J.J. McCarthy vs Drake Maye: The Numbers Will Surprise You

J.J. McCarthy vs Drake Maye. In this video, we delve into the exciting comparison between these two standout quarterbacks, highlighting surprising statistics that reveal their potential in the NFL Draft 2024. Ourlads senior draft analyst Dave Syvertsen joins us to provide expert insights into these promising draft prospects. For full rankings and player breakdowns, order Ourlads' 2024 NFL Draft Expert Guide here: secure.ourlads.com/secure/pri...
Join Ourlads Mock Draft Challenge for a chance to win $500. It's free to enter: www.ourlads.com/nfl-mock-draf...
J.J. McCarthy, a National Champion with the Michigan Wolverines, showcases his impressive skills that make him a top contender in the upcoming draft. On the other hand, Drake Maye, representing the North Carolina Tar Heels, demonstrates his own set of talents that have caught the attention of NFL scouts.
Join us as we break down their performances, compare their numbers, and discuss their potential impact at the professional level. Whether you're a fan of college football, the NFL Draft, or simply interested in the future of these rising stars, this video is a must-watch to uncover the surprising numbers behind J.J. McCarthy and Drake Maye as they gear up for the 2024 NFL Draft. #nfldraft2024 #draftprospects #michiganfootball

[@gregschulte2953]

the people that trash Mccarthy, have no idea what their talking about. All I know about Mccarthy is that when his team needed him the most, in critical situations, he delivered every single time.

[@MetalMike37]

EVERY SINGLE TIME !! JJ is going to surprise a lot of non Michigan fans when he’s starts playing on Sundays.

[@garymartin1045]

If Harbaugh says he's gonna be good, it's gonna be good. It's all you need to know.

[@garymartin1045]

The competition alone is NFL worthy that he played against the other quarterbacks, no, not so much.

[@tomrockhill8634]

As a UM fan I was never worried with him under center. I figured he'd pull it out Everytime because...27-1😤😤

[@matthewhuszarik4173]

Never underestimate that McCarthy was and is just a winner. He lost one game in college. And two games in high school. Very similar to Brady just did what was needed to win.

[@oldham1846]

This kid will be the best QB in this draft class. He will be the next NFL great QB from this class. No one handles pressure better than him. At the next level, QBs will get pressure. You are not in the ACC and PAC 12. Mark my words.

[@dathorndike4908]

Watch him be the next Brock Purdy

[@ryanmceldowney2428]

Buddy is a one throw qb. Can throw a great bullet pass, but has no touch throws or anything like that. Maybe with a good system JJ can succeed, but as of right now I will take Drake over JJ.

[@kmacadaeg7]

@@ryanmceldowney2428So you don’t think he’ll get better?? Your cap on JJ is what he is right now?? Kinda ignorant don’t ya think?

[@ryanmceldowney2428]

@@kmacadaeg7 legit read what I said. Right system he will be good, but rn will prob struggle without a good supporting cast.

[@kmacadaeg7]

@@ryanmceldowney2428 Thats every Qb my guy.

[@nathanlawson313]

In a vacuum, if one QB is far better under pressure, and the other is better with no pressure, I'm clearly taking the one who can handle it.

[@yahooyates]

I think this is the most essential skill in moving to the NFL.

[@toddschneider9705]

@@yahooyatesi agree

[@JackB.Nimble999]

Maybe he had better receivers to throw to under pressure?

[@SubHero261]

Not to mention practicing everyday against elite defense all year

[@fahq6888]

JJ has also played in a pro style offense while at Michigan, which entails alot of adjustments at the line.

[@keithcrook8591]

Justified or not, McCarthy will fly up draft boards and end up a top 10 pick watch.

[@whyhasgooglemessedwithmych1423]

It's more than justified. people are breaking away from the ESPN propaganda, and the boys that know football in the NFL are looking at him are beginning to salivate at what they have forthcoming.

[@randyhelgeson1254]

He would be good in New England. More nfl ready. Proven in the cold.

[@archsys307]

@@randyhelgeson1254we do love white niggas from michigan

[@Tmacademia]

Top 4 pick

[@wesleyblanton2432]

Kwesi make it happen JJ to JJ!

[@jdemille79]

Michigan fan here: The issue with McCarthy, is that the offense he was leading was not a pass-first offense so his sample size is so much smaller and analysts are left to wonder if this is the norm or an outlier with him. But when he was asked to put the game on his back, he delivered. I think he has some work to do but he has the physical tools, is a winner and seems to have the mental capacity (which is 95% of being an NFL quarterback) to succeed if put in the right situation.

[@kirbypuckett2823]

He Will Look Great In PURPLE👍

[@casablanca2745]

Had the same question. Michigan was a run first team so I would like to hear what the actual number of passes each threw last year for a more fair comparison

[@JOHNWAYNE-pd2pg]

I have a question for you. Why did a QB guru coach in Harbaugh didn’t trust McCarthy to run an explosive qb offense. Did he not trust him. Why did he want a run first offense knowing he’s a QB guru. That’s my question.

[@jessemontgomery8987]

​@@JOHNWAYNE-pd2pgisnt he a run first guy? Like did he not come from the shannon tree? Not the young one but his daddy? Maybe it wasnt jj fault but the coachs scheme.

[@NamelessViking01]

​@JOHNWAYNE-pd2pg he did trust JJ, Harbaugh let JJ run the offense if something looks good or bad was let him change plays. Michigan just had a dominant running game and why would you pass just to pass if your run game is so good + it runs down the clock a lot.

[@tramayneford3190]

Thank you! That last drive against Alabama, was amazing to take it to overtime.. No,one is showing that NFL will have you under pressure..

[@matthewmatt5285]

People underestimate JJ's escapabiliy, pocket presence, and manuverabily. He also makes these roll out running TOWARD the target throws where his feet Leave the Air and he's able to get amazing torque on the ball. I don't see ANYONE making athletic throws like that,. and it's Part of his Repetoire : )

[@tomrockhill8634]

There are videos of him from H.S. All Star camps running, jumping, turning in the air and rifling the ball about 30 yd to the back corner of the end zone 😮. He would practice it😂

[@matthewmatt5285]

🙂🙂🙂🙂@@tomrockhill8634

[@RunningWild.]

McCarthy played better competition and is a 3X BIG10 champion and a National champion! Who did Maye even play? What top defense?

[@JohnAC4]

On the same coin Maye had the highest drop rate of 8.2%, higher than any of the big 6. Maye also had a bad offensive line and receivers that couldn’t really separate. And guys like Josh Allen, Mahomes have proved that your competition in college doesn’t really matter since it’s a big leap anyway from college to NFL no matter what conference you’re in

[@tue1981]

That's what a Georgia person (in MN at Amazon where I work) said, Maye did not have as good (a) competition as SEC guys

[@RWildekrav66]

I’ll take the guy that doesn’t buckle under pressure and is a proven winner !

[@DavidSyvertsen]

Hard to argue against that

[@jaredpribyl]

Niether of them do

[@letstalknfl]

You just described Christian Ponder.

[@GuanRytheFantastic]

Let me guess, you also feel Greg McElroy is a HOFer?

[@DavidSyvertsen]

@@GuanRytheFantastic I had him graded as a round 6-7 QB

[@jasonpeterson8]

Thank you for this… Drake Maye is truly the one that’s overrated…. #GoBlue✊🏾💛💙

[@calvinhobbes6118]

Michigan Fans: We told you so.

[@cullendillard6696]

BET!

[@matthewhuszarik4173]

I think barring injury that JJ McCarthy has the best NFL career out of all the available quarterbacks this year. Reminds me a lot of Joe Montana.

[@archsys307]

Pats getting him

[@BloodySoup74]

​@@archsys307They are going Daniels

[@waynefriedman7728]

Pats are either drafting Maye or trading the pick to the Vikings. Pats are 100% NOT picking JJ with #3.

[@matthewhuszarik4173]

@@waynefriedman7728 The Pats should wait to the sixth round. It seems to be the only round they can find a quality quarterback in.

[@archsys307]

@@waynefriedman7728 We trading down for the entire sixth round. If there’s a Brady in this years draft we getting that nigga

[@T.D.61]

I’m a Bears fan and our GM Poles is looking for the QB that is mentally strong with good leadership skills. McCarthy who is from Illinois and could be the target after a trade down. McCarthy’s 3rd down conversion rate is unreal.

[@edwardgray2102]

Bears fan here as well I’m leaning towards Nix or McCarthy a trade down would be good

[@aaronjulius9148]

You'll take Caleb Williams and you'll like it

[@thecourier7964]

The dude in the video wasn’t comparing McCarthy to Williams for a reason. People loved to hate on stroud before he moved to the league, look where he is now.

[@cornpop8570]

​@@aaronjulius9148 The only reason why the Chicago bears want Caleb Williams is because he is not white they are racist! 😡

[@JakeK3339]

lol the Bears aren't trading down. They're taking Caleb Williams

[@301gobluehailmich1]

our QB!, our LEGEND!, our GOAT!.....GO BLUE!

[@markhall6306]

I want JJ as Vikings fan not Maye hell naw

[@markhall6306]

Skol blue get JJ

[@donfain6608]

I’ve always liked JJ but have been sold on him as a high first rounder. The more I see and listen, the more he appeals to me and that’s BEFORE this video. I’m now firmly on the JJ bandwagon. He has the physical tools, pro-style offense experience, youth, and toughness to be a franchise QB. I hope the Raiders land him since they won’t land Jayden.

[@visforvegan8]

Ooh, shots fired Good analysis. I'd be comfortable with the Giants going McCarthy now.

[@aaronalbrecht4404]

Appreciate the review. McCarthy is my favorite QB in this draft. Sure, he's young and may need a year to develop, I only watched a couple of Maye's games in college, but in those, I came away with his concerns about his decision making under pressure. The arm talent with Maye is unquestionable, but I worry that he'll struggle with composure and turnovers at the nfl level. McCarthy seems to thrive under pressure which to me is the #1 trait to look for in a QB.

[@paulmayer8654]

And it wasn’t just the under pressure against a pass rush. It’s also in high pressure situations. Every time they needed him to make a play to win a game, that’s exactly what he did. He is as clutch as clutch is.

[@nicolastomas8436]

McCarthy is underrated and prob better than Daniels

[@RWildekrav66]

Not probably.

[@tomrockhill8634]

I'm a UM fan and love JJ but Daniels pretty damn good too😂

[@PSU2024]

I've been telling everyone JJM is being overlooked. If JJM played on UNC spread offense and Maye on Michigan you would see JJM with similar numbers as Maye did. You put Maye on Michigan and he has similar stats to JJM but will he carry his team a Natty like JJM?

[@whyhasgooglemessedwithmych1423]

you're nuts. the reason why jj excelled is because he performed the best under the most pressure. you may on michigan and they don't even win a big10 champ let alone get into the playoffs.

[@WPD3947]

Just a thought Bear Fans! Trade #1 to N.E for #3, take JJ McCarthy, get 2 more quality wide receivers, a solid tight end to help Cole. A solid running back from the draft

[@Silverfox501]

Awesome job with the breakdowns and comparisons! One of the most honest and truthful comparison video’s I’ve seen so far!

[@WoodyGoBlue]

People are starting to see what Michigan fans were blessed to watch the past few years. Dude really is special and if we had to throw the ball 50 times to win like others he would have put up insane stats too. He only cares about winning It was actually insane to watch this year on 3rd and passing situations, it started to feel like JJ was damn near automatic whenever it mattered most

[@Yesquire0]

Sports Illustrated compiled an interesting stat: Passes on third down that resulted in a first down. JJ ws #1 last year, and about 20% or 30% better than anybody else in FBS, includng Williams, Daniels, Penix, and Nix.

[@WoodyGoBlue]

@@Yesquire0 yup and if you watched every snap like I did, you noticed it and 3rd and long should never feel automatic, but it did with JJ for most of this past year I have seen some say it but most don’t mention at all the fact he got hurt 1st half against PSU, didn’t practice almost the entire week before Maryland, and it was still lingering until he had time to rest it after B1G championship game

[@Yesquire0]

Also, detractors of J.J. are quick to dismiss the opinions of Michigan fans as biased. Michigan had a good QB in Cade McNamara who was at the helm when Blue defeated the Buckeyes for the first time in about a decade. But even back then, fans were clamoring for J.J. to take over the starting QB position. In the playoff semi-final against Georgia, McNamara looked bad under pressure and Harbaugh put J.J. in later in the game when it looked like Michigan was hopelessly behind, and J.J. managed to move the ball. Sometimes you can just see when a guy is way better than the competition. J.J. took the job away from McNamara in 2022. Literally nobody wanted McNamara to continue as the starter. It was that clear that Michigan needed J.J. in order to beat the nation's elite teams and win the natty. Meanwhile, McNamara entered the portal and went to Iowa, where he was viewed as the savior of Iowa football. We fans have been able to compare J.J to a very good college QB and easily see how spectaculary better he was and has been for two years. The dichotomy of opinions about J.J. is very strange, especially with all the video evidence of his success and his skill set.

[@WoodyGoBlue]

@@Yesquire0 sounds like you and I have probably been in the same boat during this process. Since JJ declared I have been ADAMANT about the fact that JJ will go top 10 and he’s a top 3 QB at worst in the draft. I live in Ohio so I am surrounded by people who have been adamant that JJ is a 2nd rounder at best and it was baffling hearing so many talkings heads saying the same. I just kept saying wait until the combine he will skyrocket, but now they all seem to realize that the people that actually KNOW football have much different opinions on what they see on his tape. He might need a year or two to grow up and bit and get used to the speed but JJ has the most obvious IT factor intangible I have seen to be honest. Dude is NAILS

[@tomrockhill8634]

I'm a UM fan and we rarely worried on 3s down😂

[@dking6455]

Great work as usual Sy. Should be an interesting couple months.

[@OurladsFootball]

Thank you. Buckle up

[@studygodsword5937]

@@OurladsFootball The thing you only slightly addressed, is how much easier it is when you have a top notch running game ! I will choose Penex, and the 2 high ranking o-line people you can get with the draft picks, THAT YOU DON'T GIVE UP (MN) !

[@benbred79]

Imma umich fan....having jj as our qb.....idc whos on the board....idc if who is available in free agency...id want jj...that kid is all about his teamates. He very intelligent...i think he needed 1 more yr in college but i understand why he left...as long as he has a yr to get a system down, pack on little weight, n just get slightly better with decision making....this kid is going to be great

[@kevin041777]

So many commentators sit up on the fence refusing to take a chance or make any bold predictions for fear they might have to admit they were wrong down the road. You've got "BIG ONES" man. I absolutely love your commentary. Thanks for making an argument and taking a stand. I've never seen or heard of you before. You just popped up on my screen. I liked and subscribed. I think J.J.M. will adapt and do great in the NFL.

[@DavidSyvertsen]

Thanks Kevin. Nobody knows what’s going to happen. Nobody. Might as well lean on your own thoughts rather than parrot everyone else. I’ve been wrong before and I’ll be wrong again.

[@wdtipvr1888]

Drake Maye is going to be the better, more flashy NFL qb of the whole 2024 class. I'd take Drake Maye over JJ McCarthy all day. But that being said, JJ McCarthy is going to a stud in the NFL. And I think he's going to win alot of games for a team. Personally, I'm a bucs fan. I would be ecstatic if JJ McCarthy was there at 26. Bucs should draft him in a heartbeat. He is going to be a great franchise qb. Hes so young and raw but still so damn talented with the work ethic to match. Also, I think Bo Nix and Penix Jr are going to be good franchise qbs too. It's a great qb class. This might be the class that gives us the Brady, Peyton Manning, Big Ben, Rodgers, Brees top qbs getting big numbers consistently, that the NFL has been missing.

[@ERizzo5]

Who knows what this class will be in the nfl. But I agree, this generation is not as talented as the previous one. Rodgers, Brees, Brady, Peyton > Mahomes, Jackson, Burrow (can’t stay healthy), Allen. JJ McCarthy will be the best of his class. Watch

[@davegcomedy1267]

Great stats and breakdowns ✊

[@mikecarr2085]

JJ about to climb the rankings after the combine.

[@EnzoMoresi-mj8bc]

This is some great analysis. Just subbed. I would add "pressure" is relative to the athlete as well. For JJ, pressure is different than "pressure" on May because of JJ's confidence in eluding the rush. Will be interesting to see how both pan out.

[@jcoopdo]

Jj to minnesota to be developed here by O'Connell and co. We have everything needed to support an encourage a young qb besides a solid offensive line. Its decent, but he's going to have pressure but as long as he can stay cool we can work around that with him. Im rooting for him here in mn.

[@kennethmcdonough835]

First time watching Ourlads. Syvertsen has some great insight. Just as good as a lot of those guys at the networks. Must have football experience he sounds on point.

[@derekgorski3331]

This is really really awesome Sy, thank you

[@DavidSyvertsen]

Thank you sir!

[@robertc7072]

Agree 100%. We've seen what happens to "pocket"passers in Minnesota even as good as Cousins was he was unable to scramble and extend plays. Vikes never had a solid offensive line so I'd lean McCarthy to Minnesota. He'd give you that ability to extend plays, makes throws across his body and throws on the run not to mention already well coached. Maye has a beautiful deep ball but you'd better have a stout O Line for him to be successful. There's also that "swagger" component. I feel McCarthy gives off that vibe that motivates an offense and plays with a bit of that swagger. Able to play under pressure is a natural "gift" not all the time learned. Brady had it (and yes I know he's not Brady lol). As a Vikings fan I'll take either or but will be somewhat disappointed if they don't land McCarthy. Come'on.. JJ to JJ!

[@ghupe03]

Off had the Vikings at 5th best Oline last yr ... 2 great tackles

[@gregschulte2953]

Would have to agree. Was listening to Schlerer (I think) and he mentioned and I agree-that what made all these guys special in college, 70% of it does not translate to the nfl. He said the one exception was McCarthy, who ran a 100% pro style offense. Al the other qbs ran a static spread that is non existent in the NFL as it is very simple.

[@florida1289]

Sounds like Maye is Jared Goff which is a great QB but not under pressure Needs an elite oline JJ will be the better QB Wait until they test and interview

[@cullendillard6696]

Mental toughness trumps highlight reels! JJ is cut from the same mold of another Michigan Great, TB12! GO BLUE!

[@breezeb8720]

This is some great content!

[@DavidSyvertsen]

Thanks we have some more fun stuff coming up!

[@richardbosh4522]

Agree coach I said a 1 year ago JJ Mccarthy before his National Championship Win I said this kid is a Beast QB1 quality that New England Patriots needs❤

[@VikesTrendingUp]

Man. That's some good stuff. As more scouting info comes out, the more I'm leaning towards JJ.

[@iamwhoiam7482]

Deadhead and Vikings fan?? Did we just become best friends😂😂 NFA✌🏻

[@Gr8Nuzz]

Dang man. Never thought I’d want the giants to draft JJ at 6 but I’m all for it now. I was hoping they would draft Odunze at 6 and then trade back into the mid-late first round to get JJ like that but probably not happening. Maybe a possible scenario still with Penix though

[@matthewmatt5285]

Giants not taking a QB would be a nightmare decision at #6,. They can't keep thinking Danielle Jones or Danny DeVito is going to help them win,. I don't care WHAT player they take at #6,.. If it isn't a QB they aren't going to be better anytime soon,. Maybe draft back for Nix but they HAVE to get a QB~

[@Gr8Nuzz]

@@matthewmatt5285 one thing i really hope for was Odunze at 6 and take Penix somehow by trading back into first or if he falls.

[@calvinhobbes6118]

Penix has bad knees and has hit his ceiling. Id take at least 5 other QBs before him.

[@matthewmatt5285]

@@calvinhobbes6118 Michigan beat him to a Pulp~

[@Sonisoon]

JJ McCARTHY IS GOING TO BE A GIANT

[@richardwhite6062]

DISAPPOINTMENT

[@KindHumbleWise]

Or Drake Maye

[@stevesalisbury3657]

​@richardwhite6062 you were?

[@richardwhite6062]

@stevesalisbury3657 He has a long way to go to be a quality NFL qb. Intangibles? Sure although I get Zach Wilson vibes. But he throws into coverage with his eyes closed. Doesn't react to post snap and panics into his presnap reads if protection breaks down. Very bad for the nfl. Has no accuracy or touch on his passes. Also very bad for the nfl. Wherever he goes, pray you have a veteran to ease him along under. But if you throw him to the wolves, he will have a poor td to pick ratio with his current habits that will take time to iron out.

[@stevesalisbury3657]

@richardwhite6062 if you think that than you don't realize he's been running nfl type offense for 2 years... just becuase he didn't throw 40 times a gane means natta

[@KongchengVang]

JJ to the Vikes at 7, if ATL doesn't get Fields. Maye will go at 3 or 4.

[@staceykillings4229]

The NY Giant's aren't going to let themselves be outmaneuvered sitting at 6.

[@eriksvideos6022]

Good takes here. 👍

[@secondstring]

So, do you have those same metrics comparing McCarthy with Caleb and/or Daniel’s?

[@mannyaraujo1]

Jj McCarthy tom brady. 2.0. Both played in Michigan, looks plays like brady, much better foot work.. a stud

[@cooldad895hess8]

Well said. Most of these qb’s can throw the ball well. In my mind, the best qb is the one who makes it happen when you need it most. Can he get that 1st down when it’s 3rd & 27. Or throw that touchdown when there’s 3 seconds left in the game and your down 6 points. The guy’s that perform the best under the most intense pressure are the winner’s in the NFL. They end up making the best possible decision in the worst possible scenario’s. Instead of buckling under pressure, they notch another W in their belt. JJ McCarthy did a lot of that at Michigan, which is why he has a 27-1 next to his name.

[@kevinmcwalters7172]

Great stuff. Hoping Giants land Maye, McCarthy or Daniels

[@DavidSyvertsen]

Thanks for the support Kevin

[@staceykillings4229]

​@@DavidSyvertsen You shocked me with which qb you'd take ! 😮 Great work as per usual.

[@seanmesaehable]

jj just wins and he played his best in big games

[@arizonawildcat3821]

The issue with JJ is, while looking great on tape, there isn't enough tape to really give a proper analysis. We have no idea how he preforms when he's fully running the offense. Michigan understandably relied heavily on their 2 top 10 RB's. When you are centered around running the ball, it's obviously a lot easier to catch the defense off guard with the passing game. Not only that, but these defenses are primarily preparing to try and handle the run game. Regardless, I can't think of a single star NFL QB that passed for under 3,000 yards in a season and that's in 12 games. JJ Passed for less in 15 games. JJ had in 15 games 332 Attempts, which is below #50 in the country, and 2,991 yards which is #35 in the country. Removing the 3 extra games that leaves him at 257 attempts (#97 in the country) 2483 yards (#60 in the country). This is very concerning for an NFL Scout. I'll be the first to say that stats don't matter very much, but in this case this is a severe lack of stats and actual QB play. I hope I'm wrong, but ultimately JJ Is a risk to draft.

[@marianchicago4002]

While I am not a Michigan fan and only watched a handful of his games over 2 years, when I first saw him, he reminded me of Trent Dilfer, he’s developed over 2 years and in this year’s playoffs, he reminded me of Matthew Stafford, I think he is a project in Ben Rothlesberger mould, he will need to be brought along slowly and develop, he’s used to hard coaching, McCarthy, Broncos and Shaun Payton seem like a good fit together.

[@grbggaming6885]

People thinking he didn't throw more because Harbaugh didn't trust him really know nothing about football.

[@terryhodges6986]

JJ all away

[@vkon1]

Who releases the ball quicker? And does this have anything to do with the reason for facing pressure? I think that they will both do really well at the pro level.

[@JohnSmith-of1tl]

Great look at both QB’s. Didn’t know about all the under pressure stats that were brought up here. JJ to the Broncos, Raiders, Seahawks, or Giants. Maye to the Commanders.

[@orlandohinojosa6673]

New England should pick him up,they do well drafting Michigan Qb's

[@johnpreston3706]

Michigan vs Penn State was a great win for Penn State. JJ gets a great win and he was not allowed to throw a pass. JJs stats in the Championship game - Was hidden by a coach that knew him better than anyone.

[@JOHNWAYNE-pd2pg]

I have a question for you. Why did a QB guru coach in Harbaugh didn’t trust McCarthy to run an explosive qb offense. Did he not trust him. Why did he want a run first offense knowing he’s a QB guru. That’s my question

[@secretasianman2531]

national championship. that's the answer.

[@DavesWestsideEdit]

Awesome!

[@JoeSmith-ln9rh]

Who had the better offensive weapons around them? When under pressure those guys could be making the difference getting open/out fighting defenders for the ball. Everybody can throw out numbers one way or another that backs up their point of view. It be easy if we were comparing oranges to oranges but we are not.

[@marty5300]

I think McCarthy is my guy after looking at this class. Overall I don't really like this class, there is no standout blue chipper this year like Stroud (the Stroud vs young debate was ridiculous, there was no contest between them imo and that was before he lit the league on fire) This guy doesn't have the elite qb skills of a CJ Stroud, but he's good enough, and more athletic and so young. Of this class I like this guy the best.

[@ericp7413]

What team's situation would be best for JJ? I would love for him to study under Matt Stafford in LA for a few and then start when he ultimately retires in a few seasons.

[@jona.scholt4362]

@3:04 That was one of the most impressive throws I saw all year, maybe the most impressive, from any college QB. People who say crap like, "JJ is r accurate, he doesn't have a strong arm, etc etc", I present to you: Exhibit A

[@OurladsFootball]

Good call.

[@secretasianman2531]

the reality is that most folks don't have the time to dig down deep enough to appreciate what jj mccarthy has to offer and they rely on certain numbers which just don't tell the whole story. the best part is that jj doesn't care what haters think.

[@jodyfoster9278]

JJ will great for the Patriots.

[@jeffcoleman5947]

Of all the stats, how you produced on third down or under pressure really is by far the most important stat. It might be the ONLY stat that matters. If a QB can sling a deep ball while NOT under pressure, I say SO WHAT?! Any strong armed qb can produce without pressure. Guess what? Compared to college the QB will ALWAYS be under pressure. McCarthy still needs work, I hope he sits on the bench his first years or two, but he will be very good in the NFL.

[@outoftheblue7445]

JJ is elite. I’d take him over every QB in the class 10 times out of 10. Plus Brady is mentoring him.

[@johnvfx143]

The Patriots should seriously consider taking JJ at 3, or even trade down to 4 or 5 for an extra pick or two, and still take JJ. The O line is still under construction, might take a season or two to get figured out.

[@shamelessdaddy8707]

I came into this process of evaluating QB prospects for the upcoming draft with JJ at #6 or #7 best QB in this draft. The more I dig the more I think he's the cream of the crop. I seriously wouldn't be surprised if he's the 2nd QB off the board.

[@paulmayer8654]

This is what I’ve been telling people. I wouldn’t have been surprised if Harbaugh traded off Herbert to Atlanta for a ton of picks to fix their cap situation and then draft JJ there at #5 😂😂 but you just can’t do that

[@ConversionCenters]

Thank you for the breakdown! Prefer McCarthy over Maye, but, Harbaugh did not ask him to throw very much. McCarthy was 22 pass attempts per game and Maye about 36 pass attempts per game. McCarthy is young and has the ceiling along with he's a winner. Maybe not the next Michigan QB GOAT candidate, but, out of all the top prospects? He looks like he's worth a higher pick. #1 Williams #7 Daniels #12 McCarthy #17 Maye The desperate NFL GM "looking for the savior" thing distorts the draft positions. Thanks for your analysis, guys, always look forward to the next.

[@strangesightsinthesky]

saw both these qb's last year a lot and have a scouting eye for talent.are you saying maybe that drake maye is bledsoe and jj is brady?

[@dj7973]

Drake and JJ are my 1-2.

[@calvinhobbes6118]

Youd take a proven loser over a proven winner? Interesting tactic.

[@kft590]

J.J. McCarthy had one of the highest completion rates on third and long in college history. Also he completed over 70% of his passes when he was scrambling.

[@OurladsFootball]

Great stats!

[@JayByrd83]

I'm so stoked for this draft. You watch. The 1st 6 picks in this draft is going to be wild. What if Caleb doesn't go to Chicago? Can Chicago take a UNC QB again after the last one they picked? Do the Patriots take the Heisman winner, or the Michigan QB? After all of the success they had with another Michigan QB?? I don't think that Arizona is budging unless they get a haul of a trade. They need a playmaker at WR. I'm hoping they pick Nabers, so that Harrison Jr. can land right in my Giants lap. I'm expecting the Chargers to trade here, unless Harrison is available, they might have no other choice but to keep the pick after trading Allen and cutting Mike Williams.

[@Giggle-stick64]

JJ has just as good of a arm he can run just as fast and he has a high completion percentage and is the most ready by running a pro offense under center he is a ++ pro prospect

[@mikeymike2524]

I think that this is your typical case of drafting a “prospect” or drafting a “player”. Maye strikes me as a more of a prospect with potential as he has that big frame and big arm… however jj is more of a dog he’s definitely a winner, can throw well, has nfl level coaching behind his belt and runs well I think jj is for sure the more complete nfl ready guy

[@derekgorski3331]

Sy, the top 3 receivers all seem to be franchise players: these qbs also seem to be high level as well. Can you give us a sneak peek of your stack of these seven players?

[@DavidSyvertsen]

Not yet. But to your initial statement is in the ballpark.

[@mikeses4392]

JJ put those numbers up against some of the best defenses in the nation. And he beat an Alabama team with 24 five star recruits on the roster while Michigan had only two…

[@clintonpollard1120]

Great oline rb when was he under pressure?

[@Krawllll]

If my team gets either of the 2, i will be very very happy!

[@evadd2]

One thing I would like is level of competition. JJ has seen everything big.

[@tue1981]

So Maye's comp is maybe Kirk Cousins, and JJMc has the winning moxie Jim Harbaugh's (and his staff's) recruiting of JJMc and his (Harbaugh's) recommendation means something

[@randyhelgeson1254]

You also have to watch some video. ball placement not just read the completion percentage. Didn't JJ get extra coaching by Life Coach Greg Harden? He has also proven himself in cold weather.

[@desmondwilliams4068]

I dont know Drake Maye, but I am a Michigan fan, and sometimes McCarthy has really bad misses on throws. I love JJ to death, but if he were more accurate, with his age, pedigree, college winning record, athleticism and room to grow physically you would think he would easily be top 5. Someone needs to put together lowlight tapes on players. I would love to see Drake Maye and Jayden Daniels lowlights because I did not watch them as much as C Williams, Penix and McCarthy...

[@WeDontHaveToBreed88]

Watching a video of all Maye's throws and runs, I can't say I've seen him throw from under center, it's shotgun or pistol formations and that's concerning for me. I've watched McCarthy run play-action from under center and do it better than Cousins

[@ianpeyer4880]

Every good rookie QB will develop into a better player and after that happens you tell me who you will take, bet it will be Drake. I like JJ but I wouldn't sell Drake short. There is a reason he is ranked higher

[@FhillipFry]

JJ had a better team around him. With that said, he seems pro ready and a better athlete.

[@aleckfedorkiw4005]

JJ Mc Carthy is a decent QB but don't understand since he never had to carry his team. While Drake May showed he can do that and believe last year he had protection problems and some receivers left.

[@smercxz]

I’m not a Maye guy at all but JJ is kinda growing on me. With that said it leads me to my question. All the stats you stated are facts but don’t you think the level of talent Maye played with compared to JJ plays a HUUUUGE factor? Drake Maye lost some guys to the nfl and still proceeded to put up some pretty amazing numbers for what he had to work with. Just want your opinion, respectfully not trying to come off as ignorant or anything. I don’t like Mayes footwork or his elongated throwing motion so I’m out on him but I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t interested in em if he could clean that up with the right coaching.

[@alexcolbert4395]

JJ to the Falcons

[@JohnSmith-of1tl]

Didn’t think about the Falcons and McCarthy. That would be wild.

[@kmacadaeg7]

Man, as a Michigan and Lions fan, I’ll be devastated if the Vikings draft JJ.

[@joeshawcroft7121]

I love both JJ and Maye. If the Broncos landed either I'd be thrilled.

[@khalilscott3921]

I think the Vikings get JJ McCarthy and the commanders get Drake Maye

[@Kskol-ld7cq]

I HOPE the Vikings get McCarthy

[@davecavalieri]

Numbers are numbers but the bottom line is Maye had a bad team around him, McCarthy did not. I do like them both over Daniels. My pick would be Maye.

[@bernardthefourth]

McCarthy and Maye should be second round prospects but teams are so desperate they will draft them at the top and probably wind up with Daniel Jones or Zach Wilson. Both of those guys were easily second round prospects at best that got pushed up. Everyone acts like they knew better but now the same people are pushing Drake and McCarthy.

[@fyuriusryage5353]

I think it's hard to compare these two right now. Maye lost a lot of talent in the 2023 (spring) draft, and it showed. His line was weak, he definitely was skittish about pressure, but he looked great in 2022 season. Whereas JJMac had a championship quality roster around him. The lack of reps though, it's funny because some people have literally written him off already. Foolish!

[@elbee1771]

I'm taking Drake Maye. "Winners" don't necessarily translate to the NFL level. Top 5 winningest QB's in NCAA history...Kellen Moore, Colt McCoy, Andy Dalton, David Greene, and Peyton Manning. The problem with college QB's is there is no underlying factor that says a QB will be legit at the next level. Not even passing efficiency translates all the time. If the NFL knew what translates, there would be way less misses.

[@paulkaiser9851]

I can't wait to hear The Voice of The Vikings, Paul Allen screaming 'TOUCHDOWN JJ to JJ!!' If you've never heard Paul Allen, look up a video, he's so good!

[@thecorvus100]

Give JJs star O line to Drake Maye and then do the numbers. 😉

[@thecorvus100]

And all the other weapons.

[@giuseppecarpanzano6689]

I"D love for JJ to land in Minnesota. He's not a finished product yet, but has a lot of talent and intangibles. Maye has a lot of bust qualities that worry me.