"It Was" in SPANISH - FUE ERA ESTABA ESTUVO - Simple Shortcut Lesson

[@MB-uy2ne]

I always struggled when to use fue, era, estaba and estuvo. Now I stumbled across your channel and you made it so easy to understand. The fun thing is I am German! 😀 Muchísimas gracias!

[@leenobody3249]

It is wonderful when you finally start to ‘feel’ the correct way to say things 😀 Thanks

[@RR-et6zp]

start thinking

[@leenobody3249]

@@RR-et6zpwill it make me a genius like you ?

[@RR-et6zp]

@@leenobody3249 read my previous comment

[@sxribblez5873]

Exactly 💯💪

[@t-rob2943]

Wow! I looked at seemingly 10+ videos trying to understand the differences in these Spanish “was” verbs. This was (estaba) the best and most effective video to watch on this subject.

[@normansidey5258]

I have spent a straight 288 days on Duolingo, and whilst I can read and write some Spanish, I can’t speak, or understand spoken Spanish, however just watching a couple of theses videos I have more confidence in speaking albeit just a couple of phrases. Subscribed and will enrol for the course, start again as a beginner.

[@mannyy266]

It takes practice, time and immersion.

[@Julian-mc2lk]

Duolingo won't get you very far. Spainish Input learning & more demanding online lessons will.

[@unclepoutdoors2420]

"was" in spanish used to be a nightmare for me but it makes sense after a while, these vids are great👍

[@Westhamsterdam]

Don´t forget "hubo" as well!

[@johntrojan9653]

@@Westhamsterdam True enough ! "OUCH" 😱 !

[@tromboneJTS]

Funny that you use "was" and "used to be" in the same sentence.

[@kigaluramadhan4265]

Gracias por tu ayuda

[@sifugurusensei]

Write that in spanish

[@ericbaugher]

One of the interesting things about learning a new language is learning a new way of thinking. This video teaches five different words in Spanish that all get translated into "was" in my native English. There is an old saying in American English that the Eskimo has over 100 words for snow and they all mean something different. So learning Spanish teaches us new ways of thinking about the past. Great and for me at least it "was" a much thought provoking video.

[@LEGIONARIO1970]

That's why some say that speaking a second language is like having a second soul, definitively a language tells a lot about people's idiosyncrasy, in that sense English is a more practical and pragmatic language than Spanish just like the people who speak it. Greetings from Mexico to all Spanish learners.

[@LEGIONARIO1970]

@@UserName-kh9rh It is, he has Spanish accent and he pronounces Z and C like the Spanish do.

[@johnclark3697]

Yep similar to SOBRE, ABOVE ABOUT & ENVELOPE.🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@mosesstrange9753]

Inuit*

[@howardplotkin871]

If the question is asked: como fue la fiesta? The questioner is generally asking for a short description of the party such as , it was great,it was bad. If the question is asked: como era la fiesta? The questioner is asking for a great deal more information such as how was the food, who attended, how was the music, etc. both era and fue may be used depending on the amount of detail the questioner wants.

[@lehaim37]

Como español debo decir q tu respuesta es basante precisa amigo!

[@lianavercammen3524]

y por qué no La fiesta estuve fenomenal...El espéctaculo estuve fenomenal????

[@andym28]

Knowing Spanish well either way they would respond Bien.

[@howardplotkin871]

Liana Vercammen an online Spanish teacher does precisely what you are asking about. Conversely I asked her what about fue or era and I did not get a satisfactory response. This topic causes a great deal of confusion.

[@atttalvarez]

I’m a native Spanish speaker and the sentence “¿cómo fue la fiesta?” sounds very strange to my ear. I would say “¿cómo estuvo la fiesta?” or “¿qué tal estuvo la fiesta?” If I used the construction “cómo era la fiesta” is because I’m probably telling a dream I just had related to a party or a get -together, and somebody asked me “¿como era la fiesta?” specifying how was the party in my dream. Only in that context this sentence can sound natural.

[@elviajerosediento]

Thanks buddy. This really helps. I was going crazy with WAS all the time. This video has made it so much more clear for me now. I think it's always beneficial when an English speaker breaks down a foreign language. Much appreciated !

[@jaybird8748]

I owe you a beer man. Sincerely, thank you for sharing this knowledge. I thought I was going crazy with this subject.. you untangled a huge knot for me in just a few minutes. I am impressed. Thank you!!

[@klasmova2771]

exactly! every other youtuber has this stupid way to remember it but him putting it in the exact basics made me understand what I couldn't for over a year.

[@brebrown5338]

It’s crazy how “was” is such a hard concept in Spanish. It’s the whole reason I gave up the first time I tried to learn Spanish. Great video.

[@kellycheney6367]

These videos are to the point and informative. No extras. Great! I go back time and time again until I really "get" it. Gracias por lo bien trabajo. Era interesante. Kelly

[@repa49]

La lección de hoy fue amena...

[@jodo6329]

Eres una ángel

[@sukhveerdhillon5016]

Your lesson is very educational. Thank you for your efforts and educating the community.

[@craigward9279]

Thanks for the video, I have seen multiple videos on this subject but you made it so simple and clear - I feel I finally understand!

[@almor2445]

He leido sobre etse tema muchas veces y este es el mejor instruccion

[@goingforward]

Excellent video. Concise, useful and unforgetable

[@cristinaravet3706]

Fue: pretérito perfecto simple (Finished time on the past) Era: pretérito imperfecto (unfinished time in the past)

[@naeimabhalim2643]

eres absolutamente un gran maestro. 🔥

[@symer1]

Genial siempre muchas gracias, lo haces mucho mas facil a entender.

[@cristinaravet3706]

Ser: indicates a long duration in time (or permanent). "Yo soy español" Estar: indicates a short duración un time. "Yo estoy enfermo"

[@gbaca07]

eres un excelente maestro. Muchas gracias por todo lo que haces.

[@caspe2073]

Excellent explanations ! I have struggled with this for years.

[@mehboobyaqoob473]

Sir please do a video on difference between use of .. "PUDE, PODIA and PODRIA " difference

[@millardkeyes5187]

let me guess from the sub continent or who else will be SIR ing everywhere to everyone! What a servant like attitude the British taught....

[@semperfiarcher]

@@millardkeyes5187 That's how we respectfully address teachers in my continent as well.

[@arnietwo11]

Mehboob, i think you already know ?? Its just the same as todays lesson, Puedo, present, i can Podria, conditional, i could Podia, imperfect, i used to be able. Pude, preterito, is used in more a negative form, when at that time you couldnt do it. Like, a noche no pude hacerlo !!

[@mehboobyaqoob473]

@@arnietwo11 Unfortunately i don't know. I watched a video but could understand properly, because that was in spanish and i am tryo in listening. By the thanks foe helpful comment bro ☺

[@davidbell6636]

Do regular folks really make these distinctions in everyday conversations.?

[@mehboobyaqoob473]

Liked before watching... I know its gonna be amazing help for all of spanish learner. Thanks for making this video Sir ☺☺☺🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@semperfiarcher]

Ameno! :-)

[@johnshort5003]

It's going to be an amazing help for all Spanish learners.

[@semperfiarcher]

@@johnshort5003 John Short :-D (Sorry, I couldn't resist!)

[@lynfitzpatrick1435]

Bien hecho, Sr. Por fin, entiendo!

[@Gaibreel]

This is really helpful as I'm learning past tenses now. This saved my life.

[@allan.valerion]

@learn Spanish Well,I don't know for others, but for me you are the best organized Spanish teacher I have met and your content is super helpful and interesting and I have recently completed your prospanish 1-6!!!..So,how would one ask in Spanish, "How was your day today??"

[@LearnSpanishLearnSpanish]

Thanks for the generous feedback. The most common way would be "Qué tal tu día? " leaving out the was completely.

[@robbrown8483]

My translator likes. “Cómo te ha ido el dÍa hoy?”

[@randonneenepal2533]

Thanks to Learn Sapnish! I am beginner and it is being very helpful with your youtube!!! Gracias

[@amorodauda6875]

Thank you very much for this lesson.

[@BestNewDirector]

Really glad to have you back, it’s been a while since you made videos and I remember feeling a little sad when you went mia for a while. Could this be one of the benefits of lockdown? I find your method of teaching to be one of the best of everything I’ve tried...and I’ve tried many things.

[@getsugatenshou1879]

Thank you so much for this explaination

[@isaacandmary]

Otra leccion muy util. Una palabra en Ingles, 'was'. Cuatro palabras en Espanol!! Muy dificil. Gracias por tu ayuda.

[@theworldaccordingtoallie1176]

I love your lessons!

[@vladanraz6081]

perfect way of describing something which i had a problem with ... not anymore. Thank you.

[@krishnashrestha9539]

Very helpful and informative

[@luisamontanez6091]

Gracias por la explicación, The word lujoso is mispell "lujuso"

[@eddoctora]

This was very helpful thank you very much

[@djamilb52]

thank you so much for this video

[@MarinaSharp]

Thank you so much for these videos. I'm using the Rosetta stone app, and it doesn't explain stuff like this. It's fully immersive and when I see these words, I can't just automatically figure out how/why they're used. They should have mini lessons in the users native language or something. This channel has been a lifesaver and helped so much!

[@amorodauda6875]

What kind of app is that?

[@ayannadelarosa4752]

Esto fue genial, he estado buscando "sistemas de lotería que funcionan" por un tiempo, y creo que esto ha ayudado. Alguna vez escuchó de este sitio t.co/hdTbIVxWZy He escuchado algunas cosas extraordinarias al respecto y mi compañero obtuvo excelentes resultados.

[@jennyfersuarez7478]

En Bogotá, Colombia decimos: ¿Qué tal estuvo la fiesta? ¿Qué tal estuvo la fiesta? Suena más natural así. Excelente trabajo profe. Gracias.

[@champfeilden3674]

Fue una lección muy útil era aprendo español contigo desde hacer un año 🤓🙏

[@thenbhouse5570]

Para tener más oportunidades de ganar que el resto de jugadores juntos, tienes que ver esta presentación en vídeo de Richard Lustig, ganador de 7 loterías t.co/JdniYo0yqD

[@cristinaravet3706]

Fue una lección muy útil. Yo aprendo español contigo desde hace un año. (Creo que quieres decir esto)

[@robinacero1340]

@@cristinaravet3706 Fue una lección muy útil , he estado aprendiendo español contigo desde hace un año...

[@dollytachn3066]

love your lessones!!

[@jacob6039]

“Was” is so hard to understand. I need more practice smh

[@farzaneheslam3842]

Kk I’ll ki

[@blueface456]

Me too. Why can't spanish have one way to say each word.

[@blueface456]

Don't forget "Iba," 😅. And this is just "It was not to mention he was she was they were and you were and I was. 😮

[@effahelizabeth1685]

Me gusta cómo enseñar tus leccións. Fue interesante y ùtil

[@meshail59]

I was thinking how to say in past.. and use was just yesterday. Thanks 😄

[@turkdouglas]

Thanks so much for this, it's very useful. It will take a bit of work for me as I find trying to decide what qualifies for which version a bit tricky. For instance, if I want to say that the episode of a TV series I just watched was great, would I use fue, as it is a particular moment? Or is it an object that can change depending on the episode therefore I should use estaba? Sorry if I am getting this totally wrong 🙄😁

[@LearnSpanishLearnSpanish]

You are asking the right questions. Firstly, you can eliminate estaba, because you want to mention the qualities of the object (episode) - so adjectives like interesante, fenomenal, divertido etc don't get used with estaba (estar). The one exception to that would be if you want to say 'it was OK' in which case "estaba bien". So that leaves era and fue. As mentioned in the video if you opt for 'era' when unsure, you will mostly be right because there is a degree of interchangeability. In the the example you give, it could easily be either because there is some perspective involved. Are you describing the 'event' you experienced (fue) or are you ascribing a quality to the episode (era)? So, basically both would be perfectly correct!

[@turkdouglas]

@@LearnSpanishLearnSpanish thanks so much for replying. It is going to take a bit of getting my head around but for the first time ever I am starting to get more of an idea. Much appreciated 😊

[@scotscub76]

I'm finally getting this! Gracias.

[@stephenstuart9881]

Brilliant - summed it all up really well and logically. Thanks.

[@perunut4656]

Just ashame I was given a present another language course as I much prefer this style.

[@bluebelle6833]

I can't believe you explained so easily when to use fue and era, where have you been all my life.

[@anitaramani5046]

Just stumbled onto your channel. Love the content and the manner of explanation! Thanks very much

[@AwalemManseya]

Very useful! Thanks!

[@laurexcee]

You have a wonderful Spanish accent and a great English one too. I enjoy listening to your videos. 😊

[@dschlag9956]

this video is goated thanks!

[@honeyinglune8957]

This is such a useful lesson

[@IntendJOY]

So very good. Thanks. Muy util

[@nanahussein8158]

❤️❤️la lección hoy fue ameno y no problema

[@kcorpora1]

amena

[@cindys2995]

Each time I've used "estuvo", I was wrong. LOL. I use estaba now - thanks for saying that!

[@amorodauda6875]

Me too

[@ceciliarodriguez6650]

Estuvo también es correcto es lo mismo Estuvo interesante Fue interesante

[@cindys2995]

@@ceciliarodriguez6650 Yo sé, pero a veces Google me correje. Me molesta.

[@howardplotkin871]

Cindy S estaba is used to describe something without known beginning or end: yo estaba en la biblioteca. Estuvo is used to describe something with a definite time frame: yo estuvo en la biblioteca ayer a las dos de la tarde.

[@cindys2995]

@@howardplotkin871 Yea, I know but Google often corrects me even when it's supposed to be estuvo

[@Richie_W]

Going the other way for Spanish people learning English, imagine how difficult it must be for them to wrap their head around how English has just one word for ‘to be’ in the imperfect and preterit tenses for inherent qualities and states. As a Spanish learner, once you grasp the notion that ‘to be’ really does have two distinct meanings, which Spanish separates as ser and estar, you’ll have made a big leap forward.

[@seuntimilehin3381]

Unless i misunderstood your comment how exactly would it be hard? Wouldn't it make it easier to learn English if there's only one word for to be in the imperfect and preterit tenses for inherent qualities and states? In the same way, English only has one word for estuve, fue era and estuvo

[@blueface456]

English is easy to pick up on because you will hear the same words over and over. But spanish has a different way to say one word. He was she was I was the word was pops up every time. But in spanish the word "was" is pronounced 40 different ways. That makes it difficult to catch on to. But vice versa,having only one way to say it makes it easy to catch on. English is hard if you plan on getting a degree in college. But if all you want to do is talk, then it's easy.

[@jillian0824]

so helpful 4 yrs ltr thank youu

[@janethcotanda6233]

thanksss❤❤❤❤ for the knowledge

[@Roberto-et2tb]

Lujuso?, should that not be lujoso. Many thanks for the explanations, good video.

[@RohitKumar-gg7qz]

Good video

[@ksmith2852]

Estuvo is used in Latin America to talk about being somewhere for a period of time "Estuve en Chile (por) 10 días"

[@murphypaschal]

Excellent presentation and explanation. Well done!

[@EJKelly]

Very cool. It's first time I fully understood the various uses. Thanks.

[@jaysantotv4614]

Impresionante!🎉

[@ksmith2852]

Que tal el clima? Which would be used since the verb haber is used in the presente. Hace calor in the present

[@osmonddsilva1577]

Excellent!😄😄😄

[@RudyTinoco]

Excellent! Thanks!

[@sarapowell46]

Thank yooou! This was so helpful 🙏🏼

[@NJeezy]

A lot of my Spanish-speaking friends say that they usually describe events using "estuvo," like "La fietsa estuvo divertida." Is this something that varies in different countries?

[@LEGIONARIO1970]

"Estuvo" is correct, since a party is short term event.

[@siriusblack7714]

So is there really a difference between a time and a place? If you go to a movie and someone asks you how it was. You are simultaneously describing the 2 hours and the movie itself

[@halimameslouhi4267]

U are the best

[@ferhatcirpan9639]

Please do more videos like that 🙏

[@Bit-while_going]

It's a fact that both characteristics and temporary states can be attributed to objects. Es un hecho que ambos características y estados puede ser atribuido a objetos.

[@demetriceb6659]

Muchas gracias!

[@willtabacchi1408]

I would have appreciated a laundry list at the lesson end summarizing the different kinds of WAS.

[@und.2378]

ياررررب اتعلم الاسبانية 100% احبهاا مررررة 😭😭😭😭❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@sarahfellows3074]

Would how did you like your coffee be estaba or era? I'm confused because I'm asking if they liked it (to describe it) but it was also transient which makes me question if it is estaba?

[@LearnSpanishLearnSpanish]

With food and drink: estaba. E.g. ¿Qué tal el café? Estaba muy bueno.

[@sarahfellows3074]

@@LearnSpanishLearnSpanish thank you 🙏

[@idktwt1907]

Fue interesante para mí😊

[@lada4665]

Thank you, it was simple, clear and usefull, just one question, 11:03 you say: Qué tal el hotel?, but wrote : Qué el hotel? Is it the same? Greetings from Prague :-)

[@benbliss8293]

Greetings from New York! I'm pretty sure that was a typo.

[@denasedaghat1122]

Mucho gracias✨

[@merveguner8522]

You are great• thank you

[@stargazer8225]

11:34 Small correction - it's not "lujuso" but lujoso. Nice lessons, thank you for them!

[@dominikadd4812]

Really nice video .. Really helpful

[@winifrednjangnjang7511]

It is just wonderful

[@franceshall7127]

hi thank you so much ,,, so im from usa so would i say estuvo a not estaba ?

[@iwd1428]

Love it. Subscribed

[@chrisg7261]

Thought this was excellent thank you

[@romummecul8032]

Ganar efectivo con lotería podría ser muy desafiante. ¿Sigues buscando enfoques acreditados para ganar dinero con lotería? Afortunadamente, finalmente has encontrado t.co/7JV5POnH7N Verá mucho sobre el método en el sitio web. En el sitio web, puede encontrar todos los recursos y métodos esenciales para ganar su primera lotería

[@howardplotkin871]

So estaba is used to describe a temporary condition in the past the same way está is used to describe a temporary condition in the present (other conjugations as well, in both past and present). I would use estuvo to describe a temporary condition in the past that had a specific time reference and was completed in the past. For example: Él estuvo en la biblioteca ayer desde las dos hasta las tres en la tarde. I don’t think estaba used in this context would be correct because it’s normally used without reference to a starting or ending time.

[@repa49]

Loved it - like always! :)

[@leenobody3249]

Estuvo is surely heavily used ? My native speaker intercambio friend says it is anyway .

[@miketopper1737]

And by exercise , I mean a homework assignment, ( I see it as an object or is it an event ? )

[@kathypayne3820]

LUXURIOUS-LUJOSO.

[@kimbinhdam1731]

Thank you very very much !

[@diazlucy2033]

Would you like to speak Spanish that could impress a native speaker? Want the words to freely flow from your tongue instead of sounding like a slowed down, broken record because you’re constantly grasping for the correct grammar in your head? Visit here for more info *LearnSpanish.4yourhelp. Com* (remove space and open the site)

[@gordonmalcolm9117]

Para tener más oportunidades de ganar que el resto de jugadores juntos, tienes que ver esta presentación en vídeo de Richard Lustig, ganador de 7 loterías t.co/JdniYo0yqD

[@shmema12]

Gracias

[@leonardodelacruz3859]

I need help. How was your day? It was fine. Or it was a lazy day. What should be used here. Thank you guys

[@daniellaquart2419]

Please i paid for the prospanish course a week ago but yet I haven't received the message to download, please let me know

[@johnclark3697]

Great stuff mucho appreciado . Entendiono completo

[@Tamara-ju3lh]

So if someone says "la pelicula era muy interesante" are they saying it incorrectly? This was a grammar lesson I was subject to.

[@LearnSpanishLearnSpanish]

Era interesante is fine. Era would be used here because what the film was like is not a event but the occasion (trip to see a film) is like an even. Another example: the beach was nice - la playa era bonito. And my trip there was fun - mi excursión a la playa fue divertida.

[@Tamara-ju3lh]

@@LearnSpanishLearnSpanish thank you!