasted… 🥲

[@Zeroedits_alt]

Real

[@shadowmomochiuchiha6839]

@@theohuntt Brace yourself

[@Guapanator]

​@@theohunttlet me tell u something 😂

[@LayingInAMeadow]

Me!!!!

[@7StarKarma]

Shane was essential for the first two seasons, anyone calling him overrated is on crack. Most of the internal conflict came from him, it’d be pretty uneventful if he wasn’t around.

[@JacobChardBRA]

so weird how heath just disappeared and it felt like no one if any cared about it in the show.. the characters barely mentioned him if I remember correctly.

[@jonfreeman9682]

He was in the RV and got attacked and disappeared after so we all assumed he was dead. The actor wanted to leave the show for a starring role in another show so they wrote him off without killing him to leave an opening incase he comes back. Maggie did the same thing and then came back.

[@theohuntt]

Yeah I know it was so strange. At the time I thought they were setting up another storyline with his disappearance, but no bro just vanished 😭😭😭

[@theruiner4272]

Shane is actually a bad survivor for The Walking Dead. Not only is he overrated, people act like the man would conquer the world if he would've killed Rick. not only is the guy clearly a mentally weak and unstable person, but like you said, he's extremely impulsive, hot-headed, and his plan to go to Fort Benning was stupid. Also could you imagine the group's response if Shane came back to tell the group that Rick had died after he killed him? Lori, Carl (who had left the house around the time Rick killed Shane and likely would find his dad's corpse), Daryl, and Glenn (who both would likely put two and two together after finding out that Randall died from a broken neck) would all know that Shane is full of shit and killed Rick. They wouldn't accept the man as their leader. I'm pretty sure Daryl, Glenn, T-Dog, and even Hershel would all agree the man should die and be left behind. Something also tells me if Carl stumbled across his dad's corpse after wondering off and he saw Shane while the farm was being attacked by walkers, he'd likely kill Shane is a similar way to how he killed him in the comics. Let's say there was a storyline where both Shane and Rick survived season 2. In order for this to happen, Shane's entire character would likely have to a be a bit different. He might still be a deranged hot-head, but he wouldn't be as deranged and insane as he is in the show. he still likely wouldn't survive long. He'd likely be kicked out of the group once they all find out he killed Randall. If Rick somehow convinced Shane to come back to his senses and drop his pistol, Shane would either leave the group right there, or Rick would later kick Shane out of the group after the zombie overrun the farm. And how long do you think Shane would survive out there alone? He's not Daryl. Aside from being a formidable combatant and former police officer, he doesn't have a lot of survival skills. He probably wouldn't show up again.

[@mkwsoxfan]

Hot take if maggies character was going to leave the show 3 separate times for large chunks of the show after Glenns death, then it should have been someone else besides glenn dying. Imagine Glenns character arc if maggie died, and Steven's portray of glenns change after his wife and baby died

[@mkwsoxfan]

Even further, if rick, Michonne, Maggie, and other characters were written out of the show without dying other characters who died who actually wanted to stay should have had storylines changed to. Aka kill Rick Michonne Maggie, let Carl, Glenn, Jesus live 🤷

[@theohuntt]

Yeah I agree! I think Hershel needed to be born but after that I would have been fine with Maggie dying as she just basically leaves the show

[@Voltrix-r5t]

Agreed bro, Glenn should’ve lived and had that Season 5 Rick arc

[@jonfreeman9682]

Yeah that would be cool to bring him back but this time they followed the comics. Killing Carl was unexpected though as that's not the comics and the actor wanted to stay on the show too. But honestly that was peak TWD.

[@ashton__769]

I don’t think he’s over rated but I do think the fan base is overly hyped anytime he is mentioned bc he was the first character to embrace the end and live in the “new world” in season 2. I think people wish Shane was able to somehow survive his situation and come back later and that what makes him “overhyped”.

[@theohuntt]

Yeah totally, Just because Shane was the first to adapt doesn’t mean he’s the best equipped

[@ashton__769]

@@theohuntt and I think people tend to forget that as well. He had issues and not being able to live long enough to see him change still messes with fans till this day imo. He never really got an arc that mattered in the long term. People just wish he was bigger than what he is but I don’t necessarily think it’s to the level of overrated but close bc Shane fans are wild.

[@jonfreeman9682]

Shane is a legend and what made the first two seasons so amazing. I would argue the first season was the best and the farm season was very well done.

[@alexandraalves6620]

As a woman, it baffles me everytime someone uses the " Misogyny " Card on the walking dead. Like, are you kidding me??? Are we watching the same show?????. Andrea got butchered by bad writing, while Lori was just there, I guess... It's hard to feel simpateticly about Lori's character and that's fine. Women are people, and people can be flawed and annoying sometimes. About Shane, while I don't agree that he's overrated, I do think that his die-hard fans can be as annoying as Negan's fanboys. I read a lot of fanfiction on my spare time and I cringe everytime a see an author writing Rick as this stupid sack of waste ( Shane's always a misunderstood Angel👼). Everyone with two functioning brain cells knows that Rick's a waaay better leader. Congrats on the subs, my dude. Your work is amazing!.

[@theohuntt]

Don’t get me started on Negan. The way people talk about him 😭😭 but thank you so much it means a lot! :)

[@Change--Eleven--11]

Lori was s*xually assaulted and manipulated by Shane yet the fandom blames Lori for having those things happen to her as if it was her fault, that's the misogyny. And this misogyny bled into real life interactions with fans towards Sarah Wayne Callies. So yeah, the misogyny is very much real.

[@FBelos]

@@Change--Eleven--11 hi that wasn't what i meant when i comment that I know there's people like that I meant those who act like the show version wasn't still dislikable and make Misogyny the only reason people could dislike her being sexually assaulted is NEVER anyone's fault no matter the gender or how likable they are

[@PigossiWhisky17]

Many guys in the TWD fandom are indeed misogynistic, Lori is the perfect example of this, all the wrong things she did, Rick and even Daryl did, but I never see anyone judging the stupid decisions of the male characters.

[@grepenoop]

If shane ended up as the leader we all know he'd eventually snap and pull a Governor 💀 Also, Enid is an uninspired and annoying character that is a net negative to the episodes that partially focus on her.

[@theohuntt]

Hahaha yes definitely! And I’d agree with you there about Enid

[@PerplexineEditz]

No he wouldn’t he’s a great man before the apocalypse, he protected the group in s1 when no one else was being a leader.

[@PigossiWhisky17]

What did Enid even do to be "annoying" she's always trying to help everyone.

[@TheRealCaptainGold]

I'm always happy to be in a Theo Hunt video. 😎Great takes, as per usual mate.

[@theohuntt]

Thank you my man!!!

[@Voltrix-r5t]

Hot take: Glenn should’ve survived, or at least didn’t have an “Invincible arc” in season 6. I always thought that having Carl and Glenn alive together would’ve made a lot of things sense. Daryl is the heart of TWD, Glenn was the soul. I suggest making a “What If Glenn Survived and Maggie Died At The Lineup?” Would’ve been interesting to see Glenn being much more darker and interacting with Negan in this scenario and the friendship between Rick and Glenn be tested in the future. Hell, Glenn could overtake when Rick leaves the show, having Glenn and Daryl side by side being the main characters. Daryl can step back a bit so Glenn can be there, having better character development than Maggie did. I don’t hate Maggie, I just hate the fact that she became worse the later seasons.

[@Itz_Puxe]

As a Shane fan MANLEMMIETELLYOUSUMTHIN MANITELLYOUWHAT😤 they got walkers all out there in the WOOOOODS okay?! Now if they wanted to live, if they wanted to survive, they had to fight for it. 😂 I read all of this in Shane's voice as I was typing it out

[@theohuntt]

Hahahahah that’s brilliant 😭😭😭

[@Kinja99]

Hot take Morales shouldnt have died and maybe he could have stayed a prisoner and changed like alden that wouldve been cool

[@theohuntt]

That would have been so much better than what we actually got 😭😭😭

[@thirty-thirty.v2]

Shane was always right and wrong at the same time. 😅

[@theohuntt]

I know his heart was in the right place most of the time he just went about everything wrong 😭😭😭

[@corbinowens2437]

I agree w/ Glenn needing to die when he did. I remember saying all summer long while waiting for the S7 premiere that it HAD to be Glenn or Daryl in order to have that impact that it needed. Also, Glenn killed multiple people in the episode “Not Tomorrow Yet”

[@AyeitsWood]

Let me tell you something man, Shane is in the mount Rushmore of The walking dead, on its success, he might be a little overrated as a survivor but one of the best characters in the whole universe

[@theohuntt]

I’m with you on that, Shane is a brilliant character don’t get me wrong but people talk like he would have found a cure for the virus 💀

[@cStatE95]

The reasons why i liked shane is because the relationship he had with rick from friends to having to 86 one another, he is what every other villian ended as. (Survival to villain aka governor negan alpha) plus jon berthnal acting awesome. You wanna talk about overrated characters letmetellyousumthingabout carol and daryl (rubbing my head)

[@thedecipher346]

Jessie was better for Rick than Michonne

[@Furiasu]

Hi Teo, I would like to clarify my take, because I didnt explain myself properly: I dont think the whole series became boring, I even watcher until the whisperer's destruction and I really enjoyed it. My take was that the walkers felt somewhat worthless and irrelevant after season 4, up to the point were, if you eliminated them the world wouldnt have changed (lets say the got destroyed decomposed by heat or something similar). Aside from that, I agree with the characters being the main points of the show and that the stories were really enjoyable, I just would have liked that the setting of a zombie world would have got more of an impact, because the walkers became something irrelevant. Hope I was clear, aside from that, I really liked the video.

[@theohuntt]

Ahhhh I see, the frank Darrabont zombies from season 1 probably would have done something similar to what you described. Thank you for leaving a hot take and for the kind words!

[@mxndae]

Part 2 all day! Mine is that people's response to the graphic nature of Abe and Glenn's deaths was a bit dramatic. After watching Rick slaughter the Claimers the way he did and the trough scene at Terminus right after that, I find it hard to believe that everyone thought it was too much after everything we'd seen so far.

[@brittybrad]

I mean, Lori did think Rick was dead and used Shane as a coping mechanism in my opinion. But she handled the situation when Rick came back like garbage

[@Herne0011]

Gotta agree - the way Shanes character was headed was only towards fascism and making sure his personal needs were met. Every action he took in the show without fail was either to show himself as a/ a good parent figure / b a good provider /c a good leader with good judgement. None of it seemed to stem from a real desire to lead - but for what it would get him. These sort of leaders are never effective in real life and always fail or are replaced by a real leader in the end. The same people who seem to love Shane are also invariably the same people who would also love Homelander unironically in real life. That is the truly disturbing thing.

[@theohuntt]

Homelander as a leader is crazy 😭😭😭😭

[@SergeantMajorRickGrimes]

@@theohuntt he wasnt a bad leader at all he was leading the group just fine before rick came and if IF rick and shane had good relations ignoring lori inbetween (which they already had) and had already resolved the issue lori just messed both rick and shane turning towards each other i really dont see rick making good decisions either yeah right the fact is shanes decisions never got anyone killed and ricks? multiple times u can pull out the argument of saying that is because rick had to go thru what shane didnt Right but shane would still deal with it better as he doesnt take chances like rick did MULTIPLE times just so yk the arguement *shane only cared for himself* that arguement has been debunked years ago firstly they say he put lori and carl as his first priority (PRIORITY) welp too bad rick did the same and we can also see that in season 6 he puts michonne as his first priority over the alexandrians while drawing the hoarde away he literally says do not save them if yall are in trouble maybe also the fact rick *cheated* on michonne by getting with jesse yeah maybe their relationship wasnt like it is now regardless she was ricks closest women shane tried saving rick twice shane also saved glenn shane also saved the atlanta group also remmeber shane was the one who trained the atlanta group also he was the omst realistic one rick was delusional wasting energy and time on finding sophie which is also a STUPID IDEA RICK SAVING sophie was a good move but what rick did WAS STUPID leaving a goddamn kid alone in a apocalypse while having walkers around expecting her to be safe and not panicking while you couldve easily dealt with the walker by urself with no issue if it were shane he wouldve managed the walker and kept sophie shanes instincts never fail to disprove rick rick from s1 aint gonna fit in the later seasons shane? hell fit in with ease

[@commonidiocy.]

Congratulations on 5k subscribers !!! (that's only the beginning of whats to come) Keep making amazing content like this! I just love hearing your perspective on the show and the funny bits you've been putting into your videos recently.. very underrated about the Shane and Andrea scene 😅

[@theohuntt]

@@commonidiocy. thank you so much for the kind words!!! I hope you continue to enjoy my content!! :)

[@commonidiocy.]

@@theohuntt Thank you so much for always responding and I hope to keep enjoying your content too!!! 😁

[@donkeymoo1581]

I don't care at all for "villains" in any infected post apcolopyse setting. I think they are lazy stupid boring writing because they don't have the talent to use the infected as the real threat instead of a side gag but if you are going to do a villain someone like shane is absolutely top tier perfect writing. Having someone who is part of the group who is your friend or family so you can still have survival and infected be the threat and focus of the show but have the bit of side drama was such a good touch. The entire drama with shane and rick was coming from them struggling to survive as it should be in and post apocalypse setting. No villain after that was the same. It was just copy paste "hey guys we found a safe spot :)... Oh no some big evil guy from near by wants to destroy us for no reason now we have to move again.... yay we found a new spot! Oh no some big evil guy wants to destroy us.... Yay we beat the evil guy now we can try to rebuild... Oh no some evil guys who for some reason were not around the entire war suddenly showed up claimed they were here the entire time and this is their land now they want to destroy us :(" Shane is not over rated. He was the second main character to rick and core to the group and even as they transitioned him into a villain character it was still fully unique. Every single villain past that was just a carbon copy generic power hungry person who wants to control and destroy. Anyway no point arguing much when clowns make claims like this being viewing figures are a permanent fact for how wrong people are when it comes to who were good characters and when was the writing good lol

[@BoogSReviews]

I have never liked Shane as a character. I’ll never understand why he has so many fans. He was a hot head, slept with his best friend’s wife knowing full well Rick wasn’t dead, and not mentally stable. If Shane would’ve been in charge of things, all of the group would be gone. He was too hot headed and arrogant and would’ve led so many people to their deaths with him as a leader.

[@jonfreeman9682]

Well to be fair he tried to save Rick but Rick was in a coma. So when he left he assumed he was killed by the zombies. That's not a stretch. But he shouldn't be having sex with wifey after Rick came back though and they had a heart to heart. But trying to kill Rick crossed the line.

[@hoykfnvnnesnxnnensncjforkx1616]

I think people like his actor and can't separate them I think he's interesting and complex but he isn't perfect. I see often people saying "he's misunderstood" or "he was ahead of the game and did what the world needed" but he legit tried to rape Lori and never thought anything through. He would ruin so many alliances in the future if he was around.

[@FBelos]

Thank you for your take on my Hot take I loved Andrea and Lori in the comics alot :( In the fandom if you say you hate Lori or Andrea you get accused of hating them bc they're women with flaws not just because they're people with flaws

[@PigossiWhisky17]

The hate towards Lori never made much sense for me, and this became much more evident in the last seasons. The same bad decisions that Lori made, characters like Rick and Daryl also made.

[@Wildtingz]

I’ll never understand why they forced Heath’s actor to wear that raggedy arse wig. Almost made me glad we never saw him again sorry lolol

[@BURP39R]

The thing is it was called The Walking Dead not The Boring Time Jump Farmers. By the end it was pretty much pointles. If the dead dont matter then the living has to have better writing. They just didn't know when to quit.

[@sourmintsowplays648]

quality content as always! 💯💯 Virgil is another character that could've had a bigger role just like Heath. I mean we see Virgil for what? a total of 4 episodes? he wasn't even a bad character. just heavily underused. and the last episode he's in, he walks up some stairs in the middle of the storm at Alexandria just to never be seen again

[@theohuntt]

Yeah that’s so true another character who just disappeared. When we saw his arc in bloodsworth island I thought he was going to become a regular tbh it’s a shame :(

[@thephantomblader8746]

Rick became Shane in most ways especially when Shane had his moment in Rick’s delusion when Rick exit the show. Shane voice literally said you took a page out of my book. Rick’s mind version on Shane was proud of him. To tell Rick that the machete moment at the church and him bitting that guys neck was something that he was proud of. Shane viewed the world as it was going to be but Rick couldn’t admit it at the start because he was officer friendly, a man with more hope for a better situation than most people in the apocalypse and as soon as Lori died, he went berserk in the prison killing walkers after he already machete’d a prisoner. He killed porch dick and challenged Negan. He gave Aaron and Michonne so much shit when he first met them before he trusted them. Shane would be a great partner for Rick if it wasn’t for Lori to be honest, she gave him shit for their love before Rick came back and the more Shane got pushed away, he kept trying to support leading the group when the group was being weak. Even Daryl was on Shane’s side when it came to Sophia. Shane would have been a great leader if he wasn’t too bold too soon considering later in the series, it’s more common to see that mindset so more people understand it. Rick had that mindset. Even Maggie was having it. He would have been better if he came back later in the series as a leader of another group opposed to just die at the farm.

[@bobhollywood4093]

Laurie didn't cheat on Rick with Shane. She thought her husband was dead. She moved on, as she had every right to do. When she found out she was wrong, she came clean and got back with her husband. She never got back with Shane after Rick was revealed to be alive.

[@starlad11]

Andrea was such a fence sitter during the prison season and made a clear choice of the governor and her good friend michone while acting holier than tho made her unlikeable for me And lori did the cheating thing but she thought rick was dead. But she flip flopped being mad at Shane then begging him to stay then telling rick she doesn't trust him then getting mad at rick for killing Shane when he was defending his own life from him! She was just a shady lady imo

[@theohuntt]

I totally agree with you good take!

[@taylorsues302]

Don't find him overrated, without Lorrie he would have been a much better character i still miss him 😭💥🌟

[@neilito15]

Scott Wilsons portrayal of Hershal was do good, his a charcter which went a bit to early

[@BelowZero2010]

Imagine a more “realistic “ take on zombies on the walking dead .No easily puncturing skulls with a pocket knife or throwing dead weight around so easily.A zombie getting a hold of you would be extremely dangerous since they act only on instinct with no stamina like the living.

[@donnymann6739]

Think it was pretty much answered about Heath when Ann got out of his truck.

[@Guapanator]

I had seen in a video of shanes actor saying that he wanted to have a shot after rick killed shane, rick checks the gun and it was empty. Shane wanted to die for how twisted the world had been and how he was too far gone, and rick killing him would make rick become stronger. Which we wouldve seen at the end of season 2 and for the rest of the show. If we had gotten that scene it wouldve added alot more complexity to shanes character and showing how he was a tragic villan. Also it wouldve shown that shane wasnt meant for the new world, Rick was. Shane knew he had the potential and the drive to survive since rick had something shane didnt, which was a family. With how the show ended up being he wasnt as complex and he wasnt an S tier character, he honestly ended up being a A- at most for me. But lets be honest, the shane fanbase really glazes him so bad when everyone knows the best character is Dog

[@petter215jones]

Walkers were only a big threat because humans didnt know how to deal with them.. that dqngerous isnt gonna last too long. We went from rick running away from 2 of them to easily taking on 5+ hand to hand..

[@lanceknightmare]

Maggie was never a leader. When she first showed up at The Hilltop. She demanded to stay without any conscience. Maggie put everyone in the Hilltop at risk because of her wants. The fact that no one had the nerve to throw her out is a point I would like to make. It was always a developed respect for Jesus which allowed Maggie to lead. She was never a leader because she put her wants ahead of the Hilltop even after assuming a leadership role. When she returned, some character growth was assumed to have happened. Only for Maggie to fall back in her want without conscience.

[@FroggyBunwich]

Overrated is a broad term. Those who say Shane was treated unfairly in the Rick/Lori situation are right. Same with those who say he was correct about Randall. Those who think he wasn't manipulating the group for his attempt at leadership are wrong.

[@joshuacampbell289]

Shane was my favorite character. He was very important for character development

[@andrewthomsontaylor]

Loveu bro but that Shane take at the beginning is diabolical 😂

[@TheNeighbor216]

Being popular doesn't mean that it's overrated

[@donnymann6739]

Shane was a good character The writer screwed him...

[@theohuntt]

Yeah Shane is amazing

[@maryammenalagha8989]

Glenn most definitely killed more than just one guy at the satellite outpost the group invaded in season 6 episode 12.

[@c.k-da-kxnghere]

The show itself showed that shane wasn't as great as fans think. Hes ruthless to a point. He felt nothing but guilt after shooting otis. He started losing it after that because he is a tv cop, most if which have elevated levels of morality. He was right to shoot otis, they both would have died if he hadnt and carl with them, but even with that knowledge he couldnt handle it. Plus he also shown to be rash and unstrategic. The governor would have ran him over

[@OfficerGrimesYT]

Shane is underrated as a character, usually seen way more hated then he should be lmao

[@rhydianwilliams9161]

Hot Take:Jimmy from season 2 should have played a bigger part and should have Taken Billy Greenes comic death running from the Governor with Beth and as theyre holding hands Jimmy is shot or alternatively mayby give him and Beth the Chris and Julie arc whats your opinion

[@Whatyoumeanyoudont]

Will always be a Shane fan 💪

[@theohuntt]

Don’t get me wrong I’m with you I love myself a bit of Shane!

[@rickgrimes4998]

Shane is not overrated he was one the characters in the show like Rick where he was a larger than life character. if he had gone on longer the show would be much better. The show severely lacks characters with that level of charisma, Rick is probably the only one left with that kind of Aura with respect to all other characters they don’t exactly demand that kind of excitement.

[@Mark-G1978]

And no one was mad at Daryl for getting Glenn killed.

[@bell5248]

he was mad at himself

[@MattBuckhout]

Lemme tell you sumin mahn *scratches back of head*

[@bell5248]

shane is a really good character its the fans who ruined him they act like he beats up people like the governor and negan and say shane would have destroyed the verse they missed the whole point of his character, yes he was ahead of the group but his obsession with lori and his choices got him died while i do think he would survive if he got over her, people say he would have killed negan or whatever when thats not true the reason he would survive would be the same as rick and thats would be because he got broken mentally and physically if he was hot headed all the time he would have been killed multiple times he was ruthless and brutal but also untested

[@BabyStation-z3r]

No, he was right on time and right on point. Shane is the reason Rick evolves throughout the series. Shane was right the entire time although he was psycho lol

[@winstonedeaver]

I agree with season 5, it's better. Special dynamics with the character arch. That is what make TWD is special

[@josephgallagher3397]

My hot take that shouldn't hot at all and frankly should be more respected is that scott is the best twd character. Very underappreicated. OG Alexandrian. Got shot that one time, too.

[@sydnitheromantictaylor112]

Heath actor got written off because he went to a different show

[@darthdan3983]

The show killed itself when they killed off Carl !

[@james11latimore]

Shane was never a leader he was a hitter tho and would’ve been a asset to the group

[@shaneovids4852]

The first one is stupid ofcourse it's not misogyny 😂😂😂

[@corbinowens2437]

Heath is not a hot take, most of these weren’t tbh. Most of these are things I’ve heard the whole fanbase say.

[@ajaxaceofaces]

Yes, Shane is a bit overrated. Still love the character. Jon Bernthal really gave that role his all.

[@Myjacob99]

Overhated yes overrated never

[@tahaiftikharneedsattention7318]

I don’t think he is i didn’t like him originally cuz i was a kid but rewatching at an adult he made sense

[@Jcage22]

shane is underrated imo

[@idkwhattohaveasausername5828]

Shane may be right about survival, but man is he a garbage person lmao

[@DashingDavid]

No. Next topic.

[@JamesScottSelfDefense19]

Say what you will about Shane, people should talk about differing opinions. I'll say this and I really don't expect any pushback; Nobody rubbed their head as often or as awesomely as Shane.

[@theohuntt]

He did love a head rub! What an icon

[@ChampionProductionsYT]

Shane is also the most overrated character in terms of combat

[@HenzoW-cf3mh]

Carol is the most overrated imo. Yh I said it. Wtf was so special about her character post s6? She outlived her arc. She proved that she was a badass and loyal but they ran out of material and slowly made her a terrible character. She pulled a Strand and Daniel fall off from fear before it was even popular - her fall off is no where near the atrocious fear characters but I used those 2 as examples bc I liked all 3 of them before they all got ruined. Those 2 got ruined bc the writers were idiots but I think Carol got ruined bc she stayed too long. Characters like Herschel, Abraham, Bob, Shane, Glenn, Merle, etc will always remain in my very high tier bc they didn’t overstay their welcome and their characters were solid and not all over the place. This was a lot of yap going on but I wanted to plead my case.

[@SergeantMajorRickGrimes]

i dont think shane is overrated name any other character in those 2 seasons which matched shane theres none and if u were to put shane a few seasons ahead suppose s6,7,8 or like that hed still fit in having 0 trouble most characters in the span of 2 seasons were just delusional crackheads The fact there are still people comparing shane w characters from later seasons is enough to prove hes ahead of his time also his character played an important role for the entire TWD franchise in shaping the rest of the characters

[@TeleportBlock]

MORE HOT TAKES

[@jordanlear]

My most controversial opinion is that anyone who stopped watching the show solely because of Glenn’s death is childish.

[@FBelos]

you brave soul

[@kimberlyweaver1285]

I loved Shane. He got hotter and hotter. 😍 😊

[@theohuntt]

Jon Bernthal is very handsome man

[@Rick79LUFC]

Lori is completely to blame for Shane's mental breakdown he wasn't a bad person and the group would of remained stronger with Shane surviving 😊

[@ithanvega]

Negan is overrated af. He’s annoying tbh.

[@MAGAWillSaveTheWorld]

Heath sucked!