Julia Hartley-Brewer Ties Labour MP Into Knots Over Gender Bill

Sir Keir Starmer will promise to halve levels of violence against women and girls within a decade if Labour takes office.
TalkTV’s Julia Hartley-Brewer challenges Shadow Justice Minister Ellie Reeves over Scottish Labour’s support for Nicola Sturgeon’s gender bill.
“You cannot come on my show and talk about how Labour want to tackle violence against women and then refer to a double rapist as 'she'!”
#talktv #talkradio

[@talktv]

Would you trust a Labour government to fulfil its promises?

[@twisteddancer7773]

Definitely not

[@oldfella3919]

Trust a Labour government???? You're having a laugh surely.

[@imbonkers3629]

Wouldn’t trust the anti British party as far as I could throw them 🙈

[@jenniferparry8709]

No. We have seen the results of Labour in Government.

[@francescostello1377]

Really, both parties are two cheeks of the same backside fgs, both Neo Liberal WEF Globalists, owned lock stock and barrel. We have a one party political system with two names, that are destroying this country for Globalists.

[@mre7550]

Starmer hopes to tackle violence against women, as soon as he can figure out what a woman is.

[@denisecrawford2425]

In the meantime, men are allowed in women's spaces as long as they say they are a woman.

[@errin-mp1zy]

Exactly ...so really....he is going to tackle violence against men who dress as women

[@evaeden5820]

@Errin Yes this is exactly what he intends to do it’s so TRANSparent. Starmer = Saville & Rochdale.He must be kept out!!

[@martinwallace7182]

😂👍

[@mikipiediaelburro7588]

This man cannot be trusted on anything...a slippery lawyer who has absolutely no principles

[@littlemascara6385]

I've always supported Labour. Now they're just an embarrassment. They lost so many women supporters over this gender trend.

[@GingerGeorge-iy2ui]

There are alternatives to both Labour and the Tories, they are now both the same party who have no interest in us!

[@jimmorrison5493]

Labour will die on this hill

[@sudenims5235]

@@GingerGeorge-iy2ui at least sunak has said what a woman is.

[@handyjayes1]

Same as the conservatives. The UK deserves so much better

[@SensibleMoniker]

Lightweight and Woke - God save us

[@Anita1984isuponus]

He, he he. You cannot come on my show and refer to a rapist as she. Julia, love you for this. The gaslighting from newsreaders doing exactly this has disturbed my brain last few years every time I hear a man referred to as she. Thank you good lady xx

[@maggieegan5258]

Font they know women dont have a penis to rape anyone

[@mirrage42]

Wow. As a US citizen I had never heard of Ms Hartley-Brewer. This popped up in my feed due to my support of Kellie Keen. The bit in this where she insists a rapist be called he is impressive. This is the strong push back we need to stem this horrifying tide of female erasure.

[@stuartparkinson8168]

Unfortunately she's few and far between, the vast majority of British media are bed wetting lefties who are so politically correct, they support this trans madness.

[@haret0n]

totally agree. i am in new zealand and wish we had journalism like this here. julia is brilliant.

[@marcia5939]

If this is Labour's shadow Justice Secretary then God help the justice system.

[@Paul-pf6rm]

Exactly. Plus there's Starmer, in his 50's and still can't tell you what a woman is. 🤣 And don't get me started on the "Ginger Growler" Rayner....!

[@ascari6790]

All the neurones are firing but not necessarily in the right order.

[@drunkinclam100]

Starmer made a mess of justice 20 years ago as DOP

[@normankennith7919]

let boys be girls & girls be boys!

[@hittitecharioteer]

@@ascari6790 😂 comment of the day 👏🏻.

[@alexispaterson814]

Labour has lost my vote for. 1,Keir doesn't know what a woman is. 2 They backed The Scottish GRB against the safety of girls and women

[@barneyrubble8590]

Starmer bent his knee in support of BLM too😬

[@1blokefor1cloak31]

How exactly does the GR bill put women and girls in danger?? 😂 have you even read the bill??

[@lindseyspence3140]

​@@1blokefor1cloak31 have you

[@lavienestpasunlongfleuvetr2559]

He knows what a woman is, just like every other person on the planet. He's simply too crafty and cowardly to say.

[@hittitecharioteer]

@@barneyrubble8590 Got a bit close to "the ginger growler" doing it 🤢.

[@LondonSteveLee]

People didn't "make sacrifices" - they were illegally put under house arrest (which was supported by the entire political elite) - the two things are very different.

[@JaEDLanc]

She makes Dianne Abbot look coherent.

[@chrisjones7236]

Almost

[@jpeiper314]

About right, which is an absolutely shocking thought. God help us!!

[@JaEDLanc]

@D T Day 😂

[@poxeh]

I’m concerned about the people who have voted this insane woman to stand for them!

[@bruce8359]

god help us if labour get in

[@angelapetrie2418]

She's just dim, dim, dim! What a complete embarrassment!

[@davidgraham8058]

It’s the same old ideological talking points coming out of her mouth. Unbelievable

[@jerrywaterfalls5865]

You probably voted for Boris Johnson 😂😂😂

[@joycegibbs5267]

@@bruce8359 not even he can help us then !!

[@lespritchard2870]

Good God, who on earth could vote for this person to represent them?

[@robertadams1054]

She is reading from an Auto Cue.

[@Julian-ux5ke]

@@robertadams1054 Which Dianne Abbott is holding back to front..

[@uniquevideosUk]

She's so bad int she & a shadow of justice aswell.

[@alanfrost4661]

Not just this person the whole party

[@barriekinnaird5856]

Another thick as mince politician.

[@fasteddie8980]

they're "on the side of working people" 😂😂😂😂😂

[@rocketwarsletsplay1437]

As a Tory the tories gave let me down and wasted the vote we gave them but labour are still much much worse. I am a voter that has no where to go other than reform

[@esclad]

I seem to remember Labour calling for harder and longer lockdowns... People in glass houses shouldn't throw stones.

[@wundurra24]

BS Labour called for earlier, therefore shorter lockdowns.

[@1blokefor1cloak31]

You’re a fool mate if we lockdowned sooner which is what Labour wanted and had actually locked down properly - the borders were open the entire time- then lockdown would have been shorter, why is this so hard for you lot to understand?? 😂

[@bobsocks7575]

They did, but obviously will deny that now

[@jamescollins-ci6hg]

Labour, Conservative, Liberal Democrats are all cut from tha same cloth, they are bred to follow bullshit rules and laws, to pretend we have a democracy, but whoever gets in, we all still skint, we all still pay every penny we earn back to these muppets to start wars etc, and they all fuck tha NHS up tha ass, and blame tha other. British politics is dead and a waste of ya time voting.😵‍💫

[@limpethead]

They think we are thick. Labour loved sticking the thumb on the head of all!.

[@BassplayerPaul]

How did someone like her get elected as an MP? She is shockingly inept as she stumbles and stammers her way through this interview. "Labour has a policy to protect women and girls" "What is a woman?" "Oh, erm...er...well, um, er...well, we've got a policy..."

[@lukejames5184]

WEF World Economic Forum

[@crawford1083]

And a shadow minister! Utterly brainless t@rt!

[@hittitecharioteer]

Have her constituents no self-respect?

[@unnamed3932]

LoL--spot on.

[@john8443]

Her or him?

[@pauljames970]

Go Julia !!! You had her by the throat !! Great interview !!!!

[@simonwhitworth4688]

This women just ranted with no real answers, well done Julia for calling out 😮

[@Milburt]

I agree, but please learn how to spell ‘woman’, it’s ridiculous how many people can’t spell a simple word. “Women” is plural.

[@maggieegan5258]

​@@Milburt haven't you heard of just a mistake.i have tremors and have to go over and over what I type because of people like you. It's not kind clever or necessary. Its just picky.dont be that person. ❤

[@williambolton4698]

Why did Julia let her off the hook over their transgender madness? They need to be forced to address this.

[@errin-mp1zy]

I think it was because Julie couldn't cope with 10 minutes of her continuous stuttering.

[@saintapathy]

No need to hang her when she's supplying her own rope?

[@Anita1984isuponus]

She was about to spontaneously combust and Julia didn't want to be blamed for her demise

[@grahammitchell5444]

Madness? The only thing that's 'mad' is NOT letting grown men....er...truns wimmin compete against primary school females! Bi**ts! (TRUNS: Truns Radical Unhinged Nutters, so there!)

[@MrDunkycraig]

If shes a labour shadow minister god helps us. She makes bojo seem coherent

[@grahammitchell5444]

Bojo's got an 'out'; if convicted and sentenced, he's going to come out as 'truns' and get himself a cushy number in a wimmin's prison.

[@gordoncoles1204]

Anyone remember the tweet from Labour MP Naz Shar ? I quote . “ will the victims of groom gangs keep there mouth shut in the name of diversity “. She is still an MP today .

[@a.hoctavius5848]

Everyone in the Labour party has the worst voice. Absolutely grating

[@1blokefor1cloak31]

That’s mental illness mate sorry

[@thelimey351]

She wouldn’t answer the Trans Woman question - she literally ignored it & repeated her answer on a different subject !

[@evesapple]

If they truly cared about getting the tories out they would stop with this idiotic madness. The bare minimum I ask is for you to stand up for material reality- if u refuse to do that, why would I or anyone sane vote for you?

[@thelimey351]

@@evesapple They won't stop because Labour has a very large section of its party that literally *IS* idiotic.

[@stone33]

Surprised some people did vote for this MP . She clearly is confused on her own words

[@BazColne]

What a great job Hartley-Brewer does.

[@norwoodboy6048]

This is what labour will bring to you folks.

[@jujutrini8412]

Tougher minimum sentences for rape , a domestic abuse register, specialist domestic abuse call handlers, specialist rape and sexual abuse units in every police station and rape courts to stop victims having to wait years and years for any sort of justice. Why would anyone object to all this?

[@rangers7259]

The mere thought of these clowns 🤡 running the Country anytime soon is truly terrifying…🙄

[@judysimmance657]

She still didn't make sense. She said Isla Bryson should not be allowed in a woman's prison, then keeps refering to him as her !?

[@grahammaund7405]

Brilliant interview. Julia Hartley brewer is one of the best in the business.

[@robertstaveley9418]

As much I would struggle to vote Conservative right now, I just can't vote labour when they can't even say what a woman is!

[@golden.lights.twinkle2329]

Most conservatives can't say that either.

[@robertstaveley9418]

@@golden.lights.twinkle2329 Which ones?

[@halloweenville1]

The parties don't exist, they are just smoke and mirrors, lol.

[@lynbob1872]

Reform

[@ohwellwhateverr]

Vote Reform

[@twisteddancer7773]

Politics in this country is well and truly broken

[@nick1065]

I almost felt sorry for this Labour MP here. So out of her depth.

[@twisteddancer7773]

​@@nick1065 James o Brexit would probably give her a hug

[@nick1065]

@@twisteddancer7773 And there’s the difference between the hosts. Love her or loathe her, JHB invites a politically wide spectrum of guests onto her show. O’Brussels on the other hand doesn’t….anyone would think that he doesn’t want his ideas and opinions tested or debated by an opposing perspective. Echo chamber doesn’t do it justice.

[@uniquevideosUk]

​@@twisteddancer7773 spot on 😂

[@barneyrubble8590]

@@twisteddancer7773 🤮he’s vile..

[@mickyday2008]

It’s frightening that this woman will be in power soon

[@bobbyuk5866]

"The MPs on the committee are highly respected" 😂😂😂😂

[@philg7889]

Labour MPs making assumptions about what the public might think is precisely the problem with Labour.

[@philg7889]

'D'you think it's getting worse, or is it getting worse?' Well done Julia. Facts not feelings.

[@joycegibbs5267]

not anymore !!

[@jujutrini8412]

The number of reports of domestic abuse has doubled. She answered that particular question adequately.

[@jacquelinetaylor8683]

Selective memory syndrome here. I remember Kier Starmer being photographed at a meeting eating and drinking. His deputy leader Angela rayner Jr denied she had been there when she was. The phrase glass houses comes to mind.

[@willingcube5713]

it was a work meeting which was allowed under the rules.

[@GingerGeorge-iy2ui]

If people think the tax burden will come down under Liebour, they are in for a nasty surprise.

[@PK-in6up]

She's one of those with power who happily punished people with lockdowns while claiming it was to keep them safe.

[@Anita1984isuponus]

Julia's face when she said that! Priceless.

[@bruce8359]

who this fool ??????

[@Nick-nk8to]

I was embarrassed just listening to her. She could hardly string a sentence together.

[@mikehopkins4040]

Well she is a Labour MP.😂.

[@MrJevman]

“The rules kept people safe” Kept them controlled more like.

[@colsand]

Nice one Julia! Keep up the good work.

[@maggiemay6625]

The Brewer is fantastic always the voice of reason 👏👏👏👏❤️

[@paulhebblethwaite7168]

"Keeping people safe"? Being arrested for drinking a cup of coffee, alone in a park or being an 80 year old lady holding a placard. Yeah. Right. And still there are those out there driving alone in their cars wearing a mask.

[@snelgrave101]

👍 just watch any auditor video, you will see between 2-10 cops appearing for a guy with a camera standing on a public right of way, but see 0 appearing for violent crime and their the next best equipped to the army, hurt someones feelings and they will also appear team handed.

[@markmiller6402]

I lost brain cells just listening to her. Well done Julia

[@jokester5812]

Well done julia, well done.

[@ruthodonnell2350]

Bloody Elle is talking BS

[@pauljames2050]

Yet again someone who supports the 'weird side' avoids the issue rather than argue for it.., which proves what we all know..., they're lying. Yet another win for Julia., unbeaten.

[@robertcapewell2788]

Vote them all OUT.

[@chillijoe8264]

people walked into a voting booth and thought this is the person i want to represent me.. just let that sink in....!

[@rumoursofwar4624]

This is why as bad as the tories get, large numbers of working people are nervous of voting in labour as many of them come across like they couldn’t achieve a leadership role in a normal corporate.

[@Mark_Dyer1]

Well done Julia! What a load of inconsequential guff!

[@theknowerandtheknown]

This two party system needs to end asap

[@denisehay8895]

well done Julia.

[@seantaylor861]

Much respect to Julia.

[@anthonybartlett6924]

the rules kept people safe, funny how all the medical evidence says the exact opposite.

[@hooverbaglegs]

What evidence? Not saying you're wrong...just curious

[@lyndamyles8354]

@@hooverbaglegs you should watch and follow Dr. John Campbell

[@anthonybartlett6924]

@@hooverbaglegs the latest peer reviewed medical paper released 2 weeks ago & discussed on dr john campbells u tube channel stated masks make little to no use in combatting the transmission of an air borne virus, that now makes 8 since 1922 who have all come to the same conclusion. lockdowns only work until you release everybody then it lets rip. you need to jab eight hundred thousand people in the most vunnerable group to stop 1 hospital admission & the amount who need to be jabbed to stop one climbs rapidly the lower the age group. the rate of side effects is one in eight hundred thousand so even for those most @ risk it's 50/50 as to whether you get hospitalised with the lurgy or side effects from the jab. dr john campbell does an in depth study of all the latest released medical evidence with no bias that i can see. hope this helps

[@sandersson2813]

​@@hooverbaglegs For a start the wearing of masks was proven to give no tangible benefits. Children were largely not affected by covid and as such schools did not need to be closed. Thirdly it was shown that having the vaccine did nothing for the transmission of covid meaning that those who young and healthy did not need the vaccine.

[@golden.lights.twinkle2329]

They were thought to at the time. Now we know different.

[@theangrygamer1008]

Imagine her in government 🤪

[@paulredhead8603]

I'd rather not.

[@joycegibbs5267]

not long now, terrifyingly.

[@anthonymichaeldurkin6244]

lets not

[@moose6676]

I would never trust the Labour Party 🤢👎🏻👎🏻

[@peterloxham502]

My god and this is the opposition this country is going to get!

[@MrLachlan09]

Back in 1960s we still had politicians who had been in wars, been barristers, businessmen. Now we have career politicians who do a politics degree and go straight into politics. And this is what you get a stumbling, inept individual like this who's only recourse is to antagonistic responses. "The there, there, there, we are really clear" God help us.

[@PamelaD963]

Mostly woman as well. Not good.

[@willingcube5713]

You do realise this MP was a barrister before she became an MP...So you can't call her a career politician who went straight into politics. She was a barrister before...just like those mps you talk about from the 60s

[@MrLachlan09]

@@willingcube5713 she is the exception rather than the rule

[@willingcube5713]

@@MrLachlan09 most MPs had jobs before becoming MPs.

[@harryrobertson3746]

If I remember correctly I saw videos of both Starmer and Drakeford dancing with close groups of people during lockdown.

[@bobsocks7575]

They would have been work meetings 😉

[@PamelaD963]

They knew it was all FAKE that’s why .

[@eddiesillence9690]

Also, Stephen Kinnock attending his father's birthday party, and Tahir Ali "attending a funeral along with a large group"! Labour are in no position to claim the moral high ground.

[@caeserromero3013]

One thing the public won't forget is how much pressure the media put on BoJo to make those 'Decisions', especially when it looked like he wasn't going to make them. I remember him saying it would be 'unthinkable' to cancel Christmas. At which point the media exploded and mounted enormous pressure until he reversed the decision. So when people like this woman talk about the 'huge sacrifices' people made, we also remember it was people like her who ensured they had to be made. To quote from the movie The Outlaw Josey Wales:"Don't piss down my back and tell me it's raining,"

[@maggieegan5258]

The trouble with women in charge ,just shout over everyone so you never hear anything good or bad.just fish wives

[@spector969]

It's like talking to Simple Jack, she just doesn't get it! She's clearly taking the position that Isla Bryson is a woman, yet she wants to place Isla in a men's prison? Don't Labour understand how completely idiotic they sound with this nonsense? It's honestly mind boggling...

[@markwhitbread7383]

How can Starmer reduce crime against women when he can’t even say what a woman is?

[@bobp3194]

never as long as labour is in existence we are doomed while captain hindsight is in labour

[@danielshagman]

"It was about keeping people safe" lol That worked well then.

[@g.p616]

JHB, with basic questions of accountability is able to demolish this woman! …… pitiful

[@neils4886]

Lots of media coverage about splits in the Conservative Party, BUT very little about the fact that the Labour Party is split from top to bottom. Viewing the left wing/ socialist KZbin channels etc. it is really eye opening as to how many Labour MP’s, members, and supporters absolutely detest Starmer, his close colleagues and their policies.

[@joycegibbs5267]

trouble is, they're even more extreme than he is. We are in a very bad way with these extremists taking over !

[@jameskennethflynn]

Tbf that's usually the conditions that lead to them winning...look at Blair for eg.

[@brianstubberfield2116]

Sacrifice yeah. Starmers in Durham labour HQ eating sandwiches and drinking beer was following the rules .. really ?

[@robertadams1054]

What about the Curry.

[@elaineneilhutchinson8240]

And he couldn’t remember whether his deputy - Angela Rayner was there or not! Doesn’t say much for his memory and he wants to be PM.

[@joeljamie9266]

If you keep promoting people based on identity you'll get more performances such as this.

[@JamesCartist]

the people made Huge sacrifices while all the politicians carried on as they pleased, these people are not interested in representing the people, they just want power and money. the whole "what is a woman" debate should be the death knell for the politicians, if you cannot define something how can you protect it? insanity.

[@michaelbell6916]

Absolutely ripped to pieces well done Julia

[@ivanwilmore7469]

Boris facing this somewhat biased court is a bit like a Spurs manager being in court with the whole jury being avid Arsenal fans 🤣

[@joycegibbs5267]

I despise the Tories and Boris but this is definately a stitch up.

[@johnburnett3942]

Great interview, I believe that the labour minister needs to find a new job.

[@KW-ws3vl]

Julia YES well said.

[@searan5130]

I remember seeing pictures of Keir Starmer and his staff drinking alcohol and eating at a gathering....was this not a party?

[@maggieegan5258]

No one says anything about his wrong doings.he is a sir after all.i would like to know how the hell he got that.smarmy rat

[@lindayoung1152]

There must have been thousands like me who completely ignored the rules, my grandson was told he couldn’t come to see me because he would kill me, what a way to treat children I told my daughter to bring him over.

[@chrisblyth6716]

Why is it when a politician is asked a question they start off replying with waffle waffle followed by blah blah. The country is looking for those with maturity, a sound mind, impeccable wisdom, accountability and beyond reproach. Not a playground with tit for that mentality. It grinds the country down and we're fed up with it.

[@stephenswindells9999]

Labour wanted the rules to be stricter!!

[@ianpurcell4445]

No evidence on keeping people safe

[@OpCrownVet1]

Rabbit in the headlights, hasn't got a clue!

[@azzajames7661]

Oh, if liebour gets in the UK, it is doomed🤯

[@luckyrobp]

Julia should have pressed her harder to reply to her questions not ignore them.

[@juanajimenez7631]

Well done Julia, I really love your programme. You are so fair to your guests. Ellie Reeves is very difficult to listen to with her stuttering poor thing. However, she does not give me any hope that Labour will make a better job of governing our wonderful Great Britain. I don't trust the Conservatives or Labour. Heaven help us!!!! What's the future going to be like!!!!!

[@sammic7492]

The future is shaping up to be an amalgamation of Orwell and Huxley, God help us.

[@1blokefor1cloak31]

Fair😂😂 she has no idea what’s she talking about and just throws sound bites at people and is completely deaf to any form of nuance, just look at her interview with that bloke from amnesty, embarrassing

[@joycegibbs5267]

it's going to be horrendous and be an even more scary place to live. Nobody is fighting for normal, common sense anymore.

[@PamelaD963]

Love how she explains what 1% of people means . “That means for every hundred people only one is convicted “ These people are idiots .

[@petercaswell52]

If these fools get in we're finished! 😡🤬

[@alisonstuart2784]

The lockdowns have been widely discredited. Keep up love.

[@nick1065]

She needs to go on James O’Brussels show….though I think even he would struggle to find her credible.

[@garyhope3731]

😂😂

[@davidtaylor4039]

Yeah but, no but.... umm.... arrgh... er......umm. Oh my Godfather! No wonder this country is in a mess with people like this in politics and Parliament.

[@michaeljust1193]

Yes I kept myself and my family safe by not following the "rules "

[@albion1953]

Well done Julia

[@maggiemay6625]

we did what we was orderd to do not what we thought was the right thing to do massive differences there lady 🇬🇧

[@conservativeview7233]

Who was the Attorney General when grooming gangs were swept under the carpet? Uh, uhhh oh yes, it was Keir Starmer

[@pablocortando1]

Alleged crimes,all must be investigated thoroughly first.

[@christinewilkinson2424]

I watched the interview this morning that MP was awful, couldn't string a sentence together that made any sense. I think Julia let her off lightly at the end though.

[@cerealkiller4248]

Well, she talked for 10 minutes and I’m still none the wiser what Labour will do……………….?

[@barneyrubble8590]

Apart from thinking the trans rapist is a woman 🙄

[@frankbrennan1619]

What on earth is she talking about with her drivel of ''highly respected committee'' & ''highly respected MPs'' when the facts are only ever these are grubby, little, fifth rate, career politicians whose noses are permanently in the trough....

[@fictionalme]

Too bloody right 'HE!' Well done Julia.

[@outpost31737]

I didn't follow the rules, they were not rules or laws they were mostly guidance. I didn't wear a mask or socially distance and I certainly did not take part in the arm intervention.

[@ajax201000]

Congrats, she followed terrible rules, that just makes her a mug and Boris a corrupt mug. She also does think that Adam Graham shoulld be in a women's prison but is still calling him "Isla Bryson"

[@gerardhampson9089]

I just could not put any trust in the Labour party , i have voted Labour all my life ,but never again I can not put any confidence in kier Starmer whatsoever.

[@natsohigh5552]

More "ugh" and "erms" out of her than a footballer.