David Gilmour (Shine on You Crazy Diamond - Live w/ Crosby, Nash & Wright) KnR React

[@TheCornishCockney]

David Gilmour. The God of all guitarists in my opinion. NOBODY gives the emotion from those strings like he does.

[@vikusen1857]

Except Gary Moore....

[@atman4733]

SRV does

[@docwobbles]

Andrew Latimer!

[@nikelodeon6852]

John Petrucchi 'nuff said'

[@TheCornishCockney]

@@vikusen1857 good shout,but not as accomplished as DG,Rory Gallagher another who plays from the heart,Robin Trower the same,but David Gilmour is special and stands alone for me.Just my opinion and i wouldn't dis ANY of the truly great guitarists ever,i love them all but Gilmour? The best.

[@keithmockridge3329]

What can i say. Possibly the greatest guitarist of all time, one of the greatest songs of all time, and 2 of the greatest singers Crosby and nash as backing singers to the awesome David Gilmour and Richard Wright plus a great band.

[@mickgriffiths9982]

I'm 62 years old from England this still gets me

[@innerdarkness1988]

I can't imagine a world without David Gilmour...

[@mf112ut]

There is nothing like the sight of David Crosby watching David Gilmore play some of the most iconic guitar lines on the planet. That level of admiration and respect is what it's all about and, what's important for us all.

[@George39280]

This song has been deemed a masterpiece by musicians of all types of music. David Crosby was honored to be part of this concert for this song. Weather it is the concert version or the album version, it is simply put, A MASTERPIECE.

[@sean_b_drummer]

The saxophone switch was even more impressive when you realize that the Baritone (first one) is in the key of E flat and the Tenor is in B flat. So he had switch up the transposing too. Yeah, I played Baritone, Tenor, and Alto back in school.

[@rondohunter8966]

I have no idea what you just said. But as long as you and others do, the uninitiated such as myself may enjoy the labors of your enjoined skills. Thanks to you and all those who create.

[@sarahkinsey5434]

And wearing 2 instruments of that size his heavy

[@rondohunter8966]

@@sarahkinsey5434 It certainly helped that he was the "Big Man" in more ways than one.

[@openmusic3904]

@@rondohunter8966 Basically, when an E-flat saxophone plays a written concert pitch 'C', the actual pitch sounding will be an E-flat. So if it was playing with a violin, the violin would be written in the key of C major, and the sax would be written in the key of E-flat major. It can get quite convoluted and it takes deep experience with the instruments to be able to switch them so effortlessly.

[@moodfm5673]

cool story bro

[@lebenswasser4224]

It can only be a good day when you're just waking up and listening to such a classic for the first cup of coffee and looking into your smiling faces.

[@Diomedene]

How iconic do you have to be to have Crosby and Nash as your backup singers?

[@boosuedon]

You are probably aware that little more than a week ago Davids 'Black Strat' was auctioned off at Christies for 3.9million dollars (including fees). THAT is iconic and all about respect!

[@GoldTop57]

No kidding, right? Legend of legends

[@iphonemodDOTcom]

Gilmours tone is sublime,without doubt the very best non shredding guitarist to walk this earth.Dick parry is a bit special aswell.

[@Varksterable]

@@iphonemodDOTcom "..very best non shredding guitarist... " Excuse me?! Why that particular qualifier? I seem have been coming across this all day. Shredding is technically very, very impressive when done well; I admit that. And yes, if you want; I'm a jealous loser who can't move his fingers. But to put technical ability above the way some musicians can read your emotions like a book and then scribble all over them is just pure bunk. To expand on what I said on another channel: There is a physical limitation to how fast you can play. Well done to all who get there or get close. But there is NO limitation to how much emotion you can convey with music. If you value the first more, then I personally think you're not cut out to be listening to music.

[@iphonemodDOTcom]

@@Varksterable calm down pointdexter, I've got no axe to grind about guitar shedding, I was just liking gilmours soothing melodic tones.

[@Varksterable]

I'd not heard (or even heard of) this version before this evening. So here's My 1st reaction: . Rince and repeat until the track ends. Thanks for posting this! Take care, both, all.

[@lubos1207]

I consider this an absolute musical gem. Especially when you still know the background of the creation of this song - it always amazes me ...

[@aaronbeal6041]

I am a divorced fella, unfortunately, who is a huge Tool fan. The Tool is how I got here, but as I struggle to find the resolve to soldier back out to try to find someone to share life and love with, you guys give me the framework to strive for. I hope you guys really treat one another this well all the time.

[@diane2193]

Aaron sorry about your divorce BUT you cannot rely on another person for happiness. They will ussually fail you.Avoid depression and just say NO. Please listen .Buy a boat or a show car or both.

[@Halloween111]

It always brings a smile to my face seeing Kel take so much joy in discovering some of the greatest music she never knew existed. After so many of us have worn our albums out listening to them over and over- Her wonder really makes the appreciation for these classics, and the artists that created them, brand new again.

[@unpluggedist]

The most brilliant version I've ever heard of this song. Together with "wearing the inside out" also from this concert one of the most unbelievable music moments I have experienced so far, and I have experienced a lot. Greetings from Germany, dear ones

[@George39280]

There is ONLY ONE way to describe this song ---- A TRUE MASTERPIECE

[@garygraham2513]

I could listen to DG play All day and not get tired of it.

[@RB747domme]

Guy Pratt has to be one of the most underrated bass guitar players of all time. Yes Rich, Steve DiStanislao was incredible on the drums. Respect.

[@Jelsick]

The Pulse version is pure magic as well. This is just a magical song in any version.

[@matthewchance8835]

Beautiful! Amazing song, what a classic, such a wonderful work of art. Love this version!

[@valrtcrimson6747]

Pink Floyd is one of the few bands that can make me cry, for joy or sadness. You don't have to record it but please listen and enjoy all of there music.

[@matthewmaus]

Defo one of the most underrated lead guitarists of all time. I mean this, and the perfect solo in The Wall, etc. etc. xxx

[@thoronthol1175]

Thank you so, so much. I love this song in the original, but wow... wow. So much passion, soul, and craft. Pure artists, beyond their peak, and higher.

[@gordonhughes3445]

Royal Albert Hall London, wonderful location, wonderful concert.

[@pineappletree50]

This right here is what perfection sounds like 👍

[@Pulsar77]

The Live In Gdansk version is arguably even better: the intro is played on wine glasses, followed by Rick Wright's synth. Magical.

[@fabienlouvel5536]

quite agree. love that version

[@grrr.9998]

The guy playing the wine glasses was invited to play after Dave spotted him playing in the streets of Gdansk the previous day.

[@RB747domme]

Not to mention the polish philharmonic orchestra.

[@RyanMovingViolationz]

Absolutely agreed!!!

[@ChrisPage68]

When my elder brother was in the aviation industry, his company had an Open Day. One of the flying displays was two gliders doing a formation routine to Shine On You Crazy Diamond..

[@dpeck4146]

Song dedicated to band co-founder. RIP Syd Barrett (2006).

[@paulgourdie]

One of the best rock guitarist to me seen them live myself lefted with goosebumps

[@Vader1138]

When that was released little did we all know that it would be one of the last two recordings of Rick. (The last being Live in Gdansk from the same tour) I get sad watching it. His keyboards and vocal harmonies were so integral to PF's sound. The favorite live version of Shine On for me though has to be the one on Pulse. When it came out I would sit in the dark, eyes closed, with headphones listening to it. Letting it wash over and through me.

[@allenhuling598]

Completely agree with this entire comment!

[@davidmorgan5312]

The only way to listen to Floyd in the dark and with cans.

[@flubblert]

Amazing version. Doesn't get much better than that. Great reaction!!

[@anthonybutler6365]

Rich I enjoy your musical knowledge and Kel I love your reactions you two are such beautiful people and so deserve each other

[@Kel.N.RichReactions]

Thank you x a zillion Anthony!!! We are here. We see you!!! We are here! We are on a medical hold because of the injuries and problems Kel suffered in the pitbull attack. She has another surgery scheduled for mid February so we are optimistic that that will have a good result and we will return by summer. Obviously no way to tell at this point, but that’s what we are hoping for. Thank you so much for reaching out Anthony. Please stay subscribed so that you can be alerted when we drop our first video comeback! All the best to you and yours, Kel and Rich

[@JustPassingThru12]

I'm the 1st viewer of this reaction video! Woohoo!! Love you guys Rich n Kel! Great song here. A classic!

[@kelligafter502]

Hello and thanks! We are so glad you stopped by! We did 4 reaction videos this evening but 2 got blocked.... we are going to try to get them on a server and post them to our site tomorrow so stay tuned! Lots of love for you!

[@TheJanisjoplin58]

As a fan of Pink Floyd i can attribute this to listening to Uriah Heep, who were always underrated, the David Byron era is a must.

[@docwobbles]

David IS a guitar god, and this was the best live recording of this one I've heard.

[@user-ky6vw5up9m]

This was written about their estranged band member Sid Barrett. When they were recording it, Sid (who was going through a tough time) unexpectedly turned up at the door to the studio by coincidence.

[@Kel.N.RichReactions]

Yes. Syd. He had gained a ton of weight, was balding and was diabetic.

[@pauldoerwang4879]

That's some of the best sax I've ever had!

[@williamosborne6866]

You MUST play "On An Island" from this show....the harmonies are epic.

[@wpollock1]

The Gdansk show with the wine glasses is also very cool. Local guy playing the wine glasses for the intro sounds. RIP Richard Wright

[@lawrencejohnson2179]

This version is fantastic with David Crosby and Graham Nash. Did not know of it’s existence. Lastly, David Crosby put out a solo album around 1971 with a song on it, Cowboy Movie. That song and album is what got me through the teen years. Anyway, great Floyd version here!

[@ChrisEchoes]

They did even better on a song Gilmour wrote called The Blue where he specifically arranged it with their stellar harmonies in mind. It is found on the On An Island album and on this live dvd.

[@lawrencejohnson2179]

Thank you! I will most definitely check that out.

[@BongEyedBastard]

One of the greatest song ever recorded and the greatest 4 notes ever laid to tape.

[@Rush2112mnPeartLeeLifeson]

saw the Delicate and Pulse tours.....Gilmore puts so much soul into his guitar solos...

[@ronaldelliott4373]

Whenever I listen to Floyd, I’m always left in a better place. Grateful

[@jamessweet5341]

This is a much sparer, quieter arrangement than most of the others. Still another dimension of a man noted for high production values throughout his and Floyd's career.

[@cyphon4280]

Best version of this song ever!

[@RyanMovingViolationz]

Ann and I were there for the Rattle That Lock tour stop in Chicago....best show I've ever seen, besides of course Tool for their Fear Inoculum tour at the end of 2019. This video is spellbinding!!! 😮😮😮❤️

[@fittrege2778]

That guitar solo have been inside my head for many many many years. Listening to it again brings back a lot of past memories.

[@keithpasculli7465]

I got goosebumps when the vocals started.

[@niteboatermusic]

The gold standard of Pink Floyd songs. At some point, perhaps you too have had a Syd Barrett in your life, someone you admired and respected and is now - gone. An absolute must listen!

[@MSB-fj7cd]

That was pure awesomeness and both thank and love you guys for sharing your reaction.

[@annettemoore7264]

I think it's hilarious watching Kelly transform into a full blown rock chic...❤

[@allenhuling598]

Great video, great choice of version to do! Like how you're evolving the channel...carry on!

[@jacquesdemolay2699]

Royal Albert Hall is a theatre in London. (for those who are not familiar with England)

[@hakanandersson1276]

I have never seen this version. One word. Masterpiece and i have you to thank for it!!!!

[@ippolit4262]

GIlmour's live acoustic version might be my favorite live rendition

[@franckbizouard3357]

Subtle and quiet version, magnificent one ;-)

[@waynehauser3611]

Masters at work indeed ! When you watch pure genius !

[@kevinrombouts3027]

You are picking all the best songs of all time. Share class. Listened to this in 75 whenbit was first released. The radio played side 1 on one night and side 2 the next. Just blew me away especially this song.

[@justincase8533]

Hadn't experienced that rendition.. chills! Thank you!

[@oldsoldier4u814]

I hadn't heard this version either but it gave me goosebumps when they first harmonized!!!

[@RyanMovingViolationz]

Absolutely spellbinding performance!!! 😮❤️

[@jamessweet5341]

That is one power packed stage....

[@kencraig7308]

There will Never be another David Gilmour. RIP Syd Barrett.

[@traceybanting3952]

Just beautiful! Morning tears here in England. Fantastic choice Kell and Rich! Now I need to redo my makeup 🥰😘 xxx

[@simply_psi]

What a great arrangement I'd not heard this version before thanks. David Gilmour is a master did you see his black strat sold for $3.3m at Christies last week, bargin 💰

[@Kel.N.RichReactions]

Thank you @Simon Austin. We will be doing more like this. It’s too good to not do for everyone, including fellow Floydians. I can’t believe someone owns that guitar. Imagine plugging it in and having that sound connected to you. We are all blessed to live in the time when David Gilmour was playing music. Good lord. Much love. Rich

[@ElTigreEsq]

this must've been when Nash and Crosby weren't at war with each other. They definitely are now.

[@diane2193]

Rich I like your Pendragon shirt .Another little known prog band. One of my favs .

[@michaeltveten8458]

Really cool performance. I’m a big fan of Gilmore, Nash, and Crosby.....But, I can’t help but feel an emotional “hiccup”, seeing this song performed w/o Roger there......Just saying. Please unleash CSNY on Kel! I can’t wait for her reactions to “Teach Your Children”, “Our House”, “Suite: Judy Blue Eyes”, and “Southern Cross”....👏

[@roberthalliday3192]

Do David Gilmour Marooned from Fenders 50th birthday, please

[@sumbadcat]

Have you listen to Allan Parsons Project yet? their song Time is very Good

[@reb1050]

Correction: Allan Parsons Project's "Time" is not very good...IT'S GREAT! Pink Floyd is probably my favorite group of all time, but Allan Parsons Project has some fantastic music as well.

[@jesperhald3969]

@@reb1050, and a fun fact is, that Allan Parsons actually was Sound Engineer at the "Dark Side of The Moon"-album.

[@Narpets2112]

After the massive success of Dark Side Of The Moon, they decided to take things a notch down and record an album called "Household Objects" in which they would use things found around a house to create music without any traditional instruments. That proved too difficult and the project was scrapped but one sound that survived is the opening 'synth' wash to this track which was partially created by running a finger around the rim of wine glasses.

[@matsjakobsson1376]

Fucking ridiculous talent as backround vocals!! Great song!

[@david_v2.1]

You gotta do David Bowie singing Comfortably Numb from the same Gilmour show!

[@MamawT65]

My favorite Pink Floyd song thanks for the reaction

[@jamescutler8055]

Pink Floyd is always about the journey, not the destination. Stop and smell the roses, see the trees, watch the sunset be present in the present.

[@michaellord9]

let's never forget Roger's input in Parts 1 to 4....

[@bmet47]

The performance of "Echoes" from this same show is memorable too!

[@doulos737]

Wow!... I never knew Crosby and Nash performed with Gilmour. What a match up!... Fantastic!... :-)

[@keithpasculli7465]

This is great music with enormous emotional content when you consider the topic.

[@artbagley1406]

The etherealness of this extended-time work is a continuation of PF's early 1970s "Atom Heart Mother," "Echoes," "Meddle," and "Ummagumma" days. Gdmn adverts! KZbin should change their approach to inserting marketing. Sheesh!

[@advans7469]

Just perfect !

[@chrismorris4392]

You might also want to watch Comfortably Numb from the same concert. One David Bowie on vocals. Also one of the last performances of Echoes.

[@markhouck5258]

Kel Was That A Tear Falling From Richs Eye During The Fade? "Love Ya Both" ... Thank You! ...

[@ianchambers6191]

Is this every guy's dream? To have a girl with a passion for real music like Kel has!

[@Bawedge]

Please keep watching any David Gilmour live. Its so fun to watch

[@wmgilliland2582]

This song was for and about Sid Barret, the original force behind Pink Floyd.

[@RushfanUK]

Is was at all 3 nights of these shows back in 2006, stunning shows, 3rd night encore was the best as Nick Mason joined David and Rick on stage, no film of that has come out even though I know there was some filmed as the 3rd night I was sat above the remote camera operators in the choir stalls and could see their screens.

[@marknpb]

Cool, I haven't seen that performance before! :)

[@ronnie241259]

You really need to do Comfortably numb, from the live pulse concert. An absolute eargasm when the endsolo takes off!!

[@1nelsondj]

I love Crosby & Nash, have all their albums. You should react to 'Carry Me' and 'To the Last Whale' both are gorgeous songs from "Wind on the Water."

[@kosys5338]

That video was great. Got a good look at the infamous Gilmore bend that makes David Gilmore a legendary guitarist.

[@shawnc666]

Jesus...that was fucking amazing!!!

[@jeffmiller4832]

Don’t forget, David Bowie did Comfortably Numb in the same concert with Mr. Gilmore and company.

[@philliprayner283]

Brilliant ..what a guitar solo ....should check out ..anything by slade ...one of the most underatted bands ever & been credited as influences ..by the likes of kiss & quite riot amongst many ...

[@timothybessemer7316]

Seeing these rock legends together is magic!

[@flubblert]

Yes indeed!!

[@MatheusFerreira-kx1gp]

So cute! I loved you guys

[@darkpitcher5242]

I love this version but it also makes me sad to see Rick Wright RIP I wish you were here

[@stevenmurano7863]

One of the greatest songs ever. still moves me to this day. There is a Gilmour live version (gdansk maybe?)....where that opening chord that's droning in the back over the intro is done on wine glasses (you read that correctly...wine glasses.). pretty cool!

[@George39280]

If you are moved by the lyrics of songs, I have a song that I know will make the list. The song is Dreamer by Ozzy Osbourne. There is such a powerful msg in those lyrics. I look forward to seeing your reaction to that song. I can already see Kel's reaction in my minds eye.

[@vernhoke7730]

I was working part time during high school as a stock boy in a women's store, Ormonds if either of you remember, in our local mall when this album came out. The assistant manager loved Floyd, Zeppelin and those types of groups, the manager was a full on feminist Carly Simon, Carole King and Helen Reddy type. Used to try and schedule when Meg, the asst manger was working, because the music we had was donated from the Sam Goody store in the mall, she'd load up Welcome to the Machine, Dark Side of the Moon Animals, Zeppelin II, III, IV and Physical Graffitti on the store turntable and turn it up. Made the days or evenings go by so much better!!

[@dorothycollinsware7445]

Can you please do Pink Floyd’s Comfortably Numb my favorite song ever. It fits me having lupus and other problems. It sure helps me thru the horrible days. Love you both.

[@rondohunter8966]

My sympathies to you for your lot in life. Hope the best for all you do.