Is the James Webb Breaking Cosmology?

[@nicholashylton6857]

Those AI "science channels" are soooo annoying! They ramble on about this or that & pull viewers away from excellent channels like this.

[@BLD426]

Big time. They should be banned. They just junk up the place.

[@dcquence]

They are very often giving bad information and click-bait crap too.

[@roryb5512]

💯

[@ARWest-bp4yb]

If your cosmology has been broken please check your warranty and call customer service to schedule for repair or replacement.

[@chadbarnard3620]

Toddler galaxies have to be the most chaotic...

[@sinebar]

I think the Big Bang is a lot more complex than we realize. Cosmic inflation I think is a clue to something we aren't understanding about the origin of the universe. I like to think of it as a huge beautiful painting on a wall. Like a wall mural but only a very tiny postage stamp size of it is visible. You know there's a painting there and you know its fantastic but you can't tell what it is because you can only see a very small part. I think that's where we are in our knowledge of the universe.

[@marilynkozak17]

Missed you here, Dr. Sutter. Welcome back.

[@chrissscottt]

Cool vid. I prefer the term "mistaken" to "stupid" though.

[@EL_DUDERIN0]

Another great video, you're an awesome science explainer dude, Paul!

[@slartibartfast7921]

Not being invited to specific parties is often the surest indicator of integrity. Not just within science….. hint hint.

[@malcolmlane1489]

a great talk by an interesting guy

[@stevedrake6529]

Is there a music free version of this video??

[@BlizzAz]

I'm all for galaxies with bigger bursts. It sure would explain a lot!

[@darylmorse]

Another great video. You should have 10X as many subscribers.

[@MattCarvin]

“Interesting” is completely subjective.

[@CaptainBlaine]

Call me crazy, but I don’t think we should be basing ideas of the formation of the universe on dark matter that hasn’t yet been proven to exist.

[@tune490]

You are not crazy, but the stars of galaxies are moving faster than they should from what is measurable and the light around clusters is bending more than it should, a lot more. Also, dark matter isn't the issue in the video, it's dark energy.

[@CaptainBlaine]

@@tune490 yes, dark energy, which also has not really been proven to exist. Obviously SOMETHING has to account for all of the missing mass and energy, but I’m hoping that in my lifetime something more concrete and interesting comes along than those two gap fillers.

[@TurdFerguson456]

Science Journalism may be bad, but mainstream journalism is just pathetic and morally wrong. Especially political, especially about Trump! Love your channel Paul!

[@hedlamp1497]

it's a fractal, The universe is bigging and banging at the centre of every galaxy all the time,

[@kuukeli]

interesting video

[@spencerholmes7602]

Truly excellent, Paul. Another ‘Big Banger’ 😊

[@misslayer999]

This was so interesting I had to stop listening to it because I need to get to sleep 😆. Will pick it back up tomorrow

[@MattCarvin]

If it’s interesting it’s wrong though.

[@wknajafi]

AI generated videos, especially science, are God Damn boring 🥱

[@FrankMerton]

Yes, missed you. I have seen science, and, indeed, all human knowledge, compared to a huge edifice constantly being enlarged, where from time to time some part has to be renovated or altered, but the edifice remains.

[@russellneitzke4972]

Does gravity need particles? Can dark matter be damaged, broken, bent space without any particles?

[@DaFinkingOrk]

Do we have tunnel vision about assigning everything to particles (because quantum theories work very well). If gravity is the curvature of space then how can that be caused by particles anyway? Curving space surely is just curved space, not transmitted by some graviton particle?

[@anaphylastiks]

Your videos have come a long way. My problem is that, this conundrum is not interesting and therefore is probably correct. Happens lots, and you know this Paul.

[@iugoeswest]

Video starts at 5:30

[@romekin]

I am not interested in listening to ai video, the next things it will be generated ai scripts, and ai generated voice, and we wont know what real or not

[@tune490]

Yes! The Answer to your question is Yes!

[@tune490]

However, it is only breaking the widely accepted cosmology. Lambda-CDM is an unfalsifiable model because it just keeps changing or updating!

[@dassemutlor]

Their are missing pieces to the puzzle of everything

[@monolalia]

How on earth did your sense of personal integrity survive praising this sponsor? :(

[@DaFinkingOrk]

💰💰 Just let him have it and ignore the sponsor I guess, it's free money for people we like. Though I wish channels were more selective with who they advertise, or at the very least included hints that the sponsor is bad, I've just learned to completely ignore them and guess/hope most people do by now.

[@monolalia]

@@DaFinkingOrk I don’t begrudge him the money but it’s just depressing to see him advertise the very technology that drowns out good channels like his own with soulless unconscious mass-produced blather distilled from the collective work of who knows how many real people.

[@MJ1]

No, but clickbait headlines like this are sure breaking the public’s confidence in science. Are the clicks really worth it?

[@ogxs1433]

It was already broken.

[@kricketflyd111]

I've seen you on tv, not sure what series but you sound like you have an archeology hat in the closet. ❤

[@kricketflyd111]

Dr. Becky says that's fixed now.

[@tenbear5]

🤣