KPOP Hater reacts to SEVENTEEN (Maestro, Fear, LALALI, Spell, Ready to Love)

[@mallhiy]

Reacting to seventeen for the first time and not reacting to Super and don’t wanna cry is crazyyyy

[@NesrineOu-gk5jm]

Ikkkkkk and ROCK WITH YOU

[@heyitsmikey7572]

heavy on this because this quote on quote minghao who recommended this trolled

[@rwwwwwvt]

Literally

[@Ggujvfdrrrr]

Ikr

[@ThisisChacaa07]

Yeess and HOT

[@Say1henam3]

Having 13 members is a waste?????? BRO THEY ONE OF THE TOP3 GROUPS IN KPOP

[@mwendemeleka]

we also dont need two people to react

[@dew3019]

and who the fuck told them to open a reaction channel if they don't know how to react and criticize them , whom you don't even know .

[@Say1henam3]

@@dew3019 exactly

[@Caratforever13]

28:42 you can called out to songs as a carat i dont have any problem with that as everyone has different taste and liking in music. But saying ''13 having in one group is dumb'' is a not a statement to do, They still managed to have most ''eqaul line distribution in kpop'', managed to be ''King of synchronization'', ''performance powerhouse of kpop'', ''Theater kids of kpop''. They debuted as 13 and they are in their 10th year as a 13 member. Also they have already said about song recommendation in the end, they don't want to explore svt so dont give them.

[@fbjmmll_2309]

Right!! They took all that time criticising the members when they're supposed to be reading the lyrics and understanding the feeling of the song. Atp, these guys just wanna say something bad to anyone they react to.

[@shinhyunah7776]

“He’s dumb”

[@radioactive_baby]

I haven't seen a single video of theirs where they haven't said rude stuff about a group and their music.

[@shanieliabryce]

I love the way you worded everything I felt like him saying that about having 13 members like that it should be a thing was just unnecessary like in stead of saying that they could have just said how cool it is for them to mange to fit all members in a song I feel like it was just a negative comment and also the song choices could have been a little better I feel like the person who picked it should have left out the recent songs that came out this year and give songs like super or hot for example as a choice

[@bankolejanet4095]

Like why do y’all hate seventeen. You shouldn’t have cared to watch their videos if you are gonna hate 😡😡😡

[@ElGato0123]

How could this person leave out HIT, Hot and don't wanna cry???

[@ellamaeplayvods]

This!

[@xiayu6098]

Litteraly left out their best songs new gen Stan’s…

[@Dee-iu6ni]

Even Super!

[@nirzzz2254]

Different people has a different types of music that they like, so it's not like we can force you to like their musics....but please do not make a joke of their hardwork for making their own music for more than 10 years.

[@nirzzz2254]

Plus the 13 of them has been together more than 10 years of friendship by doing something that they like 😊

[@immeanddontbother]

indeed, being respectful and mindful will not hurt

[@Magiknewjeans]

Whoever choose these songs as a suggestion really set them up…..

[@stephbodie]

I thought the same thing. I would've chosen 25 other songs to show before choosing most of these. Haha

[@heyitsmikey7572]

heavy on this because I didn't think a carat would troll us like this

[@Mimi-nm1le]

True.

[@kunikuzushis]

I haven’t liked a lot of their title tracks in recent years as someone who was a fan for a fairly short time so it’s interesting to see even carats seemingly think the same at least with these songs.

[@elitesquad1681]

@@kunikuzushis They just chose the weirdest songs tbh and ready to love and fear are not recent at all. It would have been better if they added hot and super which are way more recent in comparison

[@fairylixx]

guys i don't think it should matter what songs they pick for them. they're just bitter. and you guys keep feeding into it

[@sofi360]

fr! why are ppl in the comments acting as if ready to love and maestro aren't amazing?? like are yall really carats???

[@plu8620]

⁠@@sofi360you don’t need to love every song to be a fan of an artist. It’s ok to think some releases are weaker than others, doesn’t make you any less of a fan

[@sofi360]

@@plu8620 thats def true. however, i mean that the ppl in the comments are undermining svt and their amazing songs (that also are really popular) and claiming that the songs are bad, which is why the reactors don't like them, when that isnt the case.

[@tia1496]

​@@sofi360More than not being good, it's that they are not beginner friendly, and hard to listen for the first time. To be honest the first time I heard super and maestro I didn't like them. Part of it was because I listened to them without watching the mv, and the other part is because they are hard to digest at first. However after hearing them again while watching the mv, they've grown to be one of my favorite songs. And I want to point out that I didn't force myself to like them, I was just bored and rewatched them cuz I had nothing to do.heck I can't say I'm an svt fan

[@hana3703]

My only problem in this reaction is the constant "they don't need 13 people in the group". Like sure, they've been in this industry for almost 10 YEARS now and still getting recognized. Sure, it'll bring them more money, that's how shallow they are. They just care about the money right?

[@cmsquad7367]

Why carats keep recommending songs, for what? So they can give more hate comments? Millions people love Seventeen, we don’t need these 2 ppl recognition

[@ranichalam3210]

Right seriously.... Why we want their opinion on seventeen songs... Like if they didn't like it's okay move on.. Why keep recommending them with songs... Is their approval that much needed???

[@yvlovi]

well said

[@danielaa_st]

Not everyone is going to like what you like and if you don't want their opinion on SVT then don't watch it, go and watch people faking reactions. There are some reactors who hype everything when you can see that they don't really enjoy it and like it that much. Honestly it's better if someone says when they don't like it instead of pretending. I am not hating on SVT, I like all this songs.

[@ranichalam3210]

@@danielaa_st hey dear I just gave my opinion if you are disagree, it's okay.... 🙂 as it's related to my fav grup that's why expressed my view... In the end we all love seventeen songs... No hate please... 😊

[@danielaa_st]

@@ranichalam3210 no, I don't disagree at all, it's just that not everyone it's going to like it and I think that it's better to just don't watch those reactions. I am also a fan of SVT and I won't watch those people reactions if they are going to hate. It's okay if they don't like it but moking them it's way too far. I only watched their reaction to Maestro and I stopped watching it after seeing it and reading comments.

[@Taraonrepeat]

Imagine reacting to K-pop already knowing you hate it. So their fans can click on your videos and sit and watch you tear to shreds their favorite artist one video after another.

[@Pookasoul]

That's actually untrue. Lmao. They don't shred anything apart. They Always have positive and negative Things to say, because there's RARELY anything perfect. As Fans, we are used to be absolute biased. We tend to eat Up and overhype everything that we Love... And we tend to Love our reaction Videos where people Go absolute as Crazy as we do for the Same Things we Love... We Hype with them, to feel that someone understands us.. Problem is, many of them Fake it, in order to use us and our Obsession for Views. These Guys, on the other hand, are actually quite neutral! Despite the "hater" Not being a Fan of the genre, He has Always a fresh Perspective on the Details he disliked, and surprisingly also mostly really good Things to say about other Details. Plus, as Fans, when he actually DOES give a high Note and enjoying something, which happend a few times already, it's Worth 1000 Times more than all those Fake reactors together! ❤🎉

[@Taraonrepeat]

@@Pookasoul Really? Really?? I feel like we haven’t watched the same reactions.

[@Pookasoul]

@@Taraonrepeat I absolutely agree with that. And I watched every single reaction 😂

[@Taraonrepeat]

@@Pookasoul It literally has the word “hater” above him. I don’t know how you’re managing to spin his onslaught of negativity into a positive but good for you. 👍

[@Pookasoul]

@@Taraonrepeat it does. But I have Seen every single Video, and I have literally heard Him having Always both negative AND positive Things to say about the songs he hears, despite considering himself a hater. And Like I said... He actually ended Up adding a few Songs to his personal Playlist, which for any Fan, is more Worth than all of those Fake reactors combined. If you want people jumping Up and down to your favorites, you can find plenty of them on here. Some people, Like myself, WANT and Support real Feedback on the music production from Outsiders and non biased sources, thank you very much. There's plenty of content to scroll through, you have alternatives.

[@yoona.11]

Damn im not a carat at all. I'm just a seventeen casual listener, and since day one, seventeen existed, it's the first time i see carats being mad, and that's how i figured out that the reaction was ass 💀

[@laiteish]

The song choice is fine. I feel like the white dude is just trying really hard to be cool lol they are both just tasteless lmao

[@xoelkizz]

Nah fr, like the songs are pretty normal (as in easy to listen if u havent heard of svt before tbh) so idk why they hating so much. I understand if u dont like the song but theyre hating on the most unnecessary things

[@laiteish]

@@xoelkizz yea it’s obvious and it’s embarrassing for two grown men

[@xiayu6098]

Nah as a carat this was a poor poor selection of songs

[@Naya0_0_0]

I hope you start paying attention to the recommendations written in KZbin comments and not just Discord. If I wanted to recommend songs by Seventeen, I would have mentioned songs much better than these.

[@Pookasoul]

They only take requests from the request forms.

[@gooofygary]

It was one persons request that got sent in! Also people in the discord are complaining about this lineup of songs as well, so it's not just the youtube comments

[@sneha7410]

Leave it guys..they are just trying to get views...they will just hate anything we recommend..so 🙂🙂

[@VitoriaN.]

The songs are not the problem... you know that

[@elitesquad1681]

2 unit songs in a first reaction is crazy

[@neszoaaan5431]

They’re both good tbh but not for a first time reacting to seventeen definitely

[@msnina5379]

​@@neszoaaan5431 agree.. Rather than Spell it would be better to watch Lilili Yabbai because the MV was focus on performance,, those close up zoom in Spell was a treat for Carats,, non Carats (especialy males) wouldn't understand And its a pity that they talked about the lack of vocal in Spell and then skip Cheers of Youth. Like, the one who recommended this,, if you want to introduce Unit songs, do it properly

[@pumpkin2396]

Clout chasers. This isnt even a constructive criticism, this is straight up mockery. Nah. Carats will never take the both of you seriously.

[@macyglory1500]

i just came from their nct 127 reaction and it was crazy that they just disregarded half the members who are vocalist and just said they should do rap like lalali... i feel like they're lowkey also rage baiters because they've got to know how the kpop community is by now with how many groups they've reacted to.

[@lovewarning-vv4gq]

CARATS please stop commenting, recommending and boosting videos of people who don't deserve to listen to seventeen and people that question an artist's passion because THEY didn't like a lyric, speaking of lyrics imagine being a reaction channel and not even reading lyrics except to mock them .

[@Jackrond-qy1qx]

In my opinion, these songs are not the best entry point to start knowing Seventeen's music.I would suggest you start with left & right, dont wanna cry, super, Aju Nice, god of music, run to you, Hot, Fear, Heaven's cloud and Home Run. seventeen actually has more bright and fresh songs in their discography. if you want focus to their vocals then To You, Kidult, Run To You, Don't Listen in secret it's one oh the best choice

[@Naya0_0_0]

+ Anyone & rock with you

[@NesrineOu-gk5jm]

CANNOT agree more , seventeen have a lot moree songs that are better than some of these ,I’m a BIG carat but I don’t really love fear tbh

[@heyitsmikey7572]

no literally whoever put this list together trolled so hard

[@jasminpizarro6702]

Facts 😅

[@jasminpizarro6702]

Fear is really good so i think that one was good also spell and lalali

[@bishhk]

I don't really think the song choice is the problem here...... its the people ig.. don't even know a gruop and their songs but have to criticize them ouhh good job..... if you wanna know a group just listen to thier hit songs first and then get to know them better.. it's like they just reacted to them cuz they had to.. and no offence it's bg na it's hard to praise talent .. they how they are surviveing 10 years in the industry without a flop sngs and thehy are telling those songs got no james... THE SYNCHRONIZATION KING , ONE OF THE BEST VOCALS WHERE EVERY MEMBER CAN SING WRITE RAP DANCE , SELF PRODUCING IDOL.. AND FYI THE SAME PRODUCERS MADE ALL THE SONGS..

[@nc_gotpink120]

This is not critic, this is straight out the hate. THESE songs and video music are fire and SEVENTEEN is the biggest group. You don't like it? Who cares? Nobody. For carats here, suggesting another songs, ARE YOU REAL CARATS? Maestro, Fear, LALALI, Spell, Ready to Love - are amazing songs! These people are nobody compared to seventeen, so have a little respect for a group you are supporting!

[@alesandra17]

agree! and to say: please, you should give SEVENTEEN another chance! like what??? those people don’t care about SEVENTEEN or their songs, so clearly we shouldn’t care about them either… we don’t need validation of some prejudiced no names

[@diggypooper]

who is picking these songs? missing all the big ones...

[@mushroomcows1539]

Idk maybe they pick songs based on how recent they are

[@cherrybxmb18]

@@mushroomcows1539the person who recommendeds them in the discord is who picks them. they never pick the requests

[@NesrineOu-gk5jm]

@@mushroomcows1539super and hot and much others are more recent than ready to love , it’s just the recommender personal taste I guess 🙂

[@mandyjazzy9689]

i bet the picked their fave songs

[@priscilaramos2459]

they wouldn't like them either 😬

[@shavonnoel3860]

I feel so misrepresented as a carat. Who picked these songs?! Please give SEVENTEEN another chance but use the comment section of this video. Please. The fandom begs of you

[@heyitsmikey7572]

this quote on quote Minghao trolled us so hard

[@fairylixx]

The thing is... THESE ARE GOOD SONGS!!!!

[@JaanviMishra-lo6md]

Not listening to don’t wanna cry, aju nice and hit is a crime 😢

[@spicybiryani2617]

How come the react to subunits mvs first rather then seventeen older mvs oof

[@purplepotato1778]

As a carat I don't even want to "beg" them to react to SEVENTEEN's other songs. I understand that everyone has their own preferences when it comes to songs. I understand that not everyone will like what I like. But no matter how ignorant they are about something, I think there is a 'better choice of words' to express it. Moreover, when they indirectly say 'putting 13 people together in one group is stupid', as a carat that has crossed the line

[@clauu9370]

was going to watch this but reading the comments made me not want to...

[@TXT11COMINGNOVEMBER]

Me too

[@staceyzhang3512]

same…

[@kayadams4175]

same

[@boosterx50]

Same.

[@stxrgaze_ing]

right??? I did not even watch this video bcoz of the comments lol

[@Mangobibi15]

This was a TERRIBLE song recommendation. How could u miss out on all the iconic seventeen songs?…

[@pumpkin2396]

Mocking SVT by having 13 members. FYI those 13 members have more talent and fame in their toenails more than the both of you could ever have in your entire bodies.

[@theightstar]

imagine you saying that a group with almost 10 years of career that didn't have ONE bad phase, didn't even have ONE flop song in their discography, a group of 13 friends has no connection and charisma based on 2 two mv's with different styles that you saw , this is bullshit! without commenting on how annoying it is that you keep saying that having 13 members in a song is stupid, isn't it and you know why? Because they have been in the industry for almost 10 years, with the same 13 members being one of the biggest groups in kpop history. So no, it's not stupid to have 13 members. If you have no idea how seventeen works or how they are working with this system, you simply don't go around talking shit.

[@Kuinliu..]

Holy jesus I honestly had the hardest time watching this reaction, I'm all for an individuals opinion and their view of certain things, but at some point you guys worded out things in such a harsh way it wasn't even a criticism. These 13 members you guys were literally mocking are the most talented hard working down to earth people, came from a small company with their own hardships. It's fine to not like a song or the group but please have a better way to say it out.

[@stephbodie]

Um, this grouping of suggested songs is definitely a choice... Seventeen has a whole treasure chest of gems to pick from and in no universe would I have come up with this combo to start. Haha.

[@heyitsmikey7572]

literally

[@SSHDomi]

I think someone suggested them

[@Dee-iu6ni]

If this was suggested to a person who's into kpop for a long long time, they'd definitely love it but here I have no words to say. 😂

[@googlophotoo3456]

They proved that 13 people in one group is not a weakness. It's better that you guys are not in our fandom !!

[@user-Favour1234]

They know the easiest way to get views and comments is to fake being haters when they know the songs were good

[@AngelinaKing-u2m]

Damn right 😅😅

[@anapurwasih616]

I Just Don't Understand the song choices for Seventeen, or I just love their old song. I need justice for "Don't wanna cry, Left & Right, Aju Nice, HOT, Rock with you, Adore U"

[@elen_kpop1]

Exactly And don't forget super it's cool

[@cherishht6449]

Please can’t you all realize, this is not about the song choice. All the songs here are masterpiece. They just want to give a hate reaction for views and clout. Please carat stop saying these songs are not good

[@Bionca._.h]

Yeah, bc there's a lot of non K-pop fans(or K-pop "haters") who've reacted to K-pop or a K-pop group for the first time, with most of the songs either being brand new or a little more recent and they liked/loved them. I honestly think it depends on the person, whether they're open minded enough or just love music and based off of what ppl are saying in the comments(I haven't watched the vid due to it), regarding his/their remarks... he appears to be more on the single minded side(no offense to him). It's best to do what we've always been doing... agree to disagree and just keep it moving. Afterall, we're not known as one of the most cordial fandoms for nothing lol so we shouldn't let something as trivial as this get the best of us🙂

[@njn4s]

kazinho needs to mature. this is 10 years of their hardwork and theyre EXTREMELY successful, more than he’ll ever be. theyre so talented and such amazing people with the greatest mindests and personalities. wheres his respect.. he doesnt know how much seventeen have gone through all these years, this is their life and hardwork. have a more open mindset i beg.. you need to appreciate and be attentive to the small details.

[@kaylat618]

i understand it’s the bit / gimmick of the channel but there’s a line between hating for fun and being a bit disrespectful?? but that might just me be being sensitive also like many who’ve already commented this was a poor list of songs for first time reactions.

[@woolasticplasteen9502]

I feel like the song choice is good, no matter what song they react to, they will still hate it tho

[@moxxymoxx3987]

definitely will need to listen to some older seventeen songs like AJU Nice, Clap and Don't Wanna Cry to see a more fuller and diverse kind of Seventeen. I feel by covering the sub units in this video you wouldn't get to fully appreciate the raw power that Seventeen has to offer.

[@priscilaramos2459]

i truly respect having a different taste, but there's absolutely no sense to make these reactions if you're not really open minded about kpop world, it's not the same industry you probably used to, at this point i think it's just to gain attention and views with mockery on these groups. no really, what on earth give ANY person the rights to do this type of criticism like they are the actual rulers of how music should or should not be? please, only react to what you actually LIKE, it will be less problematic for all of us.

[@KeiC123]

You know, I promised myself never to post any hate comments but I'm VERY tempted to go back on that for this video. You can dislike things because it doesn't fit your personal taste or give constructive feedback WITHOUT being derisive, disrespectful and ignorant. Edit: I could go back through the video and pick out every single moment that pissed me off and why but I won't waste my own time and energy on you.

[@stansvt17]

I love carats, they'll straight up say without holding back while also remaining respect. You guys have your own opinion on music and that is completely fine, no one should be forced to like something BUT that doesn't give anyone the passes to make dig at SVT's hardwork or any of the 13 members. Mind you they are at their 10th year as a self-produced group and never have their passion ever flattered. It is not a big deal if you don't like their music or concept but please do not disrespect the hardwork SVT has put out, it's not even about being a 'kpop hater' but just plain disrespectful as a person.

[@prernamahour2755]

this was the DUMBEST reaction i have ever watched i dont even know how this video got 1.1k......and i was going through the comment section and seeing carats supporting our guys i was soo happy (i am also a carat btw). Carats lets not recommend any songs to these guys .. hater will hate, we dont have to waste time on these guys.

[@siruiii]

if the white guy is such a "hater" why is he sitting down and watching these i'd much rather watch an actual fan react to mvs over a flat out hater who refuses to accept anything and always has something to say and is it just me or does the "fan" not rlly seem like a fan bro seems more like a hater

[@is-pb5fi]

Reacting to kpop as a hater is pointless. if yall are gonna make videos on kpop groups just to insult them then dont react to them! Nobody is forcing yall,Besides,SEVENTEEN is already rich and successful with millions of carats supporting them.Dont give these click bait ppl any recs!

[@izelcruz2123]

Y'all I'm a casual seventeen listener but they did Seventeen dirty in this 😅

[@siruiii]

with the comments their making abt svt youd think that they were famous kpop idols themselves💀

[@Recheal-t6g]

KI won't say the recommendation is that bad cause it has Maestro and fear in it. Literally Fear is one of svt's loved song and Maestro is bang that you can't talk shit about i know we'll have different music preferences but if the song doesn't suit your taste judge it according to the music side of view. And next time when you're reacting focus on the lyrics too cause if you did you would've noticed how good Maestro is, the beat changed everytime the lyrics were like "i change the rhythm....." you guys didn't notice the art in this song i thought that's the reason for reaction videos

[@jessicaglass]

So the spell I think that’s what it’s called. That was just the performance team. They from my understanding are more the performance and the dancing but they also do sing and rap as so does all the other members. The person who requested these songs thank you for the request by the way. Didn’t put one of the vocal team songs in this group of videos. Which woozi the producer he’s in the vocal team. I do hope you guys do come back to seventeen. They have a really good variety of songs and they actually do songs where they just do the units. Thank you for giving them a chance.

[@fbjmmll_2309]

Thisss!!! "spell" was intended to cast a spell to the viewers. They kept saying how repetitive the track was, but that was literally the case. They also don't read nor understand the lyrics... Wow, this reaction video really made my blood boil. 🎉🎉

[@rise7b757]

Be easy, Carats. It's just two people. They don't have to love Seventeen. Our guys have millions of fans without them. It is ok. Don't upset yourself by taking words people you don't know to heart. Better listen to some of your favorite Seventeen's songs.

[@pidza4life]

Truu

[@tamtye7947]

I'm not recommending anything to you guys. Why should I when you said this starting at 55:41 . Woozi and Vernon (I included Vernon because he is 2nd in writing, producing and composing) work hard at what they do. These men are a self made group. I respect that because there are groups out there that buy their songs. Are you actual reactors? I just saw someone who reacted to them for the first time. They started with the group as a whole and then they said they will react to the sub units one at a time. They are also learning their names so that they are respectful. That is how you react. They also looked at the lyrics and remembered that some things are lost in translation. You didn't do that. Whoever mentioned Clout Chasers, got it right.

[@njn4s]

why is he calling everything lazy and horrible ?? who let these flops speak on seventeen

[@NesrineOu-gk5jm]

I wished there was other songs like: Rock with you , HOT , cheers( by the units leaders) , very nice, Fire( hip hop unit song ), SUPER ! I hope to see more seventeen’s reactions from you cuz these guys have a lot of content and this list here was not satisfying tbh

[@NesrineOu-gk5jm]

Oh also : GOD OF MUSIC and _WORLD

[@fbjmmll_2309]

These songs would have been great for a first time reaction. But at this point, let's just stop giving them SVT recommendations since they always try to hate at the fact that they have 13 members💀 And they aren't only doing it to seventeen, I heard they also said the same thing for ateez.

[@KungKungChiPakChi]

I find it absolutely hilarious that the "fan" is so obviously vibing to the music and enjoying the melodies but immediately switches up as soon as the "hater" has something to say. It's okay to have your opinions, I don't understand why you're looking to your friend for some kind of validation. The opposite is true too: case in point, rating lalali high but saying negative things about it? Pretentious asf

[@zennx_]

at this point they're literally just trying so hard lmao. they're rlly getting into that hater role. their feedbacks are so hard edge serious it's not even criticism anymore- but for what (im not saying they're not allowed to have their own opinions) and also saying.. "lacking" like no way are you for real? y'all are not even professionals but the way you disrespected these hard working boys makes me ick. straight up being picky and hard to satisfy- like y'all had one job 😭 also the song choices are horrible who's even picking these..

[@Armycaratzeroseluneatiny7139]

Yes finally seventeen.... They are so good...they make their own music.... 13 people synchronize dance....they didn’t have bad song...the power house of kpop...they are the most positive idol i have ever seen....true talent is seventeen... Self made idol...work hard...funniest idol.... Singing well...they made their company pledis big...

[@noonatdawn]

"Give seventeen another chance" I'd like to say that since I did get offended by "when the vocal unit was in main focus, there's just something missing" but it seems like your views won't change? It seems like your audience in all your videos are displeased with you. You guys didn't even react to a song by the vocal unit, the heck are you talking about??!! And seventeen is probably the most diverse kpop group out there. So there is so much more to explore that you can't genralise them based on some recommendations you got from god knows who. Next time, better check out their perfomenaces. Calling one of the best vocals of the industry like that and how you word it when you talk about having 13 members will never sit well with me. Getting 13 people to be the most synchronised ever and from debut till now entering their 10th year, they're still strong and 13. Not many can do that. Oh, god. Idk who it was who told them to react to Seventeen without any other information given. I find no problems within any of their songs but for someone new, just like any other person, I think they should be reacting to songs like : Don't wanna cry, Super, Hot, Very nice, left and right

[@forfantasylife2188]

I was waiting for this but seriously these song picks is really bad.. Their hit songs aren't even here..

[@imreallllyboreddd4607]

Just bc they didn’t enjoy them doesn’t make the songs bad, I actually enjoy all these songs here and I don’t get why everyone’s degrading them just bc these guys didn’t happen to like them 😂😂

[@forfantasylife2188]

@@imreallllyboreddd4607 the songs aren't bad , they just ain't good for a first listen. And don't get me wrong, I have no problems with them not liking it, it's the main reason I watch their vid afterall since they say what they like and don't like. Just that there could have been better songs here that would better introduce seventeen.

[@rwwwwwvt]

We NEED a second part with the most known svt songs

[@hana3703]

No we don't need a part 2. They can keep it to themselves

[@alexschmitt6207]

Please stop recommending songs to these guys

[@bingbing2821]

i dont want you fitting 13 people in one track its dumb- well if youd actually start knowing them (which i doubt because 13 people is too much for yall) you'd know that they always make it work! sub unit songs are just bonuses for us! they have 13 people, which they shouldnt - they are one of the few grps that are still active (despite being on their 10th yr on their career) that are still complete!!!!!!!!! there are grps that already have missing members despite having low no. of people in the first place. imagine the loyalty and trust they have to put on each other to last long. i dont think you have a say on their no. of members.

[@peaceful_chaos14]

This is one of the prime examples of "pre-conceived notions ruining a reaction" that I've seen on youtube. SEVENTEEN might be 13 members, but they're probably THE most balanced and well-rounded boygroup in the entirety of kpop. And I'm saying this as an avid follower of kpop. So whatever that white guy has stuck up his ass, I'd suggest he take it out immediately because he sounds incredibly biased for no reason.

[@CR-ug3be]

I am of the opinion that a lot of the recent seventeen releases have not touched the quality of their earlier ones like don't want wanna cry, aju nice, etc. And those are what I believe are truly representative of seventeen's music. In general especially when reacting to older groups, I hope this channel picks better songs and not only go off from discord. I'm guessing alot of the community members within your channel are newer kpop fans.

[@njn4s]

make ur own song before you talk shit ab seventeen.. who are literal recognised musical geniuses

[@stanloona420]

why’s everyone dragging these songs 😭

[@roxanne_han]

i think this songs recommendation is so wrong , they didn't even put their hit songs like Hot , Super , Very Nice , Rock With You , Hit and Don't Wanna Cry , i'm not saying these songs aren't good but it's not a pick for beginners , some might like it and some might not that's why it's a problem , i wish they would do another one with much better songs recommendation

[@ECN300]

All the songs suggested are controversial ones. Fear and Ready to Love were hated down when they were released, Maestro had the both the fans and the non-fans divided, some liked it and some hated it, and the rest of the two are sub-unit songs that are not vocal heavy (coz, well they are not vocal team's). Whoever gave these suggestions was really trying to set them up lmao😭

[@angelaself6261]

First they aren't talking about Post Malone! Its Karl Malone who has made the most free throws in NBA history. Second SVT and kpop in general isn't just as simple as the music in your ears. It's about the whole experience. The production of the song is going to match the lyrics, the mv, the styling and the dance and vice versa. All of those are going to be working together and tell a story, convey a whole vibe or be something closer to experiencing art. For example when you said Fear felt hollow or like it was missing something, i loved that you felt that way. It's meant to make you feel that way. It's what the song is about. Anyway. Im not as salty that you aren't fully into it. Everyone has their own tastes. I also think you can take any song from SVT. It doesn't have to be a hit song. I will say that you guys may actually enjoy the B sides more over kpop title tracks though. I hope you will one day try more seventeen out. If not the music, they have a whole other fandom for their variety content. Oh but just a note, last year svt was first in physical album sales in the world and 2nd as artist to Taylor Swift. 💕

[@sunghaneul]

Actually, I wish y'all reacted to Seventeen's Killing Voice episode instead. It's a show where kpop idols go to sing snippets of their songs, title tracks and b-sides alike, and Seventeen's Killing voice episode in particular has actually attracted a lot of new fans/ carats ever since it's release. Their vocals shine in that show as well. I STRONGLY recommend you two to watch it/ react to it together because I really feel it's such a shame that these were the songs that was being suggested for people who know nothing about Seventeen's discography in the first place. First listens with these songs is not easy.

[@tiffanykatepajarit3700]

WE DESERVE A PART 2 FOR SEVENTEEN PLEASE

[@Jetcandy]

It’s funny how from the get-go the hater’s body language was let me hate all the songs and nitpick everything 😆 Guess he lived up to his role.

[@jujoonline8248]

You don't have to like seventeen but these song choices were abysmal. Leaving out their hits and then put two out of three unit songs in this is such a bad choice... This "Minghao" gave you a list of his favorits and not the best ones to get into the group. Giving a performance team song to reactors that aren't interested in performance and music videos is crazy! Lalali is a bob same as Cheers to Youth by the Vocal team but that conviniently isn't in the mix... Also I get that you didn't like the songs but don't unnecessarily make fun of the group. They came from a small company with little to no funds and build themselfs up to beat the curse of the 7 year mark and are now in their 10th year after being told by everyone that they wouldn't make it. They aren't just self produced but self made and one of the closest groups in the industry, according to everyone who works or interacts with them in the industry. You don't have to explore svt, if you don't want to, but I just wanted you to know that.

[@Namedrakuba]

Honestly I feel like you guys gotta listen to more songs only bc they have so much more hard hitting songs that show their talent. Songs better than even Lalali. I love so much by them but these aren’t the best picks! Plus ready to love had a lot of company influence cause it was right when Hybe acquired their label, so it’s not just a woozi/bumzu (seventeens main producers) production.

[@mwendemeleka]

I wish they could produce their own song for us to react😁,and lets compare

[@mwendemeleka]

checked this account ,they are still reacting to kpop

[@junepeatman5967]

so I have watched a few of your kpop reactions so far and can i just say... If you are coming to kpop already deciding you hate it, as in your name, then you are not even giving these groups a chance are you? you are sat with a look of distain before the opening credit finishes. all these groups have put many years work into their careers, and are the best in the business, so many groups dont even make it. Seventeen have worked so hard to make it big from a small company and are still their biggest group. Pledis have supported these boys so much. they are not from Hybe, they are not in one of the big three companies, yes they are under the hybe umbrella but pledis is still its own company. You haven't listened to a smidgen of their music, and instead of checking the songs that are the highest watched, choosing a variety of music from different comeback or years you go with their latest ones, and then have the audacity to say they shouldnt have thirteen members performing at once.

[@Jennielrc]

*Riize* ( siren, get a guitar , talk saxy , boom boom bass, memories) and *NCT127* ( superhuman, kick it, sticker, 2baddies , favourite)

[@guguguguure]

recommending sticker is FOUL😭 setting nct up so bad when songs like back 2 u and whiplash exists

[@Jennielrc]

@shaehillstead sticker is a good song and the flute ain't that bad yall just love being dramatic

[@stayl7336]

+Riize impossible

[@looryc.r]

yess

[@larissalima6422]

YEEEEEEES

[@lamaralnuqaydan9688]

Thank you so much for the reaction !! I really hope we can get a second parttt ! I really enjoyed your sincere and honest opinions but for the next part I Really recommend that you watch hot , left & right and super and maybe if you guys enjoyed the hip hop unit song then you’d definitely enjoy cheers by the leaders !!

[@tolentinolawrence3543]

imagine reacting to seventeen for the first time and you decided to react to Maestro and Fear... this was a setup😭

[@LolaDo2024]

These 2 are trying to be the antithesis of the regular "reactors" who love everything. These guys don't really like anything KPop since a huge part of KPop is the visuals. I'd love to know what they usually listen to day to day.

[@heartsounds36]

chile boo. I've gone through most of these reactors' videos, and let's just say they pretty much don't know wtf they're talking about. It's ok to not like k-pop, but damn, stating your opinions as facts is not the business.

[@tj.8924]

these song choices for every single one of these groups are so trash omg!!! seventeen have one of the best discographies and these song sit at the very bottom.

[@Jackrond-qy1qx]

noo, These songs are very good songs, but I don't think they're the best choice for discovering Seventeen's music for the first time. but I think Fear is a good choice, it is one of Seventeen's masterpieces

[@tj.8924]

@@Jackrond-qy1qx fear i dont mind but maestro and the subunit tracks as your first reaction??? pls be so fr. i need to have a talk with who’s requesting the song choices.

[@linlovemail]

@@tj.8924 whoever requested these set them up so bad.. like theyre not even bad songs but theres better choices to show for a person who doesnt like kpop

[@nehabhoyar310]

Bro whatever you say we are carat and we will forever love our seventeen. Because only carat know of their efforts after every song they make(produce) it takes us no effort to judge them just by listening one or two songs.

[@alexxx3142]

I don’t mean to add to your plate but I think solo artists would be a cool idea for the future, maybe hwasa, Sunmi, taemin, Kai. I think there discography is really good.

[@neszoaaan5431]

+ taeyeon

[@butterflypixy]

i would love to see iu and boa reactions as well

[@Rosaline-d3o]

Frankly speaking, this was deeply disappointing. While honesty is appreciated, dismissing an entire group after listening to just five songs seems unfair and superficial. Worse yet, these selections weren't even representative of the group's diverse discography, especially since these songs are unit tracks rather than full group releases. A more balanced approach would have included a variety of songs or, better yet, their Killing Voice performance. It was disheartening to see the complete disregard for their lyrics, except for a single line, which was commented on to mock rather than analyze. The group's lyricist, who is also a member, deserves more respect than this. The shallow comments on the Spell MV also shows attention as barely paid. This isn't just lazy, it's downright disrespectful. Questioning their passion for music based on the delivery of one line is astonishingly unfair, especially for a group that has consistently demonstrated their dedication for nearly a decade. It's ironic how compliments are lavished on other groups, yet the immense effort this group pours into their work is overlooked. This blatant bias and lack of genuine engagement is glaring. With that said, I do hope you'll consider a part 2, featuring a more thoughtful and varied selection of songs, with more sensible reactions. Emphasis on thoughtful and sensible. Hopefully, there will be no blindly picking songs as there are more than enough suggestions in the comments, as well as unprofessional comments such as their line distribution "shouldn't work that way" and "having 13 members is dumb" will be filtered before spoken out loud . It would be disgraceful to see the same mockery and hypocrisy repeated. Again.

[@Meow_472]

If you come to the comments before you watch this just don’t, it’s not a reaction it’s just unnecessary mockery, go watch something else instead!!

[@rionagichahi9574]

Giving out your opinions that the sub-units are fire is fine but saying 13 members is too much and dumb is going too far RESPECT THEM!!! it's not like you could do any better than them🙃

[@peacefulbunny530]

That’s why they are stuck doing hate filled reaction videos they couldn’t make music never mind ‘good music’

[@BlossomRosee]

ppl saying the song reccomendations were horrible.... srsly??? FEAR??? SPELL??? ESPECIALLY READY TO LOVE???????? HORRIBLE??? in a single sentence that is a crime, purely just cus they didn't listen to the "iconic or best" songs doesn't mean these are horrible. dont call yourself a carat if that's the excuse. the reactors just don't accept or try enjoy these. NOT because the songs are bad. and to say that having 13 people is a waste dont you dare try speak when you barely know anything about the group after just a few reactions. you have no clue of the history or rest of the discography/content they work their asses off for, ask anyone who actually will try and enjoy it will confirm, that seventeen are one of the greatest and most respected groups. haters will always be haters and you rly proved that if you dont like the song, then you dont like the song.. dont mock the people for views

[@melona_a]

Everyone has rights to their own opinion and tastes but why show K-pop to someone who already has a negative prejudice against it? What do you get out of it at the end? Just some guy upsetting the fans of Seventeen.

[@rylietiara]

Only talking about the singing in Spell lmaoo they are the performance unit. The choreo for this song is unreal. It’s not alwayssss about the vocals being phenomenal, and they didn’t even react to the vocal unit

[@prvley8t]

this was so hard to watch

[@geetikasharma158]

IF YOU DON'T LIKE KPOP , SIMPLY DON'T REACT TO IT. PERIOD.

[@alzeenariza8935]

Y'all all these four songs are good atleast acc to me!!! Their old songs are also good !!! These ppl are haters and gonna hate even if you suggest them svt's old songs!!! Honestly i liked this whole new album!! The concept the mv the song the creativity, everything screams SEVENTEEN!!!! 99% of the utubers were in Aweeeee reacting to these songs!!! And these guys are already throwing hate just because the group has 13 members!!!

[@efiiphqny]

yall ain’t even criticizing us straight up being disrespectful 😪 these boys put so much work into their music and yall js trash on it. idc if kpop ain’t ur thing like ok ill respect that but js straight up hating for no reason when u don’t even know these guys is kinda weird??

[@yaa.todoro]

def being a hater after this video bc what. how can yes stuff are bad and pointless that's so disrespectful bruh like this is subjective you cant just say that

[@eunwoonator]

if u are a kpop hater then dont react to it and unnecessarily hurt the fanbases is it that hard 🤷‍♀️

[@SeventeenIU]

You said you want a recommendation of the hiphop unit’s songs, well all of their albums have unit songs except for Face The Sun, but the songs in that album are all really good specially the message

[@misscaite]

12:30 i knew kazinho was gonna mention the pause LOL

[@Cherryheart0808]

I’ve watched a lot of first time reactors but I’m surprised to see these songs on a first time reaction to Seventeen. Not sure what to feel after watching this video. Thanks anyway!

[@ECN300]

Whoever suggested these songs is definitely a new fan coz why tf would you suggest the new sub-unit songs before the iconic ones?☠️

[@DreamieQueen]

The only song I knew of SEVENTEEN before watching you guys' reaction was Left and Right and I love it, but sadly wasn't in this lineup. Also, those songs weren't nearly as bad as you guys make them out to be. It was a first time listen for me as well and I thought they were all good songs and whatever you guys criticized was weird and oddly knit picky. Not a fan of this reaction tbh. Maybe the next one will be better.

[@cupoftea3717]

Though I actually understand where you guys are coming from, that these songs are probably not the best introduction to seventeen (I would not pick these either) I find it a bit amusing that almost everyone is saying these guys dislike the songs this much because the recommendations completely suck. Now, yes, these are not my favorite seventeen songs especially ready to love 👀, but they are still not horrible AT ALL. I personally really love lalali, fear and maestro has kind of grown on me. The person who recommended these might have genuinely liked them (and I think seventeen really like them as well 🤧) You guys are going ahead to recommend songs like don't wanna cry, left and right, aju nice, hit and so on, but I can almost guarantee that they would not like those songs any better 😐 Judging by their reactions, I feel the need to conclude that 70% (if not more) of svt's discography would not be their taste. I don't see the need to recommend more and endure more pain 🤧😭 Their label is literally 'Kpop Hater' it should not come as too much of a surprise after clicking on this video that they don't like these songs (not that I understand why they are then bothering to react to them though) I do want to comment on the comment about the size of their group. It works for them, the line distribution works fairly well. Some members shine more in some releases, others in others. They've been together for many years with the fandom, and no one has a problem with it. So I am pretty sure it works for them. There's no need to say having 13 members on a song is 'dumb' or something they 'shouldn't' do.

[@Miren-1331]

I never really thought kpop haters existed and I was right; they aren't kpop haters, just haters who wanna hate. Like everyone has there own taste in music, and that's fine, but hating on the group, people they don't even know-now that's just pathetic. Those 13 boys that you called dumb have lived a much harder life than you could ever imagine; if you don't know them or their story, then why do you get to say things without context? You know every day feels like a loss to humanity and I hope you know why and if you don't look in the mirror!! I really wish you would go and reflect on yourselves instead of posting stuff like this.

[@notquiteizzie]

Is this like the channels bit? I'm confused. They are rating the songs like 8s- but have nothing nice to say, I don't get it...

[@onceyouwheeinyoucantwheeout]

Bruh I would hope whoever gives them the next list of seventeen songs would choose wisely 😂

[@Only_for_a_while]

I know people will ask me why i watched it if i didnt like it but curiosity got the better of me and i guess their plan to hate-bait worked😂. It is a bit ironic how LALALI is a written for haters and they still didnt get it, there is a thin line between having a different music taste and completely insulting an artist(s) who have poured their heart and soul into their work, calling them a waste or dum or working for a paycheck is a bit disheartening. They did not offer any actual constructive criticism they basically just dissed them. Using metaphors like 'dump track' is needlessly insulting as if they were trying to intentionally cause a stir of angry emotions from Carats. Anyway, i hope you have a good day and may God bless you

[@NadiaSmith-n5l]

Didn't expect these songs honestly Someone please tell them to react to Big mama killing voice