Kashmir: China vs India vs Pakistan

Рет қаралды 191,170

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 1 900

@aayushthorat314 Ай бұрын

9:28- China did not "LIBERATE" Tibet it annexed it and then killed buddhists to take over a country based on borders from ancient China. Aksai Chin has been recognised as a part of India since Independence and the Indo-China war wasn't cause of "MAOIST CHINA" but because the PLA kept on breaking the border and harrasing villagers which it continues to this day in states of Arunachal Pradesh which it claims for itself as well

@oz2362 Ай бұрын

Its absolutely fucking insane to me how they think they could get away with saying that.

@Ibnfunk Ай бұрын

@@aayushthorat314 non-native speakers around the world mobilising in these comments to remind english speakers not to use sarcasm online without some kind of visual aid 😆 Subtle tones and inflections are very hard for non native speakers to hear

@Milicija-kp1mk Ай бұрын

Sarcasm

@SMathai Ай бұрын

I could clearly hear the sarcasm when he said that, but I'm a native speaker. There is a pause, intonation change at the word "liberated". Orally speaking he was putting the sarcasm quotes on the word. It also helps to have listened to quite a few Simon videos and I've gotten familiar with how he speaks, and he does make regular use of sarcasm, though usually you can see his face at the same time (multiple cues to understanding the sarcasm). In this case, given the topic, it might have been safer for him to be clearer on what he meant by "liberated". He does get clearer at 19:45 - "Given Chinese treatment of tibet..."

@katmandu0 Ай бұрын

same as u indians did with kashmiris and sikkim

@avinashchaudhary8545 Ай бұрын

Pakistan surrendered (gifted) regions of kashmir to China as disputed territory and they're crying for removing article 370? Hypocrisy ki bhi sima hoti hai

@DarthVaderoftheShire Ай бұрын

Doesn't mean what you did with the article is the right thing.

@avinashchaudhary8545 Ай бұрын

@@DarthVaderoftheShire am i justifying it?? And how can you decide what is right what is wrong on one side there's country controlled by military didn't care about democracy, human rights minority and on the other side there's largest democracy with few flaws nd recent incidents?? Who is right

@Pinicle_of_evolution Ай бұрын

@@DarthVaderoftheShirecry about it paki it's our country our rules

@DarthVaderoftheShire Ай бұрын

@@avinashchaudhary8545 related to kashmir India is wrong considering Human rights violations and disempowerment of people and broken promises.

@avinashchaudhary8545 Ай бұрын

@@DarthVaderoftheShire making Kashmir independent pakistan will start it's invasion as they started after Kashmir king decided to stay independent no to join india , pakistan. Would you justify that also separatist funded by Pakistan definitely don't fall under human rights , agree that most of innocent their are facing oppression but they still better than Pakistan have you seen situation in pakistan they're more focused on Kashmiris and discriminated pakhton , baloch and several others

@someguy2707 Ай бұрын

This guy has not said a word about the atrocities in Pkstani occupied Kashmir. Surely thingsmust be extremely rosy there. A human rights paradise.

@mahadahmed1996 Ай бұрын

Please do enlighten us about the 'atrocities' your godi media tells you. And just btw I've been to both AJK and GB and have family in GB so no need to bullshit us

@Octopus04 Ай бұрын

@@mahadahmed1996why Pakistan gifted saksham valley to china... Are they afraid of the Chinese Army ?? 😂😂

@seventhuser904 Ай бұрын

@@mahadahmed1996 Videos dont lie. There have been huge protests in POK against the mis treatment and atrocities to POK residents by the Pakistani Authorities. While Indian Administered Kashmir prosper and flourish, POK residents feel left out.

@maquacr7014 Ай бұрын

@@seventhuser904 Protests happen in any democracy. And Pakistan does claim to be a democracy.

@maquacr7014 Ай бұрын

@@seventhuser904 The most militarized region in the world is prospering? Where is the prosperity?

@singatakberpura Ай бұрын

Fun Fact : The name Kashmir comes from the name of a Hindu saint called Rishi (Sage) Kashyap. He started the human habitation around a lake there in Kashmir. Hence Kash from Kashyap + Mira (Lake) The natives of Kashmir is the Hindu Pandits. Sikhs and Buddhist are also present in Kashmir. Muslims only appeared there 600 years ago and thereafter with Islam 4 exodus and one genocide of the native had taken place.

@huanwang-ur5ve Ай бұрын

Hindu kush?

@hmmlol-yi9kv Ай бұрын

"Namaste Sharada Devi Kashmira pura vasini"

@Gen-wt Ай бұрын

Mythology lol Had it been true, burzhom settlements would not have been there

@proudkaafir5126 Ай бұрын

@@huanwang-ur5vehindu kush is what the mountain ranges are called. Kush in persian meaning kill. Cuz this was the route that islamic invaders used to get hindu slaves across the mountains to turkey,unzekistan etc and many hindus would die from sheer exhaustion walking in the oxygen deprived high altitudes.

@MK-ji6dw Ай бұрын

98% Kashmiri pandits converted to Islam. Fuck off with your Wikipedia knowledge. Hindus killed Buddhists , destroyed their monasteries in Kashmir.

@The_SkullKnight Ай бұрын

Talking only about Kashmir and leaving out PoK and GB was so convenient 😂

@mohitbhardwaj3532 Ай бұрын

No citation of treaties no constitutional articles no mention of standstill agreement no mention of transcript of 5 points of UN resolution of 1948, who started the act of aggression first.And who did the kashmiri pandits genocide also not shown। All the legal aspects thrown into the corner in this video.

@wajhussain786able Ай бұрын

Kashmir should have gone to Pakistan automatically in 1947. Kashmir being 77% muslim majority means it's part of Pakistan. That's how British india was partitioned.

@mohitbhardwaj3532 Ай бұрын

@@wajhussain786able No one wants to be a part of confedration of occupied terrotoriries of Azaad Balochistan (1947) and khyber agency and occupied gilgit wazarat and Baltistan agency(1949) along with occupied Sindh. A country known as 'Motherland of terrorism' with 10's of UN designated terrorists. A fake artificialy crafted country by the british, a country with a severe identity crisis, no history whatsoever, formed to create a buffer b/w India & Afghanistan in a period spanning b/w 'The great Game' & WWII .Period. !! Fun Fact : Pakistan is the only country in the world whose all 3 borders named after a serving agent of British boundry commission based in london. All 3 borders are burning except one i.e open and safe thats the Arabian sea 😂😂✌

@bharathyadav1589 Ай бұрын

Sure😂😂@@wajhussain786able

@adarshsingh1745 Ай бұрын

@@wajhussain786ablethat's what Jihadis teachers teach in pakistan? It's the leader who decides ,not the public. And the leader decided to integrate with India . India didn't invade Kashmir when they asked for independence , it was Jihadi Pakistani themselves , thinking everything can be assimilated by force. Then the Kashmir leader asked for india help with the condition of being integrated into India

@srinivasnyayapathi9083 Ай бұрын

Simon you should have read the UN resolution before making this video. You sounded like the perfect Britisher who has a bad hangover from 1947.🤣

@rounakdebnath2895 Ай бұрын

bro assembled entire south asia

@SG-cv4pf Ай бұрын

and China apparently.

@thepax2621 Ай бұрын

Never let the british draw a map 😅

@bvedant Ай бұрын

Never let the british do anything besides pubs, fish and chips, and prog rock.

@markgrehan3726 Ай бұрын

We didn't create Kashmir

@joeyjoejoeshabadoo1411 Ай бұрын

Imo Pakistan and India would have had a civil war between the Muslims and Hindus if Britain didn't split the country. It would have been very bloody. I think it was the lesser of two evils. But regarding Kashmir, nobody seems to care what the Kashmir people want.

@mfd8346 Ай бұрын

During Britian : lets set aside our differences. After Britian : I have decided that I want to be racist.

@cmath6454 Ай бұрын

@@joeyjoejoeshabadoo1411 Just because it is bloody dont be in a rush to say the alternative is the lesser of two evils. No autonomy and nuclear threats doesnt guarentee that a alternative of peaceful borders drawn in willing blood for generations to mutually acknowledge and respect. Autonomy is better than otherwise

@avinashchaudhary8545 Ай бұрын

Pakistan preaching human rights 💀💀

@Jamala_ Ай бұрын

India disappearing thousands of people 💀 India is just as bad if not worse than Pakistan in terms of minorities, but atleast the Pakistani government doesn't violently blind children, disappear the innocent, or crack down on protestors. Indian BJP supporters need a reality check because being blindly nationalistic will get you decimated by china. P.S- India is closer in its capacity to Pakistan than it is to china.

@DorkDork69 Ай бұрын

better than india

@avinashchaudhary8545 Ай бұрын

@@DorkDork69 yeh sure 😂😂👍

@Lua-420Hertz Ай бұрын

both nations are horrible when it comes to human rights, stop joking yourselves, you monkeys.

@minecraftwater8544 Ай бұрын

as if india has a clean track record.

@abdullahmohamed1417 Ай бұрын

I am sure the comment section will be full of people discussing this topic with civility and decorum.

@CedarHunt Ай бұрын

The Indians, Chinese, and Pakistanis are mostly asleep right now. We have a good 6 hours of civility before they wake up.

@Karne282 Ай бұрын

The comment section might get more entertaining than the video tbh. Time to get some popcorn for the shit of show polarized views.

@simonkompe2164 Ай бұрын

I have 🍿 rdy.

@Timewastedonyt Ай бұрын

🍿

@Tmaget Ай бұрын

😮🍿

@RajneeshSingh-i5t Ай бұрын

Innocent pakistani:- We have lumber one intelligence agency, ISI.💪💪💪💪 But if something bad happens in Pakistan. Now innocent Pakistani:- RAAAA ki sajish hai. 😂

@ryankline1164 Ай бұрын

Ah yes the brilliant ISI. Who "accidentally" let a global fugitive (I honestly don't know how to label the guy with how bad YT censorship is these days) have a huge compound right next to their military academy in Abbottabad.

@muzamilraza49 Ай бұрын

You call pigeons terrorists and an isi agent. Raw lumber 1☝

@nikhilhamand Ай бұрын

RAA aur MAA ki Saazish....😂

@DoloMalo-mw4zl Ай бұрын

@@nikhilhamand Bharat Mata Pakistan Papa

@nikhilhamand Ай бұрын

@@DoloMalo-mw4zl Pakistan ki faut ho gayi hai beta..

@jabbathetrump Ай бұрын

I swear to god I've seen you in like 7 different channels

@saulcat1984 Ай бұрын

Welcome to the simonverse

@aligee7903 Ай бұрын

Don't get it twisted, he's paid to narrate content, they aren't all his channels😅

@LuKaZz420 27 күн бұрын

More like 20

@sanchayandeka2500 Ай бұрын

Wonderful getting lectured by a Brit on issues they created. And also, what a childlike simplification of the issue of Kashmir. Goes to show how easy it is to build a script basis a few articles online and read it out on a KZbin video.

@TyroG007 Ай бұрын

Did he just say China liberated Tibet?

@ibrahimsalman5504 Ай бұрын

Deadpan humour is dead

@thearpox7873 Ай бұрын

@@ibrahimsalman5504 If that was an attempt at humor, it was horrendous. And I say this as someone that loves deadpan humor.

@thearpox7873 Ай бұрын

@@wassupyeah28 No, I can't. The delivery was crap.

@tufanrakshit7624 Ай бұрын

HE HAS BECOME a mouthpiece like BBC , good old Simon is gone

@nothankkyou3176 Ай бұрын

@@thearpox7873the fact you don't know if it was a joke says the delivery was perfect

@paul5677 Ай бұрын

4 Indians and 20 Chinese !! cause the Chinese never give a correct number.

@moin7427 Ай бұрын

It’s a number shared by numerous credible third party sources. You want us to believe Indian sources, CCP wants to believe theirs.

@xxertzz Ай бұрын

⁠@@moin7427Multiple American and Russian sources confirmed more than 30 Chinese dead. China has a reputation of lying and deceiving so i wouldnt really trust their say.

@prakritimishra2997 Ай бұрын

@@moin7427credible sources like who? USA? Pakistan? Who?

@samarthbagwe1736 Ай бұрын

@@moin7427Indian sources are true it's more like 80 chinese Because there are 80 chinese graves right after conflict

@exurgemars Ай бұрын

It's a figure quoted by neutral third parties, not verified. @@moin7427

@RiggsBF Ай бұрын

Restore the Mongolian Empire, Genghis Khan would know how to handle this.

@malegria9641 Ай бұрын

No he wouldn’t the man stayed far away from the Himalayas

@prayagjoshi1179 Ай бұрын

He tried but failed !

@ry5199 Ай бұрын

Yes he was the epitome of diplomacy

@seansingh4421 Ай бұрын

An Alauddin Khilji a day, keeps the Mongols away 😂😂

@VijaySingh-wt1sp Ай бұрын

@@seansingh4421he was not the reason it was the climate of India that made the mongol horses sick and later on they got divided into 4

@whiskey_tango_foxtrot__ Ай бұрын

The religion of peace and tolerance not getting along there either...

@Talisguy Ай бұрын

Read up on the Partition of India sometime - the tensions are definitely not one-sided. Reality is very rarely as simple as "it's always Islam's fault."

@DorkDork69 Ай бұрын

@@Talisguy you're explaining it to a hindutva guy. Speaking against a wall really

@jacobscholtissek2410 Ай бұрын

@@Talisguy and if you wanna go further back, it was the west "fault", Islam was reforming in the 19thcentury but then the west occupied or controlled indirectly large parts. Thats resulted in more conversitism and xenophobia in Islam. But remember India has more grievious towards Islam than the Brits, due to col..

@sschaubal Ай бұрын

Do they ever get along with anyone?

@JohnAdams-vd5dc Ай бұрын

@@sschaubal No they don't.

@MisterKnightly Ай бұрын

Last time I was this early, India and Pakistan were still part of the British Empire.

@Tonius126 Ай бұрын

Last time I was this early, UK was a based conquering empire, not a woke DEI hole with a two tier policing.

@bobfromaccounting93 Ай бұрын

@@Tonius126 Last time I was this early the UK wasn't populated with Indians and Pakistanis everywhere I look.

@cwj2733 Ай бұрын

last time i was early, it was still called hindustan

@WildsDreams45 Ай бұрын

@@Tonius126 The USA neutered your country and you still do whatever we tell you to do. At least the French have enough backbone to try and resist. Even if it is while asking us for help lol.

@ibrahimsalman5504 Ай бұрын

@@cwj2733Last time I was this early "Hindustan" was ruled by Muslim for over a 1000 years

@JohnDoe-zg6qt Ай бұрын

Kashmir always was and always will be Indian territory.

@CSS_Mustafeez Ай бұрын

As a Pakistani I would say the opposite.

@durgeshsss Ай бұрын

@@CSS_Mustafeezbut truth is truth

@_snehaa_._2 Ай бұрын

Kashmir the land of Rishi Kashyap says it all

@Chiga-lt6vq Ай бұрын

@@CSS_Mustafeezdude ur country is barely surviving Just heard there was a bomb blast in karachi How can ya claim more lands when ur own land is in shambles

@Humorhub121-v3f Ай бұрын

@@_snehaa_._2 avg lindu

@pyariskitchen9215 Ай бұрын

Bashing the only one real democrazy in the region to support pakistan, because america made a blunder.

@DarthVaderoftheShire Ай бұрын

Partial democracy for partial regions. As we understand it Kashmir is ruled totally different.

@Pinicle_of_evolution Ай бұрын

@@DarthVaderoftheShireKashmir was ruled totally differently under 370 which under the current government is removed, its as democratic as delhi or MP or you can just disagree with facts

@DarthVaderoftheShire Ай бұрын

@@Pinicle_of_evolution don't make a follow of yourself. Kashmir isn't ruled in a democratic way right now at all. Laws like PSA, AFSPA, media act, downgraded to UT and ruled by a governor. Not to mention the impunity that the police and armed forces enjoy to do as they please. These are no democratic laws or ways to rule a territory.

@bruderschweigen6889 Ай бұрын

What did america do? You guys blame them for literally everything be a man and own your shit.

@RR-pc7yv Ай бұрын

@@DarthVaderoftheShire LMAO, you've no idea, buddy 🤣🤣

@rebelsindeed Ай бұрын

Kashmir legally acceded to India & a legitimate territory whether world accepts it or not. Those who have problem please ask Pakistan & China to vacate parts of JnK under their occupation.

@blackkn1ght Ай бұрын

Acceded by an illegitimate genocidal monster who killed over 200,000 kashmiris in an attempt to change the region's demographics. Kashmiris want either independence or to join Pakistan. Your hindutva ideology is an affront to humanity.

@ibrahimsalman5504 Ай бұрын

Bro feeling are hurt from reality lol ,which is why you'll never make it out of the slums

@rayyanzalmi6998 Ай бұрын

but had a muslim majority population should have been acceded to Pakistan. A plebiscite should have taken place like in Junadhgar

@attari56 Ай бұрын

legally acceded but if it was put up to a vote back then it would of been voted either as independent or join pakistan.

@m.sahil.stag18 Ай бұрын

who are you to decide the succession, we want a free nation, and we will have it, not india, not pakistan,,, a free kashmir

@seanbinkley7363 Ай бұрын

Also, very soft material for sweaters.

@SG-cv4pf Ай бұрын

and socks

@wile-e-coyote8371 Ай бұрын

and a nightmare to properly wash.

@comlitbeta7532 Ай бұрын

And a great song by led zeppelin

@DKing627 Ай бұрын

Led Zeppelin has been bringing attention to Kashmir since 1975

@janjansens8724 Ай бұрын

Hiding pedophilia since way before then

@SnakenBacon87 Ай бұрын

So have sweaters

@pocketstring3634 Ай бұрын

Except they confused it with the Sahara

@rheinhardtgrafvonthiesenha8185 Ай бұрын

@@SnakenBacon87do you mean sweat as in stanky?

@BornKafir Ай бұрын

@@pocketstring3634yea, I don't think they really knew where Kashmir actually is and what it really looks like.

@batprime1177 Ай бұрын

India’s birth rate is declining as well and just dropped below replacement level so it is highly unlikely India will have a billion more people than China in 2100

@Shreedhar_Shukla Ай бұрын

Not talking about the Kashmir genocide I see.

@Ibnfunk Ай бұрын

It's a term pretty much only used by some hindu nationalists. The more accurate term for neutral audiences or scholars are: 'the kashmiri hindu exodus', 'the displacement of kashmiri Hindus', or 'the displacement of pandits'. I'm not trying to refute your point - he didn't talk about it. Just giving some advice if you want to discuss it seriously with people outside of hindu nationalist circles. Otherwise, you'll get dismissed as biased or extreme

@paulbreakable3302 Ай бұрын

can we please stop using the term genocide so inflationary, thereby softening it?

@RR-pc7yv Ай бұрын

@@paulbreakable3302 It is ethnic cleansing. Genocide is the whole history of Kashmiri Hindus since the day Islam arrived...

@mohitbhardwaj3532 Ай бұрын

Silent genocide happening since 13th century in kashmir

@vamshis1756 Ай бұрын

@@Ibnfunk its not like the killings didn't happen, and if you want to be accurate, be completely accurate, say "forceful kashmiri hindu exodus", "forceful displacement of kashmiri hindus", or "forceful displacement of pandits". because this is the most accurate term, the people didn't leave because they wanted to, they were literally forced out in one night, it was literally run or die, and people were killed when they didn't run fast enough. its good that you want be accurate. I would suggest you to be make a statement with complete accuracy, not just the parts you like.

@rishavmishra8675 Ай бұрын

The Western media's selective coverage of the Kashmir conflict often perpetuates a biased narrative, disproportionately focusing on India while overlooking the human rights abuses committed by Pakistan in Pakistan-occupied Kashmir (PoK) and Aksai Chin. The Kashmiri people living under Pakistani rule face severe restrictions, including limited freedom of expression, arbitrary arrests, and extrajudicial killings. Despite these grave violations, the international community has been largely silent, allowing Pakistan to evade accountability for its actions. Such double standards undermine the principles of justice and equality, and it is imperative that the global community demand a more balanced and comprehensive approach to addressing the Kashmir issue.

@selenacasper5691 Ай бұрын

So kashmiris in the Indian controlled areas are free?? Stfu.

@Bino9898 Ай бұрын

Basically no mention of any Pakistani human rights abuses but like half the video to India's 🤔

@devanshsharma5757 Ай бұрын

Because he cannot mention American blunders for supplying terrorists with weapons, which they still do with back channels.

@Timewastedonyt Ай бұрын

Totally unbiased video🙃

@emanuelrogers1162 Ай бұрын

Let's be honest 90% of human rights violations are done by India, I am a kashmiri myself and have never heard about any major problems that kashmirs have faced in the other part of Kashmir. Now I am not saying that pakis don't do any human rights violations, I am sure they do 10x more than India does but they do none of them because of the Kashmir issue so the admin doesn't have to report them in a video related to Kashmir issue.

@zaraf Ай бұрын

Because there are a thousand times more human rights abuses in Indian Occupied Kashmir than in Pakistan's Azad Kashmir and Gilgit-Baltistan. Maybe eat less faeces and you will be able to think logically.

@Hash125 Ай бұрын

Pakistan does not oppress the Kashmiris it rules. India oppresses the Kashmiris it rules Case closed.

@Makem12 Ай бұрын

China liberated Tibet? I'm not sure whoever wrote your script understands what the word liberated means unless you are being sarcastic in which case I did not pick up on the sarcasm.

@lucaslightbane Ай бұрын

It was sarcasm. I heard it but sarcasm doesn't always come across.

@eddiecallan Ай бұрын

Oh it was full on Sarcasm, watch it again and you'll see/hear it.

@Ibnfunk Ай бұрын

The tone was very obviously sarcastic

@Aeradom2000 Ай бұрын

I certainly wouldn’t say it was an obvious. His tone and inflection didn’t appear to change but they also chose to not show him on camera so body clues couldn’t be shown. The only clue really was the slight pause after saying it. To me it felt less obvious and more like they were skirting a line.

@Ibnfunk Ай бұрын

@Aeradom2000 english is my first language, so the tone and pause was very obvious to me but maybe it's difficult if it's not your first language

@syedmustahsan Ай бұрын

1:27 They are beating each other with iron rods; because india and china have an agreement that if faceoff occurs they will not use any guns, and that lead to use of iron rods

@The_Viking970 Ай бұрын

Looking in the past won’t solve the problem of present. As an Indian I would say since that 370 article was dismantled, India invest a lot of money on infrastructure of Kashmir and it’s showing very good sign of growth. You can see a lot of tourists vlog about indian Kashmir but for POK situation is very bad as economic conditions in that part making the population very unhappy. Many saying it openly that they want to be part of India as living conditions in Indian Kashmir is many times better than their side. For Chinese, they just want this issue not to be resolved as this will force India to spend lot money and keep the military in the region. Anyway only peace can bring prosperity to the people of Kashmir.

@jetaceflankerkillerbot2185 Ай бұрын

Simon how did you forget about 1.Genocide of original hindus in Kashmir 2. Its not only modern history you should take into account Thats why he had slogan Simon go back

@MK-ji6dw Ай бұрын

There are no Hindus in Kashmir.

@beast6029 Ай бұрын

Its clear neither India or Pakistan will let go of Kashmir. But it is also pretty clear that India has the upper hand in everything from ammunation to manpower to geopolitical influence over pakistan. And with Pakistan crippling economy, political instability, I don't know how much longer they can hold onto Kashmir. They just have to hope that India somehow goes through the same thing they are so they can gain some upper ground against India, but that does not seem the case atleast in the next half a century.

@rogerpenske2411 Ай бұрын

Let Jimmy page and Robert Plant, Govern Cashmere

@joeyjoejoeshabadoo1411 Ай бұрын

China won't let India get control of Pakistan controlled Kashmir. The CCP has a lot of investments in Pakistan and as Simon said, they have a better defensive position, and the land route is a major part of their belt and road to contain India. Unfortunately, none of the parties seem to care what the Kashmir people want

@ribhavmishra1103 Ай бұрын

@@joeyjoejoeshabadoo1411calm down bud, once China tries it's hands on going for Taiwan, US will keep them busy enough for India to take Kashmir permanently, once and for all. Also, the belt and road initiative is never going tobe successful, I think that is a public news already. Also, don't forget that 80% of Kashmiris want to be a part of India. Take a chill pill, Mr. CCP

@joeyjoejoeshabadoo1411 Ай бұрын

@ribhavmishra1103 Haha, that's the first time I've ever been accused of being a CCP shill. I loathe the CCP. Imo this whole thing started because Kashmir didn't want to be absorbed into Pakistan, and Pakistan wanted it anyway. My point is that Pakistan and China have a common goal of stopping Kashmir from unifying under India because of their investments and trade.

@rtyrsson Ай бұрын

Valid points. Pakistan cannot even control their own country. Certain regions are lawless and rife with terrorism; as is the military and their intelligence services. If they took complete control of Kashmir it would only increase their headaches. At this point it is only misplaced pride. The only way in which Pakistan is equal to India is nuclear weapons. Manpower, technology, economy, political stability, etc are all in India's favor.

@ItsChronoHawk Ай бұрын

Another channel I come across with Simon as the host.. this dude is just built different !

@itr8247 Ай бұрын

People who say kashmir should be with Pakistan because its Muslim majority, never talk about pakistan taking the remaining muslims of India. No reason for India to have 15% Muslims when Pakistan has 1% Hindus.

@cynthiaherbst3909 Ай бұрын

Do I recall correctly that there are more Indians who adhere to Islam than the literal population of the whole of Pakistan?

@Erik_Ice_Fang Ай бұрын

Pakistan has over 200 million people, so odds are there aren't THAT many Muslims in India.

@Erik_Ice_Fang Ай бұрын

Also, what happened tor trying for peaceful coexisting? I know its hard at times, but are we really advocating for ethnic cleansing here? C'mon man

@romeovky Ай бұрын

@@cynthiaherbst3909that's correct, India has the second largest Muslim population in the world, only after Indonesia.

@durgeshsss Ай бұрын

@@Erik_Ice_Fangatleast google before speaking...Google is free

@PraneethP-qf1yt Ай бұрын

0:44 independence was declared to kashmir when becoming a part of INDEPENDENT INDIA. Wait for some time and the whole of kashmir will become an independent part of india.

@saus9870 Ай бұрын

as if amnesty international has any credibility these days😂

@muhammadalimalik337 Ай бұрын

Hi Zionist

@rhyscruz Ай бұрын

@@muhammadalimalik337Hi radical islamist

@mr.comments7017 Ай бұрын

@@muhammadalimalik337 hello terrorist supporter

@twandamhof3517 Ай бұрын

They do? lol

@aimanmarzuqi4804 Ай бұрын

Except they do. Just because they call out Israel's actions doesn't make them suddenly wrong

@Ace-ye5ei Ай бұрын

Recent developments are covered in somewhat good manner. Two historical discrepancies are there. 1. In the first war, Pakistan invaded Kashmir. Since Kashmir was not part of India then, India held back any military operations. King of Kashmir signed instrument of succession (a UN recognized tool for merging into a country) with India, then only Indian forces entered Kashmir to defend it against Pakistani aggression. 100% legal merger with India. 2. Regarding referendum - UN asked for a referendum, but the pre-condition was that Pakistan and India withdraw their armies from the region. Pakistan never did. Pakistan has always waged proxy war in the region. Sending its military personnel in clothes of local people. So the referendum never happened.

@og2838 Ай бұрын

London is disputed area. UK 🇬🇧 should remove its occupation army from London.

@prateekkackar Ай бұрын

Dude! Some of your stuff is really good! Some is just picked up from biased sources!

@dr.python Ай бұрын

Just choose your side and stick to it. India or dictatorship?

@abdullah45o Ай бұрын

indian occupied kashmir is dictatorship in kashmir people dont have their rights they cant vote to chose which country they want to be part of

@surojeetchatterjee Ай бұрын

They will choose dictatorship & then preach democracy from UK. 😂 funny ppls.

@ahmadqadiri8239 Ай бұрын

I am from Kashmir and i want independence. And no I don't have any love or care or hate or distaste for Pakistanis like i don't with Indians or Chinese. I hate all three of their governments equally. I would rather be a citizen of a free sovereign nation that doesn't get discriminated against or harassed by the army and the government everyday. Every Kashmiri i know has always wanted independence. I don't know where you get your facts from. The war between India and Pakistan and India and China has nothing to do with us but we are used as cattle for their proxy wars.

@ss_avsmt 5 күн бұрын

What's the difference now??

@sohovulture87 Ай бұрын

'...it's like blowing up your house to kill a wasp, when you could just open the window...'. Brilliantly descriptive. Very informative and interesting, thanks for that. One can't help but feel for the poor people who actually live there.

@Saiitejareddy Ай бұрын

Pakistan and bangladesh are also part of greater india befire 1947 just because some people converted to islam doesnt make the history false.

@ranfak Ай бұрын

Greater India rule by British lol. Let’s bring back Britain

@islammehmeov2334 Ай бұрын

India belongs to MUSLAM like the MUGHAL EMPIRE

@ssmsgaming7289 Ай бұрын

like mongols 😅😊😂

@darkgalaxy5548 Ай бұрын

No, India and Bangladesh was part of Greater Pakistan before 1947.

@Prince-ox5im Ай бұрын

@@darkgalaxy5548 great pakistan my ass

@TheStuffedIguana Ай бұрын

Fun fact: it's also a belter of a curry house near Bradford University.

@twilightwyrm Ай бұрын

I need to make a correction here: "The strong do as they will, the weak suffer what they must" is paraphrasing the greek historian Thucydides, not Machiavelli from several centuries later. While Machiavelli might well have been familiar with the quote, and its sentiment or the equivalent doubtlessly included in his thinking on matters of statecraft, The Prince (his more infamous work) does not reference the quote, and would find statecraft unduly based on the maxim to be bad statecraft.

@StoicPrince1674 Ай бұрын

Quoting Omar Abdullah on Kashmiri issues is like quoting Marjorie Taylor Greene on USA's issues

@gp-1542 Ай бұрын

Being sandwiched between three powers is such terrible luck

@PiousMoltar Ай бұрын

And your other neighbour is Afghanistan, as if it couldn't get any worse

@Asura_clan Ай бұрын

Actually Afghanistan and Taliban treets us as brothers I don't know on first America is our partner and Afghanistan is our brother Don't ask me how @@PiousMoltar

@Asura_clan Ай бұрын

While only two neighbour in the entire region is your trusted ally while surrounded by dick heads First we have America our strategic partner and second Afghanistan and Taliban as brothers I don't know they treet us like brother. @@PiousMoltar

@buddy6437 Ай бұрын

You mean two powers and one pauper?

@biggpicture2930 Ай бұрын

Especially when a nation has certain plan..... Abrogation of 370 was the first step in erasing Kashmiris from the land. Greater India is very similar to Greater Israel. Washington Post The New Alliance Between India and Israel”, published in February 2023 wrote on October 11, this year in an article: “Over the past decade, India and Israel have grown increasingly closer as partners and allies…Ties have blossomed under [Indian] Prime Minister’s Narendra Modi and [Israeli Prime Minister] Benjamin Netanyahu, with India and Israel using similar tactics in the occupied territories of Kashmir and the Palestinian territories…seizing lands, displacing people, criminalising dissent, muzzling journalists, and controlling people’s movements…Zionism and Hindutva [Hindu Nationalism] in controlling Palestine and Kashmir…whereas Israel wants to erase Palestinians, India has for decades, used assimilation as a tactic to control Kashmir. Now it is a lot more open to erasing Kashmiris”.

@AlanDugdale-bh4lc Ай бұрын

This channel is great for stripping out the bias of many news channels but it does make me despair for the human race. Apes with dangerous weapons and complete disregard for the people who actually suffer. Same all over the world, very sad

@dre_withwithout Ай бұрын

I remember the news of the iron rod fights being a quick blur in the news.

@rishidubey8745 Ай бұрын

Kashmir, Aksai Chin, and PoK are Indian territories, and China annexed both Inner and Outer Tibet. No amount of propaganda can change this fact

@The_SkullKnight Ай бұрын

This is like a dramatic reinterpretation of everything happened. It feels like its entirely based on BBC kind of coverage of and it doesn't surprise me tbh

@markgrehan3726 Ай бұрын

Explanation?

@karandullet380 Ай бұрын

BBC is one of the most curroupted news organization out these purposefully providing propganda for its benefactors and its been proven many times as well hence people don't trust their info anymore @@markgrehan3726

@Futuremodi Ай бұрын

@@markgrehan3726 he omitted the exodus of Kashmiri pundits. He omitted how the Indian govt is trying their best to develop kashmir but like in palestine which has the hamas consuming the aids given to them to build tunnels Indian kashmir has such extremists in powerful positions. The ones who got house arrested before the removal of article 370 were such extremists. He omitted that. He omitted the current situation of Indian kashmir where smart cities are being built, investments, even from Dubai are flocking in, tourism is prospering. Indian army stays there with an iron fist cos whatever India does Kashmiri people are easy to be fooled cos they think with their religion and not with their brain. It's sad but true. Kashmir was once a land of Hindu yogis but these people drove them out(latest being the exodus of Kashmiri Pundits) and populated there. India rn is trying its best to calm things down but BBC will always focus on the negative sides just like this guy did.

@surojeetchatterjee Ай бұрын

@@markgrehan3726 bald Simon is living in UK & barking from there against worlds biggest democracy.

@biggpicture2930 Ай бұрын

Maybe based on US's? Abrogation of 370 was the first step in erasing Kashmiris from the land. Greater India is very similar to Greater Israel. Washington Post The New Alliance Between India and Israel”, published in February 2023 wrote on October 11, this year in an article: “Over the past decade, India and Israel have grown increasingly closer as partners and allies…Ties have blossomed under [Indian] Prime Minister’s Narendra Modi and [Israeli Prime Minister] Benjamin Netanyahu, with India and Israel using similar tactics in the occupied territories of Kashmir and the Palestinian territories…seizing lands, displacing people, criminalising dissent, muzzling journalists, and controlling people’s movements…Zionism and Hindutva [Hindu Nationalism] in controlling Palestine and Kashmir…whereas Israel wants to erase Palestinians, India has for decades, used assimilation as a tactic to control Kashmir. Now it is a lot more open to erasing Kashmiris”.

@silenttoxic707 Ай бұрын

Cracked me up at "what the hell is going on?"

@AarStark Ай бұрын

Simon it would have been great if you just listed out the UN Resolution 47 once. What is the first point written there? I reckon you chose to be ignorant or its just lazy research work.

@therationalhuman9874 19 күн бұрын

0:12 You left Aksai Chin out of Jammu & Kashmir here!

@ChekovsSplaser Ай бұрын

I've never heard more audible air quotes than that "liberated" at 9:22

@Mullins23 Ай бұрын

China has no claims to Tibet or Kashmir

@riteshbavad8354 Ай бұрын

Kashmir was defined by volatility, fragility etc before 2019. Currently tourism has boomed in the Kashmir valley, businesses are sustainable, there is infrastructural development and well as investments in Kashmir has risen. Dubai's Emaar group is planning a $60M shopping complex. Kashmir is now open to opportunities like rest of India.

@barkhapradhan6739 Ай бұрын

'China LIBERATED Tibet' 'India ANNEXED Kashmir' Dude either doesn't know what he is talking about or he DOES KNOW what he is saying.

@biggpicture2930 Ай бұрын

It is the truth.

@biggpicture2930 Ай бұрын

Abrogation of 370 was the first step in erasing Kashmiris from the land. Greater India is very similar to Greater Israel. Washington Post The New Alliance Between India and Israel”, published in February 2023 wrote on October 11, this year in an article: “Over the past decade, India and Israel have grown increasingly closer as partners and allies…Ties have blossomed under [Indian] Prime Minister’s Narendra Modi and [Israeli Prime Minister] Benjamin Netanyahu, with India and Israel using similar tactics in the occupied territories of Kashmir and the Palestinian territories…seizing lands, displacing people, criminalising dissent, muzzling journalists, and controlling people’s movements…Zionism and Hindutva [Hindu Nationalism] in controlling Palestine and Kashmir…whereas Israel wants to erase Palestinians, India has for decades, used assimilation as a tactic to control Kashmir. Now it is a lot more open to erasing Kashmiris”.

@biggpicture2930 Ай бұрын

india erase life.. china improve life.

@swapnaneeldas3227 28 күн бұрын

@@biggpicture2930 lol let me guess,pakistani?you don't say the truth🤣🤣🤣

@strikeeagle360 Ай бұрын

great video as usual :D

@prakash86anish Ай бұрын

Countless Pakistani channels openly show the harsh reality of Gilgit Baltistan (GB) and PoK. Even Pakistani podcasters talk about the suffering and exploitation of people living in PoK & GB. Strange how the video did not even attempt to cover PoK and Gilgit Baltistan.

@prakash86anish Ай бұрын

Also @9:23 'China liberated Tibet'! LOL!

@mike-oj7sy Ай бұрын

Pok GB bolte ja Aranchal Ladkh Sikkim Manipur gawate jao 😅😅😅@@prakash86anish

@klintonunited Ай бұрын

Kashmir belongs to India , I’m American and a historian

@mike-oj7sy Ай бұрын

Say it again without crying 😂😂😂😂

@aliozanerbektas Ай бұрын

I think we all unalived in 2012 and now we're living in hell...

@SFray-sf7gr 10 күн бұрын

The only Kashmir I care about is “Oh, let the sun beat down upon my face, stars fill my dreams. I am a traveler in both time and space, to be where I have been.”

@Advaitamanta Ай бұрын

kashmir produced tantra Philosphy, trika philosophy. there's no kashmir without kashmir shaivism. kashmir's greatest man/saint is abhinavgupta who was one of the greatest hindu polymath buddha. kashmir's greatest king is Laliltadtiya who slayed muslims and defeated calipahtes. kashmir's essence is hindu and will remain hindu. if given a choice kashmir would definitely not going to choose pakistan. they have seen the condition of pok. budget of kashmir is higher than pakistan's entire aukat. no kashmiri want to go to Middle Ages. sooner or later kashmiri will denounce islam and embrace their aborginal superior faith of shaivism. it has already begun.

@ibrahimsalman5504 Ай бұрын

@@Advaitamanta cowpiss has got to bros brains frfr

@shayan.a Ай бұрын

lol

@zaraf Ай бұрын

Such delusion is truly comical.

@Advaitamanta Ай бұрын

@@shayan.a why do you people name your missile after the people of Afgan, Turk, Iran and India. A country that celebrates foreign invader Quasim instead of their own Raja Dahir. Pakistan is an abomination on the brink of a collapse. Kbhi America ka kutta bn k Iran pr attack, kbhi China ka kutta bn kr India pr.

@Advaitamanta Ай бұрын

@@shayan.a kzbin.info/www/bejne/f4e5oaOjhNZjoZIsi=LoPArSrjB_yjIRb- Lol

@Jay_Frank Ай бұрын

I have to say, I like the channel name change.

@avinashchaudhary8545 Ай бұрын

India and Pakistan fighting for Kashmir China: silently taking aksai chin

@biggpicture2930 Ай бұрын

"We maldivians see india as an aggressor, boading maldivian fishing vessels inside maldivian waters"

@rahul0898 Ай бұрын

@@biggpicture2930Ok then give our 4 billion dollars beggers 😂😂

@swapnaneeldas3227 28 күн бұрын

@biggpicture2930 and then start promoting UPI in that failed island🤣🤣🤣

@avinashchaudhary8545 27 күн бұрын

@@swapnaneeldas3227 bruh he's just pakistani with fake id beware of those beggars

@segfault4568 Ай бұрын

A few things: 1. People of Gilgit Baltistan are ethnically different from rest of Kashmir, Indian Kashmiris are also ethnically different and only about 40k of indian Kashmiris reside in Pakistan's (Azad Kashmir). Pakistani Kashmiris are ethnically Northern Punjabis (Pahari-Pothwaris). 2. Pakistan does treat Kashmiris better in my opinion, They are free to buy land all over Pakistan and have quotes in Federal Government but a Pakistani National cannot buy land or hold any position in Kashmir. 3. During the start of first war of Kashmir both Indian and Pakistani Armies were still under British high command, they both refused to send in regular troops. Pakistan however sent in Pashtun militia instead, they did find some initial success but soon turned into looting and r-ping local Kashmiris they were meant to liberate, This gave Indian side of British command cause to pitch in regular troops while Pakistani side still wasn't able to for a long time, As soon as snows started the Militia started to go home anyway with war loot and they were quite easy pickings for regular Indian Army.

@asce634 Ай бұрын

Dude if u look at the Indian state of Jammu Kashmir and Pakistan’s state of Kashmir u see which state is booming in tourist economy. And recently they r going through an election now showing that they have democracy there

@भारतीयहिंदू1 Ай бұрын

Indian state of Kashmir get 40million visitors Around 84 infrastructure projects has completed worth 1800cr ( triple it to convert into pakistani currency) Per capita of REAL KASHMIRI IS MORE THAN PAKISTANI SIDE.

@muzamilraza49 Ай бұрын

@@asce634Rampant internet blackouts Limited freedom of movement not having any control of their territory. Yeah😅

@RR-pc7yv Ай бұрын

@@muzamilraza49 Today Kashmir enjoys 5G network and those days of blackouts are long gone now...

@muzamilraza49 Ай бұрын

@@RR-pc7yv According to international reports from 2020 to 2024 Indian administered Kashmir has experienced 254 internet black-outs. And according to human rights Watch India shut off the internet in Kashmir for 500 days from 2019 to 2021 which is one of the highest in the world.

@ignitionfrn2223 Ай бұрын

1:05 - Chapter 1 - A brief history of kashmir 9:00 - Chapter 2 - Crouching china, hidden baton 13:30 - Chapter 3 - What's in a claim ? 20:45 - Chapter 4 - The legacy of kashmir

@0anant0 Ай бұрын

What, neighbors are fighting? Well, a Britisher must have passed by.

@rowancrouch4789 Ай бұрын

Fighting is a long part of south Asia's history

@pandibbarman Ай бұрын

Because it was very peaceful before that no fighting between kingdoms

@surojeetchatterjee Ай бұрын

@@pandibbarman less than Europe atleast.

@harshraj6219 Ай бұрын

Pakistan took a loan of $7billion to repay previous loans and India just invested $10billion in Kashmir. ~Rajnath Singh

@mike-oj7sy Ай бұрын

Laskher Taiba takes responsibility after attack labour of tunnel construction recently in Kashmir 😅😅

@harshraj6219 29 күн бұрын

@@mike-oj7sy but India won't stop construction and west still won't accept that Pakistan is hosting terrorism

@kunaldeo9679 Ай бұрын

Ah yes I see Simon is choosing death by covering South Asia. Just kidding he's probably getting tonnes of views from ranging Indians, I'd know I am one. And too all those getting pissed at the maps being used, first of all these are the international maps so yes they'll use these instead of the domestic ones in India, second of all tbh I don't know what the actual map is anymore. I have no idea whether the parts of Kashmir shown as parts on India on our maps are still under Indian control. Last I heard there was quite a lot of Chinese encroachment in Ladakh.

@dpm2312 Ай бұрын

Kashmir is India's. Period. We will always retain Kashmir.

@mike-oj7sy Ай бұрын

Not more than 5 years 😂 Kahlistan knocking the door in your country 😅😂😂😂

@dpm2312 Ай бұрын

@@mike-oj7sy let's reconnect after 5 years and see who's right

@Buzyideas Ай бұрын

16:40 Adding more context on Pakistan story (Total joke.) When Pakistan tried to annex Kashmir and India, on signing the treaty with Hari Singh retaliated, India was the first party to go to UN to resolve the issue. UN then, devised a three step solution for Kashmir. First - Ceasefire (Both party stopped war at that time.) Second - Pakistan troops to recede from Kashmir and back to orignal border lines because Pakistan was the aggressor first in the region. (Pakistan never did hence and created PoK or Pakistan Occupied Kashmir) Third - Plebiscite (Never happened because second part of the solution never happened). You can refer the referendum for more. But this was the gist of it. The Plebiscite to be conducted gave Kashmiris, 3 choices. To be with India, merge with Pakistan and form their own country. This referendum also served as the first hope of Kashmir to become a country rather than a state in India or Pakistan. Despite what my heart says as an Indian, The decision is their own citizens.

@rayroa12 Ай бұрын

All Muslim occupiers must get out of the Indian Subcontinent.

@wajhussain786able Ай бұрын

The UN did not give the right for independence, they were to decide whether they wanted to go with india or Pakistan

@biggpicture2930 Ай бұрын

Why india disrespect UN's map... India sitting illegally on...

@rayroa12 Ай бұрын

@@biggpicture2930 Muslims need to vacate Hindustan and go back to central Asia and Persia where they came from. UN has no authority on any sovereign country.

@OCuinn1981 Ай бұрын

“Oh, pilot of the storm who leaves no trace Like thoughts inside a dream Here is the path that led me to that place Yellow desert stream My Shangri-La beneath the summer moon I will return again Sure as the dust that floats high in June When movin' through Kashmir”-Led Zeppelin

@lukecreamer8426 Ай бұрын

Simon understated the reality of the situation in Kashmir when he said it's the first time any state has fought with melee weapons in the 21st century. It's the first time in hundreds of years that that many men have assembled to brawl so savagely - they weren't even using archers and catapults, that might set it back thousands of years.

@mitchlinnen2228 Ай бұрын

Simon, I can tell from your jiggling jacket that you're bouncing your leg under the table. I also wish that this didn't distract me so much; I absolutely was not listening 😂

@BornKafir Ай бұрын

Only viable solution is to accept that Kashmir is now divided. Just like bengal, and punjab. Time to move forward, South Asia!

@matthewvalenti1348 Ай бұрын

crazy that they made that place from a Led Zeppelin song into a real thing

@abhaybhandary7010 Ай бұрын

Whatever political spectrum u are on in india every single indian should thank Modi for what he has done to get kashmir👏🏻

@razorburn645 Ай бұрын

Unless you're not Indian.

@musaib69 Ай бұрын

As a kashmiri he has done nothing just fooled all of you.

@Asianrepresentative Ай бұрын

@@musaib69 chuslami bot spotted 🤡

@abhaybhandary7010 Ай бұрын

@@musaib69 9 medical colleges; 1.5 million tap connections; 8 million Ayushman cards; 0.2 million homes; 0.8 million toilets; 65 million tourist footfall; 81% decrease in terror incidents; 30% increase in school days; 9000 km roads - since 370 abrogation I'm pretty sure you're either pakistani or aren't well read on what he's done.

@prakritimishra2997 Ай бұрын

@@musaib69 aap Pakistani Panjab se ho na?

@stephenmogaka3454 Ай бұрын

A very interesting video. One important point, the quote is by Thucydides not Machiavelli

@free_at_last8141 Ай бұрын

Kashmir: "We want independence!" Pakistan: "See India, Kashmir wants independence from you! They want to be a part of Pakistan!" India: "See Pakistan, Kashmir wants independence from you! They want to be a part of India!"

@JohnAdams-vd5dc Ай бұрын

That's not true at all. Gross oversimplification of facts including genocide of the original habits of Kashmir which by the way were not Muslim. Do better.

@GrievousReborn Ай бұрын

@@JohnAdams-vd5dc 🎶 smallest 🎻

@free_at_last8141 Ай бұрын

@@JohnAdams-vd5dc "Do better?" Did you really end with "do better?" Good Lord, Poe's law personified.

@bvedant Ай бұрын

They'd ideally like complete autonomy but they claim if they were under one of them that Pakistan would be better for them, and IMO besides religious tolerance (for Muslims), don't really know why.

@introvertidiot1502 Ай бұрын

@@free_at_last8141 well, he is correct about the first part regardless of the end. But yeah, it was taken a bit too seriously

@005civ_ibrahimsalaria2 Ай бұрын

As a Kashmiri, I glad the perspective of the people has been included. We do indeed want to be free from all three, to build our nation and achieve our deserved peace.

@satyamjee-yz1ul Ай бұрын

ok tell, me once you become free what are you gonna do?? how will you boom your economy and what if pakistan attacks you, what if china claims you what you will do?? huh, kucch bhi bologe?? free nation karna is a very very very very big task..you have to see every possibilities this is not like a game.. and yeah mat kehna tourism ke dam par chal jayegi aapki poori economy, milit. ke liye India,pakistan yah china ke paas hi jaaoge fir bhi controlled hi rahoge.. isliye be happy wherever you are.

@adheeshbharat2644 Ай бұрын

@@satyamjee-yz1ul let me handle this,I actually live in Indian administered Kashmir and look at the progress thats happened.

@not_k2 Ай бұрын

I like the "neutrality". Being an Indian citizen, it's not easy to see Kashmir discussed by other nations as if it were a territory our government has colonized. But also not being a Kashmiri, I have learned that the people of Kashmir may well want to be independent.

@l3176l Ай бұрын

It’s hard to find good sources of info on such a politicized topic. :(

@silverfish2380 Ай бұрын

realistically india can't leave Kashmir, i know humanity and thing but as a nation its in Indian interest to control kashmir.

@lakshaymittal4257 Ай бұрын

nothing would go wrong when a contested region between three nations goes independent

@ronkledonkanusmoncher564 Ай бұрын

India didn’t come there with the explicit intent of colonizing the area but they have become the defacto military dictators of the area for decades now.

@arunsheokand2527 Ай бұрын

Independence is not an option for Kashmir

@SirNekoSama Ай бұрын

bro, your vids are so good

@ashurathi9286 Ай бұрын

China annexex Tibet and killed so many Tibetan Buddhists. Pakistan raped and killed so many Kashmiris in 1948 invasion. Hari Singh and Omar Abdullah signed documents and formally joined us. Our soldiers died for Kashmir now how can we leave from there? Everywar that was done, always was initiated by China or Pak first not once by us. India even offered Plebiscite but it was impossible because quite a chunk of population is stuck in Pakistan occupied Kashmir and without them plebiscite would have no meaning. So, India asked Pak to move back but they never did thats why it is a stuck situation. Now if any Pakistani or Chinese or pseudo intellectual person wants to argue with me, they should first do a basic google if they have it jn their area, then come and argue.

@biggpicture2930 Ай бұрын

United States Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) gets detailed briefing by Fermand De Varennes, United Nations's Special Rapporteur on Minority Issues on India's blatant, massive, systematic and extremely dangerous targeted killings, marginalization and genocide of religious minorities including Muslims, Sikhs, Christians and other minorities under the supervision of India's Prime Minister Narendra Modi. The report highlights the dark reality and the real face of Narendra's Modi's Hindutva led ideological plans for India along with his vicious intentions to create an imaginary normalcy around events of targeted marginalization, killings, riots, abductions, arrests and intolerance. USCIRF exposes Modi's government and its real agenda behind the annexation of the state of Jammu and Kashmir (J&K) in 2019, criminal negligence and ignorance towards the genocide in Manipur and the most recent incident of killing of Hardeep Singh Nijjar in Canada.

@biggpicture2930 Ай бұрын

Let's see how much land this thief in India has stolen from his neighbors. ---Annexed Kalapani from Nepal in 1962; ---Annexed Turtuk from Pakistan in 1971; ---Separated Eastern Pakistan from Pakistan to become Bangladesh in 1971; ---Annexed Tin Bigha from Bangladesh in 1972; ---Annexed Sikkim to become one of its states in 1975; ---Tried to invade Mauritius but failed in 1983; ---Committed massacres of Sikhism, captured their territories and attacked Harmandir Sahib so Sikhism believers assassinated Indian Prime Minister Indira Gandhi in 1984; ---Invaded Sri Lanka in 1987; ---1st time invaded Bhutan and failed in 1990 due to international pressure, but has controlled its defense and diplomatic affairs till now; ---Supported and financed the terrorist organization Tamil LTTE to rebel against Sri Lanka government but gave it up later under great international pressure. The betray triggered huge anger of LTTE so it assassinated its Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi in 1991; ---Annexed Dooars from Bhutan in 2006; ---Annexed Moreh from Myanmar in 2013; ---2nd time invaded Bhutan but failed in 2017 due to international pressure; ---Tried to invade Maldives in 2018; ---Invaded Nepal and one of its soldiers was shot dead by Nepal Security force in Jun of 2020; ---Keeps nibbling lands from ChinaTibett and Kashmir that led to a war in 1962 and border conflicts with China till today; ---Keeps nibbling lands from Pakistan Kashmir that led to daily border wars and gun fights; ---And more….

@biggpicture2930 Ай бұрын

My searches show India is an aggressor.

@cvineethr Ай бұрын

You lost me at " Washington post " @@biggpicture2930

@RK-ln6kg Ай бұрын

Kashmir has and will always belong to India.

@atharpandit7160 Ай бұрын

Let us Kashmiris decide it and Indians have no right to speak on our behalf and our struggle for self determination will continue despite all your military might and oppression

@mike-oj7sy Ай бұрын

Kashmir belongs to Abu 🇵🇰

@ddvn7128 Ай бұрын

The last part of the video is beyond the limits of delusion. Pakistan can't risk a nuclear escalation with india, With its current stockpile of low yield nukes, it is a well documented fact that india has much higher yield nuclear armaments and a nuclear triad to wipe out Pakistan in any such situation. India also has overall much more resources at its hand to forecast any such event. Also Pakistan will never have further control over Kashmir, Jammu and Kashmir is not just a muslim majority area, It's a diverse region with Hindu majority in Jammu and Buddhists and Shias in Ladakh. Moreover it is much more likely that Pakistan may lose its illegal control over Balochistan region that it continuously keeps impoverished.

@mike-oj7sy Ай бұрын

High on sasta nasha ganja. 🤡 Khalistan creations ready in india Punjab Haryna Himachal 😅

@mike-oj7sy Ай бұрын

Khalistan in India be like : Knock knock my boys 🇮🇳 😅😅😅

@rtyrsson Ай бұрын

You rightly point out the religious/cultural divide in this issue between India and Pakistan; and that Beijing's quite flimsy claims to certain portions of Kashmir are based on Buddhist and cultural connections. However, let us remember, Communism is practically a secular religion, if not in fact. Many communist dictatorships have made some terrible and horrifying geopolitical decisions based purely on communist ideology, and not on rational thought. And make no mistake, communist China is indeed a dictatorship. The few remaining churches and temples in China (per capita) have recently been forced to remove any pictures or icons of Christian and Buddhist figures and replace them with portraits of Xi Jinping; and "Xi Jinping Thought" is the enforced philosophy of the country. So... will China make a move based purely on ideology, even though there is not a religious component? Yes, this is quite possible. It may not be economically or politically beneficial to China, but to a communist, ideology alone is its own goal. Based on this theory, I think India would be wise to increase military spending and plan accordingly. They have some breathing room, given their focus at present is Taiwan... the free China.

@ranfak Ай бұрын

Now you are lying . People who have visited china say otherwise . if you go by that logic capitalism have destroyed more cultures aswell. and you hijack capitalism with democratic to define you high horse . Wake up people no longer case you definition of democracy lol. Each nation have their own kind of democracy and people like America or from India try to point out other as dictator .

@sleelofwpg688 Ай бұрын

Seriously? LiBeRaTeD Tibet... -.-

@devanshsharma5757 Ай бұрын

gotta get those ccp propaganda funds😊

@Talisguy Ай бұрын

@@devanshsharma5757 It's a joke. The pause is for air quotes.

@GrievousReborn Ай бұрын

@@devanshsharma5757 have you even watched his other channels where he's made videos criticizing China

@razorburn645 Ай бұрын

Sarcasm you rotten turnip.

@multiyapples Ай бұрын

I hope the Kashmir situation is resolved peacefully.

@ozymandias7372 Ай бұрын

@iycaus257 Ай бұрын

@@ozymandias7372Sir you're living in dreams, also economy of PoK is worse but IoK has not face no tragedies at all.

@jeneric989 Ай бұрын

Comments are angry Simon can’t recite the entire history of Pakistan, India, and China by memory and that he doesn’t know their mothers maiden name. Due to this failure he is a British and or American spy.

@markgrehan3726 Ай бұрын

Don't forget he's also an agent of the PLA.

@shaurya3430 16 күн бұрын

7:56 😂😂 ironical Mumbai 2008 Delhi 2001 Uri 2016 Does it ring a bell?

@RajneeshSingh-i5t Ай бұрын

Pakistani army never won a war but always win election. 😂😂😂

@SSMasseus Ай бұрын

bla bla

@techinsider3611 Ай бұрын

Kashmir is also a source of fresh water for these three countries so this is not just a history problem. Who ever controls kashmir controls source of fresh water.

@aayushthorat314 Ай бұрын

0:22- No the Kashmir people do not want independence. Unless all of your reporting comes from the actual terrorists of Kashmir every poll done independantly or by the government of India has confirmed that Kashmir's want to remain a part of India. Do Not Misrepresent people you know nothing about.

@hardinrace. Ай бұрын

😅 we will be independent,we want independence , kashmir only belongs to kashmiri people, pandiths,Sikhs .

@openlyracist8055 Ай бұрын

Most ar muslim, only the non Muslim minority want to stay in India, the rest want neither you or Pakistan.

@salmanwani8827 Ай бұрын

So why not hold the well promised plebiscite promised to us Kashmiris by Indian government? That would clear everything up 🌝

@mohitbhardwaj3532 Ай бұрын

Yeah man as always these western countries shows biased towards India with no on grounds subject knowledge while peddling along the narrative of terrorists(Pakistan) and refers it more legitimate, which is a complete bias if not a joke. He didn't mention foreign country diplomats visited Kashmir valley this September and just before that An American delegation paid visit to NCs Omar Abdullah on August 24. I'm sure this video made after 24 August. In this video he hasn't even shown a single video or clip from Pojk and gilgit baltistan(because no international media allowed to). All they shown are 7-12 years old Indian videos. He don't Mind pay attention to what happened b/w May 11-14 this year in Mirpur and Muzaffarabad Pojk and see it for himself.

@anurag_mck Ай бұрын

@@salmanwani8827 Last time I read, the plebiscite was to be held after the Pakistani army leaves PoK and the Indian army secures the borders.😊

@ABUIZZAOFFICIAL092 Ай бұрын

I'm a Kashmiri I want free Kashmir no occupation 😢

@Sar-dard Ай бұрын

yes we also want but tum jao baha se pakistan chale jao kuki wo muslim majrity desh hai maje se rhao fir baha ja ker, kuki kashmir is land of india ,

@antojose6902 Ай бұрын

You are not a Kashmiri get lost

@abhinav7sinha Ай бұрын

how can that determination happen when most of Kshmiris who want to live in India were either murdered or thrown out of their homes

@tristarknights Ай бұрын

It's crazy for me to think that just because your a nuclear powered Nation does not mean you're a superpower, also becoming a nuclear powered Nation paints you a Target and usually forces you into some sort of treaty or alliance.

@CedarHunt Ай бұрын

Simply having nuclear weapons has never made a country a superpower.

@tristarknights Ай бұрын

@@CedarHunt yes and no

@ManiaMac1613 Ай бұрын

Britain is an interesting example of a superpower that became weaker after acquiring nuclear weapons.

@karandullet380 Ай бұрын

Good thing India isn't in any keeps us relatively independent offorgine influence