Kashmir को India में नहीं मिलाना चाहते थे Sardar Patel, फिर किसने उनकी सोच बदली? | Patel Vs Nehru

Much has been said about Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel's differences on the annexation of Kashmir to the Indian Union. We will tell you where they agreed and disagreed through the medium of this video.
What is the story in history? Both Gandhi and Nehru wanted Kashmir to be included with India. But what did Patel want? VP Menon was Mountbatten's political advisor. He has a book written - 'The Story of the Integration of the Indian States'. It has written in detail that what is the story behind the native princely states that were merged in India at the time of Partition. There is a contradiction in Patel's words as somewhere he says that he has no differences with Nehru while somewhere he disagrees. Once again, the same Patel says that the Kashmir problem would be solved, but could not solve it because of Nehru. Sometimes they disagree on the decision to go to the UN, sometimes they defend it. Sometimes he says that the ceasefire was not right. Had the army not been sent from Banihal to Poonch, then things would have been settled.
Watch the video to know the complete story.
#SardarPatel #PatelOnKashmir #NehruOnKashmir
Install The Lallantop Android App: thelallantop.a...
Follow us on: / thelallantop
Like The Lallantop on Facebook: / thelallantop
Follow The Lallantop on Twitter: / thelallantop
For advertisements e-mail us at: [e-mail]
Produced By: The Lallantop
Edited By: Radhe Shyam

[@TheLallantop]

दी लल्लनटॉप का ऐंड्रॉयड ऐप इंस्टॉल करिए और फीडबैक दीजिए: play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.thelallantop

[@NITYANSHBHARDWAJ]

nikhil Ji aapki maine to Nehru aur Patel ke beech matbhed tabhi maine jaate jab Patel Ji khule kaam Nehru Ji ki baaten cut karete. kya Patel Ji ne Nehru Ji ke. PM hone ka samman rakha to galat kiya?

[@ashishprajapat4624]

Lallan top congress ki gaand chatate rahta he

[@humanists55]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/lWSrd4Gnm9Sln68 Hear this ,real speech of Patelji on Kashmir... Lallantop had Hoti h kuchchh bhi bakwaash krne ki

[@surajwaykule8695]

Bilkul ek trafa

[@chetansingh6080]

I have noticed Lallantop channel recently has started very sutlely favouring one party in opposition and have started demeaning the Govt of the day...Its not just this reporter..others...please be unbaised... otherwise what is the difference

[@rishisheikhar1630]

सरदार साहब ने कभी भी देश की एक इंच ज़मींन छोड़ने की न बात की ,और ना ऐसा सोंचा! जय जय सरदार साहब

[@MrBhadoriya]

सच्चाई जान ले नेहरु और पटेल दोनो पक्के कांग्रेसी थे पटेल ने बीजेपी ज्वाइन नही की थी 😀

[@shivamishra2338]

@@MrBhadoriya fir bhi congress party ne unake contribution ko kabhi acknowledge hi nahi kiya ....

[@druvshuka3132]

@@shivamishra2338 sab congressi hai itna bht hai 😁😁

[@shivamishra2338]

@@druvshuka3132 suno tab ki congress ab ki congress bahut antar hai . Ab ek family hai bas congress

[@INSRaptorOp]

​@@shivamishra2338 ye kisne kah diya tumse😂😂😂

[@rampratapmishra1353]

लौह पुरुष सरदार वल्लभ भाई पटेल को शत शत नमन

[@kpbansal2406]

पटेल जी की सोच आज भी देश की एकता में शक्ति दे रही है

[@andhbhaktonkabaap8931]

Tabhi toh patel bah atankwadiiiii hai

[@maahimann64]

Nahi , Sardar kii soch ke naam par aaj desh ko kucch 50 lac crore ka chuna lag chukaa hai , ( Bade industrialists ke paas fd ki gayi hai ) des 50 saal pichhe kar diyaa gayaa hai aur Sardar ki ektaa tahas - nahas ki gayi hai.

[@anilokukiw5930]

@@maahimann64 source dedo ki 50 lac crore ka chuna lag gaye.....mtlb kaha ka data h zara batana 😁

[@bhrajpoot272]

कुछ भी कर लो......कभी भी सरदार पटेल की अहमियत कम नहीं होगी। सरदार पटेल भारत माता का वीर सपूत और अनमोल रतन थे।

[@humanworld7774]

Practically pak se bat krke kashmir issue solve krna chahiye y india k lie bhtr hai pakistan ka kya unko economy se Lena nhi hme hai security pr billions of dollars kharch krne pdte hai sirf kashmir valley me 8 lakh army hai or vo mrte hai to pension alag se or Russia central Asia eu se trade bhi nhi krskte Pakistan k raste se isse billions nuksan hota hai pak k sath trade🤔🧐😐 Hme ise solve krna chahiye dono jagah k kashmir valley ko alag desh bna Dena chahiye Jammu laddakh india or gilgit baltistan pak rkhle practical solutions se fayda hoga😐🧐

[@radhan6424]

सरदार पटेल, जवाहरलाल नेहरू और महात्मा गांधी ये तीनों महान लोग हमारे स्वतंत्रता संग्राम के त्रिमूर्ति थे।

[@kamaljeetsingh3817]

Anmol Ratan to vo h Sardar Patel ko tum RRS Sanghi apne vote bank ke liye acha bolate ho patel to khud bolate the ye RRS sanghi desh ke liye khatra h

[@DigvijaySinghRathore-s7x]

Right

[@White_Devil153]

Patel ji ne RSS ko ban kiya tha kyonki RSS ki kartoot hi aisi thi😅😅😅

[@itsnevertoolate0001]

सरदार पटेल भारत का एक अनमोल हीरा थे। वे नहीं होते तो शायद आज का भारत भी नहीं होता।🇮🇳सरदार पटेल को नमन 🙏🙏

[@shamimahmad5816]

Arey bhaia Gandhi ji ko bilkul hi bhool gaye?

[@itsnevertoolate0001]

@@shamimahmad5816 गांधी जी को कोई नहीं भूला लेकिन यहां बात भारत की अखंडता की हो रही है, जो की सरदार पटेल की वजह से हैं।

[@indiamylove4833]

Bhai akhnadata tu mughal aur british ki den hain.....hindu kal me india 200 state me bate huye te

[@itsnevertoolate0001]

@@indiamylove4833 भाई अखंडता अंग्रेजो की देन कैसे हुईं, अगर अंग्रेजो ने भारत को एक किया तो फिर आज़ादी के वक्त अंग्रेजो ने 565 रियासतों को ये मौका कैसे दिया की वे अलग हो सकते हैं या पाकिस्तान में जुड़ सकते हैं। अगर भारत एक था तो फिर तो ये सुझाव आ ही नहीं सकता था। और मुगलों की बात यहां कैसे आई अगर मुगलों ने पहली बार एक किया था भारत को तो भाई बता दू कि सबसे पहले चंद्रगुप्त मौर्य ने भारत को एक जुट किया था।

[@chetanjain1918]

हकीकत यह है कि उस वक्त की परिस्थितियों के अनुसार ही निर्णय लिए गये थे. आज बड़ा आसान है सही-गलत ठहराना.

[@aby897]

Sahi bole bhai

[@nikhilalgoudar938]

Sahi hai

[@simy507]

Nucd

[@simy507]

Nicd

[@shubham6374]

Mai aap lsd sahmat hoon Jo aap kaise sochne wale logo ki jarurat hai aaj hamare desh ko

[@jyothivankadari1885]

Koi maane ya naa mane patel was the great person who is my one and only inspiration 🙇🙇

[@reejutasharma4460]

Yes..

[@sanketsdrawings1206]

No .... netaji subhas Chandra was😍😍🥰🥰🥰

[@jyothivankadari1885]

@@sanketsdrawings1206 yeah!!woh bhi the pride of ur country😤

[@poormanzeroman7535]

👍

[@devrajkanji3185]

X ,

[@manveersingh3138]

भाई आपकी बातें तो अच्छी लगी। परन्तु पूरा काश्मीर भारत का हिस्सा होना चाहिए। एसा होना बहुत जरूरी है।

[@shyamsunder2947]

बहुत संतुलित विश्लेषण, आजकल की विभेद व शत्रुता भरी झूठी सच्ची बयानबाजी से अलग, विवेकपूर्ण-- ऐसी शांत समीक्षा के लिए धन्यवाद।

[@drashtithacker8618]

Saradar patel is one of the best.. Person.. Today is say to easy what do patel in his time.. he give your best in his time.. Respect to saradar vallabh bhai patel..iandian ayarn men.. Is best...love you patel sir.. My roll model.. Patel sir🙏🙏

[@utkarshparihar9855]

Thats what narrator is saying if we were not present then we must not blame anybody. And if we want to blame someone then the culprit is fucker jinnah and british who just created problems kashmir,palestine and many more.

[@Toptrending02]

Same goes with Nehru... people should not blame nehru as the situation was not easy at that time...

[@andhkasur]

@@Toptrending02Apni community ko Samjhao ki Desh ko ander se barbad na kare

[@andhkasur]

@@Toptrending02 kzbin.info/www/bejne/iqe7gYmhrJh4adk

[@andhkasur]

@@utkarshparihar9855 kzbin.info/www/bejne/iqe7gYmhrJh4adk

[@secularindia8185]

Janmat Sangrah hona chahiye tha to aasaani se kashmir India ka ho jata. 🇮🇳Jai Hind🇮🇳

[@yogeshdansena1341]

Jai Hind

[@shuklaomprakash8811]

Very informative balanced approach.

[@rahulrajpoot9183]

Ha jese muslman Bharat ko vote dete 🤣🤣

[@realtaker02]

सरदार वल्लभ भाई पटेल सच्चे मायने मैं आज के भारत के जनक है। जो नक्शा आज हम देखते है वो सरदार वल्लभ पटेल की देन है । उन्हें अगर भारत का राष्ट्रपिता कहा जाए तो ये अतिशयोक्ति नही होगी।

[@RameshSingh-zl6uk]

Yadi aap ka bat man liya Jay to aap batay ki Patel ka chunaw PM ke pakchh me tha to nehru ko PM kis liy banaya gaya

[@realtaker02]

@@RameshSingh-zl6uk क्योकि उनके माउंटबेटन से अच्छे संबंध नही थे ।

[@chandrashekharshukla1596]

​@@RameshSingh-zl6uk Gandhi ki wajah se pm nhi ban paye Gandhi ko lgata tha agar nehru ji nhi pm bane to kangress party khatm karwa denge baki Mountbatten se bhi achhe sambandh the Nehru ji ke

[@kamaljeetsingh3817]

@@chandrashekharshukla1596ye bhi h bhai unki Umar us vakat jayada thi or bimari ke karan bhi unko pm nahi banaya or vase bhi thik kiya tha congress ne us vakat jo kaam patel ne kiya us vakat koi or nahi kar sakta tha dono neta Nehru or patel apni apni jagah sahi the desh ke liye acha hi kiya

[@jantawarriors4719]

फेंकते रहो इंडिया का जो भी बना वो 4 5 साल से लगे कई दिमागों की उपज थी अकेले पटेल से कुछ नही हुआ।

[@atdworld]

Sardar Patel had successfully integrated most of the princely states through his power of persuasion but he faced acute difficulty in integrating - Junagadh, Hyderabad and Kashmir. The case of Kashmir was different from other states as it had important international boundaries- to the East was Tibet, to the North-East lay the Sinkiang province of China and to the North-West was Afghanistan.

[@shriranggore5578]

यस यस यस यस यस ... 100 % राईट च संदेश ... धन्यवाद

[@bhagwansharanjaiswal3895]

यह वीडियो biased है

[@rpatel2450]

SARDAR VALLABH BHAI PATEL P.M. HOTA TO YE KASHMIR BHARAT KA HI HOTA. NAHERU GADDAR KI VAJAH OR GANDHI KI VAJAH SE KASHMIR BHARAT KA NAHI HUVA. YE SUB GANDHI OR NAHERU KI GALATI HAI.

[@vsnrajua]

Patel was h minister ,so both Pm Nehuru and Patel gets the cretid, because Nehuru ordered Patel to do the eork

[@dukhanpradadyadav2147]

कश्मीर पर जो निर्णय हुआ वह समय और परिस्थिति का तकाजा है.ऐसा ललन टॉप भी मानता है.हम व्यर्थ में किसी को दोष देते हैं.

[@rajendrasingh-sh2dp]

सरदार पटेल सबसे लोकप्रिय नेता थे देश सदा उनका रिणी रहेगा

[@sanjibkumardash1075]

ये आर्टिकल सरदार पटेल की अहमियत को कम करने की कोशिश हैं। अगर आप को दलील मान लिया जाए तो फील्ड मार्सल मानिक सॉ के इंटरव्यू देख लो वो क्या कहते हैं कश्मीर के बारे में।

[@RahulPatil-fs7bc]

😂😂😂😂 लिंक दे दो

[@Mystylehumanity]

भक्त गण वैसे भी सच हजम नही कर सकते...

[@rajubhaipatel7141]

इसमें क्या सच है सब झूठ ही झूठ परोस रहा है ।

[@bharatyadav4949]

पटेल सिर्फ हरिसिंह को ये बोल रहे थे कि हरिसिंह खुद फैसला करे कि उनको कहाँ जाना है । इसका मतलब ये कैसे हुआ कि पटेल भारत में काशमीर का विलय नही चाहते थे ।

[@shamimahmad5816]

Patel hari singh ki ichhansar chahtey they lekin janmat sangrah ki bhi baat kertey they, janmat sangrah mein kashmir mein muslim aabadi honey ke natey hamarey hath se nikal sakta tha isliye janmat na hona hi hamaarey liye theek tha.

[@well_said7846]

@@shamimahmad5816 bilkul sahi

[@diptyprakashswain1121]

​@@shamimahmad5816yaah patel is iron man ..

[@banesinghbanna3846]

​@@shamimahmad5816 🇮🇳आपने बिल्कुल सही कहा है, परन्तु आज सरदार पटेल को संघ+भाजपा अपने इतिहास में शामिल करने के लिए मनघड़ंत तर्क बनाकर जनता को भ्रमित कर रहे हैं। क्योंकि इनके गिरोह का इतिहास तो देश के साथ गद्दारी का रहा है। सरदार पटेल को आतंकी गोडसे और माफीवीर सावरकर में मिलाकर गोडसे को विश्वगुरु का पद दिलाना चाहते हैं।पटेल भी कांग्रेसी थे,अगर नेहरू जी और गांधी जी को पटेल से नफ़रत होती तो देश के सबसे महत्वपूर्ण पद पर क्यों बैठाते। पटेल और संघ+भाजपा वालों की विचारधारा ही एक दूसरे के विपरित है, पटेल जोड़ने वाले थे, यह तोड़ने वाले हैं। पटेल ने गांधी जी से कहा था कि कश्मीर पाकिस्तान में जाए तो मुझे कोई दिक्कत नहीं है। मुझे यहां के सेव अच्छे लगते हैं, जिन्हें मैं टैक्स देकर मंगवा लिया करूंगा। नेहरू जी ने कहा था कि कश्मीर हमारे दिल की धड़कन है मेरे जीते-जी कश्मीर को पाकिस्तान में शामिल नहीं होने दूंगा। वैसे भी नेहरू जी कश्मीरी पंडित थे इसलिए कश्मीर उनके लिए अतिप्रिय होना लाजमी है। लेकिन इतिहास के गद्दारों (अंग्रेजों के मुखबिरों) की देश द्रोही नस्लें अच्छों को बुरा साबित कर देश को लूटने के लिए तरत-तरह के नुस्खों का अविष्कार करते रहते हैं। आज इनके बेशर्म मुंह ज्वालामुखी बनकर देशभक्तों की शहादतों पर दिन-रात लावा उगलते रहते हैं। 🇮🇳जय हिन्द 🇮🇳

[@bhagwandasprajapati1955]

नेहरू अगर जम्मू-कश्मीर में संघर्ष बिराम की घोषणा रेडियो पर नहीं करते तो सेना जल्द ही जीत जाती

[@shyamsinghrawat2654]

It is very simple, Pakistan was created for Muslims and HINDUstan was for Hindus. Whosoever allowed muslims to remain in HINDUstan was a traitor and had no farsightedness too see that again they will grow to become a majority after a century. How a guest can become owner of your house?

[@nazimayasmeenam2298]

@@shyamsinghrawat2654 Agar teri bat mane to kashmir me 90% Muslim rahne ke bavjud bhi kashmir ko Pakistan me vilay, marge hone kyun nahi diya

[@PraveenKumar-it8vs]

Dik

[@ganeshbanerjee9841]

@@shyamsinghrawat2654 जिनका दिमाग नहीं चलता, वे ऐसे ही सीधी सादी लकीर पर सोचते हैं

[@btsistrash.k-popisgay.4920]

@@nazimayasmeenam2298 Kyunki unhone wahan ke 100% hinduon ko mar ke waha aabadi badhai

[@kamalakarmishra8896]

It is a very good clarification. Both Patel and Nehru were freedom fighters. There was no rift between the two. Difference of opinion always happens but Bapu was their leader who used to sort out their differences. No one should cast any aspersions on our past leaders who were great Patriots.

[@rajankumarsinha6626]

तूं झूठा है।ये कहां का झूठ परोसा रहा है बे बच्चे? सारी सच्चाई बहुत पहले सबूत सहित जनता को मालूम हो चुका है। तुम्हारी सारी बातें झूठ पर आधारित है।चूप रह देशद्रोही लल्लन गदहा।

[@nashimarashaikh6739]

Right

[@Netfreetome]

But lallantop and AajTak both are part of same India today midea family then why they make opposite propoganda on there respective plateforms?

[@sj6986]

For Patel to be a successful Home Minister, he had to have the unwavering support of the PM, irrespective of their differences and that’s exactly what Nehru gave Patel. If any PM undermines the HM then how can the HM be successful? Patel led the way in integrating the princely states in India but Nehru stood by Patel all the way. They were close friends and colleagues, not enemies as some people have tried to portray them.

[@sj6986]

@@NetfreetomeJisko jo news pasand aa jaye - aap Modi bhakt ho ya anti-Modi, Zee chahta hai ki aap unka hi koi channel dekhen jisse ki ad ka paisa unhe milta rahe.

[@hemantojha2850]

Mahabharat teaches that when a leader of a country starts blaming past instead making it better then is no longer 'prajatantra' as it becomes 'rajtantra'.

[@ajitsir1957]

Very true

[@adkm986]

Wrong....apki raahein kidhar se chali h wahi apki manzil btati.....we need to know truth abt our freedom

[@shahbazakram3866]

@@adkm986 i think thanos was ryt He said 'insaan apne past ko zakhmo ki trh khoddta" Aur jab tak ye apne past ko bhula nhi skte tab tak aane wale kal ko apna nhi skte

[@FirstLast-qr6yq]

Ha to kr to rhe he 370 sulta diya CAA aa gya nrc ho rha assam me ucc aane vala he ye bahut important decisions the jo congress muslim appeasement ki vjh se nhi kiya...lekin muslim personal law board, vaqf board, vaqf act 1995 air 2013 le aayi sirf muslim public ko khush krne ke liye madarchox congress

[@Itachil203]

Sahi kaha jaise modi ji hamesha past ko blame karte rehte hain ek mare hue vyakti par parliament me itni arguments hoti hai keval Nehru ji ke upar. Nehru ji se pehle desh zaroori hota h. Nehru ke baare me logon ke man me zeher gholke hoga bhi kya naa desh ki gdp badegi, naa corona jayega, naa development hoga, naa unemployment khatm hi hoga.

[@shriranggore5578]

😀😃😄😁😆👌👌👌👌👌✌🏻✌🏻✌🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻 ... अप्रतिम च संदेश कार्य विश्लेषण ... जम्मूकाश्मिर प्रदेश की * अनसुलझीं समस्या का * ... हिंदुस्थान भारत की * हेडएक का * ... जय जय हिंद हिंदुत्व हिंदुस्थान की जय जय ... जय जय श्रीराम कृष्ण हरी भगवान जनताजनार्दन परमात्मा की जय जय 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@aryavaani8605]

भारत के संबंध में ललनटाॅप के विचार राष्ट्रीय शुद्धता से अधिक वाणिज्यिक होती है जो संतुलन बैठाती दिखती है।अंततः सबके साथ मित्रता भी तो निभानी है।

[@SanjayKumar-cf3bs]

Inko ab pahchan liya gaya hai bhai

[@bhupindersdadhwal443]

Beautiful, balanced presentation, it conveys true historical facts and removes many misconceptions about Patel and Nehru...thanks

[@spsharma8108]

There are several authentic books/documents other than the ones you have referred to. Read them also.

[@VikramSingh-vg7gv]

Name plz....

[@shashank2361]

Any book name please ?

[@prafullamohapatra8417]

@@shashank2361the first q

[@chudasmayashpalsinh9922]

Book name ???

[@ganeshbanerjee9841]

किताब का नाम बताइए

[@geetapandey5325]

It was very tough situations to resolve for Nehru ji & Patel both. Had Raja Hari Singh willingly merged in India, there would not have been Kashmir issue but Raja wanted an Independent Kashmir.

[@tekuvaswani4859]

Agree

[@DigvijaySinghRathore-s7x]

It's because some areas such as Jammu district kathua district and udhampur district are hindu majority and ladakh was Buddhists majority only kashmir valley, west Jammu and gilgit baltistan was muslim majority at that time so Hari Singh was neutral he don't want to disappoint anyone but muslims of Jammu and Kashmir not happy with Hari Singh rule

[@rajivkaushal7376]

After reading the below comments... I can say that, We the Indians don't believe in facts. We are totally moved by emotions. I pray to almighty to give prudence to us to make the correct judgements...

[@cricket_football2093]

Absolutely correct They are still reading WhatsApp gyaan

[@andhkasur]

@@cricket_football2093Pata Nahi kaun WhatsApp university se padha hai

[@andhkasur]

Tumhe bhot believe hai ki is videoe Sab sach hai!??

[@progamers5936]

@@andhkasur tum

[@andhkasur]

@@progamers5936 mai kya?

[@robintanwar7489]

Sher E Bharat Sri Sardar Patel ji...Jindabaad Jindabaad...Jai Hind

[@santoshkharde6392]

लोहपुरुष

[@sunilgawai6294]

मुर्दाबाद किसने बोला?

[@FirstLast-qr6yq]

@@sunilgawai6294 ye dallantop kr rhe indirectly...thumbnail dekho inka

[@beardogamingff9833]

Manipulate kr rh hai Itna hi agr j&k ko bharat me milna tha To usko special state ka darja kyu dia Patel kashmir ko special state bnane k virodh me the Or nehru ne usko special state bnane k liye open support kia Ye manipulate Krna inka purana dhandha hai

[@Sanjay-ub7eq]

@@proudlyindian9113 lekin shree vallab bhai patel bhi toh congress ke the na..?

[@Viru0008]

काश सरदार पटेल जी भारत के पहले प्रधानमंत्री होते तो कब का पाकिस्तान भी हमारा होता | इससे कश्मीर समस्या ही नहीं पाकिस्तान समस्या भी सुलझ जाती |

[@nepalichoro6208]

Bro he died before first elections

[@mission4724]

@@nepalichoro6208 mere dost 1947 me vo jinda the ,he died 1951 ,jo sahi hai usse glt karane ke liye ye logic mt do

[@Dk-vw8mc]

@@mission4724 tum dono lol ho congress allready sardar Patel ke paksh me thi lekin vah apni marji se hi pm nhi bane kyuki jyada pade likhe nerhru de videsh niti ko chalane ke liye perfect the isliye vo apni marji se nhi bane vo grah mantri bane😂😂

[@shrutitawde9886]

एक नंबर गुरू ❤ Thank you.. निखिल.

[@atdworld]

Menon went to Jammu. He informed the Indian government’s decision to the Maharaja, who signed the instrument of accession that Menon had brought. Maharaja reiterated his request in writing for immediate military help, if the state was to be saved. Menon returned to Delhi on the evening of 26 October (with the instrument of accession and Maharaja’s letter) and went straight to the Defence Committee meeting where it was decided to fly an infantry battalion to Srinagar the next day. By the early hours of 27 October, over a hundred planes, civilian as well as military had been assembled. Weapons and supplies were airlifted and before dusk, the first battalion arrived in Srinagar. When Jinnah heard about the unexpected and prompt airlifting of Indian troops to Srinagar, he flew into a rage. Not prepared to lose the valley, he ordered General Gracey to move troops forthwith into Kashmir. Gracey did not carry out the orders; instead he sought approval of the Delhi based Supreme Commander General Auchinleck who was in charge of all the British officers that remained on either side. Auchinleck refused to oblige Jinnah. But he did not give up his plan. He carried out an invasion of Kashmir by the Frontier tribesman. The Indian battalion headed by Lt. Col. Ranjit Rai secured the airport and advanced towards Baramulla. In repositioning near Pattan, Rai was killed. But in a couple of days, three more battalions of Indian Army had landed at Srinagar, bringing the number of Indian soldiers to about 2,000 for defending the state’s capital. The attackers were stopped. Patel had realised immediately that the battle would be long. The only motorable roadlink available to India via Sialkot to Jammu and Srinagar had been snapped with Sialkot having gone to Pakistan after partition. There were great difficulties for Indian troops in moving through tough terrain and difficult passes from Jammu. Patel took upon himself the task of building the road link. In the last week of October 1947, after a cabinet meeting, minister for works, N V Gadgil, recalled that Patel ‘took out a map and pointing to the Jammu-Pathankot area said that a 65 mile road between the two towns had to be made- capable of carrying the heavy army traffic before July 1948 i.e. within eight months. Within a fortnight necessary materials were assembled at worksite, around 10,000 workers were brought in special trains from Rajasthan and the entire workforce involved in round the clock job numbered over 40,000. The 65 miles were completed on time.’ Behind the success of the project lay Patel’s resolute mind. Vallabhbhai made his first visit along with Baldev Singh, the defence minister on 3rd November and discussed the political and military situation. Even in the judgement of Sheikh Abdullah, ‘events took a decisive turn’ after Vallabhbhai’s Srinagar visit. ‘The Sardar did not lose even one minute. He studied the situation and said that the enemy must be driven back.’ It was, thereafter, decided to establish a new divisional headquarters in Kashmir (Jammu and Kashmir Division). Indian forces occupied Baramulla and captured Uri. Later, for more effective military operation, the Jammu and Kashmir force was split into two divisional commands- Srinagar Division and Jammu Division. Important areas like the Leh-Ladakh valley and Poonch were recaptured by the Indian army, but a cease-fire was ordered by both army commands from midnight of 1 January, 1949. Patel did not believe in carrying the Kashmir operations half way through. He would have preferred the Indian Army not to halt at Uri or at Poonch, but to go beyond- possibly upto Muzaffarabad. General S P P Thorat confirms that ‘our forces might have succeeded in evicting the invaders, if the prime minister (Nehru) had not held them in check and later ordered the cease-fire...’ V T Krishnamachari in reply to Patel confirmed the thoughts of the public. ‘It is a blessing that inspite of initial handicaps, the situation in Kashmir has now improved. Kashmir, and all Indian states generally owe a deep gratitude to you and the government of India for the timely assistance which has preserved the integrity of Kashmir.’ Differences between Nehru and Patel on Kashmir It is true that over the issue of Jammu and Kashmir both Nehru and Patel had differences of opinion as far as the method and approach of tackling the problem were concerned. Patel had a pragmatic and practical approach in dealing with Kashmir and preferred to take timely action whereas it seemed at times that Nehru had emotional attachment for Kashmir- the land of his ancestors and for Sheikh Abdullah. It also appeared that Nehru hesitated in taking firm steps as he was weighed down by international opinion and personal friendship. Jawaharlal Nehru had taken away the Kashmir charge from Patel and decided to manage Kashmir himself as he thought that Abdullah was the key to Kashmir’s future and believed that Patel would mishandle him. Further, Nehru’s lack of frankness with Sardar Patel, regarding appointment of N Gopalaswami Ayyangar as minister without a portfolio to assist him in handling Kashmir had, inter alia, also contributed to their differences over the issue of Kashmir. Jawaharlal’s agreement, albeit on Mountbatten’s persuasion, to make a broadcast, offering a UN-controlled plebiscite in Kashmir was also opposed to Patel’s strong view of timely action in Kashmir and instead of bringing India’s affairs into the vortex of international politics. Patel said, ‘We should never have gone to the UNO... at the UNO, not only has the dispute been prolonged but the merits of our case have been completely lost in the interaction of power politics.’ Kashmir was Jawaharlal’s baby and to avoid clashes with Nehru over it, Patel adopted a bystander’s attitude, but helped whenever the situation demanded or he was called upon to do so. As far as Kashmir was concerned, Patel was provided with limited space, nevertheless, his timely, swift, decisive action saved Kashmir from the perils of imminent danger and ruthless invaders. Sardar Patel’s mindset about the Kashmir issue can be gauged by the following incident from when he was acting as the prime minister in Nehru’s absence. Patel sent for Air Marshal Thomas Elmhirst, chairman of the Chiefs of Staff Committee with whom he wanted to discuss a point relating to the Kashmir war. Elmhirst writes: ‘He was not well, and the meeting was in the sitting room of his home, and we were alone. He said something to this effect- ‘If all the decision rested on me, I think that I would be in favour of extending this little affair in Kashmir to a full-scale war with Pakistan... let us get it over once and for all.’ It is apt to mention here the findings of Jagmohan, ex-Governor of Jammu and Kashmir and close observer of Jammu and Kashmir polity, when he writes- ‘There are many ’ifs’ of history. No one can say with certainty what would have happened if a particular ‘ifs’ had materialised. But hard evidence with regard to integration of 565 States indicates that Sardar Patel’s approach would not have allowed the Kashmir problem to arise and even if any problem had arisen, it would have been nipped in the bud

[@souravmukherjee704]

Ankur Desai Patel initially was not interested in Kashmir as it was a predominantly Muslim majority state...but when Jinnah insisted on Junagarh then Patel changed his mind & insist on Kashmir

[@nayakarma3839]

Big BS and lots of imagination. you have NO clue that Indian and Pakistan army was at that time or until 1950 headed by British general. and mountbatton was in control. we never had plane or bomber . stop BS

[@ajmalaviya123]

Patel was always wanted a kashmir, but he knews that kashmir is muslim majority state so, lets deal on other states first and control those states. So until the end he makes everyone confuse on kashmir and after took all other states in india sardar patel came to discuss kashmir issue in the end..he knews how to deal with kashmir....So, Patel was very clear that Kashmir will never been given up...lol...Jay Mataji.

[@ramachandranmenon3410]

All things happened because of the co-ordination . They had no difference in between Patel and Nehru.

[@Sanjay-ub7eq]

which book

[@hiteshshandil7496]

मुझे आपके इस वीडियो में प्रयोग के लिए एक शब्द पर बहुत दुख है इसमें आप पटेल जी को बर्थडे बॉय कह संबोधित कर रहे हैं यह बहुत दुर्भाग्यपूर्ण है क्योंकि पटेल इस देश के नेता ही नहीं बल्कि इस देश के लोगों के आदर्श है इसलिए ऐसे शब्दों का प्रयोग मुझे लगता है ऐसे व्यक्तित्व के लिए नहीं होना चाहिए...

[@devendarayadav6542]

Lallantop people r not mature enough

[@PawanSharma-kn4in]

So colled... . dallantop se aur kiya umeed ???

[@ManishSingh-uh4xc]

JNU के लोफरों से इससे अधिक उम्मीद भी नहीं की जा सकती

[@bharatshah3412]

Completely agree with you, I had same feeling when I heard that.

[@Lifestyles_GoGreen]

Jab Pakistan pok sr nahi hata to Jan Mat Kya or Nehru ne UN me ja ke Kya ukhad liya.

[@moonak88]

Love u patel sir Respect sardar patel ❤❤

[@rohtashsihag5646]

👌👌🙏🙏

[@sushantakumarbehera8816]

Nehru ji_Patel ji doo bhai thye aur dono mein bahut pyar thaa👍

[@chudasmayashpalsinh9922]

@@sushantakumarbehera8816 😅😅😅😅.......

[@chudasmayashpalsinh9922]

@@sushantakumarbehera8816 nehru ji adwina ke aashik the ...

[@drashtithacker8618]

💯🙏💯

[@rajantirkey7769]

बेहतरीन जानकारी तथ्यों के दोनों पहलुओं को खंगालते हुए 👌👍

[@Goga_chehar_contruction]

आपका अधुरा ज्ञान अच्छा लगा एक लेखक ही सही है बाकी के लेखक शायद गलत

[@ranvirkumar7268]

👍🙏🏼

[@VijayYadav-fn8tf]

👏👏👏👍👍👍👍👍

[@LEGENDgaming-bd9xk]

नेहरू ने तो देही दिया था पर सरदार साहेब ने लिख दिया था की 370 कलम राष्ट्रपति के कहने पर हटा सकते है और कश्मीर परमनेंट भारत का होगा इस लिए आज कश्मीर भारत के पास है हमे गर्व है साहेब पर

[@desisingingstar593]

Eye tu soch le beta pakistan or India bhai hai tera bhai ko tera baap kaa daulat main se barabar ki hissa dega yaa nehi tera bhai ka sabaal hai ye ye to chalta hai india main bhai bhai kabarar milta hai

[@विरगुरुजीगोविंदसिंध]

🚩जय हो सरदार पटेल🚩 सरदार पटेल वडाप्रधान होते तो आज भारत महासता होता 🚩कोई माई का लाल भारत उपर बुरी नजर से देखने की हींमत न करता,

[@armaan7229]

पर पटेल का निधन 1950 में हुआ और आम चुनाव 1995 में हुआ

[@ajitsir1957]

Nehru has done so many other great things for this nation there can not be any comparison.

[@k.r.dewasi6275]

अगर नेहरू और पटेल में मन भेद होता या पटेल नेहरू के खिलाफ होते तो पटेल प्रधान मंत्री बनते क्योंकि कांग्रेस कमेठी पटेल के समर्थन में थी और वो वोटिंग के आधार पर प्रधानमंत्री बन जाते लेकिन उन्होंने ऐसा नहीं किया

[@kunalwankar5698]

अगर सरदार वालभ भाई पटेल जी को काश्मीर को पाकिस्तान मे विलय होणेंसे कोयी दिकत नाही होती तो वो देशी ही आर्मी को कश्मीर भेजते ही नाही ,

[@shivaniparihar8372]

Sahi h

[@hanumansingh2721]

सत्यमेव जयते सरदार वल्लभ भाई पटेल कश्मीर में सेना बाद में भेजी इसलिए जमुकशमीर आज पुरा कश्मीर भारत में क्योंकि जमु कश्मीर नेहरू की जन्म भूमि थी यह गलत इतिहास अंग्रेजों के तलवे चाटने वाले चाटुकार सघीयो संघी देशद्रोही थे और है गांधी नेहरू पटेल में कोई विरोध नहीं था तीनों ने देश के लिए संघर्ष करके देश को आजाद करवाया उनमें पद लालासा नहीं थी अगर संघी देशद्रोही अंग्रेजों के तलवे चाटने वाले चाटुकार नहीं होते तो भगतसिंह राजगुरु सुखदेव को फांसी इन राक्षसों सघीयो का काम था देश आजाद चालीस से पहले आजाद हो जाता और इतने शहीद नहीं होते सघीयो की वजह से देश का बंटवारा हुआ आज गद्दार देशद्रोही बिजेपी संघ ने देश को अडानी अम्बानी को बेच रहे देश को गुलाम बनाने वाले हैं कांग्रेस ने सतर में इतनी तरक्की की उसको सात साल में देश को बर्बाद कर दिया गद्दार देशद्रोही बिजेपी संघ ने देशद्रोही बिजेपी सघीयो पहले ईस्ट इंडिया कंपनी से किया तालुक था कारातीकारियो के ठिकाने बताना देश आजाद करवाने वाले की सुचना देना बिजेपी सघीयो जलियांवाला बाग की सुचना जनरल डायर को तुमने ही तो कहा था देशद्रोही बिजेपी सघीयो और अब भी भारत को बांटने की कोशिश कर रहे मनुवादी सघीयो तुम्हारा डिएनए भी गोरों से मिलता है देश में सबसे बड़ा आतंकवादी मोहन भागवत संघी देशद्रोही झुटलर उर्फ मोदी ढोंगी टकला तड़ीपार गद्दार देशद्रोही है चोर है लुटेरे गुंडे

[@salauddinsaifi1763]

आज़ादी के वक़्त देश जिस हालत में था उसे नेहरू और पटेल दोनो ने ही बड़ी जिम्मेदारी से सम्भाला। किसी के भी योगदान एयर काम को कम नही आंकना चाहिए। नेहरू बनाम पटेल करना निहायत ही गलत बात है। ये सिर्फ राजनीति है

[@PracticeB4Preach]

Undoubtedly Patel was more deserving PM!

[@manishupadhyay5412]

Not more than nehru

[@chandrakantshah2525]

Lmao

[@AyushYadav-ll1cp]

Patel died in 1950 and first general elections were held in 1951! So how?

[@CHAITANYFORINDIA]

abey BEFKOOF , patel ji ka swargwas pehle election se pehle ho gaya tha

[@iamanonymous9061]

@@AyushYadav-ll1cp 1947 Provisional govt ka PM

[@jyotimahajan3959]

Ndtv के बाद आपका चेनल ही भरोसेमंद है आपने इस वीडियो के माध्यम से काफ़ी कुछ बातो को सही दिशा में रखा 🙏🇮🇳🙏

[@mrigendradevsarma3288]

U people r awesome. Carry on. May god bless u. 👍

[@RaviPatel-of3tq]

KABHI KITAB KHOL KE DEKH ,,,,,GANDU.....

[@krishankashyapff6643]

tum log asli gadar ho desh ke salo

[@trilokinathgupta3887]

सरदार पटेल शुरू से ही कश्मीर को भारत में मिलाना चाहते थे शुरू की सोच जो है कश्मीर को भारत में मिलाना था सोच सोच की बात कहां से आ गई

[@dhananjay7170]

Sardar Patel was a legendary man nor gandhi neither nehru can match his virtue

[@neel333neel]

this video is for yours type andh bhakt, who always criticise the truth and good people without any proof. yours type people are not good for Indian society, because andh bhakt people ruin the society with lie

[@dhananjay7170]

@@neel333neel just take your so called intelligence somewhere else today's India is definitely due to the visionary Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel the man behind United India just go and read the history written by your communist ancestors even they gave credit to him 😅😅

[@sanilyadav1450]

@@dhananjay7170 We are Secular India not Hindu Rashtra. Sardar Patel That is called Visionary........

[@dhananjay7170]

@@sanilyadav1450 well bro being hindu is our national identity don't confuse yourself 😅

[@ozarks2345]

@@dhananjay7170 kaun bola being indian is our national identity

[@nikunjpatel736]

Thank you

[@vedavrataaalok296]

आपके विश्लेषण में जूनागढ़ की 1948 वाली घटना के बाद पटेल के मन का बदलना कैसे सही माना जा सकता है? क्यों कि कश्मीर की घटना 1947 की है। इसलिए आपका विवेचन लगता है कि पूरी तरह से सही नहीं है! है न?☹☹☹

[@rameshdevadiga910]

Overall this small time media's analyses abt then situation is definitely influenced by some interested opposition party's. Secondly if u hv so many proofs, why not you challenge Modi's recent statement of, if Sardar Vallabhai Patel would hv been d first PM of lndia, lndia's progress would hv been different & better in this past 70+ yrs.

[@rup3945]

Crystal clear clarification

[@prachikhilare163]

Rupali Thaakur lawda crystal clear ...Nehru ko whitewash kiya chutiyo ne

[@rup3945]

@@prachikhilare163 tumhare shabd se bhi crystal clear ho gya h the kind of upbringing you have got May God bless you with some brains

[@abhisheksarkar513]

Agar patel sahab hummare desh ke pehele PM hote tho desh ka naksha hi alag hota koti koti naman patel sahab ko 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩

[@Instantstatus0]

Bhai kese hote wo first pm 🙄

[@Ravindra0998]

वो पीएम पद के उतना काबिल नही थे जीतना नेहरू

[@EC__ASIFRaza]

Pahle to Gandhi ji gaddar then ab Jawaharlal Nehru bola jata h n ki desh aazad hone ke bad beta bhi bap banjata h

[@arunkumarjain7675]

Another excellent video that provide a correct perspective of a contentious issue. Kudos to the entire Lallantop team. 👍👏

[@VikashKumar-qr6zi]

सच पूरा बताइये sir नेहरू कश्मीर के मामले में गलती की हैं पटेल ने नेहरू से पूछा आपको कश्मीर चाहिए या नही उसपर नेहरू ने कुछ नही बोला इसलिए पटेल एक्सन में आ गए

[@sajangahlot9387]

Tu vha Beth kr unki baate sunn rha tha kya

[@VikashKumar-qr6zi]

पढ़ना आता है तो इतिहास जा कर पढलो फिर पता चल जाएगा कि हम वहा थे या नही

[@VikashKumar-qr6zi]

यह पूरा घटना जम्मू कश्मीर का ह जब नेहरू और लार्ड माउण्ट बेटन साथ मे स्टेज पर बैठा था फिर नेहरू भाषण देने के लिए उठा

[@vaibhavsrivastava0769]

Jis group me Mila h mujhe bhi add Kar lo

[@kunalk1234]

How many people from RSS fought against British? RSS was always working for British. Nehru was quiet because his answer was always yes. As a PM he naturally authorized Patel's action

[@yruxotic_]

Jhut sardar patel is one of the great person

[@Itachil203]

Bhai kya insaanon se galtiyan nahin hoti unse bhi ho gayi hogi ham koi bhagwan to hain nahin jo zindagi kabhi galti naa karein.

[@manishapatel596]

Agare bura hota to 10 me se 9 vote Patel ko milatha nehru bhadve ko pm nahe ban ne deta pure India ko es ne ek keya he

[@akumar2991]

इतिहास की सत्यता पर भी शक होना लाजमी है क्योंकि इतिहास लेखन भी किसी न किसी के पक्ष में ही होता है। जो लोग कांग्रेस पार्टी में एक परिवार के अलावा किसी को सुप्रीमो होने नही दिया, वो इतिहास में हीरो किसी और को कैसे बनने देते। ये आपका विश्लेषण ऐसा ही है कि 20 से कम 19 भी नही है, दोनों खुश। ठीक है सम्मान दोनों लोगों का होना चाहिए लेकिन विश्लेषण निष्पक्ष होना चाहिए।

[@abdulzafin8282]

Modi joota a,

[@ajaydevkate1476]

Abdul Zafin our sahi bol Rahul Gandhi Muslim hai

[@prakharvihaan350]

Patel ke likhe part padho

[@abdulzafin8282]

@@ajaydevkate1476 itne paglagaye ho ki ek hindu ko Muslim kehre Hai ho, jo b ho o chor nahi modi jaisa, or naa hi joota or naa hi Ambani ki gulam

[@akumar2991]

@@hoodasaksham सरदार पटेल ने पूरे भारत भारत को एक सूत्र में बांधा उनको भुलाना सबसे बड़ी नाइंसाफी होगी, नेहरू से कही ज्यादा लोगो मे स्वीकार्यता थी लेकिन फिर भी pm नेहरू बने। इसलिए गांधी जी ने कहा था कि आजादी के बाद कांग्रेस को समाप्त कर देना चाहिए, नही तो एक परिवार केंद्रित कांग्रेस हो जाएगा जो आज सत्य है।

[@ChandraShekhar-fx4pp]

आपने अच्छी जानकारी दी है। बहुत स्पष्ट रूप से तथ्य सामने रखे हैं। आप बधाई के पात्र हैं।

[@madhushreepawar3203]

Aapki batonse to aisa lagta hai ki neheru ji or sardar patel ji aapke langotiya yaar the . Give respect and take respect .

[@namdevmulay1080]

Namaste Sir you are right thinking.

[@kanhaupamanyu1183]

सर सबसे पहले आपकी विडियो के लिए धन्यवाद में आपसे सहमत हूं ।🙏🙏 मेरा मानना यह है।उस समय में जो भी हुआ हो, उन बातो में नमक मिर्च लगाकर कहने से बचना चाहिए। चाहे किसी के भी गुलाम रहे हो अंग्रेज़, मुस्लिम सच्चाई को स्वीकार कर, उस समय मानव सभ्यता का परिवर्तन काल था दुनिया के सभी देश आपस लडकर गुलाम, आजाद हो रहे थे हम अकेले नहीं थे। इतिहास से सीख भविष्य और वर्तमान सुनहरा समय लाये।आप ईमानदारी से देखेंगे तो हमारे पूर्वज देश के लिए लडे थे, न कि पद के लिए और हम आज आपस में लडकर अपने पूर्वजो का सपना तोड़ रहे हैं। मेरा किसी राजनीतिक पार्टियों से कोई मतभेद हो नहीं क्योंकि वो नेता भी हम मैं से है, और हमने बनाये हैं। आशा हैं आप मेरी भावनाओं को समझेंगे। कृपया अपने विचार सभ्यता से दे समस्त देश वासी जय हिंद जय भारत 🙏🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@adarshsingh3138]

You are right

[@kanhaupamanyu1183]

@@adarshsingh3138 thanks Bhai ji

[@manishpandey3733]

मोदी जी की सही बात है कि यादि सरदार वल्लभ भाई पटेल भारत के प्रधानमंत्री होते तो आज जम्मू पाकिस्तान को नही देने देते

[@radhan6424]

बहुतही निष्पक्ष और रिसर्च के आधार पर बनाया गया वीडियो है। आप का अभिनंदन।

[@trueknowledge4176]

Jammu Kashmir riyasat religiously 3 hissa tha . 1.Jammu: Hindu, 2.Kasmir Gilgit : Muslim, 3. Ladakh: Buddhism.

[@anazad7734]

Jammu was Muslim till 1948 massacre happened

[@dr.bashirahmadsheikh5038]

In Jammu massacre 5lakh Muslims were killed.so it became a minorty area.

[@anazad7734]

@@dr.bashirahmadsheikh5038 Yes, right. And many more were displaced who are in Pakistan.

[@पुराणकथा-ढ4ठ]

1930 tak kashmir completely hindu state tha ye bat ek Christian ne batayi hai

[@imgujjarsahab]

@@पुराणकथा-ढ4ठ true that. First hindu were genocide in the Kashmir, and it was a hindu country.

[@SAMEERKUMAR-wz7bn]

Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel ❤️❤️

[@RISHUBHPA]

Please provide all facts link on your video description included in this video .

[@sundarpatil1446]

Lallan आज सब सही झूठ बतायगा,कुछ दिन मे बोलेगा अभि सही जाणकारी करानी पडेगी की सही है या गलत इसलिये भरोसा मत कर.

[@SatyaDrashya]

आपके द्वारा दी गई जानकारी बहुत अच्छी है मैं आपसे सहमत हू आपका विश्लेषण निष्पक्ष है

[@NeymarRock]

LAL BAL PAL ......Great person ........

[@arjunjena8845]

Patel respected a lot to gandhi so he never did disagree wth him He looked gandhi as his godfather

[@atulcd]

The video is totally biased, continuously blaming Patel and totally inclined towards Nehru. Intentionally released to campaign for congress & targeting BJP. At one point he has mentioned Modiji, w/o any reference of context.

[@patna2234]

Abe yh jo vp menon ki books me jo likha hua h uska baat kar raha h

[@atulkaushik5264]

तो आप बता दो आप भी तो वही बैठे थे दोनों के बीच मे

[@mayankjadon1921]

Read the book 'The story of Integration of India'.

[@arunchauhan1831]

Ye channel hi pro nehru/congress hai

[@andhkasur]

@@patna2234 Sari books ko man loge!???

[@demolisher47]

सरदार पटेल नहीं चाहते थे कि काश्मीर का विलय भारत में हो यह कोंग्रेस का एक और जूठ है। जय श्री राम। वंदे मातरम्।

[@rudram3781]

You have SOLD YOUR SOUL for Just a few RMB.

[@pranjaldev9559]

🤔

[@shankersoni8051]

भारतीय स्वतंत्रता संग्राम में क्रांतिकारी सशस्त्र क्रांति पर 1858 से 1947 तक के इतिहास पर वीडियो बनावें

[@surajvyas1655]

यस सर जी

[@gameslovers3473]

love from junagadh ❤️❤️

[@y4shladani]

Jai girnari

[@androidtv8560]

Bahot hi achhe se explain kia gaya hai...production team tarif ka huqdar hai

[@AbhishekDaYoutube]

जो स्वतंत्रता सेनानी पूरी देश की रक्षा के लिए अपना जीवन न्यौछावर कर दिए आज वर्तमान में यह देख कर बहुत दुख होता है कि हम उन्हें एक दस देशभक्त के तौर पर नहीं बल्कि एक पार्टी से जोड़ कर उनकी आलोचना करते हैं ,कोई सही शिक्षा के आधार पर सही तथ्यों के आधार पर सत्य भी बताने का प्रयास करता है तो हम उसे संबंधित पार्टी का चाटुकार कह देते हैं यह अत्यंत ही शर्मनाक है हमारे युवाओं में निष्पक्षता का ह्रास होता जा रहा है जो कि देश के लिए सही नहीं है ।अगर कोई देश अपने आदर्शों पर भी संदेह की निगाह से देखने लगे तो उस देश का विकास कैसे होगा । प्यारे दोस्तों मै किसी की आलोचना नहीं कर रहा हूं लेकिन इतना आपसे विनम्र निवेदन करता हूं कि भले ही आप किसी की बात से सहमत न हों लेकिन उसने अपनी बात रखी है तो उसका सम्मान करिये ,किसी बात पर अगर वैचारिक मतभेद हो तो उसे 'मनभेद' में मत बदलिए आप लोग ।

[@naziaperween1205]

Aapki thinking acchi hai

[@naziaperween1205]

@Abhishek Kumar aapki thinking acchi hai

[@krunaljoshi9746]

Sir aap Jo book ka havala derahe ho wo book likhi kishne v.p.menon V.p. Menon kishke salahkar the ❓ Aisha to nahi hota k v.p.menon Jo angejo k salahkar the our wo likhde wohi India ka itihash banjaye 🙏

[@vidyadharnagesh8339]

Bahut sudar

[@mrinmayjoshi7551]

Kashmir me Kashmiri pandit rehte the 7 baar jinko Kashmir se Khatam Kar Diya Gaya, waha ke mandir tode, dharm parivartan Kar Diya Gaya, Kashmiri panditoon ke liye abhi Tak kisine kuch nahi Kiya , waha ki sabhyata Khatam kardi gayi ,Puri kaum ko Khatam Kar Diya gaya. It was genocide...ye he kashmir ki kahani Aur tu Kisko sir bol Raha h Bhai .. abhi voting ke pehle modi ke khilaaf news chalti thee is Channel pe...ab modi Jeet Gaya to ab uski chatne lage.

[@omprakeshsaini5761]

Mrinmay Joshi u

[@Phonix_Shabd]

बन्धु इस विडियो को बनाने का आपका उद्देश्य तो यह समझ में आ ही गया कि आप काश्मीर समस्या का जिम्मेदार नेहरू को नहीं बनने देना चाहते परन्तु आप ही ने यह स्पष्ट कर दिया है कि पटेल का मत नेहरू से नहीं मिलने पर भी गांधी जी के वफादार सिपहसालार होने के कारण उन्होंने जो गलत हुआ उसे होने दिया

[@ravimathur3597]

Ye news sirf bjp ka birodh karti ye news ka bahiskaar karo

[@valmikvarandani4545]

@@ravimathur3597 kyu bhai agar koi video sacchai dikha rahi hai or uss sacchai m tum logo ka rajnetik nuksaan hai to bahishkaar kro..bhot bdiya..sb anpadh nahi hote

[@surajshinde9482]

@@valmikvarandani4545 sacchahi 😂😂😂😂

[@abhishekanand8876]

Acchi jankari di lallantop ne,baat nehru vs patel ki nahi thi jo aaj banayi jati hai. Sabhi desh k nirman mai apna yogdan de rahe the isliye ye kahna galat hoga k fala ki galti se ye hua ya galat hua.

[@Phonix_Shabd]

@@abhishekanand8876 सबके सहयोग और देश निर्माण की बात से अलग बात है देश का प्रथम प्रधानमंत्री बनजाना जब कि कोई भी वोट मिला ही नहीं । यहां गांधी जी का हिटलर शाही रवैया भी स्पष्ट दिख जाता है । क्यों बाबा साहेब आंबेडकर कहने पर मजबूर हुए कि गांधी देश के लिए खतरा बनते जा रहे हैं

[@hemantkusurkar8510]

Excellent my young friend ...,

[@sachinmane8647]

@Lallantop Kya tum isaka sahi se reference de sakate ho history me.

[@rohan723723]

Waaah modiji waaah

[@rocker1ism]

To 19 minute ki video mein wo bechara doraemon ki kahani sunaa raha tha 😄😄😂😂

[@dharmeshpatel7120]

हकीकत यह है कि उन्हें आजाद हिन्दुस्तान बनाना था । और जब कश्मीर हमारे पास था तो क्यों नहेरू को un में जाकर कश्मीर देने की बात की थी??

[@yadvindersharma2416]

I Salute You Youngman, You Have Completely Explored All Events Related To Our Lovely Kashmir Fantastically .. I Also Request All Educated & Wise Indians To Not To Misguide The Other Innocent Indians On This Issue, Specially BJP Minded People. Jai Hind.... 🇮🇳

[@samiahamad24]

👏 👌

[@rakeshchadhare8755]

Writin

[@euginiamiranda4990]

It always gave me pain whenever read about Kashmir and related matters, how the semi-baked and hate mongers blamed Nehru ji, for everything, these ungrateful people should read such vedios and keep their brains sane. Thank you Genleman for this great Vedio

[@ramvirsingh1498]

आपने बहुत पुरानी बात को यथासंभव स्पष्ट करने का प्रयास किया और मुझे अच्छा भी लगा और मुझे यह लगा कि आपने जहां तक कोशिश की है इसे सही तरह से समझाने की यह बात सही भी है और मेरी बहुत सारी शंकाओं का समाधान इसमें अभी हुआ है जय श्री राम धन्यवाद

[@meenakshipillay2515]

If patel would be prime minister we r far far ahead of the situation what we r now this is Nehru and congress alliance khangress who is responsible for underdevelopment of our country and Kashmir issue

[@pranjalpanwar3149]

Patel Congress m hi the😂

[@pallavisatish7989]

The book says he assured Lord Mountbatten to agree with king... it never said he wanted Kashmir to be part of Pakistan.

[@sundarpatil1446]

सब गलत बताना तेरी जिम्मेदारी है क्या. सरदारजी पटेल जी अमर है !!!!!!!!!

[@drashtithacker8618]

💯🙏💯

[@ramnareshsharma7310]

True analysis. Nehru and Patel both were great.

[@sudhanshugupta1392]

Nice video. I have read many books on this topic and overall I agree with you. And this is coming from a guy who absolutely loves Modi but also agree it was not Nehru's mistake. Request everyone to first read on the topic and then judge. Don't just assume anything from word of mouth. It's dangerous. And no need to use abusive language.

[@dearcricket66]

👍👍👍👍

[@VivekSingh-rr6rb]

Sardar Patel is a great leader in whole india

[@PrajwalNanaiah]

Yes. Nehru too

[@manishupadhyay5412]

@@PrajwalNanaiah Nehru ji

[@not_arsalan2630]

One of the greatest position of their time, there are no single, more also

[@VikramSingh-vg7gv]

Bose,gandhi, Patel, Nehru and Ambedkar....these 5 were greatest leaders of modern India.... comparable to any of greatest leaders of human history. I have doubt about Savarkar..... should i include him here??

[@dhirajwaghmare571]

Who's watching after remove 370artical

[@vinaysinha2506]

Bahut achha laga. Bahut hi santulit vislashan Kia hai Ap ne is video me.

[@gautamjain8857]

The best first Prime Minister would be Subhash Chandra Bose

[@theindianfoodie2040]

If Subhash Chandra Bose was there , there would have been no division of countries . Plus there would have been presidents rule like US .

[@ugamsingh5663]

काश, ऐसा होता!

[@nilaykulkarni1099]

भाई साहब गलत इतिहास मत बताइए हमने भी वीपी मैनन की वह बुक पड़ी है उसमें ऐसा तो कुछ नहीं लिखा है पर ऐसा लिखा गया है कि भारतीय सेना ने पीओके मतलब पाकिस्तान ऑक्यूपाइड कश्मीर को भी जीत लिया था तभी और उसी वक्त नेहरू जी ने यूएएन में जाकर मसला हल करने का प्रस्ताव रख दिया

[@madankandal3549]

Aap kripiya dubara pad len.Itihas itihas hai na iska na uska. Hamen topi pahnane wale bahut hain. 76 saal ka general Hardik shubh kamnayen

[@nathulalsharma8179]

सीज फायर करके सेना को वापस बुलाया आर्मी ने प्रतीरोध भी किया लेकिन सेना के प्रती रोध को दरकिनार किया

[@krishnatiwari8514]

ये चैनल का कुछ भी न्यूज़ देखो, कांग्रेसी दलाली की बू आती है ।

[@vishnuacharya6352]

Nehru was hesitant but finally agreed when Srinagar was about to fall. The greatest mistake of Nehru was to go to UN, when the war of Kashmir was almost won: why he went to you, is debated. This talk about Patel’s wavering mind on Kashmir, is debatable: your “discovery of truth” seems contrary to the generally accepted. On the face of it, it is difficult to swallow.

[@lokenathsen6264]

exactly Sir!

[@lokenathsen6264]

I think Lallantop is biased , and propagate agenda narrative

[@sheenpipin]

I endorse your stand. The channel is distorting facts with a seemingly vested interest.

[@ramjisharma2223]

कश्मीर पर पटेल काफी ग्यान वरधक लगी इतिहास संतुष्ट कर देने वाली थी।नमस्ते ।राम जी शर्मा सीवान से

[@TechCookies]

Who else watching after pulwama attack

[@savitass2125]

Me also

[@OutofTheBox754]

Savita ss means

[@PD130470]

मैंने 2 महीने पहले भी देखा था और आज भी देख रहा हूँ।

[@Aanya01]

Me and after much reserach, I know that Lallantop has intentiona;;y tried to serve lie in favor of Nehru.. Dont Trust them.. watch other videos on Kashmir story....

[@Shadow-qk4ug]

I am watching after Air Surgical Strike :)

[@kailashthapliyal1909]

निष्पक्ष ,अविवादित, बाते कहने वाले ही अक़्सर अगर मगर का शिकार होते हैं, उन्ही में से ये दो भी थे , दोनों को 100 100 बार नमन, सबसे अच्छी बात "आज से 50 साल बाद आपका इतिहास लिखा जाएगा तो सोच समझ कर काम करे नही तो आप भी अगर मगर के शिकार हो सकते हैं"

[@ps5606]

This video has delibrately been made to save the face of Nehru.

[@skjahirmohammad4593]

Will u elaborate

[@ps5606]

why is it that Nehruji and other softline netas were never sent to Kalapani, because they diverted the anger of the Indian people to an impractical ways of non violence which also suited British because they were easier to handle. These type of netas were put in VIP jails and used to get all facilities which netas even today get in jails. Public was made fool then also and now also in the name of arrest of netas. Nehruji has written letters to Indira Gandhi from jail, that means he used to get freedom and time to write such letters. I dont know how many campaigns were led by Nehruji during Freedom struggle, yes but he participated in movements started by Gandhiji and used to keep him happy, which paid him when he Gandhiji overruled Patels selection as first PM in his favour. Yes he also kept Mountbattan and his wife happy and thus became their choice for first PM of India. British knew which Indian leaders will toe their line even when they leave the country. He messed up Kashmir issue is well known to all. And what he did during his 17 years of being PM is a different story. It is because of these social media platforms that people are knowing the truth. History is not being manipulated @Erina Khadka. That is why this video is made to save the face of Nehru. Read the comments of Ankur Desai below to know the truth.

[@rajeevjain3117]

@@Handle12456 , for once I say that all u told is right( cause I do not want to conflict with you ). But tell me, what about veto power he gave to China. India was offered veto power but he gave that to China. There are many more mistakes he did, but i do not want to conflict. Moreover, sardar patel told many thing about future of India which came true and also have suggestions which were denied by Nehru.

[@rajeevjain3117]

@@Handle12456 , I just want justification over veto power. Today, this China uses veto power everytime to refuse Indias proposal in UN or other things

[@dm-tq2sx]

Initially sardar Patel was not Gandhi's follower. His views were different and from 1917 everything changed. But that doesn't mean Gandhi and sardar were competitors.

[@subhashinidube3117]

बहुत उम्दा लगा । कुछ असलियत जानने को मिली ।

[@rvgoswami200]

अखंड भारत के शिल्पी सरदार वल्लभभाई पटेल जी...lallantop valo desh ko sahi History bataya karo

[@tanveerchoudhary9160]

Tum bta do bhai

[@cricketornothing4876]

@@tanveerchoudhary9160 whatsapp university ki hostory bta dega

[@pramodchoudhary3930]

Bhakto ki kya sune. Wo to anpadh ganwr h

[@amitsingh-xt1og]

Abtk ye sale ham logo ko whatsapp ki farzi history sunate the ab khud sharm aa rhi hogi bhakto ko apne upar

[@dwarikaprasadkaala4594]

Very Well narrated.Most people run down Nehru on Kashmir. I also thought so till I heard you. Thank you for clearing my doubts.We should not blame Nehru or Patel for that.It was a complex problem that was haunting every one then.

[@syedpasha5509]

Dwarika prasad Kaala true boss

[@pramodkumaragrawal8426]

We should not blame anyone. We can never know the circumstances of that time.

[@medhagupta6223]

Hey. You shouldn't take information from biased and misinformed people. Do some research yourself and you'll realize that you have been misled. This video is a distortion and perversion of history. You would be better served by fact checking your sources

[@ojarering4861]

Biased and misinformed

[@medhagupta6223]

@@scientia.veritas It feels to me like you're the one who is a recent alumnus of it. My facts tend to come from government archives

[@NVS-kc8ew]

Pandit Nehru passed away@my teens, there are no videos except the Films Divns news in cine theatres before the scheduled picture's exhibition in those days or the newspapers or monthlies like Soviet Bhoomi, now I am recalling those days firmly through this U+tune thank U!

[@manjitnarula1998]

A well researched and thought provoking video.Thanks a lot.

[@sachingurjar4516]

🙏🙏आप पटेल को जानना चाहते हैं तो उनके कलकत्ता व कानपुर के भाषण सुने,ईर्ष्यावश नेहरू मुस्लिमों की मण्डली इकट्ठी कर विभिन्न मुद्दों पर गांधीजी को उनके खिलाफ़ भड़काने का प्रयास करते थे क्योंकि उस समय कांग्रेस में गांधीजी की ओपिनियन विशेष इंपोर्टेंस रखती थी।🌹🌹

[@kirandeshmukh5977]

Only Nehru's ego is responsible for all the deaths of soldiers happened till date and yet to happen in future due to Kashmir issue

[@aditya__1606]

Itna bada video dek ke bhi tumko kuch samajnhi aaya bhai sahab kya aadmi ho yr ego nhi bhai aaj modi bhi china se doka kha gya na bahut baith baith ke jhoola jhul rhe the to kya ab baith ke gaali de modi ke sab log chathe hai ki ache relation bane lekin mila dokha n usi tarah us samay bhi unhe jo shi laga kiya gya koi kaam jab ho jata hai to koi galitya nhi nikalta aur agar koi kaam nhi ho pata hai to kamiyan nikalne lagte hai aise nhi aise karna tha bahut bade gyani ban jaate hai sab kyu itne hi bade gyani ho to jao desh chalao n itna easy hai desh chalna .. Aur bhi bahut saare kaam kiye nehru ne usko bhi kabhi pado Nagaland ko milna easy tha kya Naga tribe marne maarne ke liye hamesa ready rhti hai koi samjouta nhi karti apne wasoolo se lekin kaise kaise nehru hi the jo kar paaye nhi to lik ke deta hu koi kar na pata daman and diu and Dadar and Nagar haveli , pondicherry, Goa ka pado kaise kaise kiya sab . Kabhi us kursi pe baithe aadmi ko bhi samajo ma agar uske man me koi khot hoti to uske pass 17 saal ka samay tha wo kuch bhi kar sakta tha lekin kisi tarah desh chalaya desh ko ek rakke rakka aur aaj bhi ham hai kya desh ko unit kar dene se kaam katam ho jata hai bhai uske baad kya desh nhi toot sakta . I think bahut lamba ho rha hai bahut kuch example ke saath bata diya samjdaar hoge to samaj jaoge

[@tgsaravind]

@@aditya__1606 ye log nai maanenge bhai.. Nehru ke khilaaf itni hatred faila rakhi hai.. sab fake. India would have been a huge failure without Nehru and would've mostly balkanized by now. Logo ka brainwash kardiya gaya hai

[@haryanatravelersvlog5201]

अगर नेताजी सुभाषचंद्रबोस प्रधानमंत्री होते तो देश का विभाजन ही नही होता

[@subesinghhudiyawal6995]

क्या जिन्ना मर जाते क्या

[@haryanatravelersvlog5201]

@@subesinghhudiyawal6995 jinna ki chlti tb na Ajad hind foj m bahut se muslim sehnawaz khan aur dusre unka rutba tb jinna se kahi jyda hota

[@nirajannirala3147]

Subash chandr bosh देस k Nayak the but o to 1945 me hi gaya ho gaye the chutiye