COUPLE REACTS TO 마마무(MAMAMOO) Wind flower + Where Are We Now MVs

[@h.i3440]

We all agree that Wind Flower is one of everyone's favorite songs, right? is beautiful.

[@brialdamn2317]

Yes definitely . And They knew that that was fans ' favourite song even though that song was not that successful in korea😢.

[@onceyouwheeinyoucantwheeout]

Yesssss

[@8ight603]

All moomoo love wind flower.

[@LaksamanaAziz]

Wind flower is the hidden gem in kpop

[@mmrn2574]

Yup Wind flower is 💚💚💚💚💚💚 a very special. Song to Moomoos

[@邱亭鈞]

Where Are We Now is actually a song talking not only about the disorientation of their life as a singer but also the confusion of their future as Mamamoo. 2021 is the seventh year of Mamamoo, they had been walking together for a long time, but everything just became so different from the time when they debuted. They all had different dreams, careers, and life. Time just ran so fast in these seven years that they could not realize the changes between them, between their relationship, and everything around them. Things became so much more complicated now. I think this song actually brought these four girls back together again to their starting point. They were able to stop and ask themselves, " we've came so far, but where are we now and where are we going?" I truly believe that this song is another starting point of Mamamoo. This songs was made by their tears, laughter, and their memories of the seven years. Although the future might be uncertain and they might sometimes feel lost, but they have each others. They are the strongest when they are Mamamoo. I am always teary whenever I listen to this song, because we all know how many difficulties they had been through to become this famous, successful and iconic legend in Kpop industry. I just wanna say that they always did a good job. I feel so lucky to meet these four gorgeous girls. I will always cheer for them as long as they are standing on the stage.

[@teambellavsteamalice]

Yeah that is so nice! When I first saw it I was scared it was a farewell song! 😱

[@KyrainMcLeod]

Especially in combination with the MAMAMOO documentary with the same name "Where are we now" this is such a heart-breaking song for me (as a Moomoo). I was so relieved when they released 하늘 땅 바다만큼 (mumumumuch).

[@samouraibamboo4446]

Same!! Especially when Wheein and Hwasa sings the last sentence "We both shared the same dream, where are we now?" 🥺 Also there are tons of Easter eggs on the MV for ex in the scene reminiscing of Solar's 'Spit it out' she has Hwasa, Wheein and Moonbyul's tattoos drawn on her, the moon in Wheein's scene is a reminder to the 'Starry Night' scene etc...

[@BlackHoleSpain]

Yep, the 7 years curse. Everybody was thinking they disbanded. In fact this lead to a 1-year hiatus where the 4 of them went solo and brought up such magnificent works. Fortunately Rainbowbridge World have kept them together and we just got a comeback last month with ILLELLA.

[@ELmayberry]

​@@teambellavsteamaliceyeah, I was scared too 😱

[@xheralt]

The very last line of "Where Are We Now", the Hwasa/Wheein duet, "On this beautiful star / the two of us shared the same dream / where are we now" is especially meaningful because Hwasa and Wheein grew up together, went to the same school, dreamed of becoming idols together, and landed in Mamamoo together. And this beautifully highlights their connection.

[@hi_jjesse]

Yes, yes, yes and yesssss. Makes me teary eyes every time

[@omarsoliman2355]

"Where are we now" is NEXT LEVEL,.... so STUNNINGLY emotional. They treated it like a single when it dropped. And people were in shock. like OH YEAH!!! they're the best singers EVER. Did anyone actually forget that? It also came at a time when we didn't think they were staying together. And it sounded like a last song or a break up song. No one really knew. But it definitely added to the emotion.

[@cluster_f1575]

Definitely! IIRC, this was the time when we learned WheeIn chose not to renew her contract with RBW so this very much felt like the end of the road for MMM. Just knowing their journey together & how they’ve remained such a tight-knit group makes this all more the emotional song that hits you in the feels.

[@parthbhatt715]

bro i felt so sad during that era. And the mv just made me cry.

[@shreybaee]

Where Are We Now hits even harder with that final harmony between Wheein and Hwasa when they sing "on this beautiful star the two of us shared the same dream, where are we now?" especially when you know the duo's history. Wheein and Hwasa literally went to grade school and high school together, they're from the same hometown, and have been best friends since they were very young. They both auditioned together for RBW, got in together, trained together, and their dynamic is what inspired RBW's CEO to find members that matched their energy and create Mamamoo. When Hwasa was dealing with internet trolls about her looks, Wheein was there for her. When Wheein was under fire for some stuff her father did (who isn't even in the picture), Hwasa was there for her. They've been through thick and thin with one another. When Hwasa was dealing with anxiety, Wheein was there. Wheein working to cope with her depression, Hwasa was there. They've been with one another through thick and thin. This song was released at a time when their contracts were starting to end; and while Hwasa decided to continue both Mamamoo and solo promotions with RBW; Wheein decided to switch to another company for her solo work with only her Mamamoo promotions being done with RBW. So when they sing "on this beautiful star the two of us shared the same dream, where are we now?" they fully shared the same dream, lived it together, and their journeys are starting to move them away from each other. And so they ask themselves and each other, is our bond still deep? Are we still together? Will our journey end as we walk away? Or is our bond even stronger because no matter what ways our paths go, they will always converge at one point? Is our love for one another enough to conquer the different bridges we are both crossing? It's honestly so heart-wrenching and I love that harmony will all my being.

[@letthemeatkpop]

Where are we now is so emotionally overwhelming. Such a beautiful song

[@thatkpopsis]

Where are We Now literally broke me and I ugly cried when it came out. They were going through contract negotiations and their future together weren’t known by moomoos. I love them so much and I’m so happy they continue to be a group as well as solo artists.

[@faiththomas6137]

"On this beautiful star, the two of us shared the same dream" Hwasa and Wheein harmonizing together at the end NEVER fails to make me emotional

[@CatarinaRock]

The bond these 4 wonderful women have with each other is so special🥲💖

[@monicarlo15]

Moonbyul in windflower era was next level 😩

[@jamescurfman3284]

Where Are We Now was done for the group's Seven Year Anniversary last year (so it has been more than eight years since their debut as of now and obviously they have known each other from before that, so somewhere over a decade...). This song really hit WAY harder for people who were fans and stans from the very beginning or while the group was still trying to find their footing than the way it hit for newer fans. I am a newer fan (just a few years, nothing like the OGs who knew about the ladies from pre-debut) and this song hurt me, so I KNOW that longer-time fans were crying. It's really a soulful piece and it will be one of those legendary timeless masterpieces. It's about the members' collective friendship with each other (especially Wheein and Hwasa because they have known each other since middle school) and the rather rocky road they have had together (including arguing and even fighting with each other). But it's also about their perseverance; how they are still together, how they made it to the seven years together when so many other groups don't make it that long, how they beat a bunch of others in so many shows together (they proved so many people and companies wrong and are still standing). They got disrespected not only individually but also as a group but they are still here because they stayed together. It's BEAUTIFUL, and I cried the first couple of times seeing the MV. It's just as emotionally charged as Hwasa's solo song LMM. These ladies are Awesome, Amazing and just deserve all of the superlatives. Hwasa has one of the most flexible voices, I swear. Maybe she doesn't hit all of THE HIGHEST notes like some others (those would be Wheein and Solar's forte') but you can't argue with her low notes, as you have mentioned. Maybe she doesn't belt quite so BIG as others have (obviously Solar's specialty), but she has real RANGE to her voice, she can go big and harsh or she can go light and delicate, she knows how to be subtle. AND she can rap. Out of the entire group, she's my pick as the Vocal Swiss Army Knife (with Moon Byul right behind her). I am hopelessly OT4. I love every one of these ladies to pieces. I straight up cannot pick just one as a bias because they ALL are, they HAVE to be, because QUEENS. Luv ya both!

[@JemuzuDatsWho]

damn, yall really picked two of their best songs in their discography to check out at once and I am just as shook as I was listening to them the first time... Mamamoo, eternally stunning

[@deempols_meows]

Great reaction! Wind Flower is my fave Mamamoo songs though all of their songs are my favorite it's just that wind flower hit differently. And same as you guys I did tear up a bit the first time Where Are We Now was release. It was a special song as it was from the album before their contract with RBW expires and we all know the 3 (Solar, Monnbyul, and Hwasa) renew their contract and Wheein decided to move to another label agency, but she had a special contract wherein if there are group promotions she will be readily available for Mamamoo that's how much committed she is to the group.

[@deempols_meows]

TMI: Where Are We Now MV actually showed pieces of their different MVs for the last 7yrs, that's why it was really special MV.

[@martinschafer7404]

Wind Flower was shot in Hong Kong and one of the things it's doing is an homage to a famous noir director. The color palette many of the locations and scenes are taken from his films. It's my favorite MV of theirs. Where are We Now came out in early June. It's them singing about their experience over the previous 7 years. 6/19 was their contract expiration and Wheein had not signed. When I heard it I was really afraid they were disbanding and was an emotional wreck for over a week. Final gut punch was Wheein and Hwasa the two middle school friends harmonizing one the "We shared the same dream, where are we now?" The ice cream scene gave me some hope. Funny you have the videos ending in ice cream in this reaction. Mumumumuch finally healed me.

[@ArtelleElloise]

Y'all should totally watch their Paint Me MV, it's so beautiful as well ;;

[@lentucker1920]

I totally agree with this. Wheein has that stunning short hair and seeing all of them in such beautiful dresses looking iconic af.

[@kalaksed]

Oh yeah, wheein's short dark hair we only saw for what felt like 3 seconds before she bleached it for "starry night" (that is one of my favorites on her, but still wished we got more of the short dark style first)

[@hi_jjesse]

​@@kalaksedyes same

[@ChangGang]

Seeing them perform Paint Me in concert was so epic and powerful. Had me tearing up.😢

[@dewiayuritonga6588]

The ice cream scene from Where Are We Now is indeed a homage to Wind Flower. Actually, moomoos could find a lot of things/scenes from Where Are We Now as homages to their older hit songs since Where Are We Now is a song of their 7th years as Mamamoo, the end of their previous contract which gave them roads to go as a group or individuals. Btw, the cinematography & scenes in Wind Flower is based on Wong Kar Wai's films, a famous film director from Hong Kong, where they filmed this.

[@leggosss]

Where Are We Now never failed to tear my heart up everytime i hear it. Knowing the meaning behind this song that makes it more emotional. It hits different. This song is special to Mamamoo.

[@stephp3455]

Also since that time it was a hard time for moomoos and mamamoo too.

[@Redz016]

No matter how many times I listen to "Where are we now" the last part where Wheein and Hwasa sing together always hit me

[@ajyunais]

Like what a lot of the comments have said here, Where Are We Now is a song for their 7th year as a group. Idk if you guys are aware, but idol group contracts lasts for 7 years before the renewal period. This is why there's a thing called "7 year jinx" in kpop. Meaning a lot of groups don't really renew their contracts after, or maybe only some of the members only, causing for the group to continue on but w/o those who didn't renew. Some groups don't even reach the 7th year mark before they disband. This is why the 7th year is a very important for both groups and fans. Just like the title of the song, Mamamoo questions "where are we now?" at the point of their career as a group and as individuals. Personally, the last part hits very hard because the lyrics were "On this beautiful star, the two of us shared the same dream. Where are we now?" and it was sung by Hwasa and Wheein, who are childhood friends since middle school and dreamed of the same dream, and miraculously debuted in the same group.

[@Chili_Moo]

7:46 this scene refers to the Hong Kong gay movie called "Happy Together" ;)

[@leftieceliz]

wind flower is one of my fave mamamoo songs because of the lyrics, but the mv is also so cinematic. where are we now is a whole other level of emotion because it came out on their 7th anniversary, the cursed year when most groups disband and we didn’t know if hwasa and wheein will stay… then they put this song out with these lyrics…i was a mess hahaha

[@Maria-lb5uq]

Where Are We Now was a song that mamamoo dropped for their 7th year aniversary after a period of time where they were more focused on their solo careers. In fact, a documentary came out around the same time where it was revealed that they felt like they were growing apart, not because they cared less about each other, but because they had many things and people in between them. Wheein also left the company around this time so there was an overall sense of dread about mamamoo's future. When this song dropped it was very bittersweet for many fans as it felt like an ending. Now we can see that it was in fact a new beggining and a renewal. After this, the girls grew closer than ever before. They both found peace in their solo careers and realized that mamamoo as a group will always be their safe place and family.

[@wheeinace4123]

Wind flower is that song!!! this is everyone's favorite, even for mamamoo they LOVE this song so much.

[@bobolee10000]

If there is another track that made me sob, it was 'Hello Mama' Its one of their sub track in the album 'Reality in Black', but the LYRICS AND THE MELODY MADE ME CRY SO MUCH If you ever get the chance to check it out I highly recommend it!

[@hannahwalker2386]

Wind flower is one of my favourite Mamamoo songs! So glad you enjoyed it! One interesting thing I saw on a Twitter thread about the music video is that it plays homage to an LGBTQ+ Hong Kong film called Happy Together about the relationship between two men. I think the music video was also filmed in Hong Kong too

[@tashalee2462]

I think it includes references to multiple films from the same director, including Happy Together!

[@tashalee2462]

The scene of Moonbyul and Solar in the cab is from Happy Together and some of their photos show the Happy Together movie poster in the background

[@YoshiPotter88]

OH MY GOODNESS YES YES!! I clicked so fast when I saw the notification, y'all I have been waiting for you guys to react to these because man they are both up there for favorite Music Videos (again Starry Night is still my favorite but those two are really far up there)- I loved every moment of each of these songs, they are just PHENOMENAL! Dude at 1:28 and 7:28 SOLAR CAN STEP ON ME AND I'D SAY THANK YOU- holy cow she was stunning one of my favorite looks from her definitely, at 5:01 and 7:59 same with this Wheein looked so freaking Gorgeous (this and Starry Night and a couple others are my favorite era from her) this short hair on her looked GREAT, at 5:11 this look from Hwasa made me go crazy just again STUNNING like always, 6:33 this was definitely one of my favorites maybe favorite singing/rap from Moon because holy cow the look and her DEEP voice just WOW, at 7:44 as a MoonSun shipper I loved this part they are super cute together, and at 8:38 and 9:46 this made me laugh so hard I was waiting to see your reactions to this because I was confused as well (everyone was)! And for Where Are We Now dude at 11:16 and 14:08 Hwasa looked so stunning and her freaking vocals and the DEEP vocals that she did as well like holy cow she can step on me again, at 12:05 and 13:48 Wheein is just WOW first of all secondly HER VOCALS HAD ME DEAD HOLY COW they are legit like honey, at 12:16 and 14:39 Solar just WOW- just wow not only was she Gorgeous like always but her Vocals had me speechless my jaw dropped when I heard them, at 13:09 Moonbyul in that suit made me go crazy I love that suit on her and that Rap was just AMAZING, at 15:15 okay from here until the end had me again speechless this was beautiful, at 15:50 I legit teared up here with WheeSa singing "The two of us shared the same dream" that was not okay, and at 16:14 I am so glad that you guys watched these two in the same video because of the link with them and the ice cream again I teared up! Anyways I can't wait for you guys to react to more Mamamoo such as more Music Videos, B - Sides, Live Performances, Covers, Dance Practices, Moments, and of course Ships! I can't wait for more Content from you guys and I hope that you both are doing well and staying safe and healthy! P.S. If you ever need any good Videos I could totally help you out if you need it!

[@krysivory493]

MAMAMOO is THE GREATEST gift that keeps giving. 😭🌊

[@christonalva7032]

"Wind flower" was the first ever song that I heard of Mamamoo. It made me a Moomoo. Here I am 3 years later.

[@yozo217]

It’s safe to say that Wind Flower is a fan favorite. So sad that it didn’t do well in the charts cuz rbdumb didn’t properly promote their comeback.

[@wdcemamamoo6586]

Where are we now i think talks about their time together as a group

[@omarsoliman2355]

Has anyone recommended the 2016 MAMAMOO CONCERT 'MOOSICAL? The music set there has some really outstanding songs that you never hear anywhere else. "Dab Dab" and "Funky Boy" are cool. But "Girl Crush" TOTALLY should have been a single. Where is the MV for "Girl Crush"?? It has a similar vibe to HIP,... and that's a huge hit. And they have so much fun singing it too. In the show it is coupled with their version of Pink Panties,... you gotta see them sing it to believe it. But the whole show is FIRE!!! They usually do it with a live band,.. live vocals,... just KILLIN it!!! Just to repeat, (in the category of "we do what the F we want to do") THEY COVER "PINK PANTIES", that catchy Blurred Lines thing. Who on earth WOULD,... and WHY ON EARTH would you?? Mamamoo. watch MAMAMOO MOOSICAL PREVIEW LIVE CUT

[@DatzREIN]

I absolutely love Mamamoo! Where are we now gives me the feels because it was their 7th year and them staying as a group was uncertain. However the behind the scenes of them making the MV is so funny because they are literally beagles but the finished MV literally tears. Wind Flower is a BOP!

[@yunaleenoelle]

Wind flower is and will always be my favorite MAMAMOO song.

[@robertalanfowler4287]

Got to say good choice on the MV's for this one , the ice cream scene at the end means so much seeing them back to back

[@Beniceee.]

8:53 that’s what kess does to us every single livestream 😭😭

[@belld.s5276]

Huh, I just noticed the similar ice cream endings. That's sweet. Yeah, I love both of these MVs. I really like the vibe of WAWN's MV a lot. The RV, the forest, the nostalgic shooting, and the use of contrast, everything. For WF, of course the HK style makes it one of my favorites. The girls are just special, no doubt about it. I mean...I can say so much, I've spent years loving them. I'm just happy to see that even now, they can bring happiness to other people. Sharing their brilliance and inspiration...what more can a moo ask for? Enjoy your journey, ladies.

[@OVarela3103]

I love their live version of where are we now with live band, it's so pretty that I always tear up! Recommend checking it out 😘

[@phoenixwing5133]

I hardcore SOBBED when I first heard Where Are We Now. I had been a fan for only a few years but it hit so hard.

[@nabiddalgi6699]

Thank you for reacting to Wind Flower and WAWN! The music video of Wind Flower is inspired by War Kong Wai movies, most likely Chungking Express and is shot in Hong Kong. The shot where Solar leans onto Moonbyul is a nod to his gay movie Happy Together. The chinese characters Solar painted on her mirror is Wind and Flower.

[@jjjulia127]

WAW is a song that came in MAMAMOO’s 7th Anniversary after Wheein decided to part with RBW as a soloist but to stay as a part of MAMAMOO, and this song brought so much relief to me - MAMAMOO is OT4, they’re 4 as always. I was crying when I watched this video for the first time, it has so deep meaning to moomoos. HwaSa and Wheein are best friends since middle school and they decided to sing together no matter of what, and all the MMM girls had about 50 auditions but nobody wanted to take them in a debut group (what a crime!). And only CEO of RBW risked and created this gorgeous vocal group. As MMM didn’t suit Korean beauty standarts CeO said that girls need to perform like nobody could so they did! And money for girls’ trainings were brought back 4 months after their debut. MAMAMOO has one of the best career in kpop imho. And they are THE ONLY KOREAN GROUP every member of which was on first places in the World ITunes Chart as a soloist. My Queens now and forever❤ Many letters but Inlove these Artist sooo much since 2016 omg

[@grnd4540]

They treat each other as a family member. I cried with you.

[@meimeichan1765]

OMG YESSS MORE MAMAMOO REACTIONS HEHE SEEING BOTH OF YOUR REACTIONS ARE ALWAYS THE BEST!! 🤍🤭😌

[@cinnamonbreeze5618]

wind flower was one of my favorite songs after starry night and the mv is definitely one of my favorites :)) where are we now... the lyrics hit so hard when you realize theyve just been (as the lyrics say) breathlessly running from the start without stopping, wheein went through depression, hwasa developed pre-stage anxiety and has trouble sleeping, moonbyul had insecurities about her singing and solar had to be the leader and pull everyone through even when she wasnt sure of herself. the last part of the song where wheein and hwasa harmonize is so beautiful because they really did chase the same dream, and where are they now?

[@jasonfisher8529]

Ah, the Wind Flower jump scare, gets new reactors every time ROFL And, yeah, it's just an absolute treasure, almost as good as Where Are We Now.

[@jamjam9129]

mamamoo is very confident and brave when they released a ballad title track. what to expect to our 4 unbothered queens

[@lunecelesterosier]

Where Are We Now hits different especially after watching the documentary it's impossible not to get teary over this song

[@arwindrasutapa1243]

Yeaayy.. Wind Flower. My first Favourite song from Mamamoo that makes me stan them 😉😄 Where Are We Now is a song in 2021, where Mamamoo and the Moomoos has the hardest time. This song is so emotional that it reflect the conflict in Mamamoo members heart. And to Moomoos, this song is like a goodbye song from Mamamoo worrying they might get disbanded. A little story for you guys, 2021 is the year where all members contract is finished. In the early year, Solar and Moonbyul renew their contract followed by Hwasa in middle of the year. But Whee In... she hold her contract and doesn't show any sign that she want to renew it. That moments is the hardest moments for Mamamoo especially Solar. She thinks a lot about the future of Mamamoo. And finallay Whee In decided not to renew and move to another company. Why she doesn't want will be talk in another occasion 😄

[@LastKnight0727]

9:20 We all do. Like drinking with Mamamoo and Dreamcatcher (together or separate) is a bucket list item. Where are we know is a song that has so much meaning if you dig into it. It was one of the last songs they put out with all of them being in the same company. It's talking about their journey as a group and how uncertain the future is. The final harmonization with Wheein and Hwasa is super meaningful since they've been together since they were 10 years old and the lyrics reflect their shared dream.

[@freginah]

the photography of wind flower was inspired by the movie "happy together" the 1997, in the mv there are many references like solar and moonbyul in the car and one of them puts his head on the other's gold. It's my favorite mv of them, very beautiful!!!

[@FlowerMumu]

This is my most favorite MV of all time. The music is so good, the lyrics are beautiful, and the colors were amazing. It feels like a Won Kar-wai film.

[@tinggarpradipta]

Where Are We Now composition is so good. The vibes, the story, the MV. It's all perfect ❤️

[@kalaksed]

The closest many of us will likely get to hanging out and drinking with mamamoo is watching their tipsy live videos. They've released 4 of those, so far. They're drinking, eating and having fun together in them all, while also playing games in three of them (the third one, "wind flower" era, was just them hanging out in a restaurant). There is also a much more recent honorary mention of a show called 'my shoulder is dislocated' (which is a popular korean drinking song). They're with three male hosts there, all idols of different generations, but wind up getting tipsy and letting loose there, as well

[@dee2784]

everyone has their own fav song of mamamoo. but windflower just hits different and have special spot to moomoo. it's everyone's fav. period.

[@moomoom]

Always looking forward to your Mamamoo reaction videos :))) They really are so much fun and make my day thank you so much!!

[@najilouk001]

I love how no matter the mood of the song they always find time for ice cream.

[@tana-db4he]

thank u for reaction! I knew I could trust moomoos in explaining the back story of both of these songs also it's a cool coincidence that in both mvs in the end they are eating ice creams🥺

[@iamwynnosaur]

Wind Flower has always been my favorite song from Mamamoo. The MV is also my favorite of them all. It's a masterpiece

[@qkdspace]

oh finally Wind Flower..!!!!!!!

[@mayranoblecilla3217]

Every one, absolutely ALL of us have cried with Where Are We Know, it is part of the many songs that Mamamoo has that even without knowing the lyrics can make you feel the feeling of longing 😭💕

[@hangezoe456]

imagine witnessing 2 amazing songs in one watch!! 💖 the vibes of both songs feel so touching 💖💖

[@carlitadengari]

As always with these ladies, "Where are we now" is even better live.

[@FeveroseJade-bg6zp]

They have a concert tour, i do hope you can watch them live.. But they don't have a US schedule yet..

[@sendarian]

These are definitely great songs, you should see Where are we now, live especially. They sing live as good if not better than the video in the white dresses. Wind flower is also on everyone's favorite list. Great reaction as I have been a moomoo for years so it is nice to see new moomoos experiencing mamamoo and they are an experience. What Solar wrote on the mirror was for Chinese or Japanese writing Wind and Flower. I speak japanese so that is what it is for me. And if you really want to tear up if not cry, watch the liver peformance oft he song 'I love too' at the Moosical concert , RBW made it an official live video so easy to find, I wont spoil anything but not only will you be tearing up, but amazed how they were able to keep singing considering what happened.

[@Ja3bUmp]

I hope they will include "where are we now" in the next concert list 🥺

[@woonieya]

Wind Flower is filmed at Hong Kong (my place!) and Hwasa has an immense love for HK especially the old movie stars and style - the MV’s styling and filming are definitely paying a homage to that. Wind Flower did not manage to win no.1 in music shows and was a less publicly well-known song but it was the members’ favourite 🥲

[@sainetkirman9748]

Ver a Mamamoo es una bomba de emociones💚

[@yugmi853]

Wind flower is superior mmm song! It made me their stan and i still love it

[@mirroruniverse9331]

Where are we now producer got awarded with daesang. It sure has great shots and as a ballad fan, I loved the song and lyrics. I miss my old friends and it's feels nostalgic

[@rocket7D]

Mamamoo is amazing, Wind Flower and Where are we now are work of art!

[@juleemoo6351]

You must watch the behind the scenes of those mv on mamamootv. These songs are so emotional but they filmed it in the funniest and chaotic way. Mamamoo as always.😁😆

[@h.i3440]

I'm early for the first time, I love your reactions ❤️

[@ianian5724]

Windflower... The more you listen to it, the more you like it... And then it becomes your best Mamamoo's song...

[@muzza1967]

There are a few Mamamoo songs that can bring on the tears.

[@autumneagle]

The Wind (Whee In) and Flower (Hwa sa) are truly beautiful

[@sass7047]

Windflower MV is inspired by Wong Kar Wai films. The parallels are amazing. There are Twitter threads that explains the connections well.

[@blurpaholic]

The way they dropped WAW when their contracts we’re about to expire and no one knew what would happen next was pure torture. Beautiful, gorgeous, heart wrenching torture ;___; There we’re tears when I saw the MV the first time and I still get close to crying when I watch it now…

[@dopamine2655]

Can't wait for you guys to react to their Queendom performances.

[@DREx14]

Wind flower is my favorite song of them I'm so happy you reacted to it ☺️🤗❤️

[@CatarinaRock]

Yaaaaay!! WIND FLOWEER!!

[@Regel2008]

Wind Flower definitely one of the underrated title tracks. It didnt get enough love like Starry Night and Egotisic. I believe they also took part in this song and I remember in one performance they were really disappointed on kpop community that Wind Flower wasn’t as popular but they did so much into it (Please correct me if I’m wrong)

[@anonygent]

No, you're right. All of their ballads have had disappointing results compared to their more upbeat songs, but I think that's just the nature of the business.

[@hq3727]

I agree. Blue;S was the least promoted album in 4S4C, MMM choreographed Windflower themselves (last title track they did personally before 1M was introduced in Gogobebe). The girls were already mentally and physically exhausted by then, and Windflower promotion was during year end, where more groups promoted + the year end awards + it being a ballad made it hard for Windflower to get any wins. :( However I feel MMM were heartened to know that WF is one of the most loved by Moomoos even up till now. ❤

[@lapizlapoppy]

Funny how ya'll watched Wind Flower & Where Are We Now together as both ended with an ice cream scene. Like WAWN actually directly referenced WF with that ending ang it was very emotional

[@riconguyenofficial8947]

Wind flower is my mood when I’m like OK, this is it, we all gonna be fine, just chill with the vibe

[@zear704]

Wind flower is my favorite song because it film in my hometown. They dress like the old Hong Kong style is so pretty and the song is so good.❤

[@uunuuliebeleben9323]

These songs are just masterpieces. I really love everything about them. Also, I really enjoy your journey with them. Thank you so much for everything. You would like a bunch of stages of these songs.

[@mamamoojowaeyo8098]

Gladly, you heard this a year after their renewal as a group..

[@RinnietheMOO]

08:33 those are Chinese characters for "Wind Flower." The MV was filmed in Hong Kong, so they probably incorporated that for the concept. Those characters were also on the cassette tape Hwasa put in at the beginning of the video.

[@genesispsalmsadol145]

Trivia: Windflower is one of Mamamoo's fave song, andn there's a scene in the mv that is inspired in a movie. Where Are We Now is just a very heart warming and wholesome song And these fits will always holds a special place in our hearts

[@roparedes3772]

WIND FLOWER is my favorite MV and Song by Mamamoo ever ❤️❤️❤️

[@washn9817]

This is underrated and deserve the Win 🥺 but they arent receiving any for this comeback. This is very beautiful. Even Mamamoo is my second best favourite but this is too beautiful and harmonizing good. I hope they can continue as Mamamoo for a long time❤️

[@esquivelerick]

Beautifulls songs both of them, but I love where are we now the most.

[@bartovra1657]

You guys I recommend watching the video of mamamoo after the manager falls asleep, it's very funny ❤

[@hossetttren253]

windflower is mamamoo members fav too and fandom

[@autumneagle]

I'm excited to see your reaction to Paint Me when you get to it

[@Vlc506]

So glad you played Where are we now. I’m always requesting this one and no one ever plays it. I just adore this mv and song. Mamamoo is the best and only female group I watch.🫶🏻

[@TheAlanaria]

You should take a look at "Paint Me" because it's such a great song and often overlooked by newer fans in my opinion.

[@Moon_Wolfie]

Wind flower was a track that grew on me, Moonbyul’s rap is spot on as usual. Where are we now.. that damn song almost made or did make MooMoo’s cry. I just wish it had more Moonbyul.. thought I think all Mamamoo songs need more Moonbyul to equal out the distribution. Where are We Now is the title of an album that was just ballads and that is something I don’t think any other female KPop group has done. Be is promote a ballad or make an album of just ballads. The where are we now video had so many little Easter eggs in the camper trailer.I believe Solar was originally suppose to wear the dress Byul wears and vice versa, but instead Solar ended up in the sexy dress and Byul in the ruffle dress…

[@oof8099]

Only mamamoo can make me cry with a song

[@aka_slendy]

Where Are We Now makes me cry every time

[@melissaw5583]

These two MV's were actually really fitting to be in the same video, since the ice cream scene in WAWN was a callback to Wind Flower. Looking forward to your deep dive!

[@Jfyfy]

Really love your mamamoo reactions!! I love these 2 songs as well. And I suggest you guys react to other beautiful mamamoo vocal heavy songs that will surely make u cry. Particularly : Paint Me, I love you too, and I miss You (Queendon Version) 💕