Mancera Red Tobacco Vs PDM Carlisle (Face Off)

This is a requested video from two brothers. I have recently bought Carlisle and I owned Red Tobacco for couple of years now. they are similar in many ways, thus the comparison. lets see who wins this battle. also please chec out my full reviews on each.
Fragrantica links
Red Tobacco
www.fragrantic...
Carlisle
www.fragrantic...
My other PDM Reviews
www.youtube.co...
My other Mancera Reviews
www.youtube.co...
Please join my Facebook Fragrance group
/ 1721430791491588
My Decant page (For Bangladeshi Members only)
/ 630887023787651

[@johnborges5938]

To my nose there is too little difference between these two after the first half hour to be worth having both; Carlisle is much more refined for that first half hour, but for me that doesn't justify the additional cost. Chopard Oud Malaki has that same tobacco note as these two in a refined and interesting composition that offers something more, and is much less beastly - probably more appropriate for serious situations where these two would be too overpowering.

[@GCBR-Dog-Training]

Red tobacco is worth the money . Carlisle is a tip off. I just bought a bottle of Carlisle and it lasted 2 hours on skin. For the price that is shameful

[@galinn76]

Red Tobacco has a nuclear projection and longevity. When I saw your bottle, I was really interested, how did you manage to spend so much of this perfume?

[@Woyto]

He's decanting perfumes :)

[@kevino73]

Good review. I own both and agree with almost everything you said. However, I still prefer RT because it's a little more rough around the edges, and that makes it more interesting to me. Carlisle is more versatile, better blended, & probably uses better ingredients, but I still prefer RT.

[@rareELL]

hey i got my red tabaco today. wow it is the strongest frag i have ever smelled ever. its super rough. tried scrubbing it off after 20 mins, nope, took a shower. nope. can still smell the two sprays to my wrist 16 hours later

[@mixedpleasure4324]

@@rareELLwhy tf would you rob it off? Its one of the best fragrance out there and it only just start to reach its peak after 30 minutes so you definitely missing out on some great stuff

[@mehrba]

Carlisle has more spicy medicinal vibe and to my nose I detect clove at the background while Red Tobacco has more tobacco/leather and fruity vibe. Both are great

[@ardenpowers7730]

Thanks for the comparison Joy . . . great review !

[@chipmcgee4393]

Joy. As always thanks for the content. I have bottles of both. Red Tobacco is Carlisle's rougher little brother. Carlisle is more refined and better blended but I like both. I reach for Carlisle more and it is a compliment beast. Be safe.

[@Namo81]

I perfer the mancera over the PDM better price better fragrance that makes statment

[@wagnerporras7616]

Love Mancera red tabaco is Awesome 😍

[@HumbleD50]

Subscribed.Good luck with your channel.

[@09Germ]

Great review like that you pop in 1984 hafez also for the comparison. So looks like Red tobacco is definitely a getter for the cash value.

[@michaelbullock8011]

Great video and I enjoyed it and i like pdm Carlisle and im going to try red tobacco and have a blessed day

[@Raj-fp1zq]

Great Joy.! Kindly do the video on Prada LRS and Prada LRB (Comparison). People need to know awesome those are and which is the best. Thanks Joy

[@pawekaminski2051]

I'm the only one who think Carlisle is a mess? Its like mixture of Layton and Herod going into feminine side.

[@bigboibenz]

Is no one going to talk about the urine-like animalic in the opening of Carlisle? It's almost unbearable for a few minutes. I like the scent, don't get me wrong, but not the opening.

[@minibus1351]

I don't get good performance on Carlisle. I have the 2020 version, and it just doesn't last long at all. Maybe they reformulated it?

[@DanishKhan-ky8su]

PDM house is super pricey. I wonder if I will ever try it. I'm more inclined towards Mancera Cedrat Boise.

[@donrock6503]

@Duke Of Prunes recent batch performence sucks

[@ee-linyong6732]

I own PDM Carlisle and Oajan. Both are so nice but I prefer Carlisle a little better. Yet to try mancera red tobacco. Seems like a masculine scent.

[@arkanelyass7697]

What about pegassus exclusif

[@erickalseco8808]

I have both and red tobacco outshine pdm Carlisle specially projection and longetivity. It depende how cold in your country where they triggered

[@ramoneregal8317]

The issue with comparing is red Tobacco is a true firey Tobacco.Carlise is a dark fruity fragrance

[@kevinmitchell4094]

Great Review! Don't have Carlisle. One spray of Red Tobacco is enough.

[@AB-bw5yc]

I just put a spray of each on the back of my hands. The pdm is hands-down the superior fragrance, by a wide margin imho. The mancera is loud and strong but 2 dimensional. Carlisle is smells more full and rounded off. It has a higher-end feel. At the price point it's not a surprise. You're better off saving for the pdm. I bought an 8ml travel spray of pdm and here I am less than a week later ordering the bottle online. I already had the mancera but will be re-homing it.

[@mixedpleasure4324]

Stop it both are super duper great fragrance both are a 9 or a 10

[@bigboibenz]

@@mixedpleasure4324 Agreed, it's all personal preference obviously. I've had both and in terms of quality, Carlisle isn't much better than RT IMHO.

[@nyknicky]

Hi joy, have been following you for long. Humble suggestion- kindly make vdo on notes like sandalwood, rose, neroli, vetiver etc. Thanks 👍

[@jhors7777]

Thank you friend Joy

[@erickalseco8808]

Both of them spray it on same arm you can detect that red tobacco is much powerful than carlisle

[@HardHatEugene]

One spray of red tobacco obliterates my nose. It’s so ridiculously strong it’s insane

[@reasonableselectivefragran5047]

Like your take on these two Brother👍👍👍💝

[@firemedic5170]

MaxAroma has 18 bottles in stock with a 15% discount posted on their page for purchases over $200. This is as of 10/30/20 so please don’t kill the messenger if they run out lol I hope that helps everyone a bit!!

[@BKG0730]

Love love Red Tobacco

[@oyefulefemi7744]

Hi Do you mind sharing what batch number you have Ive just bought this after watching reviews and feel like it must have been reformulated

[@thefragrancefreak9059]

I love Mancera ! Great house

[@bl5204]

Hlo bhai! Keep up the good work!!!

[@rezafalsafi]

Great review 👍 Carlise for me was the best and got many compliments. Issue: As of now Carlise is completely out of gray market and you can find it with complete retail price only. Any thought from where I can buy it?I mean any discounter has it still?

[@firemedic5170]

MaxAroma has 18 bottles in stock with a 15% discount posted on their page for purchases >$200 😊 Best deal I’ve seen a long long time

[@jaigijags1936]

Bhai please do a review on set wet body perfume gel (30 ml) discontinued now. And if you can find it please let us know i would buy few of them.

[@adiljiva5800]

Brilliant review

[@adrianr4095]

Just got a 4 oz tester of red tobacco for 63 bucks. My first niche fragrance. A blind buy, i hope i like it.

[@firemedic5170]

What a deal! If you don’t mind me asking, where did you get it at such a great price? I lovvvve red tobacco!

[@adrianr4095]

@@firemedic5170 on ebay from the seller beautynuvo. Its a tester came full presentation in tester box.

[@firemedic5170]

adrian r you’re awesome, thank you! Going to search now 🤞I’ve had great service from them in the past 🙌🏻 (edit: I think they’re sold out- 💩)

[@adrianr4095]

@@firemedic5170 yea they probably are out. They had 8 left a week ago when i purchased mine.

[@firemedic5170]

adrian r I’ll definitely keep an eye out for it in the future. Thank you again!

[@AM-ln2ck]

Is it the same as Hafez perfume ( hany )?

[@burgersuperking]

Now compare both to Frederic Malle Monsieur.

[@Ed-ce5mb]

Parfums de Marly has REFORMULATED Carlisle. I own an older formulation which has an alcohol concentration of 77%. The new formulation I see in stores has 81% alcohol. My formulation is a dark ORANGE / AMBER color. The new formulation is a very light, faint copper color. The new formulation does not last as long and it smells different. Parfums de Marly fragrances are ALWAYS getting reformulated and become much weaker than their ORIGINAL releases. Parfums de Marly HAS NOT been transparent when it comes to the reformulation of their fragrances. Herod, Layton & Oajan have also been reformulated and have 3%-4% more alcohol in newer batches.

[@mixedpleasure4324]

Still perfoms great

[@Remio777]

Dude you are everywhere saying the same thing. We get it. I get 12+hour on new batch. Shut up already

[@Ed-ce5mb]

@@Remio777 I am happy that you get 12 hours in performance with the new batch. Parfums de Marly is thrilled to hear that you see no difference in the new formulation. I posted my comment 5 months ago as a FYI. Obviously, a lot of people do not want to hear the truth. People also do not believe in free speech. If people disagree with you, they call you names and tell you that you are not allowed to make comments that they disagree with.

[@dmmice2344]

I can’t believe they have the nerve to still keep the same price range but make it reformulated and weaker. What a scam 😡

[@MrCrownHolderz]

Can’t find Carlisle anywhere

[@lexusgs2672]

I own red tobacco...would it be redundant if I’ll buy PDM Carlisle?

[@boardcrf2763]

I think they are 80% similar, Carlisle sweater and smoother.

[@kevino73]

I think it depends on the size of your collection. If you have a smaller collection, you probably don't need both. Otherwise it's fair game.

[@sandvich9]

I own and love both. Had Carlisle first and bought Red Tobacco after trying a sample.

[@faheem1992]

Which one do you prefer

[@owenchukunda4186]

How is the scent of the red tobacco? Can I wear it to school and In summer?

[@realblackbetty2204]

To me it’s a night scent or when it’s cold. Might be a little too string for school.

[@firemedic5170]

I’d say absolutely not for summer lol I got a decant and tested it again for my fiancé about a week ago... she absolutely loved it (indoors). Well, fast forward a few hours, we were outside doing yard work in 90F FL weather and it was literally choking us out 😂 Def go easy on the trigger, it is NO joke!

[@sipandsniff1744]

Just DO IT !!! One spray at a time though 😆🫶

[@smellycatreviews]

You didn't just pit them against each other! You're going to start a war! 😁

[@lovaszgergely]

Great comparison, interesting content! Carlisle is undoubtedly better than Red Tobacco.

[@DocRock71]

Carlisle all day long. Red Tobacco is too challenging and far less mass appealing. I still like it a lot, but Carlisle VS Red Tobacco...? No contest if I was offered a free bottle of one or the other.