Mark Kermode Star Wars The Phantom Menace 3D

Has de 3d improved the good doctor´s opinion of the first film of the new trilogy? has it? u think so? really?

[@JamesCarmichael]

Phantom menace in 3D...............................................................................................................................................................................................right

[@johnsmisek02]

“In the year of the blindee blumbb when the navri flumb” I’m dying.

[@luckyjosh7]

Mark Kermode is the key to all this. We have to make sure we get him right. Because he's a funny film critic than we've ever had.

[@CloseUpLover]

OHHHH MYYYY GODDDDD

[@dragonphoreal]

That quote from George Lucas is ironic considering he was the same guy who challenged Ted Turner against colorizing old black and white films...

[@bilalkhares9337]

@David Nash A lot of people liked the Phantom Menace and it's story, it's not as good as the original trilogy but if you watch the whole trilogy it plants a lot of seeds really well.

[@and8091]

@@bilalkhares9337 Only children and young adults with rose tinted glasses like the phantom menace.

[@Gadget-Walkmen]

@@bilalkhares9337lol this a joke right? Phantom menace is NOTHING that which you say as it’s unbelievably terrible and horrible I’m every way to be one of the worst blockbuster films of all time!

[@Tez-cg8xc]

@@bilalkhares9337 I enjoyed it but then I like all the political stuff.

[@philmitchell91]

​@@and8091Bet you like the Disney trash

[@blokey8]

Never quite got the whole "don't get scared, sad or angry or you'll turn evil" philosophy. Surely someone would've realised that every jedi repressing their emotions is the perfect way to make people rebel and go bad.

[@cartmanfan4life1]

the story about the fan that won some sort of contest and got to go to the world premiere, was so excited to be there and then was as he said "completely heartbroken" is honestly one of the saddest things i've heard in a while.

[@mortalhellion]

Part of the charm of the original trilogy is how much of the back story is kept to the viewer's imagination. The best Star Wars film is Empire Strikes Back which has the least involvement from Lucas. I didn't understand the inclusion of Jar Jar Binks when you already have comedy relief from R2D2 and C-3PO.

[@Owen-ub3fv]

At 2:51 I honestly thought it was a Mark Kermode impression because the background music abruptly cut out yet the dialogue still remained. It sounded a lot clearer as if recorded in a studio. Did they really bother to cut out the background music just so they could play the clip for a bit longer?

[@KSRugby]

just show your kids Star Wars original trilogy and explain that 4-6 are typos, n always say that Han shot first. The charm and brilliance of the Star Wars original trilogy will stand the test of time.

[@blvd93]

The main selling point of the Phantom Menace is that it looks fantastic, and if the 3D is as bad as he says then it's a wasted exercise. Although nowhere near as bad as Attack of the Clones.

[@h.b.smith_writer]

Mark Kermode sounds like a British Woody Allen.

[@blokey8]

Another problem about Lucas' decision to release them chronologically- not only does cramming old characters into the prequels create all manner of plot holes, but kids seeing them for the first time will also be confused about why the ships and lightsabers get more and more OTT only to suddenly end up in Episode IV with lots of grey square ships and two old guys just swinging boring single-blade swords and no backflips. The ADD generation will just find the original trilogy boring.

[@andrewattenboroughtwothumb4697]

I remember seeing it in cinemas as a 10 year old kid and saw it in 3D as a 23 year old and still thought it was ok in 3D

[@Owen-ub3fv]

2:39 That Ki Adi Mundi line makes him sound like such a troll. LMAO

[@GlennDavey]

Phantom Menace tried to take something familiar and quite American and say "actually, it's this foreign thing, with weirder people and creatures than you remember, and you don't actually know Star Wars at all. And to achieve that feeling we're going to make it slightly impenetrable to throw you off and disorient you to begin with before things start to get more familiar later on."

[@alyxi]

Blimey Charlie!

[@RoninDave]

People wanting to see the Originals in 3D might think again if the 3D was so bad for TPM, a film made much later after them. I have no desire to see the film in 3D or again in 2D. 3D won't make up for the lack of an interesting story and interesting characters.

[@peterd788]

The Phantom Menace was shot on 35mm like the original trilogy but the other prequels were shot in low resolution video on mostly virtual sets (Revenge of the Sith returned to the UK for lengthy reshoots and had a few real sets but still poor video resolution). Episode 2 used an HD image sent to tape which could only record at a resolution of 1440x1080. Episode 3 used a more advanced system to record at 1920x1080. The original trilogy can be digitally transferred at much higher resolutions than the sub mobile phone footage of episodes 2 & 3. The TPM 3d conversion failed because it was a crap movie and very little care went into the conversion. Even with the higher quality originating format of TPM the effects and editing were performed digitally using rudimentary transfers. That's why the prequels have that soft look. The remastered Star Trek: The Next Generation look so good because the TV show was shot on 35mm but edited on video with effects edited at that stage but the remastered stuff rescanned the 35mm original and re-did the effects and editing at modern resolution. That option is not available for episodes 2 & 3 because they were originated at a lower resolution than medium budget TV shows.

[@janhardwick2]

"greek bail out" HAHA!! the first review where simon says anything funnier than mark.

[@clonard]

Best review of star wars 3D I've heard so far. Mark has proven to me it ain't worth coughing out the cash to see this shit all over again. And I heartilly agree with his comment on Titanic. Its a far better movie than The Phantom Menace, and will more than likely look fantastic in 3D.

[@badhead]

@LivinWorstNightmare not me this time. It 888minutes. a thanks to him, saves me uploading it

[@dadandRiy]

Lucas seems to think he is perfecting his movies by re-tooling them every ten years.

[@Owen-ub3fv]

The Phantom Menace=The Tax Policy Creator

[@KSRugby]

haha yeah, ive never heard him review attack of the clones, only heard him say he thought it was rubbish, but yeah would be good to release 3D attack of the clones just to here Mark rant in depth about how bad it is

[@blokey8]

Is anyone else now looking forward to the Attack of the Clones rerelease, just for Mark's rant?

[@jaiminroger1978]

@badhead spot on mate :)

[@mortalhellion]

I'm more of a Doctor Who fan than a Star Wars one.

[@pippipster6767]

When are they going to make Star Wars: Battle of the Zimmers ?

[@badhead]

classic

[@RoninDave]

@themenaceanish you know you want him

[@ZuluRomeo]

@NamFarwd as Simon would say, put that on the poster!

[@Predator251]

'The Phantom Edit' ftw

[@121jakethesnake]

Good for you!

[@DMEB]

I often come back to these rants when I'm a bit gloomy. They pick me up. I miss this show (Although the new take is quite good).

[@Gadget-Walkmen]

Lol the “show” isn’t gone at all. Kermode still reviews films to this day!

[@Tomatito1981]

So good he took early retirement lol

[@youjustfailedfilms]

NO. Monty Python and the Holy Grail.

[@kemp10]

the mpaa doesnt give out awards...

[@knownpleasures]

Phantom menace is the best Star Wars movie 🍿. Fantastic entertainment

[@doodooswaggy3825]

This is the worst opinion I’ve ever heard

[@Tez-cg8xc]

@@doodooswaggy3825 I think nostalgia plays a big part. Attack of the Clones is my favourite because it evokes childhood memories.

[@Maximillionaire666]

To Lucas's credit, he did say that he thinks black-and-white films are good too (4:32), and that colour films LOOK better than black-and-white, not ARE better in general. Even though that itself is debatable, and I do agree Lucas has definitely sold out, I think Kermode misinterpreted the quote.

[@frogtastic1000]

@themenaceanish lol still at it i see

[@bilalkhares9337]

I agree with Kermode about 3D but tbh it seems kind of strange for him to be condescending about someone who made one of the greatest stories of our era

[@thecinematicmind]

I much prefer THX 1138 and American Graffiti

[@bilalkhares9337]

I found Jar Jar Binks a little annoying as an adult but funny as a kid and it is primarily a kids film

[@JasonX2]

I fucking loved loved loved this film and always will.

[@Goochbot]

I can't believe the likes of The Godfather, Citizen Kane, The Seventh Seal etc. was beaten by the Star Wars films

[@scottwilliam3470]

Greek bailout lol

[@MrnoWun0]

@themenaceanish behave

[@TheCharlzee]

Don't be silly

[@chrishiggins7166]

The film’s stylish, action packed, well scored & has some good acting, however some of the acting is dull & excessive, the film’ script is poor as the film becomes unfocused & long. (56%) (3/5 stars) (mixed)

[@efcdk92]

HAHAHAHAHA!

[@robotpanda77]

No ewoks? How u gonna make a star wars epic with no fucking ewoks? If it doesn't have them I don't want to see it.

[@casino3261]

the worst 3D ive ever seen forsure and i like 3D but this was an abomination and so is the movie

[@jaiminroger1978]

@qwertyuiopdan1 and from the whole universe...;)

[@Gryffster]

Let's be honest. They aren't very good films. Not one of them. Empire Strikes Back - possibly has some merit...that sense of menace, the plot twist (spoiled by a friend in the queue who had already seen it, and couldn't resist telling us) And Return Of the Jedi? All about merchandising. They turned a swashbuckling buccaneer into a lovesick, clumsy puppy. If someone handed me a Scroll Of Genocide, those fucking Ewoks would be dead within seconds. But the dialogue is embarrassing. The plots are wafer-thin. The acting is wooden. Even when I was 15 I was disappointed. I've still seen them all.

[@Solarstar10]

Couldn't disagree more. The acting in the original trilogy isn't Oscar worthy, but it's by no means awful or wooden. The dialogue is the same. The plots may not be complex deep or thought provoking but wafer thin? Not even close. The stories are fun, highly engaging and immensely entertaining. Not being the most complex doesn't mean they're bad. You also have fantastic characters, wonderful world building, great effects that still look good today blending stunning computer generated imagery with great practical effects. The films also feature some wonderful cinematography, lavish production design so on a visual level they're outstanding. I can understand why you'd think they aren't the best films ever, but they are certainly good films, he'll I'd even say great, despite their flaws. But to each their own.

[@iamnegan938]

Dumb

[@frogtastic1000]

the phantom menace is pretty good...to say otherwise is folly

[@danpereira7366]

So many problems with the movie and Kermode picks on the opening crawl? Poor guy can't even pan the movie correctly! 😂

[@bigbangtheorymanic]

Because the opening crawl and what it reads is the heart of the problem with Phantom Menace

[@KermitHitler]

As teeth gratingly irritating and pointless as JarJar Binks is, he isnt a patch on Simon Mayo

[@reinforcedpenisstem]

It's funny listening to people give unsolicited advice to George fucking Lucas.

[@ALocalClown]

Off to the Plinkett reviews with you.

[@reinforcedpenisstem]

@@ALocalClown I've seen those. They're review theatre.

[@doodooswaggy3825]

Cry