Carol of the Bells - Pentatonix "Christmas Under the Stars" REACTION

[@tammyroberts1218]

This song is also known as when does Mitch breathe lol. Love this song.

[@CourtneyLiz1220]

@tammy roberts We refer to it as the Mitch fish song because gills are the only explanation here. 😂

[@renee176]

Yeah, they would have to have oxygen on standby for me, because I would have passed out a long time ago...lol! Their breathing techniques are A#!! 😊🎤

[@ChrisAndCats]

Dimash said he does a lot of underwater swimming to enhance his lung capacity for singing - judging by this, Mitch has to be doing something similar, this level of control is insane.

[@thegirlwhosparkles]

Matt did Avi proud with this one. That bass line was damn incredible

[@carolynl.higgins6206]

His role was not to make Avi proud. It is to please God who bestows him this marvelous talent; himself; his PTX family; and the fans. Sure you mean well because you probably believe the myth that Avi helped to choose him.

[@thegirlwhosparkles]

@@carolynl.higgins6206 considering I just really started listening to them in June of this year I know nothing really about how Matt was chosen just that he came in to replace Avi. Don't talk down to me like that. I was just saying he filled the bass role nicely. Almost as good as Avi's. You could have been a little nicer about it.

[@rexs.musika]

@@thegirlwhosparkles totally agree.

[@gailseatonhumbert]

@@carolynl.higgins6206 his role is to acknowledge that Avi created the bass in this group and the bass line for this song. I don't believe God was involved or should be discussed at all when talking about a simple musical performance.

[@buckeyegirl16]

1. Super proud of Matt on this. I know u haven't seen their original performance of this, but its an Avi and Mitch heavy performance. Matt had some huge shoes to fill on this performance and he KILLED IT!!! 2. Mitch isn't human. No human can go that long without breathing. 3. When u have time, I recommend u go back and watch this 5 times. Follow one person all the way thru each time so u can really see the intricacies of the individual parts...insane

[@anitaslack9193]

This arrangement is also known as the "Mitch, BREATHE!" song.

[@jcs1025]

Best a cappella groups in the world, and one of the best harmonizing groups overall.

[@andrecaudle832]

He sang 36 seconds straight without taking a breath, his breath control is insane.

[@edsartistry]

The most amazing thing about this song is that ONLY five people are doing this song and making it sound like a whole choir!!! And when Mitch starts singing the lyrics he Doesn't BREATH ! Matt and Kevin just blow my mind with the percussion and bass, while Kirstie and Scott build on top of that with all the background notes and it all comes together in a massive musical production. They are EPIC!!

[@cslapler007]

They essentially made a Fugue out of Carol of the Bells. Fugues are an old style of composition dating back to at least the Renaissance era. Bach is probably the most well known composer of fugues. Genius to arrange it like this, not to mention they pull it off to perfection!

[@shanialover]

You actually stopped to mention Mitch didn't breathe in the MIDDLE of him singing without breathing!!! 🎶👱‍♀️👗👠👠💓

[@nicholasw.3488]

“We’re getting Mitch Slapped in this one” I love that 😂

[@conniehill4851]

The level of complexity and Mitch freaking breath!!! Omg fantastic all of them. Perfection

[@jlelliotton]

I would loved to have been in that small audience for this performance.

[@berlyn3014]

Watched this when you first released it but here it is June 8, 2024 and it was recommended so I had to watch again. I'm still yelling breathe Mitch breathe.

[@geriatricptxer2362]

Carol of the Bells was PTX's first Christmas video way back in 2012 so I can only imagine how many of times they've performed this song. If you play that first video and compare it to this live performance, the only difference you'll hear is the maturity in their voices. Even Matt, who's only been around for 3 years now, has matured. Every time I watch a performance of this, I just want to scream, "Breathe Mitch, Breathe". However, as we all know Mitch is an alien and doesn't need to breathe.

[@heidifruchtl354]

If you ever get the chance, there's a video where PTX talks about how they did some of the videos way back when, which includes the Carol of the bells. They hiked for about 2 hours, looking for a waterfall, but decided on the spot for the video, they carried all of the equipment, including a generator and just as they finished filming, the generator died, and they had to carry it all back out. They laugh about it now.

[@Sadarsa]

on that last line where Matt comes in, you can hear that he trips up for like an instant, and corrects himself. To me that's proof that there is zero offstage "help".

[@mjbartholomew5317]

They are not even looking at each other. Not in a circle or anything. Timing is perfection.

[@Karen-Campos]

Great Reaction! My favorite part is when the trio break into 3 separate layers on top of each other starting at 7:38. Of course the Matt/ Mitch ending is superb!!! 🔔

[@violetf.2025]

That's my favourite part, too 🤗

[@shilohauraable]

This is performed in Madrigal style! A very complex, lacey & beautiful style! 💖

[@marymichele340]

Excellent! They are all amazing but not sure Mitch breathes at all. Great reaction!

[@dawnemami3089]

This song should be named .. Mitch, breathe!!!

[@sheilad5321]

I get a pain in my chest helping Mitch keep going and then I remember the rest of the group are working just as hard so I breathe, relax and enjoy this amazing arrangement. Kudos to Matt for working so hard on it and stepping in to admirably fill the gap so we can continue to listen to this masterpiece.

[@bfly5990]

This is a masterful performance

[@Wyndigayle]

That last section is the best, absolutely the best, counter melodies I've EVER heard. How Mitch, Kirstie and Scott can stick to their own parts no matter what the other is singing, when their parts are so similar, is amazing. LOVE this performance (live and recorded).

[@selinbaltac6843]

Matt really made Avi proud with this live performance. He is awesome! And even getting better and better

[@carolynl.higgins6206]

His role is not to make Avi proud. It is to please God who gifted him and guides his amazing talents; himself; his PTX family and his fans. You probably mean well and think that Avi helped choose him which is a myth.

[@susanb4213]

Classical musicians tell me if I'm crazy: This arrangement has some Bach-reminiscent elements to me. Anyone else hear it?

[@leighbesstoad]

The first time I' heard it I immediately thought 16th century madrigals with the contrapuntal nature. It's a brilliant arrangement.

[@susanb4213]

@@leighbesstoad Yeah, that's a good take. I guess I heard Bach a little at the end with Scott's lines. But overall, your characterization is on point.

[@Korbin_Arts]

mitch's breath support in this song is NUTS

[@Bonofox1]

😌👉It was originally done with Avi about 7 years ago that is why Matt is saying that he practiced his part a lot!! Also react to the official video!!🙏🙏

[@Seriphina]

Pretty sure Mitch is a robot that doesn't need to breath.

[@anessalyn1035]

this was a fantastic performance. I've watched it a few times. Yes it was a Live performance for anyone that still questions PTX's talents. Oh the headphones came off. Yes, please go back and do the one with Avi

[@renee176]

Yep, and that was a live performance... so Excellent job PTX!

[@rexs.musika]

Awesome reaction as always dude.

[@barbarabishop9362]

Sigh. It amazes me that a full four years after Avi left the group, there are still people who resent Matt. I also love the 2013 official video for this song, and frankly, the sound quality is better because it's a studio-produced song, which allowed them to make sure all the balances and levels were perfect. You can't do that with a live performance. Even so, this is a wonderful video and I love how little difference there is between the old video and this new one. Matt followed Avi's original bass line and did a terrific job. Kevin's audio was a little too soft - you can hear his part a lot better in the 2013 video. Mitch ... I can only shake my head and wonder if he's managed to incorporate circular breathing in his performance. Holy cow. Kirsten and Scott just flat out sound great. As always.

[@j.6133]

Thank you!!!!

[@carolynl.higgins6206]

Continue to tell the truth! Matt is an amazingly talented and beautuful young man. He is not filling anyone's shoes, he's walking in the steps ordered by GOD.

[@kattrina42]

I like the old Matt of the group. I wish him well on his journeys. But Mr Sallee is killing it

[@Sadarsa]

I don't think anyone "resents" Matt... they just would have preferred to have Avi. Matt is amazing and no one is trying to take that away. Still, Avi has a tone to his voice that's more suited to PTX than anyone else on this planet. Matt has this rich smooth velvety quality to his voice that is lovely to hear... but it feels just a tad out of place with PTX. Where as Avi's voice is just the perfect fit for them. That's all there is to it.. it's not "rawr! we hate Matt"...It's just that i feel Avi is the better fit is all. If there is anyone to resent, it's Avi for leaving to do his mountain man routine, that i quite honestly can't get into.

[@j.6133]

@@Sadarsa Avi CHOSE to go solo. No one kicked him out. Matt was the best fit for the band. He brought a lot of light into the band (the band was in a bad state mentally that year for many reasons), he's INSANELY talented. Go watch their live performances from their concerts. With Matt they headlined Madison Square Garden, with Matt they all now finally happy and bubbly, with Matt they released 2 of their BEST albums to date. He works HARD. He has nothing to do with that person who left 5 years ago. Why compare? Move on. You don't like them with Matt? Go listen to something else. How would you feel If hundreds of people kept telling you 'Oh, that person who had worked here 5 years before you, he was WAY better than you at everything you do!!', every single day?

[@bartonbagnes4605]

I believe they did, and did excellently, about a dozen songs for this show. This show has had many great artists host or co-host in the past. Like The Band Perry, BYU Vocal Point, One Voice Children's Choir, Peter and Evynne Hollens, Gentri, Lexi Walker, Lauren Daigle and many I haven't heard of, but maybe you have.

[@darlenemartinez817]

That was superb!😍🤩

[@marablemorgan8292]

🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@mermaid6808]

What a great reaction, thank you so much 🤗 I agree with all you mentioned 😊

[@dawnpatterson8708]

FYI I love your card statement. Subscribed right away. Will start sharing right away. So you can get your "likes" up.

[@kristinwerner5519]

Love it when you break out the stank face! LOL

[@kennethvanwetering692]

EARGASM!!

[@Ptxlive]

U gotta check out “the first Noel” from the same show “Christmas under the stars” byu tv !😊

[@j.6133]

I second that suggestion!

[@margaretkichenama2040]

🔥🔥🔥Reaction! ❤️It

[@suzannebastien2918]

Mitch just forgot to breathe 😂

[@jessicakluck1926]

Plz do Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy next

[@karenmcglone9096]

Is Kevin covering Mitch for a breath in the middle of those runs? I’m gonna listen again to see if I can pick it up better to confirm or not. Great reaction

[@adam.4487]

I so rarely hear Matt's base in their videos. Cheap headphones I have, but I hear it pretty good this time with yours. Very strange how things work hehehehe

[@southernscribe1272]

Heads up! It's no compliment to Matt to comment about how his performance meets with Avi's approval. I'm sure he doesn't care. I know I (and a lot other fans) don't either.

[@carolynl.higgins6206]

Amen!!

[@Miobambino]

THEY ARE ALIENS! 👽 But amazing 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿❣️

[@G-grandma_Army]

I think you can now add conductor to your job or talent descriptions. 🙂 Nice reaction!

[@ellenhulslander2897]

This is the only version of this carol that I like. Someday we may find out what Mitch's secret is.......he's a unicorn!

[@mazcolyer1972]

This was amazing I watched the whole off under the stars and they were absolutely amazing great reaction thank you 💕 How are all your head sets still working haha 😂

[@PTXWeeklyNewsPWN]

🥰🥰

[@heidifruchtl354]

This is the song that launched me on PTX years ago. Please react to the Avi version. And yes, you just got hit by the PTX 2x4. Mitch slapped into a stank face.

[@christinadowdican3268]

YES PLEASE!! NEED. SOME AVI IN MY LIFE😊❤️

[@MioneBristow]

You have to do the original. It's shot in a much tighter view so you see all of them the whole time. They're too spread out here... But. If I shut my eyes, Matt was pretty dead on sounding almost exact to Avi in the original video so he was amazing! I'd know the difference, I think because I'm pretty sure Scott riffed a bit in this and it was different than the other version.

[@drewcomparato111]

You have to do the original!!

[@pughead2]

I would recommend listening to the Official video, even if you don't react to it (I would love to see your reaction), because they are so much younger and you can see what each part they are singing easier, plus Avi.

[@isidoradancerfans]

I wanted to hear it again but apparently they deleted it

[@teresa6034]

check out Carol of the Bells by Here Come the Mummies. You will love it.

[@carolynl.higgins6206]

Dennis and Avi fan club, Matt is not filling anyone's shoes. He's following the steps ordered by GOD for him ... amazingly in this and many other songs. Four years and you're still comparing him ... such unnecessary, biased scrutiny. He's an amazing, beautiful, super versatile multi-talented asset to PTX.

[@ric7044]

Mitch may not need to breathe, but I suggest that you do, for a moment. People are just excited and expressing their amazement and joy. What's the objective of your comment?

[@carolynl.higgins6206]

@@ric7044 ... Breathing 24 hours a day with the breath God gives me and discerning each waking hour with the wisdom and intelligence He gives me. My comment and objective were both clear; your response wasn't.

[@ric7044]

@@carolynl.higgins6206 Actually, the objective of your comment was not clear, and that's what I called out. Your tone was unnecessarily critical and negative, in a video where most people are expressing admiration for the hard work of an excellent group. I hope you're all caught up on the objective of my comment. No need to continue. What seems clear is that you're interested in arguing. Is that God's plan for your life?

[@skylermichaeljameson8392]

Please react to Pentatonix joyful joyful ft Jazmine Sullivan reaction Please 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@arsenelupin4888]

Can you please also the react to the live performance of first Noel?

[@afian005]

Man i really miss Avi

[@Angelkbf16]

If you are looking for any other Christmas videos to react to, I recommend this if you’ve never seen it. It’s called Angels From the Realms of Glory by Piano Guys kzbin.info/www/bejne/hqOvoIqqZ9mZp8k

[@mooses-n-gooses9712]

Yes please do the one with Avi. You won't be sorry. Mat is awesome and always getting better, but Avi always hits different.

[@Bonofox1]

🌟👉THIS IS AMAZING! But please react to the official video with Avi, you'll see that it is exactly the same as this LIVE version!!!

[@dabooser1048]

Just found your channel. React to Morissette Amon, "could you be Messiah"

[@6906Gaming]

I would definitely recommend checking out this song with Avi.

[@nikkibanning176]

Avi!

[@dwfarr]

Matt!

[@orangegirl247]

I love Matts voice, however for this song I like Avis voice better.

[@carolynl.higgins6206]

@elody raven Then please go listen to the other version. Matt is amazing here and in so many other songs where, after 4 years, he's still over-scrutinized, compared, criticized and not properly acknowledged. I'm so happy "no drama" Matt rolls on with his beautiful PTX family.

[@orangegirl247]

@@carolynl.higgins6206 whoha. I did not mean to critique Matt, his performance or his talent. I think he is amazing and in some songs even better suited then Avi would have been. Mr Grinch is currently stuck in my head for example. I am sure there are covers of songs you like better than the original or vice versa. This is my simple preference of the version with Avi over the version with Matt. I am happy Matt has such dedicated fans out there (I count myself one of them). He deserves all the appreciation and love and more.

[@candacelong7643]

@@orangegirl247 Like all their new songs and covers? Matt is currently a better fit with the direction the group is taking. It was destiny that Matt was added when he was. He’s better suited now for the current sound of the group. Avi was better suited back then. Matt has injected them with a sound and personality they lacked. He fits seamlessly with them

[@orangegirl247]

@@candacelong7643 not sure what you mean in your first sentence. For this song in particular I simply like Avi's voice better. If Avi came back and they would perform Amazing grace, I would most likely prefer the version with Matt. As said before, this is not me putting down Matt or denying his talent or that he fits in perfectly with ptx. In fact, I am a huge fan of ptx and him. I simply like the 'original' version better than the 'cover'.

[@candacelong7643]

@@orangegirl247 My response is in regards to you saying in some songs he is better suited. I believe all of their new stuff Matt is better suited than Avi. The group is moving in a different direction and Matt matches a more modern sound. Their old songs sure Avi was likely better suited, but that was a different Pentatonix. The group is better suited now to transition to the new sound and direction of the times. Matt is perfect for where they’re headed now.

[@nikkibanning176]

The one with Avi is better imo.

[@PtxXtp]

Then go watch the one with Avi. He has moved on and Matt is doing a fine job taking his place and allowing this group to continue on and thrive more than they ever have.

[@barbarabishop9362]

My biggest problem with live performances of PTX is that the sound quality is NEVER as good as the studio-produced music. The 2013 video has the advantage, simply because of that. I adore Matt, though I also adore Avi. They aren't the same and that's ok.

[@notbanksy2977]

@@barbarabishop9362 Because Ed Boyer is mixing it, and it's still a polished up Studio Production by Ed, he produces them like any other Studio Pop Album with Reverb, Layers, Effects he talked about it. That's why the Live stuff is the real deal, even PTX has huge ass Production.

[@j.6133]

@@barbarabishop9362 The 2013 video was not a live performance, it was lip synced.

[@PtxXtp]

@@barbarabishop9362 yes I agree that sometimes the live audio can be bad if not mixed correctly for a cappella or mixed by the professionals who know their voices and arrangements but this performance actually sounds perfectly mixed and in my opinion better than the video since it doesn't sound produced like the video does. These 5 are perfectly capable of recreating live versions of studio recordings that sound just as good if not better. I feel like the last few years ptx has gotten a lot better at making sure they're mixed properly when they sing on TV shows

[@firemetalhead5863]

Either Matt is really good at mimicking Avi or they had Avi’s voice playing cause that didn’t sound like Matt at all 😂

[@carolynl.higgins6206]

His goal is not to mimic Avi. What is wrong with the Avi fan club here? Matt who is extraordinary will never suit you. He is not trying to fill anyone's shoes but following the steps God orders for him in his amazing mesh with PTX. Enough ...

[@firemetalhead5863]

@@carolynl.higgins6206 I mean that’s cool. I’ve been following PTX since the sing off, and have always been a fan of Avi. Never said I didn’t like Matt. So calm down. What I do know as a musician, that studied music theory… it really did not sound like Matt. He has a softer undertone and doesn’t have the flexibility of range as Avi does. And that’s my opinion sorry you got your feelings hurt 🤷🏽‍♂️

[@candacelong7643]

@@firemetalhead5863 Lol. Sounds like you were impressed and trying to discredit him. You can literally hear him take breaths. Just say he did great and move on. He impressed you, it’s okay. Avi’s memory still lives on lol

[@firemetalhead5863]

@@candacelong7643 I was impressed that he sounded just like Avi 🤙🏼