What If Bone Island had Air instead of Bone

[@JakeTheDrake]

Clavavera tap dances and claps now okay

[@low-opportunity1846]

Ok

[@doctorarashi8267]

it was excellent

[@Justshay123]

Awesome

[@Ep1cthebox]

Ok

[@mr.mammott9434]

🤨

[@creeper1087]

This completely changes the vibe of bone island. Now it sounds more like some kind of marching parade and I am all for it. Floogull is flawless

[@mizopa6001]

Pretty fitting for Beat Hearafter

[@H2O_CoolDude]

but what about the bone monsters

[@Msmguynumber-1936]

If they add the bone it makes a fifth elemental monster and two more four elemental! That would be amazing

[@talenshane2]

he sounded like trumpet

[@FourTuneado]

Wasn't it alredy?

[@silverpickle9337]

Bro predicted Flum-Ox on Bone island

[@RedAppleBoi09]

Flum ox aged like wine

[@Autumn_guy]

EXACTLY

[@Batistaanm.ofc0_0]

Exactly

[@kermitwo895]

Floogull just makes everything better. Put it on any island and that island becomes godlike.

[@DaBlu-rok]

same with Sooza, its the same but low piched

[@Cahrssomething]

Floogull is one of my favorite monsters ngl

[@kermitwo895]

@@Cahrssomething floogull is just my favorite in general

[@sabrinaadams3392]

Amber ligit *RUINED HIM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!*

[@kermitwo895]

@@sabrinaadams3392 how?

[@atomiccreations8960]

This makes bone island sound a lot happier than it usually does. Like the creature it used to be is still alive

[@Fernsaur]

​@@Skrappr1hes also a skeleton tho

[@Bd-qs5bn]

@@Fernsaur no he just has hollow eyes

[@blankspace9452]

skin island

[@bun-masaru5362]

glowl sounds dead

[@Eviewithaneye]

this is my 13th reason why

[@shrekguy6261]

Fun fact: if you give Jake a piano he will literally go insane!

[@lennahcmarblesmonstersandm6070]

Explains why he has 4 piano monsters

[@lennahcmarblesmonstersandm6070]

@Dimaryp Yes you got them right

[@lipflub]

That one meme with Mozart playing a burning piano.

[@lilsooza8827]

Same with a floogul

[@lilsooza8827]

@Dimaryp no they just grab a floogul and then just squeeze it like bagpipes and that's how they did it

[@CurlyFriStudios]

When Floogull joins, the whole song becomes SO FUNKY. I LOVE IT. I could also tell immediately that Wubbazt voiced some of these, SHE IS SO GOOD. I loved everything about this video.

[@GMDDARKNESS]

Its Banjaw But Trumpet

[@theperfectspongebobpopsicl8007]

@@GMDDARKNESS And It Makes It Way Better

[@weirdghazt]

Floogull's sound is like troll song

[@kir3795]

@@weirdghaztnaw what

[@pawer_themaw]

Cybop makes it even better

[@TheJesshihowareya]

I think you have singlehandidly given me an appreciation for Floogull that I never had before. The Full Song is amazing as well, the Phangler part goes so much harder then it did before

[@austinsisland4777]

floogull is sood good no matter what drake makes

[@smileylylyface]

floogull pog

[@MrFishio]

Floogull has and always will be my favourite monster

[@Mikescool444]

@@MrFishio Floogull is the bowgart of the fire elementals.

[@mangobee1177]

Bowhead is the new bowgart.

[@QQ-gk6qe]

The craziest thing about this is that you *IMPROVED* bone island by *REMOVING* withur. That's absolutely insane.

[@cycoMSM]

No denchus 😢

[@novaraxis]

​@@cycoMSM dadadadadada daratdatdarada

[@notsansutplays8178]

@@novaraxis RAT TAT TATA DURAT DAT DATADA! RATATATATATA DURAT TAT TADATA!

[@L0cal_Librarian]

it's like withur literally carries the island. so it's impressive how jake managed to have the island sound good without withur.

[@lilkiki0038]

yapo yapo yaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa

[@CraigtheCadrum]

I really like this what-if! Replacing Bone with Air made the song much more lively as a whole! From the upbeat instrumental sounds like Quibble, Floogull, and Clavavera, to the energetic vocals like Tweedle, Cybop and Whaddle, everything blends in so nice and neatly. Well done, Jake!

[@zwodderk]

3:25 caught me off guard, it's absolutely amazing as usual!

[@thechoirtar6077]

I really wanna see someone animate Clavavera pulling off them dance moves, it'd be a real treat honestly. Also as someone who's favourite Monster of all time is literally *Flum Ox* this is truly a treat & a blessing for me to behold, also holy shit Tweedle, Glowl, Whaddle, Floogull & Clavavera go real hard here! Honestly such a missed opportunity that BBB never gave Flum Ox a Fire Island when *Flum Ox is the OG Fire Quad who came before everything else among Fire Naturals.* :/ Insert Fire Bastion joke here somewhere.

[@CoinyforReal]

FLUM OX HOMIE

[@thechoirtar6077]

@@CoinyforReal Ayyyy

[@themasterbee]

FLUM OX

[@GMDDARKNESS]

Sorry But I Like Phangler

[@bun-masaru5362]

sneyser fart nose

[@monkeyman3257]

I love how you didn’t just make them sound like a bone monster and you actually made most of them original!

[@Blmurphy00]

I can say that your Flux Ox, and also Cybop, make me filled with so much excitement when they’re included in these. Your covers for them are perfect for every song I’ve heard. Keep up the great work!

[@the.192]

Ah yes, Flux Ox

[@cjsinterlude]

The part with Whaddle and Tweedle makes my brain itch in the best way possible. Also,I really loved how the chord progression in this version is a bit different than the original.

[@HoverMelon2000]

Very good way to describe it.

[@NexusTTV]

Yo holy crap its CjVibes

[@lord_raptorade4853]

I read whaddle as wheedle

[@anath887]

brain itch

[@NowNormal]

Whaddle is inaccurate. Reason? Because Bone Island was supposed to have Air in the concept, so they pre-recorded Whaddle but the Magical Elements came in and replaced Air. While making Amber Island, BBB noticed Whaddle's Voice Actor has left so they reused the Whaddle Bone Island Sound which sounds similar to Banjaw who is a Bone Elemental and thus replaced Whaddle becuase Bone replaced Air.

[@NebTube1]

Blud predicted fire expansion 💀

[@RealAshleyChill]

Pretty bonkers cover, all of the vocals are great, Floogull goes hard, and it's just all round awesome!

[@AbsolutelyAri1]

Haha… bonkers…

[@pokeriolu]

@@AbsolutelyAri1 intense psychic island vibes

[@alanfam1263]

pretty WHAT cover?

[@lilkiki0038]

bbbbb bbbbbb bbbbb bbbbbb.

[@spunchbob.]

The chorus sounds so much more energetic, definitely a bop

[@GOOSEBUMPS_FOR_DUMMIES]

The Calavera instrument change was incredible. We definitely needed more Percussion for this. Noggin, Scups, and Quibble surely helped carry the percussion too. Amazing Work 👍

[@ghostytunes4712]

Clavavera was already percussion but I’m not complaining, it _is_ really good!

[@GOOSEBUMPS_FOR_DUMMIES]

@@ghostytunes4712 I knew they were

[@Kalebed]

@@GOOSEBUMPS_FOR_DUMMIES But Quibble isn't percussion...

[@GOOSEBUMPS_FOR_DUMMIES]

@@Kalebed No, they’re a percussionist. I understand that people get confused with this, but a piano isn’t a string instrument. The piano is hitting the string, making a percussion sound. So no, quibble is 100% a percussionist.

[@Kalebed]

@@GOOSEBUMPS_FOR_DUMMIESMk sorry; after a little research, Encyclopedia Britannica says it's both 👍 While the player smacks the keys (percussion) the strings themselves are the things actually making noise (string)

[@chinchillaphage6]

Floogul and cybop changed the entire feel of the song

[@ThompsonMSM]

The passion you put is the cybop, man

[@CesarSalad69]

*_"DEN UP DOO NUP DEN UP DOOP DNOW"_*

[@RmationYT]

DANE DOT DO DAT DO DA DO DAWG

[@raven1647]

DA DA DU DOP DU DOWWWWWW

[@SOMEONEONYOUTUBEIDK]

*DAY DAH DO DAH DODAH DA-DOW*

[@mrmissingno10]

Again, he sounds 20 or so years younger now

[@sirsquidpotato3027]

Of all the “magical island with a natural instead of magical” videos, this is the best one by far. I really wanna see this animated

[@NoahPhillips31]

How the- I'm at a loss for words. This was the best cover of any MSM island I've ever heard! Whaddle and Floogull go incredibly hard and every part was made ten times better! Good job dude!

[@Fwogpog]

BROOOOOOO THIS GOES SO HARD 😍😍😍😍

[@DevibriBnuuy]

HI FWOG POG :D

[@SAB-Studios]

Bonkers

[@Fwogpog]

@@DevibriBnuuy hi 👋👋

[@HollowKnightFanGD]

Hi

[@JustAB1gsh0t]

Pog

[@ErikTheCleric]

I love the fact you also changed some existing monster sounds to fit the new vibe the song has

[@Lockpicksaretasty]

The best verse of bone island has turned even better! Floogull and Clavera give it such a nice feel!

[@isoldethedog675]

I know im very late to this, but clavavera sort of "tap dancing" actually works really well, as it could reference Folklorico, or mexican dance, which does very much resemble tap in some ways. Great video 😁👍

[@ArtistThatsBlue769]

Bro predicted flum ox on this island almost perfectly a YEAR before it came out CRAZY

[@Wubbazt]

ooOO I LOVE THIS SO MUCH everything you compose is just absolutely brilliant. every time

[@samszczepanski2281]

Well you did an amazing job at voicing tweedle, glowl and whaddle!

[@Grunkfuss_The_Clown]

You're so cool.

[@navlisking]

the combination of floogul, quibble, scups and cybob rocks hard with phangler i love it!

[@MysteryMusic512]

Floot fly!? That’s the Faerie single elemental lol, you’re thinking of Floogul.

[@B0bby_V]

I like cybob aswell

[@novaraxis]

​@@B0bby_V cybob 😃😃😃

[@omaramo19]

Despite "Flum Ox Island" having very weak percussionists, it still sounds so good.

[@G1MM1CKTUNES]

Well there's also the bisonorus and incisaur islands, but they keep pace with other islands using strong instrumentalists like bowgart, sooza, quibble, and rootitoot

[@MoopyMSM]

@@G1MM1CKTUNESand the yelmut one only has pango but at least woolabee thumpies and sooza are there

[@G1MM1CKTUNES]

@@MoopyMSM Yeah, I'm honestly really surprised there aren't that many fire element percussionists

[@Cashcorn]

JakeTheDrake + brass = a masterpiece every single time. Finally you’ve remade my favorite island 🥹❤️💀

[@syabilalbilal4069]

The build ups to the beatdrops sound SICK

[@ShiningStar1244]

actually incredible. wubbazt's vocals are fantastic as always, and the way you added little edits to the original vocal tracks was an awesome addition !! i LOVE the part with floogul and cybop as well, it gives the song a really fun, exciting feeling :D

[@xboomerboyx5888]

Oh my gosh, you made the song sound even more jazzy than it was before. Especially with floogull and cybop.

[@garoldghost]

That was the best fan made "what-if" song i ever heard. DO A EXTENDED VERSION OF THIS, PLEASE!!!

[@ynynynynyny]

QUIBBLE AND FLOOGULL SLAPPPPPPPP SO MUCH GOOOODDAMN this is so freaking good im in shock

[@fredrai9999]

That part with Quibble, Floogull, Phangler, and Cybop is just god tier stuff! Great stuff here, Jake! ^^👍

[@Drumplermsm]

I love this especially floogull,cybop,scups,clavavera and all the characters added

[@Beneviento456]

Me encanta por fin una nueva música, me encanta el trabajo, empeño y dedicación que le pones a cada uno de tus videos, sigue así

[@aquasanty0663]

Porfin alguien que habla español

[@Beneviento456]

@@aquasanty0663 jaja así es

[@Zowk_]

Increíble, es poco probable encontrar gente que le guste este juego y hable español

[@Beneviento456]

@@Zowk_ pues aquí estoy, es un buen juego y su comunidad es bastante sana y sin tóxicos como otras, y sin mencionar los fanmade de las islas que crean, son increíblemente pegadizas y buenas

[@luangamepley098b4]

@@Zowk_ es verdad,yo nunca encontre un youtuber hispano de este juego,curioso no?

[@VoidMarshal11]

I was completely unprepared for the beat drop, and it was startling! Perfection! Floogull makes everything better and cybop is amazing!

[@TheMartiann]

You know what I can mess with this. This is glorious Now imagine if you kept the bone monsters... It be flipping over

[@PenguinIsEpic]

Quibble sounds like if someone would mix jazz hands with an upbeat song. (edit) Quibble, Cybop, Scups, And Floogull are the four horsemen of carrying this song by an absolute landslide. also, the drop is a bop bro good job

[@Salkauski]

Clavavera: 😐

[@Salkauski]

@@PenguinIsEpic understandable

[@eightyeight8_]

i never thought he had it in him, Scups, good job

[@heybak]

Never knew a scups couldcarry a song

[@YanSimTuts]

@@heybak lol

[@mobileempire5446]

I didn’t know Whaddle can produce such a sound in in love with this song

[@uncleirohislegendary]

Flum ox ended up there either way

[@Phantomical14]

flum ox actually came to bone island

[@Mr_Bubz_MSM]

Who’s here during Feast-Ember 2023 after Flum Ox was actually added 😭

[@Madisongs]

Me!!!

[@ChristopherHill-nt9ir]

Me too

[@oddness6373]

"That moment when you walk into a cartoon bar: 0:20 " But tbh great remix and i really like that phangler and cybop duet eachother now.

[@TheBattleCatsMola]

I'm really late on this, but you've done a FLAWLESS job on this. you made every monster sound good, even scups somehow. great job!

[@jackofroge]

Not Clavavera using the Jitterbud soundfont 💀

[@BumbleBoiMSM]

3:25 the best part to save y’all time

[@DevinFindlay-dl4jd]

Fum ox is now on bone island

[@bumm1120]

Still coming back to this and MAN that Tweedle and Whaddle duet part SLAPS

[@ColmGibney]

Incredible! I’m currently trying to replicate this in MSM composer. Sounds great 👍🏻

[@NoobieLovesGdCologne]

Cybop goes hard with floogull

[@downgradedchair7617]

Finally one that actually makes sure you can breed them-

[@maximilianocabrera8338]

Sounds INCREDIBLE

[@Deuces2nd]

I like how such a small change to Fwog makes him sounds so much better!

[@ClownyGamer]

Never thought I would start simping for cybop

[@RolveGamesAreBad]

im normally just like “okay yeah that’s cool” to these sorts of remixes but holy shit this ones going in the playlist

[@Kneecapss]

This is insanely good. They should add this into msm. It sounds so great. It’s perfect. Down to the last minute detail.

[@imaginemiles1133]

I kinda feel like Fire, Water, Earth and Air is literally the perfect combination of natural monsters

[@rachaelchampion6195]

To me it's: fire, water, plant, earth.

[@MysteryMusic512]

Hey Jake, is it possible you could release versions of the four Magical Island what ifs without the individual sounds at the start? I have them in my playlist, but I’d rather not have to whip out my phone and skip to the full song, and I also wanna listen to all four in a row. Thanks, and *INCREDIBLE* work!

[@Gumiwastaken]

I love Quibble Holy.

[@zionlauina8076]

Bro this is crazy, it gives bone island a whole new vibe 😂😂 This is actually amazing 👍🏽

[@spaceboykk1224]

Clavavera is all ready in bone island

[@tinmanne]

clavavera was added after this video was posted

[@ImagineIfNetwork]

Jake I got a 6 part challenge for you One : replace light on magical sanctum with earth Two : replace psychic on magical sanctum with cold Three : replace faerie on magical sanctum with water Four : replace bone on magical sanctum with air Five : add additional fire to magical sanctum Six : fan make a fire water cold earth air quint monster for magical sanctum or should I say... fire sanctum

[@mranima748]

Both of you did an amazing job, this is my favourite island of yours

[@Wawluk]

Floogull as banjaw made the song very catchy For some reason I thought that the whaddle would sing here it's verse from amber island

[@Sigma_on_the_wall76]

О вавлук

[@Syp4ik]

It's cool that you also made cover of the island itself

[@mystery5906]

A COLLAB BETWEEN THE TWO BEST MSMTUBERS?!?!? AMAZING

[@atunlata]

floogull carrying it fr

[@TheCodaCrew]

I love how upbeat this is!

[@AutisticCrackhead]

Cybop and Phangler dueting was awesome

[@Molo_da_boi]

This has no right to go *THIS HARD* Jesus I love this

[@verdellium]

the sudden transition from quibbles first track to the second track when you were showing them was INSANE. i felt so many goosebumps during this. great work!

[@itsJadite]

God I wish msm island songs were this dynamic, I feel like the only one that came this close was Magical Sanctum and maybe Amber island. Like I wish they felt less flat like Verse, Chorus, same verse, same chorus, repeat same chorus.

[@zoliver8974]

My Floogey boi just makes any song amazing. That aside though, you’re a super talented and amazing creator. I went for a while questioning whether I should continue watching KZbin or not but you’re one of the channels that convinced me otherwise. Keep up the good work

[@shellyvision9693]

This has a very different feel to Bone Island and I like that a lot. Bone Island is amazing but I really like the feel this goes with.

[@what_gaming0]

Floogal,quibble,clavavera literally sounds like a superhero epic scene is playing

[@kanecirooey3160]

0:00 tweedle 0:13 quibble 0:55 cybop 1:06 glowl 1:16 scups 1:22 floogull 1:49 whaddle 2:01 flum ox 2:14 clavavera 2:49 full song

[@PauloRicardo-ou4fn]

THAT WAS FREAKING AMAZING!!!!!

[@Sparky6Voltz]

Wasn't expecting the changes to existing monsters- this all sounds absolutely amazing!!

[@MARRYME2DPLEASE-]

THIS IS AMAZING!!!!this is exactly what I needed.

[@NSGRex]

ok.. hear me out. Floogul, phangler, and cybop sounds AMAZING

[@AlwayzHazbin]

Ikr, Best trio ever

[@starynights384]

I LOVE THIS COVER SM 😭😭

[@nathanterho-streck5546]

4:26 these four are soo good together

[@detricadams1292]

This is so much better and this is an absolutely amazing cover, good job

[@hirocoldy6023]

Amazing! Clavavera changing to a percussion monsters makes quite a difference

[@Gmanrocky]

Clavavera was always percussion, this is just a different instrument

[@LunarTFM]

@@Gmanrocky yeah, her instrument, as her name states, is a clave

[@Gmanrocky]

@@LunarTFM did i say it wasnt? No i just said it was always a percussionist

[@NuningMinie]

Floogul is litterally a boss music

[@goofygames974]

lesson learned: jakes voice is unbelievably good

[@houseplant5236]

You’ve put my favorite fire monster on my favorite island, thank you

[@calebalderete1]

PLEASE!!! WHAT SOUND FONTS OR WHAT MUSIC SOFTWARE DO YOU USE FOR YOUR INSTRUMENTALS THEY SOUND OUTSTANDING!!!

[@mynameispat_]

yeah, this is it. this is the best one, by far. the ENERGY is just UNMATCHED

[@Ms-bi-gi]

References Cybob - phangler Floogull - denchus Quibble - stogg Clavera - clakula Flum ox - the quad Whadle - amber island kayna

[@Judgeofmonsterworld]

Scups - Hawlo Glowl - Uuduk

[@firstwaddledee9182]

Dude, the piano and trumpet are fantastic!

[@crimsonclamoris777]

Literally made the island 5x better. Edit: kinda ironic how removing the bone in Bone Island actually makes the song better.

[@littlemow]

they have two different moods and are basically two different genres you can’t really compare them

[@crimsonclamoris777]

@@littlemow guess I like the more upbeat one better.

[@nonexistentperson69yearsan13]

I’ve never heard a cybop with more passion than this one. Good job!

[@M.t.chaty72-Mispi14-]

Cybop 🔥

[@SATURNZFLOW]

Quibble and Floogull have to be some of my favorite monsters and I love them in this mix so much! Thank you Jakethedrake for making this with some of my favorite monsters