A Clean Cut

The plaintiff dated the defendant, and they have a child together. She says they went to a hardware store together and he cut her arm with a blade. She’s suing for medical bills. The defendant insists it was an accident.

[@oodief88]

Box cutters can be really sharp, but what kind of swinging was he doing for her to need 36 stitches?! Whoa.

[@scottrogue946]

It’s giving me Benihana Slice and Dice tease 🍚 😬

[@oodief88]

@@scottrogue946 crazy! It sliced through her jacket and still did a great amount of damage to her arm.

[@sheilabrown5511]

He meant to cut her

[@TaintedBeautifully]

“He’s a great person”.

[@zulu3274]

Razor blades are sharper than brand new kitchen knives. It doesn't take much force for them to cut something soft...but indeed he shouldn't have been playing with it in that manner....

[@mariaelena8710]

If he was such a “good” person, they wouldn’t have had to go to court. He would’ve made sure to pay that bill instead of being so nonchalant about the incident. Run 🏃🏾‍♂️sis!

[@raquelh8791]

They will be married next week. She's still giggling and got googly eyes for him. Girl run!

[@firstnationfall5451]

Exactly

[@ayabaesse8421]

Ur right, it don’t add up.

[@greatmind3842]

OMG! You just took the words out of my mouth!

[@goldensage5766]

She's lying for him, he did that on purpose. Don't take him back!

[@MrsSexiiShay17]

Right look at 7:52 Look how she staring at him she know he lyin

[@MrsSexiiShay17]

Then judge is full of shit on this one because why would he encourage him to get back together gotta be crazy

[@Kaee_411]

Y’all seen the look he gave her after she said he was intimidating & Judge Mathis said he looks like a nice guy😂 That facial expression alone explains it all. & with how big that scar looks, he applied way too much pressure rubbing that blade to be playing🤦🏽‍♀️

[@ciearra6573]

Exactly what I was thinking like I know that had to hurt and I’m sure she told him to stop. Something isn’t adding up.

[@phillybonewilliams2560]

Exactly!

[@vanessakenney3144]

Shucks, I was looking at Judge side eyed when he said this man didn't look intimidating. 😁😁

[@tosha0508]

She's low key afraid of him. The nervous laughter, instantly giving him praise, being cautiously soft spoken so she won't spark any rage from him.....she ain't fooling anybody. If he was as good as she says, they would still be together

[@Bih1stOfAll]

Very astute. I was going to leave a similar comment

[@jacobestevez7570]

exactly

[@kdw1356]

Period been there

[@angelfrmheaven]

Exactly! This was her way out and she took, hope she doesn't go back!

[@kentthomason6285]

If she was that scared, she would not have gotten on tv about it

[@blahaaaaaaan]

She need to find a more loving and mindful companion, maybe I'm old fashioned but men don't even play harm with their ladies!

[@sereneamani1713]

That can also be said as "Find somebody who won't maim and/or kill you".

[@cosmicpressure]

I don’t even like the thought of my wife getting a paper cut lol

[@highlander666]

Not sure why a grown man would be playing with a razor blade anyway; but if he lacks sense that badly, that's enough to leave him alone altogether

[@TheM1220yh]

They both said it was still in the package. People play around sometimes and things happen.

[@tom11zz884]

He made a mistake GEESH. I've seen people forgiven for far worst things.

[@payableondeath9091]

@@tom11zz884 someone pretending to cut you aint forgivable 🤔

[@serious7179]

@@tom11zz884 my husband never played around me with a knife.. you don't play with knives. Seems like the so-called mistake wasn't a mistake

[@leelew.1462]

I was trying to figure out who in their right mind would "play" with a box cutter? Grow tf up🙄

[@dianabialaskahansen2972]

Run girl! Run as fast as you can! He seems violent and prone to rage.

[@dunkman2004]

Shut up

[@evangeline6]

If someone loves you and they accidentally harm you they wouldn't minimize it & they wouldn't need a court order to pay. That's a long cut

[@autumnskai6383]

He assaulted a guy that looked at her, her friends say he's intimidating and accidentally cut her. He's crazy! He shouldn't have done anything like that, who plays like that. Judge is wrong for encouraging them to get back together. Don't go back sis!

[@Mr.Boring_Man]

"If I can't have you, no one can" is the vibe I get.

[@nettyspeaks]

Judge is very toxic his darn self. Im tired of him

[@kdw1356]

Exactly

[@virgoscorner]

Don't forget his own mother warn him that he would be alone bc of his temper!!

[@alphonsocoley5170]

He haven't run up on the right one that's jus one guy he know he can beat but don't be slow he'might come back for him.

[@elh1977]

I don't believe him. He the type to joke around about a serious issue then claim he was just kidding but we know he wasn't. Hope she doesn't take him back.

[@Renrens-LionessofJudah]

They are definitely dangerous . I known a few of them.

[@tom11zz884]

Learn to have some forgiveness in your heart for Black men. The man said he was sorry

[@serious7179]

@@tom11zz884 you can forgive someone without taking them back. No need for her to submit to a life of unhappiness just to make him feel whole.

[@SamuelsReview]

I heard/ saw too many red flags. Would've been out like the roadrunner 😂

[@nicab5819]

36 stitches inside and outside 😕🤨Naw sis that ain’t no joking around he meant that cut smh

[@Mr.Boring_Man]

Guy has a violent history she clearly thought was cute until he brought that energy to her. I get that "if I can't have you, no one can"vibe.

[@scottrogue946]

He could of went to jail for that and probably should have. That cut looked horrific 😖

[@kayshawnsimmons6822]

I agree

[@nickynick_]

Y’all saying stuff that they aren’t even saying. - that vibe doesn’t even exist with this couple

[@ak24553]

He is too old to be playing with a blade. I think he meant to do it. She’s covering for him. How many times is she going to us he’s a good guy? Something’s off about this

[@naturale9412]

Something tells me that was no accident. It sounds too familiar. Girl was fresh out of high school. Bf cut her, went to the hospital with her and he was calm as ever. Charming and knew how to act around certain people but those who truly knew him were aware of how violent he really was

[@brenttucker3933]

This is an episode that should’ve been given to Judge Judy. And I am a die hard JM FAN

[@minae9935]

Naaahhh….something isn’t adding up…I feel like she’s covering for him. It doesn’t make sense. They had to have came up with this lie together

[@ciearra6573]

I agree. Like how do you accidentally run a blade against someone’s arm without you knowingly hurting the other person. I’m sure she told him to stop or winced in pain.

[@poppmaxx2348]

I said the same thing. She started off saying He never physically abused her. Hell yess He did. That's the biggest sign right there. He didn't go to no hospital with her cause he was scared they was gonna call the police. I believe they are still together and ain't never broke up. He made her come there to get that bill paid so he won't have to pay it. They waaaaaaay too cordial.

[@MrsSexiiShay17]

Exactly you had to take a level of force to push through the jacket and on the skin

[@queenjocelyn4711]

Definitely think he purposefully cut her and she’s too blinded to see this man’s temper has effected her too

[@Killahkingkoh]

Nah it’s definitely an accident thats why she defended him

[@SpiffyPenguin]

Stop trying to force folk to get married or be together, JM. That's weird as hell. She said he chased someone down and beat them up for looking at her, she doesn't want all that.

[@Chicago.hottie]

Exactly as a father I can’t believe he even joked about it smh

[@YoungLadyInRed]

I hate when he does that. He should know better.

[@tamarshawilliams93]

@@YoungLadyInRed right! Don't JM have a daughter? I know he has a granddaughter who I know he won't take to kindly at all being with someone like that.

[@YoungLadyInRed]

@@tamarshawilliams93 yep. He’s got two.

[@leelew.1462]

And aren't they not together? Just co parent. Cause his name alone would have steered me away from his childish self in the first place. Grown boy, "playing" with a box cutter🙄

[@rmont8516]

Them brand new blades are sharp af cut through dry wall like butter.

[@moniquespight8667]

Right everybody acting like it had to be on purpose... No oOoOO not necessarily I work with box cutters all day everyday..I cut through my finger on total accident..

[@ivillage5872]

If you could do that to a person & not help with the finances, Then i do not see any future

[@mariaelena8710]

Exactly

[@latarareed7321]

👍 RIGHT; LIKE WHY DID SHE EVEN NEED TO B SUING FOR THE BILL IF HE SO APOLOGETIC ON THIS ...IT SHOULDN'T OF HAD TO COME TO LAW ..IF YA SO 💕 LOVE HER ; & HER HEALTH WELL BEING IN THE TOP PRIORITIES ...#PERIOD

[@chuck9380]

It amazes me how he really thought it wasn’t his fault

[@khrisi9410]

Grown man playing with a box cutter is disturbing.

[@winniewera2510]

He cut her on PURPOSE, period …

[@Virgoqueen920]

Period!!!!

[@serious7179]

He is a big red flag...keep it moving girl; you seem sweet.

[@jordanalston3506]

This was no accident. That cut was longggg and looked deep. He had to be holding her bc nobody’s gonna stand there and get cut like that. She’s covering for him.

[@asiam1528]

Stay away from jealous possessive men , he probably still sleeping with the ex

[@lifeinbeautifulbrown6557]

2022 & the judge is still on 🙌🏾

[@cashbaby26able]

This is the comment I was looking for !!!!!

[@kellysuero4702]

Wow crazy

[@latarareed7321]

👍👍👍💯💯✨✨👏👏👏Yahoo THAT HE IS JM FAN FO 🧬 LIFE

[@brownskinfriendly]

Why are they both acting so ditzy? Oweee I’m tired of these grown people who act hella weird and kid like. Sis all that skinning and grinning for why?

[@Poppa_Reed]

She obviously covering up for him,he cut her on purpose

[@belleame1064]

Run sis, run!

[@Vanessa_Martinez]

Judge Mathis is full of it… You don’t know nobody after a year in his voice: “you can hide a drug habit for two years”.. a year is way too soon to be having a chld and ppl wonder why their relationship end so quickly.

[@1Andrea]

Right I have no idea what the rush is I like to take my time and day and as you guys grow closer together sometimes you find out you’re not meant to be… No reason to rush no Why not day for a year maintaining or separate places in getting to know each other… If it’s gonna work they’re not going anywhere

[@SimplyASweetHeart]

this relationship was toxic toxic toxic! and should be over and never re kindled .. cause they childish with a child ... smg

[@ladyj5682]

This one doesn't make much sense to me. If u knew it was an accident, and he is cutting ex loose, then u had a child with him.....What is going on? Why have a child with him so quik? These people get on my nerves

[@peacefreedom4930]

Sir, y’all are not cool. You have a completely lackadaisical attitude about causing her pain and suffering, permanent scarring, financial damages, and stress. You didn’t take this seriously, at all. 36 stitches isn’t minor. She’s clearly very nice. She should have sued you for medical bills, her jacket, any damages to her credit, and pain/suffering. She should not entertain a relationship with you because you will not protect her or be attentive to her needs.

[@tgordon8136]

36 inside and 36 outside. Dude tried to kill her. I believe they are defensive wounds.

[@fatboythetrucker3971]

Bull CRAP! He did that on purpose! COWARD

[@nikkif9873]

I was looking for the bussy popper in the comments 😂😂 Adrianna where you at 😂😂😂😂

[@heidicrimmings9615]

He must be napping...👉👁👁👈

[@nikkif9873]

@@heidicrimmings9615 😂😂 right

[@TopherGrant]

Clown Prince

[@heidicrimmings9615]

@@TopherGrant lol.. Lol

[@youmakemelaugh1797]

Whose grown and playing with box cutters tho seriously????

[@pennypillow4445]

shes lying saying that they were 'playing' but he meant to hurt her with the box cutter, hes abusive. his body language and everything says it all

[@deejai1173]

Ilk he walked in all sloppy looking!

[@scottrogue946]

😂

[@rmont8516]

They both overweight af

[@pminor90]

@@rmont8516 you must be the ex 😂😂😂

[@catierollins8493]

@@pminor90 💀💀..

[@larhondalivelife]

Ain’t nobody accidentally cutting me with shit. Lord I dunn got mad. Nevermind

[@brandongipson9552]

U so cute

[@audrelordhammercy612]

Her body language is showing that she’s in danger. I hope they did not get married.

[@shai6134]

I'm sorry but who the f... play like that ?! I definitely dont.

[@leahnole9771]

If a guy, Even Mistakingly, cut my arm like that I could never ever be in a relationship with him or marry him! Am I wrong for thinking that way y'all? From a Sista from Brooklyn, NY

[@Thathotti]

How do you accidentally open a box cutter? Those things are hard to open.

[@darrellbaker974]

All different types of box cutters

[@kayshawnsimmons6822]

Yes they are for reasons like this. He grown and knows exactly what he was doing

[@Immacuti3]

They're still in love.

[@Vanessa_Martinez]

I feel like that’s one of the most disrespectful things a baby daddy/ ex husband can do is bring the next women to your house without your remission.

[@tinawalker5335]

Let me tell you how my boyfriend sent me to pick up his kids from his bm house when I was 21 (dumb as hell). I knock at the door and she just yells come in.. I go inside and the apartment (projects) was filthy and full of black trash bags of stuff. She was half dressed and I guess she thought it was him but when she turned and saw me standing inside her kitchen she could have died a thousand deaths. 😂😭. It took our kids becoming adults before she ever liked me after that. To your point, he didn’t tell her I was coming and I assumed she knew. So it was disrespectful on both ends.

[@BigMerkGee]

@@tinawalker5335 I'm glad you didn't get cut too!

[@Tee-kk6tj]

If I’m done, I don’t care who’s in the car when he comes to pick up our children as long as his tail shows up. I couldn’t/can’t pay my ex husband to spend time with the kids. I could care less who he with as long as they’re not tripping on my children.

[@sereneamani1713]

@@tinawalker5335 All I got from that was "the project apartment was filthy". Just felt the need to say, "everybody who lives in the projects is not filthy". Note: Not saying you said that.

[@donaldg2415]

Love hurts… or however that song goes lol

[@kayshawnsimmons6822]

"Playing" with dangerous weapons NEVER ok. Leave him gurl and don't look back

[@tatihendrix1785]

She’s covering for him

[@generationalcursebreaker5397]

She definitely lied for him! She didn’t want him to go to prison for that so they came up with a story .

[@marroonrider3193]

who plays with box cutters?

[@joefriday5917]

no one

[@sweetsweet81]

Either it happened exactly as they both said, or she's covering for him to keep him out of prison. It was like she was floating between being in love with him and being afraid of him. They are from my birth state. I bet JM knows Pastor Richard Howell!!!

[@MOOCHIE2BADD]

Capricorn ♑ 🐐

[@sweetsweet81]

@@MOOCHIE2BADD yes ma'am!!! Don't forget the 🐟tail!

[@mrshappilymarried1]

36 stitches in no way sounds like an accident but okay...

[@fatboythetrucker3971]

You would be CRAZY ASH to marry someone that fight people for looking at her! She is BEAUTIFUL 😍 NO CAP! But, marriage?? Naw, he would probably end up hurting her. Just co parent with him🙏🙏💯

[@shortcake2204]

That long of a cut was a mistake? That deep? Who do they think they are lying to🙄...

[@theculturalconfusion7748]

Nah. That ain’t no damn accident.

[@vapaperboi]

Why does he look intimidating because he has dreads?

[@t.c.5456]

Ask her, not us.

[@STAYFOCUSED00777]

This 1 seems kinda SUS to me!🤔🤨

[@nettyspeaks]

Hes very ashy

[@1234pixy1]

Yall went to buy a blade to scrape something off?? Yall don't have knives 🤣 Edit: I swear this show just has some charity cases sometimes.

[@queenb2713]

How was that a joke or an accident...wtf..girl I hope you left him...bcuz next time he stabs you for real and then say oh that was an accident...so what would you do then???

[@worldhealthrn]

She SAID it was an accident and that he wasn't abusive... don't think she was trying to drag him down or lie about him

[@deetheefoodie]

I never heard of anyone “playing” like that.

[@queenandcrown]

I never 'played' with any sharp objects. Him not taking responsibility for his negligence is such a turn-off. The man has anger issues, as well as being violent. There's nothing funny about that. She probably bought those razors to protect herself from him.

[@elisapierre-procope9177]

Oh noooo honey. He keep saying "she knows..." She knows i love her, she knows it wasn't intentional. Poor girl.

[@sereneamani1713]

I was resting my eyes and just listening to this video. Unfortunately, I opened my eyes in time to see that gash. I hope I will one day be able to unsee that. To think that she experienced that at his hands is unnerving. Accident, playing, or not.

[@jenn_x.]

"I love her"...gives me those 'See what you made me do?!' vibes. Been there, ran from that.

[@ariamarshall5161]

She’s covering for him mainly Bc they have a child together & likely still loves him & might consider taking him back & so she doesn’t want to look like a woman who stayed with a violent man who has done her bodily harm. 36 stitches is NO accident. Not even sure how the story told is even possible. Huh? He JOKINGLY did a 12in slash down her arm deep enough to open her arm to the white meat? No ma’am? Just randomly in the package it was open & the blade was extended? No Sir? The story just literally sounds ridiculous. They are lying of he’s a clown a** immature man-child. Either way hope she doesn’t take him back, ever.

[@poppmaxx2348]

Chile he made her come to this show to get this paid for him. She started off saying He never physically abused her. Hell yess He did. That's the biggest sign right there. He didn't go to no hospital with her cause he was scared they was gonna call the police. I believe they are still together and ain't never broke up. They waaaaaaay too cordial.

[@Radiance230]

10:20 2022 and he is still here!! Congratulations Judge.

[@Iamwhoiam993]

They met at ⛪ and then had a 👶🏾. 🤨

[@KINGDOMDAUGHTER]

@7:01-7:20 when plaintiff describes the blade incident. Doesn't she read her Bible or that church didn't teach her, them, that words are power, and will certainly comes to fruition. Proverbs 18:21, death and life is on the power of one's tongue..... so speaking such, he, the defendant acted upon such with instructions from those spiritual robbers stronghold spirit's In addition, STOPPED being naive, abuse is abuse, whether it is physical, verbal, mentally, emotional, spiritual and financial..he may not done the physical just yet, God is and has being telling you to RUN RUN RUN and don't look back; but you went and shacked up together, play house, fornicate in sin, lust and iniquities and then having baby/babies by an unfruitful man who literally has issues and seeing such from his babies mother(s); you still got stronghold and soul tied by this sucker who his own mama spoke into fruition that if he didn't stop and get his act together, he will be alone, again this is spiritual warfare manifesting upon him

[@briasymone7807]

A clear evident story. He should of never been playing with a knife if he loves her. I've had similar experiences and happened to be never hurt. Stay aware Queens 💗

[@fionadarlingb]

Something is fishy and odd about this case.... The cut doesn't look like an accident.

[@theinvaderblankman4226]

A grown man shouldn't be playing with nothing other than a woman kittycat but that's just me and she still like him or love him lol

[@wildfiregirl1556]

Facts.

[@rj5778]

The fact that his trying to brush it off like ugh it’s not that serious is disgusting.

[@Vanessa_Martinez]

I don’t believe he accidentally playing did that. I think she embarrassed and don’t wanna tell the truth. Because ppl probably told her she shouldn’t be messing with him and she didn’t know him like that but got pregnant by him.

[@Biznessbestie]

Idk if I believe that story

[@jeannettamitchell4177]

I love JM however that dude wasn’t playing.. he was serious. He knew it and remained calm like now. He’s not fooling no one ☝️. JM gotta talk to him like a child.. smh. This gotta be a horrible joke JM please tell me this isn’t so. Sigh 😔.

[@suleykauribe8483]

Nah that wasn’t negligent he purposely did it

[@SamuelsReview]

Cuts through the box & jacket down to the white meat. What type of pressure is required?

[@wildernesswarcry4882]

That look at 7:48. Yep, nobody's buying that story. What grown man "plays" with a box cutter like that? Girl, you better run for the hills. Oh, and flee fornication (1 Cor 6:12-20).

[@barbarapaton4005]

Why didn’t he just pay the medical bill??

[@eleanormcgee1507]

Good, JM don’t know that pastor so no stories😂😂😂

[@Amber2divine]

She sound like she don’t want him. It’s all in laughter and brushing off the advances

[@maesams6212]

Any rational-minded person would know that they're responsible for the bill!

[@Ash-ol3ji]

I had this episode playing on my TV when they showed her injury. I dropped my phone and almost knocked down my computer. Why would you play with a weapon?! That's asking for someone to get hurt. 😩

[@Meme-qt1ww]

damn i hope this sista didnt rekindle nothing wit this foo... famo dangerous

[@iwishyouwould9985]

grown man with sagging pants

[@TopherGrant]

Calm down Gramps. You don't wanna have another stroke screaming about pants and shaking your cane!

[@blackpowerpuff6155]

Sorry but I don't believe story, I think he did it on purpose.

[@1Andrea]

That doesn’t sound like he was playing at all especially since she was upset that he made the joke. If he was so remorseful why didn’t he pay the bills get a second job to make sure she healed probably. And if it was really an accident why are you minimizing the injury accident or not that was kind of severe

[@bxgirl2930]

Anger issues yikes 😳😳😳😳 it's only a matter of time

[@dance4life1208]

Nah he wasn’t playing with the way that cut look

[@lilmisszoe2012]

Who plays with box cuters?? They sharp asf for real

[@everybodyhatesbri]

He definitely looks abusive af... how do u "jokingly" slice down someone's arm... like u didn't stop when it first started slicing her skin THAT DEEP??? That wound is long and DEEP AS FUCK!!!

[@KINGDOMDAUGHTER]

VET, who you coupled up with, entanglement with, play house with and having babe's kid's with. Do not loan, cosign nothing for anybody.

[@thematerialisticreview]

She'll be on the news later if she keeps excusing behaviors and overlooking red flags.

[@irwinthomas3665]

You keep thinking you can beat people up, you might not make it to old age, people with temper's don't live long.

[@t.c.5456]

He seems mean

[@ShanaeFlower]

Well 2016 came and left, we need an update 😂😂