Jaguar F-Pace v BMW X3 v Mercedes GLC v Land Rover Discovery Sport - Carbuyer

[@jtrekmadone]

I agree with there reviews actually. I just turned in the land rover discovery sport off a lease and got put in a jaguar f pace. The handling on the road and interior are a notch better. In the winter will be the true test when we get snow, the land rover drove through everything I want to see how the jaguar makes out.

[@nialahmad]

I'd go for the GLC or the new Q5.

[@martinlang9615]

One of the best "condensed" reviews I have ever seen....oh, with a tiny bit of humour thrown in. Very well done.

[@royalstf]

the most biased review I have seen!

[@danielroberts8835]

Totally agree with this order, u gotta love the F-Pace

[@prayerpowersr854]

can you do a review of the national express travel card? these cars are a little out of my price range

[@EinkOLED]

Bus w@anker

[@prayerpowersr854]

Your mum

[@yassine-ayad]

@@prayerpowersr854 I think if you are looking for a good car you should go for the honda crv it is a perfect car and it is so practical but if you have just a little higher budget you should go for either a skoda kodiaq or a skoda kamiq (notice: I tried all of these cars)

[@gusbandicoot]

A good balanced review. I personally think it's GOOD that each car (along with others not reviewed here - XC60, Q5) all have their place and are slightly different to each other. Comfort, sport, off road ability, image, practicality etc.. each one excels at some but not all. My choice is still currently xc60 and the new one should be excellent.

[@Kumdoin]

I totally agree with this review, however, I ended up buying the GLC as F-Pace only offered dismal discount

[@sweetfreedomGB]

A great and very grown up review, better than anything on tv. Well done both of you.

[@MrTrull1]

Excellent video - my favourite of the year, I think. You two are a great double-act!

[@AHCy0]

Mercedes may look distinctive on the road but it doesn't amongst other Mercedes. They're all way too similarly looking for my liking, but that's my opinion

[@peterambrose2148]

Same story for bmw. their fronts look exactly the sane

[@doodieberry8788]

Same story for audi. their fronts & back look exactly the same. plain,dull,boring. just different in sizes.

[@AHCy0]

Doodie Berry While this is true, I do think Mercedes is still the best at copying and pasting car designs

[@henningvauleberntsen7369]

I thought that the BMW would win! Since he said so many nice things about it! Great review btw!

[@rmixfaats]

Henning Vaule Berntsen i though the same and that made me happy BMW 😍 but the new x3 is coming so...

[@stephenwinship4685]

Great insight guys, appreciated, i get my 18 plate Jaguar F Pace R Sport next week, fair to say your review helped me make up my mind 👏

[@alxactly]

Really? The jaguar best looks? Well unless you pay over 60k for the top trim, you get your standard everyday soccer mom car.

[@nosecomosellama]

Woody Brits testing British cars = fuck everything else

[@MrTrull1]

Aaarrrggghhh!

[@markopolo9559]

nosecomosellama Not sure if you watched the same video but there was a BMW and MERCEDES being tested(obviously Greman!)

[@bensmyth6976]

Marko Polo thank you so much for proving my point!!! You made my day!!!!!!!!!

[@morganoxer5560]

Woody you don’t have to pay £60,000 for the nice looking one you can get that for around £38,000 and that’s the same for the other pretty much but in the trim they had there looked horrible, especially those wheels

[@yudhabagaskara98]

1. F-Pace 2. GLC 3. X3 4. Discovery Sport

[@RockHash]

Maybe some ppl actually like hearing the engine rawr, like me. First place is the Range, Jag, Benz, Beamer.

[@steeple001]

Great Review and I would say pretty accurate. My wife has the X3 35m diesel at the moment and it's been a fantastic car. Test drove the GLC recently and with the smaller engine it was way to underpowered and felt like a boat. We also looked at the bigger engined F pace and its great a huge amount of fun but as another comment states feels much more "plasticky". We have had a Range Rover sport before and it's unreliability has put us off Land Rover forever. In the end the winner for the new family car was the Porsche Macaan, yes its way more expensive and there is the excessive price tag you pay for Badge but it was absolutely wonderful in just about every respect. One thing which was a pain was all the buttons but other than that it wasn't possible to fault the car and the smile you get when you drive the thing makes the eye watering price tag worth while for us.

[@wattouk47noob54]

Steven Singh *Macan

[@tckzcombatcrew5625]

Land Rover is best; Best looking, most customisable, and the best off road. After all, a 4x4's intentions are to be able to be good at off roading, rather than a 'false' off roader. Maybe I'm biased because I have bought into the Land Rover brand multiple times before, but you can look at it like this " next time there is a blizzard/ flood ect outside the supermarket, do you want to look like a div or not?

[@dummy3646]

TCKZ Crew I love SUVs that are real 4X4s, but the kind of people that buy these vehicles are not interested in driving up a mountain or carving through dense forest. While a Land Rover has legendary off road capability, the majority of users won't use it. After all, would you take £40000 with you into the mud?

[@richardbenn5034]

Crap reliability

[@rraj4988]

Hahah! The worst Engine ever

[@DonLee1980]

The land rover disco was like the worst reliability of all luxury SUVs. That must count for something when you buy a car...

[@JC-xw7ml]

Don Lee Hi mate, had mine 3 years, not a single problem with it, been superb. Taken it off road a fair bit here in Australia too, sand, deep mud no problem, super comfortable on gravel bumpy dirt tracks also. Infotainment is a bit laggy but the meridian stereo more than makes up for it (better than Burmester in C63s Merc) Just thought I'd put this out there as there is so much negativity on LR vehicles.

[@DonLee1980]

J C people have cancers and survived, people have chain smoked for 40 years and are still alive. Don’t mean cancers and cigarettes aren’t bad

[@JC-xw7ml]

Don Lee Just saying mine isn't. Jheeez, bet you're a laugh down the pub

[@DonLee1980]

J C nope, cuz you won’t find me at the pub. Enjoy your car and good luck

[@gerasimosrico]

I'm a huge BMW fan, but seriously the X3 should get more concern by BMW's engineer

[@theblueeyes3889]

Jaguar is beautiful, but the Land Rover is the best. Britain wins in my eyes

[@VYM]

Excuse me, what? Brits? You mean Indians? 26 March 2008: Ford agreed to sell the Jaguar and Land Rover operations to Tata Motors. June 2008: Tata Motors finalised their purchase of Jaguar and Land Rover from Ford and put them into their new subsidiary, Jaguar Land Rover.

[@Elijah-cy9do]

@@VYM so it became Indian when bought by Tata from British when owned by Ford? I dont get it, is Ford a British company? BTW, JLR is based and registered in Coventry and Tata even called JLR British in their website. The cars themselves are undeniably British being designed, engineered and made in the UK with little to no interference from Tata as JLR is very independent as a subsidiary, to the point that they didnt want to give opinions about the XF when it came out in 2008, and JLR even stopped reporting monthy sales to Tata shortly after that.

[@antonioaa8101]

Carbuyer please stop promoting british car manufacturers... the jag is not a car to compare with a merc a bmw or a land rover, because with a british point of view especially it humiliates the other cars because of that sporty way of driving and slick and expensive look, and dont get me wrong but with all those expensive options it will have a higher price tag. For instance compare it's petrol power engine version with a porsche macan or a maserati levante, that would have been more interesting, and fare as the jaguar is promoted as a sporty suv. Also, a better video is comparing x3 glc the new q5 the disc sport the evoque or the nx because they are not cars that are all about rapidly fast engines sport driving position and etc but, they show how practical they are, how comfortable and convienient they are for families, how economic they are and even their off-road capabilities. For me this video is pointless because having said that the jag is more expensive, it has the worst interior and it's really ugly from the back. Did the fancy plastics and the stupid standard infortaiment system of the jag made you more excited than the gorgeous glc's interior or the perfect bmw's system? Also, who the hell who ownes a jaguar will go off road, as the land rover is a thousand steps far away in off-roading. You can't avoid that the germans are the best in the business as they nailed the mid size, very good overall suv game, beacause of their great driving experience in town or highway(like the x3), stylish exterior or interior(like the glc) and their practicallity. And for me the true and honest ranking for the video without including the f pace is: 1.GLC 2.X3 3.Discovery Sport. I haven't said that the f pace is not a good car, actually is a great sporty fast suv in my opinion. But with making this video you brought it at another car category which makes it not as shine and special, and the main purpose of the video is getting lost. I can tell that you must take few lessons from Matt Watson at carwow....

[@onepunch9]

The jag F PACE and the DISCO SPORT are the same car, engine all the running gear the floor panel are exactly the same. Its the same story with the jag E PACE and the RANGE ROVER EVOQUE. And are both Indian owned by TATA

[@0000-d9p]

1. Mercedes-Benz GLC 2. BMW X3 3. Jaguar F-pace 4. Land Rover Discovery Sport

[@value2127]

GLC is the best.

[@giorgiegetashvili4924]

Value 21 i agree on that

[@joshuaquan-buchanan6850]

@@giorgiegetashvili4924 it actually has a steering problem that juggered and bangs at full lock and eats up tyres, look up videos on youtube

[@louischan3052]

British always praise their own

[@MrTrull1]

Nonsense.

[@doodieberry8788]

that is the problem for Brits reviewers

[@MrTrull1]

Doodie Berry. It actually isn't. It just seems to be a problem for people like you.

[@damian1228]

Aaaaand the Landrover broke down.

[@arnavsingh8558]

nailed it.

[@emililorenzo3835]

next year i want to see this also with audi q5 and the brand new volvo xc60 when she will come out.

[@Arlind22]

For me GLC, F-Pace, X3 and Discovery Sport. Personally my favorite is still the BMW and it still holds strong even though the car is the oldest from all of them with a big margin.

[@factsaroundtheworld123]

I think the f pace is the best. It's not that loud inside, I personally think it's pretty quite

[@mrlilmatt123]

The BMW does NOT have the best quality interior.. I don't know you you 'test' this metric.

[@shaid8973]

jags and rangeys are the best bye miles

[@kuddin9021]

1) Discovery Sport 2) Merc GLC 3) Jag F Pace 4) Bmw X3

[@animegang705]

K Uddin RIGHT NUMBER 1 SHOULD BE DISCO SPORT

[@aayangoverski3437]

The X3 isn’t really that bad. It has plenty or features and very nice interior quality. The interior design is nice, but now it looks a bit old. But still, respect goes to Land Rover, Mercedes, BMW, and Jaguar

[@EKcars33]

7:44 while reviewing the X3 they show the GLC's back end :D

[@mbizozo6271]

The Jag in that trim is UGLY, and that interior looks cheap. The trim you've chosen for the test in the Merc lets it down, the Land Rover is expensive. The X3 is the oldest and yet the interior is the best in terms of material used and how everything fits together. The exterior is dated but I'd still take the X3 over the others.

[@erodigie]

Sthembiso Lebuso thanks mate, I agree too

[@williamunga]

Looks like they were advertising the jagua

[@Aurora_v_cali]

There was so much road noise in the jag and landrover

[@debasishdas4006]

Outstanding review!!!

[@YourTechGerman]

I actually love the X3 interior design but the Jaguar takes my personal no°1 spot

[@turquoisecat761]

Nice review from Batch and Ginny, they work well together and appear to like each other

[@TanaseLiviu]

anoying as ever ! Happy new year

[@Gandalf606]

F-Pace looks gorgeous but the car I am looking forward to in 2017 is the new Volvo XC60. If Volvo gets the engine combination right, that cold be the 4x4 sensation of 2017.

[@MrEngland92]

Yup, for me interior is vital!! I don't know y so many people don't care about them

[@ranjeetbains2577]

My list: 1. BMW 2. Jaguar 3. Mercedes 4. Land rover

[@CoolManiac89]

this should have included the Porsche Macan

[@dummy3646]

Cool Maniac1989 It's too small to be put alongside these.

[@IgorsPlay]

For me: Heart = Jaguar F-Peace Brain = BMW X3 :)

[@mrehman306mr]

Android Games & Tech- I couldn't agree more.

[@ojannobell]

glc the best!

[@huy_131]

2017 audi a5 coupe vs 2017 Mercedes c class coupe vs 2017 BMW 4 series pls!!!!!

[@arpitgaur7077]

Jaguar f -pace is the best looking car compared to other cars

[@nrnccrdn]

You are missing Q5 though. Please redo this once new Q5 is out.

[@nrnccrdn]

And Lexus RX could also fit here.

[@roxor1980]

Really useful as making this decison currently. I've had to go with the 3.0 v6 diesel F Pace. I test drove the 2.0 (which is the same engine as all the smaller landrovers) and for me it needed a bit more power.

[@Mashburn007]

f pace is the best looking End of Discussion .

[@seanlovi8798]

The music at the end.... anyone?

[@prayerpowersr854]

Sean lovi darude sandstorm

[@seanlovi8798]

John Kyon Lol.. i just said the same thing to another guy just recently. Oh well..

[@aleixcasademont]

what about the q5 ???

[@adriannippy]

I think the Landrover looks the best.

[@Kaisuke971]

It really is time to replace the X3

[@peterambrose2148]

ikr

[@kelvo6983]

2018

[@muratbagsz]

While he tells about the interiors of all suvs, he says bmw but video screen shows the merc and vice versa. Also you tell us they are similarly priced but land rover is 10 grand expensive as tested. C'mon guys...

[@shanjanusman9974]

Land Rover Discovery Sport is the best and Merc is last for me

[@gilmoskovich7304]

what about Audi / Porsche / Lexus / Infiniti ? Aren't they any good ?

[@MrTrull1]

The video would go on forever if they included every competitor.

[@aysbg]

It would but they included quite old X3 instead of new Q5. X3 is due for replacement in 2017.

[@MrTrull1]

aysbg This is a UK video & James has said elsewhere that the new Q5 isn't available yet in the UK.

[@aysbg]

MrTrull1 Fair point but could have waited to include another proper competitor into comparison. All models, except for X3, are about 1 year old.

[@MrTrull1]

aysbg I don't think the solution is to just not do the video. These cars are just as test worthy as any others & the world does not revolve around Audi. Perhaps they should have just cut out the X3 from the test altogether - imagine the protest. It was included because they still consider it one of the best choices. Basically, they cannot win whatever they do.

[@madhu79lika91]

1 jaguar 2 land rover 3 Mercedes 4bmw

[@mcharyulu1]

Jaguar and Land rover are now Indian TATA owned. I Like the BMWs.. though Audi Q5 is more refined

[@Elijah-cy9do]

Everyone knows that now. But JLR is still based and registered in Coventry and Tata even called JLR British in their website. The cars themselves are undeniably British being designed, engineered and made in the UK with little to no interference from Tata as JLR is very independent as a subsidiary, to the point that they didnt want to give opinions about the XF when it came out in 2008, and JLR even stopped reporting monthy sales to Tata shortly after that.

[@shakir4969]

q5 will surely win this test as Mat Watson said

[@tobiasfellas]

I can imagine in 2020 Mercedes comes out with a 18 speed gearbox bloody hell only 5 years ago people thought 7 gears were too much but Lexus 10 speed like come on.

[@RatimirRS]

And the relative price wasn't even mentioned! Not biased at all...

[@safwanc3043]

The X3 is the best. Period.

[@berten673]

Make the same review pls but with the X5, range rover sport etc...

[@marcelboeltjes9148]

Is the Evoque not a better comp. against the Benz en de Beamer???

[@AlbertArrabal]

Marcel Boeltjes Evoque is more in the Q3, GLA, X1 Segment

[@Kaisuke971]

Yeah the Evoque is a segment below these, it's a pretty small suv

[@marcelboeltjes9148]

Albert Arrabal Not, looking at his price!!!!

[@1petulko]

Arctico leather is great way how Mercedes-Benz showing there is no need to slaughter poor cows just for bit if luxury. Arctico is also so easy to maintain and clean.

[@ayassin1480]

The F pace sucks ass, test drove it last week and to be honest I wasn't impressed one bit. Furthermore, the navigation lags like a MoFo. For the money go for the Benz or BMW.

[@menovive]

what about Audi Q5 and cayenne? which one is easy from maintenance point of view.

[@twenty514]

Great review. But why no Porsche Macan?

[@tobbe5189]

the legend says that the bmw x3 is still stuck in 2015

[@castrolgtx5064]

It would be a personal choice here i think rather than going by the review... personally i would of chose the Land Rover and my second choice would of been the Jaguar.

[@DRETV100K]

made a mistake with the x3. had a clip of the GLC while talking about the x3

[@nathankan7309]

how about Lexus nx?

[@esteban75lover23]

I got so nervous towards the end

[@ts6070]

I totally disagree as an Audi fan I am loathe to say the BMW X3 is best small SUV until the Audi Q5 gets tested..

[@007JHS]

The BMW engine must be exceedingly quiet... I recently (just over a fortnight ago) acquired an F Pace 2 litre... Used to a 3.0L V6 Jaguar...I have to say the engine/interior is quiet... and not lacking in power... in in dynamic and sport mode... very surprising.

[@super7kay]

when i see Ginny with a Merc, smile on my face, like her a lot.

[@cratra]

"Oldie but a goodie"

[@Appydem]

This is very biased, that Discovery and Jaguar are nowhere close to the same level as the BMW and Mercedes Benz.

[@decko20009]

Wind noise in the GLC is a serious problem.

[@darksideofmind91]

This segment is so full that you should've included double the competitors :p

[@dummy3646]

Skyler91 The video would be an hour long if they did that.

[@darksideofmind91]

Yeah, i know, but it would be a nice challenge-review ;)

[@kodjoansah2689]

Uhhh correct me if i'm wrong but isn't that the Mercedes shown at 7:46 while speaking about the BMW?

[@bensmyth6976]

I am sorry, But please don't put such an emphasis on how a family car for how it drives. The main emphasis should be placed on how the car feels (comfortability) so therefore the Mercedes should have won!!!

[@RazvanBestea]

At 7:46 you were talking about BMW and the footage shows the back of the GLC. :D

[@dave_thomas]

Would been nice if the Audi Q5 was in this review.

[@tuomaspeltola4094]

you are copying carwow's head to head tests and whrere is Audi Q5

[@adityanimbalkar2404]

can someone please tell me what colour was the f-pace here

[@thethird1967]

Only the F-Pace is the pick for me.

[@MordFustang1966]

If looks are what you want: 1.BMW/2.Jag/3. Merc/4.Land

[@ljakrtsh1]

Arven Tahtyan x3 in first place? I don't think so

[@johnkinnander9139]

other way around would be more fitting

[@bigbadbear2962]

1.Jag 2.Merc 3.Bmw 4.LR

[@WiseWik]

"BMW is the best but comes last because it's older" Fuck logic... Also where's the Q5 and Macan?

[@dummy3646]

WiseWik I think the Macan is a bit smaller than the others. I've seen it compared to the Range Rover Evoque as opposed to the Discovery Sport.

[@jhseven1469]

Adam's Vendetta Porsche is smaller then the others, biggest is Discovery sport and GLC

[@dummy3646]

Tolga Nalbant I know the Disco sport is the biggest. What I'm saying is that the Macan can't be compared to these because it is significantly smaller than all of them.

[@johnle1535]

Everyone knows the Q5 is the best one, it sold the most and everyone just loves it. I find it a bit boring though..

[@singhsahab23075]

Volvo

[@marinoint]

You really should keep the volume of your voice more consistent! It's extremely annoying to have to adjust the volume multiple times while watching this video.

[@diogo_martan]

Audi Q5??

[@alexanderfost7092]

At this price, I would definitely spend 10-15k more and buy the Porsche Macan, it's so much better than any of these cars. It will also hold its value better, so in long term it would cost the same as these four.

[@dummy3646]

Alexander Fost The Macan is smaller than all these. Buying the Macan means that you are leaning more towards the driving experience rather than practicality or family friendliness.

[@nabillarif]

Fpace is the worst interior.. Its sooo plasticky...

[@myagony449]

It's not, check other videos of its interior especially the F Pace S it looks better with full leather/wood/alluminum interior material.

[@Gdank72]

I have one and the only cheap plastic are the door bins at low level.

[@gurianzguro9204]

When will you review the ford kuga?

[@MrTrull1]

I left an ironic comment on here a couple of days ago, predicting typical responses. I cannot believe how quickly they all came true. Very depressing.

[@dummy3646]

MrTrull1 Did you expect a different result?

[@MrTrull1]

I stupidly hoped some people might get the hint. 😕

[@dummy3646]

MrTrull1 People don't get hints here. This is the comment section of a youtube video. Hoping for a different result will only set you up for disappointment (provided that you even care).

[@MrTrull1]

Indeed. I think I'll just skip it in future. I feel sorry for the presenters who have to suffer reading offensive comments and the same drivel repeated a hundred times.

[@LacoteCohen]

Did she say two bricks and two germs? 😂😂😂

[@monkey2702mw]

£56k for the discovery sport! No thanks I'll have the Porsche macan!

[@sos10]

I agree that the BMW feels a bit dated compared to the other ones, but it drives very well. The DiscoSport is plasticky inside, even in top trim levels and the build quality is just terrible (just go and see any DS forum) The Fpace looks fantastic outside , but inside not so much, I found the 2ltr engine too small, the 3ltr is a much better choice. The MB is good but just too bland. I don't know who the winner should be, but the Disco should be 4th.. the tested version costs 10K more than the others and still is lacklustre in all except offroading (which nobody will ever do).

[@noorata6976]

7 seater SUV s please.

[@jamesfreedman1680]

After all that melodrama, an almost bankrupt company makes a comeback and then brings a product called Jaguar F-Pace smacks everyone and wins the 2017 World Car of the Year

[@jayx6766]

What about Porsche Cayenne or Audi Q7 or Ford Edge or Volvo XC90

[@dummy3646]

Jack George All those are too large to be compared to these. The XC90 and Q7 are 7 - seaters, and while the Edge and Cayenne are not, they are big enough to be. The Discovery Sport's third row seating is too small for anyone taller than 5 feet, so the extra seats aren't worth it.

[@johndoe3665]

and where is the new q5?

[@adrianp.3182]

Getting repaired lol

[@marioboskic5936]

Drezdan Ha-ha. You drive Fiesta?