It Ends With Us- book review | Rabia Mughni | Colleen Hover

#itendswithus #rabiamughni #bookreview bookreview

[@sawerasuhail8346]

The way lily's mom told her "if Ryle really loves you he would never ask you to take him back in your life by himself." That is one of the most beautiful quote from a mother because sometime we think the person we love has gone away and not even he messages us or even try to ask for apology because he knows if he would do it will make us shatter into many pieces, he stays far from us for not to hurt us physically or mentally

[@zafirahnafrin1443]

These are my favourite lines..they just made a whole perspective shift for me. There is no such thing as bad people. We’re all just people who sometimes do bad things. ”No one is exclusively bad, nor is anyone exclusively good. Some are just forced to work harder at suppressing the bad.

[@mehakriaz1588]

Colleen Hoover usually writes very intimate stories, but I am turning 19, not that I like intimacy in books because it's not something that excites me at all, the kind of romance I like is more soulful which is highly available in urdu literature✨ Secondly Colleen Hoover is someone I am a huge fan of! 🌺 I read Maybe someday which again had intimacy, but every word was poured with emotion and I could feel every emotion that Ridge, the female protagonist and Ridge's girlfriend felt! It had it's own intricacies but I could feel it with so much clarity! I love Colleen, unlike other English writers, emotions doesn't get lost in her romances! Big fan of her! 🌺🌺🌺🕊️

[@amnaahmad3307]

Totally agree!!this book is only for mature minded, and 18+ people.

[@samiyakhan7134]

i started reading this book yesterday and finished it today....and just love it........and love the character of Lily for her brave and bold decisions........and the fact that Ryle accepted her decision of divorce because he knew he cant change himself and sometime in future he might behave wrongly with Liky in front of Emmy.....cant wait to read It starts with us....

[@noormeow5075]

The main theme that I picked up from this book is that .... One should accept the apology for not more than two times because then it becomes a valueless trend

[@laibaimtiaz5788]

the fact that Ryle was abusing Lily just because of her past was so wrong, he read through all of her personal letters and imagined that she still in contact with him but in actual she met Atlas after so much happened between Ryle and Lily .

[@Laiba_Husain]

Honestly, after reading this book my respect for urdu writers have reached sky.......I am 18 but found some scenes quite very uncomfortable ....and can't call it a love story as soul connection is what I found missing..🌸

[@taskeenanwar535]

The same happened to me i m feeling so proud of pakistani writers who without vulgarity portrait the story in a best way , and i couldn't love english novels as much as i have craze for urdu novels. .

[@Laiba_Husain]

@@taskeenanwar535 English novels can entertain mind but urdu novels reach the depth of the heart...❣

[@taskeenanwar535]

@@Laiba_Husain exactly that is what i m saying

[@haseebsharafat2405]

Can u plz recommend me some Urdu love story books or novels i will be thankful. From Afghanistan​@@Laiba_Husain

[@Laiba_Husain]

@@haseebsharafat2405 peer e kamil by Umera Ahmed jannat ke pattey- Nemrah Ahmed Haalim-Nemrah Ahmed Amarbail-Umera Ahmed ( I have only read these 2 writers and they are awesome)💛

[@curiousways7827]

This book is amazing..❤..I completed this book today.. Along with a good storyline, it has many insights about domestic abuse. By reading this book, I got to know Why women take back their abusive husbands and why they can't end up a relationship.This book totally answered my questions...I totally love it ❤

[@anwaarlight1043]

The story of Atlas and Lily is the best part of the book

[@Mano12-uq4uw]

But I love ryle and Lily more.

[@joohimurmu1585]

​@@Mano12-uq4uw me too

[@fariasaif9781]

It ends with us is one of the greatest book of our era but the whole story is so emotional and it also overwhelms you. I think it starts with us is a treat for readers who have read it ends with us. It is much lighter but also covering some child custody issues between lily and Ryle which is very important part. But lily and atlas getting together is the happiest ending lily deserves.

[@gm.8805]

greatest book? it’s mediocre at best, it’s terrible

[@newarsachin9302]

while i was reading this book.I fell in love with Lily...such a kind hearted girl she was♥️

[@syedanaba]

Well said ! Bht sahi kaha rabia aapne ...I'm 18+ and when i read this book i was distaurbed completely cz of those physical scenes written in the book..its toooo much ! For those of u who dont want to disturb their peace of minds dont read it pls even if u r an adult! My frnd asked me for the book i gave her but i never wanted her to read it and i stopped her from reading it so that her peace of mind doesn't get disturbed!

[@KakulBisariya]

Peace of mind? Literally...Read about sylvia plath someday, enough to fuck the mental peace

[@masoodabeera477]

I love Rabia being Rabia. Ngl, in this Pakistani media Rabia Mughni feels unreal. I ope she doesn't change!

[@barirasarfraz684]

Such an honest,real and authentic review 🙌

[@anwaarlight1043]

If you've read this You have to read it starts with us As well It is much more interesting

[@Manahil124]

I honestly loved this book❤️ I completed it in just 2 days , it’s so gripping and interesting that you don’t feel bored ♥️ totally recommend it if you are 20 plus , can’t wait to read “it start with us” 😊

[@fabihaider2618]

you handled the age limitation part very nicely and i totally agree w you at that point.I heard from tik tok about this book and honestly at first I started reading it read a few pages and leaved itbecause i could'nt connect I guess but when i've read it I love it the way the story flows the details, the descriptions, the quotes everything. And you are right sometimes we dont even know k hum kis tarah connect kar jaty jein kisi character sy the love I have for this book is unmatchable .When I first read it little did I know that If I could ever love a book this much. I don't know is book ko itna hate q milta hai I love it and is a definately must read recommendation to you from my side you are right rabia insan ka damagh khulta hai currently reading its sequel it starts w us.Its been pretty good so farr.Also love the content quality i am soooo happy k finally hamari country m b aisa content ban raha hai ab thank you for speaking up

[@teenboy616]

Here are some best movie which can learn so far about love, tamasha, love aajkal 2 jab we meet, milenge milenge, rockstar, love aajkal 2 ,chandni etc

[@rabiazulfiqar4042]

Just finished reading. It was a good read on many levels. The quote you mentioned was in this. It was towards the end. I always felt Ryle will be the abuser. He was a good man but a weak one from the start. Atlas on the other hand was a strong character. Zindagi Ki bhati mein Pak ker jo banta hai wohi sona banta hai. Lily's kind gesture came back to her at the end. One might face many struggles in life but your little good deeds come back saving you from its intensity. Waiting for another re view or recommendation.

[@Maham447]

I was always been on atlas's side and completely loved that book but when I go on TikTok for edits and saw little teen girls saying such things like ryle deserve better lilly was wrong coho is bad and I double check my reviews on this book I was so confused and lost but than I found ur review u say every word that I think about this book.... Yay!!! I'm grown up not a teen anymore

[@xyzstudent9332]

Ths book first seen in my Classroom hold by A girl.accrdng to U ma'am thank God we are in medical graduation college.I didn't read book but watched ths review vdo ,bcs of u, and ths done by U,Huge love nd respect frm 🇮🇳

[@zainab-qw6qx]

Rabia do you know I really cried on last chapter when her daughter was born when Ryle took in his hand lily I can see Ryle can do anything for her Daughter and second point she said first time I really saw tears in his eyes but in my point of view lily should gived last chance to Ryle

[@-nb5sk]

Lily gave him 3 chances! She made the right decision. If you read the sequel, you'll realize he didn't change. He couldn't. You must realize it's so much more harder for Lily,and people like her than us readers or any third person. Ps-Cherry on top-Atlas is amazing!

[@veer52]

Have any one read it starts with us

[@-nb5sk]

@@veer52 yes, I have

[@seekers8887]

Its second part It STARTS WITH US is so so good . I highly recommend it because in contrast to Ryle’s mindset you will find how gracefully Atlas handles the situations. The approach is very different and practical. Second sequel me objectionable content hai zaroor but it can be overlooked, i guess

[@zabby404]

I am sorry but i cant bring myself to stop thinking about how sometimes lily should have been more honest and open with ryle, how she hid stuff about atlas and about her journals, the phone number atlas left while he was there to meet her at ther shop right after atlas and ryle got into a fight, these are important things that i honestly think you should not hide from your significant other. ofcourse they are problematic things and i felt like ryle deserved to know from lily and not on his own. I still cant bring myself to really like lily but its also not like all she went through was deserve, not even ryle deserved to be unaware of the truths. i felt so confused, frustrated and angry while i was reading the book and i dont know how to feel about it anymore. I can not fully allow myself to support lily as she believes she never did anything wrong, but did she really not do anything wrong? even if she did do something wrong she didn't deserve to be hurt the way she did, but also ryle didn't deserve to be uncoverd and unknown of the truth but what he did was also something that can not be justified and forgiven. this book has got me so confused i cant even side with anyone.

[@samlimitless1739]

I think so past doesn’t matter when you move forward. If you’re a mature person and you love the person you’re with then you should accept their past and that doesn’t justify them to do worst in the name of love. Lilly had a complicated childhood and Atlas was an escape for her and he was someone who saved her. Ryle was unjustified because he knew Lilly’s past and he knew who Atlas was to Lilly. Lilly choose Ryle and she was with him and married him. So, he was a priority in her life and a person who’s as educated as Ryle and who has gone through his own Trauma. If that person claims love then he should have been able to accept her completely.

[@zabby404]

@@samlimitless1739 who said the past doesn't matter?? i mean ofcourse you should leave your past and move forward with your life for a bright future ahead but that doesn't mean you shouldn't let your partner be aware of the past you had and the fact that Lily still had feelings for Atlas and wasn't telling about it to Ryle HIDING infact from Ryle is toxic too(change my mind if you can🤷🏻‍♀️)ofc im not saying what Ryel did was completely right but every defending Lily is just to sad to see that people would still support the female even if she was in the wrong too...

[@Mahnoor1647]

I totally agree

[@nishatshaikh6418]

Because of the intimate scenes I stop reading the book and come to watch your video 😁 Thoug I am a married girls but still feels uncomfortable to read such intimate scenes

[@muskan.dp.]

Rabia api I'm 16 now but i read some comments they all pointed out that not to read this novel so I'm sorry i'll not read it after 18, without watching detailed explanation

[@sheisfictional]

I bought it last year but couldn’t read so i have just finished and go through this video so just commented... About the is just it is so so good that when i was reading i thought i m in that scene.... Such real scenarios and and was so much realistic this book was that everyone would be able to connect and relate.... Such a good book it is....obviously "every person with a heartbeat should read this book" ❤️

[@rabiazulfiqar4042]

Thank you for being you and letting adults know to keep a check on young ones. I would recommend a book for that age because I believe we must give kids some alternative. It's called Nisha's war. Excellent read for middle schoolers. I enjoyed that book with my son. And I haven't read it ends with us I think I would give it a go. Let's see. Will come back to your review then. Was waiting for some book review thanks again for sharing!

[@zainab-qw6qx]

It is my favorite book I have completed it in 2 day's

[@aestheticCreeps]

I'm still living in this book's life...I feel like lily, atlas, ryle and all characters are alive somewhere, living there lives😭😭😭😭

[@izohraahmad]

This is why I only read non-fiction books, they have a lot of intimate scenes which are not right for me even though I am 22 years old😅

[@misbahhassan3092]

You may try Nemrah Ahmed novels if you want to read fiction 🙂

[@mehakriaz1588]

If you don't read fiction, you are missing out on the most beautiful category

[@izohraahmad]

@@misbahhassan3092 I have read all Nemra's books🤩🤩

[@misbahhassan3092]

@@izohraahmad That is great👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾

[@NOT_ain]

You mean FICTIONAL books ! As they’ve got intimate scenes

[@mohiuddeen__]

It brings up the past trauma you don't even know you have within you. page 213; Atlas Corrigan: "When my life is good enough for you to be a part of it, I'll come find you. but i don't want you to wait around me because that might never happen"

[@sejalverma9775]

I had read both the book it ends & it starts both books are really grab you throughout .

[@Humyra..13]

Yes you should continue doing book reviews. Both urdu and English.

[@saadqasim6044]

Main NY abhi start hi ki h or apka review a gaya thanks my favourite person 😻♥️💋

[@ermonazmi151]

loved this....would love to see more reviews of english novels

[@teenboy616]

Really iam surprised here are so many muslim Lady, who had read this book, I hope more and more muslim girls get education and love their live beautifully and joyfully

[@WareeshaWajid88]

I have just finished reading "it ends with us" and now started "It starts with us." I somehow found it relatable tho.like seeing domestic abuse and then lily being stucked in a love triangle.the best part of the book other than the story was how she introduced all the main character in the story for examlpe atlas like instead of writing a whole chapter before starting the story of ryle and lily or introducing him and his story in her next book and wrote it in the form of diary. After that there is for sure some adult content but with a message like people are addicted to Wattpad content which is much more.here she is not glorifying marital rapes or domestic abuse. I loved the part where lily stood for her mother. she said no to giving chances again and again and set boundaries .in asian countries women have normalized comprising even if they are beaten everday. She chose to be single and independent .she tried her best not to be hard on herself or be like her mother and broke the generational trauma which she faced as a child just because of her parents and the best part when she gave birth to Emmy and her first few words were its ends with us emmy. i haven't finished reading but she took a step for her happiness her first love and decided to be happy to give love another chance and to stay with a man who knows her worth!✨

[@mehreenbabar4912]

While reading I felt from the start that Ryle was not my ideal character. There was something very off about him or maybe I am good with red flags😄.

[@muhammadadan2783]

Rabia you should review other books of Colleen Hoover.. I have read almost all her books and all are excellent and disparate with each other and yes are absolutely right men should read books to alter the wrong preconceived notions that have been fed to them by the time of their birth.

[@purbanshree]

I think teenagers should not read this book....i m 18 and read this book about a few days ago....and i was really disturbed alot.... everybody can't handle this much... this is an adult book like not in age but who are about to get married

[@hijabkhan4881]

Great review but one thing you should talk about atlas more i mean how graceful a man should be in situations even he know lily is dating someone else he still cares and respects her decision with so much grace ❤

[@accidentalcooldestiny]

Thankyou Rabia for speaking up!

[@fateesheikh7275]

Thank you soo much for your starting review it made me to change my decision to read it.Actually I was confused to read it or not then this comes in my mind that you review this book so that's why I came here so I come to know that this book is not suitable for me as I am of 16.

[@FUCHSIAMagazine]

#itendswithus...

[@ajwaasim7607]

Age appropriation is very important, but very much ignored these days. I myself found the content extremely bold, and knowing the fact that my younger cousins read it made me extremely uncomfortable.

[@ajwaasim7607]

Funny thing it was recommended to me by a 15 year old

[@syedatehreemmustafa6157]

Rabia, it’s lovely how you reviewed the book. Looking forward for more books reviews InshaAllah 💓

[@salinafarhan9154]

I just loved the idea of book review..I enjoyed all urdu book reviews and now iam jolting the name of this eng novel. Thanks for updating us..and do some review over JULUAQUINN books they are fantastic!

[@ambreenriaz9492]

Thank you so much Rabia for sharing good contents with us .....

[@youfnanadeem277]

I don't why but I like Ryle character and I just don't like why Arthur didn't mention Ryle POV because he has sad past 😢

[@anwaarlight1043]

My favorite line from this book is Cycles exist because they are excruciating to break Because it's so relevant for everyone in one way or the other

[@naqshhhsagar2265]

Ya u should revw the book. Ur styl of reading is just awwsmmm. 👍 i did nt read this book but in future may b i will. IN SHAA ALLAH

[@taliyaearish6110]

Ma ny nhi pirhe vi, likn ab pirhe hon zurur, INSHALLAH

[@khadijatariq7057]

I think it's good but not worth the hype also it starts with us is more good

[@daisyr2519]

As a muslim I don’t think even 18+ people should read such books.

[@UNQ_GAMER000]

bro i'm 15 😅

[@Naaz440]

Kya ye book aur iska 2nd part padhne se gunah milenga ?

[@Naaz440]

Aur ye bhi bataye please ke it's ends with us,it start with us ,pride and prejudice ( five parts), great Gatsby,wuthring heights,before the coffee gets gold ( three parts ) ye books bhi padh sakte hai kya ? Aur agar ye books buy kar liye toh un books ka kya karna chahiye?

[@Naaz440]

Please answer

[@talha9256]

​@@Naaz440parh lo

[@Aysh_khan_i]

I'm new subscriber. Your reviews on books is awesome . Please continue it❤ And the fact k ye book me ne parhi nhi but apki btai hui story mjhe 90% khud ki lgi he😂 bht Ziada relate kr rhi ye story meri life se...😂

[@tayyabariaz8636]

Such a nice review Rabia...very well explained❤ You are our fvrt for a reason (for many reasons😉)

[@zeynephala7176]

Apka bolne ka andaaz>33

[@functionalintegrativeheali8965]

Great review! I would love to hear you review the book ‘7 triggers to yes’. 🙏😊

[@amritapatel1941]

I'm 16 but i read it.

[@neelamsays]

A movie is also made on this..Just saw the trailer...and Blake lively is the lilly...

[@shapaa1022]

I didn't read it and didn't watch the movie. one of my friend suggested me this book and i told her I'll read after watching some reviews and here i am.. after Rabia's review I'm not gonna read this because i am not married even though i am an adult 22 years old woman but still I will say no to this book

[@Samk_0]

Heyy rabia pls review about “ the kite runner” pls pls its my favourite book

[@Reddit.stories287]

people got offended because i was defending Ryle but i can totally see he was not at all wrong but Yaa he should have handled himself better that night when he found about the tattoo and everything other than that he was a good guy man he did not wanted a relationship but he got all in for Lilly and later she got together with atlas really man

[@Halay111]

I am 14 i also want to read this book but i don’t know that this book is like that type so now I don’t think i am going to read this 😊 thanks for letting us know about that…. Main ap ki 4 saal baad review do gi aus ka😂😂

[@naemafirdowsmirzarafatbaig9415]

Plz suggest me urdu novels except nimra ahmad and umera ahmed becoz i already read it aese novel bataye jisme thriller , suspense , ho

[@rahilvahora7778]

Which book I should read first? It starts with us or it’s end with us frankly.

[@monikadewangan250]

Hey ..which book i should read firs? Please tell me

[@MehreenIqbal-n1g]

It ends with us

[@aafreenalam2607]

It ends with us

[@kashmalachandi363]

I have started the book. I am on page 31.

[@inked_star_9507]

I was team Atlas from the start. I didn't like Ryle tbh😂 Atlas is Atlas afterall😍

[@sadiarashid3261]

Assalam o Alaikum, rabia g ap umera ahmed pe b review kijiye ga.

[@seeratfatima5469]

Maala novel kab aha gah 😌 and this novel is fantastic

[@mishalsarfraz8483]

I have completed this novel last month . Now I am going with "Forty rules of love"

[@mariagohar6196]

Online kahan se search karon

[@Ayesha-nf7fs]

Rabia i really like your personality ❤️❤️

[@kashafabbasi6915]

Yes please do more book Reviews😍😍

[@Apocalypse055]

Please read 'A place for us' by Fatima Farheen Mirza. I'm sure you will love it.

[@AliAkbar-zg9vo]

Please review The Book Thief by Markus Zusak if you've read that, or read later anytime.

[@mahroshdilshad9353]

Assalamualaikum can u plz review Twisted series by ana haung❤ If its right or not to read

[@ssha1kh]

Have you read All your perfect by Colleen Hover. That’s one of my favorite from her

[@NoorFatima-dp6ow]

Rabia please share more reviews of the both Urdu and English books

[@sundastehreem6860]

This is the best and worst book I read at the same time. Initial chapters were absurd and nude but the motive and issue is worth reading.

[@barira219]

can you please suggest some books for growing age child

[@afluffybear1442]

Wow!! Wonderful review..mam please cover "it starts with us" review too

[@ayeshazubair7010]

Have u read verity? By collen hoover

[@misbahubaid7920]

Plz guide me about books for teenage ... my daughter loves reading.... I just know about the Urdu writers

[@tayyabariaz8636]

Wonder Is a decent read for any teenager....Your daughter would definitely enjoy it ❤ In Urdu literature, you can go for any book of Nimra Ahmed or Umera Ahmed.

[@accidentalcooldestiny]

Finally someone said it!!!

[@fatimanaeem3993]

Which lipgloss youre wearing? Youre looking so beautiful💖

[@SharmeenZariwala]

Can you review ayesha muzaffar’s books?

[@M.daily24]

Very honest review❤❤

[@Rollerjourney7578]

11 minutes Novel is also like this

[@IndianninUSA]

Great review, Rabia! You should definitely do this often. I would like to recommend you a couple of books, A thousand splendid sons and The Kite Runner, both by Khalid Husseini. I am pretty sure you will be in awe of his writing skills and the way he unfolds the climax in all of his stories. If you plan to read it, please review it as well🤎

[@AliAkbar-zg9vo]

"It'll tear at your heart" I read that on title of A thousand splendid suns" and wonder how come. And then I read THAT LADY walking to her execution spot & knew for first time what "it'll tear at your heart" really feels like . A splendid book in deed. ❤

[@tayyabariaz8636]

Khaled Husseini is, hands down ,one of the best writers....I've read both these books and HOW BEAUTIFULLY WRITTEN THEY ARE❤❤❤

[@MuhammadUmar-df4nb]

Have you read the sumera hameed nolels.....

[@WashmaShahid-zq5hx]

Is this book have vulgur scenes?

[@jfcreation7874]

Rabia ap waseem bdami ka bhi iterveiw kre na plz

[@AliMalik-n6z]

rabiaaa !!!! whyy aree you nott rewieing peerekamil..... i am waiting so longgg plzzzZ cmon i only read the books u approve !!!! also read milk and honey😊😊😊❤❤

[@eshuslifestyle3060]

So first we have to read it end with us?

[@Mano12-uq4uw]

Yes

[@QuranRevival2.0]

Lily was toxic af. Ryle really loved her but sometimes it’s better to get away from a healthy love too

[@Nasi.reviews]

1st comment 😍

[@omamazahra3129]

Yes ,pls review 'it starts with us 'as well .....plz

[@shahminahil9578]

Hello umama. How is salar?

[@RizwanKhan-bi4pm]

Kya ye urdu translate hui hai