It’s Time for the Miami Marlins to Trade Everyone AGAIN

In this video, I give my ideas for another Miami Marlins fire sale.

[@tylermccann848]

Personally, I'd rather have Kiermaier in CF over Jazz. But that doesn't mean there isn't a spot for Jazz on the Jays... Actually Kiermaier isn't exactly known for his long stretches of being healthy either.

[@FriendlyNeighborhoodGentile]

Marlins got 2 rings , sure their lows are very low but the banners are permanent

[@CADClicker]

Their lows? You mean every other years since they've existed

[@HoshizakiYoshimasa]

​@lingering-dreadMiami is a major market though. And it's booming in population along with the rest of Florida.

[@YoSoyDeWehPamBeash]

People also forget the 2017 fire sale. Jose Fernandez death was really tough. We were so close to being a serious contender. That 2017-2018 fire sale was the last straw for me. We had the best outfield in MLB LF-Christian Yelich CF-Marcell Ozuna RF-Giancarlo Stanton I understand keeping Stanton was going to be expensive but when they traded Yelich (who went on the be MVP the very next year) and then Ozuna too, I was pissed. Oh by the way we had J.T. Realmuto behind the plate. Yup let him go too. Should have built the new stadium in Broward County, keeping the team as the Florida Marlins and had a big draw from fans in Palm Beach County too. Look at the success the Florida Panthers are having now. Marlins Park could have been next to them.

[@mikejanacone8328]

Don’t forget they had Yelich Ozuna Stanton then Bruce Sherman and Derek Jeter bought the Marlins. They had that fire sale don’t forget about thatone.

[@ACT1ONJAXS0N]

I’d trade everyone you said yourself except Arraez, I’d Build around him, Alcantara, Burger, De La Cruz, Sanchez, and Perez then get a haul for Scott, Luzardo, Bell, Anderson. Then I’d give Xavier Edwards a chance to play.

[@mattmoore20]

As a marlins fan, I dig all these moves. But like u said they are only great moves if they sign them all early

[@rhyde]

!

[@ballinwitac6090]

I'll also point out with the Tim Anderson going to the Dodgers I honestly don't think if would about "getting a natural shortstop more so they have gotten literaly nothing from Gavin Lux so far so Tim Anderson would be a nice bat as long as the OBP is there to put at the back end of the lineup because I would envision him scoring with the top six the Dodgers. I also think LA could be in the mood for a starting pitcher at the deadline. As good as Tyler Glasgow and Walker Buhler are and could be Glasgow I don't think has thrown 100 innings in quite some time and Walker Buehler hasn't pitched in 2 years. James Paxton has faced the 6th most full counts coming into his last start so his numbers could down. Clayton Kershaw lets face it hasn't been the best postseason starter. I'm just saying there is still the posibilly on what happened last year with them obviously if their all healthly the pitching is fine but there is that possibly

[@BoondockBrony]

Right, I see the Marlins as stuck with Anderson since I think even if he did bounce back to a degree his attitude might put off teams. Regardless if someone did bite for him they would want someone else as well

[@XheatliferX]

When the last 3 owners don't want to pay a dime for anyone and really don't care for the fans, this is what you have. They spent 5 mil in free agency this year 5 mil.

[@bezllama3325]

Big overpay for Jazz

[@rhyde]

I disagree. He has multiple years of control after this season, and he’s an excellent talent when healthy. His value would be much higher if health was on his side.

[@zachattack245]

The Marlins get everything they deserve for trying to screw over Kim Ng.

[@reicestark7867]

Maybe she should’ve built a better team and farm system 🤷‍♂️

[@GeraldM_inNC]

Derek Jeter quit because they broke their promise to him to spend more money.

[@zachattack245]

@@reicestark7867 rofl she built a whole playoff team as well as developed some really good pitching prospects in an organization that is notorious for bad and cheap player development. But yeah man you’re right, she should’ve done better

[@nathanhansen1846]

Only issue I have with the Jazz trade is who is the face of the franchise if Jazz is gone? Is it Alcantara? I think someone who plays everyday is better to promote than a starter is.

[@JacksonLane02]

They could but kinda feel like I they do it's gonna be the ones like a year or 3 near free agency. If they do then we all might be dead by the time Marlins make it to the postseason again

[@CoryKeepers]

Not many ways to make the marlins worse but alek manoah would do it

[@rhyde]

I am pretty sure people said the exact same thing when they traded for Jesus Luzardo

[@SomeChink]

honest question why do people still show up to Marlins games? they just do this time and time again

[@BrianSchaffer]

They have made the playoffs 4 times in 31 seasons. None of them division championships. But somehow have two championships…

[@lakerskid2013]

Only 8 winning seasons as well for their history which would be worse than the Colorado Rockies without those titles.

[@ernestop7454]

Man hate being fan of this team

[@bryangonzalez4604]

Same

[@penguinfan774]

Chisholm would fit perfect on the jays if healthy and performing to his potential, but I think he needs to prove he can be healthy first

[@rhyde]

fair!

[@FriendlyNeighborhoodGentile]

Overrated and overhyped ? Perfect blue jay fit

[@penguinfan774]

@@FriendlyNeighborhoodGentile Like I said he has to prove he can be healthy and perform over 162. He is a power lefty bat with great speed, all of which the jays need

[@omegasenpaiz]

The Dodgers should all over on Jazz Chisholm Jr

[@resmarted]

​@@penguinfan774 Jazz Chisolm's potential is a 3 WAR season.

[@christophercampbell2929]

If the Dodgers wanted Tim Anderson, they would have signed him.

[@BoondockBrony]

Exactly plus even if they wanted Tanner Scott along with Anderson, he would get the treatment Jean Segura got when the Marlins traded him for Josh Bell. Immediate release.

[@User-b9q2z]

No

[@rashiroselin]

I'm sure the Marlins would love to find a way to get out from under Avisail Garcia's contract even if it means getting fewer prospects.

[@graysonbuza1074]

They'd have to pair a prospect along with Garcia to get rid of him imo

[@BoondockBrony]

@@graysonbuza1074 Yep or retain at least half the money therefore dumping him pointless.

[@dereklee8103]

Hes a free agent after next season. Not worth losing on prospects. It sucks but suck it up for one more year, maximize your trade assets you do have, and come back stronger in 2026

[@DSu77iViN]

You’re disappointing me , “Giraffe Neck Robbie” Luzardo to The Yankees? What happened to your potential deal to Boston ?!

[@DSu77iViN]

Jazz is a bum

[@MarlinsBaseball]

Fire Sales have been a pastime here in Miami...I feel there's a need for another one...as much as it pains me to say that with how the season has been going. Thank you Robbie for this video.

[@Godzillajeff]

That is one ugly, tacky stadium.

[@TheRaginCajun6]

They just need to trade Jazz Chisholm and get rid of Gordon, and Anderson. All three are toxic. Chisholm broke the locker room code when we talked about Miguel Rojas

[@MRGREENPROP561]

So just get rid of all the black players that's what you're saying

[@TheRaginCajun6]

​@@MRGREENPROP561 Chisholm is Bahamian and I didn't mention Bell who has a 16.5 million dollar salary. What's different from last year? I'll wait.

[@ContrastWithSepiaPrince]

​​@TheRaginCajun6 Bahamian is a nationality meaning where one has legal citizenship. Since the topic was brought up, the Bahamian populace is 90 percent Black

[@papotuto74gr59]

It’s time for MLB to stop being ass holes. Take the team and find a billionaire that can spend money just for the love of the game. Another failure from MLB owners to approve the sale to another cheap millionaire. That’s my opinion

[@fredmehr-sx2kg]

A local Jorge Mas tried and got as far as sending his business plan for the franchise to MLB when they were up for sale and his plan was to pay the players and keep the team together and buy some relief pitching but the commissioner loved sucking on Jeters knob so that ownership group got the team, like Jeter was going to spend the money he amassed as a player on other players, he invested 25mil in the purchase and his salary was 5mil a year so he could get his money back in 5yrs while being in control of operations without any experience, not one player he drafted did anything and they were all for the most part very early picks except for 2018 and all the players he traded neted them really only Sandy Alcantara. Jeter is one of the greatest players ever but had no business being in charge of the franchise. Google Jorge Mas to buy marlins

[@jayp.6166]

Orelvis Martinez is NOT going anywhere. We got torched by trading Gabby Moreno (such a dumb trade), I can't see us parting with our #1 position player prospect again, this soon.

[@zcorpalpha2462]

Interesting

[@timmyturnt]

Arraez just got traded to Padres, you called it mate

[@rhyde]

❤️

[@MikeHunt-fx9rg]

Bring back the teal while we’re at it too

[@Therealtre]

I’m a Phillies fan. But it’s beyond me how the marlins have these great players but still manage to underachieve and trade everyone. I get their ownership is cheap but you should not always mess up this bad

[@necyad]

Arraez to the mariners please, Polanco can shift and play 3B

[@jonathonedwardmiller]

I think in this firesale the Marlins need to get more Top 100 Prospect bats. I'd do DeVries and Head instead of Lesko. Arias, Martinez, Head, DeVries gives you a stronger lineup to build around. Draft a couple outfielders and you're set. And you still have Perez, Alcantara, BOTH Meyers, Hampton and White.

[@DerekDominoes]

You'd do it but the Padres wouldn't. In fact, I doubt the Padres would do the deal that Robbie is proposing.

[@Th3DarkCanuck]

I'd love the Jays get Jazz but that's a big ask..

[@buzzsaw755]

This team is a permanent dumpster fire!!

[@rhyde]

🔥🔥🔥

[@LongNguyen-ho9qf]

no way yanks trade Lombard your insane

[@Jessiedunaway27]

Kind of crazy how much potential has went through the Marlins to another destination, they just can’t get it to together and even as someone who’s not a fan of the Marlins it’s so disappointing to see Marlins misuse key pieces!

[@brandontong759]

Very disappointed as a Rays fan

[@jayfelsberg1931]

No way LA sends a package like that for Tim Anderson. Get real

[@jayfelsberg1931]

Ditto Toronto

[@rhyde]

It’s Tim Anderson and Tanner Scott. Show me what you think a better trade would be.

[@HeIsHim00]

A Red Sox fan talking as if it didn’t take y’all 80 years to win.

[@BigPat216]

The upper management for this team is so bad. They go through so many front office reboots. It seems like every time they make the playoffs, it seems like a fluke, and ownership starts firing people and they don’t build on the roster.

[@CadeNeidhamer]

As a Marlins fan I’m actually on board with this😂

[@MarlinsBaseball]

Sadly I agree.

[@bryangonzalez4604]

Me too and we may need to rebuild and trade all of our best players for good hitting prospects and do what the O’s did

[@emiliob12]

As a Blue Jays fan Martinez is going to be really good, but he still needs time to develop so I’ll take Jazz for him for sure.

[@lachlaneberle2889]

I feel like Atlanta would be in play for jazz if he became available.

[@rhyde]

😮‍💨

[@razkable]

Anual event here

[@Ahn930]

Im from la and i feel so bad for marlins. They always have to blow up their team that becomes champions on other teams or they end up being great players. So much to list and not enough space.

[@bryangonzalez4604]

Yep it’s a repeated cycle

[@GeeEm1313]

The Marlins could use Cole Irvin. Irvin and Norby for Luzardo? lol

[@nathanhansen1846]

No. But it’s a start

[@nathanhansen1846]

What id do 1) DFa Garcia/Tim Anderson and eat the $30 Million 2) Option Soriano and Nardi 3) Trade Luzardo, Scott, and Arraez 4) Extend Jazz and Burger 5) renegotiate a deal with Skip Schumacher for 2025-2027. He has proven he is worth the money

[@rhyde]

Looks good to me!

[@nickfernandez7358]

That would make too much sense, they'll trade Arraez, Burger, Jazz, and probably another starter in addition to Luzardo. All for a bunch of prospects that never pan out

[@nathanhansen1846]

@@nickfernandez7358 they won’t trade everyone. That won’t happen

[@bryangonzalez4604]

@@nathanhansen1846it might

[@bryangonzalez4604]

@@nickfernandez7358you never know look at the O’s and Royals

[@NickAlbano253]

I think Jesus Luzardo is pretty overrated. I watched him pitch recently, and I’m not going to judge him on one start, but his stuff just doesn’t blow me away.

[@papotuto74gr59]

Trade luzardo to The Orioles They have the best players

[@rhyde]

What a nasty rotation that would be

[@gregdiamond6023]

Last fire sale? I highly doubt it but for now, let’s deal with this one. Robbie, you don’t think AA can talk them into dealing Luzardo to the Braves? I think AA will try to get by within the farm til the deadline but I digress. Your trades make sense and hopefully enough prospects will pan out. Time for a full rebuild for the fish. Why didn’t you have them trading Jake Burger? Let’s blow this roster up! He could bring back some nice prospects. It’s unconventional but let’s let another team hire Skip Shomaker. They’ve already voided oh is 25 club option so this is his last year. He should never worth a draft pick or 2. The Cardinals would be a greàt fit.

[@joseph2707]

You guys have no idea what you're talking about. Jazz, Arraez, Bell, Berger and certain pitchers need to stay. Avi played great yesterday. Skip is a great Manager. We should have kept Soler and Berti. That's where we messed up.

[@snerdterguson]

Marlins get: shortstop Oswald Peraza, outfielder Everson Pereira and catcher Agustin Ramirez Yankees get: second baseman Luis Arraez. Trade SIM has the total value going to Miami at 29.7 and them getting 30.7. Forget Luzardo, he hasn't performed well enough to be remotely close to worth what you're suggesting. And the starting pitching hasn't really been an issue. Everyone in the rotation right now is pitching better than Luzardo. And the upgrade from Gleyber to Arraez is substantial, will help the team more than getting Luzardo and would cost WAY less. Now if at the deadline, Cole still isn't back or he's not the same guy... Then maybe swing a deal for a pitcher. But I would go for a more proven guy than someone with a mid 4 career ERA and a current ERA over 7. Not sure how that eases any "problem" at the top of the rotation. I mean, Rodon has a sub 2 ERA, Stroman had literally one bad inning so far this year and Cole is back in a month or so... Meanwhile, the team is third in team ERA, second in Batting Average Against and ninth in WHIP... And they have the best record in baseball... So I don't see what the problem is really.

[@thebaseballnerd4570]

Ownership: what’s this success, money playoffs this feels good. Wait we have to spend money to keep this going sell everyone

[@geraldkelman9268]

Arraez and Chisholm to the Jays for Manoah , Francis , and 3 or 4 minor leaguers ( excluding Tiedeman ) for a blockbuster trade.

[@michaelplowman8674]

As you can't really have too much pen pitching, Scoot to my Cubs for Matt Mervis (Crushing it in AAA and no home in Chicago), Mastrobouni (young utility player with lots of control left), and Porter Hodge. That's the #13 and #27 prospects from the Cubs along with a controllable utility player.

[@BoondockBrony]

I don't think Tim Anderson has much appeal anymore. If he gets traded along with Tanner Scott I have a hunch Anderson will be on thin ice if anybody bites and gets released pretty soon if not immediately after the trade.

[@deanbarrett-p7v]

Marlins management is a joke. This team is a farm team for the entire league. Poorest run organization in all of sports. Yup, the entire world!

[@jonathonedwardmiller]

Why? How many firesales does it take to field a competitive team? What it's time for is the MLB to force an ownership sale again.

[@wesleysteeleiv]

If only Derek Jeter was still in charge of the NY Yankees farm system in Miami. He could get these guys sent to the major league team in a heartbeat just like Stanton.

[@LaMonteWade31]

I think Arraez would be an absolute Necessity for the giants. Maybe Bryce Eldridge in return

[@johngittings4673]

The Marlins had a terrific season by their standards last year but it was very clear that they overachieved. Phillies proved that in the playoffs when they made quick work of them. Marlins basically have come back to earth this year.

[@texasjesus23]

As a Ranger fan, we don’t need Bell….

[@rhyde]

I’m more thinking in terms of if Jung ends up having more issues with his wrist

[@kyleravensbergen385]

Id be interested in jazz but not for orelvis hes pretty much mlb ready and were gonna need another stud in case we lose one of vlad and bo to free agency

[@omegasenpaiz]

Jazz Chisholm would be perfect fit for the Dodgers

[@basedandredpilled88]

Marlins should go back to their old jerseys.

[@vpolite1]

Who cares? The Marlins are just a minor league team.

[@rhyde]

Because they have good players that can help other teams. What?

[@vpolite1]

@rhyde So, the Marlins should just fold and become a minor league team. Makes sense. The Oakland As are the same way. Independent Minor League AAA teams. Kinda like the GLeague in the NBA. Makes sense. Easier scheduling.

[@BigPat216]

Just trade Trevor Rodgers to the Giants already so they can have then Trodgers Trio!

[@heatwave1789]

Another marlins Firesale. You seen one or two you seen them all. Not surprised. Sad cause the team should be so much better but nope cheap owners bad deals and the works... coukd be worse. Look at the angels 😅

[@lakerskid2013]

The Marlins being the Marlins as always, they can’t ever build anything to save their lives. Besides their 2 World Series titles they’ve only made the playoffs 2 other times, so 4 times altogether in their 31 years of existence and have no division titles alongside only 8 winning seasons. If it wasn’t for those championships in their early years they’d have a worse history than even the Rockies.

[@tonybob2853]

This video aged well

[@zcorpalpha2462]

Idea 💡 Marlins trade Baltimore for Jackson Holiday 🔥🥃 Yea Note 📝: Coach of the 2003 Marlins lived in our neighborhood Everyone thought he was awesome 😎 World Series Champion Trophy 🏆 was on display at the High School 🏫

[@nathanhansen1846]

I’m a marlins fan. I think Bendix is a scapegoat and no matter who the GM or Manager is, this team isn’t going anywhere until Bruce Sherman 1) Sells the team 2) spends money

[@MM33003]

*Until Marlins fans show up to the ball games and actually show some interest in their team.

[@nathanhansen1846]

@@MM33003 not our fault this team sucks

[@FeiLi-i9z]

@@nathanhansen1846 like fans showed up when they were winning?

[@nathanhansen1846]

@@FeiLi-i9z they did

[@lexiescalderon5639]

Bro who is gonna show up to watch a team that’s 3-14 and last year they didn’t show up, that’s fair but why would they when an off-season later the team is already looking like it’s gonna be dismantled again

[@captainspartan04]

I know we need pitching but jazz but was always supposed to be an Atlanta Brave

[@BobbEditz]

Imo, I believe they should keep jazz Chisholm jr to be a leader of their future team. But the rest of the trades look good to me. Maybe the Braves could try to get Luzardo from the marlins but I don’t know how open they would be to trade within the division. Good video.

[@richardroy3699]

Honestly, f*** them for firing the Asian lady and super f**k them for not paying Arraez.