Isl-49 VERSUS SEIKO SKX 013

[@islandwatch]

Great review. Thanks Russell!!!!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Thank you MARC, really enjoyed making the show and the feedback about the Islanders must make you proud!!

[@201950201950]

I love Islanders watches. They just released a whole bunch of beautiful time pieces

[@vktravellog1242]

Huge Islander fanboy here! Why would anyone buy a Seiko 😂😂😂😂😂

[@vktravellog1242]

Love how he sand bagged this video! Islander 8 Seiko 0. I am sorry but Islander is just a no brainer and you have to be a brand fool to think otherwise

[@Grendal62]

the reason Marc's watches are phenomenal is he never did this, UNTIL seiko discontinued SKX. It wasn't a cash grab. it was a love letter to the SKX. also, he is the only one doing 38mm!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Absolutely my friend, he has a relationship with Seiko which is a little mad?! But still it’s come from customer pleading!;)

[@CocoKoi321]

Or trying to pocket himself into the discontinuation of the market and be the *next best thing* but also less quality, I had 2 and the hands are awful quality looking and had tooling marks

[@monsta3038]

Tandorio does have the 38 all his parts and stuff look same and I'm positive they are ,he just buys and orders the custom logo but nice deal though,for one stop shop

[@hgr.7857]

1🎯🎯%

[@hgr.7857]

@@CocoKoi321 That's weird. I have two (ISL-21 38mm and the Spinnaker + LIW Croft LE collab) with a 3rd on the way as of Black Friday and had no QC issues. I like them bc Marc equips all of his Islanders stock with all of the mods I'd want to add to a Seiko, for less than MSRP on the OG. I'm here for it 💯

[@notyourgrandadswatch7705]

I absolutely love what Marc is doing with his watches and firmly beleive his company will be around for a long time. It's amazing what he has done in 4 short years and I can only imagine his momentum will just keep going. Seiko is an amazing brand with such a long history but their tendency to drop a watch and shortly after take it off the market really doesn't sit well with me. The prices for watches that have a reputation for cost cutting and qc issues really will help Marc down the line. Their customer service has been touted as the best in the business and to me that really says alot. Great review as always sir, cheers

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Thank you my friend! Absolutely the rise in prices without the rise in QC has made them look silly at times to Microbrands such as these! I don’t the founder of Seiko would be pleased with that!

[@matthewhill3996]

I wish seiko was the only one with QC issues. Cough omega cough cough.

[@karlsenula9495]

@@matthewhill3996 ... Jody even had a couple of Rolexes with issues ... with those prices and reputation it is worse than Omega.

[@Ticotico1]

I have 4 LIWC, and yes, they are better than the originals. Before you buy, take a look at LIWC Marc, keep the QC and service just the way you are doing. Don't bring any 90-day wonder. Keep your company yours.

[@DerekMcCoyMusic]

I have the ISL-22 (013 with Orange dial) and I love it. That bracelet is nutty good. And through sheer luck I regulated it to crazy good accuracy with no timegrapher. I also have his field watch with a blue dial and I adore it as well. I look at them like guitars; Marc’s watches would be analogous to Suhr putting out a super specked out tele or strat style guitar for way less money than Fender. Great video as always MWC!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Very good comment my friend! Glad your enjoying the watches!

[@drwallysax]

Brilliant video, loved the comparison! Personally, I'm no longer interested in brand history/stature. I always think of the thought experiment: Ship of Theseus. The innovation, value, and democratization of watches seem to have fallen by the wayside with Seiko (and others). Like the "Ship of Theseus" what remains? The name? Would I pay for 5 letters stamped on the face? I love scrappy upstarts and microbrands. I love getting to know Marc (and other owners) and seeing their passion and respect for the customers. I like my Seiko Turtle, but adore supporting mark and his scrappy brand - the Isl-01 is one of the favorites in my collection.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

One for the SCRAPPERS!!!;) yeah I hear you my friend! It comes from a passion and love of the original brand for sure!

[@richardtwyning]

One of these watches is from a well respected brand with a loyal following. The other one is a Seiko. Loving my monster, ISL-56.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Hahahaha love it

[@peterkull8354]

It´s quite difficult to decide this for me Russ. Marc is such a good guy and watch nerd. He obviously recognised the good design of the Seiko SKX and brought his version to a new level. I must admit that I tend to go with the original in case of doubt, however- this time - I must make an exception and state: Marc makes the superior watch and I would prefer it to the original...................................😓😓😓 I cannot believe that I said this.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Hahahaha! That is great my friend! Hard not to agree with that! He makes a darn good watch!!!

[@humanitech]

Although the originals always have a great appeal..but there is always something valid and good when enthusiasts create their pimped up and improved versions. So I think it's a win win for both really!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Well said John!

[@Hipnosis65]

I have the Islander... love it! Cheers to the Seiko owners... much respect.

[@gervers]

Great head to head and for me, the LI wins through. It’s just so much more modern packed with great features! Plus I really like Marc! I love the LI Red October! Love my Seiko King Turtle too!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

There is room to love both at the same time my friend! ;)

[@mikesurratt1922]

I've got two "5KX's" and I love them. I've always viewed water resistance on a watch practically. 10 bar is just fine for water sports and shallow reef diving. A very few individuals actually need more than 10 bar. The watch guys that knock the 5KX and brag about having 200 meters of water resistance are the same ones who take off their SKX before getting into the pool or the shower.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Hahahahaha well listen my friend. I’m not a fan of what Seiko has done with the SKX. They turned an iconic watch enthusiasts gateway watch that was an actual certified diver and have turned into Seiko’s fashion watch , that is what it has become with all the dials , bezels and patterns. I love the heritage of Seiko 5’s Even the fact Seiko are trying to pull in new watch enthusiasts and do you know what , these may very well be a gateway to higher Spec’d Seiko’s for them but come up with a new case . That being said congrats on your watches and respect your choices obviously ;)

[@mikesurratt1922]

@@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR the original Rolex submariner only had 100 meters of water resistance. You can dive with a 10 bar watch, much deeper than 99.999% of people will ever go. Bragging about an ISO certification on a watch you never intend to get wet boggles my mind sir...your videos are super funny BTW..

[@BeeRumblin13]

Agreed

[@nickcosta1093]

Great comparison video I love the upgrades on the ISL . And a big HELLO to MR.PAGANI

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Cheers Nick!

[@joemaldo6908]

I purchased the exact same islander about 3 months ago. I love it!

[@WINDINGCROWNS]

Great job Russell. I appreciate the comparison. Marc makes great watches for sure. Very fair assessment.

[@ChefTom777]

The feeling of wearing an original seiko skx is totally priceless... It is just money & we will still earn it.. the most important is the experience of wearing the original legendary seiko skx on your wrist it is priceless.. I am even willing to buy a new one today 2023 even for 800 dollars or even a thousand dollars if I could afford it... luckily I found a bnew skx013 on a bracelet still displayed on a department store for less than 400 dollars & I immediately puchased it... I couldn't be happier now I am wearing a legend & a gem on my wrist...

[@keithh2028]

Russ, LOVE you humming the theme song from A-Team during Wrist Roll On The Go!! Awesome mate!!!!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

It’s gonna be all 80’s my friend!;)

[@keithh2028]

@@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR YES!!!!!

[@watchncarry9593]

Love LI watches. Great design. Another great video Russel. Thanks for the side by side shots. Have a good week

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Thank you my friend!

[@NicoleCeleste]

Thank you for doing this. I have been considering this watch from mark for about a year (w the black dial). Knowing how he treats customers and the company - I’m likely going to get one if I can! Loved the comparison. (Goes to cry skx013 tears).

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Hahahaha thank you Nicole! The Islander gets a seal of quality approval for sure!!

[@TheDanibus]

I just got my first Islander a couple weeks ago (ISL-10) and I love it! You will be very happy with the quality of the watch and the customer service!

[@marshalbass7098]

Bro, just wanted to let you know I was researching this and clicked on your video first, because I trust you.

[@LaskMaestro]

Islander all the way. What a FUN video! Thanks for the thorough review!

[@divinejudge1]

Pulled the trigger on purchasing an ISL-19 (the bigger version SKX009 homage). I am very delighted with the watch and your review really helped me make this purchase. Never had a blue dial watch with a “Pepsi Dial” and my first jubilee bracelet.

[@MaroMarenio]

Brilliant comparison and summary of these watches!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Thanks Maro!!!

[@bumblebee9288]

Love that Mr Pagani mentioned me!!!! Bumble Bee 😂😂😂😂😂🐝 love to you 💗💗💗💗💗

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Hahahahahahaha

[@bumblebee9288]

@@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR I am with you ORIGINAL is always the one to have . I am considering a long Island as another beater but I am going to end up with another 10 beater watches if I am not careful!!!

[@TickSweep]

Seems like a great guy Marc and all the effort he goes into with his watches is fantastic

[@Roberto68n]

You have to do the caseback comparison again with the Islander’s new dive watch casebacks!!

[@Scum8ag]

I am right there with ya Russ. The originality and the stuff that transcends mere specs is very important to me. That being said, if you gonna do a homage, there is no better approach than Marc's! Wish him all the success he deserves!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Well said my friend!!

[@Reclaimtherainbow_Gen9]

I felt the same way about the bezel! But other than that Marc puts out some QUALITY watches for the money! Great video!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Couldn’t agree more London! Thanks for watching buddy!

[@stevefox8605]

I've always been pretty anti-homage, but got a Steeldive Ploprof out of curiosity recently & must admit I'm impressed... Good video thank you 👍🏻👍🏻

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Steve has entered the dark side…. Or is it the bright side! Either way he’s fallen off some side!;)

[@robertlindo8058]

I don't know if other viewers have noticed but your Mr Pagani character reminds me of the actor Oliver Reed. He has the same type of voice and actions, especially when he has a few drinks inside him!

[@victors5010]

I really like Marc’s creations, more though I love his educational series of videos. True passion from a super knowledgeable guy!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Absolutely Victor!

[@johanvandersandt8904]

I wish those ISL's were available in South Africa! They pack a punch way above their cost! Plus Mark is just a super nice dude so id rather support him than a soulless company.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Very good quality my friend

[@christopherjohnson4276]

The ISL web page you show says "Out of stock". MWC you did it again 👏 😆

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Oh dear!!! I’m sure that’s not the case hahahahaha however it’s a darn good watch!

[@saint1674]

SOOOOPER! REVIEW MY FRIEND , LOVED IT!

[@lufgog117]

Awesome video, great comparison review between two great time pieces

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Thank you for watching my friend!

[@Watch4Jay]

Great head-to-head comparison Russell! Thanks for broaching the subject; I know some folk get really fired up over this at times (in both good and bad ways)

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Thanks Jason! It’s a show that had to be done and I hope I have a balanced view!

[@jeffreyalbarandorivera9750]

LOL The fact that the pepsi one is imatating the seiko. Must respect to Seiko.

[@The_OG_James]

I do love a Seiko! My first 2 automatic watches were both from them but it's hard to ignore what Marc is doing with the Islanders! Hope to add a couple to my collection at some point. 😀

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Thanks for watching James! I think there’s room for both in anyones collection!

[@XEZGOLDZ]

Love this vid! I Wana see a 3 way comparison: Rolex explorer II “ Steve McQueen”, the modern anniversary model Rolex explorer II and the Homage Steinhart ocean GMT

[@dns711]

Received my first Islander a couple days ago. I got the 38mm "Pogue" and love it, but it is a little small for my 8" wrist. When Marc comes out with a larger "Pogue" I will buy it and give the 38mm to my daughter.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

I’ll take it off y’hands David;)

[@michaelbarton5169]

Love Marc's watches. I'm wearing my "wave" right now. Incredible lume and so comfortable.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Congrats my friend wear it in good health!

[@mosesgunn6937]

Great review...you have quickly become my favorite watch channel! I understand completely what you are saying about the intangibles of the Seiko over the Islander....which is why I bought both. 😂 Marc is a great guy at LIW, so I am happy to support his small business. Cheers!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Well said Moses and thank you! There is room to love both 100%! Thank you for your continued support!

[@mattcameron9349]

They sure can! I'm currently wearing a Steeldive SD1972 which has all the appeal of a Seiko Turtle. Exactly the same movement, but with the addition of sapphire crystal, lumed bezel, signed crown, no alignment issues, and 1/6th of the price!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Lovely stuff Matt!

[@Olddirtytiger]

Steeldive love 🥰

[@jimmccaig7946]

Love Marc’s watches, very classy, but, I still fall into the Seiko camp for he same reasons. Great episode. Cheers 👍🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Cheers Jim! I think you can like both ;)

[@barryvercueil2346]

Marc is a legend in the watch community. And his watches are INCREDIBLE. even used SKX's prices are becoming ridiculous. I HIGHLY recommend an ISLANDER. A watch you can wear all day everyday and enjoy. Cheers.

[@mdunawaym]

I have the Islander with a stark white dial, and Batman blue and black bezel. It's stunning, I love it, I get compliments on it, and I'll eventually get the SKX, but I'm satisfied with the Islander as it stands on it's own.

[@marcparnell8233]

When you showed the long island watch page at the end it was out of stock, did make I chuckle, it's definitely copying the skx 😂😂. Great vid as always, as enjoyable as it was informative 👍👍

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

That’s the power I have even before the show is released! The hype is real!!!;)

[@daviddorson5111]

I feel like I've missed the boat on the SKX, I do have an SPRD, and I did look at the ISL stuff as well as some other homages and although they do offer a value proposition over the SKX, I feel something that's unquantifiable is somehow lost in translation.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

I hear you my friend! I could not fault the Islander at all! Great watch ! You saw my views;)

[@TheDanibus]

Thanks for this fun video...keep up the great work! I can personally attest to the excellent customer service Marc provides. If you buy from him, he WILL make sure you are taken care of should any issues arise. I have purchased two watches from Island watch. The first was an Orient Ray (black), and the second was a Spinnaker Fleuss. The Spinny turned out to be defective, and Marc responded to my email within a hour or two. Unfortunately he was out of stock so couldn't immediately replace the Fleuss. I decided to go for an Islander #ISL-10 instead (which was actually a more expensive watch), and he threw in an extra strap. Well the ISL-10 turned out to be a way better looking and more comfy watch anyway, so I am glad this happened. Go ahead and buy an Islander...you will be happy!!!!!

[@MrLewisWhale]

Couldn’t agree more, there is no doubt that Islander is better on paper, but the SKX just has something the Islander doesn’t.

[@GeorgiosPavlos]

What a great review this one Russell, its amazing watching your work evolve with every video. Difficult comparison this time, Marc being such a gentleman and the SKX being such an icon, but you nailed it. Now I want both.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Hahahahaha thank you my friend!

[@miss2369]

Seiko prices no matter the “history” hace gone bonkers sorry but not sorry will not pay those prices and buying them second hand…. Love your show!

[@kobusvanrensburg4092]

Great video, thank you! A bit like America VS the UK...... Of course the remake is better* *Comments made under the influence of alcohol.

[@jjbuckmaster7059]

I have the SKX009 and the 007. They were two of my early purchases when I first was really getting into collecting. I have four ‘Islanders’ in my collection. In my opinion Mark’s watches are better in EVERY way. Mark produces the SKX that we all wanted… And in my case modded, the SKX to be! Thanks Russ!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Thanks for watching and for your input my friend!

[@simonwright6882]

The 013 was also my first automatic and the only watch I really regret selling. But I do have a 009 with an nh36 and uncle seiko president and I luvs it.

[@craigs1710]

The SKX has always been an anomoly...an icon in it's own right, and at the same time, very poorly specced for the price (not to mention alignment issues). Marc gave this icon the specs it has always deserved. The fact that this has been accomplished by a genuine enthusiast is icing on the cake.

[@dalerichardson8842]

I think I'd do the same Russell. You'd still want the original. If you got one secondhand you could put a saphire crystal in it if/when it needed it.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Cheers Dale! Think it came across ok? This subject can always be spicy !

[@dalerichardson8842]

@@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR it was perfectly pitched as far as I can see. You said it is a superb watch for the value but purists will want the original, can't be more honest than that !

[@Watch4Jay]

@@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR I agree here. Your delivery is spot on and no doubt people will relate. Was it the A-Team theme song on Watch roll on the go? 👍😀

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

@@Watch4Jay yes Jason! It’ll be 80’s themed I think from now on!;) thank you! As always this is a hot debate !;)

[@drwallysax]

@@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR 80s themed? You speakah muh language!

[@derekmiles7358]

Excellent job 👍👍 love the blue and red together I would have the Seiko as it’s a classic

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Thanks for watching Derek!!!

[@IlluminatingWatches]

Points to you if you get a badminton reference in Pagani sketch. Badminton > volleyball (and tennis of course)

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

I so will do a badminton one Gordon!!!!!

[@davidbridge5652]

I've been saying suuuupa round the office hahaha brilliant video

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Yes David!!!!

[@TerminusVox]

I hear what you're saying with Seiko having generated and developed the product but it can be said the Long Island Watch was part of that success. Seko dive watches were their best selling models and then the manufacturer let them know those watches are being discontinued... well, they developed a good replacement for those dive watches that weren't going to be coming from Seiko any longer. Islander Watches want to sell me a watch now and Seiko do not. Maybe five to ten years ago before I acquired this debilitating interest in watches Seikos were affordable. Now brands like Islander are trying to fill that niche.

[@TerminusVox]

Admittedly, a tiny part of that global success!

[@drwallysax]

Well put, Marc is on a mission to serve the enthusiast community. Also, "debilitating interest" haaa! Love it.

[@watchesandsmiles1971]

Have to say I really enjoyed this episode mate. Great to see the comparison of what can be achieved in a homage. I'm like you I love the history behind a company which makes owning and wearing a watch a bit more special. Long Islander watches done an amazing job however and from a price point great value 👍👌 well done as always mate 👍

[@dimasbujursangkar8120]

love the A-Team theme song haha

[@cyrax1700]

This is an epic episode. That appreciates innovation (islander) and golden heritage (sieko skx). Magnificent.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Thank you for your comment my friend appreciate this a lot!

[@9426sunny]

Marc's Long island watches aren't homage, but just only inspired from SKX and he is making them much better and perfect.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Hahaha well I agree my friend with the last part!;) his love for Seiko is obvious to all. Without the SKX , the Islander would not exist. It’s a Homage no doubt Sunny ;)

[@MichaelWilde.pushbikegraddad]

I love my old skx007, it would be interesting to see an Islander in the flesh, if the watch is anything like Mark, it will be a top notch watch

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Thanks Mike! It’s been great getting to know this watch over the last couple of weeks. Take care my friend!

[@TheDanibus]

@@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR you're so right about that bracelet too. SO COMFY and sturdy

[@robh.2400]

Great video! Long Island makes nice watches.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Cheers Rob!!

[@shaneturner3818]

I have a SKX009 Pepsi and a ISL01 and ISL18 love them all equally

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Excellent my friend!

[@Kevins-Philippine-Retirement]

Thank you for your statistical review. I am a Siko FN too; mostly from tradition. But the Islander is truly bang for the buck if you're looking for a true tool watch without brand loyalty 🤣😊😉

[@stefpix]

The island is also a chrono with the little dial below 12

[@NikonFM2n]

I love the A-TEAM theme song.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

All 80’s from now on my friend!;)

[@247tubefan]

We all know that the majority of the money we spend on watches is for brand recognition. But I get the most compliments on my Hot Pink Dial Invicta Pro Diver. It's definitely a conversation starter.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Absolutely my friend! I need to see this watch!

[@fraisernash5656]

Great comparison. I love my Islander, the isl18, and the spec you get. I'd like to get more. it's such a shame the import charges are so expensive

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Yes I hear you on the charges Russell! What is it 50 quid on top?

[@fraisernash5656]

@THE MAD WATCH COLLECTOR £60 for mine, but I believe it's calculated on the retail amount from where its sent, all my watches that have been sent from Creation I've only paid £6 royal mail, but creations postage invoice shows less for the item, It could be how they get round customs ?

[@Seffsqautch]

I’m going to get a Islander one day!

[@panospeter_pan4257]

Lovely watch. Great price. On my list maybe? Perhaps...

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Maybe on a long long list? My watch list gets longer by the day!;)

[@goodonthewrist]

I was gifted a Seiko Willard homage by Stealdive as the previous owner purchased the Seiko Willard… I really like the Stealdive and for a $1,000 savings… it’s an amazing alternative!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

It is my friend, having reviewed a Steel dive it did not stop me from buying an SPB153;) it made me want the Seiko more

[@karlsenula9495]

Heard you humming the A-Team theme song. Guessing your favorite A-Team member was Murdock?

[@cougarbatterie]

Thank you Russell. You said it all at the end. Can't beat a watch brand and reputation no matter what better specs you put on it. I like Mark and he certainly have quality watches, but it is an Islander, not a Seiko.

[@WesWatchRoom]

That wasn't even close at all, would really like to see more of marcs watches put up against seikos in this series. Awesome work mate and very enjoyable 😄

[@jamessalepe]

What a good surprise the Islander.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

It’s a well Spec’d stunner!

[@karlsenula9495]

So hoping Mark does an Islander version of his beloved Squale ... or a Seiko Presage in iced blue.

[@steffydog]

Fascinating stuff, thanks

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Thanks man!!!

[@chrish.1983]

Great show Russ, really like what Marc is doing with his Islanders 👍 And yes a homage can give the real deal a run for it´s money no doubt.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Cheers for watching and the support Chris!

[@yo-sefakimbey7009]

Hopefully you'll have an opportunity to review some of his more dressy watches. Those are the ones I'm most curious about

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

One day I’m sure my friend!

[@edteach3r]

Another fascinating video, thank you. I agree with you on Seiko heritage. Nonetheless, I really like Marc’s watches and, more importantly, Marc as a person. So, I did the next best thing… I bought a SKX007 from Marc and then had him mod it for me with a flat sapphire crystal, sapphire bezel insert and Strapcode bracelet. I wanted to retain the original look of the SKX and the only thing that I changed was for a coin-edged bezel as I did not want to damage the original bezel and insert. Marc even pressure tested the watch and provided a printed confirmation. The Islander is definitely still on my shopping list and the only trouble is selecting which one to buy. 😊

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Hahaha there is a few to choose from! Thank you for this Eddie!

[@clark3830]

I know I am 1 year late responding but it helps your channel. Great video and yes they can be better. I love the homage more. Maybe Seiko will get the message and do a remake to compete. MAYBE!

[@anonymouswatchguy4223]

I’m not a big fan of homage watches.. but I am a fan of Marc and Long Island watch. Seems like a great guy and his watches are high quality and fairly priced.

[@joeygreen77]

Fabulous Video mate. I really respect your love of brand heritage. I get that it’s one of the most important things to you. Myself I don’t really care. Yeah the back story and history is all nice, but I don’t really care. I do agree with you on this occasion though. I’d take the Seiko over the Islander. But just because I think it’s a nicer looking watch. 😅👌

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Cheers Joe! Loved history as a boy and I also love delving into a brands lifespan y’know, then I become more attached to a piece . Very hard for me to fall for a brand that is brand new. I don’t think I ever have ! Sinn, Squale, Seiko, Rolex even Casio , rich history, loads of watches helping them (hopefully) perfecting the craft! Can totally get someone just liking a good watch though Joe!;)

[@cuckooforwatches382]

These videos are soooo good man. Great stuff!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Thanks for watching my friend!

[@alientechnology5496]

Ok, I don't own either watch. I own two Seikos and like them. I don't own a Long Island watch. I would run to the Islander. Run! Not even a contest. Now I have to decide if I go for the Ford Pinto or the Tesla. Decisions... Decisions.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Not sure this hit the intended mark my friend!;) but I’m looking into getting a Tesla!!!

[@garethsigrist8714]

Awesome comparison MWC! Makes me wonder how an Islander would stack up against a 5KX. Probably very similar outcome to this head to head but certainly interesting. I really like what Marc is doing with the Islander range,. Obviously it doesn’t have the history or heritage of a brand like Seiko but there’s no denying the specs for the money are great! This video reminds me that I really do need to add an Islander to my collection at some point 💸😂

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Right?!! Absolutely Gareth!

[@BenOwen152]

Another great review Russell! Thanks! I'm a big fan of Islander Watches, Marc is doing a great job over there! You should check out the ISL-54! (yes I've said this to you before, but will keep bugging you until I hear you've checked it out! 😜). Keep it up! All the best!

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Nice pilots style watch my friend! Will investigate further!!! Cheers Ben!!

[@karlsenula9495]

I'm with your wife ... not a fan of the 'Pepsi' colorway although I know it is popular.

[@bereadyeveryday6764]

I've been very impressed with the in-house watches at Long Island watches.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Absolutely my friend!!

[@SparkyMarkyMark23]

They're Both Awesome👏🏻🤩😎!

[@samuelyoung4646]

You have a good point, choosing the SEIKO over the islander because of the history. But since the SKX is discontinued, it has gotten extremely expensive. The islander on the other hand, is only $300 from the website. Pair that with much better specs, I feel like I would go with the islander every single time. And if the Islanders few years of history cause it to only last a decade or so? Then at the end of the day it was only a $300 purchase and it’s paid itself off more than once.

[@karlsenula9495]

I like Seiko (own a couple) but with many styles (and after watching many many many videos including positive ones of Seiko) I can't bring myself to buy their REALLY inflated prices (i.e. Captn. Willy reissue for $1k) along with a QC crap shoot ... so I also own many Seiko homages ... so long as it is better QC and specs for a much better price (again do my research). Never been a big 'I have to buy the brand name regardless' kind of a person.

[@flanners41]

I like Marc's watches and enjoy his channel and his guesting. His SKX homage watches look good, given I have both the 007 and 009 there will be no need to get the homage.....I really enjoy both of my SKX divers such awesome watches and I wanted them because they are Seiko and iconic and not homages so I agree with you.

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Great comments here my friend! Thanks for the support!

[@diydad7704]

Seiko may have more history to show off but Mark has worked on the F-14 and does the watch world a big favor with his watch-and-learn videos. I wouldn't pick the ISL-49 but i'd always prefer an islander over the SKXes. And your score table tells me i'm right. Thanks for the lovely video, though. 👍

[@domgatrell651]

Very good, relevant comparison Russ. Many collectors thinking about the same. Frankly i would now go for Marc’s SKX watch over buying another SKX. SKX Mod parts fit Marc’s cases as well so you can continue to mod away to your hearts content and even stick a seiko branded dial in it (though that would create a whole new debate about authenticity!)

[@THEMADWATCHCOLLECTOR]

Hahahahaha woah steady Dom!;) you could have a riot on your hands!!!!;) well said my friend!

[@BlackWipeout]

What is was funny, Citizen is born because Seiko has this great idea... rising taxes from watches coming from Switzerland in Japan, over 50% ;)