KOTLC BOOK 10 THEORIES!?! Keeper of the Lost Cities Elysian Theory Video!

[@splash7351]

Here's a theory I've seen come up a few times and one of my favourites (apart from Jolie being Lady Cadence). I reckon that Tinker is Kenric's twin sister. This is because Kenric and Tinker have similar features (same eye colour, same hair colour), and the reason she didn't want people to know that they were twins was because she didn't want Kenric to lose his council position. Another big piece of evidence towards this is that Tinker might be afraid of fire because Kenric died in one.

[@emilysmith4213]

Ooh this is a big take! 😱🤩✨

[@Ammiad]

That's a really cool theory! Could you elaborate on the other theory you mentioned?

[@splash7351]

@@Ammiad that was mainly mentioned in another theory video from this channel actually

[@brinleyisawesome6398]

Hmmm interesting

[@SnowyMount10]

Everyone keeps saying how they think Keefes gonna die (and I kinda (sadly) agree) but that raises the question, how would it affect Sophie? Think about, Sophie changed so much after Keefe left, she had limited patience, she was reckless, bossy, sassy, and overall just kinda done with everyone. But if Keefe died? I honestly think she'd murder Gisela (cause if anyone's gonna kill Keefe, it's probably her) and just be darker in general. And once Gisela's gone, Elysian is really the only villian left, and Sophie will maybe need help from humans somehow to defeat her. I think Sophie will need to overcome her grief and guilt,and maybe even be tempted by Elysian (a lot of last books have an emotional struggle for the main character) But in the end, I think the humans and elves will work together, cause that was the whole point of Project Moonlark. Also, Caprise Redek has more to her story for sure, cause in Nightfall, Fintan mentions that Caprise tried to keep Marella away from the Neverseen. Also, the ability restrictor, they bring it up several times later in the series, like in Stellerlune, Oralie mentions how the Neverseen could probably make an ability restrictor... Also, Ro and Forkle are probably gonna die. But in the end, the elves and humans will unite. That's why there's a Moonlark, right?

[@emilysmith4213]

I read Evelyn’s theory last time in the comments and completely agreed with her! It’s a long, but fantastic theory that sounds like something Shannon would totally do✨✨✨

[@AnshulM-x9g]

AMAZING THEORIES!!! im honestly dying out here waiting for the next book. At least this channel keeps my curiosity burninggg

[@Lea-q5j4u]

I reread the series and I noticed that in Nightfall when Mr Forkle tells the group that he is a twin and stuff. Tiergan also says after Keefe asks if he has any life changing secrets, Tiergan said that "Nobody reveals everything" so, I believe that Tiergan has a huge secret which will be revealed in book 10. Also I believe that Prentice will get some memories back because Shannon added him there for a reason so, by getting his memories back he will be answering questions like why Prentice called swan song and it could help progess into the book because we know that whatever Prentice is found is connected to Stellalune and even Elysian.

[@mikahuman5791]

Okay, my theory is really long and really detailed so bear with me please! Let's start with the main question we were all wondering when we finshed Stelllarlune: Who is Elysian? Well, lets start at the beginning. Mr Forkle told us the the Black Swan had been around for much longer than anyone thought. And I don't think the Lost Cities became fractured and damaged overtime. I think that it was always going shatter. It was just a matter of when. I think a selected group of individuals thought so aswell. Now to put it into perspective, the time I'm talking about is when Fallon and Fintan were Councilors. So thousands of years ago, the Black Swan was formed. I have always wondered why the Black Swan took such drastic measures to make the Lost cities a better place? Yes, the Councilors wouldn't listen, but couldn't they come to an agreement without forming a illegal rebellion? This is why: before the Black Swan was formed, a secret group of powerful elves knew it was only a matter of time before thier world began to crumble-- enter the Neverseen. What I'm saying is that thousands of years ago, the Black Swan and the Neverseen were formed. But ultimately, the Neverseen formed first. And due to some sort of leak, the news got out of the silent rebellion. But the only ears who hear this were the elves who eventually decided to form the Black Swan. The reason the Black Swan formed was partly because they wanted to make the world a better place, but also because they wanted to protect the Lost Cities from the Neverseen. Okay, are you still following with me? If not go back and read it again, and I'll try to explain it clearly. Somthing else I wanted to point out is that we have never met that many members of the black swan. There is no way that such a powerful group can consist of the Colective, Pycic and a few dwarfs and some gnomes. So there are obviously members we haven't me yet. They may in fact be part of the original group that first formed the black swan. You may be wandering how this has anything to do with Elysian? I'm getting there I promise! Somthing else I need to point out is that I find it really strange how the Neverseen have not yet tried to copy Sophie and make their own version of a DNA experiment. Well, they have . Now we know that the Neverseen are much smarter and about ten steps ahead of the black swan. So, when they first formed they made their own DNA experiment. Elysian. So she was born to 2 members at the Neverseen at the time. ( keep in mind the time setting is when Fallon and Fintan were Councilors. ) Unlike Sophie wh9 was experimented on before she was born, Elysian was experimented on when she was around manifesting age eg. 12, 13, 14 . How did they experiment on her you may ask, first we have to go forward to Legacy. Have you ever wondered how Lady Gisela knew how to experiment on Keefe in Lonnamore? Well she didn't invent it. Vespera did. We all know just how smart Vespera is, and how much she recerch she does. That is also why she went to prison so long, not just because of her expermenting on humans, but also on Elysian. Well, she used an Ancient flasher and shade to blast 13 year old Elysian with Quinttensise and shadowflux, tied to magsian. Where did she do this? The Elysian fields. Right where we end Stelllarlune. And when did she do this, well remember when Nightfalls stars would align in Stelllarlune? Who said this. Vespera. And what is this special day that the stars of Night Fall align? Well it is a special day I like to call Initiis Novis ( this is just a name I made up.) It is a event that only happens every 500 years, where not just Nightfall aligns, the Prime sources, Sunlight, moonlight and Starlight evaluate the same amount of power. You may be thinking, aren't they always even? Isn't that what they told us in Legacy? Well yes and no. We could all have guessed that sunlight is the most powerful right? But on Initiis Novis, they are exactly the same , and you can obsorbe their power. Since Vespera blasted Elysian with Quinttensise, shadowflux, Sunlight, moonlight and Starlight she made Elysian very powerful. But she didn't actually know this.After Elysian woke up from her inbetween state, the Neverseen tested her, but they couldn't find anything, so Vespera dumped her on the footstep of one of the Councilors offices ( probly Fallon). The Councilors also tested Elysian, but their findings were much more detailed. That is the reson they hid Elysian in the most secure place they could find, and erased her from their memories, and stored her secret in their caches .Elysian's powers consists of many different things. She can control people's abilities ( to turn them on or off at will.) She can also control Quinttensise ( just like Tam can control shadowflux) and -- she can also control The Prime Sorces. To some extent at least, because the Prime sources literally run through her veins, she is connected to them on another level. She may also have many other powers that we don't know about, but here is my theory on another one She's a Crystalite ( someone who can control Crystal and jelws.) Why do I say this? Well you know that crystal Sophie had at the end of Stelllarlune? Well Elysian made that crystal. I have also always wondered why crystal was used so often in the lost cities e.g all of the buildings are made from crystal, leaping crystals, magsian. And yet there is no Crystal based ability? Well, there is but it is just very rare. Also the reson Elysian found Sophie, Lady Gisela and everyone else is that she can track the crystals that she forms. Another think that I would like to point out is that I know who Elysian's mother is. Vespera. Let's just think about it for a moment. Elysian ( when she reveals herself) will be an Ancient because of how old she is. Vespera is also an Ancient. And she may have been working with the Neverseen from the beginning. So she had Elysian for the simple point of making her daughter the most powerful elf in the lost cities. Another reson why I think she's Elysian mother? Does anyone else find it strange that Vespera died in the explosion? Why would Shannon kill her off? We hadn't even really gotten to know Vespera and what she stood for? How did she die? Elysian killed her. Her Crystalite powers allow her to have some sort of control over rock materials and minerals. And Elysian hated her mother for abandoning her and experimenting on her. I would also like to point out that Elysian will not be on Lady Gisela's side. Why? A) She turned off Lady Gisela's conjuring. B) She'll hate Lady Gisela fpr what she did to Keefe, because she expencied it herself. And I don't think she'll side with the Neverseen ether, because what did they do for her? They left her to rot away in a cell for her whole life. I don't think she'll side with the Councilors either, because they were the ones who locked her away. But she might just settle for the Black swan because theybare kind of a middle ground. Anyway I hope you liked my theory! Sorry that it's super long! And thank you for making it all the way here! I love your videos!!!! They are super amazing! Thanks, Your average Moonlark 💙

[@elisabethjones4857]

GOODNESS GUACAMOLE THAT WAS LONG

[@mikahuman5791]

@@elisabethjones4857 Sorry for writing so much !😅🤣 But thank you for reading it!!🙂

[@jadeleplus8320]

If vespera is elysian mother's, then why do she seems to be surprised when they arrived and there is this giant colourful building. To me it seems that everyone was panicking when they find out that. Like it seems some kind of shady ancient secret hide by the council 😂😂😂

[@briannaberry1487]

While Evelyn Rowena Dawn’s theory is very likely I have a theory of my own that I would like to share. I believe that Elysian was born on a special day with special powers/abilities Which we have yet to see. The ancient counselors used the ability as a power source until she lost control/went rogue. They couldn't control her so they locked her away. As for turning everyone's abilities off I think that just like how Sophie switches off her enhancing ability Elysian uses an advanced version of that and combines it with outward channeling. And in my opinion it's not a mysterious/new ability but a long forgotten skill. And if I was thinking more about Evelyn's theory and combining it with my personal theory. I think that there would be a much more plausible explanation, but this is what I had so I'm just throwing it out there.

[@jacelyn5349]

These are some really good theories! Thank you as always!!

[@fantasy_fanbase]

Of course I’m glad you liked the theories!

[@jonah4932]

On the first theory, about everyone still not being able to use their abilities. I think that having to work without abilities and skills would be a good way to target the talentless stereotype. It would allow people like Kesler (and Jensi?) to help the cause and also show the world what they can do. Additionally, a similar approach could be applied to fire, where fire is ultimately banned. (Council’s doing?) - Maybe the council arranges for some purifier that extinguishes fire? Similar to the way the lures (trees) purify the air. I like the theory - mainly the first part though.

[@Leo..sumthing]

Listening to all these theories i just thought bout something imagine when sofie and keefe one day have children both of them are already so powerful imagine their children

[@sxmmersnxw8829]

I think Lady Gisela will go through with the third step of stellarlune, and Elysian will join the black swan. Also i think Ro is going to die, and Keefe will die in the process of the third step of stellarlune. I also think that Sophie will open the caches, and in Councillor Clarette’s cache specifically, Sophie will find out everything about Elysian (and possibly her dad) since Clarette is a flasher herself. Another thing about Elysian might be that she is multiple combined dead elves (jolie, cyrah, forkle, umber and others) and the power source holding the lost souls together is ‘merging’ their abilities into one that can control all the elements (water, fire, earth, air, shadowflux, quintessence and the seventh, which has no name) so Linh, Marella, Tam, Trix and Glimmer might help Elysian work out the elements and so on (this might be a strech but they could also fix Keefe and kinda like bring him and Ro back even though i doubt it). Also they will probably team up and beat the neverseen. Hoping Gisela will die in the process of the third step of stellarlune

[@A_SleepDeprivedBookworm]

Here are the events I think are going to happen in book 10: Keefe said that he was numb and can't really feel anybody's emotions in the last book, what if keefe is going to be forced to hurt elfs into submission for something Lady Gisela wants, and because he won't feel their emotions, his mind won't shatter. Sophie will get a power just as groundbreaking and new as Keefe's power Keefe will die at some point to save Sophie's life. Elysian was a human that got experimented on, and therefore the elf gene was created, Elysian was scared of what was going to happen next so Elysian had help with a boy who worked there and ran away from the lab. Soon they repopulate and the family tree starts to get bigger. That's why humans probably knew elves existed before they erased their memories, because they had found out the experiment worked and realized they had created a new civilization. Because Elysian had been experimented on by humans, Elysian wants to have revenge, so I don't think she will be on the Neverseen OR Black Swan, but I think she will see Keefe and Sophie and how useful they would be. So she will try to do what ever it takes to get them on her side, including kidnapping, it would interfere Lady Gisela's plan so she will be forced to work with the Black Swan to get Sophie and Keefe back. Keefe will sacrifice himself so that Sophie could escape. ( this is the part where I think Keefe will die ) Lady Gisela's plan failed because Keefe is dead so she can no longer continue her plan and will get exiled

[@fantasy_fanbase]

Out of all of your theories the one I most agree with is that with Keefe coming to have this very powerful ability, I also think that Sophie might counter it and get a powerful ability as well! We know there’s a lot more about Sophie that we don’t know about so it could be another ability! Thanks for commenting your theories it’s greatly appreciated :)

[@SofiesPalace]

It’s kinda inspired by the “Elysian a Black swan experiment like Sophie theory” in fact I suppose it’s more about that amazing theory so Black Swan has been there for a while right? So in the beginning they tried to create a force for peace, someone who could not just switch off but absorb someone’s ability for a certain period of time or convince the ability to subconscious stop for a minute, which I know sounds weird but Sophie can turn off her enhancing, can’t she? Only after the reset so probably due to her unique genetics because I mean I don’t think that in all of eternity no other enhancer has ever tried that before, so maybe with practice she can also stop or absorb someone else’s power. Or perhaps Keefe can since that was what he was panicking about anyways. Elysian also said that she’s the power source Lady Gisela believes that they’ll need her for the last step of Stellarlune Stellarlune is to use Prime sources(7th element-manefestation of prime sources), elements(shadow flux and quintessence- second and probably 1st step of Stellarlune, 7th element for 3rd, 5 rivers, noxflare- need fire, from earth, strange butterflies), and other celestial objects that can probably loosely tie into the sources. All of that leads to a power source, the 7th element and I may be completely wrong but……….what if Elysian is the 7th element, like I suppose the best example may be like in Frozen, there are manifestations of the elements. She’s not good nor bad

[@somethingcool2904]

Ok I have this random theory it doesn’t really make much sense but as I was rereading the book series it started forming in my head. Basically what I think is that Elysian might be some experiment by Lady Gisela or someone on the neverseen. When I reread flashback I noticed it said Lasy Gisela was working on a replacement for Sophie because she wasn’t cooperating or something. So I thought this might be Elysian. Maybe Lady Gisela trained her without revealing any of her intentions, and she brough Elysian to the end fight in stellarlune, and Elysian overheard Sophia and Gisela talking and saw Gisela kill Vespera and revealed herself and declares herself neutral or on Sophie’s side. I also think Elysian might be a flasher and a shade because in Flashback when Wylie and Umber used their abilities against eachother, it caused everyone to temporarily lose their powers, which is kinda like what happened at the end of stellarlune. Anyway, those are just two of my Elysian theories, they’re probably incorrect but yeah 🤷‍♀️ Great video!

[@fantasy_fanbase]

Oh okay so maybe Elysian is working with Lady Gisela and maybe helping her with Keefes transformation due to Sophie not cooperating! Awesome theory! Thanks for watching :)

[@jadeleplus8320]

Great theory, but if I remember well, Gisella looked like she was genuinely surprised when she discovered the new place, moreover she arrived after Sophie and co destroyed the illusion probably because she couldn't go there without them. To me it seems more probable that she is older than that, maybe some kind of first elve and not a young teenager like Sophie

[@jadeleplus8320]

But it's difficult to know since we don't have any physical description of Elysian, juste a weird voice 😂😂

[@somethingcool2904]

@@jadeleplus8320 That’s true! I can’t remember but I think somewhere it said that she recognized Elysians voice but I’m not 100% sure. If she did though, that goes against original my theory.

[@chayagittel]

I think Elysian is Sofies twin and oralie trapped her In that dome with ought the black swans help and she won't help anyone but Sofie she wants to rule with Sofie and help humans

[@aanyacreations3890]

Same? I think she’s a failed prototype of the moonlark or she is lady fayina

[@Marabelle5.]

I love these theories. I think that Elysian is some experiment of the council and was forgotten or erased in like shame or some thing like that and there was a fight between the council and Elysian and combined forces of the never seen and the black swan like long long long long long ago and was just forgotten.

[@fantasy_fanbase]

Yeah I definitely agree that she could be some sort of failed experiment that got to powerful and Elysian ran away somewhere and is now returning to the Elvin world! Thanks for commenting your theories!

[@genshin700]

I honestly think Lady gisela will get her way, making keefe go through the 3rd step of stellarlune he will have very powerful abilities. In the process we find out that the lost cities is being kinda like CuRsEd or smth. Sadly keefe will sacrifice himself so he can’t hurt anyone. Also sophie will find her dad and he is the lodestar. So yeah lol We will also find the concilers catches and since Bronte is VEry old, they will find out that him and the black swan expatamented on Elysian, sadly her death was in the process but she was a very dangerous expat ment she didn’t exactly die, she became the power source, if that makes sense.

[@fantasy_fanbase]

Yep I think its not a matter of if Lady Gisela will complete the transformation it’s a matter of when! I just think it’s inevitable by now! Thanks for the theory, hope you have a great rest of your day :)

[@fyodorsfavoritelice]

Cha cha that’s such a good theory!

[@ineedsleep_88]

​@@fantasy_fanbase yes same it was also mentioned that Sophie kind of wanted stellarlune to be finished it would help keefe control his ability

[@BeanCatLady]

Hi char lol

[@greenbean_123ean]

I think Elysian is or has something to do with the origin of Brumvale Think about it: Mr forkle said know one knows about the couple that originally owned the light house And what if the couple didn't die (at least the wife) and if the husband died and all of the other chaos with the humans and elves started and the wife (Elysian) ran off and all other elves stemmed from that couple And the light house was a peaceful tranquil place that everyone gathered But when the drama with the humans started things weren't peaceful anymore and the couple (who might be Elysian and another) left so they won't be in drama Maybe not the couple being Elysian and another exactly but I have a STRONG gut feeling it has to do with Brumvale and why Lady Giselle targeted to destroy it for some reason

[@fantasy_fanbase]

Oooh good theory! I’ve never thought about Brumvale having correlation with Elysian glad you brought it up!

[@greenbean_123ean]

​@KotLC Fanbase my thought process is questioning why lady Giselle destroyed it She wouldn't do it with no good reason

[@wonderstruckblushing]

My theory is really long but basically in flashback gethen said that Gisela was preparing Sophie’s replacement,in legacy idk if she just hadn’t finished with it yet or she just didn’t use it because Sophie was there but I think she’ll still use her replacement for Sophie at some point,she could also need Sophie’s dna to create a powerful telepath. Elysian could be her replacement.Gisela could have just finished creating Elysian and took her with her to the place Elysian for Keefe.

[@wonderstruckblushing]

This is the shortened version

[@fantasy_fanbase]

Yeah Sophie is definitely powerful and if it’s her DNA that Lady Gisela is after then that could be a good plot point! Thanks for commenting your theory!

[@wonderstruckblushing]

Yw thanks for replying!

[@FiannaAndani]

okay my theory is that elysian is the leader of a group called elysian, it is more secretive more powerful than the Neverseen and Blackswan. Elysian was the first elf and she was originally a human but mutated her genes and thats how she was the first elf. She also had all the abilities. eventually over time the elf's species grew and elysian grew more powerful so the councillors locked her away in the elysian fields, and she has been playing dumb but she could escape the whole time. sry for the super long thing.

[@aivamadison-po2kc]

I think Sophie's dad is a human, which would mean Sophie is part human- part elf and Sophie has a undiscovered power that she uses to stop lady Gisela but I also think keefe will play a big role in this book

[@CanadianLumine]

I think that it’s gonna start with some dramatic battle or revelation, and then keefe possibly gets taken or injured like at the end of legacy, or maybe marella and maruca, and then they’ll have that mystery again like they do every time, or something they r waiting for, but sandor set up that triplet babysitting and that’s wat I’m interested in, Sophie saw Rex acting different from before lex and bex manifested and I feel like he’s going to find out he’s talentless and there’s gonna be a big scene for that and maybe also assuming we still have keefe , jensi could find out wat he is, and back to Rex, I think we could see some stuff about him learning wat to do with himself because he is talentless so maybe he could learn some alchemy and start helping in the shop, or practice combat which I think would be really cool, but he’s not really involved, ofc these r just my theories and it’s prob gonna have like 3 max chapters abt the babysitting and then back to the big mystery that’s gonna end on a revelation that they didn’t even need to do half the work for

[@FraidelPollen]

Okay hear me out : I think Bronte actually is Sophie’s father he just doesn’t know it because how else would Sophie be an inflictor when abilities are passed down genetically i think the black swan stole a tiny bit of his dna and made Sophie look more like oralie to prevent Bronte from suspecting anything this would be so cool and really boost brontes character development even more

[@lilturnipguy]

Tbh I think the next book might be in Keefe AND Sophie’s perspective, like in 8.5. That would be a really good book.

[@arii_playxs7191]

I think Elysian has the same powers that Keefe got in book 8.5 and that she is supposed to train Keefe how to use his powers and control them and the exploding stone things are to charge his powers and that’s why his powers stopped working in book 9. I also think that Ro was captured by the defected ogres and that the main conflict of book 10 will be finding and rescuing her.

[@book817]

I think that Elysian will end up being Sophie's dad. Keefe feels nothing in Sophie's hand(similar feeling for being talentless) and I think that's because she has Elysians ability to take away others abilities. (It could be Sophie's 'winning move' in the final battle) I also think Sophie's going to kill someone, throughout the series people have said Sophie is more of a weapon/killer than the rest of the group is. This could either result in A) Sophie's sanity shatters and she'll get a personality change(which will probably be solved by the end of the book), or B) we'll find out that she's immune to having her sanity shattered.

[@AbreeMae]

elysian is a girl. but it wouldn't be a bad theory if she was a boy

[@FraidelPollen]

I also think that in the fire before kenric died in ever blaze he and oralie were together at some point and kenric kissed oralie and told her he loved her and was sorry they could never be together then ran off to hold off fintan leaving oralie flustered and barely able to make it out alive (and probably saving her life) she never told anyone but I think she could tell Sophie in the next book

[@rowencore]

Just one random theory of mine is that Elysian might be a failed experiment of Gisela? But after it failed, she had to erase all her memory of it and lock up Elysian.

[@emthewhoppah_]

Those were all amazing theories! If you guys don't continue doing these videos, I'm actually gonna be pretty upset. Now, onto my theory. So, don't stop reading because all will be explained. The goblins are working with the Neverseen. So, they brought in Sandor right after the kidnapping failed, and no one could find the Neverseen. Easy way to keep an eye on things, right? The Councillors all have goblin bodyguards as well. Really, it's a bit too easy to pull the wool over the Councillors' eyes, so that could have easily slid under the radar. Mr. Forkle describes how the Neverseen are hitting one species at a time. They could be waiting for the perfect moment where everything is in absolute turmoil and, WHAM! 12 dead Councillors. Now the big thing is, the goblins keep almost dying. (I will talk about the exception in a minute... RIP.) Why? Key word, almost. They keep putting their lives on the line because they know that the Neverseen will NOT kill them because they are working together. The Neverseen injure them to keep their cover and make sure that they are able to be "ruthless," to quote Vespera. Now, Brielle. (RIP) She died protecting Grady at Havenfield when the ogres attacked. So, basically, Brielle died. Now, onto the ogre that did the killing. King Dimitar killed the ogre responsible himself instead of handing her over to Queen Hilda. Now, even bigger thing. All the goblins are working with the Neverseen EXCEPT for Queen Hilda. She always cooperates with the Council, and, as we all know, no one likes that anymore. They all revolt in secret and cover for each other. In their training camps, they all learn about the Neverseen and the elves weaknesses. (And, you know, the different weights of the throwing star blades.) BOOOOOOM. That is the sound of your mind blowing. So, King Dimitar killed the ogre because of what he states, and also, the ogres already knew that the goblins were working with the Neverseen! That's why the ogres have always hated them. Now, King Dimitar once allied with the Neverseen, correct? The ogres and goblins were kinda like "meh, whatever" at that time because of King Dimitar and the Neverseen. That is also why the goblins were shocked when they found out. So, with that crap ton of odd bits and ends, that is why I believe that the goblins could be working with the Neverseen. If I missed something, or there is a reason this could be disproved, please tell me!

[@frostbite1994]

Remember the ancient council. They tried to master everything that the races can do best. This is far-fetched, but what if there used to be some type of lunarian race. They were the masters of the 3 light sources so the council tried to master it by creating Elysian. But again, it didnt work.

[@miizzou_]

I wish Shannon made someone important die since their are low stakes like every character on Sophie’s side has plot armour it’s basically everyone almost dying so if someone important dies it’ll show the how powerful and scary the villain is

[@fantasy_fanbase]

Vespera? I agree though, and I think a big sacrifice might happen or something in the final battle

[@vqxm7]

okay here's my opinion i feel like the neverseen aren't actually evil. like yes they've done terrible things such as the plague on the gnomes and various murders, but they oppose the council and I'm 100% sure the council has some dark secrets / history that could shatter the lost cities if everyone found out.

[@davidhagen8849]

I think that the Black Swan is 3vil. Here's why. We barely know anything about Mr. Forkle, but we do know that he has a lot of secrets and idities. We also don't know very much about the Black Swan as well. What was their original purpose? Who was there first leader/founder? So what if every time the current leader of the Black Swan dies or retires, they pick anew elf to lead them. They get their most trusted member t to train the next leader and teach them the ways and intentions of the Black Swan. They also teach them to hide the truth that the Black Swan is evil . So, the current leader manipulates the members of the Black Swan, so they don't know that they are evil. Mr. Forkle could definitely be a manip7ater. The reason that the Black Swan is trying to stop the Neverseen is because they want to be the only evil mastermind, and the Neverseen knows it. They created Sophie using forbidden ways, that they erased from Oralie's and Sophie's dads memories.. they will stop the Neverseen in book 10 and then the Black Swan will Reaves themselves. They'll take over the elvin world, and Sophie and her gang will have to team up with the remaining Neverseen,members. This is also the reason that Prentice called Swan song. He found out the Black Swan was evil! Allen was a long time member of the Black Swan, so he issued the memory break of Prentice! I spent a long time on this thery:) hope you like it!

[@wonderstruckblushing]

Hiiii!

[@fantasy_fanbase]

Hey! Hope you enjoy the video!

[@EclipseOfTheMoonsMood]

WOAH I'VE NEVER BEEN THIS EARLY BEFORE

[@fantasy_fanbase]

Well your super early today lol! Hope you enjoy the theories!

[@adyadubbudu1700]

I’ve never been so early! 31 minutes 😱

[@fantasy_fanbase]

Awesome thanks for getting early to the video! Hope you enjoy the theories!

[@adyadubbudu1700]

@@fantasy_fanbase omg this is the first time you guys have replied to me! Also, is it weird that Biana is my favorite? I mean she can fight, is pretty, sassy, funny, logical, fast learner, takes risks, is a literal queen, and is just amazing? And is it wrong that I think Biana and Keefe would be cute together? Cuz they would. Sorry I have a LOT to say

[@johnrcotton]

I have a theory, ok so I think that Sophie's dad is Lord Cassius 😮 if that is revealed it would be a shocking plot twist due to the sokeefe thing but mabey they can still be together because they are both made "Non Naturally?" And Cassius has always wanted to have a great powerful child so if he didn't know about lady Gisalas plans that just mabey..

[@Fern_edits]

I feel like if that was true Lady Gisela would have found out and done some big reveal or at least blackmailed the Black Swan or Sophie

[@AnshulM-x9g]

Also, question for y'all. Do you think there will be a book 11?

[@fantasy_fanbase]

It’s definitely a possibility! Not sure right now

[@mycvtebbym_xx]

I definitely hope though! But that might be because I’m a new reader and I haven’t had to wait as long as the og readers-

[@ineedsleep_88]

If that's what it takes to get a complete story and tie up all loose ends then yes I do

[@goldmonkey10]

Hello.

[@fantasy_fanbase]

Hello!

[@somethingcool2904]

HIIII

[@fantasy_fanbase]

Hello! Congrats on getting first to the video!!

[@somethingcool2904]

Yay!

[@greenbean_123ean]

IM TWO MINUTES EARLY 😆

[@fantasy_fanbase]

Thanks for getting here in the first two minutes! Hope you like the theories!

[@charlottezagari3680]

Noooo comments stop it I don’t want to to dieeeeeee and no abilities in book is double nuuuuuuuu me big sad also alicorn sand alvar idk why but mabye they will play a role in this, like alvar helps black swan just before he died idk lol