Just Got My Tudor Back From Repair

[@mpicanza4491]

I think your take on this Peter is balanced, grounded and spot on. Manufacturing is never 100% perfect for any brand. The brands/retailers response to your problem, tells you more about your purchase decision than the product itself. It’s a lovely timepiece and keeping it because you love it, is all that matters.

[@AshYoung8]

Love this piece. I got one for my wedding day and took it with on my honeymoon. It took her Snorkeling, zip lining, cliff jumping, sailing and it never skipped a beat! Running about plus 2 seconds a week.

[@chriszivoder2650]

I've taken my Tudor in the sea multiple times and it's still perfect. Now I've had it for a while, I've definitely bonded with it and would never sell it.

[@Will67267]

I had mine for 2 years. Great watch , wore it everyday with no problems.

[@MrNickMulgrave]

I have dealt with Brett at the Tudor AD on Collins Street and he not only provides exceptional customer service but is also extremely knowledgeable about all types of watches.

[@Lowdowndog]

My Dad being a retired insurance salesman always used to say to me that you never know how good your insurance is until you need to use it, the cheapest ain’t always necessarily the best. Life is never perfect and when things go wrong it’s how things are sorted out and your experience that will skew your views either to the positive or negative. As a few others have said the AD/brand response to the problem says it all really. Personally I have both the BB58 blue and Ranger and I couldn’t be more happier with them. No problems or issues (so far) and would happily have another Tudor if something took my fancy.

[@jackiemoon_lms]

Being in insurance myself, I use that phrase all the time. Spot on with insurance and any other brand delivering a good or service.

[@midnight71_DRVR]

Absolutely glad to see it fixed! Good to see that the customer service was nice and friendly! Now the Tudor is perfect and I love the way it looks! Nice video Peter!

[@jjjfffppp]

It's an incredible watch . Glad they took care of it !

[@Ninakoklahombi]

Nothing if perfect. I personally love the two Tudor’s I have had. I hope to own one again.

[@richardman28]

I have brought 7 modern Tudors in the last few years. I have not had any problems with any of them. I have this particular model in navy. They are all well made and all at a brilliant price point. I am not selling any of them...

[@doug2078]

Im glad you're keeping it Peter. !! Enjoy it !!

[@PeterKotsa]

Absolutely

[@ReuvenMatalon]

So happy you kept it Peter, its a stunning watch! I love my Tudor BB 925 its a keeper!

[@PeterKotsa]

Yours will patina beautifully over time 🔥

[@simonwright6882]

Great to hear the customer service was a good experience. I have the black and guilt and for me it's a life keeper. Great watches. 👍

[@watchmunch3240]

Definitely a keeper. At first I didn’t liked the BB58 blue. Now I think this watch is gorgeous 👍

[@Chris-mm5gi]

Glad to hear you had a good AD experience. I had to send a BB Steel in for service after owning it a few months as it was running slow. My AD took great care of me and Tudor had the watch back running within spec in about 8 weeks (with a trip back to Switzerland). Enjoy yours in good health!!!

[@davidlloydjones752]

Always good to hear these things.

[@kevinmccalister8197]

about a month ago i noticed my GS SBGR251 starting losing close to a minute a day. When i looked at it closely, i noticed rust on the hour and minute hands and on the hour markers. Needless to say i was really disappointed. I've only had this watch for less than 2 years. Great service from my AD, watch was still on warranty and it was sent back.

[@barryvercueil2346]

Awesome to hear you had good service at the AD. Cheers.

[@christianc2767]

I am glad you receive your watch back. I really enjoy my tudor bb58 blue. I bought the strap you suggested onthe last video and I really enjoy it. Although people will call a watch trash. There is a saying another man's trash is another man's treasure. I hope you treasure your watch.

[@Darr1071]

Beautiful piece

[@flemmingsorensen5470]

Stunning looks + great support = its a keeper 👍

[@PeterKotsa]

Couldn't agree more!

[@Roberto68n]

Excellent decision!! Enjoy your beautiful watch!

[@PeterKotsa]

Thank you! Will do Robert, cheers

[@dogsarebetterproductions]

Bought my first Tudor from there and Brett and Logan were professional and enthusiasts.

[@dogsarebetterproductions]

Been wanting this bb58 for awhile now. Have to save. Prioritise the important things first.

[@seranadesongs]

Glad to hear they treated you well, looks like they did a great job on your watch Pete. Happy for you bro! 👍

[@martinkaplan1805]

That’s a great looking watch, and it looks great on you.

[@PeterKotsa]

Thank you Martin

[@richardl4376]

Hi Peter, I agree the staff at the store are great. I thought repairs for Rolex and Tudor were done in the Rolex service centre in Oliver street . The staff there are fantastic and so helpful. Cheers

[@comeonman7423]

Thanks for the video, absolutely love the blue strap you put on the watch.

[@PeterKotsa]

🙏

[@timetowatch_francois]

Happy for you. Great looking watch and that strap choice is spot on. Thanks for sharing.

[@stevebennett7783]

I had my BB58 for less than 6 months as I just couldn't gel with it. I've since tried the new Ranger and GMT but again they do absolutely nothing for me. However, if you love it, keep it. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

[@ghitsta]

Here in London you take your Tudor straight into the Rolex head office building in central west London and they give you the full Rolex service experience. Big flash building fully Rolex'd up in branding and fit-out, they have on-site Rolex watch makers in the back that do the servicing or repairs for you. I have to say it was a wonderful experience for someone who isn't yet a Rolex owner. My BB58 winding mechanism jammed 2 months outside of its warranty period (3.5 years being an early model) and they offered to replace the whole movement free of charge. Couldn't be happier with the whole experience.

[@anonymoususer6683]

I bought a new Black Pelagos 42mm from an Authorized Tudor dealer this year. The very next day, the watches minute and hour hands stopped moving but the seconds hand worked. Sent it back to Tudor for repair, it took 5 weeks to get it back. I really love the watch but my next purchase will be an Omega or Breitling.

[@PeterKotsa]

All watches have problems. I have had a few issues with Omega and Seiko as well as the Tudor as you know. A few friends of mine have had Rolex issues...its across the board and sometimes a QC problem happens Nonetheless enjoy the Pelagos, glad to see its back, sorry about the waiting time..👍

[@andrewd7586]

Glad to see it was rectified so quickly Peter! I’ve been into the Collins St store about 6 weeks ago & the staff were very helpful & accomodating! I’m of the opinion, you had issues, they addressed them, handled it professionally as you’d expect after spending a substantial amount of money! Onwards & upwards & I’d be keeping it too!🤤👍🏼🤣

[@PeterKotsa]

Correct 👍

[@kevinbarnbrook4728]

@@PeterKotsa As for the people who said Tudor are trash, clearly they aren't the brightest bunch.

[@golfpark94]

In the end it is all the human factor that makes a brand. This Tudor deserves the wristtime and for you to enjoy it for years to come.

[@PeterKotsa]

agreed

[@crisfehr]

Having owned several Tudors and recently getting the BB 58 Blue, I've never had issues with them (knock on wood). Good to hear that your BB 58 Blue got sorted...Great vid and great piece!

[@leewatkeys9065]

Peter thanks for posting. I bought the exact same watch in June this year and it’s hardly been off my wrist; just when doing DIY tasks and messing with my cars/bikes. It really is a beautiful watch and no issues 👍🏻

[@PeterKotsa]

Thanks for sharing Lee, cheers

[@jeeperspeepers8323]

It's a lovely watch. By all means keep the watch and enjoy it. Tudor is a great brand.

[@leath25]

Beautiful quality looking watch, I would keep the original strap or bracelet on it though. Hopefully one day I'll be able to afford one.

[@randallhill7979]

Beautiful watch, I have the same color way. She’s a keeper 👍

[@sevengone]

that strap is beautiful

[@edteach3r]

My Seiko AD is a master technician, trained at Seiko when he still used to work for Seiko in Japan. He is so highly regarded that he is also the repair centre for Rolex, Omega, Breitling, etc. Tudor watches, like Rolex, Omega, Seiko are mass produced and mistakes occur. The BB 58 is still at the top of my “want list” and I will buy one as soon as I can afford it. Enjoy your beautiful watch in good health, Pete!

[@Slayaz69]

You had a very good experience with the repair of your watch so I suggest to keep it you'll enjoy wearing it more than before.

[@PeterKotsa]

That's the plan!

[@craig2100]

Glad it worked out. Thanks for sharing Mate.

[@PeterKotsa]

Cheers Craig

[@sholtobyrnes2210]

I'm glad you had such a good experience. The lume fell out of my Pelagos bezel, which was faulty - way too much play - from the start. After nearly five months I'm still waiting for it to be fixed. To make matters worse, the assistant at the AD who took it in suggested I may have to pay for "wear and tear" even though I'd had it only 10 months and swap it for a beater when I exercise! Tudor have since made it clear the repair is under warranty. But I'm seriously unimpressed

[@PeterKotsa]

I hope everything gets sorted

[@baldeagle6128]

Wise make fantastic straps (and watches).

[@Anonymouslyme1]

Keep 100%, best looking watch on the market!

[@juniorjohnson5961]

Still saving for my Black Bay 58 👍

[@PeterKotsa]

👍

[@omegaseamaster1550]

I didnt like the screw down crown on my 58. I would screw it down and after half a day it was loose. Tightened again a lil tighter and next morning same thing had to tighten before strapping it to the wrist. Nice watch, nice time keeping , looked great, but couldnt risk getting it wet in my day to day. So, of it went to another Happy Tudor Owner for what I paid for it after 18 months. They have jumped a few $$ since too.

[@maljones.8737]

Glad your happy with it pete.its always upsetting when you buy something and it lets you down 10 out of 10 for customer service. Thanks for the update.

[@PeterKotsa]

👍

[@felo6035]

I'm really happy that this issue was resolved by Tudor to your satisfaction Pete. Tudor is an outstanding brand and their watches are awesome in my opinion. Enjoy the watch and your day my friend 👍

[@harryalexander734]

Good luck. Nothing wrong with that brand or any brand of you like them and look after them. Don’t sell them, and never ever bin them. ⭐️❤️

[@anamisidro8453]

I’m glad you kept the watch. It’s a beauty. 😉

[@PeterKotsa]

I love it!

[@TitoCanuso]

Keep it, off course!!! The mere doubt offends!! I will purchase the Pelagos in black one day. I have already the 8800 Seamaster 300m in blue dial! Great video!

[@martinharrison4245]

glad they sorted it out to your satisfaction Peter. mine stopped on holiday overnight for no apparent reason and the date wheel stuck prior to that episode. mines a 2018 model so the warranty was only 2 years then. in 2020 I believe they upped it to 5 years. I haven't had any further problems since and it all seems to be running fine and keeping excellent time. I'm waiting till the 4th of November to see if the date fails to change correctly again, as it was the 4th of October the last time it had issues. if it jams again I will probably wait till I get it serviced as it's not that big a deal. that said it's still poor for a watch that costs over 4k new. I doubt I would buy another one based on what I've experienced so far, but I do really like the watch. my seiko sla043 has never had any issues like this although the movement is nowhere near as accurate as the tudor. every manufacturer has q.c issues and certain design faults with automatic movements it's just the nature of the beast. overall though I have to say all my automatics have performed pretty well, and I've never paid out yet for a service. Yes I'm a cheapskate and I'm sure I will get stung for one or two eventually, as you can't really put a 4k watch in the drawer and just forget about it, can you ? I doubt I will buy anymore expensive watches , as I have around 4 to 5 of them now. If I was just starting out again, I would probably just stick to san Martin for a few hundred quid as they offer a great watch for the money. if you buy a 4k watch you will at some point need to spend money on it , and if you do fall out of love with it , it's a bit of a bitter pill to swallow. I'm no means a rich man , but it is nice to have something nice to wear on the wrist. I've probably spent 10k over the last 8 years on watches and straps, but I would recoup about 7k back if I sold them all off , if not a tad more. not that I will, because like you I think long and hard before I buy one, and I still love everyone of my watches for different reasons .

[@PeterKotsa]

Thanks for sharing Martin, PS that SLA043, maybe look at taking it down to your watchmaker, a few small tweaks and there is no reason why it cannot yield extremely accurate results, its a solid movement cheers brother

[@martinharrison4245]

@@PeterKotsa , yeah but that costs money. If it's a few minutes fast at the end of the month , it literally takes a few seconds to put it right. I'm not that bothered about it being super accurate , but it should be better out of the box . It could be magnetized, but I ain't spending a tenner to find out, lol. If I was really obsessed , I would just buy a quartz. I just love the sweep of an automatic, always have. As long as it's reasonably accurate, 30 secs a day , I don't really give a shit !!! I ain't spent a dime on getting my watches fixed, and I ain't starting now , lol. All this crap about servicing one every 5 years is bullshit. Maybe once in 20 , is my style , if it needs it, lol. Some people have had seikos that are 50 years old and never serviced them. If it ain't broke, leave well alone is my motto !!!! Most eBay watches are sold at around 5 years old, because people don't want to service the movement, but in reality there good for 20 , lol .

[@EDHBlvd]

Yep, typical Rolex/Tudor service. They refuse to tell you what was issue and what they did. I’m amazed they told you the dial and hands were replaced. When I had watch with movement issue they didn’t tell me anything.

[@2536528]

I love my BB 58 blue. I wear it on a genuine Isofrane strap most days. I have spend years with a Seamaster and a Sea-Dweller. The BB 58 is more comfortable and looks great to me. I think the value in a BB is amazing. It also seems to run within about a second per day on the wrist.

[@135ipocketrocket2]

Great that it turned out so well! I tend to expect perfection spending more on a watch, but, sadly, it's not the case. Every maker can make a mistake. It's a beautiful watch worth keeping.

[@PeterKotsa]

👍

[@b_altmann]

The BB 58 - especially in the vintage look - is really nice. If you can get it below retail, it’s a good deal. Of course the markers should be centered, the bezel insert should be without gaps and we don’t want to see dust under the crystal. I have seen gappy bezel inserts on a Squale 1521, but that’s a £700 watch. For £3300 that the BB 58 costs in 2023, I expect a high standard.

[@travisharrisphotography]

The BB58 is an AMAZING watch and value. I have the same one (bought in April this year, here in Miami, FL). Love it. Love it. Love it. I bought a few Vanguard rubbers for it and its hands down my fav. piece in my growing collection. Frankly, I think Rolex is now the one that I would be more embarrassed to wear. It sends the wrong "message" (for me), and so many are unfortunately fake now. To me, the Tudor IS the "new" sub and I really love what they are doing with their watches recently.

[@user-qv7rw7dq1d]

Yeah Rolex is a no go here. Hello fellow Miamian 👋

[@gynechiatrist]

I’ve an old Model Ranger and it bounces between a green rubber strap and a Crazy Horse leather strap- old 2842 movement and it’s a looong term keeper. Recently bought the the S&G GMT for a bling watch. And I’m loving it. While Rolex is a great company, my long term watches have been Omega and Tudor- with a 44mm Portuguese for tuxes and black suits. Seiko, Nth, Zelos come and go. But those are the “cat daddies”.

[@davidbreckler5327]

it's a keeper!

[@jonbravo6262]

Fantastic news for keeping this watch, and great review for the local Tudor team Peter. Their quality service is paramount, the product is covered by law for issues and returns. I remember the drubbing a local Ozy Utoober gave about her local Rolly team, it’s no time to provide poor service with so much competition and diversity for the consumers dollar.

[@PeterKotsa]

Correct, very well said 👍

[@whatsstefon]

A good outcome. Those marks are peculiar. I’m not surprised there’s no explanation. The service guys probably have no idea. Lol at the comments of prior video saying it’s a junk watch. Seriously. With the horrible experiences I’ve had with Seiko, I likely may never buy one, but I still think they’re an amazing company.

[@grahamwallace]

Beautiful watch! Grail piece for me. Wish you health to wear it.

[@desireless4092]

As a Pelagos 42 owner it is my favorite watch, so much so that I am waiting for my Pelagos FXD. It is actually amusing the hate this brand gets and the bad takes I read regarding the Pelagos. Makes me like it even more. If you wanna flip it - just flip it. But it will be a mistake IMHO.

[@leonm2407]

A one month turnaround isn't too bad Peter as you said. My experience with another Collins st watch specialist went for more than double that time and was a much less satisfactory experience. Enjoy

[@PeterKotsa]

Yeah pretty happy it was a decent turnaround

[@jim_bocho]

Likely something went wrong during coating. If there’s only the slightest impurities in the process, strange things can happen - „shit happens“. That said: Definitely a keeper! Still one of the best „blues“ out there 🥰

[@PeterKotsa]

Absolutely

[@24hourgmtchannel64]

My first Todor was two tone prince date. When I seen the gold plating wearing off the band I sold it. Being a huge vintage Rolex fan, when the Black Bay came out in 2012 I thought it was cool and reminiscent of the Bond submariner. I was on vacation in Vail Colorado and had the red insert 79220r on the wrist at a AD with my credit card ready but opted out and a week later picked up a early 90s pre owned 14060 no date sub. A few years later, same thing with a pre-owned Explorer ll. I then realized Tudor wasn't for me and represents to me what many feel regarding Tudor vs. ROLEX.

[@sneak880]

Good outcome! I figure they treated you extra well as you've got 40k followers on KZbin! Enjoy the Tudor!

[@PeterKotsa]

They only found out a few days ago that I had a YT channel So hats off to them for their professionalism 👍

[@theaussiewhinger]

I'm not a big fan of Tudor/Rolex designs, apart from the neglected Heritage Chrono Blue (I love that). I do think Tudor are often unfairly placed at a level higher than they really are, but they are absolutely a good brand and are very well made. Issues like this can and do happen. The company looked after you when you needed them and that is what matters. Great video, buddy.

[@PeterKotsa]

👍

[@andyholton7959]

I would not complain about this, and a good outcome 🤙🏻

[@realmacoy5708]

Tudor is the proper Tool Watch and not just affiliated or adopted, it is technically Rolex by blood. Do not listen to those people who are saying negative about Tudor Watches, for they are the most reasonably affordable and best high end quality, great looking watches that you can buy , out in the Market today and It’s the one watch that you can enjoy and freely wear in today’s World without the worries of getting mugged, compared to those now majority Tudor haters/ Rolex fun boys that only wears their Rolexes at home or just sitting in their watch winders inside their safe…lol!😂

[@alanmckinnon6791]

Keep the watch Peter, the only people saying Tudor is rubbish are watch snobs or folks who want you to sell it so they can buy it anonymously. I don't think the boutique could tell you exactly what was wrong, on the photos we could see the blue dial paint had flaked off showing some underlying contaminant. I'd say there was dust in the air in the paint room the day that dial was painted. It happens like you say, all car manufacturers also have paint issues sometimes. It's no biggie, it's an isolated problems.

[@VersedNJ]

Peter have that watch, no issues. But was going to ask you about that strap. The BB58 blue and keep the color right is a strap monster, and was going to ask you about the strap. Also I think a blue NATO would like nice.

[@Lowdowndog]

Have mine on a blue MN style strap with a single white strap. Looks great, Infinitely adjustable, comfortable and rarely wear the watch on anything else.

[@PeterKotsa]

Hey Michael, Link in the description for that strap cheers mate

[@mgolabek89]

Hello Pete! What do you think about Eberhard Scafograf 300? In my opinion it's a quite unique design with a very good quality and a reliable, no-nonsense top grade Eta-2824. It comes with a blue and a black dials and I think they both look great. The markers utilize a bit of faux patina (which I personally hate) but I think they didn't over do it and it looks quite tasteful.

[@PeterKotsa]

A solid piece for sure. I advent seen ti in the steel, but looks really well made and no fuss design 👍

[@parky5329]

my year old BB58 black lume pip fell out so took it for repair. two months later it returns from Rolex Kings Hill with someone else's absolutely wrecked bracelet and a loose bezel! I was disappointed at first which turned to anger. Was left with the AD to sort out!

[@PeterKotsa]

ouch, I hope it gets sorted for you Benjamin

[@Dirtywesterner]

I bought a bbgmt in July and three months later I noticed a faint amount of moisture on the inside of the sapphire , and I immediately brought it in and it’s been a month since I dropped it off. I suspect it will be sent to Tudor unfortunately

[@PeterKotsa]

Best of luck with it, moisture happens to many watches (I've seen it a few times)

[@Dirtywesterner]

@@PeterKotsa I was horrified. It happened on my Seiko mini-tuna but I had adjusted the time and felt like I might not have tightened the crown enough. This blindsided me, I was driving and almost hit a light pole when first I noticed it . Big fan of your work sir,thanks for the reply

[@korbenndallass]

I think Tudor have been kicking out some great watches recently, and considering how terrible the Rolex ADs are then it’s a viable alternative to paying stupid money on the grey market for Rolex. I’ve just scratched the Sub itch with a Pelagos 39 that I’m saving for Christmas. I think the right choice to keep yours Peter, as usual great content 👍🏼

[@michaelmcneal7749]

I love my 39!!! Great watch

[@stuartheyburn8741]

Like you say, every watch can have issues from time to time, glad the experience has not put you off the watch though.👍 I would be a little perturbed that they couldn’t or wouldn’t tell you want was wrong with it though!!!!

[@PeterKotsa]

Yeah I asked at the start when I handed the watch in and also mind way if i could fins out what the problem was and they don't disclose that. No dramas, its fixed 😊

[@ianmarshall3633]

Hi Pete, it looks like watch snobbery is rearing it ugly head. TUDOR are wonderful time pieces. I would never part with mine. I've had Heritage BB 36 for 5 years and it still keeps perfect time. No issues at all. The customer service experience was second to none. People who call them a poor man's Rolex have no idea what they are talking about. I'm glad you're keeping yours. Stay well my friend 🙂

[@Nefville]

Exactly my thoughts. When I hear that I think you might as well hang a sign around your neck that says "I'm a moron". Because anyone who says that clearly doesn't know anything about watches OR poor men 🤣🤣

[@johnbeattie3146]

Another fair, well considered video bereft of sensationalism. You do a good job Pete, your camera work and narrative are first class. I have both a 36mm Date Just, circa 1982, and a late 2020 Tudor Heritage Divers both from new. I’m happy with both and they get good wrist time. The Rolex has been serviced 3 times and my experience from the AD has always been quite acceptable.

[@PeterKotsa]

Thanks John for the praise 🙏 You’ve got a very nice selection there, I love this little blue bb58, such a joy on the wrist 👍

[@chriszivoder2650]

Love my BB58 Blue. It is the only watch that I've not considered selling. For me it's how it wears on the wrist, it sits flat and flush with my wrist. I never take it off the bracelet either, I have other watches to play around with straps. I've had the watch for 2 years and still get a buzz when I wear it.

[@PeterKotsa]

Enjoy it Chris, Im loving mine thats for sure🔥

[@nmdk-design]

I bought a Black Bay 58 2 weeks ago. I wore the watch and took it off at 5 p.m. The next day it stopped at 8am. I followed my dealer's advice and wound it 30 turns by hand. I then put the watch aside at 9:30am. It stopped at 2:40 in the morning. So the clock stops between 15 and 17 hours of running time. I'm going to my dealer next week to have the watch checked. Pretty disappointing buying experience for such an expensive watch.

[@seattlegrrlie]

I love my BB58 Blue. No issues, no problems, runs spot on. Anyone who thinks this watch is rubbish is foolish

[@mordeth1964]

People who say Tudor are garbage are either ignorant, watch snobs or (probably) Rolex fan boys or all of the above. Personally I love Tudor and along with Omega and Vacheron Constantine is one of my favourite watch brands. I don't own any of them and can't afford any of them, but I still think they're awesome.

[@PeterKotsa]

👍

[@kelorednaxela]

I'm guessing the rust speckles fell off from the hands. That would explain why they replaced both the dial and the hands.

[@Styla78]

Can you recommend the best AD to buy the BB58 in Melbourne? Can you negotiate on the 58? Love the strap combo on the blue 58.

[@PeterKotsa]

I use the Tudor AD on Collins at (Hour Glass) As for negotiations, none that I know of anywhere

[@Styla78]

@Peter Kotsa thanks Peter. Is it the same with Omega? I heard people saying you can haggle them down 10 or even 15% at some dealers. Or is this non-existant nowadays.

[@paulhiggins8774]

It happens, bad batch of dials, so what, it was an easy fix. I like Tudor and don’t think they would have intentionally sold sub standard watches and ruined their reputation. Probably it was a reaction with the silver coat and the colour coat, or even the lacquer. I think you made the right decision keeping it

[@erikvermeulen9295]

Aaaah but you did not take the 400 euro anticorossion treatment option when you bought the watch......keep it! That shop gave you excellent service, that is how brands are made, costumer care is key, no matter the price range.

[@davidsandrovitch7635]

Hi Peter. Can you tell from your photos whether they just replaced the dial, or whether the dial has been repaired. I suspect they might have replaced the dial as a repair would probably have been noticeable. Maybe they even changed the entire movement as the easiest solution. Can you tell exactly what they did by inspection? You do have macro photos that most buyers would not have.

[@PeterKotsa]

Definitely replaced the dial..and handset There are small tell tale signs that the dial and hands are new. Also the movement is the original one as it was gaining 1 sec per day and running at a particular amplitude on the timegrapher..its still exactly the same to the letter 👍

[@johnbuckmaster569]

I really would like to know what caused it! They replace the handset so was there some anomaly with one of the hands that was scratching/marking the dial? I can’t stand not knowing what causes a problem when it arrises. Thanks for the great video!

[@PeterKotsa]

From my understanding the dial is brass and then painted. There might have been an anomaly in the painting process which showed up over time.. cheers John

[@klingen8019]

Never read about anyone with QC issues on their Tudor. Ive owned allt of them and never had any issues

[@2K9s]

Does “date wheel” ring a bell?

[@chriszivoder2650]

@@2K9s except the GMT lol. I guess all brands have their issues, it's all about the after care. Did all GMT's have the same issue?

[@vipeton.8927]

I would keep it. As a minimalist I like simple things. This Tudor is perfect 'One watch collection'. Suitable for work, sports, camping and high end events.

[@bonnystarks]

Bought my gmt pepsi at an AD, and after 3 days, I've noticed a tiny hair sitting on the 4 hour marker. Send it back, gave me back the watch 1 month after all clean.

[@martin4374]

When people say, "Tudor is a poor man's Rolex." What they're actually commenting on, is their own values and character. Even if Tudor made a watch that they would absolutely love, they'd deprive themselves of that joy.

[@PeterKotsa]

Nicely said Martin

[@jeffreyromain7336]

Nice resolution. It's 10:34 BST in Blighty and it's flipping tipping it down.

[@joshn.5625]

Peter - great video as always. What kind of strap do you have on your BB58?

[@PeterKotsa]

its in the description Josh cheers

[@joshn.5625]

@@PeterKotsa Sorry I missed it. Thank you!

[@PeterKotsa]

@@joshn.5625 all good 👍

[@EricBishard]

This isn't a flipper. This is a keeper. You always need a tool watch that can go anywhere, not be too gaudy or expensive for that matter. This should become your everyday beater in 20 years. Pass it on and keep the tradition of passing down Tudors to family alive. These are amazing and beautiful watch. Mine is going to my son in just a few years. I have several other watches and I'm not going to start him off with the most expensive watch nor do I want to put him in a position to have to worry about a Rolex or something else twice, three or four times the price, but I want him to know what quality is. The Tudor BB is not a good watch that you can flip anyways unless the idea is to wear it for a while and recoup some of your money back. I have flipped real estate and the idea is to find something on the cheap or that can be fixed up to sell at a profit, what is your angle with a new Tudor BB? They barely hold their retail value for anything but a short period of time and it would need to be in perfect condition. But it's not going to make you a decent profit. These are watches to be enjoyed. Tudor is anything but a trash brand. people saying that have ZERO idea about watches. Toss it in the bin. They are smoking crack. I bet anything the person who said that does not even own a watch.

[@galaga8834]

Peter, each to their own but I found the 58 too dainty for my 7.25 inch wrist. Much prefer the 41mm models especially the ETA variants that are only 12.7mm thick.

[@PeterKotsa]

I tried the 41 on and on the overhead it suits me, but seems a little too thick for my 7” wrist Cheers

[@manueljnegrete5048]

Hi Peter, good for you that you are keeping your bb58. I have been a watch lover for many decades with anything from chinese made pieces to Speedys, Seamasters, GSs etc. Couple years ago I purchased new Tudor reverse pand and loved it's design and such. When I first purchased it and wound the crown I immediately noticed that it wasn't nearly as smooth and easy to wind as my bb41 heritage burgundy. But I assumed that because it was a b01 movement it was just not a major issue. A couple months ago the watch started to to become much more difficult to wind and I could hear the rotor spinning as I wound it. I had to drive an hour to the authorized dealer in San Francisco area for repairs. Got it back last week and it is much better but still very hard to wind. In every other way I love my Tudor panda but I am somewhat leary of that movement. Lesson for me? Watches are made by imperfect humans so occasionally problems occur.

[@markwright2140]

Hey Peter, glad you’re keeping it. I have the exact same watch bought for me by my wife as a 50th bday gift last year and I love it! One question, the lume on your watch seems to be blue? Mine is green 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@PeterKotsa]

Mine is green too, I shone a UV light on it during the video, causing it to emit blue 😊😎

[@markwright2140]

@@PeterKotsaAh ok! If only they did this with blue lume ❤️

[@PeterKotsa]

@@markwright2140 if you haven't already seen this video Mark, check it out bro kzbin.info/www/bejne/i5nOgJKDjZuMZpY cheers

[@markwright2140]

This is also one of my biggest complaints about this watch. It makes no sense why they would choose green lume over blue?

[@robertlock6041]

Hi Peter, I think that Tudor's overall reputation has been enhanced by this episode. Your valid complaint was dealt with promptly by the Tudor team at the boutique and there was a good outcome. Tudor make excellent watches, but as with all manufacturers in every sphere sometimes problems can occur. Boeing found this out the hard way with the tragic 737 Max story recently, and with 787 delamination problems. Shit happens, despite every precaution. Tudor looked after you well, and is one of the few manufacturers to offer a five (or more) year warranty. Tudor seems to divide opinion widely between enthusiasts (me) and haters. The sales figures tell us all we need to know, though. Thank you for sharing this Peter. Have a good week. 🙂👋

[@PeterKotsa]

Thanks for sharing Robert, you too mate have a good one 🥃