Israelis: Why doesn't the IDF protect Palestinians attacked by Jewish settlers?

[@frododiddledeebipedybopedy9840]

"It's only a handful of people" Your highest government ministers are "those people"...

[@rebelheart8633]

👏👏

[@anniebananie416]

Maybe the questions is more like what the F Ar are the settlers doing there in the first place!

[@THXx1138]

No one wants to recognize that their country is the 'bad one' but once you do it is so glaring to witness others making excuses for theirs.

[@jool4867]

Every country is the bad one

[@azrael20009]

@@THXx1138 I think u will know the truth immediately if u start looking historically from the beginning or u can wait for the two state solution to see the truth for yourself,, God Willing

[@AndrewAnderson-vb4pp]

If you tell a lie enough times eventually you will start believe your own lies

[@chasserpasser]

@@azrael20009 "God Willing" tells enough. No one gives a shit about your religious bs. You aren't the chosen people.

[@Seanonyoutube]

As an israeli, the real answer is that in an occupation setting, the occupying force tends to favor its own people over the occupied people. Simple as that.

[@fafolaw]

True, but it's also that you guys have kahanists in important positions of government, like Ben-Gvir and Smotrich.

[@Seanonyoutube]

@@fafolawthat’s the result of indoctrination towards extremism on both sides.

[@RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla]

Where is Palestinian security forces to favor Palestinians? Are there pocketing money from international communities while being irresponsible 😅

[@catherinethomas1276]

Jews are not occupiers.

[@Seanonyoutube]

@@RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla lol, Israeli forces don’t let the PA forces anywhere near area C and most of B too.

[@Sarah-im3lp]

It's called "State sponsored terrorism"!!

[@Paul-rd5pw]

Do the Palestinians protect Jewish citizens in Gaza? Fuck no. Open your eyes!!!

[@saygebordeaux488]

Palaswine

[@user-dl1kr5ov1y]

Were you thinking of Iran and Lebanon too?

[@-------------------DD]

​@@saygebordeaux488 You just proved her point.

[@-------------------DD]

​@user-dl1kr5ov1y They don't kill 200,000 civilians and starve another 2 million, do they now?

[@almami1599]

So let me see if i am getting this right.. These 5 million Palestinians shouldn’t have a country nor an army (you voted against Palestinian statehood) and they also shouldn’t have passports to leave nor have Israeli citizenship and when they are attacked you don’t owe them protection although you have been the ones ruling them through military occupation for 57 years now.. is that the situation right now or did i get something wrong

[@michaelpovolotskyi3295]

They have passports, but not Israeli passports.

[@almami1599]

@@michaelpovolotskyi3295 given by an illegal entity that’s not even a UN member and without Israel knowing, to travel with a Palestinian passport you need first to cross to Jordan and once you do that Jordan will give you its passport because the country where you live doesn’t allow you to have one

[@Mateau35]

They have their own passports, which they then use to travel abroad through Jordan. They aren't owed anything by the Israeli government/the military since they aren't Israeli citizens, and if they live in A or B territories, then they have the Palestinian Authority that is in charge of them. The Israeli army is tasked with protecting the Israelis living in the West Bank and if possible also thwart potential terrorist attacks planned by terror groups like Hamas, Fatah et cetera. The situation is always tense and can get very dicey because of the security issues there, and so everyone is more jumpy and paranoid, and that would explain (although not justify) a situation where an IDF soldier mistreats a Palestinian (for example at a security checkpoint) because of fear that they might be a terrorist, planning to kill civilians or soldiers, where they might just be a normal civilian just going about their life. There have been cases where IDF soldiers were arrested and prosecuted for misconduct towards Palestinians (see for example El'or Azaria trial 2016). The IDF is also tasked with clearing out illegal settlements in the West Bank propped up by hilltop youth (you can look it up), and even just a few months ago it was reported (with video footage) that the IDF cleared out and uprooted an entire olive grove that settlers decided to plant illegaly (it was done in B territories, where Israelis are not supposed to live, as they belong to the PA).

[@teknomajik23]

@@Mateau35 As an occupying power under the Fourth Geneva Convention, Israel (and its military forces) has an obligation to protect the civilian population in the territories it controls, irrespective of ethnicity or religion. This includes ensuring safety and public order for all individuals, not just specific groups. The Israeli Supreme Court has ruled on several occasions that the state and its security forces must ensure the protection of Palestinian civilians and their property from harm, including by settlers. Stop displaying your blatant ignorance and racism

[@almami1599]

@@Mateau35 you are against them becoming Israeli citizens and against them having a country do you know what that means.. stateless people who are not owed protection nor representation by anyone.. does that seem like a reasonable situation?

[@GrassWarlock1]

9:25 "I didn't see any settlers burning houses or fields" 10:30 "I've been there, it happens alot and we always stop it." Something tells me this soldier isn't inclined towards telling the truth.

[@LeonKarni]

you are not only misquoting but purposefully misunderstanding what he said

[@Itsdifferent-wv4jo]

I wanted to defend him but he left no space for me, he has an IQ of Indian

[@GrassWarlock1]

​@@LeonKarniYou're lying. Show me the misquote and the misunderstanding.

[@danielspivak3926]

@@GrassWarlock1 10:30: question: "if you saw a settler attacking a palestinian". answer: "I served in Hebron, and we saw many things like this, ... we stopped the settlers from doing this, from burning shops..." What he said was that settlers don't beat palestinians nor burn their houses and fields, but there were many instances where settlers tried to attack palestinians or burn their shops.

[@danielspivak3926]

@@GrassWarlock1 I think the main thing you missed is that the first answer is about open rural areas and the second answer is about a big city.

[@matthiasdarrington3271]

it's like they have a big secret that no one wants to talk about.

[@Bobby-zp1je]

Oh they have many secrets alright but they’ll never speak on it because they need the world to believe they are the victim.

[@raia07]

Why a secret? People are answering. But the topic is usually presented outside of Israel as if the exception (being a crazy messianic settler) is the rule. And the extremists are pretty new phenomenon, and secular people are agains it. They protest for years against people like that having power , and it's surely no "secret"

[@hausofdownboots]

​@Bobby-zp1je are you here only to spread hate? Lol

[@Wise__guy]

@@hausofdownboots oh sorry you’re right. Only Israelis are allowed to spread hate. Or maybe YOU hate the truth?

[@Bobby-zp1je]

@@hausofdownboots ironic you say that considering your society is built on hate lol.

[@BGivka]

Each one is puzzled by this question - what? Oh who? Oh I don't know ?

[@Alex-xz7ij]

Yea like they’re acting like a tourists lol

[@muha990]

That's the sad reality is that these people have been made so absent-minded about the atrocities of their country's gov that they think their gov can do no harm. So when an attack like Oct 7 happens, it's like they woke up from a coma and suddenly this other race of beings from another planet just started attacking totally unprovoked!

[@rgoonewardene380]

@@muha990All of the people interviewed are current, or ex military. They know exactly what he is talking about. They just pretend.

[@atenooie]

Why do so many Israeli people always say that with every question that is asked to them on this channel, it is a difficult question and the start trying to turn the question around into an other question, thereby not simply answering the first question. Why create the chaos instead of answering it with their opinion. I question this every time, are they afraid of something???

[@atenooie]

⁠according to all international laws and UN resolutions it is occupation. The fact that the settlers and current Israeli government does ignore this does not change reality. *This was an answer to a reply that apparently has been deleted*

[@DinoBryce]

​@@atenooieSo why aren't we talking about how China occupies Tibet or how Russia occupies Crimea? Why is it always Israel's fault?

[@raymondaloni2309]

Because we don't just jump to conclusions. We know we live in a country with a very complex situation. The mind of any individual is not capable of understanding and seeing every perspective that is truly valid and non bias.

[@DinoBryce]

@@raymondaloni2309 Very true

[@atenooie]

@@DinoBryceinteresting that you are doing the exact same thing I just asked. This video is not about China or Russia.

[@The_Voice_of_Reason748]

"Colonialism gets a bad rap" - Jar of Mayonnaise from Texas

[@koolfe3018]

yes colonize palestine yes

[@naturesound8660]

Why settlers and IOF soldiers are in the West Bank in the first place? The right question is why do soldiers back up settlers when they attack Palestinians?

[@GoodStuff1992]

I'm surprised a hasbara troll hasnt tried to deflect your statement

[@Seanonyoutube]

@@naturesound8660 as a hasbara troll, ill answer. Many jews see the “west bank” as ancient Judea and Samaria where ancient jews lived. On this basis as well as economic considerations, they choose to live there. Then, once they are there, they are obviously in danger, hence the military is there to protect them. But realistically now its also a way for the army to maintain better control and line of sight on terror activity and their presence there makes it easier to “mow the lawn” of these groups & activities.

[@محمدبريداوي]

​@@Seanonyoutube the zionists like to go to live in places where they are 'in danger'. Then they start shooting at Palestinians. Remarkable people.

[@masterxmasterx7197]

they're both an occupation force

[@bjkorb7272]

Technically true. All people in every country are occupiers of that country. ​@@masterxmasterx7197

[@Carla39894]

The question should be: Does the IDF protect palestinians from violent settlers?

[@AndreyKrichevsky]

That's a much more boring question though... The answer would just be "Yes", "No", or "I don't know". But the question "Why" invites elaboration.

[@Seanonyoutube]

@@AndreyKrichevskythe correct answer is actually “sometimes”.

[@azrael20009]

​@@Seanonyoutube 👍👍

[@elirosen530]

it does...

[@fredlada1634]

There are enough videos literally showing settlers committing violence against Palestinians wit the help of IDF soldiers protecting the settlers as they were committing crimes. My favorite scriptures out of the entire Bible is from the prophet Micah, particularly chapter 2 & 3.

[@lupen_rein]

It's clear that most Israelis don't really have an accurate picture of what's happening in the West Bank. Nevertheless, almost all of them agreed that the current government policy is not fair and that the IDF should protect Palestinians as well.

[@MrBl3ki]

They do, they are just fed lies and spread lies so much they start believing in them as well.

[@MrCesar3031]

Pass me whatever you’re smoking on because it’s gotta be outta this world!

[@omarsson5107]

So you think that they who call themself "The Chosen People" dont really know whats going on? Or is it just that they can because they are "chosen"?

[@laurafalciani6353]

When all Zionists serve in the army !!!!!!!!!!

[@ronben12]

check the statisitcs. how many jewish people were murdered by "Palestinians" in Judea and Samaria and how many "Palestinians" were murdered in Judea and Samaria and tell me what are the conclusions and who needs protection

[@kemkopi]

I read somewhere that soldiers don't have the ability to arrest settlers or anyone, but they are obligated to defend them against attacks. At the same time, police áre allowed to arrest settlers, but they are not there because those lands tend to be outside their jurisdiction.

[@itamargortzak1009]

They can't arrest neither, they can detain and eventually pass you on to military police/Israeli police respectively, and they do that. obviously there are mistakes but altogether Israel as a state and the IDF isnt intentionally instructing to discriminate.

[@RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla]

Why PA security force is not questioned with their inability to carry out their duties? Why PA judiciary didn't cooperate with Israel judiciary to do solve both Palestine te RR or and illegal settlement te RR or together? Why people expect IDF to secure the place but cried oppression and colonization while IDF preventing PA from being thrown off the building by ji ha di st s?

[@cyanofelis]

It's intentionally a system built to fail. There shouldn't be any settlements. They pay extremists to live there.

[@jubanumidia8460]

@@RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla how old are you ?

[@nazeemateladia6080]

Settlers are IDF and their families.

[@Sa-ee3js]

They’ve ignored over 70 years of history, repeatedly choosing violence and bloodshed. In this digital age, where every action is magnified, that choice will only lead the world to a future filled with the same hatred they’ve fueled in this cycle of revenge. Dismiss it as you will yet the path ahead is bound to reflect the same vengeance. This isn’t just emotion it’s a genuine advise.

[@effervescentevanescenttran6331]

* advice

[@Seanonyoutube]

@@Sa-ee3js only the actions of jews against Palestinians is magnified. I rarely see terror attacks from Palestinians against jews reported on world media.

[@idanw5953]

yes... because before the 7/10 the Palestinians didn't want to destroy Israel.

[@prazzy5356]

The IDF actively protects the settlers attacking Palestinians and intimidates the Palestinians. The Palestinians can’t raise a finger against the settlers stealing their homes otherwise they have an IDF soldier ready with their gun. Wishing for peace ❤

[@thomasjosullivan9179]

Well said, even I have been watching and listening to these incidents for 20 years

[@7135HOLLY]

Yeah, Palestinians are really peace activists in terrorists clothing.

[@AbdulelahAhmed-nu6zz]

​@@thomasjosullivan9179 since 67

[@HassanBurman]

IDF have no obligation to protect non Jews

[@Twitch760]

@@HassanBurman the IDF as the occupying force have responsibility for security. Military commanders on the spot must prevent and where necessary suppress serious violations involving the local population under their control or subject to their authority. The occupying force is responsible for protecting the population from violence by third parties, such as newly formed armed groups or forces of the former regime.

[@DanielSapphire-gv3ee]

Because they support it !

[@ayalaostrovsky9550]

Difficulty in understanding the video?!

[@yusefd7818]

the video does not matter, the reality on the ground is that the government supports and arms the settlers to the teeth and then protects them as they terrorize Palestinian villages and cities. it has been happening for decades, all funded by the government and supported on every level. ​@@ayalaostrovsky9550

[@estherblashka9855]

The Areas A & B should be protected by the PA police armed by the US. And maybe they like the fighting since it proves Israel cannot "live in peace". There is no Israeli sovereignty in the disputed lands. If there was I bet Israel WOULD keep the peace!

[@inonarbiv6706]

What is this question the Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) is the military force designated to protect Israeli citizens. Palestinians are not Israelis. You cannot want to be a separate state while also expecting the soldiers of another country to protect you. It’s like Ukrainian soldiers demanding to protect Russian citizens. this is level of stupidity that i did not know existed.

[@Offa7a]

Cause it’s not the IDF it’s the IOF Israeli Occupation forces.

[@ikesileth2270]

I really appreciated Michelle’s response. I felt like she cared about the issue and the people involved, which is important

[@heleneferron5533]

SAVE INNOCENT CHILDREN PLEASE !!! > Stop GENOCIDE IN Palestine and Liban ! Stop Hitler_Netanyaou - SAVE THE CHILDREN !!!

[@TheNagualWilliam]

Here's a question for you to ask Israelis - Do you feel any gratitude to the indigenous Palestinian people that they gave your forefathers sanctuary when they fled from Europe? Do you feel any shame or remorse that you rewarded that generosity and humanity by stealing their land and committing ethnic cleansing?

[@Ofekito]

Palestnian identity didnt exist back then, it was the british mandate of palestine that let jews get back to their land after hcast. Many of them also fled from middleeast not only europe. So called arabs were against jews coming to the land while they never had leadership on the land back then

[@1minuteskin]

E-mail Corey your questions - he is more likely to ask them. They are very good ones, I would love to hear their answer

[@TheNagualWilliam]

@@1minuteskinthanks but if he can't be bothered to read the comment section he can't be very interested. Also, there's no way he will ask the questions.

[@Rae-qi7yp]

We are the indigenous people as well. "Treating us well" is only in comparison to Europe which actively killed us. We were second-class citizens akin to Jim Crow. That generosity was lost when the Arab Armies tried to steal back the land we had bought and cultivated while trying to kill us all. Then they ethnically cleansed essentially all Jews from everywhere else in MENA. So, unless you guys start acknowledging we are also indigenous, and you even based your own religions off of ours (cultural appropriation much?) then no, not a lot of gratitude for the continual attempts to kill us all.

[@user-dl1kr5ov1y]

​@@TheNagualWilliamYou have to e-mail him like everyone else, he doesn't go through the thousands of comments on this channel. Corey is very open, he's asked other nonsensical, factually false and provocative questions before on behalf of his viewers, or has perhaps already asked something similar in the past. You should look through his many videos.

[@maxx_thedragondominator]

2:55 they don't have a responsibility but they have checkpoints asking people what their religion is and refuse freedom of movement to palestinians

[@ileanaseagal6757]

Repercussions of terrorists activities! Palestinians should stop with that activity and not need for such measures. There is almost every day a terror attack by Palestinians in Israel, many at the checkpoints ! 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@AndreyKrichevsky]

In some areas they also refuse freedom of movement to Jews. Try getting past an Israeli guard into Al-Aqsa mosque/ Temple Mount if you're not Muslim... You'll be turned right around

[@maxx_thedragondominator]

@@AndreyKrichevsky like the only place for obvious reasons. But can Palestinians from the West Bank have freedom of movement to go to the Mosque? Only if the IDF allows them for arbitrary reasons.

[@anasabu-obeid4367]

@@maxx_thedragondominator actually plaestinians from the west bank are not allowed to enter the al-awsa mosque at all, only if they have israeli residency, or are married to an arab israeli. Or if you are Dual nationality West bank Palestinian (example: US citizen and Palestinian Citizen)

[@nicoleguler8211]

This comment shows that you have no idea what is going on in Israel so just stop your yapping

[@everythinginyourhands5887]

Simply overlooking occupation, we can say it is an apartheid state.

[@rid4568]

Ignorance is bliss for a lot of these people interviewed. The echo chamber is not allowing critical thinking.

[@Voltimediawebsite]

how are you so sure you are not in an echo chamber yourself?

[@spitboi7]

If the lady starting at 6:40 was the majority there honestly would be peace, its so heartwarming to see and hear Israelis like her.

[@AdegbengaOgungbeje]

So the last guy is simply stating what has been the argument against Zionism all along. Its the law of the jungle and international law isnt necessary.

[@Abilliph]

When you are in the middle east.. be middle eastern. There is only so much a civilized country that follows international law, can do against a hostile populations that respect no international law. Sometimes, it's either them or us. So they should respect 90% of international law. If they did respect all of it, Israel would've been a binational state, and the Jews would become a persecuted minority once more. All that has nothing to do with the situation in the West Bank of course.. both sides are protected by the IDF. It's just that one of those sides doesn't allow the IDF to be stationed in their villages, so it takes time to react to an attack against them. Also the other side is attacking much less than first one, so soldiers are not always prepared for the very few attacks of settlers on Palestinians. Think about it like that.. How many yearly Palestinian casualties by settlers are there?

[@bestman7776]

@@Abilliphleave the Middle East, back to Poland u go

[@YipManAOMA]

@@Abilliph how do you live with yourself, knowing you believe and help spread such outrageous lies.

[@Abilliph]

@@YipManAOMA I only talk facts.. how many Palestinian casualties are a result of settler attacks each year??.. and how many Jewish casualties are a result of Palestinian attacks?? Numbers don't lie. Israel is meant to be the state of the Jewish nation.. no matter what is their religion. People can believe in whatever you want in Israel, but the the state has to protect the national Jewish sovereignty of Israel. Any law that is against Jewish sovereignty, is not a law Israel can respect.

[@syedvasty3847]

Gahhhhhhhdddd I love your videos. I hope you get all the funding you need to continue. Videos like this make me believe that as bad as things are, there is still people on ALL sides that are actively seeking ways to understand the other side, and as long as that's the case, we can still dream and fight for peace one day (when I say fight for peace I don't mean literally).

[@anythingidkn5938]

Soldiers are usually protects settlers during their attacks on Palestinians in case you don't know this.. They are togther.. Settlers rarely attack without IDF with them

[@raymondaloni2309]

Have you been to the west bank? You can't take that at face value when all you did was saw a Al Jazeera documentary. You're brainwashed.🤡

[@Walt-z4u]

I see desperate ethical gymnastics.

[@santiagodelpilar6701]

**ethnical and it's called Eugenics

[@urameshi4725]

It's apartheid. It looks really bad on video when a Settler punches a Palestinian and an Israeli solider just watches, but when a Palestinian reacts, he is instantly arrested. Tamir Pardo has called this apartheid and he's right.

[@thomasjosullivan9179]

Yes I have seen endless such videos, the settlers and IDF are nasty people

[@8aNda1d]

When does the camera start filming and which parts are edited?

[@saskiascott8181]

I think the situation in the West Bank is legitimately wrong and bad. I just wish people would actually just criticise what is really wrong and not call for the destruction of Israel whole cloth and then start perpetrating violence on Jewish people worldwide. Which is what is happening right now.

[@Seanonyoutube]

What is it called when Palestinians lynch Israelis who enter Ramallah? Asking for a friend.

[@mugiwaraluffy4888]

its not apartheid from the israeli side, 2 million arabs live in israel with full rights how many jews live under ''palastinian''?

[@nikigba]

Give your people money and comfort and keep them blissful about oppression - colonial structure.

[@Thenoobestgirl]

And which country are we a colony of?

[@no-body-22]

Every city was founded as a colony.

[@pdnowlin]

👍🏻

[@hishamalaker491]

​@Thenoobestgirl Britian they mass imported you fks into Palestine then you fought them because they didn't allow as much by the 30s. Talk about traitorous assholes. People were right in the past about you.

[@lesweizman388]

you are right...arabs need to stop colonizing the middle east and return to arabia

[@zivgg]

As Israeli I’m ashamed about this. The occupation must stop

[@Raishah28]

They tell they are the chosen one and yet they lie so much.

[@teknomajik23]

they lie so much because they are delusional that they are the chosen ones

[@youtubekeepscensoringme]

Palestinians lie also

[@gili41]

Prove they are....

[@ronben12]

without lies Islam dies

[@MFlare-ne4tc]

@@gili41you think people are stupid?? It’s 2024

[@CristianChertes-g4u]

What beautiful the First Lady soul is … God bless her , he did not negate that are Israeli that harm Palestinians … and she sad we should stop also the Jews terrorism

[@TheNagualWilliam]

Israel was founded with terrorism and has lived by 76 years of terror and terrorism, so exactly what are you going to change? It's its Modus operandi, its khazarian DNA!!

[@HG4everpro]

There is nothing beautiful about that, she is a Zionist and a terrorist who support genocide, there arent arabs in "Israel" there ONLY PALESTINIANS.

[@dogbert52]

Thats not a question. Its an accusation. Well done habibi

[@jramir2]

Brother, I think if we hear news about it and see videos. And you deny the news or believe it just doesn't happen. Then you are the problem. Just like a terrorist who only believes in violence is the problem. We see videos of Israelis spitting on christians. And we give those horrible people tax dollars for moronic reasons. Imagine those people doing worse to Arabs, just because they can get away with it. No different than lynchings of black people by racist white folks. We seen the videos. So please dude, save us from your idiocy.

[@1minuteskin]

Yes because all those renowned International human rights organisations like Amnesty International or Human Rights Watch are wrong. Only the thieving apartheid regime is right 😂😂😂

[@Ty.Connelly.]

How can someone live on the same planet, but own and occupy another dimension? MIND=BLOWN 🙄

[@muhammadrizvansidiqui2050]

That lady in black with shades spoke the truth

[@Offa7a]

Welcome to another episode of bubbled Israel 😂

[@noukoukino]

I wonder if the " mainland" Israelis would welcome the hilltop youth and all the other more agressive settlers among their mids. Meaning if they would be ok if those settlers moved to their town or city and became their neighbours

[@Auroraxx]

We would prefer them to live in Israel. We don’t like their interaction with the Palestinians, only soldiers should be there to prevent the West Bank from becoming Gaza

[@TheCastedone]

@@Auroraxx whats wrong with gaza?

[@SnowsStorm1]

@@TheCastedoneaside from it having been a hotbed from terrorism? Geez nothing I suppose 🙄🙄🙄🙄

[@TheCastedone]

@@SnowsStorm1 gazans terrorized Israel? Why would they do that? Isn't it a refugee camp for displaced Palestinians?

[@Auroraxx]

@@TheCastedone soldiers all left in 2005 and it immediately became a terror state

[@maaz322]

Its touching that some think the IDF and police should standup to settlers, but do they really is the question. Amount of deaths, destruction, and aggression speaks to the complete contrary. Doesn't matter what they think if the fact is different. They should stand up to the fact, not speak of what is ideal, which seems to be the Israeli way. 'We have this fair ideal, but if this ideal isn't carried out, it's because the dastardly behavior of non-jews, not our own conduct.'

[@chikilic]

That's a great question.

[@BOZ_11]

not really, it's completely obvious

[@MarinaNeumann-nq6pn]

Maybe to you it is

[@thomasjosullivan9179]

I expect the racist element is part of it and Colonialism. Not forgetting the Apartheid system

[@Dignity4allhumanity]

8:35 go girl deliver the message loud and proud

[@roey218]

People should know in the Israeli "General security service" - shin bet. There's a unit called the "Jewish department", They have arrested many extremist settlers and investigated them sometimes using force in order to protect palastinias. Many times they even just like against palastinias terrorists arrested Jewish settlers without court order to prevent immediate attack on Palastinias. having Saying that it is really rare when extremist settlers cause death to palastinias while Palastinias causing death to Israelis is by far more common. Usually after a terror attack by palastinias those extremist settlers looking for revenge by mostly damaging property and bullying palastinias. Soldiers usually do protect palastinias when they are under attack by settlers. When you see on the internet sometimes some incidents when soldiers do not protect palastinias these are usually rare cases.

[@hellebachmann8260]

So what you are saying is, that all the video evidente is false?

[@merketarif126]

so they need a special force to protect them? should not all security officers duty protect people who get harmed?

[@roey218]

@@hellebachmann8260 I didn't say it is false. Sometimes some individual soldiers do not act against extremist settlers and it is against the orders. There are individuals who have different beliefs or different moral values within any society. Most soldiers would act to stop these attacks against Palastinias. Generally in most cases Palastinias are those who attack settlements. BTW extremist settlers who have history with attacking palastinias are not able to serve in the IDF and even within the settlers community the vast majority of settlers are against these extremists.

[@roey218]

@@merketarif126 The "special force" is an agency within the "Shin Bet" that fighting Jewish terrorism on the high level. On the ground on a daily basis the soldiers are protecting the settlers who are more vulnerable to terror attacks and sometimes when needed they protect the Palastinias. In the west bank Palastinias and Jewish people live together mostly peacefully. It is something that should be known, if an Israeli would be recognized within most Palastinias territories he will get killed on the other hand at least before October 7 more than 100,000 Palastinias used to work everyday within Israel and Jewish settlements in the west bank. In the west bank there are industrial parks where Israelis and Arab palastinias are working together. The Palastinias in the west bank live a peaceful and decent life. They have the best quality of life compared to the neighboring countries. The problem is that terrorism is very common and supported within the Palestinian society. Anyway I'm against the settlements. There are almost 500,000 settlers in the west bank, it is about 5 percent of the Israeli population and about 20 percent of the population in the west bank. What is interesting is that in Israel itself lives 2 million Arab citizens which are 20 percent of the Israeli population.

[@roey218]

@@merketarif126 The "special force" is an agency within the "Shin Bet" that fighting Jewish terrorism on the high level. On the ground on a daily basis the soldiers are protecting the settlers who are more vulnerable to terror attacks and sometimes when needed they protect the Palastinias. In the west bank Palastinias and Jewish people live together mostly peacefully. It is something that should be known, if an Israeli would be recognized within most Palastinias territories he will get killed on the other hand at least before October 7 more than 100,000 Palastinias used to work everyday within Israel and Jewish settlements in the west bank. In the west bank there are industrial parks where Israelis and Arab palastinias are working together. The Palastinias in the west bank live a peaceful and decent life. They have the best quality of life compared to the neighboring countries. The problem is that terrorism is very common and supported within the Palestinian society. Anyway I'm against the settlements. There are almost 500,000 settlers in the west bank, it is about 5 percent of the Israeli population and about 20 percent of the population in the west bank. What is interesting is that in Israel itself lives 2 million Arab citizens which are 20 percent of the Israeli population.

[@kwilla2001]

The first guy in the blue said he never saw any burning etc... then he said when he served in Hebron he stopped the settlers form burning shops and arrested them....🤷‍♂

[@ForeverRepublic]

We do. That was 80% of my job when i was in the army. They just don't share it on Al Jazeera. Legally, there are limitations because 90% of Arabs that live in Judea and Samaria live in area a or b, meaning the Palestinian police are responsible for them. They have their own passports, government, etc, it's a separate entity = not our problem.

[@mostm8589]

Bullshit

[@imkarciqov]

There is no "Judea and Samaria" you are ILLEGALLY occupying the West Bank. Don't start with history. Everyone should go live where their ancestors lived 2,000 years ago?

[@HeatherFoster-nk5vn]

If you're calling it Judea and Samaria then I have reason to doubt the reliability of your perspective. It's inherently prejudice

[@ForeverRepublic]

@@HeatherFoster-nk5vn That's the actual historical name for the land. It's was used by the UN in 1947, and even the Arabs themselves call it as-Samira (السَّامِرَة‎). It's not a Jewish name. It's just that Jewish people come from the land, so the land has a Hebrew name. The "west bank" is a British colonial term.

[@her23795]

But you have the freedom to harrass them at the checkpoints and deny them water even collecting rain water.You also have the right to detain children as young as nine year olds without any charge.If there's one thing I've realized about you people is that you're way too delusional to accept any facts

[@jimbopaw]

> That's like 7% of the Israeli population, or about 1 out of every 14 Israelis. Source: wikipedia

[@tylerellington8796]

I appreciate the last guy. He seemed thoughtful but his words are depressing.

[@AsiaAnsari-ck7sg]

Heartbreaking to see that these people still don't see the problem. They are standing on the corpses of Palestinians yet they are are the victim. They still are blind to reality

[@judgeyourself8213]

Hey Corey God bless you for asking uncomfortably tough questions. Can you please do a question session and ask people in Israel "Is Judaism belief system built on arrogance? Why do they believe they are chosen people? If they are chosen, why isn't their prophet sent to all mankind? Why is talmud only for them and insulting all other people in the talmud. Is it because of the Talmud, the way it speaks about non jews such as Gentiles, the reason why Palestinian are being treated like animals? Because the talmud teaches this? Please and thanks. I would like to hear them clarify these questions that many foreigners have. Again God bless you for educating people with your interviews.

[@Thenoobestgirl]

It's the IDF, not the PDF...

[@movingtargets7833]

you don't occupy the p's land then you f...

[@yusefd7818]

although pedophilia does run rampant in israeli society, especially as they allow the sex offenders from America to get out of jail and migrate there as long as they "convert" to judaism. Its sick, i know, but Israel is a hotbed and safehaven for pedophiles

[@superawesomeguyneal]

Maybe they should stay in Israel then instead of doing illegal occupations.

[@mathieufaltys]

IOF

[@KiamatChange-ke8nd]

Good question and good answer.

[@amkougljanin9497]

I hope both sides will find some solution about land and live in piece,they do have more similarities than difference

[@Bettybaminjerusalem]

We Israelies were willing to settle and tried many times, it is not what the Palestinians want. They want all the land, it is very important to listen to what they say.

[@amkougljanin9497]

@@Bettybaminjerusalem I pray for peace ✌️ both of you people look nice and beautiful in my eyes

[@azrael20009]

​@@Bettybaminjerusalem ךכן,, אבל לא כולם

[@Bettybaminjerusalem]

@@azrael20009 זה ממש לא נכון. יש אולי 2% מאלו שחיים בעזה או בגדה שמעוניינים בפתרון שתי המדינות. אני באה מהשמאל אבל צריך להיות מפוקחים. מציעה לך להקשיב להם בערבית )הסיסמא הנפוצה שלכם מאז השביעי היא: "it is either us or us", להקשיב ל- ask project ולתשובות של פלסטינים ולד"ר עינת וילף והכי חשוב לדבר איתם, השיחות עם פלסטינים זה מה שפקח את עיני.

[@Bettybaminjerusalem]

@@azrael20009 התשובות שכתבתי מצונזרות אוטומטית למרות שאינן פוגעניות בשום צורה

[@roronoazoro8789]

Blame Ben Gvir, in his political campaign he promised to get rid of settlers and here we are now

[@maxx_thedragondominator]

Ben Gvir has always been an extremist. He’s actually a settler himself.

[@aaddaamm1100]

Ben gvir backs the settlers. He is a settler himself. So having ben gvir is bad news for the Palestinians. Plenty other politicians would have acted differently. I never saw settler violence when I served in the army. It depends who runs the show

[@David99356]

@@aaddaamm1100Ben gvir has nothing to do with the army. He’s purely a scapegoat.

[@alphadog3384]

I truely appreciate how you show the diversity of the Jewish people, thank you.

[@Carla39894]

I have seen israeli soldiers protecting palestinians fron settlers but the media won't show it

[@itamargortzak1009]

True. As a combat medic I personally treated many of them in incidents that werent related to the Army, it was actually mostly car accidents and violence related.. but the media wont show that

[@mcb00]

The issue is whether they *always* do, and whether they *ever* protect or help the settlers when they are violent. And keep in mind these people are doing something illegal stealing land. The West Bank is not Israeli land

[@itamargortzak1009]

@@mcb00 Obviously nothing is perfect and the state of Israel aspires to endorse both its laws and the Geneva accordes and it will bring you to justice if you have commited a felony. All my fellow combat medics that i worked with never discriminated anyone who needed medical assistance. i think you might not have enough information on the subject to be so sure of your self about the stealing land calims. by the way did you know the west bank was part of jordanian borders? it is their west bank sa its on israels east.. do tell, why did they now take them back after the 67 peace treaty? since youre so familiar with the subject

[@idarogozin5009]

@@mcb00the West Bank in Judea and Samaria! . And look up shin Bet does to Jews how brake the law or who are on their target… . By the way those settlers that called “ terrorist” are a very small minority, especially compared to so called” Palestines” . Stop falling into every propaganda …

[@alexalexandersen5198]

😂😂😂😂😂😅

[@abd5441]

In the West Bank Palestinians are under military occupation, under military law, go to military courts, etc. Jewish citizens are under civilian law. The result is that the IDF cannot do anything to Jews, can only call the police. This is just one of the clear examples of apartheid. I first learned this from members of Breaking the Silence, the activist group of former IDF soldiers.

[@libertyandjustus8258]

Thanks! For any of us who are on one side or the other but have never been there and REALLY taken in what happens in daily life of the people who live in Isreal , we cannot really comment or give our opinion or heart against these people and their life. It's like the old adage that says " until you walk a mile in my shoes..." We can try and be informed but like the guy at the end who scoffed at that we are getting our knowledge and information from the " news " . The news can be WAY to easily manipulated to show one side and not the other. That's why I appreciate this channel. Its asking REAL people and getting their full opinion. Thank you Corey and team❤

[@Sines-s6q]

everyone but the girl who said she "danced around the question" avoided the question. and even she didn't seem to be willing to say anything critical of the soldiers.

[@joshuaman11]

There IS a system of apartheid in area C, in which 4% of the west bank population lives. This is an area that is administered by Israel (civil and military) in agreement with the Palestinian Liberation Organization in the Oslo Accords in the year 1995. Context: Israel has repeatedly tried to return Area C to Palestinian control as outlined in the peace offers in 2000, 2008, essentially offering 100% of the Palestinian land marked by the 1967 borders, a state, everything they asked for and more (reparations etc) A brief summary of those deals in the comments below:

[@joshuaman11]

Key Points of the 2000 Peace Proposal Territorial Concessions: *Israel offered to withdraw from approximately 91% of the West Bank and the entirety of the Gaza Strip, with an additional land swap to compensate the Palestinians for the remaining 9% that Israel would retain. *The proposal included some territorial contiguity between Palestinian-controlled areas and a transportation link between the West Bank and Gaza Strip. Jerusalem: *The proposal divided East Jerusalem. Palestinian neighborhoods would fall under Palestinian sovereignty, while Jewish neighborhoods and the Old City, particularly key religious sites, would remain under Israeli control. *There was also a suggestion for a special arrangement in the Old City to allow access to religious sites, including the Western Wall and the Al-Aqsa Mosque. Refugees: *The issue of Palestinian refugees was addressed with a framework that included compensation, limited right of return to the Palestinian state (not Israel), and international funding to assist in resettlement or compensation. Security Arrangements: *Israel sought security guarantees, including a demilitarized Palestinian state and Israeli control over certain strategic locations like the Jordan Valley for a transitional period. End of Conflict: *The agreement aimed for mutual recognition of each state and the end of all claims and hostilities.

[@joshuaman11]

*Key Points of the 2008 Proposal*: Territorial Concessions: *Israel proposed withdrawing from around 93% of the West Bank, with a land swap to account for the remaining 7%. This would allow Israel to keep major settlement blocs while compensating the Palestinians with equivalent land near the Gaza Strip. *The deal included establishing a corridor linking the West Bank and Gaza Strip, ensuring transportation access between the two territories. Jerusalem: *The proposal called for a division of Jerusalem. Arab neighborhoods in East Jerusalem would come under Palestinian sovereignty, while Jewish neighborhoods would remain under Israeli control. *The Old City, home to important religious sites, would be governed by an international body made up of five countries: Israel, Palestine, the United States, Jordan, and Saudi Arabia. This special status was meant to ensure open access to holy sites for all faiths. Refugees: *The deal suggested that a limited number of Palestinian refugees could return to Israel, while others would have the option of resettling in the new Palestinian state or third countries, along with financial compensation and international assistance. Security Arrangements: *Israel proposed a demilitarized Palestinian state with its own police force. It also sought international peacekeeping forces in the Jordan Valley and other key areas to ensure long-term security and stability. End of Conflict: *The proposal aimed to achieve mutual recognition and a final end to the conflict, with both sides renouncing further claims against each other.

[@joge2468]

Yes, there is separation, but it bears no resemblance to apartheid. First of all, apartheid requires separation among racial or ethnic lines *BECAUSE* the people differ in those respects. Considering there are 2M Arab Izzis, you have a very tough job proving that is why people are separated in the WB. Second, the two groups in question are citizens of different territories. Apartheid requires they be citizens of the same land, or that the ‘oppressed’ group be citizens of a different land unwillingly. Ps have no desire to live within, or be citizens of, Iz.

[@joge2468]

Third, the PA agreed to the following stipulations, and promptly reneged on their responsibilities. Iz’s heavy hand is a direct response to the PA being unable and unwilling to curb the arms smuggling and terrorism in Azag and the WB. It has nothing to do with race. “Iz shall have the overriding responsibility for security for the purpose of protecting Israelis and confronting the-threat of terrorism.” “Except for the Pian Police and the Iz military forces, no other armed forces shall be established or operate in the West Bank and the Strip.” “Except for the arms, ammunition and equipment of the Pian Police described in Annex I, and those of the Iz military forces, no organization, group or individual in the West Bank and the Strip shall manufacture, sell, acquire, possess, import or otherwise introduce into the West Bank or the Strip any firearms, ammunition, weapons, explosives, gunpowder or any related equipment, unless otherwise provided for in Annex I.” “Both sides shall take all measures necessary in order to prevent acts of terrorism, crime and hostilities directed against each other, against individuals falling under the other's authority and against their property, and shall take legal measures against offenders.”

[@RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla]

According to international general law uti possidetis juri, Israel official territory consist of Gaza west bank and Jerusalem. Israel cannot occupy what is already its. This general law applies to all the emerging states like China, Pakistan Malaysia Lebanon Jordan Ukraine etc. It says the emerging state will inherit the borders of the previous administration. Since the partition to create Jewish and Arab state is never agreed by Arabs of Palestine, the partition is never enforced. The only emerging state from the British Mandate is Israel. Therefore, Israel inherited the borders of British Mandate which is from Sea of Galilee to the red sea. Its official territory consist of Gaza, West Bank and Jerusalem. 48-67 Israel territory Gaza and West Bank was occupied by Egypt Jordan. In 67 israel recover their land but they are accused of occupation and colonization. It's DOUBLE STANDARD and MISREPRESENTATION of international law. Ukraine will not be accused of occupation when they were to recover Crimea. So Israel is never occupying Gaza and west bank because you can't occupy what is already yours. (Source: Natasha Hausdorff interview) since according to international law uti possidetis juri, Israel is the sole legitimate official state consist of Gaza and west bank, Israel is never an occupier or colonizer in Gaza and west bank. In 67, when Egypt and Jordan return the land to Israel, Israel didn't choose to impose Israel official framework of administration in Gaza and west bank because of wanting to give the land back to Egypt and Jordan for peace. The Israel built up a temporary administrative referring to occupation framework in Geneva Convention while at the same time preparing it to be exchange Gaza with Egypt, west bank with Jordan for peace. But both Egypt and Jordan seeked peace without wanting the land. Then the temporary frameworks in Gaza and west bank has not change due to the consideration of Arabs living there. That's why we have Palestinian Authority on Israel official territory. 1. Israel have tried give up the land for peace but it is Jordan and Egypt who don't want it 2. Israel have allowed Arabs to govern themselves in Israel land. We can see Hamas in Gaza attacking Israel when they are given full authority towards Arabs living there. PA at west bank is not overthrow by hamas like in Gaza because Israel has tried to stabilize PA and allowing them to govern. Source : Natasha Hausdorff My conclusion: international community is being lied about occupation and colonization. Under full authority of Hamas, radicalization uprises. Israel have don't more than other countries by to try to achieve peace but to no avail.

[@geogeo2299]

I saw there was minimal engagement on part of the Jews with Israel's major settler problem. From the 8 people interviewed, not even one accepted there's any such issue, while 1 or 2 dismissed it as being confined to some tiny social fringe.

[@igotnothingbettertodo472]

Corey you also have to realize somwthing else. Palestine soldiers and israeli soldiers operate on other sides of the areas in judea and samaria (west bank) pa soldiers are reaponsible for their areas while IDF is responsible for our areas and we cannot cross into their turf while they cant cross into ours. So if a palestinian comes to the IDF area ofc he isnt on his home base and is considered an invader. It would be exactly the other way around if a jew went to PA areas but we simply dont do that.

[@anasabu-obeid4367]

what's funny is that the IDF can operate and enter ANYWHERE in the west Bank, with zero impunity, and the Palestinian Authority will not intervene nor stop them. that just shows who really has authority over the west bank, PA has no real authority over anything.

[@raniab9546]

Fu*k what you just said. Plain bullshit and we all know it by know. There is plenty of evidence against the bullshit you just claimed.

[@GodMode365]

@igotnothingbettertodo472 Palestinian soldiers? Thought according to you guys that if you're Palestinian and decide to fight back, that makes you a terrorist.

[@1973Eliman]

When your mind is conditioned as a an etno supramacist, you do not see the other anymore. We call that dehumanasation 😢😢😢

[@blivion7203]

Israel should first and foremost protect its own people. That it their duty.

[@mcb00]

Then keep your settlers in your country

[@mcb00]

Then keep the colonizers in your country

[@jessiekatetheking]

They’re illegally stealing land goofy

[@blivion7203]

@@jessiekatetheking Welcome to the middle east. The language in there is power and and respect and not "lovey-dovey, peace and love". It's less about the land and more about them losing their dignity when they lose land.

[@nicoleguler8211]

@@jessiekatetheking Where are you from exactly?

[@EllieIbu]

There are loads of videos on BTselem showing IDF soldiers standing very close by while settlers attack.

[@Memoee-u6c]

I can see that israelins are living a good life in a land that is not for them !! May god help palastiniens from occupiers.

[@Lori1Cor15]

It is their land. Has been for thousands of years. That is why artifacts are found their,such as Rachel's tomb, the temple, aqueducts, etc.

[@markusk9080]

Of course it is their land. The Arabs should be glad that they are there, that's why it's looking so nice. Can't say the same about any Arab place.

[@Memoee-u6c]

@@Lori1Cor15 it has never been thier country !! they are europiens most of them are blond !!! they do not deserve to be thier!! only Canaanites muslims and christians and jew!

[@AbdulelahAhmed-nu6zz]

​@@Lori1Cor15 thousands of years 😂? Were they not brought last 60 years to the land after holocaustin the Palestinians?

[@joshuaman11]

@@AbdulelahAhmed-nu6zz ever heard of bayt al maqdis? guess what that name comes from ^^

[@asynchronicity]

IDF is the most moral military force on Earth, according to IDF.

[@recordgalaxy]

Obviously the Palestinians have no rights under Israel's illegal occupation what did you expect ?

[@atrixiousscramasax6686]

well, they dont even want israel to give them rights so they will not accept any. thats why there is no garbage trucks in violent palestinian cities

[@youtubekeepscensoringme]

Israelis and jews don't have rights under palestinian occupation also

[@zaienkamal3308]

It seems like most of the world can clearly see how Israelis are treating the Palestinians as just cruel and unfair. End the apartheid and let there be peace pls.

[@braveangel262]

talk about complete denial and ignorance. Pathetic. And this is occupation.The pretty lady at about 8 min in is pretty smart. She is honest.

[@AsiaAnsari-ck7sg]

Interesting point that IOF soldier made at the end... Everyone should stay in their homes and respect other peoples homes. By that point is Israel respecting Palestinian homes? They are ever-expanding their illegal settlements into the homes of Palestinians how can you expect them to not react? . And he speaks of justice for the native Canadians? Native Americans? They were genocided to make room for European colonies. They have not received justice but does that make it ok for other countries to carry on genocide of natives? In this day of modernisation human rights and freedoms which should be universal for all?

[@TruthSeeker.]

I'm from mexico i live in San Francisco, and i was lucky to have become friends with 2 jews in school they taught me about the scriptures and i became a noahide they invited me to their synagogue I'm grateful to the chosen people for tesching the right path, today I'm noahide i learned Yiddish, and i stand with lsrsel if Israel tke volunteers I'll enlist in the IDF

[@rajm2626]

The bots are evolving 🥱

[@DSweashox]

Great, now here is your tinfoil hat 🤡

[@AngelGarcia-oy3yj]

El Mesías es Jesucristo. El que no crea en él no verá al Padre, sino que la ira de Dios está sobre él.

[@youtubekeepscensoringme]

​@@DSweashoxare you melting down?

[@jorgehidalgo5786]

THE CHOSEN ONE 😂😂😂😂 SO IGNORANT!!!! SECOND CLASS CITIZEN!!!! GO TO WASH DISHES , TO BUILT HOUSES ETC SLAVE OF THE USA !!!!😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@neoalmaguer6505]

Emanuelle is whats wrong with the world refusing to open their eyes

[@Dignity4allhumanity]

Live and let live and accept nothing less than peace ☮️ Action to peace ✌️ people one man’s power should not result in another man’s warcrimes.

[@AnnachiaraRoncarolo]

I can't comment without appreciating how beautiful and spontaneous Israelis seem from these interviews, specifically Israeli women. I wish I could go on Taglit lol but I waited too much and I am old... I hope you all are safe whenever you are! Shalom from Italy.

[@azrael20009]

Shalom to you :)

[@pdnowlin]

🤮

[@ezrafinkelstein2634]

a bit of a provocative question, and the comment section is full of people who don't realize the rarity of such violent incidents. Isolated crazy people exist on both sides, byt are definitely not representative of the wider Israeli population or even most settlers who just want to live peacefully.

[@jramir2]

When was the last time, white people burned black neighborhoods? Back in the 1940s or 1960's. If it happened it again it would be rare. The fact it this happens in Israel and Palestine today, while Israel is pretending to the good guys, and they are actually the perpatrators in those "rare" events. That only shows how mentally sick are some Israelis today. Which their society protects them, because they are not rotting in jail. Until they rot in jail, or serve a hefty jail sentence, along with proven and convicted arabs, then you can call it a rare event. But if they aint rotting in jail. Then this is the norm in Israel. And its protected by their evil corrupt system and cops.

[@dontworry7127]

The last guy about justice confirmed the will against Palestinians

[@elirosen530]

sure, Palestinians wish us dead why should we care about them- we cared till October 7th all the Kibbutzim members who got butchered- Palestinians paid them with kindness by you know how i guess..

[@terminationshock1356]

I guess you didn't get the point

[@raymondaloni2309]

So with that in mind lets talk about the ill will against us.

[@Flokiy]

I am Saudi, not Palestinian. How do you want me to talk to extremist people? There are people in their government who are not satisfied with occupying Palestinian lands. They also want Jordan, Lebanon and Syria, and this is what they are doing now. If you doubt what I am saying, go and look for the interview with Misael Smotrich on the French channel Arte and listen to what he said. During the war in Gaza, the president of their alleged state issued a statement from their holy book about killing Amalek, who in their view is the Palestinian people and the Arab peoples. After that, how do you want there to be peace? After all this, America arms these people with heavy bombs with which it fights armies to kill civilians. Do you consider these to be conditions that you would accept if there was a country next to you?

[@dontworry7127]

@@raymondaloni2309 no we never get the point. Its always the others who has listened the same guy. Its because we, the others, are living in a bubble. The others how the guy has mentioned.

[@ahmadabdelmawla5405]

I don't have info, but I think the cases of Israeli police protecting Palestenians just aren't worth making it to the news and social media

[@annan.3283]

Now this is the deep thought provoking question that we all want to know!

[@iunderscoream]

11:25 For a moment I thought the question was “Adam or yam?” 😂

[@teknomajik23]

Most of these people seem to live in an alternative reality: kzbin.info/www/bejne/o3eZc2iLi9qjr6M

[@idarogozin5009]

Again propaganda!

[@maxx_thedragondominator]

@@idarogozin5009is it really?

[@aaddaamm1100]

Why do you think that? I've been in the army and never saw settler violence. It really depends on the time and who is in power. The violence now is happening. No dout

[@teknomajik23]

@@aaddaamm1100 kzbin.info/www/bejne/nKmvdYyhjZyfb6M

[@aaddaamm1100]

@@idarogozin5009 instead of saying propaganda explain and answer the question, don't gaslight

[@ibrahimsued4906]

The army's prime mission is to protect the country and this doesn't include the Palesrtinians. Though there is a responsanbility with their security, of course, but that's not the prime mission or goal of the Tzahal. The soldiers also identify more with threatened israelis, like themselves.

[@eKoush]

The inherent racist ideology that they are living by is completely lost on them.

[@santiagodelpilar6701]

Thank you.

[@markusk9080]

Thank God the other side is very self-reflective and not driven by religious extremism and antisemitism at all.

[@santiagodelpilar6701]

@@markusk9080 Y are you gae?

[@thomasjosullivan9179]

I expect the racist element is part of it and Colonialism. Not forgetting the Apartheid system

[@Finduszip12]

Saying "inherent" is not smart when trying to point out racism...

[@Picosto]

The last two guys are reasonable people

[@maxx_thedragondominator]

2:38 the soldiers are literally right with the settlers when they harass Palestinians and force them off their land.

[@idarogozin5009]

Wrong! Keep watching Palestinen propaganda . I am not saying it never happens but there is more sides to every story

[@maxx_thedragondominator]

@@idarogozin5009 videos are worth a thousand IDF talking points

[@anastasiagriswoldthean4541]

You should ask Palestinians what is the name of the ruler of Palestine. ❤ And why they think Egypt and Jordon are not taking in refugees.

[@jramir2]

Why should Egypt and Jordan take them? Why dont we just move Israelis to Montana, and give the land to Arabs. That way, you are not ever threaten by Arabs, since you'll be in Montana, US. Why dont we just take you as a refugee?

[@matthiasdarrington3271]

The ruler of Palestine right now is money. Israel would be nothing if Daddy America wasn't sending billions every year.

[@matthiasdarrington3271]

Jordan and Egypt are puppet regimes of the West btw...

[@mathieufaltys]

These are the types of questions the Nazis asked in relation to the Jewish people and other European countries during WWII.

[@anastasiagriswoldthean4541]

@@mathieufaltys Do you have sources to back up your claims?

[@davidsonna9502]

Just like everything there, both sides are right. There are IDF who have completely ignored settler attacks. There are other times when they fully prosecuted settler crimes and gave them significant jail sentences.

[@Ttinytino1]

Maybe they should try seeing some KZbin videos instead of Israel TV...

[@grasmereguy5116]

It's almost like you think Israeli TV and other media aren't critical of the government and the hardline settlers. Have you ever watched Israeli TV?! FYI, they tend to be very harsh in their assesments. The reality is when Israeli civilians and Palestinian Arab civilians interact in certain areas of the West Bank, they *mostly* get along. But there are radical settlers, sometimes called "hilltop youth," who are a small percentage of the population at large, who are troublemakers. There have been well documented cases where they attacked Palestinian civilans and their properties and sometimes IDF does little or nothing. But it depends on circumstances, and the individual soldiers. Naturally, the inclination is to go softer from your group, but there have been cases where the radical settler youth harass IDF soldiers (because of their records, they usually won't get drafted) and they also end up getting beat-downs and arrested, like the last guy said. And there are lots of incidents of Arab terrorism and violence against Jews too. Sure, more should be done to protect civilians, but your'e never going to get perfection in such a situation fraught with turmoil.

[@Thenoobestgirl]

Maybe you should live a year in their shoes instead of relying on Al Jazeera propaganda

[@Mazarakis_Spyridon]

How can I send you questions to ask?

[@RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla]

Question: why people always target israel for security in west bank, what about the Palestinian authority security force? Why palestinian security forces can get away from their responsibility?

[@zeyadghanim8271]

Who's occupying the Westbank and therefore bears the responsibility especially in the area c?

[@DwynAgGaire]

Thanks Corey! It's always edifying to hear from real people. Kudos to you man.

[@HassanBurman]

full support to Israel from india, india loves Israel billions of Indians enlisted in IDF but were rejected more Israelis should live in India indis wants ultra Orthodox Jewish neighborhoods in India like in USA 🇮🇱🤝🇮🇳

[@theoutsider078]

they don't want you

[@rajm2626]

phull sapport saar endia isrel friendship india saport israael sir ji ❤❤❤🇳🇪🇳🇪🇳🇪

[@KhanRajasthani1111]

😂😂😂😂cavechild bastard

[@mathieufaltys]

Hindu nationalists and Zios are fasc1st buddies.

[@user37642]

I don’t think they believe what they’re saying

[@keepussafeUSA]

Jewish settlers that attack Palestinians unprovoked are often arrested and tried in a court. Now one must ask how many times they were provoked. And if they were acting in self defense.

[@teknomajik23]

You must be hallucinating kzbin.info/www/bejne/o3eZc2iLi9qjr6M

[@KimPhilby203]

Your really interesting

[@tobysmith2081]

this isnt true at all. and most of the time they aren't provoked. Source: actually follow these stories and listen to what the settlers are saying. they're proud of their crimes. they aren't provoked, that's just israel's answer to everything. eternal victims

[@thomasjosullivan9179]

@@tobysmith2081 I expect the Apartheid system and illegal occupation is the cause

[@AbdulelahAhmed-nu6zz]

I saw the IOF helping Jewish settlers in occupied Palestine

[@ronadar]

Didn't watch the video but I want to answer your question. As a previous soldier who served in the west bank for almost 9 months about 10 years ago I protected Palestinians with my own hands from settlers. Among the settlers communities there are the few fanatics ones who try to attack Palestinians and they are being dealt like outlaws. There is a problem to enforce the peace against them because on the paper they're Israeli civilians and it's not in the army position or ability to act against them as they act against the Arabs in the west bank.

[@YipManAOMA]

You should be ashamed of yourself for participating in recognized violations of international law.

[@labricola6993]

Khazaria Ashkenazi Europeans without no biological connection to the middle east

[@Carla39894]

Ask palestinians why doesn't the PA don't protect jews in the West Bank?

[@seuntimilehin3381]

Israel is the occupying force in the west bank

[@ThatOneCatto]

@@seuntimilehin3381 The PA has jurisdiction over 40% of the West Bank and Israel over the rest. Why then do Jews who venture into areas under PA rule like Qalqilya or Tukaram receive no protection from the PA which has a considerable police and security force?

[@youtubekeepscensoringme]

​@@ThatOneCattogreat response

[@youtubekeepscensoringme]

​@@seuntimilehin3381says who?

[@seuntimilehin3381]

@@ThatOneCatto The PA has no real jurisdiction. Tell me why the Idf had the power to go to Ramallah and shut down Al Jazeera for 45 days in a city that's supposed to be under the PA'S control? The idf doesn't respect the PA and they'll do whatever they want

[@gategi10]

very difficult question ??? a simple question . They are just in denial ...

[@gamer1X12]

Why would they protect people they perceive to be their mortal enemies? If the roles were reversed, Palestinian soldiers wouldnt be protecting them either. No occupying or combative force protects the progeny of its rival. Why bother asking this question, its so stupid.

[@brendondaniela.k.aloadedmi7384]

Would you invite a thief into your home/neighbourhood? That's what Palestinians have to put up with

[@yusefd7818]

It violates international law and is a form of state funded terrorism which israel has been perpetrating for decades, and is at the root of the conflict. That's why.

[@jeannetteroldan5119]

One, the people in the videos didn't view Palestinians as their mortal enemies but noted extremists on both sides as problematic. Two, when I lived in Jordan as a Christian, Jordanian police (Muslim) always guarded churches on important Christian holidays. Again there was no "mortal enemy" view just an understanding that ethnic and religious minorities can be easy targets for harassment. The police presence worked. No one bothered.

[@EnglishforFOOTBALLFANS]

Absolute drivel in the original comment. People liking the comment show the vile reality of Israeli consciousness. They smile and think it’s acceptable for settlers to land grab and attack Palestinian farmers. They support thousands of children being murdered. They openly support the persecution, restrictions and occupation so asking them to show some empathy to the persecuted and oppressed does not register with them because their warped reality feels that is is rightful.

[@zeyadghanim8271]

In egypt too all churches are protected by the police because theyre a minority which makes them in need of more protection ​@@jeannetteroldan5119