Best & Worst QB Picks From Each NFL Draft (2000-2024)

[@KrichProductions]

Which QB did you think was the biggest NFL bust of all time? Let me know your thoughts!

[@connorrivers995]

You had Christian Ponder right there for 2011. At least Blaine Gabbert has made a career as a backup and a spot starter. Ponder has been out of the league since 2014!

[@aceassn716]

Jamarcus Russell

[@JonathanBrown623]

I would say that Russell Wilson was the best Quarterback from the 2012 NFL Draft. Bro has a Super Bowl ring, had elite statistical years and is the best Quarterback in Seahawks history.

[@Luv4_fat]

😂 if Andrew luck stayed healthy he would still be top 10 qbs right now

[@GDSBIFF]

​@@Luv4_fat and right now hes not a top 2 qb in his teams history soooo

[@justinterry2926]

@@Luv4_fat wilson has a ring when he was still playing. If chad Pennington hadn't fucked his shoulder He would be in the hall of fame But we can talk about what it's for ever let's stick to facts instead

[@stevenrangel.4]

​@@justinterry2926Chad Pennington 😮😂😂

[@justinterry2926]

@stevenrangel.4 it was a joke but watch I'm in college Man was a beast And had to completely learn how to be a different qb after his injuries

[@Polomainsr]

2006 bust is Matt Leinart picked 10th and didn’t do a damn thing at all Vince Young won the offensive of rookie of the year

[@coldcatproductions7737]

And 2 Pro Bowls also.

[@willardmatsaudza3101]

Yeah 100% lienhart he did way less than Vince Young

[@bigbearkat2010]

Thought that was obvious too, Vince at least had a couple good years.

[@jfritz3873]

I’m gonna have to disagree with Tim Tebow being the worst quarterback of the 2010 class. He had his moments in 2011. Quarterback Jimmy Clausen would make more sense here… 9:16

[@justinterry2926]

@@jfritz3873 one was a first round pick The other wasn't

[@gwell66v2AnimeReviews]

@@justinterry2926 Thats not the only factor. Even if it was 1 season, Tebow actually played, won, made the playoffs and won there. Clausen only ever lost and it's not like he was a 4th. He was a 2nd, right behind tebow

[@bigbearkat2010]

@@gwell66v2AnimeReviews not to mention the Atlas level heavy lifting Mel Kiper was doing hyping him up

[@ryan_2007_walls]

At 1st Michael Vick in 2001 NFL Draft clearly was the BEST because he was a 1st Round 1st overall pick by Atlanta Falcons from Virginia Tech University before the whole dog fighting thing he certainly was the guy you didn't want to miss! 0:44

[@logannixon231]

I was thinking the same thing

[@kevinn4038]

We went from Brees to QB by committee to Carr. Oh well. I went through Hebert, Shuler, Wilson, Everett, Brooks, to get to Brees. I guess I can wait another 3 decades

[@bigbearkat2010]

If they keep kicking the can down the road like they've been doing for the last like five years, you might have to.

[@mwcarolina]

I would put Leinart as the worst of 2006. He was a first rounder and did worse than Young and I think Haskins has to be the bust of the 2019 draft

[@arctrainertrex2524]

Such an underrated channel,goes straight to the point,and doesnt drag the video too long.

[@Wesleyt6475]

Carr got it dirty. He would have been better literally anywhere else. Dude was done dirty

[@crossfox255]

Same to a slightly lesser extent with Harrington. Can't fix the lions gets called a bust.

[@Outlaw8908]

Carr got tossed into the meat grinder and subsequently got Tim Couched. When he got to Carolina you could tell he was shell shocked.

[@Outlaw8908]

Vince Young when you look at the situation with Jeff Fisher. He was doomed. He needed a coach that would have worked with him, but he also needed to grow. I would say Matt Leinart was a bigger bust.

[@kingschick5780]

If we're looking at pure success during the time he's been in the league, Brock Purdy is simply sensational. Given, he does have a stacked team, so maybe it's too early to give out excessive praise. But he plays smart. Not something you can say about almost any quarterbacks drafted in the seventh round.

[@drtoxic7364]

I gotta disagree with the Tebow being the biggest bust from 2010. Yeah he wasn't good but Jimmy Clausen was just abysmal

[@NameyMcNamerson]

Yeah but I don’t really know of anyone who thought he would be a success in the NFL. He went to high school down the street from me and even the people around here knew he was a backup option at best

[@bigbearkat2010]

@@NameyMcNamerson I mean there was at least one guy that was pretty vocal about it. Even for all of Mel Kiper's bad takes over the years, that was infamously bad.

[@ErikCB912]

Sanchez is not the worst QB drafted in 2009. That would be Josh Freeman.

[@Roll-Tide-99]

Josh Freeman probably should be the worst for 2009. Not to downplay how bad Sanchez was, but Sanchez had two seasons leading the Jets to the playoffs whereas Freeman had no playoff appearances and was out of the league by 2016. Sanchez was terrible, but the fact he had two okay years and lasted three years longer in the league than Freeman puts Freeman as the bigger bust.

[@timothybruns2775]

Jason Campbell wasn't benched, he got injured and the Raiders traded for Palmer. They put too much capital into him, so they didn't re-sign him.

[@thehashtagtrashbag]

If only he did his homework instead of basing it off of his opinion, he might have come to the same conclusion

[@CaseyWinehouse]

This dude is allergic to fact checking. I've watched a lot of videos (so I guess he gets the last laugh) but yeah he sucks at pronunciations and real life facts.

[@crossfox255]

Since people put alot of credence into rings Gabbert is technically better than Newton because he's gone to 2 Super Bowls and has 2 rings. He was Brady's back up in Tampa and got one as Mahomes' back up in KC.

[@jackcady1864]

Bro forgot about Kyle boller in 2003

[@aceassn716]

Thank you feel they needed to do a bit more research Leftwich was better than Boller by far!

[@JacionBryant]

I know what the worst is Raiders nation’s jamcus Russell and Derrick Carr maybe for the raiders as best qb

[@ykm.mikemike]

ever heard of mvp winner rich gannon?

[@wholesomecomment45]

Carr isn't even the best Raiders QB of the 2000s

[@davidcalkins4925]

Rich Gannon had one good year in Oakland, when he had these two guys… you may have heard of them… Tim Brown and Jerry Rice, then got absolutely destroyed in the SB

[@davidcalkins4925]

Also the D Carr hate is so dumb, he took the Raiders back to the playoffs and made them a contender, as Saints fans, not everyone can be Brees, Carr threw for 3800 yards and 25/8, he also recently had 4 consecutive 4000 yard seasons Carrs 10 year avg - 3900 Yards per season, 24 TDs and and 10 INTs. That’s pretty damn good

[@jimboscooter432]

Kenny The Snake Stabler was the best Raider QB

[@kelleywalls460]

If you based these rankings off career earnings….. Bradford would be top 3. It’s crazy how much money he made.

[@allenhonaker4107]

When saying one player will surpass another in the future , it is always good to remember the sad ending of Bo Jackson. It's not just talent and execution. It's also longevity and maybe a good dose of luck

[@bosstankproductions1304]

I know it’s disrespectful, but even as an OSU fan I think Haskins should’ve been the bust if 2019

[@zachevans27]

Good video. As a Falcons fan, I highly dislike Drew Brees. But man, after going to a Falcons Saints game in 2016 and watching Brees warm up pregame, that dude could spin it. It was insane to watch. Out of 40 to 50 warm up throws, every pass was perfect. No receiver had to stretch to try and catch it. It was insane to watch. Probably one of the most accurate passers in history.

[@SimonMeshko]

2020 QB draft class was LEGENDARY!!!🔥🔥💯

[@bucklamb2062]

Had a great rookie year but I would wait to see what he does in his second year before everyone puts him in there MVP conversation just yet

[@deadlydread77]

Tim Tebow was a football god compared to Jimmy "pickles" Clausen. dude single handily gave the Panthers the reason to draft Cam in 2011 Tebow at least went to the SB..

[@onigiri2032]

I'd argue that josh is better because of him having more playoff success (and me being a Bills fan lmao) but it comes down to whether you grade playoff success or awards more highly. They're pretty even as far as talent goes

[@jimboscooter432]

I wanted my jets to draft Josh Allen that year. But instead we drafted a turnover prone USC QB. Ken O'Brian over Marino and now Darnald over Allen. The jets will never learn

[@onigiri2032]

@jimboscooter432 my Bills are also historically bad. I feel your pain man. If we didn't have Josh we'd still be bums. That guy is just Superman

[@noylakers9755]

I guess we have diff perception of a bust. To me, a 4th rd qb that stays in the league for 4 to 5 years is a big W even if they don't play much.

[@bucklamb2062]

Mark Sanchez, Gino Smith, Sam Darnold man you got to feel sorry for the Jets

[@jimboscooter432]

You forgot to mention zack wilson

[@thurmanwilliams7961]

I am a Tebow Defender. If a team was willing to build around his skill set, he could have worked.

[@Jahknown101]

Leftwich had a good run during his early Jaguars years I won't considered him as a bust but injured prone In mid 2000s

[@normanrodriguez6670]

Losman had a rocket for an arm, just had a crappy O-Line & held the ball too long

[@ryan_2007_walls]

Eli Manning and Philip Rivers were the BEST picks in the 2004 NFL Draft Eli Manning is the only quarterback in NFL's History to beat the greatest QB and greatest coach of all time in Super Bowl's not once but twice in 2007 and 2011 period even though Rivers did not go to a Super Bowl in his own right but to me I love and respected him very much because Eli Manning 1st Round 1st overall pick out of Ole Miss three picks later Philip Rivers 1st Round 4th overall pick North Carolina State University Wolfpack! 0:24

[@Hudiz1996]

That mahomes picture is uncanny valley eerie

[@normanrodriguez6670]

I’d put Allen over Jackson, though Jackson has two MVPs, that’s a popularity contest. Allen has produced far more yards and total TDs.

[@kaaronhudson8112]

Stop

[@kaaronhudson8112]

Stop

[@familytreez916]

Allen turn over machine 😂

[@thisisscorpio6024]

Philip Rivers was the Dan Marino of his generation. Incredible talent, but just could not capture a ring.

[@ryan_2007_walls]

Tom Brady without no doubt he's the G.O.A.T yes 6th Round 199th overall pick in the 2000 NFL Draft the Michigan University Wolverines Alumni is a 7X Super Bowl Champion with the Patriots from 2001 to 2019 Buccaneers in 2020 plain and simple! 1:00

[@carllockamy6162]

Lamar is 1B just because he has never eclipsed 4K yards passing

[@bucklamb2062]

You would figure with John Elway being the general manager he would have easily drafted a franchise quarterback guess not

[@ZachSmith-go9uk]

2024 NFL Draft: best pick is Caleb Williams, worst pick is J.J McCarthy

[@crossfox255]

Hahahahahahaha Williams is a fraud. Throws 200 less yards per game when playing a decent to good defense. He shouldn't have won the hiseman. His reciever and running back did all the work. He got 4 turnovers in a game and only managed 17 points total. He can't play in bad weather. Guess what Chicago is during football season. Dude looks flashy because of the air raid but another QB took his spot and put up similar numbers. Utah, Oregon, Notre Dame, Oregon State, Arizona State (to a far lesser extent) exposed him for the fraud he is. ESPN had a graphic during the Arizona State game that showed he had 72 tds and 2 int verus the inferior teams he played and had 6td/6 int against any team with a defense rated higher than 23rd. His best win by ranking at Oklahoma was over 22nd ranked Oregon in the Alamo bowl. Oregon had half a team and no head coach at the time. They still alomst came back and won the game because they figured out exactly what he was doing and how to stop it.

[@thomasmelancon4287]

Sam Bradford was good really good. Some bad teams especially the rams terrible injury luck. You seen the difference in him when he went to MINNESOTA and Philly.

[@nicktaylor2657]

Think 49ers could of had Tom Brady in the third round instead of Carmazzi Since Brady is from San Mateo near San Francisco would of been a dream but who knows?

[@rickvoigt8720]

No way Mahomes passes Brady. The AFC West, although it suck right now, will reload and make it impossible to achieve Brady's numbers.

[@strikedabox1163]

3 Broncos QBs says everything you need to know lol

[@crossfox255]

It deffinatly says John Elway and the Bronco's scouts are terrible at drafting QBs.

[@random-incorporation229]

I would say herbert has been better than burrow just because he has played more at around the same level

[@timothybeisner8853]

I'm not a JETS fan by any means but, I do disagree with you on Mark Sanchez. Didn't he take the Jets to 3 AFC Championship games in 3 Years??? If Not For Rex Ryan Though Coaching

[@patG85]

How Vince bust way worse in that class

[@JMaster9877]

Malik Willis is worse than Pickett in every way. Willis has never thrown a TD in every game he's started.

[@patG85]

Rosen was horrible and I said from day one he.wouldnt make it

[@Babyuzi24k]

The thumbnail got me ion think Bryce young is a bust he has no decent receivers or oline in his first season

[@e93sports80]

Nice!

[@RJPDay]

Didn’t even mention Kirk Cousins from 2012🤦🏼‍♂️

[@connorrivers995]

I think Deshone Kizar was the worst [ick in the 2017 class. 11TD's to 24 INT's, a 58.9 passer rating, completed only 53.1% of his passes for just north of 3,000 yards and, oh yeah, HE FAILED TO WIN A SINGLE GAME OUT OF THE FIFTHTEEN HE STARTED!!!!!

[@innerthoughts3031]

Bryon left witch was not a burst at all

[@bucklamb2062]

Andrew Luck could have been an all time great he could have over taken Payton Manning if not for his early retirement what might have been Andrew what might have been

[@Fighterx356]

Stop with clickbait brother

[@KrichProductions]

How brother?

[@alexrko2740]

Someone wants attention. How is this clickbait?

[@TransNFLGirl]

@@alexrko2740 Stroud HOF... Allen BUST...

[@Llosisus]

@@KrichProductionsJosh allen as draft bust are u serious

[@cmacd1901]

How's this a clickbait its the exact video it said In the title

[@ryan_2007_walls]

As a Steelers fan I will say Ben Roethlisberger was the absolute BEST QB picks in 2004 NFL Draft 1st Round 11th overall selection out of Miami University of Ohio RedHawks cause he won Rookie of the year and he won two Super Bowl Rings 2005 and 2008 after 3 trips to the Super Bowl with two different coaches Bill Cowher and Mike Tomlin too there's no question about the fact that Big Ben is the real reason why I became a Steelers Fan became of Roethlisberger he's the heart and soul of the franchise and he will certainly be a perfect candidate for the Hall Of Fame soon for real! Here we go Steelers and Thank You Ben #7🖤💛🖤💛🖤💛

[@darrenrissler3493]

I'm a Bengal fan. I hate Roethlisberger, and if I know one thing. If I hate a player on a Division rivals team, it's because their good. Nobody hates bad players on other teams. In fact they are generally my favorite player. I'll miss Pickett.

[@stevenrangel.4]

Na If he would've stayed healthy then probably but I would put Rivers over Ben and Eli despite not winning a super bowl he never missed a start in 15 seasons people don't give him credit for that he was made out of steel 👍💪

[@AlphaMayle95]

Trevor Lawrence isn’t even a top 15 QB, don’t believe the narrative, look at the stats.

[@donaldtillou1283]

Lamar can't win playoff off games he either loses to Mahomes or Allen. Plus Allen should have gotten the MVP not Lamar. ALLEN had 29 passing TD so did Jackson, Allen had more yards then Jackson and more rushing TD then Jackson. Only reason why Jackson won was Allen had lead league in interception. JUST LIKE BRETT FAVRE DID WHEN HE WON MVP TWICE.

[@JustinMartin-i4x]

Didn't even include Vick.

[@Hawkeye1593]

Dwayne Haskins is probably the worst qb from 2019 class

[@Luv4_fat]

Rip

[@Thetopmeme35]

The worst from 2022 is Matt corral

[@crossfox255]

Winston is better than Mariota hahahahaha no. Who won a playoff game? Dude threw a TD to him self off Darell Revis (Old Revis but still Revis). I'll give you that the one throw in Carolina kinda overshadows everything he's done. When you try and play hero ball it's more likely to end up making you look like a fool than not.

[@bucklamb2062]

All that dumb shit jameis Winston did in college I thought he was going to get it together in the NFL he did for a little bit but the old James one out how do you feel sorry for him because he was the prototypical Quarterback injuries and not having it all upstairs

[@jolemays3218]

Bruh qbs getting Paid paid

[@JuanMontenegro-i9v]

daniel jones in 2019?

[@justinterry2926]

Why the shit clickbait picture

[@bucklamb2062]

The Dolphins will never ever win a Superbowl with Tua at QB has a losing record against winning teams can't play in cold weather people take about game manager Tua is the definition of that Dolphins should have drafted Justin Herbert with his cannon arm the wind receivers will never have to come back for the football

[@tpvn8377]

2019 bust should of been haskins rip but come on

[@Wootensportscards]

Romo had a better career then Palmer

[@stevenrangel.4]

Romo was made out of glass just like Big Ben 😂😅

[@deadlydread77]

Romo wasn't drafted. He was a UDFA.

[@tolson488]

As a raiders fan I hate jamarus

[@anthonyglower1983]

I wouldn't say tebow was the worst

[@patG85]

Sanchez can't be bust way worst

[@thehashtagtrashbag]

The fact you said Luck over Wilson throws all credibility out the window

[@anthonyglower1983]

Bo nix is this yrs best

[@josewilliam6155]

WHO DAT!!!!

[@KrichProductions]

AYEEEE

[@ch1kmagnet]

⚜️⚜️⚜️⚜️⚜️

[@patG85]

David carr bad rep horrible team

[@LamarBragg]

Mark gets a bum wrap. We don't question Tom's greatness even though he's never threw the game winner in a Superbowl,it was always the running game kicker or defense.

[@Uaintfirsturlast]

Little troll boy

[@armusc757]

Click bait, Josh is a bust?? GTFOH.

[@JohnORatcliffe]

Bears worst caleb williams

[@Llosisus]

Unsubbed bro how is Josh allen a bust 👎

[@iconpoet]

#screwdrew

[@raymalcrawford5734]

Micheal pinx will be the best qb of the 2024 class bust is bo nix

[@ardascholar5289]

lamar "run the ball on every play" jackson is a running back, and he is NOTHING compared to Josh Allen. He will end up going the way of Cam Newton. Once injuries catch up with him in another couple years he is done.

[@Jxxx80]

Jordan Love is the Goat

[@JayBigDadyCy]

🤣🤣🤣

[@brandontaylor1688]

There is zero chance luck had a better career then russ gtfoh

[@joshgraham8284]

Butt fumble