Islam’s Quantum Question: Reconciling Muslim Tradition and Modern Science | Dr. Nidhal Guessoum

[@armankhan-wn6mn]

سر ایک سیشن ٹیچنگ کے اوپر اپلوڈ کردے۔ جہاں سمجھا جایا کہ کیسے پڑھایا جاے بچوں کو سکول کی سطح پر ؟ بچوں میں کریٹیویٹی کیسے پیدا کی جاے ؟؟ رٹا سسٹم سے کیسے جان چھڑایئں ؟؟ مطلب ایک سیشن جہاں نۓ استادوں کو سیکھنے کو ملے پلیز

[@mostboringyoutubechannel8845]

May this endeavor achieve eternal bloom and keep blossoming. My respect for Dr. Hoodbhoy and his efforts.

[@tahirahmed33]

This was a good lecture , really enjoyed it

[@susheelbachheti757]

Wonderful Chanel, keep the great work going

[@MAH-sh1zp]

Good talk, well done, Dr Hoodbhoy should be part of the education set up to promote rationalism in system, as long we don’t, people won’t vote for betters leader and therefore, better systems that can enhance our edu. Health and economics

[@englishwithmuzammal3596]

Science is just a branch of knowledge; it is not about reconciling but inclusivity where Islam stands as the primary source of all the information, which is cemented by science, in its essence. Science has nothing to do with proving Islam but just succouring it for human beings who fathom, sometimes, differently.

[@kanadchauhan]

Yeh, killing kafirs is primary thing of Islam and Islam is primary source for brainwashed zombies. Why don"t Muslims read their scriptures, the scriptures of war lord. Islam is primary source of sex perverts, wars , killings nothing else. Zombies.

[@englishwithmuzammal3596]

@@kanadchauhan In Islam, killing an innocent person as if you have killed the whole humanity, and saving the life of a person as if you have saved the whole humanity. KAAFIR is defined the person who knows what the truth is and still refutes it, not anyone who has no Knowlede of Islam or born into any other religion. Bro, you need to obtain the accurate information rafter than succumbing to something blindly. I hope it helps. Thank you for reading.

[@kanadchauhan]

@@englishwithmuzammal3596 , that's fake meaning of aayat you guys are telling us, go read it, it starts with ordained for people of Israel. Good thing is for Israeli Jews and picked from TORAH to warn them to not fight with Mohammed and except Islam. Read next aayat al maidah, 33 that's for Muslims. that talks about 'killing by cut off hands and feets those are against Allah and Mohammad'. And really who are against Allaah,? Ofcourse kafirs. Most Muslims have not read their scriptures and tend to support jihadi terrorists. I feel pity on you Muslims, since these Mullahs are making fool of whole society for last 1000's of years. Go read by yourself and understand, you will start hating it. I have started reading after dawa by Muslim friend, but came to know truth, mostly Good Islam is fake, real Islam is dirty.

[@englishwithmuzammal3596]

@@kanadchauhan With due respect, there typos in your comment, so I couldn’t understand all what you said. Well, the meaning - which is not true - you are trying to extract from the verse does make you the one having own interpretation that are accusing me of. The meaning of the AYAA is transparent like water. I have deeply self-studied Islam and other books of religion compared to other school of thoughts - comparative religiosity: Bible, Torah, Quran, Geeta, etc. and atheism. I have read the books of renewed ones; Stephen Hawking, Richard Dawkins, Sam Harris, Christopher Hitchens, etc., so I am not the reaching the conclusion with biased approach. Defence is logical in any Sirius regardless of who says it. If someone attacks for no reason, then defending yourself is the right given to you in those AYAAT. If you are reading the QURAAN from a specific lens, then it seems sklenting from verisimilitude. There is co compulsion in religion: or any other religion - what matters is the truth. The measure to differentiate veracity from pseudo knowledge demands utmost delving into the pit of Knowlede. I am not an hauteur, nor am I endeavouring to bring eristic perspectives. I am open to other notions if I am amiss. Thank you for reading.

[@AA13494]

in quran the aayat that kiiling an innocent person equates to killing humanity was for bani israel and not muslims. kaafir= non-muslim. plz dnt impose yr fraudulent god on everyone. we reject allah/. leave us alone.@@englishwithmuzammal3596

[@djawalikar2006]

wonderful lecture and discussion and I should say very bold too especially coming from a country having regressive laws such as blasphemy laws. This reminds me of a poem by Faiz ' Bol ki lab azad hai tere.. Bol zuba ab tak teri hai... '

[@hawkingdawking4572]

Don't you have religious rule in India? Do you really think such a program happening in India?

[@djawalikar2006]

@@hawkingdawking4572 No. We dont have any religious rule in India. This might be difficult for you to digest but mind you we are a secular nation.

[@hawkingdawking4572]

@@djawalikar2006 You are clearly wrong. India is not a secular nation. It's Hindu nation which favours Hindus even in criminal cases. You are living in some another planet my friend.

[@djawalikar2006]

@@hawkingdawking4572 LOL . This is what they teach you in pakistan since ages.

[@djawalikar2006]

@@hawkingdawking4572 and remember pakistan is created on the basis of so called two nation theory which our politicians have outrightly rejected. come out of the illusion of being only superior nation because ( according to you) it has been founded on kalma. LOL

[@waldwassermann]

The purpose of Allah is Love.

[@sandeepjain8843]

Dr Nidhal is just cornering the main topic. He doesn't give clear answers how islam is compatible with Science

[@jeevh2790]

If he gives clear answers - 'sir tan se juda' 😐

[@ankurroy3979]

If he gives clear answer then he'll be charged for Blasphemy.

[@skellingtonmeteoryballoon]

walking around bint imran family graves is a science and can be observed too.

[@home2223]

Islam nothing with science

[@djawalikar2006]

he never said islam or any religion for that matter is compatible with science. Listen carefully and appreciate their thinking process.

[@PSR79]

Interesting debate

[@liebedich7680]

Dr Parvez Hoodbhoy is clearly amused.

[@NevilleRamdeholl]

India has opened the gates to Infinity , Pakistan has existed since 1947 with Insanity

[@raphaelhalioua5535]

So where are all the Virtual arabic/muslim Nobel Prizes??? When this huge umah, has only been Awarded 13 such Prizes, mostly in literature and peace, and Only One in Sciences😭😭😭

[@kdshak4904]

Thank you for a great lecture. Unfortunately this will not help. Reason? Please see the description section. It states “science declined in Islamic civilization”. Science didn’t decline. It simply stopped progressing. As Islam as religion was mixed with research. Anytime religious thought is dominant, it will reduce the ability of individuals “to question”. Religion/faith asks individuals to accept things the way they are. Presence of Scientific thought means you can question anything. And if you cannot find a rational answer, it’s ok to reject. This is why religion should be kept out of teaching and discussing science.

[@nmkmit]

Partly u r true But this is the same case with other religions also In Islamic world, it is instability (political instability & corruption) done by politicians and general's

[@jeevh2790]

Whatever science exists in islamic lands or in BOOK is left over from pre-islamic societies there. After converting, the religion has degraded or finished it. In case someone disagree, MUST study islamic history with open mind and without denial, e.g. in pakistan great center of knowledge of Takshashila (Taxila) was destroyed by the invaders of the religion. Referring to ' Anytime religious thought is dominant, it will reduce the ability of individuals “to question” in your comment - Hinduism actually has promoted all kinds of question about it whatever it may be, please study evolution of Hinduism. Anyone who can think logical or rational in pakistan is because of Indian past, and most likely to become Afghanistan in few generations ahead, thanks to your republic.

[@jeevh2790]

@@nmkmit Disagree Sir, Indian stability and progress is deeply rooted in Hindu way of life. Expecting denial of this and angry reaction from pakistan, as minds there are brainwashed to think like that. A good option for pakistan is to, while remaining deeply committed to Islam, accept Hindu heritage and adopt Hindu way of life. Hinduism is NOT BAD as you are taught at your schools and homes.

[@5minutebiology]

The main point of presentation was to stay BOUND to scientific method(making hypothesis , formulating theory etc). If u want it stay in harmony to religion, then u can associate it to either religion to reconcile.(islam or hinduism) u'll get references anyway. But scientific method is of first priority cz its based on evidence.

[@kdshak4904]

@@jeevh2790 Those are all good points Jeev sahib. I have studied Gita and parts of holy books vedas and Upanishad’s. I may be wrong but I can tell you based on my limited knowledge. Hinduism today is a religion like Christianity. Thus, very little remains in practice from the original Hinduism. With the advent of concepts such as nation state, Hindu industrialists started mixing Hinduism in politics. Thus polluting a beautiful religion. Today I feel sad to see that well off Hindus are really practicing worst possible habits of medieval Christianity.

[@lustroussnow]

Rishi Kanaadi also wrote about this! 52:03

[@hawkingdawking4572]

Atoms and elements are Greek philosophic concepts. Indians used to copy Greek knowledge just like they did with Persian knowledge and culture.

[@ramkrishnan1626]

Hoplefully this discusson does not touch raw nerves in pakistan

[@MAH-sh1zp]

It won’t, I ensure Pakistanis r keen to learn and want to make their societies, the people have learn their consequences from poor corrupt parties that they need to act smarter for progress, and that is absolutely fine

[@jeevh2790]

@@MAH-sh1zp With young people like you, pakistan surely will have great future BUT islamic history world over since ancient time and current events (like TTP) tell exactly opposite. Sincere wishes that religion does not harm pakistan any more.

[@hawkingdawking4572]

You worry more about the Vimana Shasthra hoax and your Hindu Raj.

[@ishmaelabraham4884]

Quran 21:30

[@nasirfazal2787]

QM does not mix with Relativity, how all other subjects will mix?

[@anees419]

Urdu plz. What is the use if 95% audience did not even understand this lecture? Kiu ky koi foreigner to inhay dekhy ga nh ...agr Pakistan mai change lana chahty hain toh Pakistani loogon tak baat toh ponchao na..

[@sureshpandey9485]

Sahi kaha

[@hawkingdawking4572]

He is from Algeria.

[@tahirahmed33]

​@@hawkingdawking4572so he's an Algerian scientist / researcher , does he live in Algeria?

[@hawkingdawking4572]

@@tahirahmed33 He was living in many countries.

[@KrishanVermaJi]

Please first figure out how to do Namaz and who is Kafir in the Aasmani Kitab and then discuss later on the Science... Basic clear nahi hai to aage baat karne se kya hoga.

[@nmkmit]

Its very much clear to muslims

[@hawkingdawking4572]

That's up to Pakistanis. Why are you here anyway? You are a Hendoo and you have no belief in science.

[@pappu33]

Very simply, Quran was written 1400 years ago and the scientific knowledge it contains clearly reflects that.

[@NevilleRamdeholl]

Pakistan is now in the land of Insanity..........

[@rebasingh258]

Religion and Science do not mix. We must not link Science with sny religion

[@inidbil7277]

Science is just a tool to understand God's work. Scientists just discover that which God created.

[@premprasad3511]

Why look for consistency at all ? Why not keep religion and science away from each other ? You know very well they don't gel !!

[@AA13494]

sar tan se juda.