China: Anthem History

[@KingdomofFiume]

Like my content? You can support my channel by buying me a coffee: buymeacoffee.com/?via=kingdomoffiume Google Slides version (created by BrazillianBasti). This somehow includes Taiwan, but I haven't included Taiwan in this video: docs.google.com/presentation/d/1ecPm0BJLvmXq1z28pzRGgBkGsyCTpcmIqra0my1QANw/edit#slide=id.p

[@leMiG31]

dotn worry,anthem of taiwan is still same as anthem of roc

[@ragewell2097]

Bro,the Republic of China still exists

[@奧地利落榜小畫家]

I’m from Taiwan .So in my school, we says Republic of china(Taiwan) is a country.But in People’s Republic of china(China mainland) Taiwan is just a part of them

[@HuaHua-xv9lq]

@@奧地利落榜小畫家 还好不是独

[@奧地利落榜小畫家]

@@HuaHua-xv9lq 啥意思？

[@alanturing6232]

Great respect to Sun Yat-sen, the most indomitable person I have ever seen , the only light in a dark time

[@maximobrunogallardobravo1640]

Are you sure Buddy?

[@codyshi4743]

I wish Sun was indomitable, but sadly he fell for Yuan Shika’s stupid trick, by handing Yuan Shula the Chinese presidency.

[@maximobrunogallardobravo1640]

@@codyshi4743 read the book "Soong sisters" of Jung Chang

[@maximobrunogallardobravo1640]

@Long Hei Linus KWAN TV soong, HH kung they was part of the soong family as Sun yat sen and Chiang Kai shek

[@maximobrunogallardobravo1640]

@Long Hei Linus KWAN i dont know them ill investigate thank u

[@troller1257]

The roc and PRC might have different ideologies but they still honor sun yat sen 中国人：虽然中华民国和中华人民共和国有不同的意识形态，但他们仍然尊重孙中山先生。

[@世胄]

你说的对

[@myeonwooozheng5263]

He is the father of modern China

[@CannibaLouiST]

both kmt and ccp are byproducts of the ussr

[@James-cq2bj]

Taiwan doesn’t anymore because the Americans told them so

[@troller1257]

@@James-cq2bjbro what

[@khongpengthao5602]

6 DAYS AFTER THE ANTHEM WAS ADOPTED. rip to the person who composed the whole thing just for it to be replaced by sun yat sen's republic

[@Arthur-gs2jr]

It’s a banger tho

[@shinmoroboshi8632]

NATIONAL ANTHEMS OF CHINA "Pu Tian Yue" (unofficial)1878-1896 "Tune of Li Zhongtang" (unofficial) 1896-1906 "Praise the Dragon Flag" (unofficial) 1906-1911 "Cup of Solid Gold" 1911-1912 "Song of Five Races Under One Union" 1912-1913 "Song to the Auspicious Cloud" 1913-1915 "China Heroically Stands in the Universe" 1915-1921 "Song to the Auspicious Cloud" 1921-1928 "Three Principles of the People" 1930-present "The Internationale" 1931-1937 "March of the Volunteers" 1949-present

[@pidgurus]

Tune of Li Zhong Tang: It's our masterpiece 🥰 Praise of Dragon Flag: So there are our final times of this empire, but our hope for a Great Future is undefeating! Let's fight for our Dragon Empire! 🫡🐉 Cup of Solid Gold: Rise in Peace on Heaven, Qing! 🫡📜🐉🪦 Song of Five Races under One Union: So, Empire is already dead, but we're still Bros! Right? 🤓 Song of the Auspicious Cloud: Opera 🎹🎙️ China heroically stands in the Universe: Let's return our past glory! 🤓 Soviet Anthem of China: Let's build communism! 🤓⚒️ National Anthem of the Republic of China: Here we are! 🇹🇼 National Anthem of Manchukuo "early": Japan, help me! 🇯🇵😫 National Anthem of Manchukuo: Thanks, Japan! 🇯🇵🥰 Wang Jing Wei Anthem: Yipee! We're in Japan 🇯🇵🇹🇼🤓 March of the Volunteers: Let's work! ✊😄🇨🇳 The East is Red: Yipee! Communism! 🇨🇳⚒️🤓

[@TonyBrown12138]

视频做的非常好，所有历史的歌曲都呈现出来了！

[@YourLocalGeemanEmpire]

I heard Qing's anthem before and I loved it

[@svenheilborn1537]

Congratulations for your national holiday on 1st October China from your friends in Germany

[@ss_super_steve]

i think you missed it by 9 days, the correct day is on 10/10 also known as double 10th day which recently passed

[@akriegguardsman]

@@ss_super_steve he must mean oct-1 founding day in mainland China where the parades and stuff take place

[@ss_super_steve]

@@akriegguardsman i was making a joke on how that day is the incorrect founding day as the Republic of China (Taiwan) (Real China) was born on the 10/10/1911 and officially became founded on 1/1/1912

[@Angelina-ie4wf]

@@ss_super_steve 1911年10月10日 台湾属于日本。

[@ss_super_steve]

@@Angelina-ie4wf 正確，在第二次世界大戰結束之前，中華民國基本上與台灣島沒有任何關係

[@jw1731]

The Manchukuo anthem seemed to be sung by Japanese singers judging by the accent and the lack of retroflex consonants.

[@Inunaki_Doraemon]

満州国国歌は韓国の方の歌唱したものらしいです 大満州帝国国歌は日本から移住した人達が日本語で歌っていますね

[@jw1731]

@@Inunaki_Doraemon Ah I see. Now that I listened to it again I did notice the 'z' sound was shaky and sounded more like a 'j', which I understand is characteristic of a Korean accent when speaking Mandarin, since Korean doesn't naturally have the 'z' consonant.

[@Soxial_credits]

@@jw1731 The Koreans were part of the Japanese Empire and Manchukuo was a puppet state for Japan so it was Koreans and Manchus singing in Chinese.

[@nicelol5241]

@@Soxial_credits yep, some Koreans helped the invasion of Manchuria

[@shawonahammad5440]

I love Chinese history. and I love all China’s history culture and peoples ❤❤❤ 🇨🇳🇹🇼🧧🎎🍚🍜🥡🍣🐲🐉

[@matthewnggametime2537]

🥟🥟🥟

[@Owen-tb9qy]

Mhm u sure about that do u know what happened in china like in the mid 1800s to the 1950s

[@katerinadyandraprasetyohad6809]

🇨🇳 18:17

[@shawonahammad5440]

​@@katerinadyandraprasetyohad6809 Hmm... Nice ❤❤

[@katerinadyandraprasetyohad6809]

🎋🎍🎎🎆🧧🥟🥠🥮🍜🍚🐲🇨🇳

[@danielsirola1596]

Amazing as always :)

[@themomentchannel3498]

This video really shows how much China has changed in "only" 100 years time

[@MasoonCh]

The ROC is not dead, but lost to the Chinese Communist Party in 1949. (because of the ROC Anti-Japanese War of 1930-1940) The Nationalist government moved to Taiwan in 1949. 中國人和臺灣人不要在我言論下爭吵

[@토토리1912자유중국]

That is right!!!👍

[@MasoonCh]

@yiling shi 什麼惡搞..？

[@lollife121]

相信我 中华民国会卷土重来 大陆一定会重见天日

[@wengkee8081]

@@lollife121 你就像期待反清复明的人结果反了清但是却民国了。

[@闲云清清]

青天白日旗原是中华民国海军旗，陆军旗为铁血十八星后更正十九星，目前台湾的民主政府已经无法成为代表中国的民主政府，在蔡英文的领导下，台湾也过渡到了台湾，逐渐褪去了中华正统的颜色，与 3:39 五色旗下的先辈已经形成了差距

[@Avionicx]

Funnily enough, the current CCP anthem, was first made by the RoC. March of Volunteers isn't strictly a Communist song, but was made in response to the Japanese invasion

[@dingrobin7924]

it wasn't made by "RoC", the "RoC" didn't make the song, it's like saying just because l'internationale was made by a guy from a country that's capitalism, the song is made by capitalism.

[@孙笑川258-d9l]

《义勇军进行曲》的作者是中国共产党人

[@孙笑川258-d9l]

@@dingrobin7924 你看过这部电影吗

[@reynardsetiawanz8778]

@@孙笑川258-d9l What movie?

[@lgordon7054]

made in ROC, made at ROC, not "by" ROC...

[@TonnamChannel]

Good work!

[@winniechau4442]

Thank god

[@GumballWeek]

2:11 my favorite early anthem

[@USSFFRU]

The reason Cup of Solid Gold lasted so short was because China was so amazed at how good the song was and collapsed on the spot.

[@Gedaaa]

中国似乎不会再有这么好听的音乐了 Unfortunately, there won't be such beautiful music in China anymore

[@matthewnggametime2537]

because after qing dynasty all the anthem use western instrument

[@TOMTOM-ui8tl]

偉大的孫中山永垂不朽！！！！！

[@Cheucoun]

청나라 0:11 : 이중당악 1:15 : 송룡기 (음질 개선) 2:11 : 공금구 중화민국/제국 시기 3:10 : 오족공화가 3:36 : 경운가 4:54 : 단호하게 선 조물주, 중국이여! (중국웅립우주간) 내전기 6:37 : 국제가(중국어 인터내셔널가) 8:12 : 중화민국 국가(삼민주의가),국기가 중일전쟁기 10:37 : 만주국 건국가 12:10 : 만주국 건국가(1934-1945) 13:52 : 중화민국 국가 (왕징웨이 정권) 중화인민공화국 18:12 : 의용군 행진곡 18:59 : 동방홍 21:36 : 의용군 행진곡 (마오쩌둥 시기) 22:21 : 의용군 행진곡

[@Switzerlandball5316]

오 한국인이다!!

[@1Players4Joins]

?

[@Citizen.kanntv]

0:11은 이중당악 아닌가요?

[@matthewnggametime2537]

18:59 is Dong Fang Hong (东方红）

[@matthewnggametime2537]

21:36 is after the death of mao ze dong

[@eviluchiha]

*Support Republic of China, the one, best and true China!!* 🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼 Love from Brazil 🇧🇷

[@laoganmalover88]

we won fair and square the kuomingtang fucking lost and begged america to help.

[@Joao_Victor753]

E a Dinastia Qing?

[@doremi_sweet_official]

😡you are wrong, the only china is the DAQING DYNASTY

[@NathanGreau-h8u]

No the real china is people’s républic or china 🇨🇳🇨🇳🇨🇳

[@doremi_sweet_official]

Have you died before 1949?

[@拒绝模仿]

还是感觉卿云歌更体现中华精髓，词作者出自古典籍《尚书·大传》表达出尧舜禅让，百官齐鸣政通人和，让一个民族铭记并传颂千古的美德！

[@franklyu5972]

开头的旋律太有意境啦

[@peterpancake506]

还是进步一点吧 整点新的

[@mark6-]

現在中國實行的就是「禪讓制」， 由「在位者」於云云競爭者中，挑選出德能出眾者作為「繼任人」。而能於百千萬人中大浪淘沙，得以成為「競爭者」的，莫非精英中的精英；猶能脫穎而出，實乃精英中的精英中之頂尖精英也。 人口結構是欖核型，極智極愚置於兩端尖，中間皆是「智而愚」與「愚而智」者。而把「領袖選擇權」交與極少數的「頂尖精英」之手，抑或放諸絕大多數的庸碌者之手；孰優孰劣，見仁見智。

[@teinyihsia1963]

民國時期的國旗歌最能顯出大中華的美景 山川壯麗 物產豐隆 炎黃世冑 東亞稱雄 哪個中國人聽了都激動

[@ericcheung7959]

@@teinyihsia1963 如今真的东亚称雄了，不知道孙总理在天上能不能看得到😢

[@NETHERITE_STAIRS_PHOTOCRAFT]

0:14 Magra Cing 1636-1912 (李中堂乐) 1:16 Magra Cing 1636-1912 (颂龙旗) 2:12 Magra Cing 1636-1912 (鞏金甌) 3:12 Smire I Cina 1912-1915 (五族共和歌) 3:39 Smire I Cina 1912-1915 (卿雲歌) 4:56 Hemir I Cina 1915-1916 (中藏纛立字苗閒) 5:33 Smire I Cina 1915-1928 (中银要立字苗閒) 6:40 Cinu Sovu Smire 1931-1937 (Internationale) 8:14 Smire I Cina 🇹🇼 1930-1949 (中等民国国跃) 10:39 Esta I Mants 1932-1934 (溝洲國國歌) 13:54 Res Nao Gor I am Smire I Cina 1940-1945 (Zonghuaminjujuui) 18:14 Pea Smire I Cina 🇨🇳 1949-1978 (Uiryonggunhanjingok) 19:44 Pea Smire I Cina 🇨🇳 1949-1978 (Manlijangsenghanjingok) 21:38 Pea Smire I Cina 🇨🇳 1978-1982 (Maoqianjin) 22:24 Pea Smire I Cina 🇨🇳 1982-Prensent (Uiryonggunhanjingok)

[@strasbourgeois1]

what language

[@NETHERITE_STAIRS_PHOTOCRAFT]

Chinese

[@YasarLee]

我覺得中等民國國躍是不是該寫成中等民國國樂

[@DaQian-k7v]

@@YasarLee反正我是看不懂他在寫什麼 不懂中文還硬要寫的外國人唄

[@auclairdelalune314]

國旗歌和義勇軍進行曲都寫在生死存亡之秋，是民國的頌歌和衛國戰爭的戰歌

[@IRNKLLR]

good video as always and im sorry i didnt know you uploaded

[@kevinkuo5434]

国旗歌气势磅礴、意气昂扬，这才是中国真正之国歌。

[@闲云野鹤-g5w]

歌曲虽好，但国不给力 先光复大陆吧

[@themomentchannel3498]

@@闲云野鹤-g5w 現在它足夠強大

[@lvmakin]

国旗歌好听是挺好听的，可惜是个德国国歌的山寨版🤣

[@High_lord_of_Formosa]

可惜就剩个岛还在野

[@themomentchannel3498]

@@High_lord_of_Formosa 可悲的是，对此无能为力

[@peterpancake506]

The Internationale is the best. Workers of all lands unite!

[@约瑟夫·维萨里奥诺-f5d]

人民万歲！

[@bliecoug1029]

But liderated by horrible dictators

[@ss_super_steve]

@@bliecoug1029 liberated is the wrong word here, conquered and oppressed is the right one, not to mention most likely killed due to starvation

[@bliecoug1029]

@@ss_super_steve i say liderated not liberated and yes they got tortured kzbin.info/www/bejne/gqLTfYGKo9SjpNk

[@Soxial_credits]

@@bliecoug1029 Workers unite under some middle class guy. They should just make a democratic country and create a workers party and get elected, less blood.

[@IndigoFei]

The Republic of China anthem wasn't from 1930-1949, as it is still used today on the current Republic of China, capital located in Taiwan. Do note there are two Chinas, and not that the Republic ended in 1949 as it still lives on.

[@membersear9899]

是的，共产中国和民主中国

[@G107nationalroad]

Does anyone admit you? So the Qing Dynasty is still there?

[@中华人民共和国台-u3j]

@@G107nationalroad 哪个国家敢承认有两个中国？一中原则是全世界都承认的，凤梨是不是吃多了 脑子不好使了

[@jacobsmith8272]

@@G107nationalroad 中华民国有自己的国旗国徽货币政府总统，中华人民共和国一天也没统治过台湾，小粉红别再幻想了

[@约瑟夫·维萨里奥诺-f5d]

這麼牛，有本事讓國際社會承認

[@horoyoiryokucha]

8:12 Republic of China (1930 - Present )

[@harryjcy4500]

1928 - 1949

[@wolverine9377]

ROC long dead, Some lady dictator is there now 😉😉

[@邱碧鈺-o2d]

@@harryjcy4500 no is you country

[@harryjcy4500]

@@邱碧鈺-o2d 乜個意思？ What meaning?

[@orange99666]

@@harryjcy4500 今年是中華民國111年。。。

[@nahlene1973]

I love L'internationale the best, it represents the purest, most idealistic stage of the CCP, and (back then) they were awesome!

[@hoiboronguyen3127]

3:46 this isn’t 1913-1915’s recording, this is 1921-1928’s recording, because the auspicious Cloud from 1913-1915 had the different lyrics and song from 1921-1928

[@erkesi123]

正确的，多了一句“时哉夫，天下非一人之天下也”

[@TrilliCents]

FUN FACT : Sun yat sen was the founder of KMT, established ROC, admited CPC. While mainland China still honor the great man, Taiwan forgot him.

[@dickenstham5075]

What do you mean Taiwan forgot about him. Both Chiang and Sun Yat-sen are revered as father and son of the Republic

[@jasonjung0614]

I am a Taiwanese and I don’t know what the fuxk are you talking about?

[@courtly5982]

@@dickenstham5075 kmt failed to outdo the green separatist, now the current president honors a Japanese man who denies war crimes done to the same republic of China citizens. Sun yat sen would be disappointed in these scumy Separatists.

[@怪兽大]

忘了他可还行，你会背国父遗训吗？

[@Soxial_credits]

Yuan Shikai destroyed his plans of a Republic and ended up creating the Warlord Era. If Yuan Shikai never existed and the Tongmenhui robbed banks instead of being funded by foreigners who want Qing officials to be in Parliarment, the world would be different.

[@中國人柚子]

ROC is 👍 🇹🇼1912～至今

[@Zacky51188]

The ROC, a Nationalist regime under KMT was from 1937-1949 on the mainland and from 1949-present day on the island of Taiwan only. In 1949, the Nationalists lost the civil war on the mainland and retreated to the island of Taiwan so their legitimate rule was no longer recognized. Actually Taiwan is under DPP now. Acoording to reality and the UN, ROC is not really the legitimate China. Very few countries recognized it. Why still recognize a government or administration (ROC) which no longer control China nor represent it on the international stage? There is only one legitimate China from 1949.

[@Sibalabiji]

@@Zacky51188 美國講英文為什麼不是英國人，難道埃及、印度、新加坡講英文就是美國人

[@Zacky51188]

@@Sibalabiji please translate to English

[@SWIFTIESCHN]

意识形态是可以商量的东西，但是叛国搞独立是没有任何好下场的👍

[@Soxial_credits]

@@Zacky51188 If only Sun Yat-Sen and Lenin lived longer.

[@globalmotion6973]

china actually had 2 anthems which the other is ode to the motherland

[@tw_fish5462]

一首是中華民國國旗歌

[@johnchristiancanda3320]

And "The East is Red".

[@NETHERITE_STAIRS_PHOTOCRAFT]

Intro 0:01 Intro Qingoce 0:15 Gran Qing 1636-1636-1912 (Tune of Li Zhongtang) 1:16 Gran Qing 1636-1912 (Praise the Dragon Flag) 2:12 Gran Qing 1636-1912 (Cup of Solid Gold) Normal Wallday 3:13 República do China 1912-1915 (Song of Five Races Under One Union) 4:57 Imperio do China 1915-1916 (China Heroically Stands in the Universe) 5:34 República do China 1915-1928 (China Heroically Stands in the Universe) 6:40 Chinoce Soviet República 8:14 República do China 🇹🇼 1930-1949 (Nacional Himno do de República do China) Japanese 10:41 Estado do Manchuria 1932-1934 (Nacional Himno do Manchukuo) 11:10 Imperio do Manchuria 1934-1945 (Nacional Himno do Manchukuo) 12:13 Imperio do Manchuria 1934-1945 (Nacional Himno do Manchukuo) Old 13:53 Reprganizos Nacional Governmentos do de República do China 🇹🇼 1940-1945 (Nacional Himno do de República do China) 15:17 Reprganizos Nacional Governmentos do de República do China 🇹🇼 1940-1945 (Wang Jingwei Regime Song) Old in Now 18:13 Paopla's República do China 🇨🇳 1949-1978 (Marcia do de Voluntos) 19:00 Paopla's República do China 🇨🇳 1949-1978 (De Lest Tos Roje) 21:38 Paopla's República do China 🇨🇳 1978-1982 (Marcia do de Voluntos) 22:23 Paopla's República do China 🇨🇳 1982-Present (Marcia do de Voluntos)

[@matthewnggametime2537]

thanks and what language is that

[@Virrit332]

Spanish, probably.

[@冷冷的竖琴]

I think the melody of this one 3:39 is the best

[@lijiehou3816]

最文雅的一首

[@Adrian-ho3rz]

The first anthem at 0:11 reminds me of the "Anthem of the Beiyang Fleet"

[@panda-oc2dq]

the same

[@yuluoxianjun]

The International and 09:39 IS THE best

[@ss_super_steve]

man the communist oppressors really managed to take on so many people with unfortunately catchy music

[@Soxial_credits]

The International is international and has many international translations which are beautiful but can never match the French lyrics' beauty, but the Mongolian version is very cool.

[@ss_super_steve]

@@Soxial_credits ofc, but when an authoritarian/totalitarian/communist reigieme uses it, it becomes bad, it was initally a good revolutionary song but the communists basically tarnished all of what it had and now in certain contexts and langauges it is evil

[@americancommunist6076]

@@ss_super_steve Liberators*

[@ss_super_steve]

@@americancommunist6076 mm yes because liberation means oppression and killing and forcing a restructure of society, go read more on actual red terrors and crimes against humanity done by communists

[@jorgeperalta6113]

9:36 also "Sporting Anthem of Chinese Taipei"

[@huaiwei]

Still my favourite. ;)

[@等待沒結果的愛]

但這個其實是 中華民國 國旗歌

[@usershit123]

@@等待沒結果的愛 最好聽的

[@plaguedoc7727]

1:17 sounds *chefs kiss* terrific!

[@IcefPr.]

Cup of Solid Gold seems the only Chinese anthem that truly hold the Chinese essence, they should just change the lyrics when after the revolt

[@chuxiaohe-_5620]

translation of 2:11 ”巩金瓯“ 巩金瓯 承天帱 /gong jin ou/ /cheng tian chou/ ”巩“ means solidify,also means "consolidate"when describing nation,"金 "means gold/golden,"瓯"is a special form of cups that being use to contain wine,"金瓯"=golden cup,were often used in royal funeral as burial objects,so in here it represent royal,or Qing dynasty, "巩金瓯"=(may) Qing stay consolidate. "承" means inherit, "天”is sky, also commenly used as a metaphor of emperor,"帱" is a fabric being use to cover bed like mosquito net or cover wagons, "承天帱"=(we)inherit sky`s (or emperor`s) cover. (being sheltered by sky or king) 2:25 民物兴凫藻 /min wu xing fu zao/ "民"simply means people(mostly used to describe lower classes people,like 'citizens' in english), "物" is "object", "兴" is very hard to translate in a single word, in this sentence it means "great, good". for exmp: "高兴"means happy,"高" means tall(in height) or highly, highly gerat/good is "happy". "凫" means duck, "藻"is algae, duck splashing in algae can represent ''happy""self-confidence". "民物兴凫藻"=citizens and every 'objects' are revival to great like duck splashing in algea 2:32 喜同袍 /xi tong pao/ "喜”means like,happy (emotion ways), "同" means same, for exmp "同学" is classmate, "学”is study, so 'study in same (class)' is classmate. "袍" represent robe. so "同袍" is '(the people) (wearing) same robe' =fellow countrymen. "喜同袍"=every fellow countrymen (will) felt happy (becuz living under the rule of Qing) 2:37 清时幸遭 /qing shi xin zao/ "清"has other definations but in here is Qing,"Qing" is the pronunciation of "清". "时" means time, "幸”means luck, "遭"can means encounter,(in chinese we often use 遭 when something bad happens, but it`s not the case in here) "清时幸遭"= it`s our luck to "encounter" these great times 2:44 真熙皞 /zhen xi ao/ " 真"means real/really/true/truely "熙""皞"has different meanning when being used separatly, but only means "peaceful,happly and rarely" "真熙皞"=how rarely and happly time(now) 2:48 帝国苍穹保 /di guo cang qiong bao/ "帝" is emperor,"国" is an nation/country."帝国" is empire. "苍穹"also means sky but in a meta way,like "firmament"or "domes","保" is protect "帝国苍穹保"=our empire will be protected by the domes 2:55 天高高 海涛涛 /tian gao gao/ /hai tao tao/ if u remember i mentioned "天" and "高”in text, "天高高" is highly sky, "海"is sea,"涛" is waves (in water) "天高高 海涛涛"=highly sky and waving ocean

[@chuxiaohe-_5620]

formal translation： Firm and Stable be the golden cup domed by the Celestial concave. In it men and things happily prosper. Glad are we who live in the time of Purity. May Heaven protect and secure us from enemies and help us to reach the truly golden age! Oh! The Blue firmament is infinitely high and the seas flow everlastingly i always found out that CN to ENG translations were often inaccuracy and incomplete, u can tell many conten missing in this formal translation

[@文伟谢]

帝國苍穹保

[@约瑟夫·维萨里奥诺-f5d]

我不明白為什麼臺灣會變成這樣，它在90年代還很正常，堅決要統一，反臺獨。

[@约瑟夫·维萨里奥诺-f5d]

@爷爷 野 不是岌岌可危，中國不適合走資本主義道路，就算走了也是死路一條，但是某個姓鄧的卻讓中國走了官僚資本主義

[@user-fn7pz7ju7y]

@@约瑟夫·维萨里奥诺-f5d 你人如其名，就是个网左，能不能爬

[@johnyeh1679]

我也反台獨，但統一是怎麼統？誰被誰統？一定是大吞小？

[@pbbddq]

痾，你知道中國官方文件上的「台獨」包含中華民國獨立嗎

[@huuac5772]

Cup of Solid Gold 🔛🔝

[@irene_deneb]

I didn't know the Japanese collaborator regime adopted a new anthem.

[@rouwd4wn649]

Technically wang jingwei copied the ROC national anthem but used the "far east nations march" as a representation of his "restructuring process of china" which would definitely have taken out the yellow strippe of the flag after concluded... Fun fact... It never happened because first and foremost the japanese saw wang as a minor party and secondly japan lost the war

[@raghusankaran7230]

I like the cups of solid gold and the modern version of march of the volunteers

[@yoyohighness]

國旗歌每聽一次哭一次

[@jimmychen4308]

哪裡有國旗歌？

[@taotao3138]

@@jimmychen4308 9:37開始 是中華民國國旗歌 以前學校升旗典禮的時候要先唱國歌，唱完再唱國旗歌

[@Vesta_FPS]

就算現在升旗的時候只放國歌，但很多人私下會去聽國旗歌，而且真的很催淚，想起那些為革命犧牲的英雄

[@WindsorYeh]

@@taotao3138現在也一樣

[@historicalmusicdemchugdongrub]

If I may ask where did you find the Wang Jingwei Regime version of the ROC Anthem?

[@KingdomofFiume]

Hello! I couldn't find a ROC Anthem directly performed by the Wang Jingwei regime, but this was recorded when that regime was active (1941). It was performed by the Brazilian Guards Battalion. kzbin.info/www/bejne/bKqcZYl8d5qIp6s

[@historicalmusicdemchugdongrub]

@@KingdomofFiume Ah fair enough that's still a very interesting recording

[@純愛戰神-c8y]

@@historicalmusicdemchugdongrub kzbin.info/www/bejne/jHy9ZHt9fK-Fg7s

[@chervona-kalyna-1991]

in fact the same with official ROC anthem no difference, It played on Wang’s funeral

[@文伟谢]

大正时代

[@germany7846]

Nice video

[@black1837]

For no reason (i dont like political war and i dont wanna mention the ideology) i like the melodies if anthem above 1928

[@Soxial_credits]

Music that is good does not deserve to be looked down on because of idealogy.

[@宇主-m1v]

Zhung Guc' Guc Ga' Yơc Sa 🇨🇳 0:13 Ðai Čong 🐉 1636-1912 (李中堂樂) 1:16 Ðai Čong 🐉 1636-1912 (頌龍旗) 2:13 Ðai Čong 🐉 1636-1912 (鞏金甌) 3:11 Zhung Hua Min Guc 🇷🇸 1912-1915 (五鏃共和歌) 3:38 Zhung Hua Min Guc 🇷🇸 1912-1915 (卿雲歌) 4:56 Zhung Hua Zhe Guc 🇦🇽 1915-1916 (中華雄立宇宙間) 5:33 Zhung Hua Min Guc 🇷🇸 1915-1928 (中華雄立宇宙間) 6:01 Zhung Hua Min Guc 🇷🇸 1915-1928 (卿雲歌) 6:39 Zhung Hua' So Yu Ai' Gong Hua Guc ☭中 1931-1937 (國際歌) 8:14 Zhung Hua Min Guc 🇹🇼 1930-1949 (中華民國國歌) 10:38 Man Zhu' Guc 🎌 ❋ 1932-1934 (滿州國國歌) 11:10 Man Zhu' Zhe Guc 🎌 ❋ 1934-1945 (滿州國國歌) 12:11 Man Zhu' Zhe Guc 🎌❋ 1934-1945 (滿州國國歌 1945年 Version) 14:06 Zhung Hua Min Guc' Guc Min Zhơng Bu 🇹🇼 1940-1945 (中華民國國歌) 18:13 Zhung Hua In Min Gong Hua Guc 🇨🇳 1949-1978 (义勇军进行曲) 19:00 Zhung Hua In Min Gong Hua Guc 🇨🇳 1949-1978 (東邦紅) 21:37 Zhung Hua In Min Gong Hua Guc 🇨🇳 1978-1982 (义勇军进行曲) 22:23 Zhung Hua In Min Gong Hua Guc 🇨🇳 1982-Present (义勇军进行曲)

[@orange99666]

不錯哦，身爲中國人，我都沒聽過這些國歌，感謝！中華民國萬歲！！！

[@wiwaifanqiang]

战无不胜的马克思列宁主义毛泽东思想万岁

[@良辰好景]

大漢萬歲

[@whosyourdaddy5719]

你不是中国人，你是台湾人。中国不需要台湾的媚日舔美的狗。台湾人不配做中国人

[@文伟谢]

爲國聽萬嵗

[@RealHuaxia]

大漢民族万岁！！！

[@ErinyeronL]

我喜欢中华苏维埃共和国，国际歌真的很振奋人心🎉

[@sanneoi6323]

The anthems of the first and second republics are so beautiful they make me cry, all the anthems before 1928 were beautiful.

[@12823matthewkao]

One minor correction ROC: 1912- present

[@Soxial_credits]

Social credit -999999999

[@petercui5464]

really minor, not gonna lie

[@GR-lz1kp]

thanks my friends,ROC never die!!!!

[@GR-lz1kp]

@@petercui5464 We failed, so we lost a lot of territory...

[@wenrongliu-bv2tj]

​@GR-lz1kp反攻😊

[@nammonchanel2655]

我真的很喜歡這個技巧！

[@余書德]

Long live the Republic of China 🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼🇹🇼

[@余書德]

@@lmpulseno2429 hahaha....wumao.... KZbin is a crime in your country haha

[@Maoistcommunistpartyofpl]

Ah yes such a terrible commie China disalowing gore and porn omg like guys LOOK AT THIS CENSORSHIP I AM A LITTLE YANKEE THAT SUPPORTS TAIWAN BECAUSE OF DEMOCRACY (DICTATORSHIP) THAT IS IN THIS MOUNTAIN LONG LIFE REPULIC OF YELLOW USA Cope harder kid long life people's republic of china

[@membersear9899]

@@lmpulseno2429 等你可以自由上网并且政党轮替实现双普选后再说吧----来自菲律宾华人

[@user-Solntse527]

@@lmpulseno2429 你的国家不让你翻墙

[@HuaHua-xv9lq]

@@lmpulseno2429 大哥分地方啊，别又给我们招黑

[@bozhoutian5104]

The international人类历史上最伟大的梦想

[@chuwinne8104]

对

[@faaizahmed5773]

m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/rp_dq56pYtd-f6s

[@sll6773]

中华民国是1912-至今 严谨一点

[@ColinMcdonald-u9y]

我记得国民党在台湾都快干不过民进党了吧，还至今😂

[@xcat-6789]

​@@ColinMcdonald-u9y同胞 外網新聞看一下kmt的現狀 慈湖的那位老頭都要跑出來了

[@Glaozed]

1918年之前，海参崴还属于中国。 苏联建国之后，清朝最后一批边防军离开海参崴。

[@张小强-f9n]

中华民国存在，我承认。但是不过是流亡政府罢了，和南明小朝廷有什么区别？

[@sun.nielsen]

地理:中原大國(中國) 國家政權: 大清帝國(1636-1912) 中華民國🇹🇼(1912-1949) 中华人民共和国🇨🇳(1949-今) 政府: 臨時政府(1912-1913) 北洋政府(1913-1928) 國民政府(1925-1948) 中央人民政府 (1949-1954) 中华人民共和国国務院(1954-今) 中國政黨: 大清皇帝 無 中華民國國家元首 中國同盟會(1912) 無(1912-1916,1917-1922,1923-1928) 進步黨(1916-1917，1922-1923) 國民黨(1928-1948) 中央委员会主席 共產党(1945-1982) 中国共产党中央委员会总书记 共產党(1982-今）

[@sun.nielsen]

地理:台灣島 國家政權 大清帝國(1683-1895) 大日本帝國🇯🇵(1895-1945) 中華民國🇹🇼(1947-今) 政府: 大清政府(1683-1895) 日本政府(1895-1945) 國民政府(1945-1948) 中華民國政府(1948-今) 台灣政黨: 大清皇帝 無 日本國内閣總理大臣 無(1895-1898,1898-1900, 1901-1906,1908-1911,1912-1913, 1916-1918,1922-1924,1932-1940,1945) 憲政黨(1898,1914-1916) 立憲政友會(1900-1901,1906-1908, 1911-1912,1913-1914,1918-1922, 1927-1929,1931-1932) 憲政會(1924-1927) 立憲民政黨(1927-1931) 大政翼賛會(1932-1945) 中華民國總統 國民黨(1947-2000,2008-2016) 民進黨(2000-2008,2016-2024,2024-今)

[@Akarom927]

I think the best song maybe the ROC National Flag Anthem.

[@Mark-qr1eb]

借鉴德国的军歌

[@ss_super_steve]

@@Mark-qr1eb so what? they had to get insperstion from somewhere and really tried, while your people starved to death, had no rights and are currently experiencing heavy and I mean heavy turmoil, virgin simplified user go to the real China 🇹🇼

[@诛元开明]

封面地图不错，把实际边界画出来了

[@waterdropsfall]

“实际边界”，呵呵

[@文伟谢]

海峡论坛

[@恪古]

sorry,the cover is wrong. taiwan was ruled by japan before 1945

[@张可_1145_呃呃]

Dr. Sun Yat-sen!!

[@佚名-w1t]

1.代國歌《李中堂樂》 1896-1906 2.代國歌《頌龍旗》 1906-1911

[@jackhaider]

Broken China in 1913 was not big in the thumbnail at all, it had an area of 352,000 sq km

[@helengao6093]

You forgot the pu tian yue Qing anthem 1842-1897.

[@kewang9018]

Wow, I never knew the lyrics of the PROC anthem changed between 70' and 80's , then changed back

[@Gedaaa]

Seems to have died for political reasons Of course, it could also be the Cultural Revolution 记得是歌曲作者因政治原因去世，当然，也可能是因为文化大革命

[@HueyReed-sz9of]

田汉是歌词作者

[@Garfield_Minecraft]

Beautiful song the great land

[@Cookie_clicker]

Wow! this is like March of the Volunteers but SWING!

[@mustafah6150]

18:12 Originally produced in 1935.

[@chenhongzuo15]

china anthem but bad

[@EvanTheBag]

19:01 anyone got a link of that version ?

[@易陆-p6w]

As a Chinese, I prefer the Internationale as the national anthem On Tiananmen Square it is written, "Long live the great unity of the people of the world"

[@faaizahmed5773]

m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/rp_dq56pYtd-f6s

[@khiangphengtan4207]

很好！❤

[@John-mx3wq]

hey ~The ROC still alive

[@Zacky51188]

Nope, it lost in 1949 and lost representing China in the UN in 1971. PRC has the upper hand. ROC does not have full sovereign control anymore. Taiwan is not independent at least not officially. PRC would not see to it.

[@ss_super_steve]

@@Zacky51188 If a country meets the four definite definitioms of a country regonition is only a thing regarding legitimacy, the ROC is a country by the four definitions no doubt, they are the true controller of china no matter wha the un thinks, a terrorist state like Russia that terrosies its own land does not deserve to own that land nor have any legitimacy at all

[@林子皓-f1o]

@@Zacky51188 Taiwan is not independent? Taiwan is already independent in 1912, Name call Republic of China. So Taiwan doesn't need to declare independence again. PRC just replaces ROC representative in China. But ROC still exists. You cannot say that PRC directly replaces ROC after replacing China. it's two different things. The international one-China principle is misleading by the PRC. one-China principle is mean there is only one China in the world that's all. Does not mean to replace ROC this country.

[@Zacky51188]

@@林子皓-f1o I'm sorry but Taiwan is not a country and 5he ROC really lost LOST the civil war and retreated to the island of Taiwan in 1949. RoC ceased being the legitimate China then. There can only be one China in respect to the PRC territorial integrity. Taiwan might have self governing internally but not official recognition. There is a long term goal to reunite in regards to territorial integrity. China was humiliated by foreign powers and was very poor. It did not fare well under the KMT hence it chose a Communist revolution against imperialist reactionaries, the revisionists and the capitalist ideology

[@alphatrolltv15]

Let me think if this is correct, the five stripes in the flag of the republic of china are the 5 races?

[@xubuliudu步六独旭]

是的，五色旗代表五族共和，分别是汉族、满族、蒙古族、回族、藏族，不过，中国其实不止这五个民族。

[@alphatrolltv15]

​@@xubuliudu步六独旭谢谢

[@凡杨-z3z]

​@@xubuliudu步六独旭回不是回族，指所有穆斯林或者说回部。

[@niburuwoburu98]

I'm Pakistan Support china😘😘😎😍

[@speaker.man.120]

China olso support Pakistan 🇨🇳❤️🇵🇰

[@shaoweichin2784]

🇨🇳❤️🇵🇰

[@Someone-Here]

Got my respect

[@peterpancake506]

Also support Pakistan. Wish the people of Pakistan live well.

[@ActuallyBoomer]

+10 social credits

[@marseries]

21:36 was my favourite

[@leoveffcult9368]

中國萬歲！人民萬歲！🇨🇳

[@레개노-e1d]

Taiwan No.1🇹🇼

[@leoveffcult9368]

@@레개노-e1d it's Chinese flag（ROC），not is taiwanese flag！

[@劉輝炎]

@@레개노-e1d dppk no1

[@桐叡陈]

laugh, a province dare to compare itself to a great country

[@harryjcy4500]

中華萬歳！🟥🟨🟦⬜⬛🇹🇼🇨🇳

[@張騰允-v9w]

都好好聽!

[@boyiyelcham2630]

哇，版本很全

[@quiet857]

改天我给大家做一版商周秦汉到唐宋元明的国歌，皇帝们或者士大夫慷慨激昂的古诗词配上五声调式的旋律，用各个时代的乐器，主要乐器以钟为主，辅以古琴，瑟，箫，竽。

[@RandomVidsforthought]

How do you record the audio

[@ericsuarez834]

Modern artists play it to be record it

[@trangbui6268]

You forget about “Pu Tian Yue”

[@honghongnguyenA]

更想中華民國...,支持中華民國永遠還在....台灣..🇹🇼 ROC 👍👍Taiwan

[@文伟谢]

灣

[@文伟谢]

河灣

[@文伟谢]

河水

[@文伟谢]

Taⅰwan

[@PATPATpatpatoyv]

18:16 the people republic of china 1949-ปัจจุบัน (present) - since the sound is not clear Add light and clear sound

[@tw_fish5462]

China🇹🇼🇹🇼

[@上官宇航-u1m]

你死于1949年吗😂😂😂

[@ErnestJay88]

Tbh, Qing Anthem (Cup of Solid Gold) is the real "Chinese Anthem", since March of the volunteer is too militaristic meanwhile ROC Anthem is influenced by European.

[@redacted7060]

Bruh Qing is not even Chinese

[@GokageDaGoat]

@@redacted7060 it kinda is tho

[@KinLee919]

@@redacted7060 Manchu are Chinese.

[@aka-bo6ej]

@@redacted7060 Cup of Solid Gold is traditional Chinese music anyway.

[@V6AReign]

@@GokageDaGoat but during that time it very much was not Chinese in one bit.

[@blitzkrieg981]

There are two serious mistakes in this video. First, it omits a national revolution song (國民革命歌), which was the national anthem of the Nationalist government during the Northern Expedition. Second, the Republic of China has not yet died, and the Republic of China government is still in Taiwan, no matter which party is in pow. 這部影片有兩個嚴重的錯誤 第一，漏了一首國民政府北伐時期的代國歌：國民革命歌。 第二，中華民國還沒亡，民國政府在台灣，不管是哪個黨執政都一樣。

[@otto8246]

我很爱义勇军进行曲但是不得不说前面的中华雄立宇宙间，卿云兮包括国旗歌的词都写得好好，“炎黄世胄”，还有仿楚辞的，气壮雄浑，有音韵美服，有节奏感

[@livelong5016]

矫揉造作，脱离群众

[@Atmoswhale]

Republic of china is still there our beautiful country never dead

[@user-markc1106]

只要國家強大，經濟繁榮，人人安居樂業，不管國歌多難聽，都會像仙樂一樣，被人所稱頌。反之如果政府腐敗，人民生活不安定，再好聽的國歌都會被人唾棄。 如今大陸越來越強大，人民越來越富足，台灣卻是在倒退走回頭路，恐怕過不了幾年，我們也要撐起五星旗，唱起義勇軍進行曲了。

[@ss_super_steve]

Lol, you won't have to, same reason why Ukraine isn't flying the russian flag.

[@user-markc1106]

@@ss_super_steve 或許俄烏兩國並非是同一民族，這我不太了解，但中國大陸與台灣兩者本來就是同文同種，不存在民族差異的問題，人民不必為虛假的國家認同去打仗，那只是政客用來謀取私利的假議題而已。一個值得支持的政府應該是要為人民謀福利，而不是讓人民去保衛政客們的權力，人民的頭腦要清楚一點，不要被政客們耍弄。

[@ss_super_steve]

@@user-markc1106 Yes I do agree that people should fight for self determination or security for themselves and not immediately protect some higher ranking person, however I do feel like you guys have a bigger advantage in the sense that you can defend yourself easier due to you being separated by water, so simply some coastal fortification is necessary and if the PRC begins to bomb you like Ukraine, then you will gain a ton of support from your western allies even recognition.

[@user-markc1106]

@@ss_super_steve 可能每個弱小的國家都會有自己的優勢，但任何有利的因素都不會使人不怕戰爭，只有避免戰爭才是最佳的策略。台灣四面環海，一但發生戰爭，想逃難都很難，況且台灣並不是一個被聯合國承認的國家，邦交國也越來越少，如果世界上的大國都肯承認、幫助台灣，那為何不與台灣建立邦交呢？因此台灣的處境其實是比烏克蘭更糟糕才對。那些世界大國反而是把台灣當作籌碼，想用來拖垮中國，這些大國為了自身的利益，而不惜犧牲別人的利益，甚至把別人推向戰火，這實在是人類間最大的罪惡。

[@TW_Yewuyue]

我認同臺灣需要改進，但你後面那幾句我就不認同了，看看現在的中國是不是好不好？我是不想生活在那個環境啦，所以臺灣才需要改變，在美國和中國之間存活

[@PATPATpatpatoyv]

1912-1930 (รัฐบาลพลัดถิ่น) - 🇹🇼 government in exile

[@cl7276]

Republic of China also exist.

[@Alpha_0218]

I think the anthem of the Republic of China is the most beautiful one

[@飛流直上三千尺哪個宅]

怎麼沒有1929年的中國國歌和中華共和國國歌？？

[@Dibujante_viajerode_chile]

Long live the Great Republic of China 🇹🇼 and the Territory of Hong Kong 🇭🇰❤

[@tea1255]

9:36 I personally think this is the best one. From the PRC

[@matthewnggametime2537]

For me the best one among them is 8:14

[@diegoleo1279]

it's not from PRC but ROC

[@yian9226]

9:37 22:21 the best two

[@Oort-si8ck]

Only 9:37

[@ricoaranilla5949]

Now i believe that china is taiwan

[@yuluoxianjun]

汪精卫的歌曲还挺好听的，有人知道是什么歌吗

[@The_Road_to_Jihad]

东亚民族进行曲

[@arthurmorgan7038]

🇨🇳（1949-1976）

[@aaaaaa-lv5vx]

1949-至今

[@arthurmorgan7038]

@@aaaaaa-lv5vx 我指的是社会主义中国

[@虎賁中郎將]

@@arthurmorgan7038 是的现在的中国根本不是社会主义，唯物主义和大中华主义结合体

[@flyerwang9582]

@@arthurmorgan7038 现在的中国四不像

[@ericcheung7959]

@@flyerwang9582 修正主义罢了