इतिहासकार Ruchika Sharma ने Baithki में Ashoka,Taimur, Khilji, Somnath, Mughal Empire पर क्या बताया?

LT Premium जॉइन करने के लिए नीचे दिए लिंक पर क्लिक करें: / @thelallantop
The Lallantop brings to you a brand new chat show - Baithki. In this show, people from different fields will come face to face with you. In the fourth episode of Baithki, historian Ruchika Sharma answers all the queries of Saurabh Dwivedi.
Ruchika Sharma is a historian of medieval Indian history. She is a doctoral candidate of history at the Centre for Historical Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, Delhi. Previously she has finished her MPhil and Masters in medieval Indian history from the Centre for Historical Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University. She currently teaches at the Delhi University. She has also written for media platforms like The Scroll, The Quint, Newslaundry and The Wire. She runs a KZbin channel on history with a side of eyeshadow, called Eyeshadow & Etihaas / @eyeshadowetihaaswithr...
In this episode of Baithki Ruchika Sharma talked about biritish history, Samrat Ashoka, Taimur, Alauddin Khalji, destruction of Somnath temple, Mughal Empire and many more issues. Watch the full interview.
Instagram: / thelallantop
Facebook: / thelallantop
Twitter: / thelallantop
Produced By: The Lallantop
Edited By: Shakir khan

[@daljeet140177]

At 42:39 Saurabh asked her question about which source is authentic and she was visibly stumped and struggled, though she got back to her foot quickly but the damage is done. Also she not expecting Saurabh to cross question

[@PartiallyAnonymous456]

Lmao true

[@varahmihir4575]

She admitted, she does not know Sanskrit. And then she says, "A historian can be illiterate, why bother about education?". LOL Also, she translates "Chand/Chandi" to "ugly. But actually "chandi" means "fierce", not ugly. LOL!

[@prasantapandaprasanta8824]

​@@varahmihir4575than why she is misleading

[@prashtt]

Because she is JNU ki paidaish and dwiedi to hai hi to soft core dikha rha hai c

[@svgodan]

50:30 ब्रह्म और ब्रह्मा में अन्तर पता नहीं हैं इन इतिहासकार को 😂😂

[@varahmihir4575]

She is brainwashed by Persian language.

[@daljeet140177]

Somnath “Somesvara” temple is located in Prabhas Patan on coastline of Saurashtra. In Vana Parva of Mahabharat there is a mention of a pilgrim site (Tirtha) in Prabhasa Pattana. In Shiv Purana the 1st Jyotirlinga is mentioned as Prabhasa Pattana. But Ruchika wants to refer only Farsi sources and Romila Thapars research thesis.

[@RahulKumar-dh6uc]

Left wing historian 😂😂

[@sandeepram2289]

@@RahulKumar-dh6uc *distorian

[@adonismr1514]

Romilla thappar👎 koh toh ek ZORRR KI THAPPARR? 👋KI SAKHHHTTT ZAROORAT HAI😡TABHI USS BUDHHOO BUDHIYA KI NARYALL KHOPRI MEIN KUCH BHEJAA AAYEGA😡

[@adonismr1514]

​@@sandeepram2289👍RIGHT WORD BRO "DISTORIAN"👎

[@adonismr1514]

ISS GADHI LADY NE TOHH... CHANDRASHEKHAR🌙BHAGWAAN BHAIRAVV KO SOM🌙NATH SE "LADY SU- MANAAT" ... ..BANA DIYA AORR UPARR SE YEHH BHI KEHH RAHI HAI KI ISSSEYY BADI GADHEE LADY ROMILLA THAAPAR👎 NE "BAHUT ACHHI KITAAB LIKHE HAI" sacch mein gadheeyon ke sirr parr seenghh nahin hote 😡🌛

[@abhaykm07]

मैडम इतनी अच्छी तरह से बता रही हैं मानो कुतुबुद्दीन तैमूर खिलजी सभी ने आक्रमण और मार काट कर के इस देश पर बहुत बड़ा अहसान किया है। जे एन यू की शिक्षा को सलाम।

[@DEEPAKKUMAR-ku5jr]

देख रहे हो बिनोद तेमुर आये थे। अशोक चंडाल कुरुप था।😡😡😡

[@exactlearner6329]

असोक पूरे विश्व में इतिहास का सबसे महान राजा है।

[@adeshkale7812]

Science journey ne exposed Kiya hai isko proof ke sath

[@SurinderKumar-qn1wg]

@@exactlearner6329 Right

[@ASHISHSINGH-ot6mg]

Science journey se Ruchika sharma debate kr le with evidence

[@mohitkumar-ek1uz]

@@ASHISHSINGH-ot6mg bhai tumne mere Mann ki baat keh di.

[@Sabir-09]

Fake Historian @Ruchika Sharma Open Debate Challenge From Science Journey

[@PartiallyAnonymous456]

Saar debate science journey saar

[@er.rkushwaha]

ऐसा नहीं लगता, इस विडियो का टाइटल *इतिहासकार* न होकर *स्टाइलिस इतिबदलहासकार* होना चाहिए!😊

[@RajeshSINGH-nk2yd]

इनको इतिहास में फिर से स्नातक करनी चाहिए, स्नातक स्तर का लेवल भी इनके पास नहीं है। चंद अरबी फारसी शब्द को जान लेने से कोई इतिहासकार नहीं हो सकता। हास्यास्पद ज्ञान। इस मंच पर पहली बार इतना कम स्तर का इतिहास पर बातचीत सुनना पड़ा

[@varahmihir4575]

She admitted, she does not know Sanskrit. And then she says, "A historian can be illiterate, why bother about education?". LOL Also, she translates "Chand/Chandi" to "ugly. But actually "chandi" means "fierce", not ugly. LOL!

[@shyamendrasingh5623]

Average historian

[@dharmeshparikh7837]

Romila Thaapar was recently talking about Yuthisthir in Ashoka time, which was hilarious. 😂😂So definitely her work should be thoroughly checked just as she suggested academically, but the problem is whenever someone tries to do that, their whole professional attacks collectively on befalf of her. 😅😅

[@adityaray2633]

Ha yrrr Inka kux interconnect n ho pa rhi history 😂......inki thisis to hmari graduation ki copy ki trh hogi

[@ashoodubey729]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/pIDLZnxoZquZZ6M

[@ankitjain3760]

Yudhistar we don't have proof but we have proof of Indus Valley Civilization.

[@dharmeshparikh7837]

@@ankitjain3760 but here I am, talking about two time periods. I am not here asking her to have proof about whether Mahabharat or Budhha really existed or not ?😂😂 You are not getting my point here. Moreover, she is not an expert for Indus Valley history. She hasn't included any archeological proofs for her books of history with respect to the medieval period. I have read her books. Moreover, this lady in the video is so deceptive and cunning. I just asked her about Nalanda University timeline of destruction because it's actually officially available on the Bihar ASI website that it was destroyed by Bakhityar Khilji. When I sent that ASI official link to this moron student of Romila Thaapar, She blocked me.

[@20shourya]

What time period was Yudhistir around? Also what time period were people able to perform magic and then forgot how to do that?

[@pratikkinkhabwala3773]

Now I can see how historian can change history..

[@uditraj8290]

Haa😂😂

[@sanojkumar-mv2mk]

Now I can see how an andhbhakt can create a new narrative and blame historians

[@veyev4320]

@@sanojkumar-mv2mk haa! Somnath me Arabic Goddess ko pooja jata tha! Tum yahi dekho aur mano!! Waah bete! Tumse tez to saala Einstein bhi nahi tha!

[@veyev4320]

@@msdadsfsx Tu apni degree bata be!

[@kv8201]

She is a well known Hindu hater & arab invaders worshipper. You may go through her tweeter which is full of propaganda.

[@14rajib]

Continuous interactions with such people will surely enrich us except some fringe elements from both extremes. Keep us it up Sir and thank you Ruchika ji for insights

[@rudrachavan4080]

Bro I have seen her multiple interviews. And she will not enrich but distort the history same way left historians/ distorians did. She is just new avatar of them

[@JagdishKumar-uf2hr]

Thanks for deep insight into our history. Hope in near future Dr Chopra (after passing PhD) will prepare her learnings to convey to us in chronological order. Jagdish Kumar from California USA

[@varahmihir4575]

She admitted, she does not know Sanskrit. And then she says, "A historian can be illiterate, why bother about education?". LOL Also, she translates "Chand/Chandi" to "ugly. But actually "chandi" means "fierce", not ugly. LOL!

[@angelaquaenterprise6533]

मैडम कपूडगाथा मत सुनाइए. पीएचडी कर रहे हो या स्पाइडर मेन, बैटमैन की कहानियाँ बना रही हो. हिस्ट्री को सही से पढ़िए. रुट लेवल तक जाइए. बकवास स्टोरी कोई सुनेगा नहीं.अगर डिबेट करनी है ओपन प्लेटफार्म पर कीजिये. पता चल जायेगा कितनी हिस्ट्री आती है.

[@bindaastwo]

अगर आपने कोई गलतियां बताई होती तो शायद एक चर्चा शुरू हो सकती थी। पर जिस जाहिलाना अंदाज में आपने अपनी नापसंदगी दिखाई है उसको नज़रंदाज़ करने के अलावा और कुछ नहीं किया जा सकता है।

[@I.amSultan.]

👍👍👍👍​@@bindaastwo

[@n.r.meghwal4386]

50:45 सम्राट अशोक ब्राह्मण नहीं थे, इसलिए ब्राह्मणी को अशोक में सुंदरता नज़र नहीं आई। मगर शारीरिक रूप से आठ जगहों से टेढे़मेडे अष्टावक्र 'ब्राह्मण' थे; वो सभी ब्राह्मणों को रूप-लावण्य से कामदेव से भी सुंदर नज़र आते हैं। जिनमें टेढ़ापन की बजाय ब्राह्मणत्व का ब्रह्मज्ञान नजर आता है।

[@xtremtech5600]

Sahi pakde 👌👌👌👌👍👍👍

[@jaypalpatel4157]

सही कहा c grade ब्राह्मणवादी इतिहासकार है ये रुचिका शर्मा,जिसे सौरभ द्विवेदी प्रख्यात कर रहा है।

[@urrasscal8380]

uski maa brahmin thi bosrikey...

[@mohitjain9997]

Moorkh asthavakra ka matlab hi hai 8 jagaho se tedameda. Uska matlab kaamdev nhi hota

[@shubhampandit5828]

ये दोनों ही हमेशा से जातिवाद के खिलाफ रहे हैं लेकिन तुम जैसे मंदबुद्धि अपने आप को साबित कर ही देते हो पहले भी मूर्ख थे आज भी मूर्ख हो

[@zakia8623]

Concluding part by the interviewer are very appropriate. Would love to see any number of these baithakis Stay blessed

[@YogeshSharma-vp5ww]

Thank you lallantop for this type of interview . Kindly provide more interviews of historians .

[@rudrachavan4080]

Distorians 😂

[@mrperfectionist88]

Waiting for guests like J Sai Deepak, Vikram Sampath, Dr. Meenakshi Jain and Dr. Anand Ranganathan. Hope Lallantop invites them and we get to hear their side of the story.

[@rishikeshkumar2073]

ye nai bulayenge unko itni bhi ummid na rakhen

[@mrperfectionist88]

@@rishikeshkumar2073 Ummid pe duniya kayam hai. Waise dusre platforms pe to unko sunte hi rehte hai lekin I like the way Saurabh Dwivedi does his research and prepares questions for the guests.

[@clashwithfriendscolony7195]

Oh shit here we go again.. "Distorian"

[@shubhamrawat530]

वो नहीं आयेंगे क्योंकि उन्हें पता है यहां पर क्रोस क्वेश्चन होंगे। उनको सिर्फ 1 वे अपने जैसे लोगों से बात करने की आदत है‌

[@mrperfectionist88]

@clash with friends colony Oh you mean to point out likes of Romila Thapar according to who Mahabharata's Yudhishthira was inspired by Ashoka lol ok

[@sukumarnadar387]

जैसे ही रोमिला थापर का नाम लिया मैने सुनना छोड़ दिया। जिसे फारसी नही संस्कृत नही आती। वह इतिहासकार है मध्य काल की। धन्य है आपका ज्ञान। जो इतिहासकार है उनका क्या इतिहास है बहुत महत्वपूर्ण होता है।

[@anshulavaniya8751]

जे एन यू से पी एच डी की है भाई और क्या उम्मीद करेगा

[@schrodingerscat8031]

@41:00 is fun to watch counter question by Saurabh according to her and her Guru Romila thapar, she is saying only those account will be taken in which destruction has taken place so Hindus were worshipping manath as Shiva and what about our account of Jyoterling will not be taken into consideration. So where is jyoterling name Somnath is??

[@jitendrasinghjadaun670]

Jabhi to Samarkand ko Iran bata rahe he

[@hemantchoudharychoudhary3481]

​@@jitendrasinghjadaun670 thoda acche se dekho ky bat ho rhi hai fir kro cmmant

[@ramsagarprajapati111]

तभी तो सभी मुगलिया राक्षसों को थे थे सम्मान जनक के रूप में परोस रही है

[@omkarmavlankar6611]

Thank goodness we now have better sources ....n we understand how shallow this info is... Somnath is a jyotirl8ng

[@haritpurohit762]

Saurabh sir aapki way of asking questions and your reactions and all the way you talk is very beautiful.

[@abhayraj4807]

देख रहे हो विनोद एक मध्यकालीन भारत की इतिहासकार प्राचीन भारत का इतिहास बता रही है 🤣🤣🤣

[@sdevil_01]

😂😂😂😂 kuch nhi pta hai ise lol h ye

[@anmoltudu7386]

लंबी लंबी फेंके जा रही है। असोकावदान को 'quote' तो कर रही है, पर उसमें लिखा कुछ और है और बता कुछ और रही है।

[@sumitchougule2236]

😂😂👍

[@45015Kagss]

Ruchika Sharma will become one of the best modern day historians soon. She truly gives an unbiased perspective.

[@Tom-ll2cr]

😂ha Isis v hindu hai iske hisab se

[@asifrajputt]

Thanks dear for bringing nice people and taking us into time capsule.

[@rathourbaba6940]

भारत का असली इतिहास जानना हो तो science journey sir के पास जाइए सबूतों और तथ्यो के साथ

[@whatajoke2357]

Reservation wala hai kya!?

[@kamalkamaljeet7929]

Asli nahe jutha etihas jhandu journey batat hai.app asli etihas ko janty hai to ek bar sanatan sameksh chanel par jarur aye

[@KingJohnun242]

तू ही गांड़ में साइंस जर्नी वाले chutiye से

[@143sv_eadit6]

@@whatajoke2357 इंटीना(भीकसा म देहि) वाला है क्या 😁😁

[@143sv_eadit6]

@@whatajoke2357 तुम भीकसा देहि वाले हो सायद 😁🤣🤣🤣 इसलिए science से जल रही है 😁🙄🙄🙄🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Sabir-09]

Open Challenge To Bramhaani Madam Ji Debate To Science Journey ...

[@adarsh8731]

Science journey doesn't even talk about science lol 😂

[@sanjaymakwana2953]

Excellent discourse...thanks...for calling such true historian or hisory student...

[@rudrachavan4080]

Distorians

[@TheArvindUTube]

I heard about no hospitals found... pls look into kumrahar excavation in patna. Large hall pillars of Ashoka time were unearthed and a supposed center for healing with indoor patients. Just a note on wonderful historical background given by Ruchika.

[@bakwastak3513]

पोरपेगंडा इंटरव्यू

[@shafiulhaidary4567]

Saurabh sb Aadab Iran koi bhi jaasakta hai aur paarsi mein "Dawa ko hi Daaru" kahte hain Ms.Sjarma ki Lajawab prastuti ke liye bahut bahut Dhanyavad.

[@downtoearth892]

It is ridiculous. Was there any goddess named Manat in the ancient or medieval India? But Siva was there all the time. To say that Somnath was Su Manat is like saying there is possibility of finding a temple of David in ancient India. Salute such historical scholarship!

[@vidhanrana]

She is an excellent story teller, devoid of facts. Sometimes it borders on nonsense and ridiculous.

[@diptyprakashswain1121]

Lallantop toh bese bhi leftist ko hin pyaar karta hai 😅😅..esen hin dikha dia

[@vivekdas7589]

I will just clarify. The goddess is talking about is one that belongs to pre Islam era. She was one of the three chieftains of Mecca City along with her two sisters. Alat and Aluzza. She is very sacred to Persians historically. I guess that is what she is referring to

[@ssrwarrior7978]

Lallan top is in love Muslims and Rahul Gandhi .... makes sense their hosts have similar views ... Ruchika must have muslin boy friend ... that is my guess ..LOL

[@diptyprakashswain1121]

@@ssrwarrior7978 🤣🤣bhai calm rehle jitna prove mila hai utna bata rahi hai w

[@zahidabdulwasi787]

Very good information of true history and it's very intersting.I love Lollantop channel

[@ps-vv6oe]

whole interview i listened and so interestingly facts analysed by her..

[@PAWANKUMAR-ed3ug]

Konse fact

[@PardeepKumar-tk8qk]

कह रही है इतिहास को इतिहास की दृष्टि से देखिए, न की धार्मिक जातीय या अन्य दृष्टि से जबकि खुद ही दो तीन जगह जातीय दृष्टि से विश्लेषण कर दिया

[@xtremtech5600]

Brahman propoganda Bhai

[@aqdasshaikh314]

Itihas me to ab sab kuch cover karna padega na 😂,, sirf dharm ki drishti se dekho ge to andho me aur tumme kya fark hai 😂

[@gadgoli7777]

इतिहास समझने जैसे आप फारसी सीख लेती है और रोमिला थापर आपसे ज्येष्ठ होकर इस देश के इतिहास को समझने संस्कृत सीखे बगैर इतिहास गढ लेती है, कमाल है

[@PHYSMATH29]

Abe gipu Sanskrit 9th century after milti he usse pahle pali prakrit kharosti Greek farsi 😂😂 ''Phd Scholar'' kzbin.info/www/bejne/oGm3f4Oiepqio6M

[@praveen5085]

​​@@PHYSMATH29 Abe chu chu .... Sanskrit is 5000 year old...tum to 1500 sal pehle registan me nange ghumte the ..ha ha

[@nikobaka5272]

Watch reality of Islam on Exmuslim channel on youtube. Ex muslim sahil Exmuslim sameer Ex muslim deeni bhai Adam seeker Sachwala

[@AjayPatel-xm6nf]

@@PHYSMATH29 achcha to Tibet mein mili kalp vigrah murti ke saath jo tamr Patra Mila Jo ki sanskrit mein likha hua tha voh 32000 varsh Purana keise saabit hua. Ye investigation CIA-america ne ki hei meine nahi dekhlo.

[@abhishekpathak1]

@@PHYSMATH29 tu naya chuitya mila bhai or upsc ki tyari kaar ra hai... abe sanskrit 1400 sal se bhu jayda purani hai ..

[@sarapharajsande]

Very informative❤

[@veersinghyadav4861]

Nice discussion keep it continue.

[@HemantUpadhyay1993]

यहां सुनकर देखकर एक राय तो पक्का बन रही, कि सुनाने वाला या लिखने वाला खुद भृमित हो तो सामने वाले को अपने पर विश्वास ना करने की वजह दे बैठता है। और कुछ इतिहासकार या कोई भी लेखक अपनी बात को स्पष्टता, प्रमाणिक और वजनदार तरीके से रखे तो असत्य इतिहास भी विश्वसनीय लगने लगता है।

[@jagjeevan-lw9dq]

बिलकुल सही कहा भाई आपने यहाँ कुछ ऐसा ही है

[@shortinformation6073]

if prophet born in india then - “The Prophet [ﷺ] married Aisha when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old.” - The revered Sahih al-Bukhari, 5134; Book 67, Hadith 70. Section 375(6): Rape (under eighteen years of age) Different punishments have been decided foe rape of women in different ages. Rape of women under 16 years of age: Rigorous imprisonment of not less than 20 years/ life and fine. he is not suitable for modern world even today muslim is good then prophet Why i right Indian law beacause muslim belive he is ideal man for all time and follow him and his did is sunna part of Islam , what prophet did is halal for every muslim . So if Sharia law implement then merrige 6 year child is valid that country if they follow real Sharia.

[@vkant2607]

इस्लामिक मकसद ही हत्याएं लूट बलात्कार काफिर वाजिबल कत्ल है फिर संदेह कैसा , मल तो मल ही है

[@AdarshYadav480]

Gobarbhakt you want read only those history where your mythological religion and ridiculous culture will glorify

[@asheeshmishra5392]

आज तक चैनल को वैसे भी कहते हैं अमेरिकी जासूसी संस्था सीआईए का चैनल है इसका काम केवल हिंदुओं को गुलाम बनाए रखना है किस तरह से मांडू का ही हुआ एक नई नवली पीएचडी स्कॉलर को बुला लिया गया जिसके अभी सिर्फ सबमिट हुई है एक्सेप्ट नहीं हुई है आखिर उसमें क्या इतनी खास बात देखी जा रही है जी हां औरंगजेब का महिमा मंडल करना था हिंदुओं सावधान आज तक से

[@UPSCWALLAH-zf8zu]

धरती खोदकर देखो बुद्ध ही बुद्ध मिलेगे विश्व विजेता अशोक सम्राट को जीतने वाला भी बुद्ध धर्म है ❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@maheshsinghmunnusingh5494]

मुर्दे हमेसा जमीन के अंदर ही मिलते हे

[@mb-hb1fr]

Aaj Tak to nahi mile 😂😂

[@UPSCWALLAH-zf8zu]

@@mb-hb1fr tumko kuch pata hi nhi hai

[@mb-hb1fr]

@@UPSCWALLAH-zf8zu bhai kahi nahi mile aur Gautam budh khud bhi hindu hi the.

[@UPSCWALLAH-zf8zu]

@@mb-hb1fr pahli baat Hindu koi dharm nhi hai 🤣 Aap current affair ki class Kiya Karo aapko pata chal jayega Nalanda University ki khudai kare to pata nhi kitne Buddha melege

[@palashranjanbhaumick5583]

Excellent episode!

[@khalildalvi1062]

Very very important and good information about history thanks Ruchika sharma ji our Anchor ji dhanyavad

[@rishabhuniyal9747]

😂😂

[@Chandra8201p]

As she is trying keep positive image of Ghajini that he was destroying SOMNATH temple bcz he took it as su-manath. I am very sure she must have some positive arguement for Bhaktiyar khilji about destroying Nalanda University.

[@kallolpoetry]

first of all tell me who was Khalji and Ghajni from where did they came and where did they belong from? You are a big naive gobarbhakt to put both together. Going by your logic, Arabic world should bomb mongolia because Genghis laid their city into rubles.

[@chesstimenytime6994]

Prove her wrong with facts. Otherwise no value of ur thoughts.

[@Chandra8201p]

@@chesstimenytime6994 let's assume what if Ghanjini didn't take it as su-manath then would he have destroyed Somnath? What do you think? Answer it with logic

[@Chandra8201p]

@@kallolpoetry Mahmud ghazni was a Turkish slave soldier and he took control of Ghazni in 998.

[@Chandra8201p]

@@kallolpoetryAnd I am not putting khilji and Ghazni together, I am putting theirs logic behind massacre and loot together and the logic was Islam. Tumhare Abbajaan ke pitaji bhi kabhi gobarbhakt hua krte the lekin afsos ab tum sab katwe ho gye ho.

[@angelaquaenterprise6533]

असोक सुन्दर नहीं था क्योंकि वो ब्राह्मण नहीं था.

[@dnikhilrao]

Enjoyed this conversation. Many thanks to Saurabh for being a wonderful host. I hope he one days talks at length to Meenakshi Jain, author of books like Parallel Pathways, The Battle for Rama and The Flight of the Deities. She is a careful and rigorous historian who critiques the JNU school of Marxist historiography and the Aligarh school, there is much to learn from a similar interaction with her. She mentions Irfan Habib and Romila Thapar as the shadow authors of the (dubiously) iconic "Historians Letter to the nation" document released in the media in the late 80s. It was full of lies and half truths and poisoned the discourse further. Having Ruchika and Meenakshi Jain Ji together moderated by Saurabh would be a dream episode.

[@mangopudding5979]

They won't, because it doesn't match their leftist propaganda

[@mangopudding5979]

Meenakshi Jain will royally de feat this clo wn named Ruchika

[@pondorinaique6335]

Great to listen to such a knowledge enriching discussion about our past !

[@RAJKUMAR-dk8ed]

चाहे जहां जितनी भी खुदाइ, अध्ययन करलो तथागत बुद्ध , सम्राट अशोक ही मिलेंगे। सत्यमेव जयते

[@buntyghosh4959]

Nepal main hi milega aur kuch Bihar main,baki jagha 🙄 nahi ok

[@ashishtrivedi4186]

Great, thanks to anchor, lallantop and Ruchika mam to enhance my history knowledge....

[@raisurrahmanchishti3107]

The most judicious historian Dr.ms sharma having sufficient Knowledge of Persian,English, Hindi language expressed relevant Indian history. I salute young historian. From r r chishti Advocate.

[@habibgilani_Official.]

Very interesting talk! She is talking about a lively perspective of history! Love and salute from Pakistan

[@anurag6738]

Galat information mat failao, agar khudko knowledge nahi hai to gyan na chodo 🙏

[@Mr.Chin666]

ये WhatsApp university मे पढाती है क्या?

[@aviram7491]

ढक्कन हो क्या 😂😂 ये ज्ञान कोश से है

[@amittorave7879]

WhatsApp university se PhD karne walo ko mat Lao 😑 😂😂😂

[@adeshkale7812]

Science journey ne exposed Kiya hai isko proof ke sath

[@hirenahir76200]

😂😂😂

[@GauravRajput-jx2xy]

​Right 👍

[@shantikumarkhairnar9577]

Nice explanation about Indian History 👌 👍

[@ManjuSharma-eo6jn]

I love this the program Very informative about, spritualty, musican historians, writers many many other subjects, I Always looking forward to it 🙏

[@PAWANKUMAR-ed3ug]

😂😂😂 inme se kuch bhi nhi mila iske pas

[@golu7986]

Asok Bramhan hota to Sundar hota

[@ramjivyas3244]

शिवपुराण में द्वादश ज्योतिर्लिंग है 14 नहीँ श्लोक प्रारम्भ ही सुनें सौराष्ट्र च सोमनाथे श्री शैले मल्लिकार्जुनम उज्जैनम महाकल् म ओमकार ममलेश्वरम परालयम च वैधनात्म डाकिनयं भीमाशंकरम अंतिम यह है हिमालय तू केदारम घ्रसनेस्वर शिवालय 12 ज्योतिर्लिंग सभी प्राचीन शास्त्रों में

[@ChaudryShehryarYounis]

Great discussion

[@SportyEducare]

ब्राम्हि नही धम्म लिपी, देवान पिय पीय दस्सी मतलव देवोका(बुद्ध का) प्रिय प्रियदर्शी, धर्म नही धम्म.

[@xtremtech5600]

Brahman hai kaha sunegi 😂😂😂

[@truthseekerhuman]

Don't tell spicy stories please deliver History as it is mam. And also don't tell people like... "that would have been happened" Rather quote actual facts so that people will know it clearly. And I would suggest that bring experts who have properly read and decoded these inscriptions and archaeologists and not Historians. And finally GET WELL SOON LALLANTOP.

[@dilipnandi6687]

Then where did Emperor Ashok use 'Kharosthi' script? As I can remember, historians found stone pillar near Bhopal with inscriptions on Emperor Ashoka, where 'Kharosthi' script was used. It is said that kharosthi script was very complex script, in use during ancient India, though it was script would only use for writing, not as spoken language. This episode, I feel very educative and interesting. Plz. arrange more episodes on topics of ancient India. We, Indians don't know our ancient history and this is the root cause of our intersect chaos. Thanks to Ms. Ruchika.

[@shabirmirza-yb6qo]

It was a great and eye opening conversation..

[@pviveknair]

In South India, Schools were called Kalaris which were associated with certain families, temples or some teacher. This is where they taught fighting Kalaripayattu. They also teach Sanskrit & Grammar. Marmakala is also part of Kalaripayattu, so the teachers would also be experts in Ayurveda & Siddha medicines. There are 18 levels in Kalari & a student who learns & becomes an expert in these 18 levels is capable of becoming a teacher. Though not all students become a teacher later & most go back to practice their traditional trades of their parents. But they retain all the knowledge of martial arts, language & medicine. So, the villagers will go to these people for help when they are sick or injured. If someone proves to be good in treating people, they are visited more often. Till recently, around 1960-70s, these types of people were the only medical support available to villagers. And I am talking about Kerala specifically here. My Grandfather was one such person. He was in the military as well, so when he returned he had additonal knowledge of quickfixes that they use to do in the military.

[@ambedkareducation7342]

Tum sabhi Brahmanou logoun hin Buddhism ki nast krneki kasish mein Nalanda University ko Nast kiye aur apna Dosh Dhakne kliye Khilji ke upar Dosh dereho

[@pviveknair]

@@ambedkareducation7342 Ha Bhai, Bamiyan ke Buddha Statue bhi Brahmanno ne hi rocket launcher se thoda tha, phir apna dosh dhakne ke liye bechare Talibaniyo pe dosh dediya. Ghulam Sarwar Khan Niazi bhi ek brahman tha jisne Khilji ki biography likh kar Nalanda thodne ka dosh Khilji par laga diya.

[@DrDhirajPhysiotherapyClinic]

😂

[@BeingStoic086]

bhim ka gyan dhoom machaye@@ambedkareducation7342

[@varahmihir4575]

@@ambedkareducation7342 She admitted, she does not know Sanskrit. And then she says, "A historian can be illiterate, why bother about education?". LOL Also, she translates "Chand/Chandi" to "ugly. But actually "chandi" means "fierce", not ugly. LOL!

[@SUMITSINGH-tf5tn]

Saurabh guru history se anjaan hone ki acting gajab kiya hai..... information nikalvane aur disscsion ko intresting banane k liye......👏👏👏👏

[@asheeshmishra5392]

आज तक चैनल को वैसे भी कहते हैं अमेरिकी जासूसी संस्था सीआईए का चैनल है इसका काम केवल हिंदुओं को गुलाम बनाए रखना है किस तरह से मांडू का ही हुआ एक नई नवली पीएचडी स्कॉलर को बुला लिया गया जिसके अभी सिर्फ सबमिट हुई है एक्सेप्ट नहीं हुई है आखिर उसमें क्या इतनी खास बात देखी जा रही है जी हां औरंगजेब का महिमा मंडल करना था हिंदुओं सावधान आज तक से

[@manjushaganguly9659]

रुचिका जी आपकी उम्र को देखकर इतनी सुन्दर इतिहास की समझ कमाल की है !! सौरभ जी आपको बहुत साधुवाद !!!! कि ऐसी गहरी जानकार से हमें रूबरू कराया !!!!

[@girishkantpandey8759]

मैडम ने मांडू में महादेव मंदिर निर्माण का उल्लेख की लेकिन सरस्वती मंदिर के तोड़े जाने की चर्चा नहीं की।

[@avinash4522]

Something another level. Thank u so much lallantop. Very educational

[@shaz-b9109]

Timur is a national hero in Uzbekistan. Samarkand is in Uzbekistan, not in Iran, though the region is a part of erstwhile Persia. Timurs most famous monuments are probably in present day Uzbekistan. Crusaders came from all over Europe. Not just Spain and Italy. They came from eastern Europe, Germany, france and from the British isles. The knights came in huge numbers. And Richard the lion heart, who fought the third crusade was the king of England.

[@2sridhark]

If I am not mistaken, Babar (founder of Mughal dynasty in India) was born in Andijan, Uzbekistan. He is i think buried there.

[@hanaf3495]

​@@2sridharkBabur was buried in Kabul

[@sciencekids6629]

best one so far, good one please invite the Ruchika Sharma again

[@georgealexander4846]

Avery interesting and educative interview. We have to learn from people lie Dr. Sharma that there is a vast difference between Mythology and History. Great !!!

[@varahmihir4575]

She admitted, she does not know Sanskrit. And then she says, "A historian can be illiterate, why bother about education?". LOL Also, she translates "Chand/Chandi" to "ugly. But actually "chandi" means "fierce", not ugly. LOL!

[@jkshrivastava1872]

Very good discourse on History, very interesting as well.👏👏👏👏👏

[@vipankatiyal6297]

The way in which she is giving respect to these oppressors is amazing.

[@enjoyfullifenatural.cultiv8441]

1. वास्तव में हर पुरुष और हर महिला समान हैं। मनुष्य ने उस समानता को नष्ट कर दिया है - अलग कर दिया। , असमानता मनाई जाती है। मानव निर्मित मशीनें बराबर के रूप में मौजूद हैं। लेकिन पुरुषों में कोई समानता नहीं है 2. सभी 'मानव जातियों' के शरीर के कार्य अलग-अलग होते हैं। . चूंकि हम सभी अलग-अलग माता-पिता और परिवारों से पैदा हुए हैं, इसलिए हमारे शरीर का आकार भी अलग-अलग है। लेकिन वास्तविक सच्चाई जानने के लिए इतिहास का अध्ययन करें निरंतर, निरंतर, प्रचुर, निर्माता (1), बना = समान रूप से 3. मानव निर्मित = श्रेष्ठता, विभाजन उदाहरण: धर्म, अमीर और गरीब, राजनीति, सुविधा, आदि। लेकिन वास्तविक सच्चाई जानने के लिए इतिहास का अध्ययन करें। समानता की एकता विभाजित। बांटो और राज करो। (सत्ता। धन। श्रेष्ठता। वर्चस्व। दूसरों पर अत्याचार। कुटिल)

[@veyev4320]

agreed

[@AjitJoshi686]

Please understand how can she get 2 history degrees in JNU without praising them. 😂😂😂😂

[@rajeshmishra5250]

LT team works hard to find their kind of historian. They will never call likes of Vikram sampath

[@kallolpoetry]

​@@rajeshmishra5250 Sampath copied his entire book on Sawarkar elsewhere. His history society membership was revoked because of this. I don't think anyone will respect him as he had copied many excerpts from people, in some case word to word.

[@user-cw4xr8vy8v]

इतिहास से संबंधित और वीडियो बनाईये बहुत अच्छी जानकारी मिली हम ब बेसब्री से इन्तजार कर रहे हैं

[@ErMSRana]

Lallan Top is requested to invite Ruchika Sharma ji again for the historical debate. Very good information is available here.

[@NurulIslam-qu5dg]

Loved the real historical Perspective.

[@KHALILAhmed-bj3dy]

इस कार्यक्रम को बनाने, यूट्यूब पर पेश करने के लिए लल्लनटॉप और होस्ट रुचिका शर्मा जी का शुक्रिया, Thanks ,

[@namratadan3414]

Very interesting and informative 👌

[@FactaClaus]

There are so many instances of contradiction in her testimony. Why would she visit Iran to find out about Timur, which suffered a similar fate as India in the past with his attacks. Timur’s major monuments are in Uzbekistan and not in Iran. She conveniently refuses to address the description of Somnath temple in Sanskrit sources where it appears with a different name “Prabhasa Patan”. She assumes that Akbar didn’t know what was inscribed on the pillar because it was some British guy who later deciphered it. How can she jump to this conclusion? As the sources are silent, there is also a possibility that someone during Akbar’s reign translated Brahmi for him to understand the inscriptions on the pillar. These and many other instances clearly show that enthusiasm to discover something in new generation scholars of History doesn’t translate into experience which actually generates expertise to understand history through various lenses. As a matter of fact most of the modern Indian historians specially from the JNU Gharana, consistently and conveniently are reluctant to dig deeper into folklore traditions which have remained a key for transfer of knowledge in successive generations. Such reluctance in a country which is known for its oral tradition of preservation of history, is deeply concerning.

[@thebackyardpsychologist]

When did you complete your PhD in history?

[@hashminaved6523]

Supar hour ❤❤❤ really very interesting subject also she have a grt box of knowledge....plz saurabh sir call her again in ur show I will wait for her

[@sumansarkar7320]

I think Akhoka was the 1st ruler who build hospital for not only people but also for the animals.

[@Perfect32dentalclinic]

Yes bro ....

[@garimabisht459]

😂😂🤭

[@hunnysingh7547]

@@garimabisht459 has mat Shi bol rhi he

[@imranHussain-ww5jy]

Sochne se kuch nhi hota bhai souce do

[@sarasmishra821]

@@imranHussain-ww5jy bhains ke aage bin bajaye bhains kare paguraye

[@zeeshman42]

Dr. Ruchika is a rockstar. Excellent conversation.

[@pushparani5080]

It was a great session 🎉👍✍️

[@ganeshg7398]

भारत के सारे मंदिर बौद्ध स्तूप बौद्ध विहार हैं.

[@PartiallyAnonymous456]

Acha 😂

[@lovesurajsoni20]

Your knowledge is without evidence, please once debate on Science Journey about Ashoka.

[@RamBhakt1991]

इतिहास में पीएचडी कर रही महिला को चरक संहिता , सुश्रुत संहिता और धनवंतरी का वर्णन नही मालूम । और इन्हे सुनने का मतलब ही क्या ।

[@abdulwasim9364]

Great knowledge great history of India.

[@BhanuKumar-qd5rp]

She does not know that Jihadis attacked 17 times on Somnath..😂😂

[@starfootball6478]

Tasalli karle apne aapko😂

[@neerajsahu5353]

Smartest people are never afraid to look stupid. Saurabh knows this. He mixes his curiosity with stupid innocence making the guest feel more like a teacher. I refuse to believe that anything she told Saurabh didn't know beforehand because he reads too much. Other thing, really amazing to see a young woman historian. Being a history scholar myself, I really 'liked' her.

[@ramraghuwanshi2562]

Young Propgandist distorian

[@urrasscal8380]

typical librandu teenager....

[@mirramiz8181]

Saurabh is so learned, that he deliberately interrupts the lady when she talks about Allauddin Khilji coming from Afghanistan saying the film showed Jamaluddin coming thus correcting her and then she eventually told the sequence….

[@abdulhaque2354]

अच्छी जानकारी देने के लिए धन्यवाद

[@glimpseonhistory]

Very good discussion saurabh ji ..only you can do this...

[@rohitgavali8018]

मेरे तो धारना ही बदल गई yar पहले पता था कि इतिहास बहुत गलत लिखा हुआ होता है इसलिए अब तो इतिहास से मन ही उठ गया है कि कौन बेहतर था और कौन अच्छा

[@varahmihir4575]

She admitted, she does not know Sanskrit. And then she says, "A historian can be illiterate, why bother about education?". LOL Also, she translates "Chand/Chandi" to "ugly. But actually "chandi" means "fierce", not ugly. LOL!

[@Rudrakshe_PrincessRK]

रामचंद्र कह गए सिया से ऐसा कलयुग आएगा हंस चुगेगा दाना-दुनका हंस चुगेगा दाना-दुनका, कौआ मोती खाएगा

[@mdsalauddinparveez7612]

Ruchika ji lagadiya hame histori ka chaska well. Thises , analyses 🙏✌️🕉️☪️🇮🇳🫀👌👍

[@NurulIslam-kc2jl]

Great young UNBIASED Indian historian of the present day.❤

[@bst292]

❤da ka unbiased historian itihas ka kuch pata nai and gend kuch bhi bol Rahi hai ye pakka Paisa deke pass Hui hai

[@vijayyadav6031]

As per autobiography of Taimur lung,he didn't have polio. His left knee was damaged in the battle of Tashkand, at the age of 33 years.After that he limped for the rest of his life.

[@ashishjoshi11]

Sari Bakwas ki hai isne..

[@ambedkareducation7342]

Tum sabhi Brahmanou logoun hin Buddhism ki nast krneki kasish mein Nalanda University ko Nast kiye aur apna Dosh Dhakne kliye Khilji ke upar Dosh dereho

[@AnadiMishra2]

​@@ambedkareducation7342tum ambedkarities apni he whatsapp university chalate ho 😂

[@ashishjoshi11]

@@Dtara3468 Kaha tak padha hai ?

[@ashishjoshi11]

@@Dtara3468 🤣😂 Dikh raha hai

[@vedprakashyadav5395]

बैठकी बहुत सुंदर था आपका, कृपया इसे जारी रखें। बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद।

[@nitinmuzaffarnagar6919]

Intresting episode 👍👍

[@rituverma1464]

Thank you so much fr making history so engrossing 👌 I loved Ruchika’s saree 🥰

[@jerryraj1446]

Indian history is very Interesting, Demanding some more Interviews with Ma'am 😊

[@golu7986]

Science Journey se debate kijiye...

[@PartiallyAnonymous456]

Saar debate science journey plumber saar , saar please saar Buddhism older than Hinduism saar

[@anishahamed7399]

True Historyen. No political and religious angle. Salute ❤ please come again..

[@udayraj6976]

no plz try to overlap left and right theories the overlap needs to be accepted.

[@syedhisham2594]

@@udayraj6976 if the sources support it then definitely.. but if it is all tell tales then I will not accept the left or the right... like how the inscriptions of quwwatul islam mosque near qutub minar states that it was built by the destruction of 27 temples.. we will definitely accept that but if you say babri masjid was built by the destruction of a ram temple than you will have to provide sources of first that it existed, then it's destruction and then the construction... and as the judgement clearly states we don't know the answer to them.. and the evidence is all superimposed and not studied properly..

[@sirajamani9895]

Saurav aise scholarly programmes hum tak pohnchane k liye aabhar ..

[@khubaibalam5614]

Lagta hai lallantop CHANNEL ab GODI MEDIA ban gaye hai....