"It's Like A SPOILT Child In The Corner!" - Security Expert On Pro-Hamas Encampments At Universities

Talk’s Alex Phillips is joined by security expert Will Geddes on how to tackle pro-Palestinian encampments at British universities.
Rishi Sunak has condemned “extremists at the National Union of Students (NUS)” who he says opposed the Union of Jewish Students’ (UJS) support for “the principle of a Jewish state”.
Ahead of a meeting with the UJS and Jewish charity the Community Security Trust (CST) to “listen and learn from their experiences” on Thursday, the Prime Minister warned of “students and academic staff being targeted, threatened, and assaulted simply for being Jewish”.
Click here for more from Talk talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
#hamas #palestine #israel #gaza

[@jamesmurphy4976]

The deans of the university's should get a letter to these students telling them that their places have been cancelled. Then they should be deported.

[@missk9950]

Lol even the white British kids?

[@jpw6893]

​@@missk9950lol....no, unfortunately we can't. Maybe 5 years in prison?

[@tomsharpe9988]

.....to Gaza.

[@kevinbillington9773]

The deans support it.

[@simchalebovitch6944]

​@@kevinbillington9773unfortunately.

[@WCGUK2024]

These students are the future of the UK shows how fucked our country is.

[@paulagolladay6713]

No - not everyone has forgotten about Oct 7, no not everyone has forgotten the hostages, no we are not going to give up on Israel, and I for one state - NEVER AGAIN, NEVER NEVER AGAIN - AM I ISRAEL - CHAI!!!

[@user-kc2xn3lu5k]

I agree!

[@Lee.Willcox]

Don't turn up to class, lose your place. Let someone that does want to learn have their place.

[@Madame702]

You don't understand Lee. Benjamin Netanyahu will not stop at "Rafah" he can't. Even if you takes out most the Palestinians in Gaza it was Iran that armed them. He is going to drag us into war with Iran. That will devastate the UK and America. And I know what you are thinking at that time your going protests it, but by then it will have been too late. You have stop him now Lee......

[@Madame702]

Your thinking, "no Valentina he won't go after Iran". Wrong Lee, he already has, Benjamin Netanyahu destroyed the Iranian consult in Syria violating International diplomatic immunity. He was trying to start a war.

[@hudsonbear5038]

@@Madame702 What has that got to do with the OP's comment????

[@Twiggs2562]

@@hudsonbear5038nothing …just stirring 🙄🙄🙄🙄

[@Twiggs2562]

I agree Lee. What a waste of good money .

[@wickertwm]

As an American I can't believe Sunak is suppose to be a Conservative. Britain needs a Conservative party where now it just has too Liberal parties fighting each other on the same subject.

[@sc3304]

Yep spot on - there's v little difference between the main parties- there used to be but all have drifted to the left over the past 25 years. What was considered centre left views 15 years years ago is now right wing!!

[@zoltan-zq3xe]

100% it's a joke, in the states you have real conservatives, good luck with Trump 2024.

[@Madame702]

No you don't understand what these protests are about. You must understand Benjamin Netanyahu isn't going stop at "Rafah" he can't. Because even if destroy much the Palestinians in Gaza it was Iran that armed them. He totally determined start war with Iran and drag America into it. Which means America will force to do a draft. Do you understand? You say will protest it, but by then it will to late.....

[@Madame702]

You have stand with the protestors now. Benjamin Netanyahu has to be stopped now before he drags all of us into war where you are dying on the sands of Saudi Arabia.

[@andyforbes5553]

I'm sorry, my Merrick'an cousin, but you have some stones talking about the state of British politics with that dumpster fire you have back in the U.S. of A. The MAGA party would be better suited to that crazy world of professional wrestling than politics. Trump and MTG, as a tag team, that would get the crowds in.

[@coldbreeze6344]

They wouldn't let a homeless person do that

[@SpadgerMcTeagle1]

"...sadly though they just scroll through Tiktok and get brainwashed." Alex, you just hit the nail right on the head

[@stephendoherty981]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡

[@SpadgerMcTeagle1]

@@stephendoherty981 7 - 0 genius

[@stephendoherty981]

@@SpadgerMcTeagle1 I think it's Spadger and his mates that are a bit brainwashed!

[@jamierenaut]

Whereas you just watch TalkTV and get brainwashed. 🙄

[@SpadgerMcTeagle1]

@@jamierenaut And pray, enlighten us, what prompted you to such elevated doctorines of nazi ideology, genius? Mein Kampf I assume?

[@UvruvTtu-ve5wo]

This lot would protest about fresh air

[@user-yo5sh5ec8i]

Never underestimate the gullibility of the average undergraduate….,,and Professor!!

[@MarkARhodie]

Thet have probably had this Woke victim/oppressor pushed on them thru school, by teachers

[@carolineowens1364]

Brilliant. If only MSM were as honest in their broadcasts.

[@jeananderson3008]

Alex Phillips you are GREAT, your octogenarian fan in Sydney, Australia. I hope our Universities in Australia are listening to you.

[@Andrew-wl2mt]

The kids are in charge of the asylum ,good luck everyone get out before the young ones realise and start stampeding towards the border,last one out lock the gate.

[@andyforbes5553]

If it was winter, there wouldn't be too many camping out. The vast majority of students don't want anything to do with these protesters.

[@stephendoherty981]

Most of the polling among students in these colleges gives app. two-thirds of students supporting the protesters. This info is online if you want to check it.

[@stephendoherty981]

Polling suggests you're wrong. 2/3rds of students, in general, approve of these protests. The info is online if you need to check it.

[@andyforbes5553]

@stephendoherty981 Oh well, then that must be all the students because it's on an app. Lmao.

[@hudsonbear5038]

@@stephendoherty981 Ooooooooooooooh heck and how often has a POLL been incorrect due to only a minority taking part?? Jeeez I am 100% sure you'd be say just the same as I did it the result was the other way...

[@IanRuben]

if you are getting paid up t0 $1000 a day to protest you would also go protest in the middle of the winter

[@jdias3784]

Alex you are always on top what ever you discuss.

[@stephendoherty981]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@sueharrison9392]

Employees need to consider what they will employ

[@sc3304]

Finally an interviewee who knows his stuff. It's been fairly obvious that these protests have been co-ord and financed by foreign powers, probably Iran, China. The timing of escalation, the level of organisation - it hasn't just sprung up organically. And no similar disruption in muslim countries - only democracies - so go figure who benefits from this

[@stephendoherty981]

Where your evidence of 'outside agitators' ?????? A classic rightist trope when things don't go your way!!😂😂😂

[@user-bw8mc1zx1h]

What a load of tosh... Where's you evidence or are you just spitting out of the same playbook as the Israeli terrorist force?

[@Mar11932]

​@stephendoherty981 Will Geddes is a security specialist, he knows more than you. The fact you're on this channel trolling, shows you've been indoctrinated, how sad for you. You're in the minority,

[@scootaymildo1070]

​@@Mar11932 can you point to one bit of evidence he provided to substantiate his claims?

[@kevinbillington9773]

​@@stephendoherty981youtube is a court of law now 😂😂😂😂

[@majikalbushe]

Freedom of speech does not mean freedom of action. Can these muppets not grasp the difference between actions and speech. Hint hint.... One is physical and one is verbal..... Say whatever you want but detrimental actions should have detrimental consequences, end of.

[@ralphhendrix6983]

Why? What's this meant to achieve? Sounds like they need to give those places to others who would love the opportunity.

[@brasstacks4801]

The worse thing you can do to attention seekers is to ignore them

[@user-ij1wg6nx8e]

Glad he said they are watching the agitators! Good to hear

[@jonathangoddard8133]

Just take a role call for all lectures - anyone not there in attendance needs to explain themselves

[@suzann2531]

Agitators is that the same ones they use to disrupt the indigenous people when either demonstrating or just celebrating St George’s day. They don’t appear to do it to the Palestinian demonstrations.

[@kevinbillington9773]

Correct, look at Patriot Front in the US. They are all left to march, no left wing groups protest them, they are arrested by police, posing for the press while remaining masked. Like Ray Epps agitating to go into the Capitol on Jan 5th and 6th, caught on video. He was put on the FBI wanted list, then two days later, miraculously removed. Chilean dictators/death squad leaders trained in the US by the CIA. Mujahadeen, supported by the US in Afghanistan against the Russians, morphed into Al Qaeda. Yet in Syria the US funded Al Nusra a Salafi Jihadist group to fight against Assad, aswell as funding ISIS to do the same. Don't worry other countries governments and security services do the same. All the citizens of the world are just collateral damage if they are the victims of the power play.

[@R-fi2je]

Hi Alex, You both are spot on, esp about the hostages! But please note that the term is Intifada, meaning rebellion. Other important terms are: Taqiyyah, which means feigning tolerance while secretly being more Islamist, & another one: Dawa, which means missionizing Islam. During the 2 Intifadas against Israelis, 1000 israelis & 64 foreigners were killed, with buses, sueprmarkets, pizzerias, etc blown up with youth suicide bombers, esp in Jerusalem.

[@jonathangoddard8133]

How many hostages are stiil alive, how many not violated, how many women not raped? The truth will come out.

[@Force9Gale-dt4rh]

Will Geddes , the voice of sanity.

[@mischamouse1502]

Follow the money! I'm sure the Houthis will offer to educate them in Yemen like they offered the US students.

[@stephendoherty981]

Follow AIPAC/Friends of Israel money too.

[@vjtm7061]

Alex Philips turning into one of my favorite newscasters

[@angelawallismoore2283]

Old Rishi is afraid for his own skin. He dare not upset the extremists in regional England.

[@user-vd1eq1xp2b]

Most common sense conversation i have heard all day. Keep speaking the truth as it is

[@kevinbillington9773]

And, of course, the UK establishment never uses agent provocateurs to go into a protest and stand on a high point and give a Roman salute, thus giving the press a photo op, to slur legitimate protesters as "far right"

[@fridaypeters8046]

So it is now justified.

[@brendafranks6519]

Well said!!!

[@robanderson473]

"So you've been to school for a year or two, you know you've seen it all..." Ahhh, Jello.

[@toofhuny8898]

Please all vote for Eden Golan, a very courageous young lady with an extremely emotive and good song. Hopefully her performance at Eurovision final will be as good, if not even better than her semi final one. Please stick two up at all the Pallywhackers and hateful protesters who have been disturbing all our streets for the past 7 months, from the day after the 7th October - shut them up by voting for Eden Golan.

[@AntonHoward-mx9sb]

Bring back the birch

[@pallasathena1369]

The students who don't want to be involved might be feeling intimidated.

[@jenniferbarry5887]

None of this lot would last a minute in Iran or anywhere else in the ME. Dubai for instance considered a moderate ME country only allows Imams in their mosques that have been vetted by state.

[@PerfidiousPuffin]

Agitators, like the ones who instigated Jan 6 then...

[@greeniejeannie]

And George Floyd.

[@iainrae6159]

Oh dear! Looks like not everyone got tickets for Glastonbury this year.

[@stephendoherty981]

You find genocide funny?

[@hudsonbear5038]

@@stephendoherty981 NO such thing as Genocide in GAZA... in the past 30 years there has been 20 REAL genocides and many still on going, ALL of them make Gaza look like a bar room brawl nothing more.... And lets not for get that the claim figure of gazan deathscomes from HAMAS who do NOT differentiate between civilian and fighters they are all classed in the same group.. so the 30000+ deaths also include 12-14000 fighters...

[@christophercooper4169]

Shirt sleeve steve

[@hudsonbear5038]

@@christophercooper4169 Bet a tail gunner too

[@hudsonbear5038]

@@stephendoherty981 NO such thing as Genocide in GAZA... in the past 30 years there has been 20 REAL genocides and many still on going, ALL of them make Gaza look like a bar room brawl nothing more.... And lets not for get that the claim figure of gazan deathscomes from HAMAS who do NOT differentiate between civilian and fighters they are all classed in the same group.. so the 30000+ deaths also include 12-14000 fighters...

[@stefansollberger5658]

There are no protests in Geneva Switzerland as well. I am proud of these people..

[@D...........33]

No, they support and very happy to do the bidding

[@RunningMan40510]

I thought that was James Hettfield.

[@JaniceDoe210]

I cannot wrap my head why people cannot see they hold Israeli government and Palestinian government to completely different standards ? As if Palestinians are children that should be let off their behaviour, views and intentions which they vocalise. It’s so strange. I would argue it’s because they feel ‘better’ and more ‘advanced’ than Palestinians and THAT is actually quite racist.

[@craiglyttle3419]

Just love Alex, she talks sense

[@stephendoherty981]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@elmifriends7319]

I really found listening to this discussion interesting. Not madly emotional, or not to upset discussions. I have dared to say in comments before and will again, stay with your own

[@InstaltechCarAudio]

Time to pack them off to the old people’s home 🏠

[@GKSC]

Have you ever closely watched someone when they talk out of both sides of their mouth?

[@missk9950]

I find the murders of innocent children and women and men heartbreaking

[@You.are.boring.me.now2024]

Murder requires intent, Israel have demonstrated by the lengths they go to to warn civilians that they lack that intent, people are dying and while tragic that is a consequence of war, a war that is happening as a direct result of the actions of HAMAS and their vow to repeat those actions time and time again, what *exactly* should Israel be doing to protect their own people from that very real threat? What did one M ibn Abdullah say about women and children dying during his raids? ****To the YT trust and safety team**** Before threatening account closure for the umpteenth time can you please check whether anything I have said is factually incorrect, not supported by Islamic sources or not a direct response to hateful and/or abusive comments by the person who reported me or the person who made the original comment , and it would be nice if you actually identified *exactly* what was supposedly hateful and why. Due to the preponderance of false flagging from a very specific group of people I will be wording my comments very carefully to avoid it, your “community guidelines” and willingness to appease are being weaponised to prevent any criticism of/response to the dishonest and often abhorrent views being expressed by some on your platform.

[@christinecraig7473]

Exactly! I'll ever forget watching the news on the 7th of October. Devastating, horrific.

[@ajones23809]

Disgusting behaviour.Considering the blood spilt on the Magna Carter to create it.

[@alberttickle1106]

Nice hair Alex.... ❤️❤️❤️

[@mumstheword8851]

The word is intifada not infitata

[@alexedwards6509]

National Socialists. Exactly It was the socialism that was national. AH was NOT a nationalist

[@zoltan-zq3xe]

He was a Bavarian Soviet in 1919 also a separatist.

[@sharronware5247]

I love Alex , she's so passionate about what is being discussed. I come from generations of strong women with a voice and I am disgusted that many young women around the world are captured by this hateful ideology .I'm so relieved there are so many of us that haven't gone insane.

[@lwwings]

Word to the female presenter. The word is intifada . . . NOT infitada.

[@Grumpytheman]

With the Keffyeh as their swastika, the Al-Futuwwa jugend in action making semi-god Abu Ali and great leader Hajj Amin Al-Husseini proud.

[@drorsil]

Tunnels are actually shelters so way they r so nany deads ?

[@erenkobrinsky3252]

They not children,in Israel every 18 years old already serving in the army. They are very dangerous adults.

[@maggiem.1539]

So!

[@padghd]

You still call childs and immigrants to WHOLE the world???? Wake up !!!!!!!

[@specialk2666]

A few billionaires playing games funding crazy

[@zoltan-zq3xe]

' One class has fulfilled its historical mission and is about to yeald to another! the bourqeasie has to yeald to the working class, whatever is about to fall shall be pushed, we are all soldiers of the revolution, we want workers victory, that is Socialism.'... Joseph Goebbels 1932

[@hirepgym6913]

Which Magna Carta ? the one in Fort Knox ? a copy was sent to every town in England .

[@imbonkers3629]

The one in the British library they are 4 remaining

[@hirepgym6913]

As for this Israel who at least two of its PM's were part of the Stern gang or this Palestine which only got a mention because of the Mohammed Amin al-Husseini was a Palestinian Arab nationalist and Muslim leader in Mandatory Palestine who just happens to have been captured in Berlin in 1945 supporting Hitler so why the hell is any Brit supporting either ?

[@hirepgym6913]

@@imbonkers3629 they should have looked after them better then 😆

[@user-ns8ug1pv5p]

Naive students being fooled

[@bblue6095]

Isreal supports the LGBTQ2S community.

[@lindahorn9644]

They are not Palestinian they are native Arabs there is no Palestine....

[@georgetoland3007]

Funny how dubai won take in there own animals 🤔

[@bblue6095]

Im not pro Palestinian protesters but why do they always have to drag trans rights into the conversation. Almost every discussion i watch about this they do this. It's very discrediting.

[@q1q1q1q1q1q1q1q11]

Is George Soros Iranian? I never knew that.

[@deanwalker972]

Im sorry to say this but them hostages aint alive no more which makes the whole thing worse.

[@user-hv7rq5zn3x]

You are tasting your own medicine…..how sad Britain has gone to Islamic culture 😢

[@deja-view1017]

Infant Ardour?

[@brigitpimm8488]

Infitada lol

[@vjtm7061]

You don't even know the definition of the word lol

[@hellothere3097]

Don't forget to trigger the spoilt brats a little bit more tonight by voting Israel in the Eurovision grandfinal. Vote up to 20 times. Lets get the haters triggered. 😂

[@alhawaritalbi6371]

The bottle blonde from Zion & her preferred cocktail called: Infitadha!

[@longriderxx]

?

[@missk9950]

Freedom of Speech

[@longriderxx]

Talks is one thing , intimidation is another !

[@tenerremzi9202]

This woman is so funny she reminds me of a benny hill character, hilarious.

[@user-vl8te2uo3r]

Spy stories 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@jake751]

🥱🥱🥱

[@elisabethdenhartog6574]

Infitada😅

[@mrror8933]

She meant a frittata

[@IanScout1]

Old Codgers eh…you need to watch your mouth.

[@You.are.boring.me.now2024]

Why ?

[@alisonharrison8042]

Intafada

[@beatricenilsson4530]

It is inTiFada ffs. How hard can it be when you hear it everywhere and you are a host on a big channel! 😂

[@scootaymildo1070]

Theyll just employ anyone at Talk TV won't they 🙈

[@longriderxx]

Phh , silly comments are my favourite x

[@scootaymildo1070]

Lot of claims being made by this guy. Not a whole lot of evidence though... Authority by posh voice it seems

[@HaroonNawaz-mz7oj]

Talk crap tv

[@anglaispourtous4079]

Please please stop. Tens, hundreds of thousands of people are dying right now. Stop this please. We need to save them or we are all complicit. Please stop this. It's gone too far now. Stop .

[@You.are.boring.me.now2024]

Gone too far? How far would have been far enough for you, how far in destroying the ability of HAMAS to carry out their openly voiced genuine genocidal intent against the Israeli people would have been acceptable to you? What exactly should Israel have done according to you? ****To the YT trust and safety team**** Before threatening account closure for the umpteenth time can you please check whether anything I have said is factually incorrect, not supported by Islamic sources or not a direct response to hateful and abusive comments by the person who reported me or the person who made the original comment , and it would be nice if you actually identified *exactly* what was supposedly hateful and why. Due to the preponderance of false flagging from a very specific group of people I will be wording my comments very carefully to avoid it, your “community guidelines” and willingness to appease are being weaponised to prevent any criticism of/response to the dishonest and often abhorrent views being expressed by some on your platform.

[@rosarose3443]

Are you complicit in Sudan?

[@anglaispourtous4079]

​@@rosarose3443Strawman.

[@hypnotics7886]

‘Pro-Hamas encampment’? I like Talk as a platform, but this is embarrassing tagline, and framing, whether it’s a quote or not. All it does it further dehumanise the Palestinian civilians. Shameful.

[@longriderxx]

I don't hear many of them dissagreeing with hamas !

[@fadialtaji3714]

Free Palestine from the river to the sea 🇵🇸 🇵🇸

[@DelUK72]

From the river to the sea Israel will be free.

[@thirstfortruth8904]

No such thing as Palestine. That is lsrael

[@fadialtaji3714]

@@thirstfortruth8904 You can say what you want...what is between you and me is the history that no one can deny..

[@You.are.boring.me.now2024]

@@fadialtaji3714 The history is that there is not and has never been an independent/autonomous country/state of "Palestine", you cannot simply wish one into existence.

[@fadialtaji3714]

@@You.are.boring.me.now2024 Palestine is one of the oldest countries in the world. Some cities, such as Jericho, are more than 8 thousand years old. Then Palestine was under Ottoman rule until 1914, like the rest of the countries in the Middle East, and when the British occupied it under the slogan of the British Mandate for Palestine... you cannot ignore that before they conquer... The door to immigration for the Zionists who came from Europe to escape the Nazis and established a state for themselves on our land and changed its name from Palestine to Israel... You can never ignore history, no matter what you say or justify... Palestine will return free

[@missk9950]

Talk talk is trash. This is a anti war protest. Not pro Hamas. Goodness sake.

[@JadeFromHolland]

Come on Brittain. Safe your country. Now is the time! 🙏🏼🩵

[@casscamden740]

thank god some truth & common sense

[@jostopps1319]

I find it extremely encouraging

[@pedrosanchezgonzalez8693]

Yeah were all that money come from and that kind of organisation ( radical Islam and hamas Iranian sponsored disinformation)

[@rmandel925]

Intifada love not infitada clueless bint