Jay's analysis of Qadhi's 'HOLES IN THE NARRATIVE'!

On June 8, 2020, Shaykh Yasir Qadhi, a renowned Muslim cleric in the US, well known for his talks on the Qur'an's perfect preservation, was asked by Mohammad Hijab, a popular Muslim KZbinr to answer whether he believed the Qur'an was perfectly preserved, and whether the Qira'at and Ahruf differences (i.e. the later addition of dots above and below the letters, and the vowels) were problematic for its preservation.
Qadhi did NOT want to talk about this subject, as 25 years earlier he had a 'Crisis of Knowledge' concerning this very subject when attending Yale University. But Hijab insisted.
In this video Jay takes the 25-minute section of the interview where Qadhi responds to these questions and unpacks them for the rest of us, suggesting that Qadhi made quite a number of interesting yet damaging admissions, some of which he may regret later on.
Since this posting, Mohammed Hijab has deleted these 25 minutes from his 1 hour 45 minute interview, due to the backlash it's caused from the Muslim community around the world. Nonetheless, we have it all here for you to look at, and Jay to analyze.
These, then, are the admissions which Yasir Qadhi made:
1) The subject of Ahruf and Qira'at is probably the most difficult question for modern Muslim scholars like himself to answer.
2) This question, and others posed by Western scholars caused him to go through a crisis when he was studying for his PhD at Yale University.
3) He was rescued from this crisis by returning to what he had been taught since childhood, that the Qur'an must be the 'Word of Allah' because it is self-evident.
4) Uneducated Muslims shouldn't question Qira'at and Ahruf, as this must be left to the experts, the Ulemma, who have been discussing it for 1,000 years.
5) Yet, even the best Muslim scholar on the subject for the last 1,000 years, Ibn al-Jazari (he died in 1429 AD), who spent 30 years studying the Qira'at, and compiled 90 books on this and other subjects, is not accepted by scholars today, proving that even the best still don't know how to defend it.
6) Qadhi admits that today, "the Western level of knowledge is leaps and bounds above what it used to be just 100 years ago", causing a dilemma within Muslim scholarly circles.
7) He bemoans that the Traditional Understanding of the Ahruf and Qira'at in the Muslim world simply cannot answer the pressing questions being asked by Western Academics.
8) Qadri admits that, "It's very clear that the standard narrative on the subject has HOLES in it", yet he himself doesn't know how to fill those holes.
9) This issue of Qira'at has troubled the Umma (believers) from the very beginning, proving that this is not a new problem.
10) "Because of these problems, the issue of Ahruf and Qira'at should only be discussed among those who are familiar with the science", even though for the past 1,000 years they have discussed it without coming to any satisfactory conclusions, which caused Qadhi his crisis 25 years ago.
11) Qadhi admitted he had never brought this topic up himself, nor lectured about this issue, though numerous times he said that to understand it, just take his course. Not very convincing...
12) He went on to say that this question should never be brought up in public, and those Muslims who did were "idiots".
13) When asked by Muhammad Hijab whether he could write on a blank piece of paper a perfect Quran today, which would parallel the original Medinan Qur'an, and if it would follow the Hafs, or another Qira'at version (there are 37 so far); he tried desperately to sidestep the question.
14) In desperation, when pushed by Hijab, he admitted that ALL of the different Qira'at versions of the Qur'an (Hatun now has 37 in London) would be acceptable, because the Hadith said so, and the Qur'an promised that the Qur'an would be perfectly preserved (see Surah 15:9).
15) In the end Qadhi conveniently fell back on his favourite mantra on the subject, claiming fervently, "The Qur'an is the uncreated speech of Allah, the Qur'an is preserved, the Qur'an is known, the Qur'an is Mutawatir (the succession of narration), all of the Qira'at are the Qur'an, all are authentic, leave it at that. Beyond this requires background information, so take my class."
It seems to us that he is still in crisis, and Muslims everywhere should now be concerned. If he is the best they have on the subject, how then will they be able to continue this charade, claiming that the Qur'an is perfectly preserved? If they really believe it, then they will have to do a better job than either sides-stepping the issue, censoring it, or falling back on a memorized mantra.
Qadhi's full interview is at: • Video
Hijab's censored interview is at: • CONTROVERSIAL QUESTION...
© Pfander Centre for Apologetics - US, 2020 (30,130)
(Music: 'Drums of War' by Rafael Krux, from filmmusic-io License CC BY)
(Music: 'Small Adventure' by Rafael Krux, from filmmusic-io License CC BY)

[@spadadelsignore4784]

“In a Muslim environment there’s always some respect that we have for the Quran...we’ll press a little bit and then say khalas (enough).” - Yasir Qadhi

[@charlesmartel6654]

@Nunya Dibness The reason he is so cautious is because he doesn't want to be accused by his own scholarly sheiks of leaving the faith. If he was living in a Muslim majority country he would not dare bring this subject up publicly for fear of having his head cut off for blasphemy.

[@fullarmor7599]

@RealDeal441 Spada didn't lie. Khalas has many meaning. Finished, done, enough, stop, cease. What are you talking about?

[@abdulaimukaje5503]

@RealDeal441 "that's it" or "finished" is the same as "enough" when used in context. You are the big liar here. Respect to Yasir Qadhi for being honest and different from other muslim liars like you and your fake prophet!!!!

[@maxter1334]

I believe the real quran is without any dots and punctuation marks just like the holy torah rabbis study the torah without punctuation marks to find layers upon layers of info thats the same with the quran i belive all qiraat are relevant and reveal more hidden secrets and layers upon layers of information just the way the hebrew torah and bible are ALLAH knows best

[@mohangela3023]

don't question and just fellow it. Enough! 😂 Mohamad hijab have to attend his class in order to clear off his doubt

[@xxphillips]

He shot him self/Islam in the foot when he said specialist studied it for 35 years and still couldn't give others a satisfactory answer.

[@georgelee08]

He would rather hide the truth, than give a proper defense of the Quran.

[@aaronshanker6019]

He didn't even want to bring up what was the questions that caused his crisis. Enough evidence to show he is hiding smth.

[@darriuscole8544]

What he is saying is that he is hiding the truth because he CAN'T give a proper defense of the Quran.

[@leonardodavincithegenius4615]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/jobWaJmei9Kel7M

[@lorenzochimelis7359]

Boy Christians are fantastic builders unbelievable architects of amazing skill when building mountains out of mold hills all doctor quadhi did was speak on an issue relating to quira-at that Muslim scholarship has known about for the better part of what 1,360 years I use common sense where do you think these professors at Yale get there source material references from Eskimo’s in there igloo libraries cut the shit out its pathetic and desperately drastic. Here is what is better that you Chen’s your time with and that’s s criminal religion created on the basis of corruption tampering and misrepresenting text from tanahk in order to create s Christian narrative WHERE NONE EXIST worry and deal with that . The New Testament quotes tanahk some 280 or more times as a proof text to justify its existence bun claiming natural textual progression or textual continuum but on the basis of the natural basis of the foundation and mission statement of tanahk which is a refutation of all things theologically Christian the only option left was criminality to the extent that of the 280 verses from tanahk quoted in the New Testament 98 to 99 percent have been changed and. corrupted . In fact not only was there that corruption and tampering with text but that in addition to cover up or legitimize the criminality the book of Hebrews was written as an anti Judaism statement as a diversion . To be anti Judaism is to be in essence ANTIS-EMETIC critical ,devastating, catastrophic and a killer for the messiahship and even prophethood of Jesus we will not even bring up divinity as it would be utterly shameful to mention it anywhere near Jesus

[@lorenzochimelis7359]

Let me give an example of the massive tampering and corruption of text from tanahk by the translators of the Christian bible compare ...... book of Hebrews.10:5 with the boo it directly quotes from ..... book of Psalms.40:6 ..... just open your bibles no matter which one of the trillions you have and read the first thing you will see is that both books dismiss the importance burned offerings or blood sacrifice atonement which by the way is an ass buster for Christianity and then with the change of one simple word changes the definition and meaning of the hole text on top of that the one speaking in the verse is also changed see if you can pick out the word and who the new speaker is replacing the original speaker and author speaking 2,000 years before him ?

[@wisemen8085]

Islam is shaking the moment Islamists get candid and honest.

[@rayali2861]

Christianity is shaking. It's why they are clutching to this video where Christians think Qadi is against the Quran. Jay is like a drowning man clutching at a straw.

[@dinacountry6518]

@@rayali2861 truth hurts but accept it or say kallas

[@rayali2861]

@@dinacountry6518 I just told you truth which can be proven. Some Qurans have markings some don't. The text is the same. Can u say that for your 4 out of 100 gospels?

[@12dt23]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gWKUiZmFm7l5d7c

[@DavidVargas-iv4dr]

Ray Ali there’s only four. All the other ones were written after the first century and don’t even have the same theme of Jesus. Gnostic gospels are easily debunked

[@premman6052]

hopefully somebody will translate this into Indonesian very soon. These questions are thrown around very often in Indonesia but the answers from the super clever clerics always the same, by labeling the question as a stupid question and to ridicule the person who made the question as stupid person who knows nothing about arabic. I really appreciate Mr. Yassir Qadris's admission and honesty on this one.

[@b.o.c7881]

Christian prince is also one of our trusted source of info about Islam. 👍😍👍

[@RoarT19]

@19th October Wow 😘

[@MU-we8hz]

Dude, talking about CP check this kzbin.info/www/bejne/bpmbdKiQlJ6koNE

[@gewargisgeorgios8186]

@19th October Will have to add Jay Dyer to this list very soon

[@b.o.c7881]

@@MU-we8hz this is hilarious I couldn't stop 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣👍👍👍

[@medhaniebuzuamlak2333]

@19th October wonderful Islam is in the edge of falling

[@doe729]

This video caused me to have much more compassion for the Muslim. It's crushing to come to the realisation that everything you have believed in, all your life, has been a lie

[@penlight5289]

Yassir Qadir we appreciate your honesty . Thank you . You will be remembered Dr Jay Smith your hard work has yielded bountiful fruit today

[@MurraySwe]

The cracks on Islam are forming and the religion will eventually crumble. Amazing how God uses the internet and Westerners to guide Muslims on the right path. God bless, Jay.

[@greenzone7371]

Internet is the greatest enemy of Islam.

[@chm5750]

@Khalid Ibn Alwaleed There's nothing deceptive in Christianity.

[@Joel-mb9jv]

@Khalid Ibn Alwaleed Islam is the fastest growing religion not because of conversion it is because of breeding. 😉😊

[@fraudulentzakirnaik74]

Am telling you

[@neneklampir6664]

True. That is why they have strong lobby in liberal's media

[@sarahlumgair3759]

This is devastating. I pray muslims accept the quran has not been preserved, it is not divine, and that they find answers in Christ.

[@haljordan9607]

what happened to me is exactly what you write about)

[@manivannanchokkalingam8251]

One more for the journey, the psychotic prophet by Abdullah Sameer.

[@commentfreely5443]

if you don't like what the arabic quran says, wait another year till they find another one.

[@maxter1334]

The bible corupted we know this if you can take up the challenge and proove me wrong then i will be a deist rather than a christian

[@talisupremacy7176]

You can just show them. There own texts alteady confirm it wasn't preserved.

[@mychannelgo6750]

Thank you Jay Smith for all that you done to teach us by your youtube channel. God bless you Jay Smith and you all. Best regards from me in Indonesia.

[@jovanblom7742]

And God bless you, Yasir Qhadi and Mohammed Hijab! For bringing attention to the 'holes in the narrative'!

[@STIGGARRIUS]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oYOWZaljfq6sm7s

[@Nagiistopro]

Wow! Islam is a man made.

[@rationalphobia5533]

Thank you Dr. Jay Smith and Sister Hatun. All this directly linked and as a result of your investigative/academic works, now muslim scholars are in panic mode trying to salvage their "perfect" preservation claim.

[@rayali2861]

It's still perfect but the Devil is trying extremely hard to make it imperfect. All you Devils who follow the teachings of Paul instead of Jesus, have the Quranic verse "Over it is nineteeen" to see proof of the preservation. You also have the challenge of the prophet to enter into prayer & let the Lord send down his wrath on whomever is lying when it comes to God being three entities in one. I will take Jay up on that, anytime.

[@dinacountry6518]

@@rayali2861 think openly

[@collectiveconsciousness5314]

@@rayali2861 Problem is, St. Paul had no precedence whatsoever over the teachings of Christ, which you do not follow properly. We don’t believe in the same Jesus who predicted his own death by crucifixion, said that there is no marriage in heaven, prescribed baptism as a requirement for salvation, etc. Also you claim to follow the old law but you have zero continuity with it since you don’t have a temple, altar, priesthood, and the animal sacrifices for atonement of sins that took place upon the altar, nor do you even have any equivalent to passover, so there is no salvation for any of you.

[@Iris-2023gh]

Truth remains truth, no matter what people say. The bible is inspired by God. That is the truth. Pride is the word if you said otherwise. That is why they keep saying the bible is corrupted. It is the tactic used, trying to avoid facing reality. They are scared to find out the truth.

[@frankjaeger9068]

Yasir, Hijab, Shabir are now in a position where Holy Spirit is convicting them , all they need to do now is turn to Jesus

[@RoarT19]

@Бастин Џибер Hijab is a joke. Yasir is ok shabir is courageous and respectful

[@eathakotavijay]

Absolutely Agree with you, Hijab is an absolute clown, that stunt he tried to pull in his debate with David Wood was so idiotic, unfortunately the muslims are so blinded that they can't see through the facade of lies, they have been absolutely blinded by Satan and the propaganda of the Islamic apologists !! Yes the foundation of Islam is crumbling, thanks to the tireless efforts of Dr. Jay Smith, Dr. David Wood and others !! May the LORD continue to bless their efforts and we pray for a harvest of souls in these last days !

[@user-wh8xn4eu6c]

Pray for them so that Jesus Christ can reveal itself to them. May the might of Jesus Christ save them from Hell.

[@maxter1334]

I think the real quran is without any dots and punctuation marks just like the holy torah rabbis study the torah without punctuation marks to find layers upon layers of info thats the same with the quran i belive all qiraat are relevant and reveal more hidden secrets

[@maxter1334]

I believe the real quran is without any dots and punctuation marks just like the holy torah rabbis study the torah without punctuation marks to find layers upon layers of info thats the same with the quran i belive all qiraat are relevant and reveal more hidden secrets and layers upon layers of information just the way the hebrew torah and bible are ALLAH knows best

[@ravimathews1973]

Congratulations Jay! You've been hammering this for longer than 6 years I think :)

[@albaniancrusader01]

25 years

[@johnykuttymanalil5812]

Not holes in the narrative but cracks in the foundation of Islam

[@MrCaribKaraoke]

Islam critiqued...david wood...and now jay Smith are aware and have made videos. It's a great time to share your faith wisely since the evidence is right there on KZbin for them to see in the words of their own sources and trusted leaders Edit...hatun from dcci is doing a livestream today on this....I feel like eyes are going to be opened...keep praying world

[@b.o.c7881]

And Christian Prince 🙏😍🙏

[@meteraikeselamatan9653]

And Rob Christian too

[@MrCaribKaraoke]

@@b.o.c7881 what channel is that?

[@b.o.c7881]

@@MrCaribKaraoke light of all nations , I'm not sure of his actual channel. But I listened to all of his debates on one of those channel. God is love, truth of islam and light of all nations. There are many more but in bahasa indonesia channel.

[@MrCaribKaraoke]

@@b.o.c7881 can you link the video in your reply

[@chrisazure1624]

I wonder what could be openly said in a private conversations that Qadhi could not openly say in a public forum.

[@rayali2861]

You misunderstand. Qadhi is wise to know that Christians who are eager to bring the Quran down to the status of the Bible will use his arguments for the exact purpose Jay is doing here. That's why he wanted a private discussion.

[@chrisazure1624]

@@rayali2861 - Of course. He is afraid if the truth gets out, the average Muslim will ask what other lies he has been taught. He knows this will be used against the Quran. He knows the Quran is not what the Dawaist have said it is.

[@ichiniizeizel8288]

Covid19: wearing facemask is the new norm these days Me: mm.. let me introduce you to the avalanche of apostasy 😁

[@Matthew-hh6ex]

😷😷😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂🐷🐫🐖💨🕋🕋☻ avalanche-19

[@12dt23]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gWKUiZmFm7l5d7c

[@richardbenjamin8535]

Yasir Qadhi has just said that the quran should only be discussed by people that can sweep it under the rug and completely conceal the faults!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@hasanfamily6583]

Not exactly, to understand issues like that you need deep knowledge. So he did say if you wish understand join my class. You don't just join a seminar and become a doctor do you..?

[@wardragons9780]

@@hasanfamily6583 those arent issues those are "faults" and "contradictions" which every man made things on earth have... Gods word will never have faults..... So if something claim to be word of God but have faults that cannot be even corrected by new theories.... It simply means its made by a human....

[@houseofbarachah3425]

God Bless you Jay and the entire team. Praying for you all always.

[@jasontrotter7660]

Is this ☪ Islam's best defense?!! LMAO 😆... Excuse after excuse, combined with fast talking, with plenty of disqualifying rare words. Added with immature name calling. Used in such a way, as to aid in his method of escaping, and eluding from having to deal with the TRUE facts about the fabricated stories of Islam.

[@lancesteinke3732]

I really appreciate the work you’re doing here Jay. Keep up the good work! God bless.

[@jamalkhan3708]

Qadhi had so many doubts about Islam. It’s just a matter of time when he will openly admit he is ex Muslim Christian.

[@ianofliverpool7701]

I wouldn`t hold your breath waiting for that to happen, I believe many know that islam is false but they love the Ummah too much to leave islam.

[@cruizito2388]

And there are those who are too afraid to become Apostates for they could be killed. But there are also those whose heart is poisoned! They WANT to believe in the Qur'an for they are as evil as their book!!!

[@worldchanger7197]

He is afraid to die.

[@Ed-dz6be]

Sahih Bukhari 5057, Sahih bukhari 3611

[@fullarmor7599]

When you're born a Muslim, it's not your fault. When you learned the truth and died a Muslim, So sad. 😢

[@RoarT19]

That sounds Islam is crumbling slowly 🤣🙌 Great work jay smith sir 😘👍

[@said9216]

you mean climbing i guess

[@denborges8610]

End of Islam

[@MalY481]

Dream on...

[@ashokjadhav9904]

@Akmal Ahmad Yes!😊👍 Eventually, they all will!😊👍👌💐

[@SAADOFFICIAL436]

Jay smith? 😂😂😂😂 His lie has been exposed for centuries 😂

[@ianofliverpool7701]

I followed some of it, Basically he couldn`t argue against western scholars findings and that what they say is true but should only be discussed in private amongst other muslim scholars, however i`m going to keep doggedly to the usual narrative of the Qur`an is perfectly preserved............I`m glad we as Christians don`t have to go through this.

[@davidtong2776]

Islam, we are told by Muslims is the creation of one man, A clearly sinful man who's sins were forgiven or even ordered by God, a man who ordered conquest, and subjugation, brutality and murder as a way of life. Islam is the retelling of a foundation of Muhammad's lies.

[@farmuhqas]

Thank you for your opinion, now lets look at the opinions of the greats, Mahatma Ghandi: Great Character, kept promises, not spread by the sword, love for his friends and family. Alphonso de Lamartine: An achievement with very little resources produced amazing results, no one can be compared with him. George Bernard Shaw: Savior of humanity , He would solve humanities problems of today. Thomas carlyle: Lies heaped around this man are disgraceful to ourselves, probable insinuation towards Christians. Rev Bosworth Smith: if any one had the right to say he was supported by God it was him as he had all the power without the instruments and without its support. MY QUESTION IS WHO ARE YOU?

[@lkae4]

geinee Ghandi was Hindu. Ghandi was a unclean pagan according to Allah and Muhammad. I didn't know Muslims listened to pagans. Muslims, your brother here says listen to great men no matter the religion. Let's do that. Let's listen to their lives compared to Muhammad. Any of these great men order the assassination of critics? Muhammad did. Molest a daughter-in-law? Muhammad did. Marry a 6 year old still playing with swings and dolls? Muhammad did. Order the massacre of dogs? Muhammad did. What do their lives say about Muhammad? What does your life say about Muhammad?

[@farmuhqas]

@@lkae4 again my question is WHO ARE YOU?

[@davidtong2776]

@@farmuhqas Just an man, who like those you listed would like to see one less great evil in this world.

[@STIGGARRIUS]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oYOWZaljfq6sm7s

[@SliceySlicer]

The cult of Islam is falling apart. Praise the lord 🙏😇

[@robsta_79]

SliceySlicer whaaaaaaaat. 1 guy makes an error and 1.6bn Muslims religion is falling apart😀. Get off the crack

[@IbnMurrah]

Man you’re deluded

[@rpdsouza1957]

The muslim apologetics now falling down like nine pins. Yassir Qadhi, Shabbir Ally already out. Soon only the dumbhead shouting brigade of mo hijab ( with his faithful companion Mimi dawah), Adnan rashid , joker Naik will be left.

[@olubunmidaemusin2125]

Lol 😂 "with his faithful companion "

[@manivannanchokkalingam8251]

These guys are better than their murderous mo, please watch the psychotic prophet by Abdullah sameer

[@George-iv1hi]

Islam is too stupid to be saved.

[@josevergara6161]

Mo hijab left the group.

[@daughtersofthekingdom6779]

@@josevergara6161 ,which group?

[@jejewa2763]

The crisis I see from this guy is the honesty question that despite the teaching which had been his life, he does not have the honesty to admit what is in front of him. Also he would have to deny 50 (?) years of identity and I have to admit would be hard for anyone let alone a brain washed adult!

[@tonyharding4794]

Jay. This is beautiful. The teachet loves God so so so deeply. I can feel his integrity. I hope this leads to opportunities for quiet discussion. The love of God will always be the greater.

[@rayali2861]

Yes, Allah-hu-Akbar (God is greater). Let's discuss this issue where the teacher says that the Quran is clearly preserved. Jay ignores that. The matter of many different Qurans where the text is the same but the markings/added vowels are different, do not matter. The revelation came down without markings. Dots/vowels were added to the different dialects in different countries to help with the correct pronunciation of the revelation. Much ado over nothing.

[@persecutedct]

Praise OUR LIVING LORD - JESUS CHRIST - We can see islam propaganda crumbles in our life time one by one. Thank you Jay Smith, Dan Gibson, Hatun Tash, Robert Spenser, Shiekh Murad, Mel at Sneaker Corners, and other warriors

[@farmuhqas]

Michael Hart put your GOD (Jesus) 3rd or 4th on the list and put Muhammad 1st. what a disgrace for you Christians. My choice of Muhammad to lead the list of the world's most influential persons may surprise some readers and may be questioned by others, but he was the only man in history who was supremely successful on both the religious and secular levels.-Michael H Hart.

[@persecutedct]

@be positive yes.. thats muhammad the obvious fake prophet influences do... He told his followers to mock others believer, tell lies, ignorant, behave like child, and even mock his own false god by saying 'god pray for muhammad'. If we use our brain just a bit, their false god who pray, pray to who?

[@showmethetruth328]

The truth is Christianity, muslims, jews, or any religion can claim to be the right true preserved religion. They all claim to be the one right religion. All you are doing is bickering and trying to point the finger. Why don't you talk about the millions of problems within christianity. By each religion saying they are the right one all you are saying God can't send a clear perfect message. Your Christianity brother of the past killed hundreds of thousands of people all in the name of God. Get real. Wake up.

[@farmuhqas]

@David Isa yeah ok, and WHO ARE YOU?.

[@razkhan4375]

Wow these christian missionaries are enjoying this lol You are judging and blowing this up Into what .. yasir qadhi is one individual who has an opinion.. We know quran is the word of allah compared to the bible with many errors confusion story of insest come on man

[@peterfreeman7359]

Hey Jay, check out what this Iraqi ßhiekh / scholar Ahmed al kabañji who said that the Quran cannot be from God but the man Mohammed himself. Boom there goes islam!

[@Nate-vu8pe]

I was shocked when I watched it.

[@manivannanchokkalingam8251]

Hope the killings and depravity ceases, start thinking islam.

[@leonardodavincithegenius4615]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/jobWaJmei9Kel7M

[@lionabbass]

@@leonardodavincithegenius4615 the one that killed forgot that killing any while hiding under governance/eminent domain will not wash in from of the Almighty Allah. i hope you don't condone any killing.

[@islanderws]

He himself admitted, "as the saying goes 'The emperor ( aka. Muhammad) has no clothes.'"

[@interqward1]

Caught that smile on your face there, at around 14: mins, Jay Smith. Winner winner. Winners are grinners.

[@johnw7657]

Looks like MiMi Hijab has put on a bit of weight and has been eating too much.......just finished the feast of Ramadan.

[@halloransusan1842]

true noticed that too and his beard....ughhhh

[@optimusprime5199]

He is looking like a bear🐻.

[@alexassali3628]

Haha .two fools talking in Islamic space

[@lionabbass]

@@alexassali3628 let me lump you, optimus prime, halloran susan and lbw together in this reply. there is nothing wrong for an over 6 ft tall male not to look healthy. for sure he is not a butterball or chunky. halloran susan should know there is samson syndrome and every male, say true alfa male will not have his face looking like that of a woman. he is not one that wears ear rings. i am sure when you look at him, you will know he is a man. optimus prime, it is more like a lion with the beard. and every prophet [AS] of God. you have them in the bible and Jesus was one. alex assali, your finger pointing didn't remind you that your case alone is 4 times that.

[@Shamsi419]

😂😂😂😂

[@mervynmenezes1400]

Perfectectly? Really Jay? Love your sense of humour! Keep up the good work. God bless you!

[@abelkjohn]

"ALLAH PRAYS FOR MOHAMMAD NOT TO MOHAMMED!!" sorry , I just can't help it!!

[@johnlee7699]

That's a good one!!! Pretty much. Allah is basically saying, don't take all the Praise O Praised One 😅

[@stardust6769]

I guess Yasser Quadi will not agree to an interview by you. 😅😅😅

[@rayali2861]

Wrong. I think Qadhi will willingly clear up the matter with Jay if he has the courage to invite Qadhi on his show. But Jay will not do that. He just want to propagate his anti-Muslim/anti-Islam hate in the media.

[@robertsticker8856]

Two future ex Muslims

[@STIGGARRIUS]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oYOWZaljfq6sm7s

[@johnlee7699]

May they become two powerful witnesses for Jesus Our LORD 🙏

[@francescoaccomando7781]

To be ex-muslim is to embrace truth. They want to embrace lies, because their father is the liar the devil and they speak their language.

[@oklumaokiwa5372]

the more they try to defend islam the more they are making the ship of islam sink

[@eddiejcarmichael]

Sorry if I seem a little confused. So if two Muslims from different parts of the world learn to recite the Koran by rote, using two different versions of the Koran, which one is actually reciting the unchanging, un-corrupted word of Allah?

[@MrDareh]

Shaykh Yasir Qadhi has a good heart. I perceive that he is sincere in his pursuit... I pray that he meets Jesus.

[@elizabethmillan3416]

Hello Dr. Smith, I love your lectures, you're an inspiration to all of us aspiring apologists.

[@gussetma1945]

When Gorbachev tried to admit the failures of Communism, it was the death knell of the Red Scourge.

[@captainmorgan6615]

You have no idea the positive impact you are making on christians and faith you are placing back on so many.. Speaking mostly for me.. Spirit is lifted and defend my belief with confidence

[@rayali2861]

False confidence! Jay is picking and choosing what suits him to cast doubt. Qadhi admits that Quran is the Word of God which has been preserved in its original form. Let Jay argues against Qadhi's basic/fundamental beliefs.

[@ardenkilikian7990]

This is the,, 1984'' - Version of the Muslim mind. If the party tells you 2+2 = 5, then it is 5 🤣

[@defcon2544]

14 centuries of deception, Allah is indeed a deceiver like no other.

[@johnlee7699]

💯 An Absolute Scammer. The Thief that comes to steal, kill and destroy.

[@abj136]

What happens when they finally admit that the Qu'ran is imperfectly transmitted. When they acknowledge changes have occurred. What is the next step? Dismiss the Hadith that made claims of perfection? Take seriously the Hadith that indicate corruption? Eventually must come to the reality that much of the Qu'ran precedes Mohammed and is a compilation of texts rather than a series of original revelations.

[@siulong1394]

After exposing Muhammad, finally, also the Quran is getting exposed! Ma sha Allah!

[@waitingandwatching9328]

What is wrong with these people brains that even the overwhelming evidence that the Qur'an has not been perfectly preserved... They say "no the Qur'an has been preserved by Allah." Keep up the great Jay and the others ... Souls eternity ...

[@iamalfaomega3221]

God bless you Jay.

[@midimusicforever]

The holes are big, and they are many!

[@bobthebuilder4660]

Christians are winning the argument thanks Jay!

[@AllTruthRevealed]

PBWY. We would respectfully disagree. Dr Qadhi is being honest on a personal level but that is only his opinion. You will note that Dr Qadhi did not refer to any evidence and so third parties cannot reasonably state as a fact that his opinion may be correct or incorrect without assessing the evidence.

[@mumunimuniru7784]

Really, and for the past two thousand years you've not been able to unwind the riddle; three = one? Let me help you out it's NONSENSE !

[@languaha]

"The standard narrative has holes in it"

[@johnlee7699]

That's the best song to get stuck in my head 😅😅😅. I love the remix by RC (Rob Christian) 😇😇😇

[@lonleb3767]

He doesnt want to give any examples of these Quranic issues? I wonder why!

[@jonnyy4088]

What annoys me is that they know in reality it's all nonsense but try to keep people (especially those in chains in muslim countries) from thinking about it.Viciously wrong.

[@seanmarkhayes8223]

GOOD WORK JAY YOU ARE COMING THERE . GOD BLESS YOU

[@penlight5289]

2 years ago on youtube post a video called : Dr Yasir Qadhi destroys the myth of the different versions of the Quran. It is an interesting video to revisit .

[@ngatatan2597]

The problem for the Qur'an is not just the "yes"/"no" answers... Because for faith to survive, there must not be any FATAL CONTRADICTIONS. Because faith can still survive on claims that cannot be proven true BUT faith is decimated on claims that are proven false or untrue.

[@christelsimbi3408]

I thought the other guy was an ex muslim debating the hijab guy, but he is actually a teacher 😂😂. This is different level I guess

[@craigmartinj]

Thank you... this is why your studies are so very important :)

[@truthforalltube]

Thrilling! Thank you Dr. Jay for your hard work. Finally Islam is uprooted!

[@Phil-4Jesus]

I don't know if you are aware, I looked in Hijab site, the video Dr Smith referenced have been cut to the 1:16 minutes to remove the questions Mohamad Hijab asked and Yasir Qadi answered. WOW!!!!

[@pfanderfilms]

Yes, that was during our livestream yesterday! Censoring doesn't help him, and only makes his position even more tenuous!

[@donitesfu7165]

God bless you Jay. Keep exposing this cult.

[@NathanKwadade]

Yasir Qadih keeps saying: "I'm NOT going to be explicit!" He knows there are a lot red herrings that he dare not let out of the bag. He knows the Quran is NOT preserved and the Standard Islamic Narrative (SIN) has holes in it!

[@TheBornfree83]

something crossed my mind, if we can see the textual variants from the different manuscripts of the Bible and trace the changes, and we apply that to the 36 copies of the koran, would we be able to get close to the 7th century koran?

[@jyli1583]

This video deserves 100 million likes. God bless you Dr. Smith! Thank you

[@trailrunning11vlog]

Islam promised everything but they cannot fullfil

[@commentfreely5443]

whatever it promised you get a big bag of fiery hell for eternity

[@HeavenGuy]

The Quran is the speech of Allah, abrogation and all. I guess Allah can't make up his mind when speaking.

[@rayali2861]

There is no abrogation in the Quran. Each verse is applicable to a special situation which still holds true if we experience the same situation today e.g. if someone attacks you, you have the right to defend yourself. Jesus is supposed to have said, turn your cheek and let the man person kill you. Yeah, right! Can't you see? Christian nations practise what Muhammad taught, not what Jesus said.

[@RGRaj_1977]

@@rayali2861 But the Quran itself talks about abrogation in the Quran!

[@rayali2861]

@@RGRaj_1977 Give men an example and then we will discuss.

[@o.7373]

Thank you Dr. Jay to unpack it like that so that it's easier for us to understand! God bless you 🙏

[@lucrezia8borgias]

Christ Jesus is Creating a new Evangelist, But Yasir Qadri doesn’t know it yet... we bind the strong man in Yasins life and By The Holy Blood of Jesus we pray for that he is set free.. 🙏 Amen.

[@Christheking5050]

Glory be to God almighty and our Lord Jesus christ and the Holy spirit of God to see Islamic scholar accept that quran is not perfectly capable nor preserve.

[@rayali2861]

Did you listen properly? He said that the Quran has been preserved. And he will prove it to you if you ask him. The same cannot be said of your gospels which went from over 100 to just four gospels. Yet, you believe these four are God's Words. Go back to the teachings of Christ through his brother James.

[@sudhirmercy]

The truth has come out. Praise God. Jesus said in the Bible You shall know the truth and the truth will set you free.

[@JLar-bb5hl]

Jay, I think you should get a good microphone for your YT-videos. I'd chip in, shouldn't be expensive, a few hundred dollars perhaps? Who can recommend some good mics?

[@joelstock94]

Thanks for this video! :) I don't know exactly how things happen at Speaker's Corner, but I was wondering if there is a better way to introduce these ideas to Muslims. I think shouting matches usually close peoples hearts and minds to one's words, no matter how much truth is in them. Is there a more calm and respectful way to explain these important truths that you are sharing? Though we don't respect the contradictions and failures within the Qur'an, we should at least respect the hearts of those who are seeking the truth and are possibly open to what we are saying.

[@abdulaimukaje5503]

Those people you saw in the video were not seeking the truth. They were there to oppose and challenge the truth. That's how speakers's corner works.

[@pfanderfilms]

It's because of that day at Speaker's Corner that Muhammad Hijab had this crisis of faith, which led him to have this interview with Yasir Qadhi. Speaker's Corner is not for most people, but the Muslims love it, because it presents one's faith in the context of power, much like Jesus did at the temple, on Mars Hill, and in Matthew 23:13-33

[@joelstock94]

@@abdulaimukaje5503 Good to know.

[@joelstock94]

​@@pfanderfilms Thanks for the clarification :) That's cool how that day lead to his crisis of faith. I appreciate your explanation! I'm interested though, are these same things also being shared in other ways? If so, it would be cool to hear about :) I bet there are also Muslims who would respond better to a softer approach.

[@Mex-300]

@@joelstock94 Love brother. We are to be the light to the world. Where the light shines darkness must leave. Love. Love and more love. Be as gentle as doves and wise as serpents. I'm speaking with a muslim currently and I know the seed of Christ is being put forth. Let's pray he will come to just understand God and many more will enter. Amen.

[@amanuelhabtezghi3470]

You are influenced me to research more about Islam. Thank you for your critical thinking. God bless you.

[@robertsticker8856]

A thousand Christmases have come for Jay

[@joeorony2118]

Thanks Jay, you've been telling pple about this problems concerning the truth about ISLAM, now everyone is seeing the truth.. Be blessed.

[@avalancheofapostasy4916]

Because the quran is so CLEAR. Yet they need scholars and imams to explain the CLEAR Quran.

[@KaySocoFilms]

Mo Hijab looks like Hanna Barbara's Captain Caveman 😁

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

By the way his name is Yasir Qadhi not Yassir Qadri

[@gg0drk041]

It depense in wich country you live. In my country we say yassir

[@rockydsouza5304]

Does it matter dude

[@johnlee7699]

Wait, do you mean Yasir is pronounced the same as "Yasser Arafat"

[@hmz6khih]

Quran 5:101says: O you who have believed, do not ask about things which, if they are shown to you, will distress you. But if you ask about them while the Qur'an is being revealed, they will be shown to you. Allah has pardoned that which is past; and Allah is Forgiving and Forbearing. 5:102 says: A people asked such [questions] before you; then they became thereby disbelievers. This says it all, think about this !

[@semajtram8615]

I think Hijab will leave islam soon or later..👌

[@esaiamasoane8171]

I am waiting for that, he will receive Jesus try to keep quiet and hide until it is like fire shut up in his bones

[@chm5750]

Well I don't see why not, he's a very intelligent guy.

[@teejah7785]

So, he is a scholar? for a scholar to not accept the truth then he is no scholar. who listens to this Muslim scholar? I pray for you! plus, I would not take your class because as a teacher you do not deserve to be called one.

[@greatAce704]

I'm an ex muslim who was born in a very conservative community and country that less valuing the philosophy subject, thus i'm aware that i am very much lack in critical thinking skill. But i wanna ask this, every time I try to bring some matter to my parents regarding the Quran that doesnt make sense, they always brush it off and constantly said that "we're just mere human. There's something that beyond our own understanding.. & everything about Islam and Quran that doesnt makes sense to you, all due to our mind not able to comprehend them". I always got that response from them.. It just seems lazy to me every time they answered me this way. Even when i was little, I ask my mom "how's God looks like? Does he have arms like us, does he sleep, does he have feelings like human?" She would answers, "wallahu alam" (only God knows).. anyone have ways in dealing with this kind of answers? every time i ask my family, my muslim friends, this is what they'll say to make me shut my mouth when i rise some doubts "some matters are beyond our human comprehension.."

[@ianmontez4201]

This year has been full of surprises for me. The latest one is me agreeing with Mohammed Hijab. "I think it should be a simple yes or no"

[@58jfm]

If the koran is not really known, the directions of the qiblas were not pointing to mecca, and questions about the historicity of mohammed and the first caliphs, what are we to make about islam? It seems like there is nothing there historically, and we can't say mohammed was even remotely a prophet.

[@sweeneyadair2952]

Hijab still doing Dawah, he's not actually interested in what Qadhi has to say...

[@DheerajKattula]

:)

[@sandeshkhillare7478]

Thanks alot Dr Jay Smith you have explained this very well. May God keep you healthy and wealthy. Love from India. You are a true inspiration. You reflect Christ like behaviour.

[@israelperez-sg8er]

In the 6th minute of this interview Sheik Yasir Qadhi states that when you do a deep dive is when things get a bit awkward and difficult. English translation: "When you do a deep dive is when you know you´re in deep Sh-t".

[@Psalm316]

Wow! I need to share this with my brother ASAP

[@alijustin8340]

Red line in knowledge, what kind of teaching is this

[@carlosdsouza2451]

Please pray for shabbir ally.hopefully he persuades other muslim scholars to admit that there are many different qurans and for them not to deny it

[@bettymofokeng3404]

Thanks Dr Qadhi, for being honest, so that people can make their own choice about religion, not to be forced into a religion by being told lies and threatened not to asked pressing questions, i salute you

[@PerHolbo]

Do you have a link to the original video? We need to save it for future references...

[@pfanderfilms]

It's in the description box above. So is the review of the video

[@PerHolbo]

@@pfanderfilms oh.. thxs... I missed that. I'll be making a video on it in Danish. Hopefully to be released Monday

[@lkae4]

Sister Hatun gave a devastating body shot to the Quran in 2016. This is the delayed reaction knockdown. On the other hand, Hijab keeps knocking down Islam by accident. 🤣

[@mver191]

He exposes Islam as the thug religion it is.

[@georgek626]

This is interesting....I wonder how this dilemma will be handled by our Muslim friends?

[@mumunimuniru7784]

Every nominal Muslim know this the Quran have variant reading's not text.

[@Andersljungberg]

I saw that you have a facebook page But apparently you haven't used it since 2014. are you on any other social media where I can discuss and also share interesting articles

[@pfanderfilms]

I'm purposely not on Facebook, but you can contact me via the Pfander web site: www.pfander.uk/ Just hit the 'contact' button, and state my name, and the e-mail will be redirected to me.

[@GKong3]

You know, it sounds a great deal like quantum superpositions, the way he explains how all the qira'ats are authentic (canonical?). It's like, is the cat dead or alive? Yes. It's both. Until you observe it. Oh dear, looks like there's plenty of observers to collapse the superpositions now.