Judge Judy Makes Man Prove His Identity! | Part 3

[@2010mceric]

Instead of being productive, I bet the defendant spent most of his time staring out his window watching his property across the street. He probably knew every time they left and came back to the house.

[@jeffhe1701]

dang. mike myers is getting too old for another halloween film

[@StevenAndTraceyJiles]

That's terrifying 😳

[@maryfiaola3686]

exactly

[@flacadiabla3193]

Creepy

[@NOCALGooN916]

Anytime they have company he's like who is that what are they doing he doesn't live there

[@tammypetruzzi9191]

JJ is right, he lives too close! You can’t rent out a property and then constantly spy on your tenants! He’s ridiculous.

[@christibarrick1768]

I think it’s more like dementia and Alzheimer’s than him being ridiculous. Js.

[@denisestevens3102]

I don't think hes ridiculous at all hes showing signs of congestive decline into dementia. I hope he has family members who can step in and help him with his affairs.

[@oumryeternity7871]

Or at least he should do his part, they told him there was a rodent and instead of making it checked he tells them to look for a hole themselves

[@dragames]

@@denisestevens3102 cognitive* decline :p congestive decline would be bad lungs.

[@peggycassidy1594]

@@dragames True! Congestive decline? Ha!!

[@yvainedarchambeau6941]

What kind of landlord calls his tenant, a grown woman, and asks who is leaving your house at 10:00 PM? Wow.

[@SoulDelSol]

"I see you're having a male guest at 10pm young lady. Who is this man? I demand to know! House meeting! Tomorrow!"

[@reneeboyd80]

Very creepy behavior.

[@LuckyBaldwin777]

JJ hit the nail on the head when she said he lives too close to his rental.

[@cici1439]

@@SoulDelSol🤣

[@Joyjoyjoy4]

So strange

[@Atrus999]

So every time someone comes to visit does the landlord run over and do an interrogation? That's ridiculous. I feel so bad for the whoever is staying there now.

[@jlc9590]

he’s having a mental decline and probably falling under some routine of suspicion, we all have this possibility in our lives

[@rogerargueta5769]

Unless you are a squirrel... He won't even acknowledge that you are there if you like peanuts and walnuts.

[@DrMoriole]

@@rogerargueta5769 - 🐿 🥜 🥜 🥜

[@SoulDelSol]

Sounds like he holds a house meeting!

[@Palmstreet-u7x]

believe me you do get such people,

[@bruced2346]

"Your problem is you live too close". Combine that fact with an obsessive and overbearing attitude, and you get this guy.

[@shendisackett]

Obsessive and looks like he has the onset of dementia so even when told who the tenants are he refuses to believe it.

[@auntiec6294]

I think his primary problem is cognitive decline. 😕

[@sharonmonios6677]

Memory issues

[@jasperhorace7147]

@@auntiec6294 Except that there was a hint in there that he’s done this before. Known to the police.

[@debbywilkins2239]

I would never want to live that close to my landlord. Especially a nosey one like this man

[@CanMac8870]

I live next door to my landlords, they are an elderly couple and after seeing this. I'm so blessed. I never see them or hear from them until I call to let them know I'm about to walk across the yard to bring the rent.. Best landlords ever

[@susanthompson8962]

I had landlords like that too. They had a Victorian home and rented the 2nd and 3rd floor as apartments. Very nice; I lived there 13 years. They also lived on the 1st floor, and did not interfere with anyone's life.

[@ExceptionalLex]

I'd educate myself on the initial signs of dementia if I were you. You just never know

[@annelyceyawingu6678]

Omg so nice🥰 the fact that you call them before walking over...Stay blessed!

[@NewWesternFront]

@@ExceptionalLex lol they shoot him as he trudges up their lawn

[@CanMac8870]

I worked in the alzheimer's unit for three years started working privately and I have two clients with dementia/ Alzheimer's, I think I'm educated, I do thank you for the advice🙏🏾

[@s.w.d4010]

Is this man up 24/7 just watching his rental property?? How does he know when they come & go? Does he have cameras on the house? If so that’s really creepy.

[@Local_idiot_21]

Ya I thought it was weird he knew when they left

[@nanrobbins2916]

@@Local_idiot_21 He lives across the street.

[@kimm6589]

@@nanrobbins2916 Most old men aren't awake at midnight.

[@bostonteaparty3926]

LOL - Yes he is up and watching everything they do

[@Beegeezy144]

Binoculars.

[@fianait]

I think the defendant was suffering from cognitive decline.

[@cribrebo7375]

Or he's a chronic liar

[@mmarco8787]

I think he's busy-body who got two men's names transposed and didn't want a bunch of people living in his home.

[@Westindiangyal1111]

I agree!

[@Lizzy514]

@@cribrebo7375 or suffering from a condition named for his other end.

[@JoshuaR1992]

He is on the ropes

[@kimberlyhoward7666]

JJ was right, "you live too close" lol

[@jomaro8]

He sounds like he doesn't need to be living unassisted, let alone be someone's landlord.

[@truelife974]

Talking about he called a meeting. This man is a piece of work!

[@rentalguy1]

As a former landlord, this guy is the type that gives all landlords a bad name.

[@LadyAdakStillStands]

Ànd make a property manager go insane! Some clients just don't get it or are ultra paranoid retirees renting their home(s) when their health declines.

[@rocco...]

Who knows how many times he was in their place while they were out.🤨

[@rosalynw.otieno1994]

Exactly!!! What a creep!

[@mattyd3079]

Outrageous conduct by the defendant. Who the hell does he think he is spying on them, harassing them all hours of the night because he doesn’t recognise someone, and entering the house without lawful excuse? He is too close and too involved in his rental property. I believe the plaintiffs 100%. I am sure the house was not clean when they moved in and i am sure they didn’t steal his old crap washing machine. Unbelievable. I would be very concerned for anyone renting that property. The plaintiff did the right thing calling the police. The defendant looks dangerous to me - like something out of a horror film

[@jaydogg0026]

He’s the landlord and it’s his property. He can do as he wishes

[@lovelish]

@@jaydogg0026 he actually can’t do what he wishes.. Landlords have to abide by certain rules/laws as well in regards to tenants..

[@LC-se8pw]

​@@jaydogg0026 that's not at all how it works. Tenants have a legal right to privacy and "quiet enjoyment" of the property they pay to live in.

[@again5162]

​@@jaydogg0026well this landlord did what he wanted but got in trouble and it cost him money what a dum dum

[@Mongo76]

@@jaydogg0026 You are right he can do as he wishes. He wishes to be a nuisance to anyone who rents the property. While he is free to be a nuisance, it won't serve him well because his actions are actionable by law and nobody has to put up with it. Especially when he is confused as a drunken bat!

[@Sweetheartbabez]

That call at 10 pm would have gone unanswered! Straight to voicemail! You hear me. 🤳📴

[@chance757]

FOR REAL!!

[@coffeeforme6887]

The defendant acts like a house parent at a 1950’s college, checking everyone in and out.

[@SoulDelSol]

Huh?

[@damnnerves24]

This is one of the pitfalls of living across the street from your landlord! Busybody up at midnight looking across the street! 🤦🏾‍♀️

[@juliefuraitor5610]

@Tracy The owner of the house I used to rent used to ride by all of the time, aka stalking, caught him many times. What a kook.

[@damnnerves24]

@@cynthiacrawford9952 I can only imagine!

[@damnnerves24]

@@juliefuraitor5610 Folks like this should not rent!

[@teeannwalker9535]

Don’t understand everyone is piling on the landlord. He really needs to sell that property and use the money doing something to occupy himself. He will never keep tenants 😂😮

[@lightandsymbols1111]

I feel so bad for the tenants having to go through something like that and not the first ones by the sounds of it. It so expensive, stressful and time consuming to move out and find a new place. He has signs of early stage dementia I think.

[@shendisackett]

Yes it certainly looks that way. I suspect he has never been a nice landlord and always tried to dictate to people because of the fact he clearly watches the house and wanted them to sort the pest issue for him. The dementia has just made it worse as he can't remember when he has spoken to them.

[@aartadventure]

He's probably just a busy body who constantly spies on his tenants, except he has poor night vision, so he has no idea what he is really seeing. He then harrasses his tenants over it. I don't think he has dementia at all. He just needs to get a life.

[@shendisackett]

@@aartadventure the fact he has been repeatedly told the man here is Travis but is still confused as to who he is shows he has some cognitive issues developing that look a lot like dementia. He saw Travis in daylight so that isn't a night vision issue. That and how he was getting confused with questions shows he is more than just a nosey landlord. I have no doubt he's always been a nightmare landlord living so close but his issues can't be explained by poor night vision.

[@xman4328]

I think he is in advanced stages of being a jerk.

[@Palmstreet-u7x]

he must have German blood in him, lol, they act like that when old,

[@brt5273]

"You live too close!" Yep and too much time on his hands. I lived next door to a landlord one time and that was enough to learn the lesson not to rent a place where the landlord lived so close. Not that every landlord is like that but the aversion I developed from that one time is enough to keep me from ever doing it again.

[@TheHoriginal]

Agreed 👍

[@noraisacoff6649]

One of the most bizarre JJ cases I have ever seen.

[@RoxiieSays]

Omg he’s a landlord from hell. He probably just sits at his window with binoculars and watches them 24/7

[@michellebarron1987]

seriously 😂

[@velmalove]

I’ve been there! A living nightmare.

[@charleneblack2792]

I live next door to my landlord. I thought it'd be hell, but I love him and his wife. We've been here 6 years. We're always a month ahead and he let's us do whatever we want. We've taken it from looking like a 2 to a 9, putting rock down, flower beds, a building. I love my landlord. Lol

[@traceytansley1659]

Sounds like you are also a great Tennant and that you take pride in your home. You are someone who I hope is blessed with your own home one day too. So many tenants abuse the property and/or live like pigs. It's horrible to act this way and only reflects on yourself. Glad you are the opposite! 😊

[@AnikaBren]

Having been a landlord, you sound like a tenant I would want to have stay for a very long time.

[@smacdiesel]

I'm glad you found each other.

[@calebrusso3773]

Nightmare landlord. A demented old man with nothing else to do to occupy his time but get himself all riled up. It’s easy to imagine him sitting near a window with a pair of binoculars and a notepad.

[@Spencerlayne]

These cases are 10 years old. He's probably dead by now

[@THEDubbleHelixx]

Definitely; how else would he know what everyone was doing at all hours of the day and night?

[@TheFakeyCakeMaker]

​@@Spencerlayne harsh 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@mel...s]

@@TheFakeyCakeMaker I'm crying 😭😩

[@ItssKennAnn]

oh wow 🤣

[@louchris9001]

The older gentleman is surely losing his mind!!! He is a busy body and needs a hobby!!!

[@jacobrohr9658]

I’m glad the plaintiffs won but the defendant is sadly loosing his memory and mind, pretty sad poor guy had no clue what was going on.

[@deniyahsjourney2748]

He's living too close and is very paranoid

[@Realfrenchie]

I love Judge Judy.... no one can play game with her!!!!

[@queenbee3647]

My landlord loved us. His house was next to my parents. He knew me since I was six years old. Huge nine rooms, garage, attic, basement, large yard all for $110 a month. He let us have pets. He said kids would be fine. He begged us to buy from him and let him and the other elderly tennant stay. It really was great for all. We were young so we did yard work. Kept it beautiful. Had a garden and shared veggies. Shoveled snow. Watched the downstairs when they went on vacation and took in mail. Eight wonderful years renting there. But it was toooooo close to my mom. We saved almost $30,000 to put down on a house and moved away. Great way to start off.

[@crpsaiyan]

Sounds like the elevator doesn't reach the top floor in the case of the defendant. It sounds like he needs to be in an assisted facility and not a home owner/ landlord.

[@maryfiaola3686]

Dont ever go into a rental place where the landlord is living across the road from you or next door 😂😂

[@juliefuraitor5610]

Or in the same building. Recipe for disaster.

[@michellebarron1987]

noted!!😂

[@justcogitating]

My sister's landlords lived in the apartment below. They asked her not to flush the toilet after 11 p.m.

[@elizaleroux9173]

Strange person.. I wouldn't feel safe with him around.

[@travet1000]

Glad the Plaintiffs won. However, feel bad for the old man who might be suffering from early signs of dementia or something else. Very sad.

[@richardhayes7964]

i totally agree with you.

[@Mally87]

i don't think it's that. Some older people are very possessive of there property and hover the older they get

[@shelberz1]

Yes

[@acousticshadow4032]

Had same thought, Country.

[@jasonscott4366]

@@richardhayes7964 no hes not suffering from anything other than being a nosey busy body

[@ginacook1208]

he is not well... but JJ nailed it..he lives way to close ...

[@rebeccalevine6411]

I feel sorry for whoever moves in to that house

[@bobthedemon1975]

4:15 - Creepy old man alert!!!

[@citytrees1752]

The landlord is like a character that Tim Conway could play on the Carol Burnett Show.

[@brathwaitelisa]

That landlord is so unhappy he watches every movement of his tenants 😆 🤣 😂

[@sawyer4981]

More people need to start suing their landlord when they do shit like this. I let it go the first time it happened to me. Have sued every landlord since & gotten my full deposit back + court costs every time.

[@user-um7tw6kx4r6]

He makes his tenants' lives unbearable it's just shocking

[@dlm8763]

Landlords like this are creepy. I would never rent a place where the landlord lives next door. They act like they own you. Listen to him saying they arrived at this time, they left at this time It is like he is stalking them.

[@AmyTheSpiritSinger]

Yeeey!!👏🏼👏🏼 That was amazing.👍🏻😃 What a terrible landlord!😤 He had obviously received complaints before.🤨 I also think he is somewhat demented. He didn't remember the man, up to several times. Even in court.🤦🏼‍♀️ Time to stop renting that house out to people.!🫷🏼

[@frigid4real]

I'm so glad this worked out

[@Snarkerella]

And getting May's rent! Just because they left around midnight with their stuff, doesn't mean you know what's going on in their heads for the rest of the month. It was probably way too late to stay and clean and she had every right to come back the next day to finish. This landlord is a nut! I bet the little red pine squirrel that he so affectionately calls it is a good friend of his. LOL

[@RoughJustice2k18]

This case should be called "Rental Nightmares". The tenant isn't the problem here, the landlord is.

[@kaylahall1219]

Complains about them moving out at midnight; but calls at 10:00 pm

[@smiley27b]

That sounds like a nightmare landlord! Watching their every move like that. I think he needs a hobby 🤯

[@peacefreedom4930]

Dang, that’s creepy. Can you imagine someone watching your every move? He was monitoring them like prisoners. He knew every time someone entered and exited the home. If the police needed information from me about my neighbors, they’d be out of luck. I couldn’t pick them in a lineup if my life depended on it. Lol

[@johnmeskens5613]

Real creepy. He's the kind of old man that probably entered the home while they weren't aware and went thru the girl's underwear drawer.

[@kiral9201]

Defendant clearly has too much time on his hands if A) he's watching the property at all hours of the night and B) doesn't realise that working people often have to do things at night

[@patim5953]

The defendant shouldn't be a landlord. Whatever his problems he can't make it the tenant's.

[@robertjonez5]

He's a typical old person in a retirement community. Peering out the windows with binoculars 24/7 "Hey Joann look, Joey is taking the trash out today!"

[@mel924]

Sounds like the defendant had cams on the property & knew every move they made. Creepy!!!

[@marypridham3823]

The judge said he lived across the street.

[@mel924]

@@marypridham3823 I`m sure he`s not looking out his windows 24/7

[@cluezybluez]

​@@mel924Nah he probably is. This guy clearly has too much time on his hands

[@iamthomasgreenman]

It’s the calm of his psychosis that’s terrifying.

[@harmoniefaerielove]

It wasn't a rodent in the ' none attic' it was him dressed in a red squirrel costume 😄, probably putting in spy cameras on the female tenant .. He appears very creepy indeed.

[@SoulDelSol]

I bet you're right, it was probably him up there. I 100% believe there were spy cameras

[@anibaldk]

That guy seriously scares me. I would rather live under a bridge than moving into that house

[@rosalynw.otieno1994]

Can I join you?🤣🤣🤣

[@jkbc]

OMG what a creepy landlord, watching you every move in and out of the house

[@angelsandfaes]

NEVER live that close to your Landlord. Been there done that. If I didn’t clean our stove top directly after dinner she would come in while I was taking kids to school and complain about it. Every day she complained about something. I didn’t vacuum everyday. I didn’t clean water spots from the shower. It was crazy. She was also a drug addict and I got a call from the police as she had had gotten busted with a bag of my children’s medications that she collected over 2 years that they thought I sold her. I had a child that had leukemia and one that was adhd. I was so angry and hurt. We moved a week from that day.

[@smiley27b]

Whoa that's absolutely terrible! So glad you & your kids moved 😬❤

[@9liveslisa]

That landlord is too paranoid and should not ever be a landlord. Not everyone lives by the same schedule as he does. These poor tenants were working full time and had to get stuff done after hours or on weekends. I'd be happy to be away from that landlord.

[@John-fp2ls]

Judge Judy is an amazing judge doesn’t take any bull and is completely fair to both sides unlike the judges we hear about today I have been watching her shows pretty much ever since they started

[@keithgunvordahl]

The defendant operates is a world within his own head.

[@timgriffin807]

There is NO judge as GOOD as Judge Judy. I've yet to see a case where I think she ruled wrong! Fantastic person.

[@marctoleafoa5864]

What a horrible landlord. I pray he gets better ❤

[@ingridkantor4411]

Dementia doesn't get better, it gets worse.

[@MissBlueBeauty]

My mom rented from a guy like this one time. He lived across the street and would just come into the home while she was at work to “take a look around and make sure things were functioning properly”. She didn’t stay there long…

[@MsTeck883]

Oh my gosh, what a landlord, a real Gladys Kravitz!

[@oceanbreeze34]

This nosy incompetend landlord should stop renting houses. Nobody wants to live under those kind of circumstances. Happy for the plaintiff 💪🌞

[@mjremy2605]

Landlords like this crafty, greedy, SOB should be on a list of bad landlords to be avoided. He took their rent, kept their deposit, cost them double moving charges, and is a really vile man. Pretending to be forgetful but in reality a slumlord. So glad these young people got out of that awful place. He should be banned from renting.

[@FLT111]

He keeps calling him Jar XD

[@godmadesam]

The defendant’s “whistle talk” was very amusing, I must state!

[@rubi2322]

Herbert the Pervert

[@croach2194]

The landlord is insane. He should pay all their moving costs.

[@lynnecrisp]

This man ain't all there. They're better off w/out renting from him. I'm so glad that couple won

[@camilleshearon5120]

What a piece of work. O my lord.

[@dachellmcghee8901]

The girl was about to say, this was not the first time because she said cops have had to deal with him before, the man is a creep

[@AmandaCarlow-g7f]

What a nightmare landlord. He has nothing to do but spy on his tenants. Next, he will be putting cameras in the house.

[@priyankajilwani]

What if this is a scheme by the defendant? Collect a tenant’s security deposit and one month rent then get rid of them and get a new tenant and repeat the cycle. 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@GloriaYtuarte]

Thanks again for your support

[@walterjohnson2713]

Honestly I’m glad that they’re out of there because at the end of the day that landlord does not know how to be a landlord. Based on his actions

[@elanfredette4661]

“Your problem is you live too close to your tenants” 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@SimonJones49]

A bored old man who is a more than a little bit creepy, good job they were on JJ another court might not have seen it so clearly.

[@marianaya5824]

He might be heading towards dementia with the irrational paranoia of his tenants and confusion about who should be there or not.

[@kevine.lemaster8473]

Plantiffs were clearly decent people with rational demands.

[@Codydaniel672]

These are the kind of landlords I cannot stand!!! Nosy ass landlords are constantly poking their little little heads around! Literally stalking you!!

[@keoraanderson459]

He is a nut and he needs to sale that house 🤦‍♀

[@smiley27b]

JJ's face @ 1:15 🤣

[@vickyspencer2816]

That Old Man Lives toooo close....

[@oceanbreeze34]

He is a stalker! What the hell is he doing watching the neighbors day and night 😂 He probably has no own life...Happy for the plaintiffs 💪🌹

[@newsstuff82]

Honestly, watching this makes me sad. He is getting older and losing his ability to conduct his business…☹️ Yes, I felt sorry for the tenants, of course. I just hope he has family to help him.

[@soothOfTheLoop]

"did you take the washing machine? " "No!" "then the counterclaim is dismissed!" that was so funny!

[@charlesfranklinlambeth3944]

😂😂The minute the defendant asked if he could interrupt in Part One, I knew he was gonna lose.

[@sparky7915]

What a terrible landlord!! He is so controlling!!

[@CanadianMonarchist]

Obviously the defendant isn’t playing bridge with a full deck. It’s a personal tragedy for him and his loved ones.

[@idaslapter5987]

The landlords whistling speech is blowing out my computer speakers.

[@zombienectar]

The old lad can hide his own Easter eggs .

[@IH8YALLL]

😆😂

[@jules3048]

That man should not be renting to anyone unless and until he realizes what his role as landlord actually is and what he can and cannot do. JJ was absolutely right he lives to close. AND he doesn’t know he can’t enter the place before their lease is up?!? I’d be glad to be out of that place too!!

[@CookingwithAfton]

He’s a crazy landlord

[@lizoliveira5606]

Been there and done thar with these kinds of landlords. Happy that jj upheld Justice here!

[@henryreese7236]

crazy old man

[@yolandascholten2012]

I absolutely believe he’s had issues in the past! He’s a nosy busy body.

[@Fotosynthesis858]

The defendants mental health is clearly compromised. I hope he has some kind of assistance

[@peryole]

That man is absolutely absurd, no one needs to be renting from him.

[@kaamya921]

This is why I Love Judge Judy! On any given episode anyone can Get It!😂

[@hinkenixon6043]

The landlord is a complete CRANK!

[@MEGIDIOT]

The defendant is losing everything about his cognition apart from his ability to be a major karen.