Jegulus (James & Regulus) Deep Dive!

[@morganelle1707]

Noo don’t dive deep, Reggie can’t swim 😭

[@danaikageorges2496]

Oh my God that's fool 😢😅

[@ellabrandon535]

Omg that’s cruel 😭

[@mariajoseleon8680]

I LAUGHED SO HARD DHKSHFD but now I feel bad...I'm sorry my baby Reggie 🥹💔

[@Ethxxy]

STOOOPPPPPPHHH THIS IS EVILLL

[@honeyymintt]

HELPP i laughed more than I should lol

[@ew1488]

James: „He has the ego the size of a lake but a heart to match it“

[@Love_dustbunny]

A lake for Regulus to drown in (⁠ ⁠；⁠∀⁠；⁠)

[@Loaf_F]

@@Love_dustbunny STOP😭🙏🙏😭

[@Ashcloud3228]

NOOO ANYTHING BUT THE LAKE REGGIE CANT SWIM

[@joelvedamony8847]

ATYD REFERENCE!?

[@bunnyweeb7932]

Do I know what Jegulus is? Yes. Did I still watch the whole video? YES. I. NEED.JEGULUS.IN.MY.BLOOD

[@SamHallow-k9q]

Same

[@JoyHoward-gl7kj]

I’ve always thought Starseeker would be an epic name for this ship

[@symwinter]

The entire marauders fandom is truly just “this started as a joke but bro, I don’t think it’s a joke anymore” Also if you recap Crimson Rivers my life will be yours. Like, please.

[@Coffeekoe]

FR IT IS. And I will :)) the video will be up sometime soon-ish

[@meggoez]

being a multishipper is sooo nice cuz i love both jily and jegulus. people gotta understand its called FAN fiction for a reason. hell ive read poly fics of remus sirius and james before but im not over here saying its canon! its fiction yall have fun!!

[@flaviae.9072]

The way that I just stopped my wolfstar playlist when I received the notification

[@acidstrip]

I haven't read any jegulus content bc the only big fic I’ve read of marauders has been all the young dudes (thanks to you lmao) but the moment I found out abt it I was HOOKED and was so happy that (at least some of the) fandom agreed on jegulily. Like yes give Lily two boyfriends, give James two people who will gang up on him when he's begging silly, and give Reggie two sunshines who make him understand he is enough it's PERFECT??

[@guizrkive]

It only took me reading one chapter of crimson rivers to understand the hype for jegulus, It's my favorite fanfic followed by art heist baby and just lovers. I haven't read any jegulily fanfic yet so if anyone wants to recommend one to me, I'd appreciate it. Thanks for making this video, I loved it. 🧡

[@guizrkive]

Also, the only fic I couldn't finish reading was choices, it was devastating 😭

[@Coffeekoe]

that's so real, crimson rivers is so amazing :'))

[@Chappellsrchive]

@@guizrkive i dropped it after what happened to mary tbh although i might get around to finishing it, i'm not so sure yet

[@eclipsesmoon]

if u filter by jegulily and hits on ao3, the top two fics are a string of consequences and scent of the moon, which i heard a lot about ao maybe check those out?

[@lizart4679]

​@@eclipsesmoonooh I just looked and I haven't even started yet but it looks like scent of the moon is a werewolf Sirius fic too so if anyone likes werewolf Sirius there you go It's literally 40 chapters though so I'm preparing myself to suffer

[@lunathetiger1]

the way i literally cheered when you said the solution is jegulily lmao i love that ship so much ❤

[@Coffeekoe]

*real* i would too, they are my current brainrot fr

[@mokshiweasley2781]

I only just finished crimson rivers (like 4 hrs ago) and i was NOT ready for you too say "A great big tragedy" 😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@galaxyfilms8494]

“JiLy HaS tO hApPeN fOr ThErE tO bE hArRy PoTtEr” 🙄 if they really looked into the canon they would remember that Neville could have been the chosen one instead…

[@Mrs.MalfoyLady]

2:52 i was almost gonna say “YOU FORGOT TO DESCRIBE REGULUS AS A POOR LITTLE MEOW MEOW”😂

[@DarcyFanClub]

At the very end I was ready to talk about jegulily with the jegulus vs jily and when you mentioned jegulily I got so happy. And I love the mischief production sm!

[@Blue_turtle_boy]

I’m not super into the marauders fandom like fanfic more of a golden trio girly but I have a soft spot for jegulus. I find it super interesting how the fanfiction influences the fandom.

[@beth8191]

SAW THIS AND IMMEDIATELY CLICKED!! the choices mention is so special to me, it’s my favourite jegulus fic of all time even though people hate it just bc most characters, especially james, aren’t morally perfect (or it’s too heavy, which is understandable)😭 also, THANK YOU for speaking on the discourse, jegulus antis only care about canon when it comes to things they don’t like and claim jegulus is misogynistic when their whole argument confines lily to the role of a mother like?? the call is coming from inside the house and its like they don’t know ao3 tag filtering exists istg 😭i LOVED this video btw, it was very thorough!!

[@Coffeekoe]

exactly, and it's always been so weird to me that most jegulus hate i see is on tumblr *where you can filter tags the best*

[@Unapologeticallyunmaskedash]

​@Coffeekoe aren't you in Marauders cosplay?

[@TinyFrog997]

I heavily reccomend reading Only The Brave and Art Heist, Baby! Those two fics are amazing, honestly

[@mothtotheflame13]

this is gonna be my next brainrot video to watch an ungodly amount of times- anyway! jegulus is my newest obsession courtesy of crimson rivers, so i gotta get the lore while i put off reading choices because i know i’ll fall into seasonal depression early when i finish!! literally obsessed with your marauders videos :) regulus has skyrocketed to my new fave (hyperfixation) character so i’m so ready to watch this!

[@Coffeekoe]

i heavily relate to everything in your comment LMAOO. So felt!

[@ColeMercury]

OK, you’ve sold me on Jegulus. I wonder if the whole “But it’s not canon!” thing is *because* there is so little existing canon about the Marauders era - so those people are looking to Marauders fics to fill in the missing pieces. And it’s harder to fit Jegulus in with what’s there from the books: particularly with how Regulus and Sirius were basically estranged, and Sirius being dismissive and scornful of Regulus in book 5. Seems to me that if Regulus *had* dated James there was a better chance he’d have survived.

[@eclipsesmoon]

if you’re planning on reading more jegulus (please) im cheering for just lovers. god that fic is just so good. the skittles friendships are the best portrayals of them, jegulus are adorable and stupid. but honestly dont let it fool you, its definitely a feel good fluffy fic, but there are at least 3 big angst moments that have me on the floor everytime i read. not CR level but still *screams* ABH and OTB are masterpieces truly, they read like a movie?? like they’re action packed and so much plot is happening, multiple times while reading i was like “wow this needs to be on screens” bc its just that exciting. regulus is THE badass icon in OTB truly, scarier than cr!reg🤭 personally ive avoided choices bc canonical deaths are my enemy #1 (and i dont like the cheating fic thing either), so when u said james kept reg’s quaffle i needed a moment😭🔫 the general opinion on this fic is spot on how you described tbh, very controversial i’d recommend reading in the order of just lovers-AHB-OTB. those three (and CR duh) are the best jegulus reads in my experience and they give you 3 different versions of them, yk happy in hogwarts, sad heist au, badass canon divergent. and also since AHB is a SADSAD fic, so i would sandwich it between two happier fics for mental health reasons😂✌️

[@Coffeekoe]

because i'm weird and like angst and pain i'm planning to read AHB next haha, it also has the most intriguing plot to me but i'll likely read the others too :))

[@eclipsesmoon]

@@Coffeekoe ahha omg have fun, pack your tissues😂

[@scatorccios]

nahh kissing booth jegulus au is GENIUS

[@arzedudd]

im a huge jily shipper (they're my babies) but I gotta say, I totally see the appeal of Jegulus. So much that I read choices and was devastated by how sad it was (totally recommend it). So i really don't get jily shippers who hate it so much, and that whole harry wouldn't have existed without jily is so silly to me because we're talking about fanfiction, we're all playing in the same field of illegitimacy, what happens in a fic has no effect whatsoever on the cannon, who cares what some people ship?? whether there's Jegulus content or there isn't, the books will remain the same, harry will still exist, lily and james will have died together, and there will be million other people doing jily content so go read that. (and if you like jily i highly recommend the Last Enemy series, it's genuinely so good)

[@eclipsesmoon]

alsooo fun fact you mentioning mischief prod is what inspired me to watch their short films. the two jegulus ones are insane. like the EMOTIONS i was experiencing??? wtf. i now must watch them religiously everyday. and james’ casting is simply perfect, like did james potter drop out of the fucking sky and get into this film??? i just spent the entire evening yesterday scrolling thru mischief production’s ig👍 ps. i love the petty toxic jily segment AHAHA im so tired of seeing the hate all over tumblr

[@Coffeekoe]

yessss! this makes me so happy :D And yes, Rafa is totally so similar to James. The best casting ever tbh :))

[@miriheart1366]

@@Coffeekoe god i need to see these videos, help me someoneeeee

[@Coffeekoe]

@@miriheart1366 psst drive.google.com/file/d/1yqNjgsvQjmf7iFw3bZrUYVSE8cXSOp-R/view?usp=drive_link

[@Happylittlefrogs9498]

AGGGGG I LOVE JEGULUS WITH A BURNING PASSION, THANK YOU SO MUCH :)

[@Marauders_taylors_version]

I genuinely don't understand people who say it is unrealistic cause what do you mean. Literally nothing about Harry Potter is realistic and and pretty much everything about the marauders is just made up. Also a lot of jegulus fics aren't even written set at Hogwarts like art heist baby (which is my favourite fic and everyone should read). I love Jegulus but I will still read fics with Jegulily and Jily cause it's all made up and judging people based on a ship of two made up characters is stupid.

[@liiyyahhhm7]

jegulus my beloved!! just lovers was my first jegulus fic and i've been hooked ever since

[@ACE-qb1ux]

I loved that too. Can you recommend me more jegulus fics?

[@peccatore7220]

you cant imagine how happy i am rn. REALLY.

[@Ashcloud3228]

I love everything about your look! Hair, glasses, makeup, piercings, earrings, the outfit, afhhhhh!! And your eyes are beautiful! I think it’s supposed to be a James cosplay (I may be dumb) but it looks amazing!

[@ellabrandon535]

10:57 every one else gets somewhat happy ones, and then we are over here with the *fucking hunger games*

[@andyaliaga3188]

“The answer… is ✨Jegulily✨” Wiser words have never been spoken All hail the Mother Ship

[@martiibr]

absolutly loved this video!!! you should make a wolfstar one

[@Coffeekoe]

thank you :)) and maybe i will 😋😋

[@luckityduckitydoo]

art heist baby is the most popular fic ive read :(( i need to read atyd and crimson rivers but i haven't been able to commit to them :(((((

[@arablahblahh]

I just want to thank you for always shouting out the Mischief Productions because I would have never found them otherwise and I have fallen in love with their fan films (I literally started writing a fanfic that builds off of A Night's Tale and I've never written fanfiction before so I think that tells you how much I love their content)

[@Coffeekoe]

of course! Their channel is my favourite thing in the whole fandom so I always try to give them exposure and help get donations :D It makes me so happy to know that i've introduced a few people to their film

[@farahhossam2280]

and now i need a rosekiller and dorlene deep dive

[@Coffeekoe]

rosekiller will be next teehee

[@harper_leigh]

these are my favorite thing to listen to during school never stop😭🙏

[@Ashcloud3228]

I definitely recommend art heist baby! My girlfriend had me read it after she got me into marauders and it’s so good!

[@absolute7079]

I know this is a hella late comment, but ty for this! I've been beating myself up for ages for liking stuff in this fandom, especially Jegulus, that seems to be hated/loved. I needed the reminder that it's all fan-made anyway, and everyone deserves to enjoy what they want to an extent🤨(problematic ships i'm talking about you!) TY

[@Yuri_angelsCosplay]

A Night’s Tale was also the video that got me shipping Jegulus! That and this video. Your explanation was so good that even though I haven’t read Crimson Rivers, I had a dream the night after watching this video that I was James trying to survive the Hunger Games with Regulus. But AHHHH this ship makes me cry!!!!!!

[@zofiazblewska9415]

James knows how to ball, Regulus knows Aristotle

[@BananaSlushii]

I HIGHLY RECOMMEND Meeting's That Start In The Dark, it's angsty but it has a happy ending!!! And it's consuming my life, I haven't even finished it yet but I'm almost done and Harry survives for anyone who likes that :D

[@Antonia-hr1ek]

Thank you so much for all your work! I am very new to this ship and you explained everything so well that now I start to love Jegulus

[@kup536]

reading crimson rivers rn and its killing me, bizarrestars the man that you are

[@vittoria.simoncelli4711]

17:30 i'm in the middle of only the brave right now and i think i might have found my favourite marauders fanfic AAAAA

[@KenasynGarrison-zo8lo]

I always love your videos! Thanks for making this content!

[@Coffeekoe]

aww i'm glad you like them, thank you

[@frogberries]

In love.I'm not a maraders fan but I love your videos! I like to learn stuff about other fandoms especially because my friend is a maraders fan! :D so happy I got to be the 100th like

[@Coffeekoe]

aw thank you, perhaps i'll end up getting you to join the dark side (the marauders fandom lmao)

[@Rowentheraccoon]

FINALLY SOME LOVE TO MY FAV FAN FILM EVER (A nights tale)

[@scatorccios]

OMGOMG i needed this vide sm thanku moira!!!

[@mayrasilva783]

HIII Just hearing the name Choices break my heart, and is one of my favorite fics, It's hate and very human. And yeah people just hate Starchaser because they dont see the vision

[@neanekleinhans1012]

I JUST found out about Reiky's passing and I spend almost 10 minutes bawling my eyes out but when I Googled the cause, I spent another 10 minutes crying😢😢

[@cheshire_lover]

After you said “they are getting a lot of hate they don’t deserve” a Dick’s Sporting Goods ad popped up with just the giant word “Dick’s” and I thought that was hilarious😂😂 Thanks for the deep dive into the Jegulus ship! I’m newer to the ship so I really appreciate this video with all the amazing recs for fanfics and other content!😁

[@Audrey15Derf]

With three ships that are very popular in this universe that I find very adorable sometimes is Jegulus (right person wrong time) Marauders Darry (forced enemies) Harry Potter Scobus (soulmates) Next gen How I see, it is a Potter after two failed attempts, finding their true love within someone from the Black family. I just wanted to mention that because you kept mentioning Darry and I’m like oh there’s one more that is similar.

[@carmosilva3589]

Read choices, I loved it, but it is one of those you gotta decide if you like yourself!!

[@vittoria.simoncelli4711]

16:20 READ CHOICES IT IS THE BEST FANFICTION EVER WRITTEN IN HISTORY (i genuinely sobbed for 3 days straight 😍)

[@mayrasilva783]

I tried reread Choices and i still dont finished the prologue 😃

[@itssimplylolaASMR]

choices broke me but I did enjoy it. I really want to read ahb though 🙏🙏🙏

[@greenluvrbb8]

YOU GET ME WITH THE ONE THATS INSPIRED BY DORIAN AND RAFA!! That picture is the first time they met for the read through and Dorian was really mad at Rafa for being late and going straight to the bathroom they talked about it on live and it was so cute 😭

[@Coffeekoe]

fr! I actually cut a part out of this video where I was explaining the lore behind the picture LMAOOO happy to see a fellow Dorian's live's enjoyer hehe

[@night_reader7229]

Your videos bring me so much joy!

[@Coffeekoe]

aw that is so sweet, thank you sm

[@camallow4388]

I feel like Only the Brave and Choices are good ending/bad ending variants of each other. I’ve read both and the vibes are very similar, but the outcomes are extremely different with the only turning point being regulus not dying in the cave, and jily in Only the Brave not getting as serious (ha) as it does in Choices (harry comes from a one night stand as a result of the war stress rather than from a functioning marriage). Both are very good though!

[@Coffeekoe]

everything i hear about choices just cements that i am too scared to read it... THAT SOUNDS SO ROUGH LMAO!!

[@camallow4388]

I did cry multiple times! But! it is also very good and lowkey morally interesting and thought provoking. I think people who dislike it because of James’ moral characterization just aren’t willing to consider that he might be an imperfect character. Plus it reinforces what we see of him in canon with snape’s worst memory and i think choices does a really good job with thematics and moral quandaries and such! so even though it is painful i would still recommend lol

[@SophiaWalsh-q6t]

I am only new to the fandom but the shop that made me interested was wolf star and jegulus

[@00freeze]

even tho i know all of this, i loveee these types of videos. literally u could do a deep dive on anything marauders related and id watch it!!!!

[@Coffeekoe]

aw thank you

[@maridgcs]

I love your deep dives omg it made me so happy

[@Coffeekoe]

[@marthashaw-t9c]

i loveee ur deep dives so much please make more!!

[@Coffeekoe]

i will :))

[@MaudeIvory]

watching this as i’m wearing my dark green converse

[@MitsuriIsPrettyyy]

First time I'm early- 4 min ago lol , I'm sure it's going to be an amazing video as always

[@Coffeekoe]

aw that is so sweet :(( thank you

[@MitsuriIsPrettyyy]

​@@Coffeekoe omgg I'm so happy you responded ! You're welcome I'm only saying the truth

[@mokshiweasley2781]

Choices HURTS. like HURTS. but nothing can possibly hurt as much as Crimson rivers 😭😭 I personally didn't like james' mindset/morals in choices i personaly like when he is more moral highground, sunshiney (but ANGSTY) of a character but the Jegulus moments were nice:) (Can you tell i am a James Potter stan and kinny but also love reading his angst and him breaking down?:D)

[@chloed.7047]

Excellent vid as always ❤️ btw, since you referenced Solangelo - have you read the fic August by CordeliaRose? 👀👀 It is literally my favourite thing ever and it is my sworn duty to recommend it to everyone. It should be the ATYD of the PJO fandom

[@Coffeekoe]

No I haven't, i've actually never read PJO fanfic oops but maybe i'll check that out! :)

[@livelyame]

2:37 I took a second to glance at my closet.1 when you said sun and star. 2. When you said Rick Riordan (I have 'sun and the star') I keep my books in there. (It's actually on top my harry potter books) On the videos topic, I love Jegulus. In concept. I unfortunately have a really hard time find good fanfictions (on Ao3) unfortunately I'm picky with fics and characterization in said fics. However the idea of them in my head. I absolutely adore. (If you have any recommendations I'm willing to check them out, I'm so desperate for content)

[@Emberz_hollow]

I love the cosplays per video!

[@Coffeekoe]

thank you :))

[@0_uroboros]

Thanks to your videos and some fan films, I discovered the character of James from a completely new side... To be honest, I disliked (hated) him for a long time earlier because of his bullying towards Severus, because I myself was subjected to such an attitude at school from specific "golden" people, and James was strongly associated with them. But does understanding and discovering these new sides of him feel like growing up? It's like I grew out of blind hatred and realized it right now, at the age of 21. I also remember that I am not really as good as I want to appear or think of myself through this introspection...

[@shawtychar1106]

I've never read crimson rivers because IM SCARED BRO I'm so scared I'm going to bawl my eyes out and IM NOT READY for the heart break😔😔

[@Book.Luv3r.7]

Ahh love the stickers on the mic

[@Coffeekoe]

thanks!

[@chloed.7047]

‼️heads up for anyone who's intrigued by Choices‼️ it has STRONG, CONFRONTING themes of SA and CSA. Its fucking ROUGH, especially knowing that it's canon compliant. I thought it was a devestatingly good depiction, but i had to bail halfway through bc it got too intense for me personally. Be safe and never feel bad for abandoning a fic to protect your brain ❤️

[@rafa3l_22]

I’m not a big jegulus fan, I love jily so much but I’ve never minded jegulus. I’ve thought it was silly but I don’t really care for it, it’s not my thing I guess. I quite like the idea of them dating but breaking up and then James getting with Lily. But I also don’t mind then just ending up together but jily will always be my favorite just cause I’ve loved it for so long 💔💔

[@miriheart1366]

i very recently got into the fandom and started loving jegulus and wolfstar, sadly all the videos from mischief productions got taken down. Does anyone have them downloaded somewhere, i would love to see them pleaseeeeeee. its a need

[@tati-4638]

Talking about Choices Choices is very sad and yes, many people make bad desicions but that's why it's called Choices, that's the summary of the fic. They talk about making choices or accidents. One thing that a lot of people say about the fanfic is that it's unfair for Lily. And yes it is but like I said, the hole fic is sad and unfair. No one is happy. And something I have to point out is that I think James in this fanfic is poly but dosen't know what that is and no one understands it. Yes he handels it the wrong way, he makes bad CHOICES but again, that's the point. He literally says "but I love you both". Regulus, obviously not a good person but what did Lily and James say in the fanfic? Right. "I don't think Regulus was a good person" -Lily "Yes.. he wasen't. But he really fucking wanted to be." -James It's a canon compliand fic, it's sad and it destroys you in a beautiful way. It is really hard to read and many people needed to take longer breaks from reading it. The trigger warnings are to be taken seriously and the fic will always hurt me. But at the same time it will always be importand to me and to a lot of others, the representation in the fic was hard and painful but good written. And people felt seen in the fic. I will be honest here, I don't understand why so many hate the fanfiction. If anyone can tell me why, please do. And for anyone who read the fic: Boo ..

[@Achuuu-mmmm]

I love Jegulus, it became the blood that runs through my veins. But I do wanted to comment that in the Jegulus fandom there is also (obviously not everyone, just some weird people) hate directed at Lily. In some works her character is just to produce harry and then that's it, or they just use her as a stereotypical girl who steals James from Reggie. And in theory I guess there is nothing wrong with that but it's how her character is handled that saddens me. The fandom of the marauders is supposed to be a safe space, and seeing so much hate that it's actually ridiculous directed at some characters because they don't like the ship is just baffling... Yes I'm a Jegulus die hard fan but I will always defend my girl Lily. (That's why I also love Jegulily haha) Loved the videoooo, tysm for your hard work!

[@lsabellaclarkson8709]

Exactly!! Lily can be dumbed down in this ship into the stereotypical character to hate because she gets in the way of the two you're routing for. I hate when writers do that- it's not a problem with the ship, but the writers that do this!!

[@kale4365]

Thank you 🫡🫡🫡

[@Coffeekoe]

No problem 🫡

[@julia.x.o]

i used to not ship jegulus but then i saw a life changing tiktok about them and now i’m the biggest jegulus shipper eva 👍👍

[@soleilthealien]

5:09 “black family lore” LMAO😂

[@Kailinbudrow-xx8dm]

Im currently reading the choices Fan fic

[@deptusmechanikus7362]

ahckshually Harry Potter also doesn’t have to happen for the prophecy, because you know, there’s always Neville

[@renjunscar]

THE GREAT BIG TRAGEDY OH YOU MISCHIEVOUS PERSON

[@lylica_]

I love Jegulus fanfics, they are so good! I'm not much into the ship, but my ao3 historic says otherwise kkkkkkk

[@birdiescc_1]

Can we get a Jily version, I think they are one of the most important couples in Harry Potter Series😭😭

[@danaikageorges2496]

No

[@danaikageorges2496]

😅😅

[@Coffeekoe]

yes actually. I love Jily and was planning on making a video about them. Did you miss the part of the video where I said you had to be respectful of both sides? lol.

[@Coffeekoe]

I was already planning on doing a jily video but please remember that Jegulus is just as important to me :)

[@birdiescc_1]

@@Coffeekoe Sorry, I didn't really watched the video fully. And you are right I should be respectful of both sides.

[@ChasingRabbit]

"pero no existiría Harry Potter" ... well mira existe la adopción, Regulus usualmente lo pintan como una persona trans y es un mundo mágico las opciones son infinitas desde que sea el resultado de una noche de despecho/consuelo entre James y Lily porque no ha sabido nada de Regulus en un año, pasando porque Lily se ofrece a ser su madre asistida, porque lo adoptaron, porque Regulus es trans y no se ha tomado la poción para transicionar por completo o una pocion para embarazar un hombre (why not? es magia!) un ritual extraño y arcano que te da niño yo que sé! PD: great video

[@whichstyle]

Ohhh nice!! Now do poolverine!! It’s the will of the people

[@itssimplylolaASMR]

Reading only the brave and I'm literally getting whiplash because I didn't read the tags properly. 😭😭I thought it was cannon parallel then reg did something that contradicts paralell and I read the tags and I realised it was one where they survive, so I (before this video), though Jegulus was endgame but then you just said Just Lovers was the only happy ending one, and so now I'm lost and you know that's ok (sorry if you had a heart attack reading this)

[@Coffeekoe]

OKAY WAIT, I MIGHT HAVE BEEN WRONG. I just meant that just lovers is the only happy fic. Only the brave does actually have a happy ending if im remembering correctly lol

[@itssimplylolaASMR]

@@Coffeekoe YEAHHH I get what you mean that it's not an actual happy fic I'm about halfway thru and suffering 😭🙏

[@clairiannec.7981]

Honestly, people who says "it would never happen in canon"- tell me what fun even happens in canon? What is so fun about canon? All the dying? Boring ships? Also, at this point, this Fandom wouldn't exist without us, fans, creating things... I feel like people forget about it too often. Let the sad boys have a little bit of happiness dammit.

[@patriciaprocelewska5188]

I understand the Jily shippers with them being like "canonically Jily has to happen because of Harry"... and that is exactly why I prefer reading au fics where Voldemort isn't a thing, or even magic isn't a thing. :) As long as a fic has at least one ship I really enjoy I don't care whether it's a Hogwarts fic, no Voldemort AU or even modern setting AU. I will read that fic, probably even cry over that fic, but I need gay wizards from the 70s in. my. veins. Also if some of you want more Jegulus recomendations: The Black Sparrow by TheIdeaOfSarcasm (it's set in the Lightning Era, Wolfstar, later Jegulus and it has Voldemort in it) blinding lights by introvertedhufflepuff (it's a modern AU setting in which the Marauders and Valkyries are a band, Regulus is an actor) in general all the fics written by introvertedhufflepuff are good, but mostly are in modern au settings :)

[@addybugstories4695]

Have you ever seen Spookeart’s fanart? Or read anything by damagecontrol? If you’ve never heard of them, check them out! In love with both of their work!

[@gr4ss_t0ad]

GUYSGUYSGUYSGUYS!!!! Do y’all have any Jegulily fic recommendations????

[@scatorccios]

i bought sirius' wand a few days ago too!!

[@mythicalserein]

(on the just lovers bit) “i think james beats up mulciber cuz he talks shit abut reg or something…” people who’ve read the fix: O_O

[@Coffeekoe]

i have since learned from comments its cause of the lake lmao

[@gabriellahildingsson4176]

PEOPLE WHO READ CRIMSON RIVERS

[@alyssaroc]

I need you to read art heist baby😭😭

[@egiptozmogus2570]

You should read about ship “party” (barty, Evan and Peter)

[@Coffeekoe]

....no thanks *lol* but thanks for the suggestion

[@egiptozmogus2570]

@@Coffeekoe yeah ofc not everyone likes this ship

[@justanothermaraudersfan]

personally, i prefer jily, but sometimes some angsty jegulus is rlly fun to read!

[@Ethxxy]

Hi what’s funny I still watched all of this even though I know all of this

[@Flareontoast]

I was so ready for the ""arguments"" and then they're just "it's not canon" broooo. Bro. It's Harry P*tter. JKR decided it's Canon that wizards pooped their pants for centuries. Like that's the weakest argument Might have to watch that short film now.

[@alluhira7433]

Jegulily is the solution!!🥰

[@lexyoru3355]

I would like to like the 100 times more especially the end part I like both jilly and jegulus I don’t get why sooooo many people hate

[@fivesilvercoins]

So, DISCLAIMER: I never finished Choices. I don't know how it ends or anything. I did read fairly far, though, so since you mentioned not being sure why some people dislike it, here's some opinions of mine. No disrespect meant to the author or the fans of the fic, btw, I don't hate it or anything, I just don't have a lot of time for reading, so I'm really picky about what I spend that time on. The biggest thing for me was that it felt... subtly victim-blame-y? I hope not on purpose, but like... Regulus is a child going through a lot of abuse in this fic, and I got the feeling he was being sorta side-eyed for not getting out of his family situation on his own? For example, there's this scene early on where the fic makes a show of giving Regulus the chance to confide in Effie and ask for help, but he lets the moment slip by, and I guess that's one of his 'choices'? And the narrative never seems particularly curious about why that might be. Because of the title, I went into the fic expecting that we'd be talking about *why* certain choices were made, but somehow it didn't really come up? The reason why James and Reggie fell for each other was also too underexplored for my tastes. Maybe especially for James, because it's his pov, and I never felt like I knew why he liked Reggie, just that he did. Don't get me wrong, there's some cute moments, but when you actually look at what happens in the story, they go from virtual strangers to just... randomly start to hang out in secret, I guess. The fact that I already ship these two had to do a lot of heavy lifting, lol. Same with the angst in this fic, tbh. The fact that their relationship will end tragically looms large throughout the story, but that's mostly because I already love these two and want them to be happy, you know? Overall, most of the characters felt rather flat and same-y, and not only because their inner lives weren't really explored a whole lot. But, the prose is fairly good, and as far as I remember the chapters were posted quickly and regularly, right around when Jegulus was getting its first boom in popularity, so it makes sense to me that a lot of people got into it. Anyway, yeah. Sorry to be sort of negative, but watching this made me remember Choices is a fic, and I had some thoughts, lol.