My Thoughts on Citizen Kane (1941)

[@philipgior3312]

No, the world DOES need your take on this vastly important, influential film. If not the world, then at least we, your loyal fans! And you certainly did a fine job of it, pat yourself on the back. I now look forward to next week's 10th anniversary special!

[@Weiselberry]

Haha, thanks! :)

[@JeffersonMills]

Well said!

[@leanneluis3714]

Thanks you so much I just watched it last year and I am a big old movie fan 30s and 40s and I get very much as you did it kept me stuck to my seat even when I was a bit revolted by his last relationship with that singer awful but very good edgy and different thanks again

[@ron_91260]

The journalists are talking about Rosebud: "it's probably something very small," one says. Yes it is small, or is it? Your comments on the memory of youth (the halcyon times) are spot-on and Rosebud's significance is rarely addressed by critics. I wonder "why does he think of that?" and "what will be my last thought?" Rosebud is there when little Charlie becomes Charles Foster Kane. One might say sledding might be a memory of his last authentic moment. After that, it's all commerce. Thanks for the great review!

[@alanlinfield8207]

My favorite line has always been "I think it would be fun to run a newspaper." Thank you for including that!

[@cptmuska]

I'm not going to lie. I got here because of Reddit but I must say I've never seen citizen Kane and found your synopsis absolutely amazing. I'll be back. Cheers from Canada.

[@ErrolConner-p8p]

I loved your ten year special. For the longest time, visually, I would catch something new every time I watched " Citizen Kane ".

[@ButOneThingIsNeedful]

Citizen Kane is a film I liked, then liked more and more and more. Now I think it is truly tremendous and special, NOT because of its reputation or what critics say, but because I find it a magnificent portrait that is ever relevant and true.

[@ClassicswithCourtney]

10 years?!?! Congratulations, girl!!! What a milestone! ❤❤ On the film discussion side, I must admit, I've only seen the film once and didn't think much of it. I have debated seeing it again, but I never got to it as of yet. I do remember liking Joseph Cotten, though, and I love Oraon Wells' voice. By far, my favorite actor to play Edward Rochester 🥰🥰

[@Cbcw76]

Yes... I've seen it a number of times over ?? 30-40 years ?? and gained some additional appreciation for the artistry... but the lack of Good Characters to cheer for probably lessens my desire to re-see it. I usually find it in nearby film-festivals (it seems to always be available, once a year) and Big Screen and big audiences help.

[@steve4films]

An excellent review of a film so many people take for granted. You made me want to watch it more. 👍 Brilliant!

[@grammardragon8425]

As a cinephile, I first watched Citizen Kane in my 20s out of a sense of obligation. By the time it was over I couldn't believe I'd waited so long to watch it. The strangest thing about it, as you touch on in your video, is how modern it seems. The scene transitions, the shot compositions, lighting, effects, the overall truly unique visual stylings for the time, make it seem like it was made 20 or 30 years later than it actually was. Citizen Kane was truly ahead of its time in so many ways that it can seem derivative. It dawns on you as you watch it that so many of the things you're seeing were first done, or done best up to that point, by Orson Welles in Citizen Kane. Personally, I think it deserves all the accolades it has received.

[@fredkrissman6527]

What an excellent discussion of OW's CitizenKane, leading to my new sub. As a graduating senior at UCStaBarbara in 1973, I still had a GenEd requirement to fulfill, and I took the film course on offer that semester, which was on the oeuvre of OrsonWelles! The young prof, soon to become a major film critic, was so enthusiastic that I actually paid attention, and was soon swept away by this larger than life character. Thanx for the memories!

[@StephenSkinner-y1c]

Excellent review. Most classic films are more appreciated as you get older, but Citizen Kane is in a class by itself in providing so much continued enlightenment over repeated viewings, while simultaneously remaining an enigma. Greatest film ever made? Perhaps it is.

[@ClutchCargo001]

Greatest film ever made? I'm going with Tom Hanks when he presented Ray Harryhausen his Lifetime Achievement Oscar. "Some people say Casablanca or Citizen Kane. I say Jason and the Argonauts is the greatest film ever made."

[@StephenSkinner-y1c]

@@ClutchCargo001 As a huge Ray Harryhausen fan I can't help being in some agreement. For me personally the film Forbidden Planet is in the top spot. The line from Commander Adams to Dr Morbius "We are all monsters in our subconscious, that's why we have laws and religion" is to me the most profound in cinema history.

[@ClutchCargo001]

@@StephenSkinner-y1c No argument here. 'Forbidden Planet' is the gold standard of 50s sci fi. So many great lines. 'Nothtin' to do but throw rocks at tin cans, and we gotta bring our own tin cans.' 'After a million years of shining sanity... they could hardly have understood what was destroying them.' But the one that still gives me chills each and every time I re-watch it is, "Morbius... MORBIUS! Something is approaching from the southwest. It is now quite close.' Long live Sci Fi!

[@TheGodfather1955]

I actually have two top 10 list. One is what I think are the greatest movies ever made, and the other my personal favorites of all time. I think most movie buffs have two list like that.

[@peregrinecovington4138]

Synecdoche NY fits this description much more than Citizen Kane imo

[@Ned_of_the_Hill]

Congratulations on 10 years! I, for one, welcome your perspective on "Citizen Kane". I've lost track of how many times I've seen this movie, but it's probably been once every year or so for decades. When I was younger and less familiar with stylistic films, I was most impressed by the odd characters, strange camera angles, and fractured story telling style. Now, I can also appreciate the movie's take on memory and experience. All the characters are weighed down by their memories, just as Kane's house is filled to the brim with old statues and miscellaneous bric-a-brac.

[@Welles009]

Citizen Kane is one of my favorite movies. I watch it every few years and find something new in it each time. This is a really great summary of a really great movie. I don't know any other KZbinrs that could discuss Citizen Kane while wearing a shirt advertising the evil company from Alien.

[@Adam_Le-Roi_Davis.]

I love your review of this, your perception does you justice. The way I've come to think of Citizen Kane is a banquet as opposed to a snack or a normal meal, there's lots of different things to enjoy and absorb within it at a leisurely pace, not rushed. It does show off Orson Wells genius well, and that the other around him too.

[@Chinaski83]

It's one of those classics that I've never seen, for whatever reason. One reason is probably due to having heard so much about it over the years, I feel like I don't need to. Obviously, I'm doing myself a disservice. I like your shirt, I have the same one. Congratulations on 10 years of videos. That's pretty incredible, and I really hope it still gives you joy.

[@Weiselberry]

Oh, nice! We could be twins. Thanks!

[@BlueWingedRino]

Most people don’t realize how big of a deal it was to run Toland after himself in the credits. I have seen the film 3 times but not in the last 20 years though. I may have to find my vhs copy.

[@G4rt3nschl4uch]

Thx for sharing your opinion. Someone shared your Account on reddit and mentioned, you deserve more suscribers and even so I haven't seen much of you, i absolutly agree on him. You're doing a great job, i find it kind of funny, that you still use the same camera, but why not. Keep going, please never stop, YT doesn't always redeem the person that deserves it :) PS: I watched citizen kane when i was studying film directing and i think it's a masterpiece.

[@juxapostion]

Love the T-Shirt:) And i love Citizen Kane. I get why people think its boring, but I just love it. Like Alien\Aliens. Classics all of them. And Congaratulations re the 10 year on YT. Will make sure not to miss next weeks show. Thanks for the thoughtfull commentaries

[@Lokster71]

I really enjoyed that review. I watched Citizen Kane the first time expecting to be underwhelmed by it and found myself totally enthralled. I agree though it isn't one of my favourite films. But then I always think that there's a difference between 'favourite' and 'best' when talking about any films/books/whatever.

[@ronmills5234]

What a fine and fun take. Subscribed! I've always loved Kane but didn't count it among my absolute favourites until I watched it with Ebert's shot-by-shot commentary and read the first volume of Simon Callow's biography of Welles.

[@niallboyle5211]

Congratulations Miss W. A beautifully balanced and insightful review of a landmark movie. It's one of my favorites. It's a dizzying display of talent under every heading you could list. Kane remains a fascinating character. Different things to different people at different times. Materially successful, surrounded by his acquisitions, he dies surrounded by functionaries, alone and unloved. The answer to the journalist's question is known only to God.

[@mrs.evansartyparty7349]

What a splendid review! You brought back so many wonderful memories of watching this movie with my cinephile dad. He passed many years ago, but he would have loved this review. I think at its core Citizen Kane is about the human condition. How joy, tragedy, lust, power, etc. affect us all and how our decisions in life affect the lives of others. Its such a brilliant, brilliant movie, and so multi-layered. The more life you have lived, the more you get from this movie. In the end I always cry.

[@Weiselberry]

Oh, thank you! I really like that theory, and thanks for sharing about your dad!

[@johndope602]

This is a good review, nice work!

[@LazarusLong314]

Citizen Kane is in my top 5 favorite movies. It's one of the movies I can put on when I don't know what else to watch. Thanks for the review; it's great.

[@thequintanashow5058]

Somehow u popped up on my algo bc I got into a deep Towering Inferno “rabbit hole”. You are AWESOME!!!! So truly genuine and smartly funny!!! I’m so glad I found your show and thank you for making me laugh and smile! 😊

[@Weiselberry]

Thank you! Glad you found me! :)

[@user-vg2eg7oo5n]

Happy 10th anniversary! Having grown up enjoying Siskel & Ebert, you are the best film reviewer since. Keep up the great work.

[@johnrenowden7534]

Great video - might be my new favourite channel

[@WayneSchowalter]

Your Citizen Kane review was the best review I have ever seen on the subject. Perhaps because you covered everything I love about this movie. It is my favorite film. Your insight into the reporter never being fully shown was brilliant. All of your comments were so well thought out and perfect. I would like to add something about when Susan leaves Kane. The door she opens has a stylized explosion design on it. She is exploding from his clutches and out of his life. An explosion from which he never recovers. And as for that final credit with the shared names of Welles and Toland, Bernard Herrmann’s jaunty, joyous tune (that lives in your head) comes to such a crescendo that it never fails to make me burst into tears. Thanks. And please keep the 4:3 ratio.

[@mikek3979]

Watched Citizen Kane at least a dozen times - to me, the highlight is the evolution of Welles’ radio troupe into film. And, I’m so glad you weighed in on the movie - you are the most enjoyable and delightful movie/book reviewer on KZbin. Keep up your great work!

[@RSEFX]

Boy, I'd love to give this review far far more than one thumbs up! A really beautiful review, one of the best overall takes on a movie I've read, and with a really joyful land perfectly-pitched rather than stuffy or pious or full-of -itself etc of an approach which has often been taken toward this film! Atop of that I feel a bit of a personal link to this (in many ways) magical piece of film-making via my connection to the shadowy reporter figure, actor/later producer William Alland : He's also the voice of the newsreel narrator at the beginning, and would later do the same kind of thing for his later films, like his CREATURE FROM THE BLACK LAGOON.. But you probably know that, and I digress ,a n easy thing to do when considering this film and all the ways in which it stimulates us /gets us to consider again its technical attributes as well as its powerful themes, whims and enigmas. Most simply, it IS a fun film, which I am so happy to see you celebrate, if not exactly in those words,. And you bring up things I didn't realize or hadn't thought about, which is the true measure of a review's impact , usefulness and appreciation for anyone interested in repeat viewings. Thanks so much!!

[@Weiselberry]

Thank you! I'm so glad you enjoyed this video! I was pleasantly surprised to learn that Alland later became a producer of 1950s creature features, including one of my favorites, Creature from the Black Lagoon! I think I enjoy Citizen Kane even more after spending many hours editing this and going through the film almost frame-by-frame. The only drawback is that I ended up with far more images than I could possibly use. It wasn't my intention to show more than a couple clips, but I kept saying, "Ooh, I want to include that too!", and "That's such a great moment that I can't leave it out!" I'm so happy you found the video conveyed the film's sense of fun, which too often gets overlooked. It's great to hear from you, and thanks for sharing a few of your own thoughts on this one!

[@rickcantrell5302]

@@Weiselberry Thanks for this great review! You said at the beginning that you liked the film but didn't love it, but towards the end of the review, I was thinking that you sure sound like you love it! I do love it, and am always sad when I talk to people that think it is boring or a waste of time. It's not my favorite film (Casablanca - no, wait - Best Years of Our Lives), but it is certainly amongst my favorites. Congrats on your 10 year anniversary! I don't often comment, but I do love your reviews! Thanks for sharing your thoughts!

[@spotlightonthestars]

Great review! It is definitely one of the most influential films ever made!

[@brianlawton8172]

Saw “Citizen Kane” when l was 9 years old I didn’t completely understand it but fell in love with it even at that age. It’s required watching for anyone who even considering him or herself a causal film buff, cinephile or film director. And by the way happy anniversary and many, many more!

[@walterworrall]

Wow! Congrats on 10 years. You rock. Thanks for the review of good old Citizen Kane.

[@Weiselberry]

Thanks!

[@RightNowMan]

Excellent review, I love this film, very good to hear your thoughts on it. The music is really wonderful along with everything else.

[@HOLLYWOODUNAPOLOGETIC]

HAPPY ANNIVERSARY! This is one of my favorite films of all time for many reasons. I dig the shirt too. 😃

[@donkelley7407]

Wow J, you hit a home run with this one. Funny that you mentioned Roger Ebert since his is the only other Kane review I remember seeing/reading. So I'm doubly glad you reviewed it. I really enjoyed hearing your take on this classic. I think I was unimpressed with the film on first viewing, but it has grown on me. So many references to it in popular culture. I hope you decide to review more films along these lines; the top tens, super classics, or what have you. Thanks, congrats again on your ten years, take good care.

[@RicardoHarvin]

Your video popped up in my recommended feed and, since I love watching young people's reactions to media that I love, I decided to watch, and I'm glad I did (despite the 480p resolution). Your review is very good, and I love that you include so many of the reasons why this film has earned so much praise over the decades, and why it still holds up in ways so many others of the era can't. My appreciation of the movie really solidified once I learned (after two or three viewings over the years) that Welles and Toland, et al., invented so many techniques and tricks used in this movie that are still used today. Much like 2001: A Space Odyssey set a standard that can't be surpassed, only built upon, Citizen Kane forever changed the language of film in a way the art form can only advance and expand, but not surpass because it was the first. I highly recommend everyone watch the Criterion Collection's 4K transfer, it looks absolutely stunning and is almost like seeing a whole new movie. And Kane's mother only seemed hard and cold because she had to literally steel herself to do what she believed was best for Charles, despite her deep and abiding love for him, and that love is what Kane missed most in his life and is the real meaning behind Rosebud, imo. Enjoyed your review, and congratulations on 10 years 👍🏿👏🏿

[@peterkarargiris4110]

Excellent review Ms W. I'm on an Orson Welles arc at the moment myself, having watched: The Third Man, The Stranger, Confidential Report and The Lady from Shanghai recently. I don't own Citizen Kane but it's definitely on the list. It was great to hear your thoughts on the movie as always.

[@pcjs]

There hasn’t been a single time I’ve thought about CITIZEN KANE that I haven’t also thought about a girl in white dress carrying a white parasol… and she isn’t even in the film! And I think you’re right, we probably have Roger Ebert to thank for appreciating that scene-one of so many deft little touches. Thanks for sharing your thoughts (and congrats on your upcoming 10th anniversary!)

[@marbanak]

What a smashing way to close out this 10-year achievement. You brought out a lotta sweet gems I had never noticed. You're still my preferred reviewer.

[@Weiselberry]

Thank you!

[@alandhopewell]

Congratulations on ten years of great reviews, Sis!

[@mpopham1]

Thanks for your take on this film, it's such a great movie and you're right, it feels really modern, even though it was released in 1941. Great review.

[@buzzawuzza3743]

Kane is the first of many interesting and excellent films he made. Over the decades I have sought out the movies he made and found that I enjoy the different styles he used to tell stories. Your review is well done and if it makes your younger viewers seek out The Stranger and Lady From Shanghai then it's all the better. My best to you, Miss Weiselberry, keep up the good work.

[@Weiselberry]

We can hope! The Stranger is where I first took notice of Edward G. Robinson. It's an excellent thriller. I was a little underwhelmed by Lady from Shanghai when I saw it years ago, but the visuals are striking and impressive, just as one would expect from a Welles film. Thanks!

[@buzzawuzza3743]

@@Weiselberry Sometimes it seems as if younger people who watch old films like Lady From Shanghai want it to gallop along at a quicker pace. But I've seen enough of your reviews to know that any complaint you may have with it lies elsewhere.

[@winterburden]

Thanks for this super neat movie review! I'll always look for your reviews before I listen to anyone else.

[@pierredupont1096]

I had my partner (32) watch this for the first time weeks ago and she was enthralled by Welles' personality in that scene with the dancers and celebration, but also couldn't get over the camera angles, the dialogue, the pacing. Citizen Kane is in an incredible achievement and should be watched, free of analysis or not, for decades to come.

[@guyjperson]

That was very well reasoned, researched and edited. Better than my old film school teacher. Subbed.

[@Weiselberry]

Wow, thank you!

[@davidgianatasio5747]

I’m going to get out in front and wish your channel a happy anniversary! Over the past 2 years it’s become a weekend ritual for me. Fun, smart, insightful, quirky. I rewatched the snowbound books episodes recently. Classics, like so many of your videos. Keep up the great work!

[@geocarlisle]

Your opinion and analysis of any movie, no matter how extensively scrutinized and analyzed before, is always valuable. Your cred as a film critic is as good as any, and better than most. This has been as fascinating a deep dive into one of the most important films ever made as I’ve ever known. As many times as I’ve seen it, I learned some new things from you. For example, I completely failed to appreciate, in all these years, Welles’s remarkable, uncharacteristic generosity toward his DP, Greg Toland, giving him director-standing credit. How interesting and revealing of OW's high regard for one of his most important collaborators. There are so many things to say about CK, but you’ve already said them so eloquently. But I will add one thing: If you’re working for that company whose logo is on your shirt, DO NOT, under any circumstances, let them send you to another planet in search of “interesting” forms of life!

[@hyperheadquarters]

Really enjoyed your review 'JW'. You cover all the salient points and open the film to a younger audience who might not even be aware of its existence. Funny how it is considered an 'old' film, as your review points out just how contemporary many of its elements still are. Would love to hear your take on 'F For Fake'. Love the irony of your clear headed and fair review whilst wearing the logo of one of the most evil corporations known to fandom. i wonder if Weyland-Yutani started woth good intentions (like Kane's 'Principles' or Google's 'Don't Be Evil') then ditched them as power and influence came calling. Great review, great channel.

[@Weiselberry]

Thanks! Haha, I really just wanted to wear that shirt that day and thought it would also be fun to wear something film-related while discussing one of the greatest films ever made. But I'm tickled by the comments that can see a connection, and yours is an interesting and intriguing suggestion!

[@rosezingleman5007]

Jerome, I would love to see you discuss all the major works of Gregg Toland. I always think of Kane and The Best Years of Their Lives as his best, and I liked your video about Best. But I’d like to see more about Toland. He provided the visual mood for so many great films and died young.

[@kirksworks]

I first saw Citizen Kane in film class in junior college, and since the class was only 1 hr, I had to see it in two parts, Tuesday and Thursday. So I had a day to think about the first half. I was blown away by the reveal of Rosebud, and I think what is says about Kane explains a lot about him, and his behavior throughout the story. It’s not my favorite Welles film, though. The one I watch the most is Touch of Evil, the recut version that went back to Welles’ notes. A masterpiece in so many ways. I also love two of his Shakespeare films, Othello (which I think is his most beautiful - such lighting and compositions!) and Chimes at Midnight, which might be his greatest film. I didn’t care for The Other Side of the Wind, shot by Welles mostly in the 1970s, but put together by others since Welles had died. It just showed that no one could duplicate Welles. So glad you appreciated Citizen Kane so much!

[@c.7610]

I agree with you about OSOTW. I’d been waiting for it to appear in some form ever since I read an article about it in American Film magazine sometime in the ‘70s, but what was released I found distinctly underwhelming (and badly dated). Meanwhile I would love Touch of Evil unreservedly if it weren’t for Charlton Heston’s ridiculous performance in the lead. Least convincing “Mexican” in movie history!

[@Weiselberry]

Touch of Evil is a great film, one of my favorites of its genre.

[@maxdewinter9472]

I always wondered why you had no review of 'Citizen Kane' on your channel, and thought that it might be due to....'what could I say that hasn't been said before'. Well I'm glad you have finally let us know your thoughts on the film! I am always interested in what you have to say about any film. You have added to my appreciation of Kane and have pointed out some things I have missed. And I've seen it many times. I first heard of 'Citizen Kane' from an episode of 'All in the Family', where Mike and Gloria are excited to learn that it is going to be on their local PBS station. I was so curious about this film because of that TV episode. I first saw it in a film class in college and then saw it on the big screen in a theatre a few years later. Now I have it on DVD and see it every few years. I think I'm due to see it again soon. I really love the visuals. You can stop the film at any point and will have a perfectly composed shot. The sceening room scene after the newsreel is very memorable, with the smoke and light streaming into the room, and the movement of the figures in the room! And the film is full of stuff like that. I' m so glad you've shared your views on Kane! And congratulations on 10 years. That is really something to be proud of!

[@ba-gg6jo]

Thoroughly enjoyed your take on this grand breaking film. Thank you.

[@mrmatt6740]

"Here's a man that could have been president, who was as loved and hated and as talked about as any man in our time . . ." Charles Foster Kane the character in the film is somewhat like how many reflect on the epic film CITIZEN KANE. I like your take and am happy to see younger generations watch and reflect on Kane and other old movies. Although I like to think, like Orson Welles' friend Peter Bogdanovich, "There are no old movies really - only movies you have already seen and ones you haven't." Keep up the great work.

[@Rossatron]

More people need to realise how energetic (even fast paced), complex, thrillingly entertaining, all up to a surprising twist, Citizen Kane is. Masterpiece.

[@lbbotpn5429]

Citizen Kane is not one of my favorite films and has never really worked for me as a piece of entertainment, but I do acknowledge it's importance as a watershed in the history of film. As you say, there was so much innovation. I think with the passage of time, we're beginning to see the importance of the film being diminished. I think without the context of what came before and what the film's innovations subsequently inspired, most modern viewers don't have the context needed to fully appreciate it. It's really unfortunate, but probably inevitable. Congratulations on hitting your 10-year milestone! I'll sing a chorus of Charlie Kane in your honor... with all apologies to Bernard Herrmann, of course.

[@MLawrence-z9k]

Hello beautiful ❤️ its been awhile since ive been here but im so happy u are still making amazing reviews 💯

[@SlapShotRegatta22]

I really enjoy your passion. It's so rare these days to run across anyone with true passion for anything let alone classic movies and literature. Great video. Citizen Kane is one of my favorites. Not just because the innovations you mention but because of the overall moral of the story; Kane's life representing the post-modern consumeristic world. We have everything we want, all at the tip of our fingers, literally. Yet, we're all completely empty inside and we're all longing for simpler, happier times.

[@technicholls]

I agree that this wonderful piece of film-work has been commented on over and over again throughout the decades. But then again it is a movie worthy of infinite reflection. Your review, however, was one of the best I’ve ever heard! Thank you so much for your eloquent synopsis of one of Well’s greatest pieces of work. I agree with each of your observations. Thank you so much for this very enjoyable post.

[@Weiselberry]

I'm so glad you liked it!

[@SurferJoe1]

Great job, really good analysis. I always learn something from you. If you haven't seen it, seek out the documentary "The Eyes of Orson Welles" for some great insight into the extent of Welles' visual genius. As a former storyboard artist, I am not generally a fan of one arresting beauty shot after another; it tends to upstage and to take you out of the story- but "Kane" absolutely makes it work. Don't try it at home, kids!

[@TheJohnDoeLibraryRoom.]

Thompson the near faceless investigator was always my favorite character, he drifts through it in an almost ghost like manner until he winds up at Xanadu to declare the mystery unsolvable. I may be alone on this though, I never see anyone singling him out.

[@Allan_aka_RocKITEman]

{Early} *CONGRATS* on 10 years, JW!

[@postscript67]

Two trivial memories of my seeing 'Citizen Kane' as a teenager 40 years ago: first, my surprised realisation that George Colouris was the same actor who played the malingering patient in the 1950s Dirk Bogarde comedy 'Doctor in the House'; second, the speech about the girl on the ferry. I can't remember now if it was shortly before or after I saw the film that I opened The New Oxford Book of English Verse and read: 'There is a Lady sweet and kind, Was never face so pleased my mind; I did but see her passing by, And yet I love her till I die.' No doubt Welles or Mankiewicz was familiar with this old anonymous poem.

[@paulglover6525]

So neat! I have been binge watching and listening to Orson Wells interviews this weekend. Oh by the way. The person in the news room who looks like Joseph Cotton is really Alan Ladd but you do hear Cotton's actual voice. WiKi gets it wrong saying he is at the end of the film.

[@gpalmerify]

My favorite part of this video is hearing Jerome Weiselberry in her tiny voice say "I'm Charles Foster Cain!" Maybe I'll make that my ring tone.

[@Madstsone]

Had to stop the video when you did your Charles Foster Kane bit because I was laughing so much!

[@pamelahall517]

It was wonderful to hear you tackle Citizen Kane! I’ve watched this movie many times enjoying the craftmanship that exudes from the film. Reviewing all the many aspects that make it a great movie is like looking at the beautiful facets of a diamond held up to a light. One of my favorite ways to watch it is with Roger Ebert’s commentary on. He goes into minute details, which I love. It is one of the best commentaries as he sticks to the movie and does not meander in other directions as other commentators tend to do. I’m sad DVDs are going the way of the dinosaur. I loved listening to the commentaries. Anyway, I’m meandering! I’m happy you mentioned Roger E. That said this review is as stellar as your other ones and a great way to celebrate 10 years of reviews! It was enjoyable to hear what the movie meant to you. To me Citizen Kane is a movie about a powerful man who would have been better off staying with his mommy as a youth! I’ve read books and watched movies all because of your reviews and recommendations. I’ve enjoyed your reviews of movies and books I’ve already read. I am so glad Jane Eyre led me to you! Here’s to another 10 years of the great Jerome Weiselberry!

[@Weiselberry]

Thank you! And thanks to Jane Eyre for bringing you here! :)

[@Jeff_Lichtman]

Someday you might want to visit Hearst Castle in San Simeon, California to see the mansion that Xanadu was based on. Congratulations on reaching ten years!

[@ButOneThingIsNeedful]

My wife and I took that castle tour not long ago and just loved it. At one point I asked our guide about the William Randolph Hearst-Citizen Kane connection. He LITERALLY ignored my question and didn't answer me a word, quickly moving the group on to the next stage of the tour. It was very strange and made me think that is what they are instructed to do (80 years after the film).

[@bartolomeuomacduibheamhnad6855]

“ Memory tends to add a filter that softens the edges” - Jerome Weiselberry What a lovely turn of phrase. You’ve provided so many fantastic reviews over the years and this one is right up there with them and It’s really exciting to see so many people engage with this video and respond so positively to it, the world wants to hear your thoughts on Citizen Kane. I have a full size replica of Rosebud so I guess my opinion of the film must be pretty high, truth be told my thoughts are similar to yours, I respect the film to no end and do have love for it but it may not be in my top ten favourites but if forced to pick a film I thought was the greatest ever made I do think I’d say Citizen Kane, it’s the flimsiest film ever filmed lol. When everything is considered, every detail, the technical and creative ingenuity brought by every department and the year it was filmed it’s hard to argue against it, some would say The Godfather and their opinions are valid because art is subjective but for me Citizen Kane brings more in terms of a creative vision from Director, Photography, Music and Art Design, The Godfather is driven by performances and narrative, music too, the performances feel inspired but every single element in Citizen Kane feels inspired, the amazing moments you picked as some of your favourites are packed to the brim with genius. I do love that scene in the screening room with that incredible use of light, it reminds me of photos taken by Hal Morey of Grand Central Terminal in 1930, I wonder could Welles and Toland have been influenced by them. Cheeky charming Welles was the best Welles, if I was told to quickly think of a smiling actor on the spot I’d think of Welles in The Third Man, he had the faceiest face that ever faced or the smirkiest smirk that ever smirked lol he was these emoji’s-😏😉 I loved your take on the Mr Thompson character and the potential reasons behind him being filmed in shadow and darkness, so clever and insightful. I’m glad that Joseph Cotten and Welles became friends because we have benefited so much from it, it is funny how noticeably young Cottons eyes are in that scene and it’s a wonder they didn’t try shooting from a different angle so the light wasn’t reflecting of his eyes or it wasn’t suggested that he attempt to squint a little. The first time I watched Citizen Kane I thought yes it is great but afterwards I began to question myself, do I like this film because I really like it or have I been influenced by its reputation? Do I like it because I’m supposed to like it or do I like it because I as an individual with my own tastes and opinions like it? I waited a little while to see it again and my opinion hadn’t changed and watched it again a few months after that and was satisfied that I did indeed like it because of its merits and my own taste, i don’t though see it as an endlessly rewatchable film and would have other films as favourites, maybe not better films but personal favourites. I’m going to get a snow globe and have it by my bed so when I perish( hopefully as an old man 🫰🏻) I can take it in my hand and drop it whispering “ Weiselbud” someone will say what did he say? I’ll correct myself and whisper again “ Weiselberry” and someone will say what does this mean? Is he referring to that really popular KZbinr? I’ll pop up and say yup! best reviewer in the buis, watch, like and subscribe! I’ll then apologise for dropping the globe and leaving a mess then keel over and lights out lol. I’m doing a Welles smirk lol. Looking forward to your anniversary video :) ~ Thank you Ms Weiselberry ~

[@lakewalker11]

Excellent and very thoughtful review. Kane has always been one of my favorite movies of all time. I do think, however, that it falls off a bit in the second half, when Kane retreats to Xanadu. It becomes a bit soap opera-y there. But even at that, it’s still one of the greatest of all time.

[@robertjewell9727]

First time I attempted to watch it was at a party and I'd heard so much about it, but it was IMPISSIBLE to really pay attention to it. The next was in film class and its reputation shadowed and conflicted with the experience, BUT the third time was the OMG moment. Everything came together, particularly with that extended mirror image at the finale and how I could hear the important phrasing of Herrmann's Kane leitmotif and all the ways its been pointing to the answer of Kane's mystery. It's innovative and original and unusual and all that, but it also has a beautifully edited organic spirit and energy instilled in its technical wow.

[@davidhayter7954]

great videos, Love your shirt in this one!

[@walterpanovs]

Wonderful!! Thank you.

[@tomjohnson4922]

thank you so much for not making me sad. This, with Casablanca, are my two favorite movies. I love Welles, from his War of the Worlds and The Hitchhiker to this and Touch of Evil. That and Cotten, my favorite actor... wooo. I knew Ruth Warrick more All My Children than this movie and of course Ray Collins later at Tragg on Perry Mason.. All around a great movie in my opinion.

[@jameswallace756]

Great review and T-shirt!

[@DouglasJohnson.]

Congratulations on 10 years!

[@davidmackres8929]

Well done, Weiselberry!

[@drewlotzmoore]

Great review, as usual. My view of Citizen Kane is that it is a technical and innovative masterpiece, but one I rarely have any interest in watching. I'm glad that others enjoy it, but I don't connect with it myself. Perhaps it's time for another viewing.

[@russellfarina9099]

The best film review I've heard you do hands down.. in your words I can hear why this movie is great, and it's groovy cause I so respect your opinion. What do you think is the greatest film of all time 😮

[@ChristopherElli-cc1ly]

Always review any film you like or that you feel is important. Most of my favorite films are from the 30s and 40s. The cinematography and sets are wonderful. Ever notice you see a lot of ceilings in it. A lot of low angle shot. All the fascinating characters minor are so interesting. Is it the greatest American film, maybe. But i will always think that Gone With The Wind is the greatest achievement in Hollywood history. You should review it. Thanks Jerome.

[@erobinson8526]

I allways feel like Welles' performance as Kane is underrated. All the praise and focus goes to his direction, and rightfully so, but he plays Kane magnificently

[@AJBell-dh6ry]

10 years?! JW is aging like fine wine. We have the video documentation. Here's to 10 more!

[@laioren]

Now, I cannot wait to shout, "Don't worry about me. I'm Charles Foster Kane!" at someone. Thanks for the idea. I'll give you credit when they ask me what the heck I'm doing.

[@studiomangordon2933]

Congratulations on 10 years .. I loved the cinematography and editing in CK , never had it as a top 5 film but definitely worth a rewatch ! S/b will you ever upgrade your vlog/essay camera 🤔 😃

[@gregorycarnes3521]

This is a compelling film above and beyond nearly anything else. It is so rich in all the ways you mention. A film to get lost in where multiple viewings makes it no less surprising or startling. Greatest film? Maybe, but i know if i come across it channel surfing i am compelled to watch it through to the end. I'd love to hear your thoughts on Touch of Evil. Enjoy your channel. Have fun.

[@Weiselberry]

I haven't officially reviewed Touch of Evil anywhere, but I did name it as one of my favorite noirs in this video a few years ago: kzbin.info/www/bejne/nHfacmyGpMZnp6s

[@fmellish71]

One thing I love about Citizen Kane is that it seems to compound all of the artistic and technical advances that had happened outside of Hollywood up to that point and crammed it all in a Hollywood picture, which was monumental considering how little of the European cinematic inventiveness was used in Hollywood up to 1941 and was still relatively unused for quite some time afterward apart from the German imports that made film noirs.

[@RCastellanos]

I've been waiting for this review ever since your video on The Third Man. Brilliant review as always, Jerome!

[@ygstuff4898]

Your review of CK is well-received. Thank you. 😀

[@Keyser666]

The girl with the parasol story has stuck with me since seeing this as a kid, the idea of him never knowing her, or that you could leave such a life long impression on a stranger and never know it yourself. I wonder who she was.

[@PerryPapanier]

I was lucky to see it in a movie theater in NYC, I think for its 45th or 50th anniversary. They even have a couple of old cartoons before it started. It's on my list as one of the best of all times.

[@johnnyrocketed2225]

Great video.☺️ I think I remember hearing that the ceilings were actually bedsheets pulled tight- so they could hide the microphones up there. 🧐

[@Weiselberry]

That does sound familiar... Thanks!

[@PaulChiesa-db5zn]

It was a lovely review, too Thank you.

[@smelisi]

14:29 -- yes that's Cotten, but not as his character. The story goes that Welles was doing "tests" to sort of outflank the studio heads. The idea was that he would have stuff in the can already and they therefore couldn't stop what he was doing with the film as a whole. That projection room scene is one of those tests. They just grabbed whoever was to hand to fill up the room. If you look closely, the dude in the right corner is the actor who plays the waiter in the Susan Alexander scene (Gus Schilling). I think the dude in the hat next to Cotten is Erskine Sanford (Mr. Carter), although I can't be sure. I often wonder if Cotten et al would have been a bit more obscured in the original print of the film than what we have with digital restorations and such. Welles says (in one of his interviews with Peter Bogdanovich) that he too is in that room, although I have never been able to make him out.

[@Weiselberry]

Thanks for elaborating on that! A couple commenters said it was Alan Ladd, not Cotten, but I'm skeptical. I agree that the man in the hat looks like Erskine Sanford, which just makes it seem more likely that he's sitting next to Cotten. I wonder if Welles could be one of the men who lights up immediately after the newsreel is finished?

[@smelisi]

@@Weiselberry Anything for you, JW! And it's totally Cotten. Alan Ladd is in the final Xanadu scene, wandering about among all the reporters, with the pipe in his mouth. He says something like "Or Xanadu? What about it, Joe?"

[@richardenglish2195]

Wonderful film, and a superb analysis. I disagree about Bernstein's monologue not being necessary, though. It reinforces the central theme of memory, specifically _how_ we remember things. Sometimes we assign particular incidents more significance than they actually had, or - inevitably - view them out of context. In that respect, this moment is deeply important because it reinforces the selective power of memory and how it's ultimately subjective. I agree, however, that it's a beautiful scene! Also, congratulations on ten years of your channel! I only cottoned on to it (no pun intended) about five years ago, but I've been thoroughly enjoying your content ever since. I always recommend it to friends who share a passion for older cinema. I'm wondering what the anniversary episode will have in store for us... Will Joseph Cotton, Jane Eyre and Godzilla be included somehow? ;)

[@Weiselberry]

Thanks for sharing your perspective on Bernstein's monologue. As I was editing, I also found myself disagreeing slightly with what I said about it not being strictly relevant or answering the big question. It does provide a helpful piece of the puzzle. Thank you! Haha, yes, I couldn't look back on the last decade without mentioning at least Jane Eyre and Godzilla! :)

[@MikeADee]

Let me just start by saying Bravo! Bravo to you Ms Weiselberry for overcoming your reluctance to review Citizen Kane, to be fair I didn't realize that you hadn't reviewed this already. Next time you feel jittery about reviewing a controversial classic just tell yourself, it's only a movie, it's only a movie! Yep I'm shamelessly ripping off the advertisement to Last House on the Left (1972) another movie I don't believe you have reviewed, and I doubt that you will, though you have surprised me before. A large portion of my family loves old movies, and they revere Citizen Kane. While I don't believe it is the best movie ever, I have always held it in high regard. I remember seeing tv commercials with Orsen Wells when I was younger and so these two facts have biased me in favor of the movie. I even remember watching RKO 281 which I liked. Well, I've danced around the question long enough, I have seen Citizen Kane, thought it was very stylish but otherwise I don't recall whether I liked the movie or not. I need to rewatch it for a definitive answer. This is definitely possible as I own the movie. I bought the 75th anniversary Blu Ray and it's in a pile of other Blu Ray and 4k movies, still in the cellophane. It sits there Mocking me. Mr Wells would say in his old commercials that he would "drink no wine before it's time" and I shall watch no movie before its time. And I look forward to your next video and congrats on 10 years on youtube, let's hope for 10 more,

[@Weiselberry]

Sounds like you're referring to that infamous Paul Masson commercial. "Mah, the French!" I know Welles was actually extremely overtired, not inebriated, when filming those ads, but the outtakes--and the parody bloopers someone made--are just too funny. Thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed this. :)

[@davidcauley9400]

Top tier review, loved it.

[@paulcash8160]

I do think it is one of the greatest films ever made. Even Pauline Kael, who wrote a book criticizing Welles for credit-hogging, had to admit KANE was, in a perfect phrase, "deliriously entertaining." I too like Bernstein's story, because I have a similar one: More than half a century ago, when delivering Sunday newspapers early in the morning, I saw a pretty blonde girl in a blue dress, about 12 years old; in one hand she carried a suitcase, and the other arm was in a sling. I have been musing about scenarios ever since!

[@XIIIVMX]

Reviewing KANE in Weyland-Yutani t-shirt is GOLDEN 👍👍👍

[@williamblakehall5566]

The "world" may not "need" your take on Citizen Kane -- but I do, especially when you're wearing a Weyland-Yutani shirt (I assume you find Romulus to be good), so thank you. I once discovered that a Charles Foster Kent was founding president of the American Academy or Religion, and I've always wondered if the name was meant to suggest a kind of evangelical streak. Perhaps it is a tribute to the movie that I've seen it a few times and yet that dagnabbed cockatoo screech always startles the heck out of me every time! I worry that the movie may have inspired a "potboiler novel" formula, perhaps most associated with Harold Robbins, in which we get a sweeping biography of a thinly fictionalized mogul of legendary status. One of Robbins's last books was titled Descent from Xanadu and featured a zillionaire named Crane. Incidentally, not to get (especially) political, but I've been playing 1964's The Best Man, with Henry Fonda and Cliff Robertson, over and over on KZbin and not only do I find it weirdly prophetic, but it gets me all misty-eyed. I wonder if you've seen it and have an opinion. Thank you, Rome -- and happy ten years!

[@MisterMasterShafter1]

A beautiful review of a great film.

[@MsBackstager]

I visited Hearst Castle eons ago -- the movie living room scene is spot on.