JCB vs Manitou vs Skid Steer | Dairyman's Opinion

Merch: 10thgenerationdairyman.com/
Thank You!

[@iopcanada16]

Very in depth and informative review for anyone looking to buy these types of machines! Can never go wrong with Eric’s reviews!!

[@alexlehenbauer7698]

A skid steer fits your farm so well, i couldnt imagine that you get a telehandler. Maybe a Skid steer with a telescopic boom 😉 Keep up the good work!

[@jonlowe8727]

A wise decision in my opinion. Barn work the skidsteer is a no brainer. I wonder if the telehandler would be more beneficial during harvest, but bottom line the numbers have to work. Been an interesting mini series. Top content mate 👌

[@lars611farmer3]

Thanks for the in depth and informative review. Many farms in Europe like to use articulated wheelloaders, some also have a telesoping boom. Skidsteer loaders are often seen as just too small, or they can´t reach over the top of medium size feedmixers.

[@edharnish3294]

It seemed like a good honest review of the two machines. And also a good comparison with a skid loader. Thank you

[@gethinjones1348]

A concise, honest and sensible review of all 3 machines Eric, many thanks for sharing this video 👍🏻

[@cinderblock2289]

I truly have enjoyed watching you use these machines, giving comparisons, feels, etc.

[@adamhemmelgarn3300]

Your sense of humor gets me every time. 😀 Glad you got to try out some different machines and got to see how they could fit into your operation.

[@bigdcarmichael]

Rocked the review guy, without trashing the two loaners. Your savings means more toys for the kids, and more soft drinks. 🤛🏼🤛🏼

[@derschwarzbrennerausdember8746]

We prefer the telescop because we store balles over the cows and have a BGA and therefore its better. Also we can stack the balles higher on the field for bringing them home. And we have only small silos and had to store a lot of grain in halls. Hope my English is quite understandeble Jakob

[@hiramblakecamp6087]

I've been watching your videos while you've been trying the telehandlers and noticed how rarely you chose to used the JCB. I thought you were angling towards a Manitou recommendation. In the end, I was impressed that you highlighted the Kubota rather than the shiny new Maintou based upon your specific needs and included a cost comparison. Thanks and good work!

[@pinesedgefarm1155]

Always nice to hear other's opinions on equipment.

[@cashcow9584]

We just made the jump from a loader tractor to a New Holland Ls180. One of the best decisions we've made. Thinking to the future, no one on the farm is getting younger so the side entry would be worth its weight in gold and our barn lots are relatively open. I thought the way forward would be a smaller wheel loader. Thanks to your videos, starting to flirt with the idea of a telehandler. Great review and operating videos.

[@olasteer2197]

telehandlers are great machines usable for all kind of jobs can pretty much be somewhat of a cherry picker

[@johnogrady2347]

Jcb teleskid has side door entry

[@TheRealJesseStoltzfus]

There are some smaller wheel loaders that have telescopic ability.

[@roberthakeman9822]

Loved New Holland skid loaders hardly had any problem with them. We traded every 2-3 years

[@tedc.4956]

Without a doubt, a cup holder is the winning design feature. Glad you worked a Dew into the video. I'm sure it holds a chocolate milk equally well.

[@CaseIHman]

Sounds like a jcb teleskid would be perfect for you Eric! Thanks for always posting great content!!

[@charleslynch7274]

Great review I'll miss seeing you drive them around definitely looks like fun

[@markvittorini5497]

Very nice evaluation! You said good things that those contemplating a purchase of a telehandler would be happy to have one!

[@jokarchner3326]

Keep it up man your videos are the best

[@bradpogue3448]

Very good information on the different types of machinery.

[@shibarimaster1]

Everyone forgets about the cup holder until there isn't one, very under rated necessity.

[@greggardner2823]

Sure easy to get used to our comforts

[@LeRogaie]

Awesome review, thanks very much for sharing. On our dairy farm in Italy we have always used telehandlers (currently we run three Merlo's), as you pointed out the biggest advantage of these machines is versatility, if you start using them you will soon find yourself buying and building an incredible amount of accessories for the craziest jobs! We have a concrete mixer bucket, like 5 different sets of forks, buckets of all sizes, a platform for jobs at height, 3 different hooks, a straw blower and so on... Awesome machines. But I totally get the in-barn capacities of a skeedsteer!

[@cowwhisperer8927]

Nice honest and independent review. 😀

[@dougdiplacido2406]

Eric, you gave a really thorough and in depth review of the machines. I have noticed in your videos over time you are really agile with the skid steer. Gotta love the cup holder. Thanks for a great review video.

[@no_username1]

cupholders are always the dealbreaker my man. Glad you’re having fun running those and giving us some helpful knowledge along the way God bless you and your family

[@adrianhandbury701]

Great unbiased video Eric - it’s great hearing someone be impartial!

[@DocPortland]

It seems like every time I wear my 10th Gen hoodie to work, a vid comes out... great timing... Great job on the review.

[@jentpostma337]

Very honest review I think, and after we bought a medium sized wheel loader, I agree they both have their place on the farm. We gained efficiency and sped up jobs with the wheel loader, but still easily put over 5-600 hours on a skidsteer.

[@michaelg.5862]

Thanks Eric, good information. Informative review and comparison.

[@Marshall_Weber]

Awesome Video and Much Love as Always 🐄 Man!!!

[@petemeredith7759]

Great set of video's Eric, the work you do and the way you drive the skid steer in your tight spaces always amazes me, (I do wonder how many times you have clipped the odd fence or wall :-) ), the steer just costs in better, great work, hope the family are good cheers Pete

[@Der_Direktsaatveganer]

Great Video, i‘m a dairy Farmer from Germany. Nobody Is working here with a skid loader. It‘s nice to see you working with it, but i can not imagine to use it at home

[@jerrellmartin9715]

This video was very helpful. I am planning to try out that JCB, but the hold up from day one has been the price for me so I guess we shall see when I get a chance to run it

[@frasermathers2287]

Great evaluation of the various machines Eric. It was fair and detailed as to how it would suit your operation and I would say I would fully agree with that assessment. You also highlighted that very important point about how to secure your regular requirement for Chocolate Milk or Mountain Dew! Lol Keep up the good work.

[@richardtoms9161]

You hit the nail on the head when you said that a combination of tele handler and skid loader is the way. We got lucky at a auction and basically stole a tele handler. It is fantastic at a wide variety of tasks outside of the barns but we still run the skid loader for scraping alleys and cleaning pens as you just can’t beat the manu

[@robynmorris7945]

I agree, I liked the Manatou for your operation. Just seemed the right size for what you do. Happy that you got to demo the two at the same time. Good luck.

[@charlesward8196]

Be sure to pass along our thanks to the implement dealers for allowing you to demo these two machines.

[@EmiDK]

Telehandlers are awesome for certain jobs on the farm but don't have much use in tight barns. I'm European and from Denmark. We don't use a lot of telehandlers for farm work. Tractors with front end loaders and medium sized payloaders are more common. As for skid steers there's even less. They are mainly used in construction. Most farms use small pivot steering loaders that have 45-60 hp for the jobs where most of you in North America use skid steers. weidemann and schäffer being the most used brands. But i do see the the advantages of a skid steer. But i can't imagine stepping in and out of them 20 times a day. It just look very inconvenient and the ride seems rough. Thank you for the comparison. :)

[@willholliday3537]

In UK we mostly use pivot steer telegandlers.

[@gregshearer423]

@@willholliday3537 well that not true there far more standard telehandler sold in the uk than pivot steers

[@tristanasbreuk8137]

@@gregshearer423 POV the smart boy gets angry again

[@gregshearer423]

@@tristanasbreuk8137 what

[@stevensigns946]

great comparative analysis !

[@davidcantu824]

LOVE ALL YOUR VIDEOS ERIC HAVE BLESSED DAY

[@stephenbutz2621]

The cost factor is a BIG difference!!

[@bhoola123]

Thanks, really nice practical insight.

[@lathan6746]

Wholesome family entertainment...thank you!

[@Valtra-rn1ed]

Excellent video really enjoyed that! Now i want to demo a skidsteer on our farm, you made me want to get rid of our telehandler haha! Too bad there are no dealers who sell skidsteers around here, thanks for the video and indepth review

[@jamesbreault5762]

Interesting take on those machines great job👍👍👍👍

[@mikaelkarlsson4933]

Thanks för a good comperision of this maschines Mikael. Sweden

[@YoloKae]

Jcb builds a Skid Steer with an extendable boom and a side door. Might be of interest for u.

[@Bortnoone]

I’ll never be near any of them, but your comments were insightful and interesting

[@kamrankhan78]

Excellent review done.

[@michaelfilipelli2968]

Great content!!

[@lonvansickle2863]

Great comparisons between equipment.

[@Oisdead]

You just said what I've been thinking. The skid seemed like you were more efficient on your property!

[@fdelputte5755]

Very nice video, Eric.

[@farmingthemitten4887]

We run both and actually made the switch to exclusively Manitou in 2019. We have a pair of larger Manitou telehandlers and 3 Manitou skid loaders, 2 wheeled and 1 tracked. Been extremely happy with all of them.

[@Zeke-yv3nw]

Great info Eric!

[@46rambo49]

30 years of equipment maintenance tells me you did a good review on your uses. as for maintenance the CAT seems to hold up better than most of the others over time. I you have room for them they are a nice tool but in tight spaces you're right the skid steer is far better, you are spot on with the maintenance they are more maintenance. They don't sit out in the weather nearly as well other, they have more problems

[@9856CB]

Thorough evaluation,👍. Most cars in the past were sold because of cupholders🥴

[@sunroofracing]

Great video Eric! The review information is golden and highly valued. I think the small amount of money paid to dairy farms for the milk produced drives decisions like this. It would be nice to have both but you aren't being paid as much as you deserve for your product. You can't raise the price of milk. Limited rental of a telehandler for specific jobs might be a solution when it saves time and increases productivity. Otherwise - stick with what works. Enjoyed hearing your views. Well done!

[@steveneal2706]

great video Eric. thank you very much. you did good

[@jerrycampbell6181]

Great video an review !!! GOD BLESS !!!

[@bjl1226]

Well done and fair assessment

[@farmshoffman8475]

Great awesome video Eric

[@morganm9027]

I enjoyed watching you try them out and this review. I was curious to find out what you decided. You put a lot of thought in and just money wise probably made a smart choice. 🐄

[@stuartgibson1896]

Have you looked at a JCB Teleskid?

[@rmddairyfarm1426]

Great review!! Gotta have the cup holder!!

[@aidenducat2572]

Love the vids

[@GaryWrightUtah]

Funny, when you pulled those 2 onto your farm, I thought exactly your end conclusion from the start. Good to review and know for sure...

[@ArmpitStudios]

I’m surprised they telehandlers are so popular in the UK, what with their tiny barns and dumping grain on the floor for storage. Cleaning those out with a skidsteer would be so much easier. Anybody else remember when we all called them “uniloaders”? I still prefer that term. The only really good use for telehandlers is landscaping or other construction work around existing homes, where they don’t tear up the lawn nearly as much as a uniloader does. Hire someone to do a little work around your house in the US and you’ll end up with a ruined yard for the next year while you get it back into shape.

[@jeff4044]

You forgot to thank the dealer for letting you demo them but great review. God bless.

[@samherbert1724]

Great reviews 👌

[@jimpolk]

Great comparisons Eric. I still like the telehamdlees but you're right They're not as nimble as a skid loader.

[@evanhix7049]

We have a 750 cow dairy in pa and we run 4 skiddloaders and a 544g payloader and we love using skiddloaders

[@Dan-qy1rg]

Wow Eric, your point of the handling is right on point. The cost of the telehandlers really surprised me. I wasn't aware of the huge difference in price, along with all the other points you made, would make me agree with your assessment. I guess with all that considered the skid loader would me my choice too, of course I haven't used a telehandler, but I have skid loaders. Awesome comparison video, thanks for sharing, have a safe and wonderful week and weekend ahead.

[@pittschapelfarm2844]

Thanks! Great review.

[@henriverheyen6190]

Exellent review!!!

[@stefgrootlipman69]

here in europe you see smaller articulated wheelloaders quite often. thight turn radius and high lift capacity. they are used alot in combi with bale trailers. because you can load and tow the bales with 1 person in 1 machine

[@carynix8043]

Great analysis and I agree in your operation a skid steer seems better for most of your daily task.

[@dalescommonsense7676]

Great videos 👍. How do you get the time to put out so many

[@alecfromminnenowhere2089]

Thanks for the assessment of the JCB and the Manitou. I was wondering about the tight spaces that the telehandlers would have trouble negotiating. I think that a good match would be the Manitou with your Kubota someday like you said.

[@bobjohnson1710]

You're review of the telehandlers verses the skid steer was spot on from what we saw in your earlier videos. What do you have planned for your next equipment demo? Is there a Fendt dealer close by? I'd love to see a side by side comparison between John Deere and a Fendt equipment. Or maybe New Holland and Case wheel loaders. How long before planting starts?

[@dawsonrichter215]

A teleskid might be more a fit for your farm. We have one and my god I love it. Don't realize how much you actually use the extending boom. It's great. And the best part is, it has a cup holder!!!

[@rightsideofthegrass8114]

Great job in review - concise, direct comparisons, from based on experience. The 2X price makes a decision on either/or. Thank you.

[@loganbryanton5525]

I have two of the same skids steers and a manitou 634 we have had many issues with the manitou at where the flywheel connects to the hydraulic pump great machines but they do have there place we are currently in the transition of loading feed with a wheel loader as our mixer is to tall for the kubotas to load 👎🏻 great video! Commenting from Prince Edward Island Canada.

[@dobberaaron6658]

Skid steer all the way for your setup it's a lot easier a lot cheaper to get in and out can't get the telehandler into clean them baby cows bedding I just stick with the skid steer can't be the Kubota that's my opinion Kubota Tractors are all we have ran another good video to look about the telehandler good job on that stay safe stay warm God bless

[@ronreed5306]

Ohh. I don't use/ know how to use any of these machines. Price is the bottom line of course for any addition to rolling stock( skid steer, tractor, " tele-handler, hearse, limo, utility vehicle, etc.) but as one looking in from outside, Manitou rocks the house! Can't see past the dune buggy vibe or utility ( silly me) issues. Any way I won't be driving a Manitou around Nashville... but I still would love to play with one. Thanks Eric and thank you sincerely for allowing me to hang out with you and yours. God bless

[@jasonhieronimus4142]

Great comparison of all machines. Good to see that you game all a fair test. Your right on all of them. Maybe you should try the tele-skid from JCB??? That is the best of both worlds. I don't have one. I want to try one myself. Good job!!!

[@donevens4357]

Good review Eric. Hard to beat a skid loader in tight space. Ran 1 for over 40 years. They were all Case. I don't know about the rest, but looks like yours is just fine!

[@warehouseman6325]

The Manitou definatly be my choice. Looks easier to maneuver over the JCB. The JCB looks more structural solid but looks more difficult in typical farming areas

[@rollingreclinerRecumbent]

Holy cats...had no idea these little things cost that much.

[@patricianewton1417]

You are honest and fair. We need more of that in our world. I identify with T-Rex Arms.

[@geraldskaggs3903]

I sure could see where one of each would come in handy if affordable (one telehandler and one steer skidder.

[@gethinjones7501]

Good job 👍

[@michaelladue5655]

Great review

[@bobblossom2713]

You got those telehandlers pretty dirty....😂

[@Seanterpstra722]

Hi Eric great video

[@8287tjsaboe]

Great video! You're a man after my own heart Eric, Mountain Dew is the elixir of life. I would have to say, "skid steer" for the win!

[@fdelputte5755]

I grew up on a farm in Europe, we had a skid steer as well, very convenient in the old stables etc… (case 1835b and then case 1840) My father retired in 2008; …. I still own the skid steer, .. says a lot, doesn’t’ it?

[@brodieschubert2388]

Is there a cupholder for milk or dew? Watch all your videos man. Thanks for all the work you put into them🐄🇨🇦👍

[@lindavonh131]

Great comparison.

[@rosemarymurphy5767]

Very good review off all three telling about them . I stick with skid loader less parts to get and fix .

[@farmerfachie6305]

Totally agree with your opinion on the telehandler on and skid steer as we run a bobcat s70 jcb agri pro and a manitou 625 but over time the manitou 625 will lose lifting capacity and the jcb will give add blue Errors but all in all a telehandler is a better option then the skid steer so I highly recommend a jcb telehandler as it’s lasted the longest in my and neighbouring farms and good seller over in the uk and are very well built