Julia Hartley-Brewer CLASHES With Palestine Solidarity Campaign Member Over 'Jihad' Protests

TalkTV's Julia Hartley-Brewer challenges Ben Jamal from the Palestine Solidarity Campaign over whether he condemns protesters calling for 'Jihad' on UK streets.
This comes after the Metropolitan Police said “up to 100,000” took part in a pro-Palestine march in central London on Saturday, with other rallies in Cardiff, Glasgow and Birmingham.
Others protested outside the BBC’s MediaCity headquarters in Salford, Greater Manchester, over its reporting of the Israel-Hamas conflict.
Julia says: "Would you mind answering the question? I'm not asking you whether you were there."
#israel #palestine #gaza #talktv
Click here for more from TalkTV talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines

[@shanisheppard9305]

Its a crime when you get arrested for flying your own flag in your own country

[@instantkarma1229]

Thanks to idiots like the gentleman being interviewed

[@instantkarma1229]

@@amitmit502 deemed to be culturally insensitive and used by the left to cry racism

[@robertandrew5768]

​@@amitmit502Use your common sense !

[@amitmit502]

@@robertandrew5768 there is no sense in that statement. I meant why it became a problem flying your flag.

[@gail2698]

Note Always remember this pattern, 1) Conflict is always between islam vs other religions 2) Other islamic countries will not accept those affected muslims as their refugees, but they somehow sneak into non-islamic countries. (Russia, whole EU problem with refugees: France, Germany, Spain etc., India divided into 3+ countries, Iran was not an islamic state initially) 3) once they are into non-islamic countries, they create separate laws and try to break that country too.

[@Aensergio]

Israel provided, water, electricity, medical supplies, food on their own velition, israel withdrew from gaza in the 2000's, they do not HAVE to provide gaza with anything. Furthermore, israel provided between 7-10% of the water to begin with. hamas has millions of litres of fuel, they simply keep to themselves. Israel does not target and never targeted civilians. Hamas is 100% responsible.

[@joycegibbs5267]

and all the aid Palestine has been given, where's it all gone. Where's their water system they could run themselves etc....???? None of these questions are asked !!

[@abebeaku8369]

@@joycegibbs5267Water and fuel are precious to Hamas, they need it to build more tunnels and ammunition. The underground rat population needs to be eradicated. Call on Orkin Pest Control

[@frossato]

The question is what are they doing to stop people calling for jihad in their protest.

[@worldwide1856743]

Define jihad? The word means struggle from what I've researched

[@frossato]

@worldwide1856743 stop pretending to be a fool or you look like a fool.

[@davidhorton188]

@@worldwide1856743 jihad against the visible enemies is another meaning, and i think we all know what one they are using.

[@simonsayegh7535]

How about stopping the Israeli government and many Israeli politicians calling for the annihilation of Gaza? Really calling for genocide?

[@Mihaela8440]

Have you been to the protest at all? Have you heard, like Julia here, someone calling for jihad? Or justice/ struggle as I understand the word means. Even when she has never been to a human rights protest in her life she knows what is right or wrong. Why these lies and propaganda? For how long would you smear everyone who cares about every human or child’s life? Why does it sound soo bad that people want justice? WHO will have the right to defend their children lives? Their land, people and culture from the Israeli colonial interests supported by corporate Britain all the way. For how long would international law not matter if it is Israel? 😢

[@andreaseconomides6396]

The man is clarifying the international law to her but I don't think she is listening..and she is always shouting over him when he is trying to argue his point...

[@andrebeaurain3338]

Yes very clear....lol

[@davidwhittingham8617]

The guy never mentions the 7th October attack on Israeli civilians which started all this retaliation, wasn't that a crime against humanity.

[@danny.chulo.]

Oh that’s when this started? Oh ok all these history books saying it started 75 years ago by Israel must be wrong then. Thanks for the clarification

[@davidwhittingham8617]

@@danny.chulo. read what I said! started all this retaliation, that means what's happening recently not historically

[@littlecatfeet9064]

@@danny.chulo. if your history books don’t mention Jewish occupation of the land going back 3000+ years, the name Palestine being given to ancient Judea and Samaria by the Romans, the Crusades due to the many Muslim empires, the Ottoman Empire as the last of them, the Balfour Declaration, the British Mandate, the UN creation of Israel and the number of Arab (not Palestinian until the 60s) wars against Israel, the land for peace deals agreed to by Israel but not the Arabs (later Palestinians) your history book’s shite.

[@ZawieHa]

And how invasion on Gaza will help to resolve the situation? How is it helping Israel?

[@davidwhittingham8617]

@@ZawieHa And how has the 7th October attack helped the Long suffering Palestinian People.

[@josietumelty6895]

Thank god this is a minority view and most British people are disgusted and upset by the killing of any civilian

[@ssc_1]

British itself is a minority sadly

[@dslabosky]

Are you sure? I’m seriously asking because seeing what is happening in Europe from Israel it seems like he is not a minority. I hope it is only a very loud minority but it’s hard to tell from here in all the mess

[@jannyjan90]

What did he say that was bad.... That the actions of Israel that kill civilians is bad and should be called out in the same way that they call out the actions of Hamas???

[@danny.chulo.]

Most British have no idea what’s actually happening and blindly follow the narrative fed to them by their Israeli backed and corrupt politicians and journalists. Those who know, are aware and are out in protest. Simple

[@devikalambert1674]

The problem is Israel is being identified as killing civilians however he fails and so do the palastine people that jewish lives don't really matter. Israel is responding to not just the killing of Jews but the way they did it. They had no chance to move away. They were barbaric in what that did. So let's not get it twisted jews lives matter. Let's not avoid that. He brushed over that matter

[@vascobrighton1364]

Under international laws and human rights Israel have no obligation to supply anything to Gaza. Israel it is NOT the ruler of Gaza but Hamas.

[@Jezza_One]

Actually they do have an obligation under UN security council rulings to allow food and water in. The Syrian government was condemned for commiting a war crime when it used starvation against rebel held cities and towns.

[@MrTeaTwoSugars]

That is entirely untrue

[@epr11000]

@@Jezza_One Actually we are broken to supply Gaza, which was with 120K population and now it 2.4M. Ask Hamas to use worldwide financial support to make working places, power stations, medicine, etc. If you would like to support your killers, you are welcome, we are not. And Gaza has open sea and Egypt border. 50K Palestinians worked every day in Israel and these guys killed us. Including arabs and pro-palestinian activists. We are suffering from rockets attacks all the time. Who tell you that jews obligated for everybody and we must provide excuses if terrorists kill us? forget it.

[@Jezza_One]

@@epr11000 Not taking sides here just pointing out the UN security resolutions in the Syrian civil war. I cant see what Israels problem is with food and water or even medicine getting in. Its bullets and guns that win wars.

[@vascobrighton1364]

@@Jezza_One The problem it Hamas that control everything that enters Gaza. And believe me they don't care even about palestinian people,they will take whatever they want before the population get anything.

[@muhammadshahankary7228]

Julia, if you have a proof of those babies are Being beheaded, you would have a picture on your screen 24 seven showing it to everybody, but the fact that you don’t shows that you are a liar and your organization is a liar

[@RahilaAyub-w6e]

She's a nasty person who often grins at the death of innocent people

[@user-et2fj8xm5l]

They always minimize their hypocrisy and blame others..

[@boblazar1976]

Yeah, Isreali is King at that......minimalising Genocide and land theft for decades....!?! Have you seen the map....!?!

[@geraldrada]

Exactly. International Law does not forbid civilian deaths. It forbids the targeting of civilians for the sake of terrorism. Israel is not targeting civilians, it's targeting terrorists who, as usual, hide among civilians. Israel is dropping about 300-400 bombs per day (less than the amount of rockets Hamas and Hezbalah is throwing at Israel every day) and that, after 18 days of bombing, means 6300 bombs. Hamas sources (!) claim 5700 dead people, which include their operatives/terrorists and those civilians killed by the approx. 570 Hamas rockets that misfired and fell inside Gaza. That, plus the usual Arab inflation of numbers to promote their cause, means we might be talking about not more than 2000-3000 civilian casualties. That's less than one civilian casualty for every 2 Israeli bombs. That's neither genocide nor targeting civilians. By the way: he says he is not entitled to question the judgement of MET police but he takes thousands to the street to question the judgement of his government...

[@boblazar1976]

@@geraldrada I'd love to see how Brits would have taken it if Scotland annexed the whole of England because it had international mates supporting it...!?! Then bombed it for 75 years, criminalising any response as "TERRORISM".....!? How's them apples!?!

[@lucabriatore7891]

You're totally ignorant about International law

[@user-et2fj8xm5l]

@@lucabriatore7891 Last I checked, the atrocities committed in Oct are on that list as well. Also your love for law without historical context is on full display. The effect is rarely the cause. I’ll excuse your ignorance with all due respect. Whoever you may be…

[@jackshepherd93]

They keep saying people should be outraged by the targeting of civilians But that’s the issue, they are not targeting civilians That’s Hamas

[@DailyCorvid]

HAMAS are the ones who brought all those people there to begin with! They are not residents, they are from the camps in China! Yes they are Muslims but not Arabs, and certainly not Palestinian. They are there because HAMAS needs breeders and then a human shield. To free these people is to remove HAMAS as a client of Chinese human-trafficking. And the freeing of 1.2 Uighurs in China!

[@Crane251]

Not targetting civilians but managed to kill in two weeks more than 50% of civilian deaths in russia ukraine war that's been going on for almost two years. Says hamas are the ones causing destruction but all pictures of the destruction is in Gaza not in israeli cities.

[@paulsmyth3580]

When the Israeli videos of the terrorist attack is leaked' the tide will turn' the journos were crying after seeing it' even the pro Gaza ones

[@generic_handle_1]

​@@paulsmyth3580I hope you're right, but the fact that people still deny the Holocaust isn't a great indication of willingness to accept truth.

[@worldwide1856743]

A child is dying every 15 mins. You can't convince the sane world these are Hamas. This is Genocide.

[@Knowallwithmyphone]

If only one of these Palestinian supporters could just say “I really wish Hamas hadn’t done what they did on October 7th” but that will never happen

[@kavanagharchie]

It is the strangest thing, you would think in the face of the idf that pro Palestinians would unite to fight for a better state for its people, but it seems like they want Israel to die more than they want Palestine to live.

[@waynepatterson6167]

I wish Israel didn't do what they did for decades

[@amitmit502]

​@@waynepatterson6167which is? Brainwashed ignorant

[@kavanagharchie]

@@waynepatterson6167 it is true that Israeli spokespeople must say this also, the problem is no one from either side will confess their sins while condemning the others.

[@originalforgery]

all those folk would have been alive it it wasn't for Hamas - its as simple as that......@@waynepatterson6167

[@chriskhaleq8036]

She wouldn't dare to address an Israeli official that way. Thanks Dr. Barghuthi for your professional attitude and cool demeanor with her. Long live free Palestine from the mighty River to the roaring Sea.

[@alisonparker4752]

One person shouting “ jihad” is one person too many!!! Disgusting 🤢

[@balicomments]

ok bot

[@JosephB-tv7gf]

Better out than in. Their hatred is on full display for all the world to see.

[@Sarah-JaneFoster]

🙌🏼

[@Pendragon1122]

Especially in England

[@woowah32]

@@balicommentsYou’ll soon be found out.. tick tock tick tock….😉🐷🤡

[@Electriclentilman]

When your ideology sways you more than your intellect, you end up like this man .

[@Mikeey-b3o]

100 percent

[@Mikeey-b3o]

Well they do believe their prophet spoke to a ghost, split the moon in half and flew on a magical donkey 😂😂😂😂

[@aaront7077]

@@Mikeey-b3ohaha that’s correct leats not forget the angel gibriel had hundreds of wings and after that pedo Muhammad met him he went to jump off of a cliff and was stopped by his first wife khadija so who was gibriel really Satan that’s who and that’s why this cult kills innocent people the way they do evil pig swilled cowards

[@mikebeevers2416]

best comment I've seen today.

[@PeterMc141]

​@@Mikeey-b3oAnd said the world was flat 😂

[@Victoria-hz3gx]

International is NOT the issue. These actions took place in the UK. YOU are skipping around the question because you know the answer is WRONG!!

[@weallneedjustice]

This woman is not reading the news for the people. She's clearly on a mission to spread hate. She's bullying everyone who doesn't agree with her hateful agenda.

[@Peaceman324]

Lol. All oposite. Hateful agenda is of those bigots

[@salinasandhu4562]

This women is gross and heartless, terrible interviewing

[@Peaceman324]

@@salinasandhu4562 nope. Saying the truth and stoping the lies does't make her gross or heartless. On the contrary.

[@sugarkane4830]

So you mean she telling the truth and you don’t like it.

[@FerminSeferoglu]

Paid propagandist. She's on a mission to spread hate.😮

[@PA-zh9vl]

I didn't realise Hamas had signed up to International law??

[@MrTeaTwoSugars]

Oh lord, do you think Israel has?

[@stevedickson5853]

She explained in the video regarding Israels response

[@Aquines]

Amazing woman gets arrested and charged for praying in her mind , people shout and scream Jehad on a hateful demonstration and are given the green light , absolutely mind boggling pun intended watching from Dublin

[@victoria5043]

Absolutely. Same with those who marched during the pandemic. The police only arrest certain people.🤨

[@dantaninaruseb1617]

This Julia lady should undergo an urgent psychiatric evaluation for 21 days, I know mental health is real. I am concerned about her mental health. In my view, she should not be at work. I hope that her bosses will take my advice seriously.

[@ashleywebb2736]

Great point

[@davidhorton188]

@@dantaninaruseb1617 lol

[@elizabethanthony3916]

​@@dantaninaruseb1617Jamal is the one who has mental issues, and so does anyone who tries to justify the atrocities of 7th October, there is no comparison between Israel's actions and the disgusting, cowardly murderous spree committed by Hama's. Israel gave fair warning while Hama's broke the cease fire to murder unarmed civilians and children. And many foreign journalists have verified seeing the tapes of those atrocities filmed by Hama's themselves, despite Jamal's denial, he's a barefaced liar.

[@paulrichards6894]

Ben ...israel only supply 10% of the water in gaza

[@peterkeijsers489]

And yet they cut off Gaza for the full 100% of water, food, electricity and medical supplies! Gaza is controlled by Israel, an open concentration camp!

[@Celisarei]

Here is a woman who needs to do some serious self reflecting and watch her own videos so she can see who was talking over whom… how embarrassing to be doing that to someone else and then blame the other person for it. She looks like a toddler having a temper tantrum

[@skontheroad]

NOW does everyone realize why Israel can never come to terms with them at the negotiation table???

[@paulstewart4195]

What’s to negotiate. The Jews stole there land. If an American turned up at your gaff and told you he was a chosen one cos a distant cousin 20 million years ago lived where your house is and you were being evicted I have no doubt you would be philosophical about it.Gaza the biggest open air prison in the world. There will never be peace until there is justice. Free Palestine

[@stormz761]

What about the west bank PLO???

[@mojalalunia]

Yes, I agree because Israel is apartheid country, worst than South Africa and it will end badly.

[@RifromtheRa]

They are every single time. The "Palestinians" don't want to acknoledge of Jewish state or Jewish people there. Simple hate

[@fozzyisere446]

It's against international law to kill law ok !! But hamas broke this law by kidnapped 200 ad killed 1400 . Israel are really defending there country hamas broke international law first and that's a fact lol

[@micheledunn4391]

Julia, I am in awe of your patience. The man is a professional point avoider.

[@Christine-ry1qq]

He’s also ignorant on international law

[@luisfigointer]

Scumbag, in short.

[@Mikeey-b3o]

All Muslims are

[@IsraelForlife-nb7zq]

She's pure class.

[@Kaye254]

This guy is a danger to society! Anyone turning a blind eye to Hamas’s crimes, a call for Jihad or harassment on any individual is garbage and an absolute hypocrite. Just to add if the UN are getting around a billion dollars annually for Palestine aid and allowing Hamas get a large cut instead of going directly to its people then they too are garbage for allowing it! They might as well put Hamas on their payroll

[@davidsoulsby1102]

In international Law Israel has no requirement to provide water or electricity to another nation. That is Hamas's responsibility as the authority in that area. There is no indiscriminate bombing, its targeted at Hamas infrastructure. Israel is allowed to do that even if civilians are there. Its up to Hamas to either move or remove the civilians. Thats already been proven in Ukraine with Amnesty Int complaint. Israel does not control who goes in or out, Egypt does. Twisting words and facts to prove your point shows you don't have a valid point.

[@hannahchernoff6312]

Well said, thank you

[@janettedewar6617]

When will people realise that Israel really do care for Gaza citizens .

[@csansolo]

He is deflecting the questions, and giving a free pass for Hamas, I am done with it.

[@amitmit502]

What's new here? It's each and every pro Palestinian tactic

[@daveanthony2106]

She's forgetting all that is happening and only focusing on Oct 7th

[@kalsoumkhan6648]

Illogical Israel is a terrorist state Israel has and is continuing to commit war crimes Israel is currently enacting a so called “jihad” (if that’s the only way you understand it)

[@davidhorton188]

@@daveanthony2106 that is the current news though and no matter your struggle you should never result to what happened on that day.

[@Sardarji-bq6oj]

Qur’an 5:51 Oh you have believed keep not the Jews or Christians as allies for they are only allies to themselves and Allah does not guide the unjust people. Muhammad said “ There will come a time when even the rocks and trees will say “ oh Abdullha there is a Jew hiding beneath behind me, come and kill him ! Chapter one Quran QURAN TEXT: Chapter 1 - The Opening 1. In the name of God, the Gracious, the Merciful. 2. Praise be to God, Lord of the Worlds. 3. The Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. 4. Master of the Day of Judgment. 5. It is You we worship, and upon You we call for help. 6. Guide us to the straight path. 7. The path of those You have blessed, not of those against whom there is anger, nor of those who are misguided. Cursing Jews and Christians to Hellfire every morning before sunrise. I have lots more 😅

[@TA-qn4ew]

Answer the question!!!!! what should Israel do?

[@soniamolcho6689]

I guess, in his opinion, Israel should just say Thank you, come again next Saturday.

[@khusrum]

Per the argument. Hamas is a terrorist organization. If a terrorist organization has taken over a whole building with hundreds of civilians inside… would the right reaction be: bomb them? Now what if those civilians were Israeli? What if they were Palestinians? Would the reaction be the same? If your answer is different in each case… then you are either blinded by your biases… or value one civilian life over the other. And don’t say “them” or “they” caused it… because the original argument was that Hamas is a terrorist organization and by definition they terrorize civilians and use them as human shields. So shouldn’t Israel value the Palestinian civilian as much as they value the Israeli civilian? The reality is that in this context Hamas and the IDF are both conducting same acts of crime against humanity with one being an organized state terrorism while the other a militia!

[@simplesimon5739]

Why is this sympathiser even given air time. This is Britain! And now he's a specialist international lawyer. What a joke.

[@captsonko.9345]

This old man think terrorist believe in international law,he is sick.

[@balicomments]

and you’re an armchair commentator

[@terryreknaw6152]

He's given airtime to create division.

[@stormz761]

But you love this women spewing Israeli propaganda

[@duanemarshall1889]

Its war

[@crystalmontalbano9798]

I can't believe the rudeness of this woman! She is so unprofessional. Hats off to Ben Jamal, he came across as the sane, reasonable one in this exchange. It was a stupid question she was asking anyway, she needs to do more research.

[@andrewmottram1626]

That man couldn’t answer a question if his life depended upon it.

[@Gycatt]

What an incredibly patronising man… never answered a direct question, was determined to make his point at all costs…should be a politician!

[@stephendarlison8140]

terror supporters seldom do deflection is the aim of the game

[@Gycatt]

@@stephendarlison8140 I couldn’t even watch to the end of the piece. The fact that this is even a matter that is up for debate sickens me. I have always been proud of my country… but sadly these days I truly despair…

[@stephendarlison8140]

He is what is wrong here in Britain A pr!ck

[@balicomments]

okay bot

[@cr6231]

And nothing he says will stop what is about to happen

[@patbassman8251]

Shame on him ,nothing justifies the actions of Hamas on October 7th .

[@stormz761]

When did he condone that attack?

[@gabriellazar4133]

I think nothing justified Israel committed war crimes and genocide against humanity right?

[@beverley6140]

​@@stormz761He condoned it when he did not condemn it.

[@janettedewar6617]

He bypassed it. He was trying constantly to be clever by answering a question with a question. @@stormz761

[@1953bloke]

He did not justify Hamas's actions. He condemned attacks on civilians and hostage taking. How can 100 people like your comment? Are they deaf, stupid or both?

[@johnkeedwell5549]

He just agreed that targeting civilians is illegal, yet apparently, killing 1400 civilians of many nationalities is alright? And 🇮🇱 can send a missile through a window. They dont carpet bomb. To blame Israel for this is ridiculously stupid

[@Christine-ry1qq]

Where was his banner saying “Hamas. Not in our name” or Free all hostages now ??

[@ladytempest7273]

The man beats around the bush better than any slimy politician.

[@mtbsteve1]

Oh Ben! Go on answer a question please!

[@BrickBreaker21]

He beats around the bush better than Bill Clinton with an intern

[@donnastokes-manning6175]

Hamas trained him well it seems.

[@sundaynight1987]

Narcissists and marxists normally do

[@dorsol]

Such lack of honesty… I don’t ask you to agree with me or even not leaning one way or another. Just be honest and stop beating around the bush. It’s insulting, manipulative and unproductive.

[@richardnewton638]

He is avoiding the question because he will not blame hamas . For the human shield tactics.

[@richposports7030]

Are you doubting the UN and other figures re deaths/injuries? Is water and electric being cut off...no problem?!

[@themezoner1349]

Julia has a lack of basic knowledge. "there are no clear rules about hate crime" is one of her ignorant sentences. But, hey, the arrogance with no knowledge is trending in today media

[@hala8294]

tv parrot lol

[@jupiterloverful]

How someone's fighting from tunnels is using human shields?!

[@ksmdrs]

​@@jupiterloverful Its even worse if you think about it more. They attack, then escape from the tunnels (which are 🚫 for civilians), then they tell the civilians to ignore the warnings and stay and leave them to die alone.

[@armandoramirez9159]

What is the point to invite him to be interviewed and then she does not let him speak.

[@JorgeRzezak]

Very good interview, it shows Ben Jamal full support of the Hamas/ISIS brutal terrorist organization. Meanwhile he prefers to live in UK under the western standards, but justify the Jihad. Does he brings a solution to the conflict, does he wants to solve the conflict, I do not believe so, but he does show covered antisemitism.

[@1953bloke]

You thought this was a good interview?

[@JorgeRzezak]

@@1953bloke Well, Ben Jamal did not answer any question, but to not answer is an answer. Even the people that could call themselves as "intellectuals" showing books in the background are supporting terrorist organizations. No self criticism, only complains and the same political account of suffering without proposing solutions.

[@Pharadge]

or may be he is just human and decided that he should be on the right side of history when we will all one day look back and have to answer to our grandchildren where were we when all this was happening?

[@JorgeRzezak]

@@1953bloke Sure, excellent

[@JorgeRzezak]

@@Pharadge So, you are that humble person that you decides who is in the right side of the history and who is not. Maybe he is in the right side of your Story.

[@joangordoneieio]

TY Julia. I can no longer stomach them. Excusing their obscene murderous hatred. With no consequences.

[@darrensouden4]

GET THEM OUT THE COUNTRY NOW.😡😠🤬

[@marialeemckay1537]

Before they turn the fire with you.🤨

[@Blessedishisname]

Hear hear 👏

[@Welshwolf62]

who

[@Blessedishisname]

@@Welshwolf62 mobs of male migrant foreigners that come from safe countries throw their passports away and the tax payers pay 6.7 million a day for

[@jaivinpatel3317]

They’re here because of your proud British colonialism history

[@HasanAhmed-ki8yh]

When she doesn't like the answer she talks over the guest. She should not be on the air

[@DanSivyer-b4p]

He hasn’t answered the question That’s why she keeps asking it Julia is an absolute star

[@HasanAhmed-ki8yh]

​. He has. She doesn't like the answer

[@grantjamieson5874]

Not once put any blame or accountability on Hamas.

[@drrockkso8882]

Everytime this guy is asked a specific question he just repeats the phrase "international law" over and over and over again and thinks that constitutes an answer.

[@greenhammer3263]

How EVIL 😈!!!!

[@Newniche]

Because....it's the law. So, in the words of Jim Carry in Liar Liar "STOP BREAKING THE LAW A$$WHOLE"!!!

[@freebornjohn6876]

Well, Israel is in breach of international law by occupying land the UN designated for the Palestinian people. Israel is also committing war crimes right now. So, international law is important.

[@theogeorges4303]

Educate yourself and then you may know what International law actually says. How hypocritical of people and western society to be dismissing it so blatantly

[@drrockkso8882]

@@freebornjohn6876 Which international law are you referring to?

[@TA-qn4ew]

Israel does not occupy Gaza. This is a lie.

[@worldwide1856743]

True, It is besieged.

[@stevedickson5853]

​..yep ,by terrorists

[@fordcapri6288]

Of course isreal occupies gaza, in addition to this they have repeatedly land grabbed and expanded into Palestinian territories.

[@dawahnowvideos945]

Even if they left 17years ago they still have a blockade and guard the sea land and air if that’s not occupying then I don’t know what is

[@tashatsu_vachel4477]

@@dawahnowvideos945 - If the Palestinians were to stop importing vast numbers of weapons to fire into Israel then maybe the blockade could end? Tell me, why are the Palestinians not welcome in Jordan or Lebanon, or indeed any Arab country???

[@Nigelzenig]

She does not understand or want to understand his answers.

[@rosswarner8783]

Not one of them will admit Terrorist animals use innocent people as shields the basically ignore what they do it’s totally nuts

[@pommiebears]

We all know exactly what they mean by “jihad” and to try and justify it, by saying it means everything but what we know it means, is down right insulting.

[@geraldrada]

My answer to those people who claim that BS is this: in the Koran there is one chapter called "The Spoils of Jihad" where their God explains how the money and richness collected after a war should be divided by the followers...That should clear any doubts about what the meaning of Jihad is.

[@geraldrada]

Yes, and in the Koran I read, that word "war" is translated as "jihad" which is a correct translation as you well know. The word jihad, like many other thousands of words in every language, can have several meanings sharing a common feeling/idea. Jihad can mean "struggle" or "effort" and also "war" as you well know. It's quite obvious that the correct translation for that particular chapter cannot be "spoils of struggle" much less "spoils of effort", but "spoils of war". The word "cannon" comes from the Greek "normal" or "usual" and it can mean: normal, usual, rule or standard according to the context. This is to say, it's normal for words to have different meanings, which is not to say it's normal to try to give it the meaning which is more politically expedient according to your ambitions. "Jihad" means war in most cases. I don't believe Isis/Daesh was talking about meditation when they beheaded people mentioning "jihad".@@sabaaa8978

[@Keeby101]

you are actually talking complete nonsense. The literal meaning of jihad is to struggle. Research the topic for yourself instead of spouting soundbites to feed your "likes"@@geraldrada

[@buzzcut63]

Funny how against all evidence ( actual terrorsim, misoginy, homophophobia, the literal hatred of the West ) to the actual toxicity of Islam is excused. Sleight of hand, obfuscation and misdirection. The stock tactics of Islamic apologists or scholars.

[@feenambule3789]

@@geraldrada furthermore, language/words evolve with usage, which means you have to use the ACTUAL definition of the word, and not the PAST definition of the word. (and no need to say Koran is a bit outdated.)

[@gavinlevy1693]

This man has zero sympathy for those massacred in their beds.

[@alisonparker4752]

@@ghostdog4330 medication 💊 time 😂😂😂😂😂

[@DennisMerwood-xk8wp]

@@ghostdog4330 Exactly right my friend. The ignorance of these commenters is just staggering!

[@gavinlevy1693]

Do you mean massacred by Hamas who uses their own people as human shields and takes the hundred of millions of dollars of aid money to use for weapons?@@ghostdog4330

[@paulbutler7075]

​@DennisMerwood-xk8wp Another Turkey voting for Christmas 🙄

[@MarkCampbell-vi3kq]

​@@DennisMerwood-xk8wp yes exactly, that's talktv for you.

[@MogamatShabodien-zp8xx]

I think the truth is really hurting this poor lady she must be careful she might get a heart attack 😅😊

[@crystalmontalbano9798]

If only ....!

[@jimmyjohnson7027]

It's very easy to support the people of Gaza when you are three thousand miles away.

[@pgt909]

There people are being bombed though man.

[@jimmyjohnson7027]

@@pgt909 Did you assume my gender?

[@pgt909]

Yep

[@andrewburman9469]

This man surely can't believe that being condescending and evasive, is going to resonate with anyone other than the people who already think the same as him. He has no idea how to engage in debate. He is simply reading a script. It's as if he has no ability to think outside of what he's had written for him.

[@kavanagharchie]

For alot of people there is no such thing as debate, only battlegrounds for ideology. Therefore they do not engage it earnestly, the consequence of slipping up and being made a fool of isn't that you may have to re-evaluate your thinking, it's that you will have made the cause look bad but you already know it is correct.

[@mrfreeze7593]

That goes for her too…

[@janettedewar6617]

She kept trying to engage but perhaps you were watching a different interview?@@mrfreeze7593

[@jannyjan90]

@@mrfreeze7593 This .. she wasn't actually being a good interviewer or reporter when she fails to do basic research and understand the full situation.. not just the one being spouted by the western bias media

[@coma144]

She's pretty good. The bloke just won't answer the question.

[@kreyvegas1]

What the F*** was that? How did that woman get in there? No one should ever accept any invitations to that woman's show again!

[@paranoidmarty]

That guy should be ashamed. 🙏🇮🇱

[@paulrichards6894]

we all knew antisemitism was there but the atrocities of oct 7th have brought these people out of the rocks they were under

[@DailyCorvid]

They have no shame that is why they fight. They are fighting for the right to lie and steal.

[@jcr7191]

Agree

[@worldwide1856743]

For calling out crimes being committed right before our very eyes. The world is not blind

[@Endrin911]

​@@worldwide1856743 Which world? muslim one?

[@paulalloko832]

What kind of « interview » is that? She does not want a Palestinian because she think of them as less humans. She is not a responsible journalist.

[@paulalloko832]

…does not want to be aPalestinian…

[@JO-om9wd]

No questions taken by this guy... He is ridiculous.

[@mrfreeze7593]

Your all ridiculous…

[@michaelsimpson4400]

Now let me answer your question, by asking you a question lol

[@fozzyisere446]

Exactly hamas started this by kidnapped 200+ and killed 1400 . What did they think was gonna happen ? Hamas s to blame nobody else

[@bensmith5231]

Hes just ANOTHER far left Jew hating FACIST !!!! 😡

[@bensmith5231]

​@@mrfreeze7593 Who Is All ?

[@DarrenPhillips001]

You can see what we’re up against & why they behave like they do.

[@mathragovender1989]

He is clearly pro Hamas

[@jamesrobert4106]

Then I hope Mossad pay him a visit.

[@bobp3194]

you think

[@Kimllg88]

good idea@@jamesrobert4106

[@christianedwards4690]

How??? He didnt say anything close to that

[@stormz761]

Well done you goy. Keep begging your masters for treats.

[@KSchnizzle]

This should be used as a reference for all new journalists on how not to conduct an interview

[@paoloernesto2591]

It's understandable that he refuses to answer her questions: he simply cannot say the truth.

[@TheNedlin]

Really ? I think you and Julia can’t handle the truth Israel is digging its own grave by humiliating Palestinians for more than 50 years and people around the world , many of them Jewish are saying enough is enough . Israel has the right to exist but Palestine has the same right and until Palestine is free nothing will change and in the long run Israel will not be democracy but apartheid as it is right now !!!

[@theogeorges4303]

Educate yourself and then you may come to the realisation what the actual truth is if you really have any morals within you

[@greenlover4522]

BS

[@MrAbdullaalibasahi]

The truth is loud and clear. Israel is nothing but a criminal state. Fasad is broken

[@ItsNotRealLife]

People like him just keep on talking and talking over questioners and constantly interrupting and answering questions they weren't asked until they un out of time It's filibustering!

[@theworldisavampire3346]

Only purposeful LIARS would try to answer these questions tgrough a side door instead of head on.

[@MisterHampshire]

He seems to spend a great deal of time talking without actually saying anything.

[@miriamyatim8252]

This women is absolutely heartless and so disgraceful to humanity.

[@anshuaspirant1370]

First of all, someone educate this gentleman that you come to a news channel to answer the questions not to ask them.

[@davidsoulsby1102]

Before he even started his brow was screwed up and he seemed angry. He had no intention of a balanced discussion.

[@pippasessment1]

Julia was frowning throughout the whole interview...give your head a wobble.

[@martindelport8289]

People like him are always aggressive and even shout! Is what I have seen and heard.

[@paulsmyth3580]

@@pippasessment1 Because she knows she was talking to a slippery terrorist playing word games

[@pippasessment1]

Because he knows he was talking to a slippery 'journalust' playing word games.....see how it works?@@paulsmyth3580

[@beverley6140]

Don't enter into conversation with this type. They simply repeat the dogma and ideology by rote. He and his ilk are delusional and have no concept that they're seen as infidels by all who follow the Islamic faith. No amount of spineless grovelling and spouting of ideological word salad would have saved his skin should he have been enjoying himself at that music festival on October 7th. Stupid man.

[@Roughpaws_Studio]

These people NEVER answer questions, do they?

[@larryl164]

100%. Watched over 10 interviews with such people. No one answered the question. All of them use the same playbook.

[@maherali4101]

He did 😂

[@adilsamara5005]

As UN Secretary General said:” It didn’t come from vaccum”

[@jimspencer3072]

Fact they always argumentative and won't answer the questions speaks volumes

[@hecter3008]

Don't worry, Ben,they will all be coming here very soon for their free houses and free money

[@vincekerrigan8300]

And when they take over he will be living as a Dhimmi and paying the Jezhia and where wil his sympathies lie then?

[@philipwilkes2780]

This man is disgraceful!

[@captsonko.9345]

This is areal students of terrorism when a terrorist came to Britain am sure these are the guys who can harbour them this guy is dangerous to were he lives.

[@janettedewar6617]

Yeah but he is of the left (right On) and also a Palestinian.

[@bensmith5231]

Hes just another far left jew hating FACIST!!!

[@steventwine8705]

This man should be deported.

[@wajidafzal4480]

His a disgrace for telling the truth… lettuce for brains

[@saladinelghazzali177]

Julia is just a propagandist for Israel.

[@allandickman774]

This guy is an excuse maker shameful 😮 that'll be Hamas who occupied Gaza get you're facts straight😮 😮😮😮😮

[@dantaninaruseb1617]

This Julia lady should undergo an urgent psychiatric evaluation for 21 days, I know mental health is real. I am concerned about her mental health. In my view, she should not be at work. I hope that her bosses will take my advice seriously.

[@allandickman774]

@@dantaninaruseb1617 not really she was talking to an idiot 🤣🤣

[@yagambaramreddy5212]

Now I can say that this guy is in total denial.

[@eelswamp]

And not that bright.

[@beverley6140]

​@@eelswamp Thick as two short planks. As are most of his ilk.

[@wezzathegreat3827]

You are right wing!!

[@eelswamp]

@@beverley6140 Agreed. This episode in modern history is most revealing of the intellectual vacuity of the wokists.

[@joycegibbs5267]

most on the left are but look at the destruction they bring wth it !!

[@jimoconnor2594]

Pointless talking to the likes of him

[@peterkeijsers489]

You mean her?

[@CindyAnnL]

​​@@peterkeijsers489no she means him get your head straight. He is another brainwashed person who can not answer a simple question soooo typical!!!

[@io8476]

She couldn’t be anymore disrespectful!!! She should not be a journalist!!

[@iluv2b]

Julia is a broadcasting treasure, a much needed voice of common sense, but WHY are these debates needed? We are at a point where, due to the crisis in the Middle East, any inflammatory activity should be met with arrest and, if proven to be supporting terrorists, deportation.

[@alisonparker4752]

She really is , so articulate ❤

[@jim22277]

She's at the top of her game She seems to be the only presenter that will not let anyone feed her bullshit.

[@alisonparker4752]

@@jim22277 agreed 🙌👍🙌👍

[@elina33]

She's just showing how those people lack any reason, explanation and sanity

[@IronThreads8-h9p]

Except these aren't debates. TalkTV is a hugbox where you go to hide behind the legs of these bully presenters as they bash lefties and the silly people they handpick to come on.

[@alienfish8521]

The dact he avoids answering the question and makes excuses means he supports it.

[@joycegibbs5267]

of course he supports it, they all do.

[@tomdoyle6030]

They always do .. but you gotta remember this guy was under Corbyn and he has always rooted for terrorists

[@fitzgrant4404]

It seems that you support the killing of unborn babies or even the ones that have just been born.. only a beast could sleep easy knowing what is happening and supporting that type of behaviour..

[@lucabriatore7891]

He answered every question

[@kenirving5240]

Julia missed a point here. Israel only supplies 10% of Gaza’s water and not all of its electricity.

[@kriptoow]

Why should Israel supply water etc, its like asking us to give water and electricity to Dresden, Germany after bombing it

[@pamelagaull3928]

And water pipelines lifted to make rockets by Hamas. Plenty evidence of that.

[@mrfreeze7593]

She missed a lot of points, in fact she wasn’t even listening. She just did what her masters told her to do what she’s payed to say and do.all propaganda to justify mass murder

[@alanwilton6806]

Israel is not obliged to supply anything to an enemy under international law. I don’t think he knows that and Gaza has been self governing since Israel withdrew. That man is a terrorist sympathiser.

[@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci]

I don't know why they've ever supplied any, since they ended the occupation. Gaza is more than capable of providing its own water and electricity, if they would just apply their brain power and human capital to doing this rather than digging weapons-smuggling tunnels and shooting off missiles. Israel and the settlers left valuable equipment and technology behind when they left the place. What happened to it all?

[@comet6740]

Her evil grin at 6:25 when he mentions the figures of Palestinian deaths is sickening!

[@yehudakalazan1027]

She asked him again and again and he totally ignored her question, that what you respond when you don't have answers

[@1953bloke]

What he avoided was agreeing with JHB. He stated, clearly imo, that he did not support ANY attacks on civilians, ANY taking of hostages ANY collective punishment of civilians. What she wanted him to say was that his side were bad and the Israelis are good, hence justifying bombing children in refugee camps. Well they asked for it didn't they? And let's face it, they are only arabs right? It's not like the bombs are falling on our children.

[@alandagmar576]

He probably thinks females are second class citizens like his friends do?

[@mosaleem1162]

YOU CANT HANDLE THE TRUTH , FREE PALESTINE.

[@alansmith3733]

He never got the chance to answer uninterrupted. You must be the more biased than Julia

[@crystalmontalbano9798]

@@alansmith3733 only biased bigots listen to Julia.

[@elainepettis5075]

This was painful to listen to. If humans cannot empathise, there is no wonder that the World is so troubled.

[@grahamgman8706]

The world has gone mental. There is no hope for us with people like Ben Jamal.

[@DDawg-qo2yd]

He's quoting the UN and international law. What was the interviewer going off? Some random BS?

[@pamleesmith7976]

@@DDawg-qo2ydhe quotes international law. Tell Hamas to stop shooting missiles - that’s the first place to start. How can a ceasefire be considered if Hamas won’t stop shooting.

[@theogeorges4303]

The presenter is the one who needs to go and the whole western propaganda these shows are spreading. The core issue of the conflict is dismissed. The whole point of what is going on is the war crimes committed for years by Israel

[@MultiAppleworm]

He may as well strap a suicide vest and get it over with

[@masterciefl2k]

@@DDawg-qo2ydFYI Hamas is not international entity like other countries is there a seat in UN for HAMAS? Right now Israel an international entity is fighting with one hand tied behind their back with barbarian

[@soulbodyman]

This lady is crazy! How could she be a journalist??!

[@lomgale]

Well done Julia! Unfortunately, you are talking to someone who if he could not lie, would have nothing to say.

[@anthonyronan5843]

What exactly did he lie about Einstein? Crux of what he said was that killing of civilians is a war crime… for both sides

[@786Marriam]

Ignorance

[@danno2036]

He sounds like my wife, he answers a question by aasking a question. Julie and Douglas Murray tell it how it is.

[@sarzl1980]

Omg… this guy! He is insane…These people have lost their absolute minds!

[@ninaballerina2807]

They have always been mindless. Nobody in their right mind would either embrace Islam or support the Islamists.

[@adeolaosinowo2576]

No you have lost your mind… use your common sense.

[@ninaballerina2807]

@@adeolaosinowo2576 Unless you are a barbaric Islamist yourself, it is you who are utterly bereft of all common sense for sympathizing with the Islamic cause, never mind under what guise it keeps recurring.

[@AnotherJoe]

As he says “international law makes it absolutely clear that killing of civilians is outlawed“. Rightfully so. If Hamas would allow civilians to leave targeted locations by the IDF, then there would be no killing of civilians.

[@jamiewoods7733]

People like this guy need to be interviewed because all normal people would see him and his ilk for the shysters they are and might help to change the narrative about Jews being the aggressors

[@crystalmontalbano9798]

But the Jews are the aggressors....

[@peterkeijsers489]

What video have you been watching? I've seen a man trying to explain the situation to a hysterical woman (maybe she's in her menopauze?) who doesn't know how to conduct a decent interview.

[@HashtaGuitars]

he's slithering like a snake...

[@UsmanAhmed-g8c]

She is the snake !

[@rachiddekkak6299]

He speaking about international law. Which most of the commentators here don’t understand or simply don’t respect.

[@adrianmoses3420]

Jamal cannot answer the question

[@zuhairzuhairfarook9499]

Hi did,your zionist brain cant take

[@willykingston4620]

Call someone the wrong pronoun and the police will break down your door 😂😂

[@BLT-Rexx]

I don't care who you are. A politician, an organiser of marches, whoever. If you're not willing to answer questions DON'T WASTE EVERYONE'S TIME by turning up for interviews. The hosts won't let it go, they'll press you for not answering and the viewers don't appreciate it. Complete lack of awareness.

[@rb2010rb]

Well done Ben for putting Julia in her place by re-asking that question!!

[@markbelsey4003]

What this man “says”and what this man “thinks” are two completely different things 😡😡😡

[@gagacoco5577]

Well done Julia. No to Jihad anywhere.

[@jacquelinebailey3637]

Even one man, just like him, is a scary warning to the citizens of the UK. We need to start protecting ourselves, as this government is not going to.

[@ibtisamhtewek3407]

You really do ?

[@jeffkok9170]

If what this man said about the Palestinians are being ill treated and oppressed by the Israelis for countless years is true, wouldn’t we have seen the Muslim supporters going on the streets of all of the Western world to demonstrate and cause mayhem and incite violence like they are doing now?

[@kirstyduncan408]

You don't even understand who you need to he protecting yourself from. Good little goy keep hating who they want you to.

[@coldyer7795]

This government has consistently made the wrong decisions, backing America and NATO all the way. Any danger to us comes from the evil they've stirred up

[@ASSASIN7-sd5sr]

hahaha what scary about him?

[@asafweiss9674]

Had I been a Palestinian - I would’ve accepted the UN’s partition resolution back in 1947 (or any of the following propositions made by Israel at later times) and my grandchildren would have been living in peace and prosperity alongside their Jewish neighbors.

[@Lamarche62]

This man is the perfect example of disingenuity.

[@dantaninaruseb1617]

This Julia lady should undergo an urgent psychiatric evaluation for 21 days, I know mental health is real. I am concerned about her mental health. In my view, she should not be at work. I hope that her bosses will take my advice seriously.

[@pippipster6767]

@@dantaninaruseb1617 You first.

[@janettedewar6617]

If you read about him he is clearly disatisfied with his lot.

[@bensmith5231]

​@@dantaninaruseb1617What shite you chatting pal ???? Think your the one that desperately needs the help lol

[@jefflerner7526]

*disingenuousness - is what you probably mean.

[@655Louisa]

Julia is a darn fine journalist -- she's not afraid to ask the difficult questions and she holds guests accountable to respond to the questions.

[@davideddy2672]

🤣😂🤣

[@psy-op]

She asks the questions she's told to ask

[@Stxs001]

JHB is mediocre at best and virtually always has a narrative to follow. A bit like Morgan in a dress but slightly less disingenuous.

[@davidhorton188]

@@Stxs001 why do you listern to her then ? bit of an odd way of spending your time.

[@stormz761]

😂😂 you lot are lost. This is basically fox new British version. Just propaganda

[@Coopz1969]

He can dodge as many questions as he wants but Julia won't take no shite

[@pedrogonzalez2977]

She looks so foolish trying to defend Israel against this guy

[@bomberdores1]

I suppose he is living nicely in London if he wants to support them like this then he should go Palestine and stand in the streets there and shout