Julia Hartley Brewer schools Just Stop Oil activist

[@talktv]

What are the arguments for and against halting the production of fossil fuels? 🤔

[@thegrandmuftiofwakanda]

For : YEH BUT COS MUH IPCC REPORT YEH BUT COS MUH APPEAL TO AUTHORITY

[@stephenstrange4239]

Planet has been thru so many climate upheavals.wetlands bcoming deserts,ice ages etc..the climate has always changed..n if we all die then evolution will sm way to continue.these climatists are scaremongers.its just another instrument of control.its not an emergency

[@Truth_is_all_that_exists]

I'm good. You're bad I'm smart. You're stupid. I can do whatever I want to whoever I want cos I'm allowed. You can't do anything ever because you're bad. I'm better than you. End.

[@user-ug8wx5er1w]

Living.

[@tommykempo8962]

She's 17 wait till she realises that these people lie to you to make you scared so you do what they want

[@delladog]

A great example of child brainwashing

[@robjob9052]

very dull eyes.

[@Neil-Aspinall]

Like all religions

[@parajacks4]

You’ve been brainwashed to reject science. When you reject science you reject reality. When you reject reality you are truely lost.

[@Neil-Aspinall]

@@parajacks4 Agreed. Kids/activists these days follow extremist faith based ideologies that are insane and dangerous.

[@UKJ0N]

Ladies and Gentlemen this is the product of UK schooling

[@odoggow8157]

No this is the result of idiot parents giving free access to americanised Internet crap 24 7

[@dennis9387]

Freemasons

[@pizzamad3334]

It's a shame

[@paulph12002]

@@pizzamad3334 Yes, this is the result of decades of left wing being to them in the education system.

[@robertbushnell5627]

I’m sorry but you can’t say ladies and gentlemen anymore 🙄

[@markusmaximus6636]

So do they think China, India and Russia give a fuck. We’ve already sold most of our industry abroad. Deindustrialising is the end of the West.

[@James-gf9jl]

Exactly. We've kicked the ball into next door's garden, and destroyed our home industries, so we can feel good about ourselves. It's worse than pathetic.

[@Bookworm452]

17 year olds shouldn’t be scared all the time. They should be planning their weekends and having as much fun as possible. This child has been brainwashed so much I almost feel sorry for her

[@jackwatsonepic626]

When I was that age all I was thinking about was going out , like you say , somebody has brainwash her . I blame her parents . I mean fancy calling you kid xanty lol I bet she got bullied at school over that name . to me when the parents are naming their child , they should think of these things . I did and my parents did to me it's common sense . but I don't know why they call it common , because not everybody has it . and this is evidence .🤔 🇬🇧

[@johnpapworth433]

@@jackwatsonepic626 White Middle class socialist parents

[@jackwatsonepic626]

@@johnpapworth433 Yes I agree 👍🇬🇧

[@ceecee6679]

Whoever put that crap in Xanty's head needs their ass kicked.

[@garryl6594]

A child parroting exactly what she’s been told without any rational thought

[@pauladams2950]

It all started with Greta and now it’s become an epidemic of brainwashed teenagers!

[@williampotato1221]

Just like greta thunberg 🤡 🤡 🤡

[@dylanmcgowan3932]

Parodying with angst and condescension equals an annoying little twat , although we all know the education system is a massive culprit in this brain washing .

[@marcandsebe]

I wonder if she would be happy to switch off the internet and mobile phone networks to save energy, as heating and cooking is far more important. At least the group won’t be able to communicate. Or they can use pigeons 😂

[@Neil-Aspinall]

She is nothing but a cult member of a faith based religion.

[@fortuner123]

Xanty has been well brainwashed. She couldn't answer questions so she started going for the player rather than the ball. Julia was far too kind to her. After Xanty said 'what a stupid question' I'd have gone in for the kill if I'd been Julia.

[@steve10]

Two Words explain this brainwashed behavior Further Education The lecturers with bizarre ideologies are filling these children with dangerous crap , there were always lefty teachers with patches on their jackets and hemp shoes , but it now feels that dangerous ideological people are going into lecturer jobs just to spread this woke shite

[@Imw101]

JHB could have destroyed the kid. But she knew the backlash would be overwhelming.

[@rb1062]

Xanty only proved how far education has been dumbed down over the decades. When I was doing A Levels at her age, we were, very much, encouraged to read, at least, 5 different sources before arriving at an opinion. Still, her critical theory degree, she'll (no doubt) study will come in handy for her career making sandwiches at Subway.

[@mickc7388]

Julia should have really, really frightened her by saying she wouldn't be able to use her mobile phone in the future.

[@ST1GM1ST3R]

​@@rb1062 I think your inability to use proper punctuation just shows how poor the education system used to be ...

[@James-gf9jl]

"Xanty". Could be Poppy or Ada. Predictable entitled middle class activist who starts all her sentences with "so" and finishes with an upward inflection. Evidently doesn't have an original thought in her head.

[@sandersson2813]

Very true. I despise how people start sentences with "So...."

[@garryl6594]

@@sandersson2813 So do i

[@sandersson2813]

@@garryl6594 🤣🤣🤣

[@1990-t1j]

@@garryl6594 Haha! Good one.

[@saudade369]

She is such a post structuralist , indoctrinated with all the idea of subjectivity being the only truth , lived experience etc etc , that she won’t even use the constructions of the alphabet and spelling because they’re not her subjective way of spelling words and names .its schizophrenia as political philosophy . It’s why they can’t accept objective evidence , they don’t believe there is such a thing as objectivity , maybe why they will always go to the extreme , the most radical , because the average , the most seen and experienced ,understood etc is not “ subjective lived experience of themselves “ . It really is self destructive , anti social , non sense and it’s so ironic they seem to want to believe the statistics and theories of what they claim is “ consensus science ,yet reject objective evidence based proofs from what is outside this supposed consensus . It truly is tragic to hear and see the last two generstion and their , frightened , self hating , victim identity that doesn’t even accept the reality of their own form .

[@andrewburman9469]

Julia interviewing these climate children is fast becoming my go to entertainment. It feels like scripted comedy. Brilliant.🤣

[@ianwhitelaw3066]

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@DaveCorbey]

She lost me at "I'm 17 and I'm not an economist or energy expert....." This means she is completely unaware of the implications of what she wants.

[@carolflower8015]

I hope the gas and electricity doesn't get cut off in her house - shes probably looking forward to going home to her nice warm bed

[@Genghis-Khan121]

Why couldn’t she just say the truth which would be er? I don’t know what the alternative is , totally ignorant to the fact that not all the climate boffins agree and as said right from the start of all this years ago the funding for scientific climate research is all one sided in other words loads of money if your a scientist that says where gonna die and it’s us that’s the cause 😮but f…. All if you say it’s natural and oh btw look at the money making racket because of it all

[@paulcooper8929]

And what are the implications of what she's asking for?

[@bongobob7079]

@@paulcooper8929 Why don't you tell us? How about you for once in your life actually answer a question rather than always deflect and get answers from others

[@himwhoisnottobenamed5427]

17?! I’d have guessed 10.

[@philg7889]

'I'm only seventeen. I have no idea why I'm protesting'.

[@odoggow8157]

I always respond to that with then y r u talking just be quiet 😕

[@stonecoldfloors8200]

I'm protesting because all my friends are protesting and I want to be in the in-group.

[@ladyjade6446]

Yeah I don’t want to give up my car and my heat and my cell but I want someone else to do without so I feel like I have purpose lol.

[@nigeljukes9824]

I am 17 and I support the current thing

[@1990-t1j]

Why are we having to listen to another schoolchild? 'I'm not an expert,' she says. The one sensible point she makes.

[@jeddward9464]

Posh children schooling us bwwww 😆 🤣 😂

[@lozzybozzy234]

Why are we having to listen to Julia Harley Brewer then, she isn't an expert either?

[@1990-t1j]

@@lozzybozzy234 Because she has far more insight than this juvenile.

[@neneeq8533]

@@lozzybozzy234 Because Brewer is open minded... and not relying on propaganda.

[@stonecoldfloors8200]

@@lozzybozzy234 So the child wins by default ? I don't think so. Julia is there because SHE IS THE HOST... Durr... If someone claims that the world is in 'crisis' or 'we've only got x amount of years left' etc... they need to bring the evidence, not a child's ramblings. In short, send an expert. But they never seem to, do they? It's almost like they don't have any. Just idiots.

[@dunnymonster]

A stop oil activist sitting on a chair, using a mobile phone, using a webcam, all of which was made using oil products....oh the irony! 😂

[@sithvsjedi9696]

Nothing she can do about that or the past. But at least she is concerned for the future. You keep mocking a 17 year old girl. What a big person you are. 💪🏼

[@thetatcritic4236]

"Its ok when we do it"

[@stevewoolley3038]

All these very immature children thinking they know best.

[@nichan2475]

Can't we hear more about what is being done to shut these people up, rather than merely be subjected to the ramblings of children once more?

[@danw9464]

What's more concerning, what sort of parenting and education that is causing us to see a generation of self-righteous radical activists?

[@lozzybozzy234]

So you support blocking of freedom of speech? Doesn't sound like the position normally taken by TalkRadio listeners?

[@danw9464]

@@lozzybozzy234 as a Talk Radio listener, I actually agree with you 😆. But maybe the OP was more sharing his frustrations with the incessant, poorly-considered activism rather than plotting a scheme to silence them

[@lozzybozzy234]

@@danw9464 As usual, TalkRadio selects people to speak to with less confidence. Any climate scientist would wipe the floor with Julia, so understandably TalkRadio will never invite that person on. Do you think activism that causes disruption is always wrong?

[@Cynicallycynical]

@@danw9464 Don't you dare blame parents! Rights as a parent have been decimated to the point you will incur prison time for merely not validating or encouraging certain views.

[@unclem7816]

She's terrified, yet doesn't quite have the brains to realise that her terrified state might be compromising her ability to think clearly.

[@joecowhey7248]

Fear is the mind killer 😉

[@augustuscaesar5997]

@@thevoid6818 Exactly....

[@somebodyelseuk]

At 17 (1984) I was more concerned with the USSR threatening to nuke the gaff and the IRA constantly setting bombs off at random places in England.

[@TheAtheist22]

So is David Attenborough. So are many people who think straight.

[@augustuscaesar5997]

@@TheAtheist22 Climate change is a scam, the worlds climate is cyclical and has been for thousands of years! For every scientist that pushes this bollocks, there's at least 2 that disagrees...! Most of them just don't get a platform, unlike the ones who push this agenda...

[@evabee0911]

Poor Julia, you were banging on a firmly shut door there. She's where the WEF would like all people to be: brainwashed and lives in fear. This is the psychological state the population has to be kept for accepting quick, dramatic changes to their lives, routines. I wonder what it would take to make this child and her ilk to wake up?!

[@michaeljust1193]

PFIZER

[@scuteyboots]

I'm not sure a lot of them will wake up.

[@rb1062]

It's difficult to argue against an intelligent person but impossible to argue against somebody who is stupid.

[@martynashwood881]

EvaBee Half a dozen hairy arsed Russian soldiers kicking their front doors in.

[@canopus101]

Xanty has enjoyed the benefits of affordable central heating all her life. I first enjoyed this when I was 23 years old. I could go back to being cold in every room in the house bar the room that held the fire. I don't think she would tolerate her bedroom being just above freezing point in winter. My bedside glass of water would have a sheen of ice on it sometimes!

[@debby705]

Exactly, I can remember the joy of having ice formed on the inside of my bedroom windows as a child 😅

[@dominicobeng623]

Julia, you're providing good education for these folks who seem to be driven more by ideology rather than objective science. At least you're asking the questions which they should have asked for themselves in the first place.

[@MindFields_NI]

Another reason why we shouldn’t drop the voting age…

[@Tony-uq8tn]

If anything, up it to 30

[@abazely2743]

@@Tony-uq8tn certainly on topics that threaten national/world survival.

[@nickmiller76]

@@Tony-uq8tn Yes, thirty would be about right these days.

[@nolickspittle4753]

@@Tony-uq8tn Love it! Well said!

[@tanyajackson622]

This girl (and thousands like her) will be 18 when the next GE takes place. Watch out, its gonna get messy!

[@markusmaximus6636]

Let’s freeze everyone. Never mind the fertiliser we need for food. We should just starve as well. Clowns.

[@yvonnehayton6753]

Exactly. This is what she doesn't seem to understand. We lived without gas and electricity years ago. Even without coal. It was a utopia. People lived harsh lives and died young because there wasn't enough food or health care or machinery to make lives more bearable. Does she really want to go back to that because that is the choice she would be making. All to prevent Scottish people having to undo the top button of their duffel coats during a Scottish summer, to quote my favourite Leo Kearse joke.

[@carlosfandango6255]

There's good old terrified Xanty sitting in a heated room on a computer using a mobile phone. Give them up girl and don't be a hypocrite.

[@wetincornwall6882]

Her sacrifice to stop climate change was an oil based hairbrush.

[@robertwillis9988]

Yes her heating,computer and phone is powered by fairy dust

[@thecatalunya1]

@@robertwillis9988 Ha ha fairy dust fantastic..sometimes my brain hurts listening to these fools....

[@Leeds71]

It'll be paid for by her middle class parents or some 'donor' and cost a fortune thanks to this countries moronic energy policy.

[@comeonman8191]

@@robertwillis9988 Don’t be ridiculous, it’s not fairy dust….her house is heated with unicorn poo.

[@jeremyrameka1634]

Teach these kids resilience and strength

[@AC-iy1ov]

Arguing with a kid, period.😂😂😂

[@debwisey178]

How come she doesn’t realise that the mobile phone in her hand is all part of the problem. And the other daily things she can’t live without 🤦‍♀️

[@MC-nb6jx]

Oh they’ll never give up their tech… man made fabrics, in fact all the daily products they use to live such comfortable lives.. Never🤷🏻‍♂️🤷🏻‍♂️ Complete & utter hypocrites ..

[@angelahayes24]

I had wished Julia would have asked her would you like to be cold and not charge your iPhone.

[@ladyjade6446]

She doesn’t have a solution she is just parroting some lunatic.

[@rewdwarf123]

Yeah, she wouldn't like an 18th century lifestyle.

[@MC-nb6jx]

@@rewdwarf123 … We’ll I’m not stopping her (or her ilk) Martin😉😉

[@dpfghela]

Listened to this live… hats off for getting involved but scary how blinkered this young person was. And to think this is being done in schools doesn’t bode well…

[@GromDarkwater]

They indoctrinate the young because they are easy to fool. The Germans did the same in the 1930's

[@abazely2743]

Climate Madrassas

[@keepingitwild5994]

It is the third generation so far and thus the large amount of wokes who can make assumptions on a range of issues such as; what defines as a woman!

[@DAN_ZEMAN]

I thought schools taught people how to think and understand properly. How can schools be teaching critical thought when the school system and teachers display no such characteristic? They teach them all now that “we must stand with Ukraine”… Whatever the parasite media and government tell the people to think is picked up enthusiastically by the school system and pushes in the pliable children Then we see this sort of gibberish being blathered about

[@abazely2743]

@@DAN_ZEMAN Now I know who put the 'mad' in Madrassas.

[@christophermorrison8632]

"I'm not an energy expert, I'm not an economist" she says. It shows....neither is Greta Thunberg. About time we stopped giving as much weight to this lobby.

[@markbrown4955]

Well said, this is EXACTLY the issue. These kids know so little, I was ignorant at that age too, people were however sensible enough not to listen to paranoid kids in those days, they just tried to help them not fuel their fears.

[@rb1062]

I laughed at that bit, too 🤣. She showed, very clearly, she was no expert!

[@MsJackcool69]

How many times have we been told that we only have ten years to save the planet?

[@mikemontgomery2654]

Spot on!

[@mikemontgomery2654]

@@MsJackcool69 are you asking about before or after the narrative switch from “ice age” to “global warming”?

[@thegreyalien]

"FAITH" It really is a religion for them.

[@fredrikellertsen3495]

That girl totally lacked critical thinking and understanding of how today's society works.

[@hewhorocketh]

“I’m 17, I’m not an energy expert”. But still thinks no oil is the answer right this second. Clueless.

[@stopemnow6143]

My friend went to see her grandparents the other night, when she arrived she thought they’d gone out, she entered the house to find them sat in there with no heating or lights on, and in their coats! When she asked them why, they told her the couldn’t afford the bills! These are people that have worked hard all their lives and contributed to this country, it’s flipping disgusting. Net zero will never happen, it’s a money making scam!

[@CELTIC-CROSS]

its a ponzi scheme, the end is nigh, every year

[@Michael020]

Well, at least the bankers have their super cars....thats the main thing

[@keithlawton7821]

I blame her parents

[@keithlawton7821]

A slap would be in order

[@chiefstandard8mmuk591]

@@keithlawton7821 Her parents called her Xanty😂

[@davekiernan812]

OMG this is the scariest thing I have seen in a long time

[@kevinfright8195]

I really feel sorry for this young girl. We have all been politically charged up at a young age. But she is blinded by the stark reality of the energy situation. Well done to Julia for treating her so carefully in this interview.

[@rampakeshbharat1938]

Why, she has a duty and responsibility, like everyone else, to educated herself to the facts instead of blindly following a cult of lazy non-thinkers...

[@kevinmonahan7356]

I agree with you. Poor kid

[@thedave7760]

Her main issue is that she actually trusts that governments can and will fix this if only we give them more of our money so they can give it to the corporations .

[@rampakeshbharat1938]

@@thedave7760 Her main issue is she believes what she wants to believe, nothing more...

[@lindabowman2868]

When in reality it will also enter many back pockets!!!!!

[@MrRudeBert]

So sad our children are subjected to this trauma. Some parents should be ashamed of themselves!.

[@lwf3723]

I’m arguing the point on my phone, laptop, warm room and with lights! These poor children living life “terrified” of living and the future! She is listening to much to the “adults” around her! Well done Julia for great gentle approach

[@Southpaw.m]

I have sympathy for these kids who have been "terrified" by activists, this poor kid seems to be genuinely fearful

[@Neil-Aspinall]

Like all religious fanatical banter she is sure if we don't do what she says we are all going to hell!

[@Lakesider52]

And ignorant!

[@lucifer-ic9th]

It's all for attention

[@Southpaw.m]

@@Neil-Aspinall does seem to be somewhat religious culty like, plenty of other misguided groups too other than the climate crazies

[@bobsocks7575]

I agree with you, she seemed to be a nice person, but wasn’t able to discuss anything other than her views being right and others not listening to her point of view, when she was not aware of an alternative opinion herself.

[@mr.miller5041]

Xanty... Bless her. She wouldn't last 48 hours in open nature.

[@wetincornwall6882]

Rubbish, there's about 80lbs of meat on her, it'll take a couple of weeks for the critters to finish her. 😁

[@steve-manchesteruk4598]

I listened to this live on the radio and was impressed at how professional Julia Hartley-Brewer dealt with her. The caller came across as out of her depth and twice stated that she was only seventeen and didn't have the answers. She came across as insecure and neurotic. Julia gave her a pass and showed a lot of respect. Somebody is indoctrinating our youth into believing that the unattainable is achievable at a minute's notice. Such naivety shows a complete lack of social skills and awareness and probably a pampered upbringing.

[@imluvinyourmum]

When I was that age I also classed myself as an expert, or at least knew who the experts are, remember being told I have a lot to learn and now it’s funny.

[@kevinbrown3482]

My grandson is 17 and all he cares about is his next footy bet coming up 😂😂

[@markalexwhite]

I was busy playing rugby and chasing girls when I was 17! Plenty of time for this kid to grow up - and learn the facts she openly admits she doesn't know...

[@johneastwood3039]

Any question she can't answer, "Oh I'm only 17" lol.

[@MC-nb6jx]

Absolutely 👍🏻

[@MegaSting1981]

"I'm only 17"...Well shut up then.

[@oliviapiggott3690]

it just shows how messed up the government is if 17 years olds are having to fight for their future, when everyone else is ' business as usual' , and ignoring the data

[@MC-nb6jx]

@@oliviapiggott3690 .. Absolutely because the 17 year olds are not selective in any way are they?🤦🏻‍♂️🤦🏻‍♂️ I bet they won’t give up their iPads, iPhones etc to “save our future” 🤣🤣

[@oliviapiggott3690]

I think the 17 years olds are probably doing more good than you have ever done by the sounds of it. Don’t be dismissive and patronising when the younger generation are the ones who will have to deal with this mess.

[@simonj5615]

'The solutions are out there'. Good God, I had no idea it was that easy.

[@jamesmacleod671]

I know, it's a bit like waiting on a real life Superman or even God to come down and "fix things" LOL, that young lady unfortunately has been looking at too many doomsday scenarios on her mobile phone which ironically was made in a factory which used oil coal and gas to produce and deliver it.

[@davidjuliesmiththomas7983]

Not just out there but immediately available too. Why wasn't I told?

[@simonj5615]

@@davidjuliesmiththomas7983 'Oven ready' to coin a phrase.

[@andyxox4168]

As an adult I’m terrified by the fact that children and some adults are in such fear of the future be it climate change or some other supposedly existential threat …

[@Neil-Aspinall]

Religious fanatics are always terrifying.

[@davezoom2682]

When I was growing up the threat was nuclear annihilation ya know the planet hitting one million degrees in a split second !

[@Collabcreatemarketing]

It’s nothing new go back year 1250 and I bet you’ll find people that spend there life terrified of the world ending

[@daviddavidk2352]

@@davezoom2682 then there was holes in the Ozone layer, but they must have healed. History tells us there has always been extremes of climate. Every civilisation recorded floods, famine, storms etc most being caused by natural events such as volcanoes, earthquakes and the sun.

[@Imsovein]

@@davezoom2682 and the ozone layer which couldn't repair itself but did.

[@amack9702]

I was told at school when I was fifteen that because of cars, the earth was going to heat up over the next ten years so the ocean would rise by three to ten feet. Suffolk and Norfolk would be under water, Florida and the Maldives would be gone! I am now 75 and nothing has changed over that sixty years. It gets hotter or colder, wetter or drying sometimes but we called it weather.

[@desmondfrost1763]

This protester is utterly talking garbage

[@msdemena]

I loved how you spoke to her Julia, like a mother would, darling I admire your spirit but please try and think this through using the exercises I’m giving you. It’s hard to be supportive and nurturing without coming across as patronising but I think you did just that brilliantly. The British education system in universities and colleges should be ashamed of themselves. No one has taught this girl how to think, just what to think. Shameful.

[@saraandstuartshannon2160]

I am 40 years old. Climate change isn’t anything new. When I was 8, my teacher said that in 100 years, Dubrovnik and Venice would be completely under the water. This was 32 years ago, and if teacher was right, both of those towns should be 1/3 under the water, but Dubrovnik stays as it was before. Yes, Venice is sinking, because it’s build on oak planks that hold buildings…

[@gaz4276]

Hi I completely agree with you. I'm 63 and I remember when I was at secondary school being told that the Maldives Isle would be lost and under water within 10 years when I was studying geography at the time.

[@denseljosephs9500]

I was told the same that Holland and Venice would be under water I'm now 56 and they're still here !!

[@chondrinenigma]

Yep, same here. Almost 40 and I remember (as a 10-year-old) being scared to death when I first heard about Global Warming in a London Planetarium. But it hasn't happened! All the places that were supposed to be underwater by now - they're not! For God's sake, Al bloody Gore bought a beachfront villa in 2010, that was a huge red flag! And half of the 'climate science' is built on computer modelling, and we've seen how reliable that was during covid! And I was completely FOR green energy up until about 3 years ago!

[@stonemarten1400]

I’m in my mid 50s and remember being taught as a child that we would be in an Ice Age at any moment and imagining being like a caveman, all dressed up head to foot in thick furs.

[@rayfinkle8860]

When I was at school in the 90s they told us the south of England would be under water by 2020...

[@Gadgetonomy]

She's easily terrified. It's a problem with young people in general today, the snowflake generation.

[@davy2365]

It's a problem with government who keep inventing ever fantastical crises to keep the public terrified and therefore easier to control

[@raymondwilliams5661]

To right mate 👍.

[@NoelIRE]

It'll be halarious when all these climate activists are 70 years old and still alive and the planet hasn't melted and they realise there was nothing to be "terrified" of all along.

[@CupidStunt0001]

Julia, absolutely spot on as usual

[@seandelap6268]

Just let them chain themselves to buildings and leave them there they will soon end up getting bored I'm sure.

[@S1Rossco]

She used Convid as an example of how fast the government can move, yep because that worked out so well didn't it 😂😂😂😂

[@iainsnashall9969]

Not to mention it was all planned 20 yes ago....

[@rewdwarf123]

How long will be paying for that?

[@exbritishforcespatriotscha7723]

Her name says it all,can imagine what her parents are like.Bless her naivety.

[@nickmiller76]

My guess is her parents'll be 'creatives', or 'in the media', or maybe Media Studies or Drama teachers. You know, not proper jobs.

[@MegaSting1981]

Naming her xanty is probably an indication what they're like. Sad to see anyone being like this, esp someone this young.

[@minkyfran8307]

@@MegaSting1981 😂😂😂😂

[@thedubmouse]

I know the parents, and you are incorrect: they both have ‘normal’ jobs. Way to make an assumption though

[@minkyfran8307]

@@thedubmouse no normal parent would give their child such a ridiculous name, Your concept of “ normal” is obviously subjective 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@doris.from.pinner]

Imagine being lectured to by a clueless 17 year old on a subject she knows next to nothing about on live radio. My god, how far we've fallen.

[@caincotterill5493]

You are correct, your only 17. But if your old enough to try and educate others, then you deserve to be educated yourself, really really sad listening to that🇬🇧👊🏼

[@Jester-Riddle]

Her argument is I demand this and somebody else must make it happen as I am not to be held responsible for my choices ...

[@1nomadxyz]

Every time Xanty mentioned "IPCC report" I took a sip of my drink. I'm lathered now.

[@ddaybattletours]

Are you drinking shandy or vodka ?

[@Mk-cn9xw]

[@Radulph_Gunn]

😂😂

[@wetincornwall6882]

How dare Julia question the Holy Text of the IPCC!

[@violinstar5948]

At primary school in 1995 aged 11 we were told Portsmouth would be underwater in 20 years. I’m 38 now and Portsmouth is still there. Poor Xanty is a brainwashed child and hopefully oneday she may grow out of it. Xanty has anxiety which is an anagram of Xanty 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@cass6790]

This is an example of why you should get bill payers permission before allowing a child to call into television shows.

[@philiplong7390]

I love JHB and she was very kind to this young woman. I felt she dealt with this interview really respectfully. I think when they are a bit older and talking this rubbish I expect JHB to be much more robust which I am sure she will be as usual.

[@nickmiller76]

I bet her parents bring the organic lentils home in an ethically-sourced, reusable, biodegradable hessian bag though, in the Range Rover.

[@gusmlie]

Brainwashed child more like.

[@danielminor1693]

Welcome to the real world Xanty. It will be a struggle at times but try and live a long prosperous life.

[@bobmurphy9380]

I remember when I said to my mum when I was around 8 years old "mum the papers and everyone at school are saying it's the end of the world next week and I'm scared" mum replied " you don't need to be scared, it's the end of this world for thousands of people every day" that was 49 years ago! Kids all of this climate change is nonsense and is just a way to make money, that's all.

[@yvonnehayton6753]

Excellent parenting skills! Not enough of that nowadays.

[@oliviapiggott3690]

unfortunately the difference is that now the effects of climate change are blatantly obvious- a simple google will demonstrate that catastrophes already happening , particularly in the global south.

[@davidbaker6875]

The girls name says everything about her.... no idea about reality.

[@eugenekelly4638]

All hail the itcc

[@dyandavison9744]

If this young lady could only realise that at least 50 years ago, we heard all of this before. Human beings are infinitely clever at adapting and this is what we do.

[@Collabcreatemarketing]

Go even further back 500 years ago there where people who lead miserable lives out of fear of volcanoes erupting, sun not shining ect ect

[@adrazuel]

True. Fifty years ago the experts believed that we would be in an ice age now

[@terry6985]

Dyan you are so right, in the early 70s kids like Xanty were terrified into believing that by 2000 we would be living in an ice age if we didn't start behaving ourselves.....has it happened yet ???

[@beinspired1487]

When arguing with my eldest daughter and granddaughter a few months back regarding global warming. I asked them when they visited Portsmouth, England a couple of years ago if it was the Venice of Hampshire, they both looked at each other and laughed. I then told them that when it is we have a problem as I had been told in the 70s that it would be flooded by now.

[@kevinbartram5302]

Just in the U.K much more than 500 years ago This country was completely under water under a tropical sea. just check out how the rock quarries all over the country were apparently formed. Blows man made climate change out of the water. (Pun intended) unless these climate activists are claiming other scientists have faked the science. The next thing just explain how we have a reasonable standard of living in an "environmentally friendly" way without any oil at all would be good.

[@RequiemEterna]

Does this child understand how the world works? I think not

[@Neil-Aspinall]

She understands religious idealism.

[@oliviapiggott3690]

she understands the clear factual statements based off masses of data approved by over 90% of scientists who work for the UN and energy companies

[@pfauniversal1890]

Do you?

[@dvvecchio7193]

@@oliviapiggott3690 🙄

[@CrusaderSports250]

@@oliviapiggott3690 for every ipcc funded scientist pushing man made climate change there should be a funded one to put a counter argument, this would ensure theories would be "stress tested" to make sure they were as accurate as the current research can give and as unbiased as possible, unfortunately pressure groups, backed interest groups, and governments would find that to constricting and so would never let that happen,

[@annakarungari2477]

17 year olds in Africa and south America are busy trying to read and have careers in the future but not scared of climate change.

[@johnrobinson8230]

I've just discovered Talk TV and listening to these activists has made me realise that comedy is alive and well . Thank you TalkTv.

[@ashleygraham8781]

I bet this kid never complained when Mummy and Daddy were dropping her off at school in the SUV 'cos she was too idle to walk....

[@daviddavidk2352]

As a parent I am really angry that children, including mine are being fed this rhetoric. They don’t/can’t answer a question based on fact they can only repeat rhetoric. This girl was obviously being fed things to respond with, via her computer, rather than try and engage her brain. I am frightened for the future but not for the reasons she states.

[@alexmacinnes8321]

Precisely.

[@rb1062]

@@erikascheepers2375 As well as her phone 📱

[@rb1062]

Poor frightened little muppet! When Mummy turns off the heating, she's probably the first to moan!

[@watchthis12day]

Kids that can't take care of themselves think they can "save the earth" oh the arrogance!

[@joneswigan]

I remember when people used to think that the world would end in 2012.

[@JudaZuk_]

I remember when people though the world would end 2000 because "the millenium bug" would launch all the worlds nukes.. turned out it was a few gas stations that had the wrong date on a receipt etc .. that was it

[@joycegibbs5267]

the way it's gone, I wish it had !!

[@dando1898]

It amazes me that they are so frightened of the world ending. Do they not realise, if it does, we won’t know anything about it.

[@CrusaderSports250]

@@JudaZuk_ but the money that was made from it was something else.

[@Flapsupnolights]

It’s so sad a 17 years old is so scared about the future. I wish people could tell her that this climate scare mongering has been going on for years. Even when I was a teenager some 30 years ago we were all being told the planet was in crisis and the ozone layer was reducing. Turns out it’s repaired itself. Something which Experts have failed to acknowledge. Islands would be under water 30 years later I’m still waiting for all that to happen.

[@noteminemsburneraccount324]

Its ironic how somebody who admits they dont know anything apparently has the solution to everything 💀

[@unclem7816]

Xanty wants the government to invent new physics. Instantly. And doesn't think that's an unreasonable undeliverable request. Yet falls back on her being too young to do anything about it. A spoilt child who never got told NO.

[@daleskidmore1685]

Once again we are seeing a young person scared to death by bigger people. It doesn't do any good to bring kids into the argument. Back in the day oil production was pretty much entirely whale based and penguin rendering was common too. Technically they are renewable sources. Just putting it out there....

[@jamesrowlands1943]

😂 imagine telling that kid that, her brain would've melted...

[@davidbutler1622]

The fact her name is Xanty tells you everything you need to know about her parents

[@jumblestiltskin1365]

I should think this is a self gained nickname rather than her given name. However considering everything I suspect you are still right about the parents.

[@thedubmouse]

Wrong. The parents are genuinely lovely people.

[@hayleylongster4698]

Damn you beat me to it lol Either they named her this (poor kid) or they brought her up to think this was a gr00vy trendy nickname, man (poor kid)

[@davidbutler1622]

@@hayleylongster4698 I just hope she has a financial safety net from said parents

[@earlofnythe]

Love JHB, awesome woman ♀️

[@darrenporter1850]

Just a guess, she lives in London and middleclass family. I wish they would concentrate on stopping Trees and Rainforests chopped down and protecting land. We all agree on that.

[@spurge83]

I remember seeing a headline when I was around this girl's age. The headline, on the Guardian front page, predicted Siberian winters for the UK by 2022. It was by the same institutions this girl has doubtless listened to. I have since experienced a Siberian winter and several British ones. The prediction, as if I needed to tell you, was way off.

[@DW-dd4iw]

"I am not young enough to know everything." Oscar Wilde

[@colinmckay8336]

A classic!

[@ade3628]

When can we get it into their heads that we pump out very little compared to the 3 main countries, we could go zero today and it would not do a thing for the climate. All it would do is raise tax even more. These people boil my blood

[@dkvikingkd233]

The IPCC political summery is not at all the same as what climate scientists are saying in their research. Not at all!!

[@tonibaker7986]

Go xanty hopefully you still with just stop oil a privilege to actually meet you x

[@Amelia..B.B]

Bless her... As a parent of a 16 and 21 year old, I tell my kids not to trust the government or schooling systems, always ask for evidence, and think for yourself. I've got two grounded, level headed young men. This young girl has been seriously let down.

[@garyjohnson..]

the last 2yrs. tells you never trust a Government..

[@Amelia..B.B]

@@garyjohnson.. Absolutely... I'm glad I've had these examples, right in front of our eyes to show my boys how some people will lie to manipulate - '3 weeks to flatten the curve' or 'the jab is 100% safe and effective' for example. Unfortunately, most people have encouraged their children to comply instead of opening their eyes and seeing what's in front of them. This poor girl is one of them - terrified by lies.

[@l_m9494]

Imagine being 17 and thinking you know life

[@nigeljukes9824]

Has Xanty actually paid a bill in her life....get a grip

[@annvirco7308]

Isn't that the old joke ,'hire a teenager while they still know everything '😂

[@johnireland7612]

I know it's an age ago, but at 17 I was racing around the estate on a motorcycle, drinking beer on a night in the local, and trying my luck with the ladies, all fuelled by working for a living. God bless the good old days.

[@Lumibear.]

@@johnireland7612 ah, that’ll be because you weren’t a teenager with all the time in the world to sit & be loudly philosophically virtuous all day long because mummy & daddy are rich Oxford educated marxists who named you Xanti.

[@CrusaderSports250]

@@johnireland7612 golly oh gosh come and lie on the couch with a nice bit of posh from Burnham on Crouch, the late great Ian Dury, never a drinker but the motorcycle bit was fun😎.

[@Jamie-Z]

I am 17 and I do not have a clue why I am being terrified. So I want to destroy all that we have achieved.

[@ST1GM1ST3R]

Gammon central in the comment section. I think it's great to see a teenager showing this much passion and enthusiasm. She doesn't have all the answers & perhaps she doesn't handle the debate that well, but how do you think you'd fair as a teenager on national radio? Great stuff Xanty.

[@dando1898]

After ten minutes of conversation, I won’t call it debate, she finally admits what she wants. Free public transport, diesel buses and trains.

[@hyperbole6529]

This girl is 17 and understands nothing so let her pay her parents energy bill.

[@simonrichards6739]

When she was born the parents took one look and went “she’s gonna be a loony, let’s give her a stupid name”!

[@stephenirons1892]

Hahahahaha Hahahahaha

[@reesnoble955]

These spoilt,ignorant,self loving children should be seen and not heard. They always have to start a sentence with “so”,as if to sound important. She does state that she is not an expert and that is the problem. Who ever brain washed her did a fantastic job,and should be imprisoned for child abuse.

[@oliviapiggott3690]

Oh get a grip and grow up

[@tonibaker7986]

For the future generations!!

[@chomskyhitchens]

What a beautifully curated discussion

[@deco2132]

I left my car running and revved it numerous times after watching this - thanks for the motivation.

[@MrMarmalizer]

Firstly, she’s a girl, secondly, she’s been utterly brainwashed. This is incredibly sad.

[@lawsonspedding6136]

I’m amazed how our children are affected and believe in the IPCC agendas !

[@rcampbell4391]

Wait, you’re telling me the IPCC aren’t completely impartial?

[@Ngozika-ye9nq]

@@rcampbell4391 some youngsters here may take you at face value and think you are shocked someone doesn't "believe" or have "faith" in IPCC. With all the KZbin documentaries exposing the hidden evil agendas of these international bodies e.g. IPCC, WHO UN, IMF, WEF, etc., I am disheartened to learn that most of our youngsters seem not to have watched said videos. In our weak old age, how can we start all over again to WAKE UP this deluded set of humans? I give up, after all, it's now their world.

[@SirReginaldBlomfield1234]

That young lad is well brainwashed.